The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2/19/2003 - STAFF REPORTS (11) DATE: February 19, 2003 TO: City Council FROM: Director of Planning and Zoning CASE NOS. 5.0916, 5.0938, AND 5.0941 -APPLICATIONS TO AMEND THE GENERAL PLAN LAND USE AND CIRCULATION ELEMENTS SO AS TO: (A) REDESIGNATE 5.11 ACRES OF LAND FROM M15 (MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL 12-15 UNITS/ACRE)TO GC (GENERAL COMMERCIAL) AND C (CONSERVATION) FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 4155 EAST MATTHEW DRIVE, ZONE R-2 AND R-1-AH, SECTION 30; (B) REDESIGNATE 3.27 ACRES OF LAND FROM M15 (MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL 12-15 UNITS/ACRE) TO H30 (MEDIUM- HIGH DENSITY RESIDENTIAL 21-30 UNITS/ACRE) FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF MURRAY CANYON DRIVE AND SIERRA MADRE, ZONE R-2 AND O, SECTION 35; (C) DELETE AN UNIMPROVED PORTION OF ARENAS ROAD BETWEEN SUNRISE WAY AND HERMOSA DRIVE FROM THE CIRCULATION PLAN. RECOMMENDATION The Planning Commission recommends that the City Council order filing of a Mitigated Negative Declaration and a resolution to approve (a) an application by Matthew Dragicevich Charitable Remainder Trust for an amendment to the General Plan Map so as to redesignate 5.11 acres of land located at 4155 E. Matthew Drive from M15 (Medium Density Residential) to GC (General Commercial)and C(Conservation), (b)an application by Laguna Pacific, LP for Canyon Vista, LP to amend the General Plan Map from M15 (Medium Density: 12-15 units/acre) to H30 (Medium- High Density: 21-30 units/acre)for the property located at the northeast corner of Murray Canyon Drive and Sierra Madre, and (c) an application by Palm Springs Modern Homes ll, LLC for an amendment to the General Plan Circulation Plan to remove an unimproved portion of Arenas Road between Sunrise Way and Hermosa Drive. SUMMARY All three proposed General Plan Amendments were initiated by property owners/applicants and are associated with these items tonight's City Council Agenda. If approved, the City's General Plan will be amended. The Planning Commission held joint public hearings on each proposal and associated application. The Planning Commission recommends approval of all three General Plan Amendments. BACKGROUND Matthew Dragicevich Charitable Remainder Trust, Laguna Pacific, LP for Canyon Vista, LP, and Palm Springs Modern Homes II, LLC have filed independent applications for amendments to the General Plan Land Use and Circulation Elements. Each request to amend the General Plan is being brought forward in conjunction with other development projects. The justification for the General Plan Amendments and the associated projects is discussed below. GENERAL PLAN MAP AMENDMENT TO REDESIGNATE 5.11 ACRES AT 4155 EAST MATTHEW DRIVE - MATTHEW DRAGICEVICH CHARITABLE REMAINDER TRUST The General Plan identifies how the City would like land utilized in the future. The General Plan also contains policies that further address the City's expectations with respect to the physical development of land. The General Plan Map Amendment is being requested in conjunction with a change of zone from R-2 and R-1-AH to C-M and 0 in order to facilitate the existing commercial uses of the property. The General Plan designation for the subject property is proposed to be changed from Medium Density Residential 12-15 units/acre (M15) to General Commercial (GC)and Conservation (C) in order for the zoning to be in conformance with the General Plan. The C designation for the subject propertywould include hillside lands where developmentwill be limited due to the precipitous slope. If any limited development occurs, it will be subject to the City's hillside regulations. The GC designation allows for commercial uses needing a large amount of space and are not dependent on pedestrian traffic. The proposed use of the auto body shop and land use consistent with C-M zoning would be consistent with General Plan Policy 3.28.5 which states, "Develop a specific plan, when feasible, for the Cherokee Way district to provide for a transition which would move the commercial uses to the East Palm Canyon Drive corridor and residential uses to the cove area." The use would also be consistent with General Plan Policy 3.28.7 which states, "Encourage the elimination of non-conforming uses/structures and the establishment of desired uses." The issue for consideration is a determination as to where the boundaryfor residential uses should be located in the cove area. The General Plan update accomplished in 1993 showed the cove area south of the intersection of Matthew Drive and Linden Drive designated M15, East Palm Canyon Drive designated Resort Commercial(RC), and the property along Cherokee Way designated GC. There was debate at the time of the update as to the appropriate location of the General Plan/Zoning boundary for the MI5/R-2 designation. The proposal is to establish an east to west transition between multi-family residential zoned property and commercially zoned property. In addition, the property owner to the east supports moving the line eastward for the limits of commercially zoned property, closer to the existing single family residential property. The proposed General Plan Amendment would be consistent with existing uses and would allow the non-conforming use of the auto body shop to continue. Attached to related Case 5.0916, request for change of zone, is a written commitment from the property owner with regards to site improvements and the closure of the boat repair facility. The proposed Change of Zone from R-2 to C-M and R-1-AH to 0-20 is not in conformance with the current General Plan designation of M15. The present land use is commercial with outdoor storage and there are commercial uses to the west and northwest, and residential uses to the east and north. The zone change will be such that the existing businesses and related open storage areas will be re-zoned to C-M with the remainder of the vacant land and hillside area re-zoned to 0-20. The Commission finds the Change of Zone and General Plan Amendment are appropriate due to the designations of adjacent properties. The property to the west is zoned C-M and is designated GC while the property to the northwest is zoned W-C-2 and is designated GC. The designation of the subject property as GC would be an extension of the Cherokee Way commercial corridor onto Matthew Drive. p A C), GENERAL PLAN MAP AMENDMENT TO REDESIGNATE 3.27 ACRES AT THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF MURRAY CANYON DRIVE AND SIERRA MADRE - LAGUNA PACIFIC, LP FOR CANYON VISTA, LP The proposed General Plan Map Amendment refers to redesignating the 3.27 acre project site from Medium Density Residential 12-15 units/acre (M15) to Medium-High Density Residential 21-30 units/acre(H30). The General Plan Map Amendment is being requested in conjunction with Case 5.0938-PD-282 TTM 31006, a request for Planned Development District 282 in-lieu of a change of zone and Tentative Tract Map 31006 for the construction of 66 timeshare units located at the northeast corner of Murray Canyon Drive and Sierra Madre.The property to the west is designated H43/21 (High Density 30-43 units/acre) and zoned R-3 (Multi-Family and Hotel Zone). The proposed General Plan Map Amendment is a logical extension of the General Plan designation to the west. Without the amendment, the maximum allowable density for the subject property would be 49 units.The applicant's lease requires them to construct at least 50 timeshare units on the site. The proposed General Plan Map amendment is consistent with the surrounding neighbourhood because of the multi-family designations and nature of development surrounding the site. To the north of the subject property is single family residential zoned property, also owned by the applicant. The single story buildings on the north end of the project site will also facilitate the transition from the two-story buildings to the one-story single family residential community further to the north. Therefore, the General Plan amendment is appropriate and will not be detrimental to the neighbourhood. GENERAL PLAN CIRCULATION PLAN AMENDMENT TO DELETE PORTION OF ARENAS ROAD BETWEEN SUNRISE WAY AND HERMOSA DRIVE-PALM SPRINGS MODERN HOMES ll, LLC The development is proposing to remove a portion of Arenas between Hermosa Drive and Sunrise Way from the General Plan Circulation Element. The amendment to the General Plan Circulation Element is being requested in conjunction with TTM 30941 for the construction of 48 condominium units for the property located at 1460 and 1550 East Baristo Road. The Engineering and Planning and Zoning Departments required a traffic study be completed to evaluate the traffic impacts relating to the deletion of the Arenas. The study found that the impacts would be less than significant due to the low density of the project and adequate alternate access for properties to the north and west. The deletion of Arenas will extend from the proposed cul-de-sac on Arenas Road to Hermosa Drive and will be consistent with the Draft Section 14 Master Plan (see Attachment 4). The portion of Arenas proposed to the removed form the Circulation Element is also currently unimproved. ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT AND NOTIFICATION Environmental Assessments were prepared for each proposed amendment. Upon completion of the EA, staff found that although the proposed project could have a significant impact on the environment, there will not be a significant effect in this case because of the mitigation measures described in the Mitigated Negative Declaration. The EA for each General Plan Amendment was prepared in conjunction with the related actions which are on tonight's City Council agenda. Those Environmental Assessments are hereby incorporated by reference into this staff report and are available for public review at the offices of the Department of Planning and Zoning. ) M3 All property owners within four hundred (400)feet of the subject properties have been notified. In addition, the EAs were sent to local utilities and interested parties. As of the writing of this report, staff received comment from the Desert Water Agency, Palm Springs Unified School District, Southern California Gas Company, and Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians. The correspondence is attached to the report for the cases related to each proposed General Plan Amendment. No sing-nificant environmental issues were raised. Director grPlanning and Zoning City Manager c - � ATTACHMENTS 1. Vicinity Maps 2. Existing General Plan Land Use Designations and Circulation Plan 3. General Plan Land Use Legend 4. Figure 4-1 of Draft Section 14 Master Plan 5. Planning Commission minutes for January 22, 2003 (to be included) 6. Resolutions I VICINITY MAP A L 0 � UO Se- IVOLEW.4Y4 L in � zesfAo. o 0 /./9 AC= o w I�, 7 r - �I _DR/VF �- 141�Sc ry — Zea ti F,_ = zao 234.25 .. J .1 C M —2. Para N � � V ry Par 2 3 �C o ' 5.11 A C) oil R-1—AH 'S6 CITY OF PALM SPRINGS CASE NO. 5.0916 GPA/CZ DESCRIPTION General Plan Map Amendment so as to redesignate APPLICANT Matthew Dragicevich 5.11 acres of land located at 4155 E. Matthew Drive Charitable Remainder Trust from'M15 to GC and C and Zoning Map Amendment so as rezone 5.11 acres of land located at 4155 E. Matthew Drive from R-2 and R-1-AH to C-M and 0-20 0 VICINITY MAP Mo TT z,A g 20 PI 172 17 PI e.41 AC MIL TI 25 's 19 PI _ 1.15AC M/L 26 A PI 00 AC MIL � x nc.xv I v SITE 1.1RAC.MIL TRA 011-003 g TRA 011-050 g - m nee z z,w 7"MA CITY OF PALM SPRINGS QASE NO 5.0938 - PD-282 TTM 31006 DESCEIPTIQN APPLT La Application for a General Plan Map Amendment to ICAN 9 una Pacific, LP for re-designate property from M15 to H30 and a PD and TTM for the construction of 66 timeshare units Canyon Vista, LP at the northeast comer of Murray Canyon Drive and Sierra Madre,Zone R-2 and O, Section 35. VICINITY MAP TMMUITZ CANYON WAY ARENAS RGkW ARENAS ROAD — BITE Z E b _` 6atisto Road SATURNINO ROAD RNAON ROAD CITY OF PALM SPRINGS CASE NO. 3.iz7z & TTM 3os41 : DESCRIPTION Appl.for an amendment to the General Plan to delete Arenas Rd, between APPLICANT ,palm Springs Modern Hermosa Dr. and Sunrise Way from the Circulation Homes II LLC Diagram and to construct 46 condominium units on a 4.65 acre parcel located at 1516/1575 E.Arenas Rd. and 1450/1550 E. Baristo Rd.,Zone R-4,Section 14. EXISTING GENERAL PLAN LAND USE DESIGNATIONS FOR SECTION 30 •1 I I}tyu Ma [ew Mt I ASS 'A Ab '� 7 twKES.�eK L As All 4 [W ? c IW M w4c I .� i�y� • '.� GL� fe.0 AllisAc uy 1!T W�p,C NCC �'- .• G ry'/�r/IIIIpYrl111 �� All All SubTec,-r AREA � EXISTING GENERAL PLAN LAND USE DESIGNATIONS FOR SECTION 35 am L4 I N L41- I i� M rf t M I L4 Lf 4 j MIS f,, { ® ."