HomeMy WebLinkAbout12/17/2003 - STAFF REPORTS (13) DATE: December 17, 2003
TO: City Council
FROM: Director of Planning and Zoning
CASE NOS. 5.0956, 5.0965, AND 5.0977 - APPLICATIONS TO AMEND THE GENERAL PLAN
CIRCULATION ELEMENT FOR:
(A)5.0956-A REQUEST BY HUDDLE SPRINGS DEVELOPMENT, LLC FOR AN AMENDMENT
TO THE GENERAL PLAN CIRCULATION MAP TO RECLASSIFY MESQUITE AVENUE
BETWEEN SOUTH PALM CANYON DRIVE AND RANDOM ROAD FROM A SECONDARY
THOROUGHFARE TO A COLLECTOR STREET; AND
(B) 5,0965-A REQUEST INITIATED BY THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS FOR AN AMENDMENT
TO THE GENERAL PLAN CIRCULATION MAP TO RECLASSIFY MESQUITE AVENUE
BETWEEN EL CIELO ROAD AND VELLA ROAD FROM A SECONDARY THOROUGHFARE TO
A SPECIAL COLLECTOR STREET, TO CLARIFY GENERAL PLAN POLICY 7.1.5. WITH
REGARDS TO"SPECIAL STREET PROGRAM",AND TO ADD A NEW GENERAL PLAN POLICY
7.1.5.A. "MESQUITE AVENUE SPECIAL STREET PROGRAM"; AND
(C) 5.0977 -A REQUEST BY WESSMAN DEVELOPMENT COMPANY FOR AN AMENDMENT
TO THE GENERAL PLAN CIRCULATION MAP TO RECLASSIFY CAHUILLA ROAD BETWEEN
TAHQUITZ CANYON WAY AND RAMON ROAD FROM A COLLECTOR STREET TO A LOCAL
STREET.
RECOMMENDATION
The Planning Commission recommends that the City Council adopt a resolution to approve:
(A) Case 5.0956 - a request by Huddle Springs Development, LLC for an amendment to the
General Plan Circulation Map to reclassify Mesquite Avenue between South Palm Canyon Drive
and Random Road from a secondary thoroughfare to a collector street; and
(B)Case 5.0965-a request initiated by the City of Palm Springs for an amendment to the General
Plan Circulation Map to reclassify Mesquite Avenue between El Cielo Road and Vella Road from
a secondary thoroughfare to a special collector street, to clarify General Plan Policy 7.1.5. with
regards to "special street program", and to add a new General Plan Policy 7.1.5.a. "Mesquite
Avenue Special Street Program"; and
(C) Case 5.0977 - a request by Wessman Development Company for an amendment to the
General Plan Circulation Map to reclassify Cahuilla Road between Tahquitz Canyon Way and
Ramon Road from a collector street to a local street.
Individual Environmental Assessments and mitigated negative declarations have been prepared
for each proposed General Plan Amendment in association with companion projects. See the
associated staff reports on this agenda for copies of the Environmental Assessment/Initial Studies
and additional information.
SUMMARY
If approved, the City's General Plan Circulation Element will be amended. The Planning
Commission held public hearings on each proposal and associated application. The Planning
Commission recommends approval of all three proposed General Plan Amendments.All proposed
amendments are associated with items on tonight's City Council Agenda.
(A) 5.0956 - HUDDLE SPRINGS
The proposed project is to amend the General Plan - Circulation Element in order to reclassify
Mesquite Avenue between South Palm Canyon Drive and Random Road from a secondary
thoroughfare to a collector street. Mesquite Avenue is currently improved to collector street
standards at this location with a 60 foot right-of-way and a 40 foot wide pavement width. A
secondary thoroughfare would require an 80 to 88 foot right-of-way with a pavement width of 64
feet. Mesquite Avenue east of Random Road is already designated a collector street and traverses
a single family residential neighbourhood. Due to the need to transition from a commercial to
residential uses, downgrading Mesquite Avenue at this location will contribute to the overall traffic
calming program currently being proposed and implemented in the Deepwell/Tahquitz River
Estates neighbourhood.The traffic study completed forthe associated Huddle Springs project also
shows that there is no need to improve Mesquite to secondary thoroughfare standards because
a collector street could support the projected traffic volume.
(B) 5.0965 - CITY OF PALM SPRINGS MESQUITE AVENUE TRAFFIC CALMING PROGRAM
The proposed project is to amend the General Plan—Circulation Element to downgrade Mesquite
Avenue, between El Cielo Road and Vella Road, from a Secondary Thoroughfare to a Special
Collector designation. This designation would allow the existing right-of-way width of 88 feet to be
maintained and the widening of Mesquite Avenue between Mountain View Drive and Avenida La
Evelita to construct a special street section consisting of two through traffic lanes (one in each
direction)separated by a 12-foot wide raised, landscaped median,and a one-way local park access
road with parallel parking.
A General Plan Policy 7.1.5 amendment is proposed to clarify the definition of "special street
programs". This clarification/definition of"special street programs" will allow greater flexibility for
special pavement sections to be achieved and still be consistent with the General Plan. A new
General Plan Policy 7.1.5.a. "Mesquite Avenue Special Street Program" will also be created to
provide a reference to the proposed project.
The existing General Plan Policy 7.1.5. reads as follows:
"Cross-section standards may be modified by the Planning Commission and City Council to take
into consideration the need for special right-of-way widths, street improvements, or pavement
widths: where property cannot be feasibly acquired and/or within the downtown to facilitate traffic
calming and public parking facilities and/or the nature of the terrain through which the street passes
to prevent scarring of the landscape area needed to provide linear parks, bicycle or other
alternative transportation facilities and/or achieve an urban design and special street program; or
in response to a specific plan or planned development district. In addition, the determination of the
Planning Commission and City Council shall conclude that there are no significant impacts to
health, safety, and welfare of the residents of Palm Springs."
/C
The proposed General Plan Policy 7.1.5. would read as follows:
"Cross-section standards may be modified by the Planning Commission and/or City Council to take
into consideration the need for special right-of-way widths, street improvements, or pavement
widths: where property cannot be feasibly acquired and/or within the downtown to facilitate traffic
calming and public parking facilities and/or where the street will scar the landscape due to the
nature of the terrain and/or vent
to create area needed to provide linear parks, bicycle or other alternative
transportation facilities and/or achieve an urban design and special street program such as traffic
calming programs,pedestrian oriented streetscapes bike or alternative transportation paths,and/or
other coordinated programs as proposed; or in response to a specific plan or planned development
district. In addition, the determination of the Planning Commission and/or City Council shall
conclude that there are no significant impacts to health, safety,and welfare of the residents of Palm
Springs.
The new General Plan Policy 7.1.5.a. "Mesquite Avenue Special Street Program"would read as
follows:
"Mesquite Avenue Special Street Program - Mesquite Avenue between El Cielo Road and Vella
Road shall be designated a special collector street with a right-of-way width of 88 feet and a
pavement width of up to 60 feet with two travel lanes, one in each direction, a frontage road, and
a narking lane.A 12-foot wide landscaped median shall separate the through traffic lanes from the
new frontage road on the south side of Mesquite Avenue abutting Demuth Park. Various traffic
calming measures such as curb "pop-outs". "chokers", and channelization shall be implemented
in order to reduce traffic speed and discourage through traffic while creating a more pedestrian
friendly street character."
Traffic calming features will be implemented to encourage low-speed,thus deterring through travel.
Commuters that use Mesquite Avenue for through travel will seek other paths of travel that are
designed to accommodate these movements more efficiently. Traffic calming strategies are as
follows: provision of a raised median with curb cuts for access to Demuth Park and at intersections,
provide on-street parking on Frontage Road—south side of Mesquite Avenue, and provide onlytwo
12-foot wide travel lanes along this section of Mesquite Avenue. Design features will be as follows:
channelization, curb "pop-outs", raised crosswalks, and "chokers" that narrow the roadway and
discourage through traffic on Mesquite Avenue.
The proposed project will have the result of reducing the volume and speed of traffic traveling on
Mesquite Avenue between Mountain View Drive and Vella Road. The reduction in volume and
speed of traffic will enhance safety along Mesquite Avenue for the residents and pedestrians. The
project will visually enhance the established community through the installation of new landscaping
improvements, as well as decorative street improvements used for traffic calming purposes. The
introduction of 132 striped, parallel parking spaces will create a buffer between Demuth Park and
the single-family residences to the north thus creating a better relationship between the street,
park, and single-family residences.
