HomeMy WebLinkAboutA4447 - PECK SHAFFER WILLIAMS TOLLING AGR MO7002 Peck Shaffer & Williams
• • Tolling Agreement
AGRFEmENT #4447
1407008, 2-6-02
TOLLING AGREEMENT
This Tolling Agreement(the"Agreement") is made between City of Palm Springs
(the"City"), on the one hand, and Peck Shaffer&Williams, LLP ("PS&W`� on the other
hand (collectively the City and PS&W are the "Parties"). The effective date of the
Agreement is October 12, 2001.
Recitals
A, The City may claim to have a legal malpractice or other claim against
PS&W. Neither party admits or concedes the validity of any such claims. PS&W
specifically denies any liability to the City. Neither of the Parties admits liability to the
other by entering into the Agreement. The Agreement neither creates nor waives rights
or remedies for or against either of the Parties to the Agreement. The Parties agree that
this Agreement, its terms or existence cannot be used adversely to any of the Parties,
except to enforce its terms.
B. The Agreement is solely for the benefit of the Parties. No person or entity
that is not either of the Panics shall have the right, standing or authority to invoke its
terms,benefits, or obligations without the express written consent of all of the Parties,
Terms
1. In consideration, the Parties agree not to commence a legal, equitable,
judicial or administrative proceeding against one another in connection with the audit by
the Internal Revenue Service (the "IRS") of the following issuances (the "Audit"): (1)
$2,366,00 City of Palm Springs Certificates of Participation (Palm Springs Assisted
Living Centers), 1991 Subordinate Series B; (ii) $5,481,489 City of Palm Springs
Certificates of Participation (Palm Springs Assisted Living Centers), 1991 Series A; (iii)
$798,012 City of Palm Springs Refunding and Improvement Certificates of Participation
(Palm Springs Assisted Living Center), 1993 Series B; and (iv) $8,099.248 City of Palm
Springs Refunding and Improvement Certificates of Participation (Palm Springs Assisted
Living Center), 1993 Series A (the "Issues"). All time limits, in law or equity, for
commencing such proceedings or for asserting a defense shall be tolled as of the date of
this Agreement until the Agreement is terminated.
2. The Agreement shall terminate on the earliest of(a) the completion of the
Audit and issuance of a letter by the IRS determining the Issues to be taxable, or (b) 30
days after either of the Parties gives written notice to the other of the election to terminate
the Agreement. Written notice terminating the Agreement shall be delivered, by
facsimile and either by personal service or by a nationally recognized courier service with
a receipt,to the other party's counsel, at such counsel's normal address.
3. The Agreement shall not revive any claim that is time-barred on or before
October 12, 2001,the effective date of the Agreement.
1
�uu.a
yy, y.,, ul anu ia.�l rnn ci+ ,;,'uu •
4. The Agreement shall be deemed to have been drafted by both of the
Parties, and shall not be construed against either of the Parties on the premise that either
of the Parties drafted the Agreement.
5. The Agreement may be extended only on or before the day it is to
terminate, by a writing that establishes a date certain to which the Agreement shall be
extended, executed by both of the Parties.
6. In any action to enforce the Agreement or seeking relief for its breach, the
prevailing party shall be entitled to recover reasonable attorney's fees and costs.
7. The Agreement is confidential and shall not be disclosed to any person or
entity by any party to the Agreement, or their counsel and their insurer, except as
necessary to establish whether a claim or defense falls within the Agreement.
8. The Agreement may be signed in counterparts, each of which, when fully
executed, shall constitute the Agreement.
9. The Agreement is the entire agreement among the parties. Iu executing
the Agreement, neither party is relying on or acting on any promise, inducement, or
agreement not expressed in the Agreement.