` ,^ � i � ? L4 t4 i — r SiasrzcT AREA . w Mw. R MIS D3O Ll Ill ' A0. LA J.z,, iw 'rrinuunuu�ilwi�s EXISTING GENERAL PLAN CIRCULATION PLAN I ALWO CITe CIS I�MB �yM@ I ---° MA r Iv al4` • c 3a � �_��Z Iw 0 H I2 • F yJ3o 43H/eol� 4s/ao x' 4130Oki Iq At �� n $ c RC 4yso H I N43/so 14 44 45/30 I N4sho ANOAM e o AG etc _ rAkoutr NCC _ R Ac RC Act AG _ Ac A c Ia13o4j&o 1 4b.Xp V43130 H<3/30 Y AOMAS lt+ �ru4ipo J N43/3o N4A/3e SuBS>✓GTIRPt N aS0�1 430 Q 6ArVANf O �� C G ' x4/Via I Nos/so H4s/se I y I 1 0 — o � � ( S V43/yo 15 443/su /S / XGG 1 GENERAL PLAN LAND USE LEGEND DESIGNATION LAND USE DESCRIPTION DENSITY Residential L1/L2 Very Low Density 1-2 units/acre L4 Low Density 2-4 units/acre L6 Low Density 4-6 units/acre M8 Medium Density 6-8 units/acre M15 Medium Density 12-15 units/acre H30 Medium-High Density 21-30 units/acre H43/21 High Density 30-43 units/acre (A) 15-21 units/acre(B) H43/30 High Density 30-43 units/acre (A) 21-30 units/acre (B) CDL6 Density Controlled 3-6 units/acre CDL8 Density Controlled 3-8 units/acre LSR Large Scale Resort 10-30 units/acre Commercial/Industrial CBD Central Business District 30-43 units/acre (A) 21-30 units/acre(B) NCC Neighbourhood Convenience Center ---- CSC Community Shopping Center ---- RC Resort Commercial 30-43 units/acre(A) 15-21 units/acre (B) P Professional 15-21 units/acre GC General Commercial ---- HC Highway Commercial 30-43 units/acre (A) IND Business Industrial 30-43 units/acre(A) Open Space C Conservation 1 unit/20 acres D Desert 1 unit/5 acres PR Parks and Recreation ---- W Watercourse ---- Notes: (A)- Hotel Density (B) - Multi-Family Dwelling Density J L_ t_I I—J�1 I 1 1"U U U L LtSdtND ' ALSIO ROAD I a�aal� Catalyst Opportunity She f, LH�� MDR MBR MBR MBR MBR MBR 1 RA Overlay ®REO Overlay I ®Resort/Auracrlan I 1 Ilat E W I � MR REO i HR 1� w HR :` HR HR i M HR REO Recoil/Entertainment/Office 1 11 • -'+ 1 LSC Local Serving Commercial ��-- ,I—^--^--------y —^--------- 1 --^ NC Neighborhood Commercial I = AMA00 ROAD F HR Residential High REO RA HR RA RA �; HR MR MR Residential Medium a 1 i 1 1•• • MBR Residential Medium-gaffer a ANDRFA I ROAD i ANONA AS ROAD z = I � RA "� 1 REO 1' 1 1 i Neighborhood/Specialized Park RA REO a,l C Cemetery W 1 11 1: 1 �1 1 1 i..... ..aa<a aR• �� 1ANOUITt ;�I�� TWAT gra�a�a�a�l�—a�a�a�a i "J Watercourse e 1 1 REO REO 1 RA 1 C REO 1 RA RA l RA I sZ Major Divided Thoroughfare = - a 1 1 1• -•1 ��Major Thoroughfare —1———iI ARlNAS ROAD ��;,•T!� - ma ,awu Major Thoroughfare with - --- I l Reduced Pavement Width HR Special Thoroughfare LSC I I HR 1 HR ; HR r ——— Secondary Thoroughfare _ HR HR A 1 L Coaectorstreels— ----� #AALSTO ROAD LSC 1 1 1 W / Fire Station . . . . .. .. . . . . S Ai UANINO ROAD a I I HR a W a' sao� 4001 goal tzaD' s I Scone; Gum Aswc��e LSC j HR j HR W Land Use and Circulation g HR HR NC NC Plan I I _ 9 = I AAMON ROAD SECTION 14 MASTER DEVELOPMENT PLAN �1;��j PAGE 43 i AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING NOTICES I, the undersigned City Clerk of the City of Palm Springs, California, do hereby certify that a copy of the Notice of Public Hearing before the City Council of the City of Palm Springs, in conjunction with Case No. 5.0916, Case No. 5.0938 and Case No. 5.0941, Amendments to the General Plan Land Use and Circulation Elements, applicants: Matthew Dragicevich Charitable Remainder Trust; Laguna Pacific LP for Canyon Vista, LP; and Palm Springs Modern Homes Il, LLC, respectively, was mailed to each and every person on the attached list on the 4th day of February, 2003. A copy of said Notice is attached hereto. Said mailing was completed by placing a copy of said Notice in a sealed envelope, with postage prepaid, and depositing same in the U.S. Mail at Palm Springs, California. I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Dated at Palm Springs, California, this 4th day of February, 2003. PATRICIA A. SANDX City Clerk NOTICE OF CITY COUNCIL MEETING NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING CITY OF PALM SPRINGS Case No. 5.0916, Case No. 5.0938, and Case No. 5.0941 Amendments to the General Plan Land Use and Circulation Elements NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of the City of Palm Springs, California, will hold a public hearing at its meeting of February 19, 2003. The City Council meeting begins at 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber at City Hall, 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way, Palm Springs. The purpose of the hearing is to consider amendments to the General Plan with regards to the Land Use and Circulation elements. The first request is Case 5.0916, an application by Matthew Dragicevich Charitable Remainder Trust for an amendment to the General Plan Map so as to redesignate 5.11 acres of land located at 4155 E. Matthew Drive from M15 (Medium Density Residential) to GC (General Commercial) and C (Conservation). The second request is for Case 5.0938, an application by Laguna Pacific, LP for Canyon Vista, LP to amend the General Plan Map from M15 (Medium Density: 12-15 units/acre) to H30 (Medium- High Density: 21-30 units/acre)for the property located at the northeast corner of Murray Canyon Drive and Sierra Madre. The General Plan Map Amendment will facilitate the development of a 66- unit timeshare project. The third request is for Case 5.0941, an application by Palm Springs Modern Homes 11, LLC for an amendment to the General Plan Circulation Plan to delete Arenas Road between Hermosa Avenue and Sunrise Way. Currently, Arenas Road is designated as a secondary thoroughfare on the General Plan, but is unimproved in the portion described above. The deletion of Arenas Road between Hermosa Avenue and Sunrise Way is consistent with existing conditions and the Draft Section 14 Master Plan. An Environmental Assessment has been prepared and will be reviewed by the City Council at the meeting. A draft Mitigated Negative Declaration of Environmental Impact has been prepared for the subject proposals. Members of the public may view this document in the Department of Planning and Building, City Hall, 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way, Palm Springs, and submit written comments to the City Clerk at, or prior to, the City Council hearing. If any group challenges the action in court, issues raised may be limited to only those issues raised at the public hearing described in this notice or in written correspondence at, or prior to the City Council hearing. An opportunity will be given at said hearing for all interested persons to be heard. Questions regarding this case may be directed to Jing Yeo, Associate Planner, (760) 323-8245. PATRICIA A. SANDERS Publish: February 4, 2003 City Clerk The Public Record 508-115-001 508-115-002 508-115-003 Theodore H Kessel Ronnie L Sweeney William T Mead 910 2nd St S 509 Playa 6 Del Italia Kirkland WA 98033 Newport Beach CA 92660 Irvine CA 92614 508-115-004 508-115-005 508-115-006 Anthony Galietti Diane F Jacobs American Red Cross 153 E 57th St 16h 1360 Tiffany Cir N 550 W C St 1300 New York NY 10022 Palm Springs CA 92262 San Diego CA 92101 508-115-007. 