Proposed traffic calming, raised crosswalks, and installation of an All-Way Stop controlled
intersection at Mesquite Avenue and Mountain View Drive and at Mesquite Avenue and Nueva
Vista Drive is expected to have a beneficial impact on pedestrian safety. Additionally, Mesquite
Avenue and Vella road intersections will be designed and signed to direct traffic bound for the
Airport and Ramon Road to turn right and avoid the residential/park area.
/,Cz � 3
The City also intends to implement Line 22 and a portion of Line 21 of the Master Drainage Plan
forthe Palm Springs Area,dated November 1982, prepared by Riverside County Flood Control and
Water Conservation District. Storm drain improvements include new catch basins, storm drain
laterals to collect and convey stormwater runoff from various intersecting streets along Mesquite
Avenue, through a 66" diameter storm drain that will convey runoff south to the Tahquitz Creek
through an outlet structure to be located within the existing Palm Springs municipal golf course,
immediately upstream from the Gene Autry Trail bridge across the Tahquitz Creek.
(C) 5.0977 - WESSMAN DEVELOPMENT
The proposed project is to amend the General Plan - Circulation Element Map in order to
remove Cahuilla Road's designation as a collector between Ramon Road on the south and
Tahquitz Canyon Way on the north. A collector road allows for a two lane roadway within a
sixty (60)foot right-of-way. This change of street classification will result in Cahuilla Road
becoming a local street with a fifty (50) foot right-of-way width and still characterized as a two
lane roadway. Both a collector and a local roadway provide for a two travel lane roadway. No
roadway closure is proposed.
The existing right-of-way improvements on Cahuilla Road vary on a property by property basis
south of Tahquitz Canyon Way to Baristo Road. There are a variety of parking designs
including bay parking for both single-family and multi-family residences. A variety of sidewalk
widths occur and in some areas there are no sidewalks. Cahuilla Road also exhibits a variety of
existing right-of-way widths. An eight foot vacation on both sides of Cahuilla Road occurred
prior to incorporation of this area. Therefore, Cahuilla Road south from Tahquitz Canyon Way
to Baristo Road has an existing right-of-way of fifty(50) feet even thought the General Plan
indicates a sixty(60) foot right-of-way width is required. Additionally, Cahuilla Road, south of
Baristo Road to Ramon Road has a sixty-six (66) foot right-of-way platted that changes to a
reduced half-street width on the west side of Cahuilla Road from Monte Vista Road south to
Ramon Road.
The City street standards for both collector and local roadways are attached as Exhibits A and
B. A typical half-street design for a collector roadway would include the following cross section:
(a) an eight (8)foot sidewalk separated from the roadway by curb and gutter, (b) an eight (8)
foot parking lane and (c) a twelve (12) foot travel lane. A typical half-street design for a local
roadway includes (a) a five (5) to seven (7) foot sidewalk separated from the street by curb and
gutter, (b) an eight (8)foot parking lane and (c) a ten (10) foot travel lane. Thus, the right-of--
way narrows from the collector roadway status of sixty(60)feet total right-of-way width to local
roadway status of fifty- (50)feet total right-of-way width.
An associated proposed project by John Wessman located at 284 S. Cahuilla Road, on the
west side of Cahuilla Road, includes an alternative residential street section on Cahuilla Road
that includes the narrowed right-of-way, decorative walkways and modified curb and gutter.
Discussion at the November 26, 2003, Planning Commission Public Hearing regarding the
proposed General Plan Amendment included concerns from the Planning Commission that the
roadway is the alternate north/south through-way route west of South Palm Canyon Drive
except for Belardo Road. Discussion with the City Engineer included the proposed speed
cushions installation for traffic calming purposes on the same roadway and the impact that both
the narrowed right-of-way and the traffic calming would have to traffic movement. The City
Engineer responded to those concerns that the intent of both the General Plan Amendment and
C CO2 A�
the speed cushion traffic calming was to reduce traffic speeds to the State mandated speed
limit of 25 miles per hour in a residential zone. A neighborhood representative living adjacent to
the section of street defined in the proposed General Plan Amendment spoke in support of the
Amendment and the traffic calming measures. A letter of support was also received by City
staff from the Historic Tennis Club Neighborhood Organization and is included an attachment.
ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT
Pursuant to Section 21000 et seq. of the Public Resources Code and Section 15063 of the
California Environmental Quality Act Guidelines, Mitigated Negative Declarations were prepared
for Case Nos. 5.0956, 5.0965, and 5.0977. Please refer to the associated project staff reports
for copies of the environmental documents.
The Environmental Assessment for each General Plan Amendment was prepared in
conjunction with the related actions which are on tonight's City Council agenda. Those
Environmental Assessments are hereby incorporated by reference into this staff report and are
available for public review at the offices of the Department of Planning and Zoning.
NOTIFICATION
All property owners within four hundred (400) feet of the subject properties have been notified
by mail. In addition, the EAs for Case Nos. 5.0956, 5.0965, and 5.0977 were sent to federal,
state, and local agencies and interested parties. As of the writing of this report, staff has
received comment from private citizens, the Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians, and other
agencies. Any correspondence and response to comments are attached to the report for the
cases related to each proposed General Plan Amendment.
Director dt Planning and Zoning
City Manager
ATTACHMENTS
1. Vicinity Maps
2. Correspondence
3. Local, Collector, and Secondary Street Standards
4. Planning Commission minutes for November 12, 2003
5. Planning Commission minutes for November 26, 2003
6. Planning Commission minutes for December 10, 2003 (to be included)
7. Resolution
NOTICE OF CITY COUNCIL MEETING
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
General Plan Circulation Element Amendments
A) Case No. 5.0956 GPA, City of Palm Springs
Mesquite Avenue between South Palm Canyon Drive and Random Road
B) Case No. 5.0965 GPA, City of Palm Springs
Mesquite Avenue between El Cielo Road and Vella Road
C) Case 5.0977 GPA, City of Palm Springs
Cahuilla Road between Tahquitz Canyon Way and Ramon Road
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of the City of Palm Springs, California, will hold a public hearing at its
meeting of December 17, 2003.The City Council public hearing meeting begins at 7:00 p.m. in the City Council Chamber
at City Hall, 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way, Palm Springs, California.
The purpose of the hearing is to consider:
A) Case 5,0956 GPA, a request by Huddle Springs Development, LLC for an amendment to the General Plan Circulation
Map to reclassify Mesquite Avenue between South Palm Canyon Drive and Random Road from a secondary thoroughfare
to a collector street. The collector street will match existing street improvements on Mesquite Avenue with a right-of-way
width of 60 feet and a street width of 40 feet with 2 travel lanes; and
B) Case 5.0965 GPA,a request initiated by the City of Palm Springs for an amendment to the General Plan Circulation Map
to reclassify Mesquite Avenue between El Cielo Road and Vella Road from a secondary thoroughfare to a special collector
street,to clarify General Plan Policy 7.1.5.with regards to"special street program", and to add a new General Plan Policy
7.1.5.a. "Mesquite Avenue Special Street Program". The special collector street will allow the existing right-of-way width of
88 feet to be maintained and will consist of an up to 60 foot wide street width with two travel lanes,a 12 foot wide landscaped
median, and a frontage road abutting Demuth Park on the south side of Mesquite Avenue; and
C)Case 5.0977 GPA,a request by Wessman Development Company for an amendment to the General Plan Circulation Map
to reclassify Cahuilla Road between Tahquitz Canyon Way and Ramon Road from a collector street to a local street. The
local street will consist of a right-of-way width of 45 feet and a street width of 36 feet with two travel lanes,each 18 feet wide.
This street section will only apply where Cahuilla Road abuts the proposed development.
Pursuant to Section 21000 et seq.of the Public Resources Code and Section 15063 of the California Environmental Quality
Act, Mitigated Negative Declarations have been prepared for Case Nos. 5.0956 GPA, 5.0965 GPA, and 5.0977 GPA and
will be reviewed by the City Council at the meeting. Members of the public may view the documents in the Department of
Planning and Zoning,City Hall,3200 E.Tahquitz Canyon Way,Palm Springs,and submit written comments to the City Clerk
at or prior to the City Council hearing.
The proposed General Plan Amendment information and related documents are also available for public review Monday to
Friday, between 8 a.m.and 5 p.m.atthe City of Palm Springs Planning and Zoning Department, located at 3200 E.Tahquitz
Canyon Way.
If any individual or group challengesthe action in court, issues raised may be limited to only those issues raised atthe public
hearings described in this notice or in written correspondence at or prior to the City Council meeting.An opportunity will be
given at said hearings for all interested persons to be heard.
Questions regarding Case Nos.5.0956 and 5.0965 may be directed to Jing Yeo, Principal Planner and questions regarding
Case No. 5.0977 may be directed to Kathy Marx,Associate Planner, Department of Planning &Zoning, (760) 323-8245.