10. The Agreement is controlled by the law of California.
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
DATED:_ By: `i/tGrf �L�ac� y,i/y
Thomas M, Kanarr , Di r of Finance
David H. Ready, q Manager
PECK SHAFFER&WILLIAMS, LLP
.DATED: �� ��� By: ��s e lJ
Carol Duane Olson
7
2
J VUV
!L 1YV1 16V 11.01 rt L1U IOU LJVU •
THE AGREEMENT IS APPROVED AS TO FORM AND CONTENT:
BURKE,WII.LIAMS&SORENSEN,LLP
DATED: ti a .�✓ ,_t !�„�.. �-,�.o-_ -
{
I7rban J. Schreiner
Attomeys for CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
,PECK SHAFFER&WILLIAMS, LLP
DATED;
ac F. rcb
eys for PECK SHAFFER&
WILLIAMS, LLP
3
UU�
AV1J, V1 1IIU 1Y.JV "' L1J" ""
LAW OFFICES
1010,
$URKE, WrLLJAMS& SORENSEN, LLP
OM KALE ANAMUM,NTY SUITE
611 WEST SMH STREET 5AH DIEGO COUNTY 0MCE
16101 VON,Cklr 1 AYEAUl,2-100 1050
tnvlH Teti CAuroRNu n612-1DD9 SUITE 2500 sow 07GO,GLL3FOANG s81o1-a5a3
F= ("g)%3-3367 COS ANGELESN: (619)615-6511
rec (4/9)E63.3350 ,CALIFORNIACALiFORNIA 90017.3102 Fax; (619)fits-E673
Tel: (213)236-060o
Fax: (213)236.2700
RIVERSIDE COUNTY OMCE www.bWslaw,com VENFURA COUNTY OFFICE
3403 TENTH STREET,MfZ 300 2310 EAST PONDEROSA DRtYE,SUITE 25
RNPRgTl; (WO)A R 92E01-3G29 CMMU-0,CAUFDRNU,93390.4747
Td: (909)ie6-0100 Tel (Y05)9E7-3466
W. (9D9)78517C5 Fax: (WS�4E M4
win"Dvect DW
213-23E2834 OM RLE NO'
9parkQ6w4*w..m 04D64-Og01
November 1
VIA FACCSIMME(513)241.4771 AND U.S. MAI
Jack F. Fuchs, Esq.
Thornpsou Hine f
322 Walnut Street, 14th Floor —
Cincinnati, OH 45202 y �/
Re: rRS Audit of Bond Issue l� ! /J
Dear Mr. Fuchs: ?ut%EE's
This is a follow-up to my letter dated Oct
telephone conversations since October 9, 2001 with
you that your revised version of the tolling agreemen�,*wvcptaDle except for Paragraph 10. For
the obvious reasons,we advised you that Paragraph 10 must read as follows: "The Agreement is
controlled by the law of California." We informed you that our client is prepared to sign the
tolling agreement with those changes to Paragraph 10. You advised me that you would discuss
this hatter with your client and get b - ^^ aq Dossible. Attached is a revised version
of the tolling agreement
.i
To date, we have yet to he; ad return the
��_ -
agreement to us by no later than No f / s he agreement
by such,date, we will have no choir c ant's available.
remedies. -71 0
I look forward to your anti / � �u '� �'ti / � s or comments
regarding any of the above matter
v C? � 2
I L aASEN LLP
L
Enclosure - -- .
or: David J. Aleshire,Esq., City Attorney
Urban J. Schreiner,Esq.
• � A
19 MA
es
VIP
a -
j ��
— 8 X
He Edit Corirtection Setup Macro VJindo Ip
l� l974
-- __ �l
Enter a command, ,(push' return to search wit keywords)
11
Enter the Index (Retikrn to cancel )
TOLLING
'Would you Like .to lindex 'hy, the first 4, character Y (N)
TOLLING TELENOMICS
Would you Aike to use all of the key words shown-above (N)
Would ,you, like to"'add a key :word simiij ar, to, TOLLING (N)
i
The following counts were found :far each ;k,eyword
TOLLING ( 2)
i
2 Actions ,'were 'se lected
VISION CBD LAWSUIT 'MCWETHY PALM MT T0LLING AG A3481 2-1-95 133-0115-0040
'VISION CBD LAWSUIT 'MCWETHY PALM 'MT MOU STLMNT A3519 4-12-95 C 133-005-0042M
ITACHEVAH G/C INCL TOLLING' AGR A3481. ,
;Enter a co'mman'd (push return to search with keywords)
Next Set : Search ., Search Select Prey Next Refresh
Set 1 , ' � Agree Date Action Action Action Screen Exit
— - - — = -
Nurn Caps
� :... . I - u
!�SCad • ciky.rlw - ReFI.., �3j In bo,=-MirmsofP... ®MicrosyftVJord ' �"-y't;CERTR.liKPm4....+ ,�r�l _��' 3:1E�F'f-i
r
�G� S
�i