508-115-008 508-115-009 Pearl Frank Richard D See Ted & Rita Basch 184 E Palm Canyon Dr 1366 Tiffany Cir N 6370 Drexel Ave Palm Springs CA 92264 Palm Springs CA 92262 Los Angeles CA 90048 508-115-010 508-115-011 508-115-012 Marjoarie Ruthruff Cynthia Ainsworth Samuel R Rivkin 1432 Tiffany Cir N 1932 Pierce St 2815 Nichols Canyon Rd Palm .Springs CA . 92262 San Francisco CA 94115 Los Angeles CA 90046 508-11-5-013 508-115-014 508-115-015 Donald L Ross Lois R Mclean Joel E & Marilyn Sorkin 1450 Tiffany Cir N PO Box 2008 6922 W 85th St Palm Springs CA 92262 Palm Springs CA 92263 Los Angeles CA 90045 508-115-016 508-115-017 508-115-018 Gary R & Gayle Wilson Horst J Roeder Raymond D Rustad 1456 Tiffany Cir N 21 Newcastle Ln 20152 Midland Ln Palm Springs CA 92262 Laguna Niguel CA 92677 Huntington Beach 92646 508-115-019 508-115-020 508-115-021 Dale F Maguire Frank J Coronado Robert S Walwick 304 Tiffany Cir E 9474 Olive St 423 Crouch St Palm Springs CA 92262 Temple City CA 91780 Oceanside CA 92054 508-115-023 508-115-024 508-115-025 Denise Campbell Jeffrey Bormaster Robert Geissler 37 Charles Ter 538 Congo St 1477 Tiffany Cir S Waldwick NJ 07463 San Francisco CA 94131 Palm Springs CA 92262 508-115-026 508-115-027 508-115-028 Davison J March Walter E & Lona Jackson Sandra S Evans 12 Crazy Horse Ct 1473 Tiffany Cir S 267 Warren St Palm Coast FL 32137 Palm Springs CA 92262 Brooklyn NY 11201 508-115-029 508-115-030 508-115-031 Patricia N Hawley J C & Stacy Lewis Donna Y Gordon 16045 Rimrock Rd 225 4th Ave A505 57533 29 Palms Hwy 8 Apple Valley CA 92307 Kirkland WA 98033 Yucca Valley CA 92284 A ' -. 508-115-032 508-115-033 508-115-034 George T Sheridan Jane G Thompson Frank F & Barbara Feher PO Box 1360 1377 Tiffany Cir S 1375 Tiffany Cir S Palm Springs CA 92263 Palm Springs CA 92262 Palm Springs CA 92262 508-115-035 508-115-036 508-115-037 Jirina Homolka Stephen Sims Reuter 1373 Tiffany Cir S 1371 Tiffany Cir S 23662 Via Ortega Palm Springs CA , 92262 Palm Springs CA 92262 Trabuco Canyon CA 92679 508-115-038 508-115-039 508-115-040 Donald W Mcclaskey Pearl Mund Alex & Betty Zar 11 Main Ave 1520 Camden Ave 1331 Tiffany Cir S Tillamook OR 97141 Los Angeles CA 90025 Palm Springs CA 92262 508-115-041 508-115-042 508-115-043' James E Webster Warren J Westling Reginald R Belding 4060 W Lake Sammamish P 2344 Pinecrest Dr 6251 Farinella Dr Bellevue WA 98008 Altadena CA 91001 Huntington Beach 92647 508-115-044 508-115-045 508-115-046 Henry H & Bess Resnick Dennis E Sprando Phillip A Smith 10611 Lindamere Dr 2014 SE Nehalem St 1372 Tiffany Cir S Los Angeles CA 90077 Portland OR 97202 Palm Springs CA 92262 508-115-047 , 508-IIS-048 508-115-049 Sos Metals Inc Paul J Cancelli Thomas Fee . 5103 Paramount Blvd 743 N Cherokee Ave 1275 N White Ave Pico Rivera CA 90660 Los Angeles' CA 90038 Pomona CA 91768 508-115-050 508-115-051 508-115-052 John W & Helen Glessner Madelyne S Katz Theodore J Simon 707 Orange Ave G3 1367 Tiffany Cir N 218 Basinside Way Coronado CA 92118 Palm Springs CA 92262 Alameda CA 94502 508-115-053 508-115-054 508-115-055 Bonnette & Ernest Smith Elaine M Berke William J & M Healey 1450 W Colorado Blvd 20 17009 Cotter Pl 1327 Tiffany Cir N Pasadena CA 91105 Encino CA 91436 Palm Springs CA 92262 508-115-056 508-115-057 508-115-058 , Wayne & Sylvia Hilton Fern Naxon Carl R Lamarca : 9600 Highridge Dr 6933 N Kedzie Ave 1321 !Tiffany Cir N Beverly Hills CA 90210 Chicago IL 60645 Palm Springs CA 92262 508-115-059 H Kassinger Dev Cc 777 Tahquitz Mccallum Palm Springs CA 92262 502 161 004 502 163 019 502 163 021 Sunrise&Tahquitz Llc Edward Lawson Msls Mapleridge Inc 15938 Bernardo Center Dr PO Box 4750 Mariott Dr 5293801 San Diego,CA 92127 Palm Springs,CA 92263 Washington,DC 20060 50 0 001 508' 007 508 24 City Of n gs Usa Bia Palm Springs ool Dist PO Box Unlaio 0-07- Unkno Pa prings, C 92263 0 032 100 038 508 10 039 Usa Bia /� United States Of America In Usa 8 Unknown -30-1 Caliente Band Agua Unknown 10-17-88 9 CA PO Box 2245 CA Palm Springs, CA 92263 508 100 040 508 110 042 508 110 052 Usa Agua Caliente Band Of Cahuilla Place Sunrise Wolfgang&Alice Morgenstern PO Box 2245 1995 Market St Morgenstern Palm Springs,CA 92263 Riverside,CA 92501 12273 Vista Panorama Santa Ana,CA 92705 115 0" Usa Unnkno -13-79 S C 009 601488 009 603 125 009 607 097 Boys Club Of Palm Springs Inc Samuel Wacht&J Herbert Klein 201 Sunrise Way 450 S Sunrise Way 277 S Sunrise Way 9200 W Sunset Blvd#1100 Palm Springs,CA 92262 Palm Springs,CA 92262 West Hollywood, CA 90069 009 612138 009 613 347 Haskell Cahan Palm Springs Senior Center 1300 E Baristo Rd 480 S Sunrise Way Palm Springs,CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Neighborhood Coalition List MS CHRISTINE HAMMOND MS JANE COWLES SMITH as of December 2002 1155 SOUTH CAMINO REAL 12000 RUSHMORE (discard all prior lists) PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 WHITEWATER CA 92282 MR FRANK TYSEN MR JOHN HURTER MR BOB WEITHORN C/O CASA CODY COUNTRY INN PO BOX 2824 261 SOUTH BELARDO ROAD 175 SOUTH CAHUILLA ROAD PALM SPRINGS CA 92263-2824 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 MR TIM HOHMEIER MR BOB SEALE MR PHIL TEDESCO 1387 CALLE DE MARIA 280.CAMINO SUR 1303 WEST PRIMAVERA DRIVE PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 S f VN\'S 0 2S Marvin Roots Mainiero, Smith & Associates 777 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way Suite 301 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Dennis Cunningham Palm Springs Modern Homes 74-140 El Paseo Suite 4 PMB 520 Palm Desert, CA 92260 Douglas Peters Design ARC 10500 West Pico Blvd. Los Angeles, CA 00064 512 230 001 512 230 002 512 230 003 Sherr Platt&David Rosenfeld David Feldman&Irene Feldman David&Barbara Everly 642 N Larchmont Blvd 315 Winthrop Dr 2727 S Sierra Madre#3 Los Angeles, CA 90004 Ithaca,NY 14850 Palm Springs,CA 92264 512 230 004 512 230 005 512 230 006 Mario&Cynthia Berardi Randy Weiner Christine Ramos 2727 S Sierra Madre#4 2727 S Sierra Madre#5 2727 S Sierra Madre#6 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 