PATRICIA A. SANDERS
Publish: November 27, 2003 City Clerk
The Desert Sun
VICINITY MAP N�
W E
S
z
o RAMON ROAD
O '
U j
� zn
0
a , 0
a z
w CAMINO PARCELA
mFF
5 -7�
N O SUNNY DUNES ROAD
Q t,;�H SOUTH RIVERSIDE DRIVE
SAN LORENZO ROAD
MESQUITE AVENUE
PALO VERDE AVENUE
0
. OCOTILLO AVENUE
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
CASE NO.: 5.0956 DESCRIPTION:
General Plan Circulation Map Amendment to reclassify Mesquite
APPLICANT: Huddle Springs Development, LLC Ave between S. Palm Cyn Dr and Random Rd from a secondary
thoroughfare to a collector street and PD-285&TTM 31413 for48
condos, 18 live/work lofts, 25759 sf of retail, 9786 sf of office&
8000 sf restaurant at NE corner of S. Palm Cyn Dr & Mesquite
VICINITY MAP N
w E
. Mid.Valle �m
Rai ey '-q5
Ramon Road
S
a '
o a
Sunny Dates Road
m �
9
xr ti
t
`♦ r rz�t?`Yf_W
' i- ? Mesquite AVOM
vvv�+++z3;' wl�pemalh Pads .
' jL(q!�'r �✓j21
CITY, OF PALM SPRINGS !a
CASE NO.: 5.0966 GPA DESCRIPTION:
General Plan Amendment to reclassify Mesquite Ave.between EI
APPLICANT: City of Palm Springs Cielo Rd. and Vella Rd.from a secondary to a,special collector,
Garification of Policy 7.1.5; Various traffic calming measures,
landscape&storm drain improvements;implementation of Line 22
of the Master Drainage Plan for the Palm Springs area.
VICINITY MAP
W E
S
ODONNELL
GOLF CLUB
TAHQUITZ CANYON WAY
SI E
ARENAS RD.
o=
d o
0 0 0 0
o o 0
z o
a w c�� g
¢ w
BARRISTO RD.
RAMON RD.
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS /0;2
CASE NO.: 5.0977 PD — 288 PESCRIPTION:
A planned development and tentative map .
TTM 31887 proposal to build 12 tri-plex and one duplex condominium units on
6MLICANT: 2.7 acres and to amend.the General Plan Circulation Plan to remove
John Wessingln Cahuilla Road's designation as a collector street from Ramon Road
to Tahquitz Canyon Way.
i !
is
565 W. Santa Rosa Drive
Palm Springs, CA
9 2 2 6 7
Marshall Routh,Designer Post Office B o x 9 2 5 7
Palm Springs , CA
9 2 2 6 3
Telephone: 760.272.0284
ro a l h d es ign0 a arthll nk.net
November 24, 2003
RECEIVED
Phil Matchko, Chair
Palm Springs Planning Commission NOV 2 4 2003
c/o Palm Springs Planning Department Planning & Zoning
3200 Tahquitz Canyon Way
Palm Springs, CA 92262 5,C)q J1
Re: 5A. Case 5.0977 PD 288 TTM 31887 Application by John
Wessman for an amendment to the General Plan Circulation Plan to
remove Cahuilla Road's designation as a collector roadway between
Ramon Road on the south and Tahquitz Canyon Way on the north, Zones
R-2 & R-3, Section 15
The Board of the Historic Tennis Club Neighborhood Organization voted
to support this action at its most recent meeting. Cahuilla street is the
gateway to the historic homes and inns and because of its residential
nature should not be a collector roadway:
Furthermore, the population growth projections used by the current
general plan of 4%D annually did not materialize in Palm Springs. We
have only seen 1%g annual compound growth rate for the last ten years.
Traffic statistics based on 4% growth would also be affected
proportionally.
Sincerely,
Marshall Roath
President HTCNO
CC:
Dianne Marantz
Tracy Conrad
Jon Caffery Vice Chair
Mark Matthews
Jon Shoenberger A
Doug Evans
HTCNO Board
- - - - -C� RECEIVED
R 92 C°z9���ir�u¢oCR,� JR�� Gz NOV 1 2 2003 1
volt
fZ 7L ,2 twit
T� ��Z in L GG�7G f1✓ ��� f' Gf�2�/� J
iuw Juan i c
Page I of 1
Jing Yeo
From: Herbert Kouba [UConsign@worldnet.att.net]
Sent: Wednesday, November 05, 2003 10:27 AM
To: jing yeo
Subject: Mesquite Avenue
Dear Jing Yea:I realize that we are probably too late to make a comment since the planning meeting is today but,I just wanted to say that
we hope the proposal to change Mesquite Avenue to a collector street is approved.We desperately need assistance with traffic issues and
I'm sure this will be a beginning.To the best of my knowledge no homeowners have objected to the Huddle Springs Project. This is not
because we are apathetic but rather it will enhance the neighborhood and the developer and architect at the last meeting were concerned
with the traffic on Mesquite and did not want it to become a thoroughfare for non essential traffic.This is something that we all
appreciated and wish them the best.This is why there hasn't been negative feedback.
Thank you.
Respectfully,
Steven Kelley/H.Paul Kouba
231 East Mesquite Avenue
NOV - 5 2003
J W112001
Jing Ye_o
Froon: Jono Hildner Dono@hildner.comj
Sent: Monday, October 20, 2003 2:34 PM
To: douge@ci.palm-springs.ca.us
Cc: james@jamescioffiarchitect.com;jingy@ci.palm-springs.ca.us; daveb@ci.palm-springs.ca.us;
georgedunn@earthlink.net; KturnerSF@aol.com; April@hildner.com
Subject: Huddle Springs
Doug,
First, I want to thank you for organizing and conducting the meeting to
allow
the community to review, question and comment on the Huddle Springs
project.
Second, let me say that I was very impressed with the way the meeting
was
handled by you. I've had a lot of experience conducting neighborhood
meetings
to site housing that was generally not favored, such as for the mentally
retarded, recovering alcoholics and community corrections clients.
Dealing
with NIMBY is no fun and you handled this as well as I've seen.
I speak only for myself in the following thoughts/comments, but I'm sure
that--
many of them are shared by a number of my neighbors,
1. The Huddle Springs proposal is as low neighborhood impact as any
I can
think of for the property given the zoning. Mr. Cioffi and the
developer have
obviously given this lots of thought and the sensitivity with which it
has
been approached are outstanding in my experience. This project should
be
supported by the City.
2. The vast number of comments made at the meeting seemed to
challenge aspects
of the proposal, most dealing with traffic impacts. This is as it
should be,
but don't let the concerns of the specifics keep you from considering
the
quality of the whole. Mr. Cioffi seemed occasionally defensive, but
that
probably comes from years of having been beaten up badly on such
occasions.
3. The concerns of the woman who owns the house directly across
from the
access to the property on Mesquite are real, valid and deeply felt. She
and
her husband may not have fully understood the potential impact of buying
where
they did, but mitigation of the impact on their property will be
essential to
having the neighbors welcome this development. Building them a front
wall and
moving the ingress/egress slightly to the West both have merit.
4. In conjunction with the approval of this development, pleas
amend the City yy
�13
General Plan to eliminate the idea of making Mesquite four lanes �lojn � OCT 2 O 2003 i
Palm
Canyon to Random. The developer can spend that money better and I can't
i
think
of one neighbor that wants those four lanes.
1 _
3D9 6
5. You asked about access onto Random. Given the nature of the
traffic that
would go onto Random from a limited number of condos in a gated area, I
can' t
see why that would be a problem. You may want to do something that
moves them
from that access to Mesquite rather than Riverside and San Lorenzo, but
I
don' t see a big impact.
6. It seems like the beauty of this proposal will hinge on leasing,
or selling
the restaurant to someone with deep pockets willing to make a long-term
commitment to the vision. Project approval should probably be made
contingent
to that commitment.
7. I love the consideration given to pedestrian and bicycle
traffic. Keep it
in the plan.
8. Traffic calming. The biggie. As you are aware, most everyone
in the
neighborhood is concerned with both the volume and speed of traffic on a
number of the streets already. Folks are using all sorts of shortcuts
to get
from Sunrise to Palm Canyon without taking the streets designated for
that
traffic. This project has the potential to make the problems MUCH worse
and
the potential to make them MUCH better.
. The developer is not responsible for spending his money to correct an
existing
problem, but does have the responsibility to assure that it doesn't get
a lot
worse. I'm convinced that the City has the expertise to work with the
developer and the neighborhood to develop and implement a solution.
From my
perspective, this will require effort and MONEY from all the parties.