512 21Q 007 8 512 230 008 512 230 009 Michael yn Hollinger Michael&Marilyn Hollinger Betty Lesin Kotler&Betty Lesin $305 White Ave 5305 White Oak Ave#E 300 N Swall Dr Encino, CA 6 Encino,CA 91316 Beverly Hills,CA 90211 512230010 512230011 Ed&Cecile Gromis Sierra Madre Apartments 141,S Windsor Blvd 2727 S Sierra Madre Los Angeles,CA 90004 Palm Springs,CA 92264 SPONSORS/APPLICANTS 5.0938-PD-282 TTM 31006 115. APN: 12-230-01 ULTRASYSTEMS NP SIERRA MAD ENTS ATTN:ANTHONY SERPA GC MAPPING SERVICE 2727 SIERRA M 100 PACIFICA SUITE 250 ATTN:GILBERT CASTRO PALM SPRIN CA 9 IRVINE CA 92618-3811 711 MISSION ST STE B SO PASADENA CA 91030 LAGUNA PACIFIC LP CANYON VISTA LP C/O MR JOSEPH T MORREALE PO BOX 1691 LAKE ARROWHEAD CA 92352 ' 1. APM512-131-020,021 2. APN:512- 1-013 N:512-160- 3,009,014 CANYON SITE CORP BIASA PO BOX 4563 2850 S ANYON DR SAME AS#2 PALM SPRINGS CA 92263 ! PALM 5P GS CA 92264-9337 i APN: 512-171-00 OS APN 12-172-001 TO 00 ,009 TO 3. APN:512-172-005 Ol 1,0 5,017,018,Ol 2Q 022,024 BLEIIKER L.&JUANITA L.GRAHAM ; SAME AS# 464 SANTIAGO WAY SAME AS#2 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262- j � 4. APN:512-172-012 5. APN:512-180-006 6. APN:512-180-009 + RICHARD H.LANGLEY : CANYON VILLAS HOMEOWNERS ZIEGELMAN TRUST i 1875 CENTURY PARK E#3 • ASSNINC 27369 PASEO PLACENTIA LOS ANGELES CA 90067-2501 10701 WILS14ME BLVD SAN JUAN CAPISTRANO CA 92675-5348 LOS ANGELES CA 900244401 APN:512-180- 10 ! : 7. APN.512-180-013 8. APN:512-200-004 KIRSCHBROWN R&P 2000 TRUST DEANNA M.ANDREAS SAME AS : 7201 SHADYLANE WAY PO BOX 2245 ROSEVILLE CA 95747-8044 PALM SPRINGS CA 92263-2245 f N:512-200-005 •� 9. APN:512-240-001 10. APN:512-240-002 PAMELA MOSS RENTALS LLC WAHOO-CAL SAMEY:512-240-003 2696 S SIERRA MADRE i 4109 NE 19TH AVE STE B PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9454 PORTLAND OR 97211-5162 i 11. 12. APN:512-240-004 13. APN:512-240-005 SUSAN W.BRAUN LAWRENCE N.&JANICE L.TAYLOR JEAN F.FINLAYSON 1571 IRIS GLEN DR 23715 MALIBU RD#521 PO BOX 4545 TWINSBURG OH 44087-1095 : MALIBU CA 902654602 PALM SPRINGS CA 92263-4545 I 114. APN:512-240-006 j 15. APN:512-240-007 16. APN:512-240-008 IRVIN FREDERICK&LORRAINE_WOZNIAK MARTIN MAGNBS i JOSEF LEWKOWICZ . 2696 S SIERRA MADRE UNIT Ali i 606 N BEVERLY DR 1901 ROXBURY DR PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9463 BEVERLY HILLS CA 90210-3320 LOS ANGELES CA 900354031 i 17. APN:512-240-009 j 18. APN1512-240-010 19. APN:512-240-011 LEON &BERTHA GOTTLIE13 j DIANE GA13B NICHOLAS NINOS 1578 ROXBURY DR 2737 LOCKSLEY RD 2696 S SIERRA MADRE UNIT AS LOS ANGELES CA 90035-2821 LOS ANGELES CA 90039 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9462 i 20. APN:512-240-012 21. APN:512-240-013 22. APN:512-240-014 LESTER C.&ELIZABETH A HOLTZEN NORA &ARMAND KEOSIAN JACK &JACQUE L.SIERAD 606 KINGSFORD ST 18161 CHARDON CIR 23416 CANZONET ST MONTEREY PARK CA 9 1754-26 1 3 ENCINO CA 91316-4416 WOODLAND HILLS CA 91367-6013 23. APN:512-240-015 24. APN:512-240-016 25. APN:512-240-017 SHAPELL INDUSTRIES INC DONALD ERMAN A.T.&GLORIAH.GOULDING 8383 WILSHIRE BLVD STE 700 197 W LEGION RD#300 630 SANDPOINT WAY NE#301 BEVERLY HILLS CA 90211-2406 BRAWLEY CA 92227-7714 SEATTLE WA 98115- 26. APN:512-240-018 27. APN:512-240-019 28. APN:512-240-020 GREGG MCCARTY FRANKLIN C.&SUSAN L.SARTAIN MATTHEW &SHARON R.SLOAN 2696 S SIERRA MADRE 1932 S OAKS AVE 180 ANGELO WALK PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9454 ONTARIO CA 91762-6058 LONG BEACH CA 90803 4107 29. APN:512-240-021 30. APN:512-240-022 31. APN:512-240-023 BERNADINE MASSER A.THOMAS&GLORIA JEAN GOULDING JOHN W.&MARY E.MARTIN 1892 LINDEN AVE 6300 SAND POINT WAY NE 2696 S SIERRA MADRE UNIT F7 HIGHLAND PARK IL 60035-2647 SEATTLE WA 98115-7972 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9464 32. APN:512-240-024 33. APN:512-240-025 34. APN:512-240-026 HIDETAKA KIMURA SHARON M.EVER ED SYBILA B.HAMRLA VLADOSA 2696 S SIERRA MADRE 2696 S SIERRA MADRE UNIT F8 2696 S SIERRA MADRE UNIT F18 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9454 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9464 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9465 35. APN:512-240-027 36. APN:512-240-028 37. APN:512-240-029 HARVEY &DIANA MAHLER STUART &ARLENE MARZELL DIANA SERVICE 19218 WELLS DR 2020 VALLECITO DR 2696 S SIERRA MADRE UNIT F10 TARZANA CA 91356-3821 HACIENDA HEIGHTS CA 91745-4105 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9464 38. APN:512-240-030 39. APN:5 12-240-031 40. APN:512-240-032 DOUGHERTY STEPHEN R TRUST&ERNA SHAW RAWLAND&HAROLD TRUST PATRICK C.EVINGER 6974 SW TIERRA DEL MAR DR 2696 S SIERRA MADRE 5318 GLASGOW WAY BEAVERTON OR 97007-5123 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9454 LOS ANGELES CA 90045-2214 41. APN:512-240-033 42. APN:512-240-034 43. APN:512-240-035 NORMAN L.&JOY S.TITINER KURT &DIANE M.JOHNSTON SANFORD EHRENS 1164 COLORADO AVE 2696 S SIERRA MADRE UNIT F12 1301 N PALM CANYON DR STE 305 AURORA IL 60506-2042 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9465 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262.4400 44. APN:512-240-036 45. APN:512-240-037 46. APN:512-240-038 MICHAEL E.BASS KENSINGTON PLACE REALTY CO SALLY BREEN HUGHES 2696 S SIERRA MADRE UNIT F12 1920 KENSINGTON PL 671.MIRAMAR AVE PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9465 AURORA IL 60506-4519 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94112 47. APN:512-240.039 48. APN:512-240-040 49. APN:512-240-042 ZANDER BOWMAN MARCELLA CAPETA FNBC 1275 E VIA ESTRELLA 2696 S SIERRA MADRE#15 2696 SIERRA MADRE PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9541 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9454 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262- 50. APN:512-240-044 50. APN:512-250-001 51. APN:512-250-002 LESTER C.&R A.HOLTZEN M&M TRUST KELLY A.PURCELL 606 KINGSFORD ST 411 W ARENAS RD APT 4 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 61 MONTEREY PARK CA 91754-2613 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262-6371 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9354 52. APN:512-250-003 53. APN:512-250-004 54. APN:512-250-005 DON K.