I am a fairly new resident here, having lived in Oregon for the past 35
years,
but up there, we have a process that allows property owners to vote to
assess
themselves for a local improvement district (LID) for the cost of public
improvements that benefit their property. Streetlights are the most
common
use, but we don' t want those. It just requires developing a formula,
usually
street frontage and other impacts and then seeing if neighbors want to
put
their money where their mouths are. This is not to say that the City,
in
conjunction with the developer has significant responsibility, just that
we're
all in this together.
As was noted at the meeting, solving a problem in one area frequently
creates
problems in others. It seems like there are two access points off of
South
Palm Canyon and four or more off of Sunrise. We'll have to consider all
of
those.
In closing, let me just say thank you to you, your staff, Mr. Ciof
' n
developerimpressive da
'I I
the PP proposal e that TI lve seen and I hope we rove i ress for the t_ , - -- -- - --
be of OCT 2 O ����
some help in moving it to reality without inordinate delay. I•' (�"'
i
i
Jono Hildner
Consultant
241 E. Mesquite Ave.
Palrn Springs, CA 92264
OCT 2 0 2003
Z
0
m
0 R/W
R/W
Z Z o 50'
O D 5' 40'
5'
((� 20, 20' m
70
JJJJ D -u 2% 0
m z m r z
\ Z
m cn D Z \
0 co
O '
Z SIDEWALK - SEE C.P.S.
STD. DWG. 210 ITYP.1
CURB d GUTTER
_ n D SEE C.P.S. STD. DWG.
O j -0 NO. 200 �TYP,)
m 77
o mC z O
< " 0 m
z
m
m NOTES:
m 3 0
A I. SEE C:P.S. STD. DWG. N0. IIO FOR MINIMUM PAVEMENT STRUCTURAL SECTION.
� = D
Y
2, TWO 12' TRAVEL LANES; TWO 8' PARKING LANES OR AS APPROVED BY THE CITY ENGINEER
3. USE ON EXISTING GO' WIDE R/W STREETS NOT DESIGNATED AS COLLECTOR STREET ON GENERAL PLAN.
_ z4. TO BE USED ONLY WHEN JOINING EXISTING IMPROVEMENTS JOINING EXISTING IMPROVEMENTS.
> o
O
cn y
9 m
!Y a z A W
D O CA
o !^ r
fn
Z
0
0
m
u
n > R/W
R/W 60,
m n
40'
O D 10,0 20' VARIES
S
<
PER ZONE
t!,
C {n 2% O
W -0 �
(� Z
70
SIDEWALK - SEE C.P.S.
STD. DWG. 210 (TYP.I
CURB 9 GUTTER
_ A . D SEE C.P.S. STANDARD
z f _0 A_� Wp DWG. NO. 200 ITYP.)
m Z �4
m m \\ CC
m { Z
{ 0
z NOTES;
rn
rn
I. SEE C.P.S. STD. DWG. IN - 110 FOR
A D
MINIMUM PAVEMENT STRUCTURAL SECTION.
4 �
PARKING LANES
' PARK . A
2. TWO 12' TRAVEL' LANES; TWO 8 O
OR AS APPROVED BY THE CITY ENGINEER. <
E o
c> .
.z z o
o a
o
N �
L4 D
A f1 m
W
_J
Z
O
co
0
(n O
m m
O A R/W
Z m R/W
v 80,
Zo
D �n 64' e'
s'
O 32, 32' m
70 co
O D -0 2%
o
S D
D O
m Z SIDEWALK - SEE C.P.S.
m STD. DWG. 210 {TYPJ
CURB a GUTTER
= A n D SEE C.P.S. STANDARD
m > -I -0
x
j DWG. N0. 200 )TYP.)
m z
Z NOTESt
m
m 3 0F< I. SEE STANDARD DWG. FOR
in _ MINIMUM PAVEMENT STRUCTURAL
URAL SECTION. ➢
-o
v
v 2. FOUR - 12' TRAVEL LANES- TWO 8' PARKING LANES, z
OR AS APPROVED BY THE CITY ENGINEER.
m
z a o
O1 r m m
O
i D
ca a
N z A m
coo
D n W
p� a
N
AFFIDAVIT
OF
MAILING NOTICES
I, the undersigned City Clerk of the City of Palm Springs, California,do hereby
certify that a copy of the Notice of Public Hearing before the City Council of
the City of Palm Springs, in conjunction with General Plan Circulation
Element Amendments, A) Case No 5.0956 GPA Mesquite Avenue between
South Palm Canyon Drive and Random Road, applicant, Huddle Springs
Development, LLC; B) Case No. 5.0965 GPA Mesquite Avenue between El
Cielo Road and Vella Road, applicant, City of Palm Springs to amend
General Plan Circulation Map; and C) Case No. 5.0977 GPA Cahuilla Road
between Tahquitz Canyon Way and Ramon Road, applicant, Wessman
Development Compan was mailed to each and every person on the
attached list on the 26 day of November, 2003. A copy of said Notice is
attached hereto. Said mailing was completed by placing a copy of said
Notice in a sealed envelope, with postage prepaid, and depositing same in
the U.S. Mail at Palm Springs, California.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Dated at Palm Springs California, this 26�h day of November, 2003.
C: 4
PATRICIA A. SANDERS
City Clerk
NOTICE OF CITY COUNCIL MEETING
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
General Plan Circulation Element Amendments
A) Case No. 5.0956 GPA, City of Palm Springs
Mesquite Avenue between South Palm Canyon Drive and Random Road
B) Case No. 5.0965 GPA, City of Palm Springs
Mesquite Avenue between El Cielo Road and Vella Road
C) Case 5.0977 GPA, City of Palm Springs
Cahuilla Road between Tahquitz Canyon Way and Ramon Road
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of the City of Palm Springs, California, will hold a public hearing at its
meeting of December 17, 2003. The City Council public hearing meeting begins at 7:00 p.m. in the City Council Chamber
at City Hall, 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way, Palm Springs, California.
The purpose of the hearing is to consider:
A) Case 5.0956 GPA, a request by Huddle Springs Development, LLC for an amendment to the General Plan Circulation
Map to reclassify Mesquite Avenue between South Palm Canyon Drive and Random Road from a secondary thoroughfare
to a collector street. The collector street will match existing street improvements on Mesquite Avenue with a right-of-way
width of 60 feet and a street width of 40 feet with 2 travel lanes; and
B) Case 5.0965 GPA,a request initiated by the City of Palm Springs for an amendment to the General Plan Circulation Map
to reclassify Mesquite Avenue between El Cielo Road and Vella Road from a secondary thoroughfare to a special collector
street,to clarify General Plan Policy 7.1.5. with regards to"special street program", and to add a new General Plan Policy
7.1.5.a. "Mesquite Avenue Special Street Program".The special collector street will allow the existing right-of-way width of
88 feet to be maintained and will consist of an up to 60 foot wide street width with two travel lanes,a 12 foot wide landscaped
median, and a frontage road abutting Demuth Park on the south side of Mesquite Avenue; and
C)Case 5.0977 GPA,a request by Wessman Development Company for an amendment to the General Plan Circulation Map
to reclassify Cahuilla Road between Tahqultz Canyon Way and Ramon Road from a collector street to a local street. The
local street will consist of a right-of-way width of 45 feet and a street width of 36 feet with two travel lanes,each 18 feet wide.
This street section will only apply where Cahuilla Road abuts the proposed development.
Pursuant to Section 21000 et seq.of the Public Resources Code and Section 15063 of the California Environmental Quality
Act, Mitigated Negative Declarations have been prepared for Case Nos. 5.0956 GPA, 5.0965 GPA, and 5.0977 GPA and
will be reviewed by the City Council at the meeting. Members of the public may view the documents in the Department of
Planning and Zoning,City Hall,3200 E.Tahquitz Canyon Way,Palm Springs,and submit written comments to the City Clerk
at or prior to the City Council hearing.
The proposed General Plan Amendment information and related documents are also available for public review Monday to
Friday,between 8 a.m.and 5 p.m.at the City of Palm Springs Planning and Zoning Department, located at 3200 E.Tahquitz
Canyon Way.
If any individual or group challenges the action in court,Issues raised may be limited to only those issues raised at the public
hearings described in this notice or in written correspondence at or prior to the City Council meeting.An opportunity will be
given at said hearings for all interested persons to be heard.
Questions regarding Case Nos.5.0956 and 5.0965 may be directed to Jing Yeo, Principal Planner and questions regarding
Case No. 5.0977 may be directed to Kathy Marx, Associate Planner, Department of Planning &Zoning, (760) 323-8245.
PATRICIA A. SANDERS
Publish: November 27, 2003 City Clerk
The Desert Sun
VICINITY MAP4.