&MARY L.SULLIVAN BOBBY &KENDRA RICCIO SHIRLEY L.BARASCH 1511 WATERBURY WAY 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 63 127 8T ST LA HABRA CA 90631-6408 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9354 SEAL BEACH CA 90740 55. APN:512-250-" 56. APN.512-250-007 57. APN:512-250-008 ARTHUR &JACQUELINE S.BURDORF HEIDI D.FLAUM JAN &CAROL ORME , 804 WALDEN DR 401 NEWPORT CENTER DR STE 209 1867 YGNACIO VALLEY RD#402 BEVERLY HILLS CA 90210-3034 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660-6930 WALNUT CREEK CA 94598-3214 58. APN:512-250-009 59. APN:512-250-010 60. APN:512-250-011 AGNES R.CAPLAN ELIZABETH MARY THILL GALE LARSON 2661 LE14IGH ST 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 53 331 SAN DOMINGO DR ALLENTOWN PA 18103- PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9354 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-6448 61. APN:512-250-012 62. APN:512-250-013 63. APN:512-250-014 SHARON FIELD CHARLES &JOANNE P.RUPERS SURDI RONALD V 2001 TRUST 1409 SEQUOIA TRL 24779 DELWOOD ST 4017 MIRALESTE DR GLENVIEW IL 60025.2016 HARRISON TOWNSHIP MI48045-1914 RANCHO PALOS VERDES CA 90275-6524 64. APN:5 12-250-015 65. APN:512-250-016 66. APN:512-250-017 CINDA L.JOHANSEN R. &S.&PT PAVLOVICH OLIVER E.&PAMELA FRIEZE COBB 2600 S PALM CANYON DR#52 1260 41ST AVE 642 NW 163RD ST PALM SPRINGS CA 92262- CAPPPOLA CA 95010-3929 SHORELINE WA 98177-3727 67. APN:512-250-018 68, APN:512-250-019 69. APN:512-250-020 R D.&K.A. WHITE14EAD ROSENT'HAL 2001 TRUST LESLIE B.ELLIOTT 1407 LISBON IN 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 48 2212 QUEEN ANNE'AVE N PEBBLE BEACH CA 93953-3207 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9370 SEATTLE WA 98109-2312 70. APN:512-250-021 71. APN:512=250-022 72. APN:512-250-023 ANNETTE JOHANSEN ROSEMARY COOLEY RONALD E.&CHRISTINE D.COOK 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 42 1993 S MESA DR PO BOX 391399 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9370 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-2604 ANZA CA 92539-1399 73. APN:512-250-024 74. APN;512-250-025 75, APN:512-250-026 KHALIL AILABOUNI MICHAEL &ANNA W.APPLETON ROBERT D.ATKINS 2600 S PALM CANYON DR 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 38 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 37 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9346 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9370 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9370 76. APN:512-250-027 77. APN:512-250-028 78, APN:512-250-029 CYNTHIA V.WANTA RICHARD &THELMA WISPE MAURICE &BARBARA SHER 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 40 5341 KENILWORTH DR 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 34 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9370 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92649-4526 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9370 79. APN:512-250-030 80. APN:512-250-031 81. APN:512-250-032 GERALD L.CARLSON LORENTZ &MARIA FULOP DONALD W.&LAVONNE J.BURDICK 2600 S PALM CANYON DR 1935 GOLDEN RAIN RD APT 1 2600 S PALM CANYON DR PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9346 WALNUT CREEK CA 94595-2182 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9346 82. APN:512-250-033 83. APN:512-250-034 84, APN:512-250-035 MERLOW WAYNE&CHERIE MAREE JOSEPH P.&NANCY L.CATALANO JEROME L.&MARLENE LIPIN HULTGRE 414 EMERSON ST 5511 W 62ND ST 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT30 UPLAND CA 91 784-1 3 75 LOS ANGELES CA 90056-2007 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9369 �.d pe8 85. APN:512-250.036 $6. APN:512-250-037 87, APN:512-250-038 CAROL,LEE ARMSTRONG WITTER RICHARD H&LOENE M TR PHERIPO &FILOMENA IOVENrM PO BOX 16998 68 E ALEGRIA AVE 8566C LARKHALL CIR#811 ' IRVINE CA 92623.6998 SIERRA MADRE CA 91024-1203 HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 92646-5612 88. APN:512-250.039 89. APN:512-250-040 90. APN:512-250-041 ALLEN &VIVIAN DEITELBAUM JAMES R.COLE RICHARD G.&SARAH E.TAYLOR 2600 S PALM CANYON DR#N028 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 27 534 AZALEA AVE NE PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9346 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9369 BAINBRIDGE ISLAND WA 98110-2910 9L APN:512-250-042 92. APN:512-250-043 93, APN:512-250-044 LANE WINIFRED M 2001 TRUST CARL J.&ROSEMARY LANE JOHN WILCOX 31532 CRYSTAL SANDS DR 26500 AGOURA RD#724 1750 E OCEAN BLVD LAGUNA NIGUEL CA 92677-2708 CALABASAS CA 91302-1952 LONG BEACH CA 90802-6060 94. APN:512-250-045 95. APN:512-250-046 96. APN:512-250-047 DONALD P.TAYLOR HOWARD MAURICE&ADELINE DALE HOWARD &ESTHER FRIEDMAN 20 CHEMICAL WAY KASS 5518 TOWERS ST REDWOOD CITY CA 94063-2715 9855 WHITWELL DR TORRANCE CA 90503-1225 BEVERLY HILLS CA 90210-1019 97. APN:512-250-048 98. APN:512-250-049 99. APN:512-250-050 FRANK E.JACKSON RICHARD L.OCONNOR FRANK J.MAHONEY 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 19 58 LINDA ISLE 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 13 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9369 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9368 100. APN:512-250-051 101. APN:512-250-052 102. APN:512-250-053 WOLFGANG &INGRID URBAT KENNETH B.VMG ROCHELLE COHEN 2318 TEASLEY ST 2600 S PALM CANYON DR 19528 VENTURA BLVD#330 LA CRESCENTA CA 91214-2222 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9346 TARZANA CA 91356-2917 103. APN:512-250-054 104. APN:512-250-055 105. APN:512-250-056 KRETZU SYLVIA L TRUST MAX R.&LUCY A.FIELDS HARRY M.&LOIS JUNE PASKIL 400 S FARRELL DR STE B-107 2606 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 12 22 DOVER PL PALM SPRINGS CA 92262-7964 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264.9368 MANHATTAN BEACH CA 90266-7228 106. APN:512-250-057 107. APN:512-250-058 108. APN:512-250-059 CLEOPATRA &LOUIS FRANK MASCOLA STEVEN R.&MAYDA R CARNES ELIZABETH JULIA CAMERON 1909 MARINA DR 18417 MOUNT CHERIE CIR 5417 OCEAN VIEW BLVD SAN PEDRO CA 90732-4313 FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA 92708-6837 LA CANADA CA 91011-1215 109. APN. 12- 0-060 110. APN:512-250-061 ill. APN:512-250-062 CLEOPATRA & UIS FRANK MASCOLA BOBBIE HARPER PINTO GREGORY W.CASSERLY 1909 MARINA DR PO BOX 5029 19 WHITECLIFF WAY SAN PEDRO CA 9 73 313 PALM SPRINGS CA 92263-5029 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94124-2282 112. APN:512-250-063 113. APN:512-250-064 114. APN:512-250-065 LOUIS C.&HELEN SMITS FRANK SELBERIS PALM CANYON PROPERTIES INC 2600 S PALM CANYON DR#4 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 3 2600 S PALM CANYON DR UNIT 3 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9368 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9368 A $. 