IV F
z
o RAMON ROAD
a z t�
O U >
0� Z M
O Q
0 0
W Z_
W CAMINO PARCEIA
m
x
5
�O SUNNY DUNES ROAD
52)
. z
cc ' , SOUTH RIVERSIDE DRIVE
SAN LORENZO ROAD
.,. d''. _
MESQUITE AVENUE
PALO VERDE AVENUE .
0
N OCOTILLO AVENUE
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
CASE NO.: 5.0956 DESCRIPTION:
General Plan Circulation Map Amendment to reclassify Mesquite
APPLICANT: Huddle Springs Development, LLC Ave between S. Palm Cyn Dr and Random Rd from a secondary
thoroughfare to a collector street and PD-285&TTM 31413 for48
condos, 18 live/work lofts, 25759 sf of retail, 9786 sf of office&
8000 sf restaurant at NE corner of S. Palm Cyn Dr& Mesquite
VICINITY MAP
Midt'Ma
ey
Flamm Rwd
Surry hum Road
F
9 "
MoutWte AVonue
r3�H�`5f,1
glA,
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
CASE NO.: 5,0965 GPA DESCRIPTION:
General Plan Amendment to reclassify Mesquite Ave.between El
APPLICANT: City of Palm Springs Cielo Rd. and Vella Rd. from a secondary to a speclal collector,Clarification of Policy 7.1.5; Various traffic calming measures,
landscape&storm drain Improvements;Implementation ofLine22
of the Master Drainage Plan for the Palm Springs area.
VI GINI TY ,IV}AP N
Wr F
S
f Iz 4
jr T"ARISK
rC 44
co
I ,
c ro ICI{ CIz C IS M8 q�MA 4 MA ��� 1 M4 N Me ^
.rn ( I oil r o.lY ® y �o N ?H I w, _ Is
M
w o mtl j` F y 4!/io -T 4s/3o k 4s%3o i 4 ►o Is
c ee
j f I i p 6 C RC 4ly3o N I N1r3/Sa AlMI
In Rc I 43110 I H4s/3o Ai
U I a i RC 34 r1
_m 1 P ° G a r AG
f1. J TAIfgWT _
p } �1 I C'` RG RC;
^RC I .Rr" ._RC_ MCC,
12 44Jf30 I 4k3p 1 Alt jO 1143130 N4.il3o
RO
e o b GwfsN/so� !liNso tw Is� fe�� 4s w M,
i
30M NdP !W LV
C. p I s: .I c 6hTkMN! v
2 v . 6 0 ` 040o I N43/3o H4a/so I
01 a o 4JVU w
o E x I/ I H41/!10 15 Hsi/!fims,
�a !S Alec
CeP P rl N!S M MI y 4' MrS 1
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
CASE NO.; 5,0977 GPA DESC IHION;
---�-- General Plan Amendment to remove
APPLICAN :Cahuilla Road's designatiori as a collector roadway from Tahquitz
_.): John Wessman Canyon Way on the north to Ramon Road on the south. The
change in classification will result in Cahuilla Road becoming a
two-lane local street with a fifty foot right-of-way.
1� 1
Seq/77 /Ur�a�a�✓
The Collaborative West
Attention: Faye
100 Avenida Miramar
San Clemente, CA 92672
Hunsaker&Associates
Attn: Ben
Three Hughes
Irvine, CA 92618-1010
Scheurer Architects
Attention: Steve
20411 SW Birch Street, Suite 300
Newport Beach, CA 92660
John Wessman
300 S. Palm Canyon Drive
Palm Springs, CA 92262
27-1'9L
513 120 056 513 132 003 513 132 004
Palm Springs Modern Homes V Pilger Assoc Inc G Douglas Smith
74140 El Pasco#4 221 S Patencio Rd 231 S Patencio Rd
Palm Desert, CA 92260 Palm Springs,CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92262
l
513 132 005 513 132 006 513 '3Z 097
G D Smith Patencio Estates Lie Patencio states
257 S Patencio Rd 28640 Landau Blvd#1 28640 L u Blvd#1
Palm Springs,CA 92262 Cathedral City, CA 92234 Cath ty,CA 92234
513 132 017 513 133 001 513 133 002
Roger Malone&Eugene Milligan 487 Arenas Llc Emil&Joan Forrer
529 W Arenas Rd 830 Cherrystone Dr PO Box 198
Palm Springs,CA 92262 Los Gatos,CA 95032 Tahoe Vista, CA 96148
513 133 004 513 133,0OS 513 133 006
Mena G Douglas th G Douglas Smith
231 S Lugo Rd 257 S Paten Rd 265 S Lugo Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92262 Palm Sprin s, CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92262
513 133 08 513 133 012 513 133 013
Thomas L sso G D Smith Gary&Mary Nold
295 S Lugo 2201 S Palm Canyon Dr 4117 234 S Patencio Rd
Palm Springs, 92262 \ Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92262
513 133 014 513 1 513 134 001
Larry Pitcher&G E Fine Charles III&Leonard Grotty Wahoo-cal Rentals Lie
120 Hill St 275 S Lugo 4109 NE 19th Ave#B
Avalon, CA 90704 Palm Sprin 92262 Portland,OR 97211
513 134 002 513 134 003 513 134 004
Bushman F X&E G Tippin Donald&Deborah Garsh
5515 Inner Circle Dr PO Box 8171 PO Box K
Riverside, CA 92506 Tahoe City, CA 96145 Chula Vista,CA 91912
513 134 005 513 134 006 513 134 007
Frances Nadoldski&Dianne Sluzas Lee Toman&Jan Cronquist Rossi Eugene P&Adriana&Rossi
411 W Arenas Rd#5 989 Lombard Ave 3215 E Ocean Blvd
Palm Springs,CA 92262 Saint Paul,MN 55105 Long Beach,CA 90803
513 134 008 513 134 009 513 134 010
Neil Graham Diane Colgan Robert Meissner
20982 Brookhurst St#201 111 Moss Rock Ct PO Box 791
Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Folsom, CA 95630 Big Bear Lake, CA 92315
513 4 01 513 136 001 513 136 002
Kalsm Associates Don Kuzma&Dale Burr Adair Holdings Inc
47 N Pas aredo 6507 NE loth Ave 2533 N Carson St#A-231
Cathedr CMV
92234 Vancouver,WA 98665 Carson City,NV 89706
c)77� -
513 136 003 513 136 004 513 136 005
Ted Harvey Marni Scott&Maureen Doherty Laabs Gary A&Current Resident
480 W Baristo Rd 1905 Plainfield Rd#C 2780 Alum Rock Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92262 Darien,IL 60561 San Jose, CA 95127
513 136 006 513 136 007 513 136 008
Robert Gemmell&Gerald King Dean Corella Stephen&Mary Donahue
PO Box 9 488 W Baristo Rd 44 Killian Way
San Bernardino, CA 92402 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Rancho Mirage, CA 92270
513 136 009 513 1 Ol1 513 141012
Silver Palm Villas Wahoo lc Palm Spn s Modem Homes V
48550 Madison St 4109 NE 19 Ave#B 74140 El P #4
Indio, CA 92201 Portland, O 211 Palm Desert 92260
513 141015 513 141 016 513 142 001
Casa Cody B&B Con Inn Llc Casa Cody B& Country Inn Mountain Resort Palm
175 S Cahuilla Rd 175 S Cahuilla 11855 Sorrento Valley Rd#C
Palm Springs, CA 92262 Palm Springs, C 9 62 San Diego, CA 92121
513 142 003 513 151002 513 151006
Craig Blau Larry&Sharon Kramer William Davis&Trisha Davis
200 W Arenas Rd 1909 El Camino Real 227 S Cahuilla Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92262 Redwood City,CA 94063 Palm Springs, CA 92262
513 151007 513 151009 513 151010
Virginia Berardini Community Church Of Palm Springs Danny Creager
237 S Cahuilla Rd PO Box 1898 1428 Tularcitos Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92262 Cathedral City, CA 92235 Milpitas,CA 95035
513 151013 513 151014 513 151015
Joann Mcclure William&Sharon Simon Coleman Dennis Devermom&Devenrront Marg
1134 Clermont Dr 251 S Lucerne Blvd 19528 Celtic St