009 600 166 009 602 099 009 602 100 Ago Cafhe ev Authority Steven Little&Richard Langley Jr. Theodore Makin&Barbara Nialtin CANTON C Y'CLUB 1875 Century Park E#150 465 E Santiago Way 1100 E Murra you Dr Los Angeles,CA 90067 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, A 92264 009 602 101 009 602 102 009 602 105 Ernest& Carolyn Nola Estate Firm Real Milt Israel Family Trust Noia 2720 NE 33Rd Ave 300 E Santiago Way 457 E Santiago Way Portland, OR 97212 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 602 106 009 602 107 009 602 108 Daniel Livingston Joseph Kotansky&William Vanhorn George Machado 390 E Santiago Way 422 E Santiago Way 444 E Santiago Way Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 602 109 009 603 028 009 6 3 034 1988 Graham Agua Caliente Dev Authority Agua Tent ev Authority 464 E Santiago Way CANYON COUNTRY CLUB CANYO UN' CLUB Palm Springs, CA 92264 I100 E Murray Canyon Dr 1100E Canyon Dr Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm prings, 92264 009 606 026 0096 595 009 615 596 Marilyn Yokaitis Vista Vista Canyon 31 Churchill Ln 505 S Fa 1 Dr#75 505 S Farrell Dr#75 - Rancho Mirage, CA 92270 Palm Sprig A 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 615 597 00 615 598 009 615 600 Vr Can Vista Vista 505 S Dr#75 505 S F H Dr 475 505 S F ll Dr#75 P Springs, 92264 Pal prin ,CA 92264 Pal p s, CA 92264 009 615 601 00X 009 615 604 VXSell Vi Vi n 5r#75 SODr#75 505 S ell Dr#75 PCA 92264 PaCA 92264 Pal Sprin s, CA 92264 009 615 605 009 XSpnnogn Vi Vist505 S I Dr#75 505 r#75 Pal Springs, A 92264 PalCA 92264 S 4Yd 8 Neighborhood Coalition List MS CHRISTINE HAMMOND MS JANE COWLES SMITH as of December 2002 1155 SOUTH CAMINO REAL 12000 RUSHMORE (discard all prior lists) PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 WHITEWATER CA 92282 for P.C. Hearing Jan. 22, 2003 MR FRANK TYSEN MR JOHN HURTER MR BOB WEITHORN C/O CASA CODY COUNTRY INN PO BOX 2824 261 SOUTH BELARDO ROAD 175 SOUTH CAHUILLA ROAD PALM SPRINGS CA 92263-2824 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 MR TIM HOHMEIER MR BOB SEALE MR PHIL TEDESCO 1387 CALLE DE MARIA 280 CAMINO SUR 1303 WEST PRIMAVERA DRIVE PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 1U,v"2 a10401 saaaPPV ®/li IMMA 009 661175 009 702 371 009 710 027 Soirthridge Property Owners Assn David Pence&SallyPence Matthew&Vorgie Draglrevich 3333 B Palm Canyon Dr 183 Malibu Dr 4193 B Matthew Dr Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 681 160 002 681 160 012 68 160 014 Raymond Ellis Fdh Enterprises Inc Fdh s Inc 2601 S Cherokee Way 11300 N Rodney Parham Rd#300 11300 odney Parham Rd#300 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Little Rock, AR 72212 Li ocIcW 72212 1 160 0 68 160 0 681 170 001 Use iashingto aSeminole Associates U =01.83 Interior 173 N Anita Ave A DC 20401 Los Angeles, CA 90049 � $Fr0 A 6 of 681 170 007 681 170 038 681 170 063 Marilyn Zalkowitz&Annette Zalkowit If F Boeckmamr Ii&Jane Boeckmann Gary Boskovich&Lloyd Maryanov PO Box 5420 15505 Roscoe Blvd 79808 Arnold Palmer Palm Springs, CA 92263 Sepulveda, CA 91343 La Quinta, CA 92253 170 064 681 170 065 6 1 170 066 Gary sk ch&Lloyd Maryanov Gary&Susan Boskovich G vlch&Lloyd Maryanov 79808 d Palmer 4193 B Matthew Dr 798 d Palmer La -Uinta, CA 92253 Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Uinta C 2253 SranS� D Loyd Trust 681 LZO 0�68John Sanborn y Maryanov Trustee Usa Jr, gene JrSeundo Sanborn.Ale, Inc. 801 E. Tahquitz Canyon NOS ET orNOIrmER 1227S. Gene Autry Trail#C Palm Springs, CA 92262 C Palm Springs, CA 92264 Sanborn A/E, Inc. 1227 S. Gene Autry Trl C Palm Springs, CA 92264 Neighborhood Coalition Labels Bob Seale Christine Hammond John Hunter 280 Camino Sur 1155 S, Camino Real P.O. Box 2824 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92263 Philip Tedesco Tim Hohmeier Frank Tysen 1303 West Primavera Drive 1387 Calle De Maria Casa Cody Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 175 South Cahuilla Road Palm Springs, CA 92264 Bob Weithorn Jane Smith 261 South Belardo Road 928 Avenida Palmas Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92262 58. ApN:512-250-009 d u: AGNES R.Ct1 LAN 2661 LEHIGHST ALLENTO1"PA 18103- OA INSUFFICIENT FlOD RESS i NO SUCH NUMMpIEO BER%S REST S ❑ NOT DELIVER OTfj'RXzll U11,11LE iO Fgfl��SRNDORESSED 17 j - j 32. APN:512-240-024 Y- 4 �fL ii, ii MDETAKA KIMURA 49. APN:5 12-240-042 fn g 2696 S SIERRA MADRE FNBC i q�/,, PALM SPRINGS CA 92264-9454 2696 SIERRA MADRE l , v — -- - PALM SPRINGS CA 92262- 1 r +yly OR i0 75 N ,p, jo,4 64.9346 APN_512-240-001' , 9. G S? �SCA9 ,F PAMELAMOSS 2696 S SISRRAMADRB /'�vV �— PALM SPRINGS CA92264.9454 Lr 274371 �- �' �.. 512230011 5AM SON 34 Sierra Madre APanents ,t� Madre 79. 2727 S Sierra GA 92264 - GERALD L. CANYON AR 2.600 SYA�- CA 92264-9346__ GS RESOLUTION NO. OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING AMENDMENTS TO THE GENERAL PLAN LAND USE AND CIRCULATION ELEMENTS SO AS TO: (A) REDESIGNATE 5.11 ACRES OF LAND FROM MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL 12-15 UNITS/ACRE (M15) TO GENERAL COMMERCIAL (GC) AND CONSERVATION (C) FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 4155 EAST MATTHEW DRIVE, ZONE R-2 AND R-1-AH, SECTION 30; (B) REDESIGNATE 3.27 ACRES OF LAND FROM MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL 12-15 UNITS/ACRE (M15) TO MEDIUM-HIGH DENSITY RESIDENTIAL 21-30 UNITS/ACRE (H30) FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF MURRAY CANYON DRIVE AND SIERRA MADRE,ZONE R-2 AND O, SECTION 35;(C)DELETE AN UNIMPROVED PORTION OF ARENAS ROAD BETWEEN SUNRISE WAY AND HERMOSA DRIVE FROM THE CIRCULATION PLAN. WHEREAS, Matthew Dragicevich Charitable Remainder Trust (the "applicant') has filed Case 5.0916 with the City for a General Plan Map Amendment to redesignate 5.11 acres of land from Medium Density Residential 12-15 units/acre(M15)to General Commercial(GC)and Conservation (C)for the property located at 4155 East Matthew Drive, Zone R-2 and R-1-AH, Section 30; and WHEREAS, Laguna Pacific, LP for Canyon Vista, LP (the "applicant') has filed Case 5.0938 with the City for a General Plan Map Amendment to redesignate 3.27 acres of land from Medium Density Residential 12-15 units/acre (M15)to Medium-High Density Residential 21-30 units%acre (H30)for the property located at the northeast corner of Murray Canyon Drive and Sierra Madre, Zone R-2 and O, Section 35; and WHEREAS, Palm Springs Modern Homes II, LLC(the"applicant') has filed Case 5.0941 with the City for an amendment to the General Plan Circulation Plan to delete an unimproved