South Bend,IN 46617 Los Angeles, CA 90004 Northridge, CA 91326
513 1 Ol 513 151017 513 15 OI
Steven ck Louis Miller&Matthew Miller Comm Church Of Palm Springs
307 W e d 1155 Tiffany Cir N PO Box 18
Palm rings, A 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Cathedral , CA 92235
513 151 019 513 151 020 513 152 002
Community Ch c Of Palm Springs Emil&Joan Forrer Marin&G Ursescu
Po Box 1898 375 W Arenas Rd Current Resident
Cathedral City, C 235 Palm Springs, CA 92262 239 W Arenas Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92262
513 152 006 513 152 O10 513 152011
Community Ch 1 Of Palm Springs Karen Prince-wiethorn Belardo Court Associates
PO Box 1898 261 S Belazdo Rd 600 Queen Anne Ave N
Cathedral City, CA 235 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Seattle,WA 98109
67 d? 77 - �3
513152014 513 152 01
51315 019
Karen Prince-wi o Karen Prince- ' thorn Karen -wiethom
261 S Belardo Rd 261 S Belardo 261 S Bel o Rd
Palm Springs, CA 9 62 Palm Springs, C 92262 Palm,Sprin , CA 92262
513 152 020 313 153 001 513 153 015
Douglas Mannoff&Donna Mannoff Curt Taucher&Jacqueline Taucher Cont Redeve m nt Agency City Palm
200 S Cahuilla Rd 5335 E Broadway PO Box 1786
Palm Springs, CA 92262 Long Beach, CA 90803 Palm Springs, C 92263
513 153 016 513 53 17 513 153 024
Redevelop nt gency City Of Palm S City P Springs First Church Of Christ Scientist
PO Box 1786 PO Bex 743 605 S Riverside Dr
Palm Springs, 92263 Palm Sp gs, CA 92263 Palm Springs, CA 92264
513 153 029 513 153 034 513 182 0 1
Redevelopment Agency City Of Palm S Larry Kanner Vineyard Prop Artie Stev o &Ethel Severson
PO Box 2743 S K Vine Prop 730 Santiag ve
Palm Springs, CA 92263 1909 El Camino Real Long Beach 90804
Redwood City, CA 94063
513 182 004 513 2 005 513 182 006
Leo&Aylaian Lauri Fuller Will
illian An Pfisterer Enrico Margarite D&Tommy B
377 W Baristo Rd 332AP &r Enrico
Palm Springs, CA 92262 Pals, CA 92262 340 Pablo Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92262
513 182 007 513 182 008 513 182 009
David&Janice Kaminsky Guy Gorelik Madeleine Dejean
342 Pablo Dr 310 S Patencio Rd PO Box 2491
Palm Springs,CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Palm Springs,CA 92263
513182014 513182015 513182016
John Wessman Ronald Kirk Virgil Heinrich&Ardis Heinrich
360 Pablo Dr 2130 Dry Creek Rd 352 Pablo Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92262 San Jose, CA 95124 Palm Springs, CA 92262
513 182 020 513 182 021 513 182 024
William&Geraldine Jarvis Christopher&Gina Tuttobene Riordan Michael G&Franklin Tr Wats
11920 100th Ave#1203 345 S Monte Vista Dr 445 W Baristo Rd
EDMONTON AB Palm Springs, CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92262
CANADA
513 182 025 513 201 001 513 201002
Artie Stevenson&Ethel Severson Holm Stephen&Nelda Chagin
730 Santiago Ave 2301 Fairview Ave E#3 303 W Baristo Rd
Long Beach,CA 90804 Seattle,WA 98102 Palm Springs, CA 92262
513 201003 513 201004 513 201005
G C Brewer E Michael Vetterli Charles Howland
116 S Larchmont Blvd 318 Pablo Dr PO Box 460069
Los Angeles, CA 90004 Palm Springs, CA 92262 San Francisco, CA 94146
6-- og77 �41
513 202 001 513 202 002 513 202 005
Palm Springs Womans Club Eric Mellum Casa Real Estate Limited Partnership
PO Box 626 9901 Paramount Blvd#250 5750 Wilshire Blvd#610
Palm Springs,CA 92263 Downey, CA 90240 Los Angeles, CA 90036
I,
513 202 009 513 2 0 0 513 203 013
La Serena Villas Llc La Sere Villas Llc Marek Lp
760 N La Cienega Blvd 760 N La ienega Blvd 72-240 Highway 1111 Waring Plz
Los Angeles, CA 90069 Los Angel s, CA 90069 Palm Desert, CA 92260
513 470 001 513 470 002 513 470 003
Johnston John Gerard Jr. Anne Abercrombie
147 S Tahquitz Dr PO Box 2458 221 S Patencio Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92262 Covina, CA 91722 Palm Springs, CA 92262
I
513 470 004 513 470 005 513 470 006
Marc Herbert&Groth Ric Vonhungen Wanda Walker&Walker Wand Carol Hohnes
2864 Tice Creek Dr#4 3512 Ross Rd PO Box 1078
Walnut Creek, CA 94595 Palo Alto, CA 94303 Belfast,ME 04915
513 470 007 513 470 008 513 4 009
John&Jean Metzger Peter Phillips Randal an Boose
600 Arbolado Dr PO Box 115 1808 Ott St
Fullerton,CA 92835 Fawnskin, CA 92333 Portl 97212
5134 010 513470013 513 7 014
Metzger h R&Jean M&Metzger F John Gerard Jr. &Maria Belem Gerard John rand Jr.
600 Arbola Dr PO Box 2458 PO Bo 458
Fullerton, C 835 Covina, CA 91722 Covi A 91722
513 501001 513 501002 513 501003
Robert Barthel&Vinetta Barthel Gordon Leake R K Miller Inv Co&Susan Lse Bennet
123 NW 4th St#520 500 W Arenas Rd#2 500 W Arenas Rd 413
Evansville,IN 47708 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92262
513 501 004 513 501005 513 501006
R K Miller Inv Co Inc Levine Joan C R K Miller Inv Co Inc
Kathleen Highsmith 213 Rio Del Mar Blvd Philip Thompson Jr.
5 Forest Glen Ln SW Aptos, CA 95003 554 I lth Ave
Lakewood,WA 98498 Salt Lake City,UT 84103
513 501007 513 501008 513 501009
R K Miller Investment Co Inc R K Miller Investment Co Inc R K Miller Inv Co Inc&Terry Hauswir
3335 Mountain Ln 1450 La Perla Ave 1943 Pariva Dr
Park City,UT 84060 Long Beach, CA 90815 Cardiff By The Sea, CA 92007
513 501010 513 501011 513 530 001
R K Miller Inv Co Inc&Canuann Bre Lot Common Bernard Baird&Carol Rake
1447 Wikiup Dr PO Box 2002 3200 Alid Ave SW 4201
Santa Rosa, CA 95403 Palm Springs, CA 92263 Seattle,WA 98116
Neighborhood Coalition List
as of October 1, 2003 MR PETER DIXON MR BILL DAVIS AND
5.0977-pd-288 431 SOUTH MONTE VISTA DRIVE MS TRISHA DAVIS
227 SOUTH CAHUILLA
John Wessman PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262
MR FRANK TYSEN MR BOB WEITHORN MR TIM HOHMEIER
C/O CASA CODY COUNTRY INN 261 SOUTH BELARDO ROAD 1387 CALLE DE MARIA
175 SOUTH CAHUILLA ROAD PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264
PALM SPRINGS CA 92264
MS CHRISTINE HAMMOND MR PHIL TEDESCO MR MARSHALL ROATH
1155 SOUTH CAMINO REAL 1303 WEST PRIMAVERA DRIVE MS SHERYL HAMLIN
PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 565 WEST SANTA ROSA DRIVE
PALM SPRINGS CA 92262
MS ROXANNE PLOSS
930 CHIA
PALM SPRINGS, CA 92262
MS MARGARET PARK
AGUA CALIENTE REPRESENTATIVE AGUA CALIENTE CAHUILLA INDIANS
650 EAST TAHQUITZ CANYON WAY
PALM SPRINGS, CA 92262
SENIOR SECRETARY
PLANNING &ZONING DEPT.