portion of Arenas Road between Sunrise Way and Hermosa Drive in conjunction with the project located at 1460 and 1550 East Baristo Road; and WHEREAS, notice of a public hearing of the Planning Commission of the City of Palm Springs to consider Case Nos. 5.0916, 5.0938, and 5.0941, requests to amend the General Plan Land Use and Circulation Elements was given in accordance with applicable law; and WHEREAS, on January 22, 2003 a public hearing to consider Case Nos. 5.0916, 5.0938, and 5.0941, requests to amend the General Plan Land Use and Circulation Elements, was held by the Planning Commission in accordance with applicable law; and WHEREAS, notice of a public hearing of the City Council of the City of Palm Springs to consider Case Nos. 5.0916, 5.0938, and 5.0941, requests to amend the General Plan Land Use and Circulation Elements was given in accordance with applicable law; and )ate WHEREAS, on February 19, 2003 a public hearing to consider Case Nos. 5.0916, 5.0938, and 5.0941, requests to amend the General Plan Land Use and Circulation Elements, was held by the City Council in accordance with applicable law; and WHEREAS, in accordance with Section 15063 of the California Environmental Quality Act, an Environmental Assessment was prepared and staff found that with the incorporation of proposed mitigation measures, the proposed project could not have a significant effect on the environment; and WHEREAS, the City Council has carefully reviewed and considered all of the evidence presented in connection with the hearing on the project, including but not limited to the staff report, all written and oral testimony presented. THE CITY COUNCIL HEREBY FINDS AS FOLLOWS: Section 1: Pursuant to CEQA, the City Council finds that the current environmental assessment for Case Nos. 5.0916, 5.0938, and 5.0941 adequately addresses the general environmental setting of the proposed Project, its significant environmental impacts, and the mitigation measures related to each significant environmental effect for the proposed project. The City Council further finds that with the incorporation of proposed mitigation measures,potentially significant environmental impacts resulting from this project will be reduced to a level of insignificance and therefore recommends adoption of a Mitigated Negative Declaration for the project. Section 2: Given the use and location of the site located at 4155 East Matthew Drive, the existing commercial uses of the site more closely associates with the commercial uses to the west and northwest than the apartments to the north and residential use and vacant land to the east. The property located at 4155 East Matthew Drive is suitable for the uses intended in the General Plan designation and the uses permitted in the proposed zone, in terms of access, size of parcel, relationship to similar or related uses, and other considerations deemed relevant by the Commission. Section 3: The property at the northeast corner of Murray Canyon Drive and Sierra Madre is currently vacant, but was formerly developed as a tennis club. The re-designation of the property located at the northeast corner of Murray Canyon Drive and Sierra Madre to H30 is appropriate due to surrounding multiple family land use designations. The project site is suitable for the use of land on a timeshare basis due to the density and resort character of the development in the surrounding vicinity. The project will be accessed from Murray Canyon Drive, a secondary thoroughfare, and Sierra Madre, a collector street. Both Murray Canyon Drive and Sierra Madre have already been improved to secondary and collector street standards, respectively.The project site abuts the Canyon Country Club golf course and is sensitive to single family residential development to the north. The building height for the project decreases to fifteen feet and one-story 200 feet from the R-1 C zoning to the north.The 200 foot setback is required by Section 92.04.03.D.2,which limits building heights to 15 feet or one-story when R-3 zoned property abuts R-1 zoned property. /47)0"c Section 4: The deletion of a portion of Arenas Road between Sunrise Way and Hermosa Drive is consistent with the Draft Section 14 Master Plan's Land Use and Circulation Plan and will allow the General Plan to remain internally consistent. The portion of Arenas proposed to be removed is currently unimproved with no plans for future improvements. The proposed amendment to the General Plan Circulation Element is necessary and proper at this time, and is not likely to be detrimental to the adjacent property or residents. Section 5: The proposed amendments to the General Plan are necessary and proper at this time, and are not likely to be detrimental to the adjacent property or residents. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that, based upon the foregoing, the City Council hereby approves the amendments to the General Plan Land Use and Circulation Elements as shown in Exhibits A, B, and C. ADOPTED THIS_day of , 2003. AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTENTIONS: ATTEST: CITY OF PALM SPRINGS, CALIFORNIA City Clerk City Manager Reviewed and Approved as to Form: /01SC3 EXHIBIT A PROPOSED GENERAL PLAN MAP AMENDMENT MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL 12-15 UNITS/ACRE (M15) TO GENERAL COMMERCIAL (GC) AND CONSERVATION (C) APN #681-170-064 I 0O0 w M4t/sJ M• I a.0 —�_/ a M� i L4 PA PA PA I q i. Ms 7 LAKIS YY.. ku f� 7 I 4 Aug c4';, 6� '�6 a b �! I MSS � MA'rMew OR. Ncc M15 4L e Suwiaci AREA C ct/ EXHIBIT B PROPOSED GENERAL PLAN MAP AMENDMENT MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL 12-15 UNITS/ACRE (M15) TO MEDIUM-HIGH DENSITY RESIDENTIAL 21-30 UNITS/ACRE (H30) APN #s 512-172-015 512-172-019 (Lots 24, 25, 26) dos w M400Qf CK M r 4 i• Olt � 44 t4 MIS N � Ill :•• rR /-+ � ��•�` SuarF-c? AxA /�.ff w��\� 4: --'7." �r`le`� r MIS °•: 1.2 Wes L2 = 1 . 1 �. EXHIBIT C PROPOSED GENERAL PLAN CIRCULATION PLAN AMENDMENT DELETION OF PORTION OF ARENAS ROAD BETWEEN SUNRISE WAY AND HERMOSA DRIVE ALEJO Iz I +MB g✓'Me ° Ma wu u Ma I< .--— M.— I� o Iz ' t so y _K w N N is S j F M gs/io 4t I 4s/so 4a/3 oN N .p RC �iysa 4513 I N43/JO M�/3/3a K e A!Jort,irl I s RG 1tC M4W3o Ij AG AG _ TAF#�V17 Y c Y R RG RG RG AO G I�CC .a Jq G 44so o so M43/30 N43/30 P, 0 4300 rnW /HNss I (W AREN15 N t y IW � N4�ysa M. Sss, N3o I Ow SUBJE GT ¢ aArumo I AVER d } K4�V>p N41NJo N43/io i� 0 0 i C H4f(�0 IS H4S/30 I3 30 �S KGG RAMWN j ipww Ylf L/t i mff..