PLANNING DEPT. REP. CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
PO BOX 2743
PALM SPRINGS CA 92263
I
Z9ZZ6 VO SONIiidS WlVd Z9ZZ6 VO SJNIbdS WIVd b£0XN
J3MSO 311V1
3AIi10 V1SIA 31NOW HlnOs 4Z£ i mvinS 6966
3AIHa S3HV 11N3S30 OL£ O,IO�I i i8m0a 21W )i Vl3WVd SW
1NEIGIS32Id on io S,NVWOM S d ZLO 1 OZ£69 £00 Z84 £49
NOSNVH ON VN03 SW
I
91806 VO `goe092U01 Z9ZZ6 VO`sBURdS MPd
�$ k 1S smo0 Su'i Ft I w P21 SUuW V A16Z9
$ aosdwuS Anrj I mom J020g
££Tl$ £00 O£S fig ZOO 0£9 £T9
508 161 002 508 162 001 508 162 002
Riverside County Flood Cont Whitehead Prop&Marion Leonard Whitehead P onald Williams
1995 Market St 11 4511 E Sunny Dunes Rd#B 4511 E Sunn unes Rd#B
l Riverside, CA 92501 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Sp ' gs, C 92264
508 162 003 508 162 0 4 508 162 00
Lynn Shapiro&Jorcourt Faller Char q �n J Whitehead XPro5ahon Leonard
1666 20th St#100 PO Box 1457 U p 4511 E Sund#B
Santa Monica, CA 90404 San Francisco C 94114 Palm Sp ' 64
508 162 008 508 162 09 508 2 Ol
Valorie Hodgert Valorie Aim Ho ert&Richard Paul Steven e
412 Lemon Grove Ln 412 Lemon Gr e Ln 447 Cer os Rd
Santa Barbara, CA 9310h Santa Barbara '93108 Santa F ,N V 87501
508 1 011 508 162 01/ 508 162 013
Frank z &Kent Vandenberg Fore Partners Llc Lynn Shapiro&Jorcourt
775 E Mel e' PO Box 2108 1666 20th St#100
Palm Spring , 92262 Bremerton,WA 98310 Santa Monica, CA 90404
508 163 001 508 163 007 508 163 008
David&Geraldine Esth Lyons Denise Gilbert Cecil&Cleora Bullard
487 E Valmonte Norte 2496 E Santa Ynez Way 530 E Industrial PI
Palm Springs, CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
508 163 009 508 171 002 508 171 005
Bland George B Rudennan Martin A&Ruderman John Polos&Kathe Polos
982 Stone Canyon Rd 1157 E Riverside Dr S 777 S Palm Canyon Dr
Los Angeles, CA 90077 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
508 171 006 508 1 00 508 171 008
Jaynes Jackson&Aline Jackson Riversid catty Flood Cont John Polos Kathe Polos
601 Amanas Rd#W 1995 Marke t 777 S anyon Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92262 Riverside, 501 Palm Sprir , CA 92264
508 I 1 00 508 172 508 172 007
Riversi unty Flood Cont Francisse D ri i Banque Russell Wade&Jane Wade
1995 Mark St NO STREET or NUMBER Eldorado Country Club
Riverside, C •92501 CA Indian Wells, CA 92210
508 172 008 508 172 010 508 . 72 0
Riverside o mty Flood Cont Riversi e CoT
y Flood Cont Riverkide ounty Flood Cont
1995 Mark t 1995 Mar 1995 etStRiverside, CA 2501 Riverside, C ,92501 Riversid , A 92501
508 172 012 508 181 016 508 181 017
Riverside C Flood Cont Roman-Wilson Llc Thomas Battaglia
1995 Marken Yt 2825 E Tahquitz Canyon Way#D1 28851 Avenida Diosa
Riverside, CAO1 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Cathedral City, CA 92234
508 191 002 508 191 003 508 191 004
Evan&Phyllis Mclennan Frank Angel Brambila Letra Valkis
621 S Riverside Dr 2541 N Miller Rd 679 E Alexander Way
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Scottsdale,AZ 85257 Palm Springs, CA 92262
508 191 012 508 191 013 508 191 015
Scott Neil Carl&Wencke Martin 1st Church Of Christ Scientists Ps
650 E San Lorenzo Rd 24351 La Hermosa Ave 605 S Riverside Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Laguna Niguel, CA 92677 Palm Springs, CA 92264
508 192 022 508 1920 508 192 024
Michael Green& Stephen Boyd James e&Paul Galetta Del Sol Tortuga
555 E San Lorenzo Rd 949 Plea n ley Rd#2-8 715 E San Lorenzo Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 South ndsor, 06074 Palm Springs, CA 92264
508 192 037 508 192 038 508 192 039
Emery Nagy Gregory&Marie Freed Marilyn Tyler
650 E Mesquite Ave 3475 N Los Coyotes Diagonal 570 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Long Beach, CA 90808 Palm Springs, CA 92264
508 92 0 508 291003 508 291 004
Micha eon& Stephen Boyd r' Robert Wilson James Crippam
555E Sal orenzo Rd 1111 E Alejo Rd 145 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Spr' g , CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92264
508 291 005 508 291 007 508 291 010
Lynda Kerney&X&Connie Lincoln Jim Teitzel&Hilda Teitzel Robert&Barbara Woods
1317 S Calle Palo Fierro 165 E Mesquite Ave 205 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
508291011 508 291 013 508 291 014
Robert Woods&Barbara Woods Steven&Kouba Paul Kelley Jonathan&April Mdner
205 Mesquite Ave 10940 Fruitland Dr , 241 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Studio City,CA 91604 Palm Sprigs, CA 92264
508 291 015 508 291 016 508 291 019
Frank Bryan Peter Johnson Joseph Scionte&Gilda Scionte
249 E Mesquite Ave 254 E Palo Verde Ave 623 S Courtney Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Fullerton, CA 92833
508 291 020 508 291 021 508 291 022
William Waller&Christopher Martin Alfred Marohl Gaeum Choquette
216 E Palo Verde Ave 206 E Palo Verde Ave 190 E Palo Verde Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
508 291 023 508 291 024 508 291 025
Susan Colburn Neal Wilson Douglas Ciccolo
261 E Palo Verde Ave 166 E Palo Verde Ave 158 E Palo Verde Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn,Sprigs, CA 92264
508 291 026, 508 A1 027 508 291 028
Riel d W' stock Steven P ela Zeasman Jerold Harris&Larry Tabberer
Carrie radley Brien 4141 Bea r SW I 8830 Rangely Ave
60 S Cah r d St Seattle, 116 Los Angeles, CA 90048
Ventura, 93001
k i
508 291 (529 508 291 032 508 291 033
Erminia Verlengia Proffitt Edward James&Jacquelyn Storm
1080 S Palm Canyon Dr 185 E Mesquite Ave 248 E Palo Verde Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
508 91 0 4 - 508 291 035 508 291 036
Sieve- id Jim&1-h a Teilzel Everett Martin
1000 S m Canyon Dr 165 E Mes ate Ave 225 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Sp in s, CA 92264 Palm Sprin , CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
I a
508 292 001 508 292 002 508 292 003
Bigley James F&Bigley J Larry Fugate Rena Maynard&Ray Nelson
322 E Desert Willow Cir 208 S Maize Rd 135 E Palo Verde Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92262 Wichita,KS 67209 Palm Springs, CA 92264
508 292 004 508 292 005 508 292 006
Magad Taha&S W Susan Gregg Selleck Robert Free&Free Carolyn Corker
157 E Palo Verde Ave 1175 E El Alameda 9714 Lake Shore Blvd NE
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Seattle, WA 98115
508 292 007 508 A2 008 t 508 292 009
Manning Frank W Richar ee am Rosemarie Goldberg
185 E Palo Verde Ave 207 E Pal erde Ave 219 E Palo Verde Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Sprin s, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
508 292 010 508 292 011 508 311 001
Doyle Lynne Scott Diane Ronald&Leann Dale
227 E Palo Verde Ave 10528 N Sinclair Cir 253 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Fresno, CA 93720 Palm Springs, CA 92264
508 311 002 508 311 028 508 311 029
Bill&Sandra Hoppe Vance Walter H James Henderson
T Mcdonald 266 E Palo Verde Ave 256 E Palo Verde Ave
271 E Mesquite Ave Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
'Palm Springs, CA 92264 -
513 2 0 3 513 250 014 51325 020
E Alan fy&Petty r Chevrolet Macmagruder Us 5
3480 Tor lice Blvcl#212 999 S Palm Canyon Dr U, wit
Torranc , 90503 Palm Springs, CA 92264 CA
113 25 31 _- 513 250 032 513 300 0 6
E Alan Pe &Petty Riverside County Flood Cont Fey Fai vestments Limited Partne
3480 Torr Blvd#212 3133 7th St 2000 S Ma na Dr
Torrance, 0503 Riverside, CA 92507 Palm Sprin s, A 92264
513 300 007 5 3 30 022 513 300 030
Fey Family Investments Limited Panne Us 5 3 George Marantz&Dianne Marantz
2000 S Madrona Dr No 6 Palomino Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 A Palm Springs, CA 92264
l 513-300 022
508 162 004 MR WON JA LEE AND
513 300 031 MR CHARLES H, FULLER YOUNG GACK KIM
George Marantz&Dianne Marantz PO BOX 56211 1109 SOUTH PALM CANYON DRIVE
211 W Mesquite Ave PALM SPRINGS CA 92263-5629 PALM SPRINS CA 92264
Palm Springs, CA 92264
009 602 320 501 045 002 501 062 025
MAC MAGRUDER CHEVROLET SPARKS WALTER 7 MARGARET SHEARER
1999 SOUTH PALM CANYON DRIVE 3715 HILLTOP COURT 2415 KENOMA STRRET
PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 SOQUEL CA 95073 SAN DIMAS CA 91773
501 103 003 505 142 003 508 263 005
JOE&BETTY KENNEDY KENNETH TURNER MR MICHAEL STERN
1,2398 NORTH STARR ROAD 101 STATES ST#7 105 DUANE ST#4F
PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94114 NEW YORK NY 10007
508 311 015 508 416 003
MS CHRISTINE HAMMOND AND MR JAMES GILROY AND 508 421 005
MS SYLVIA ZELNYS MR MICHAEL SURINA MR NICHOLAS CHICOLA
1155 SOUTH CAMINO REAL 3015 SEQUOIA DRIVE NORTH 55 PALOMINO ROAD
PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264
508 442 007
MR ALEXANDER ARTA ROSS AND 513 193 003 508 426 001
MS DIANE ROSS MS SHERYL HAMLIN DEWEY GREEN 1992 TRUST
1550 SOUTH SAGEBRUSH ROAD 221 MAIN STREET#800 901 EAST DEEPWELL ROAD
PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264
ti
Neighborhood Coalition List
Case 5.0956 MR PETER DIXON MR BILL DAVIS AND
O.C. Hearing for12_1 431 SOUTH MONTE VISTA DRIVE MS TRISHA DAVIS
Huddle Springs Development PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 227 SOUTH CAHUILLA
PALM SPRINGS CA 92262
MR FRANK TYSEN MR BOB WEITHORN MR TIM HOHMEIER
C/O CASA CODY COUNTRY INN 261 SOUTH BELARDO ROAD 1387 CALLE DE MARIA
175 SOUTH CAHUILLA ROAD PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264
PALM SPRINGS CA 92264
I
MS CHRISTINE HAMMOND MR PHIL TEDESCO MR MARSHALL ROATH
1155 SOUTH CAMINO REAL 1303 WEST PRIMAVERA DRIVE MS SHERYL HAMLIN
PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 565 WEST-SANTA ROSA DRIVE
PALM SPRINGS CA 92262
MS MARGARET PARK
MS ROXANNE PLOSS AGUA CALIENTE BAND OF
930 CHIA AGUA CALIENTE INDIANS REP CAHUILLA INDIANS
PALM SPRINGS, CA 92262 650 E TAHQUITZ CANYON WAY
PALM SPRINGS CA 92262
SENIOR SECRETARY
DEPT OF PLANNING&ZONING
CITY OF P.S. REP CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
PO BOX 2743
PALM SPRINGS CA 92263-2743
HUDDLE SPRINGS DEVELOPMENT LLC MR JAMES CIOFFI
SPONSORS 9229 SUNSET BLVD#625 2121 EAST TAHQUITZ CANYON WAY
WEST HOLLYWOOD, CA 90069 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262
LA MESQUITE DEVELOPMENT LLC WINGUS PARTNERSHIP MR GEORGE DUNN
ATTN MR YORAM SHILY ATTN MR CHRISTOPHER J PARVIZYAR 1941 PASEO PELOTA
8929 WILSHIRE BLVD#411 9229 SUNSET BLVD#625 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262
BEVERLY HILLS CA 90211 WEST HOLLYWOOD CA 90069
Case5.0965 S.OIcg (Ip, tA�Fsgvire Avr= ,LtF, taints oc, , _ fnl1f.10' Page 1 of24
502 301 008 502 302 001 502 302 002
14a At Ke ne 'le Ele Robert Eichel Lily Rath
98005 Sepul a Blvd#720 603 S El Cielo Rd 2958 Guadalupe Rd
Los Angeles, 90045 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
502 302 003 502 302 004 502 30 005
Kelly Thomas Coleman Carozza Darcy Ruiz Edwar ay&Christopher Sloan
655 S El Cielo Rd 677 S El Cielo Rd PO Box 03
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn r 11 s, CA 92263
i
502 302 006 502 590 005 502 590 011
Rosalie Damore Desert Water Agency Dahoon Investment Co
695 S El Cielo Rd PO Box 1710 77200 California Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92263 Palm Desert,CA 92211
502 591 001 502 591 002 502 591 003
William Sperling&Charlotte Cc Antho Danny Duran Jose&Yolanda Sandor
PO Box 2400 8225 Santa Monica Blvd PO Box 266
Idyllwild, CA 92549 West Hollywood,CA 90046 Romeo,MI 48065
i
502 591 004 502 591 005 502 591 006
Hennes Albert N&Pique Edward&Judith Moomaugh Juan Magunagoicoechea& Sabine Atw
1720 Chevy Chase Dr 2700 E Mesquite North Ave#A5 2700 E Mesquite Ave#A6
Beverly I-Iills,CA 90210 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
502 591 007 502 591 008 502 591 009
Conley Frederick Z&Elizabeth K 1 Lance Wood Barbara Matty
Frederick Conley PO Box 217 10930 NE 157th St
PO Box 88 Whiter Park,CO 80482 Bothell,WA 98011
Palm Springs,CA 92263
502 591 010 502 591 Ol l 502 591 012
Dahoon Investment Cc Inc Hampton&Linda Gaskins Don Gaidano
43350 Tennessee Ave 261 Browning St BRISTOL AVON BSI 4PB
Palm Desert,CA 92211 Upland,CA 91784 UNITED KINGDOM
502 591 013 502 591 014 502 591 015
Alice Mit ell aker Western Precooling Systems Gene&Patsy Seymore
555 S Palm on Dr#350 PO Box 1338 1024 Brooke La
Palm Springs, 92264 Fremont, CA 94538 Fullerton, CA 92264
502591
17 502 591 018 502 591 019
Martin M tt Joseph&Christine Carrick James &Diane Craft
324 N Oakln -st Dr#304 1710 Via Allondra 42 Drakes Bay Dr
Beverly Hill A 90210 San Marcos, CA 92069 Corona Del Mar,CA 92625
502 591 020 502 591 021 502 591 022
Gonzalo Romero&Ann Romero Billy&Shirley Lyon Irma Salinas
1970 Del Mar Ave 7231 Palm Ave 1180 Eaay St#C
San Marino,CA 91108 Highland, CA 92346 San Francisco,CA 94109
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 2 of 24
502 591 023 502 591 024 502 591 025
Patricia Watford Vern&Mary Vilhauer Gary James Wilcox
25447 Via Nevin 2700 E Mesquite North Ave#D24 4513 Cove Dr
Valencia,CA 91355 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Carlsbad,CA 92008
502 591 026 502 591 027 502 591 028
Friedland Michael&Rebecca Mcclelland Min Hung
95 S Market St#640 Barbara Madrid 7231 Palm Ave
San Jose, CA 95113 PO Box 502348 I Highland,CA 92346
San Diego, CA 92150
502 591 029 502 591 030 502 591 031
391259 Alberta Ltd Harold&Bettie Johnson Clarence Haack
139 Hampton Park N W Alb 2731 Brierhaven Dr 2112 Linda Flora Dr
CALGARY AB T3A 5A6 La Crescenta,CA 91214 Los Angeles,CA 90077
CANADA
502 591 034 502 591 035 502 591 036
Kenneth Waltz&Anna Marie Waltz Carol Newton Glaser Roland D&Inge H
6445 E Oakview Ln 12113 Beverly Blvd#Q Glaser
Anaheim Hills,CA 92807 Whittier,CA 90601 607 S Glenwood PI
Burbank,CA 91506
502 591 037 502 591 038 502 591 039
Larry&Mary Lou Halfon Randall&Yvonne Brown Snyder Wendell K&Peggy J
1709 128th Ave SE 2700 E Mesquite Ave#F36 Snyder
Bellevue,WA 98005 Palm Springs,CA 92264 1377 Via Esperanza
San Dimas,CA 91773
502 591 040 502 591 041 6800200014�2743
Alan&Helen Smith James Temple City Oa prings
2700 E Mesquite North Ave#F40 74924 Country Club Dr#130 PO Be
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Desert,CA 92260 Palm Springs,CA 92263
j 680 020 010 680 020 036 680 020 038
City Of Palm rings City Of Pa Springs Southern California Edison Co
PO Box 2 PO B 743 PO Box 800
Pahn S rings,CA 92263 Pa Springs,CA 92263 Rosemead,CA 91770
680 020 039 680 020 043 680 020 051
City Of P Prurgs City Of P Springs Ety Of Pa tmgs
PO Box 43 PO x 2743 B 743prmgs,CA 92263 Palm Sprhigs,CA 92263 Springs,CA 92263
680 020 052 680 051 003 680 051 004
City Of Pair prings Carmen Ruiz&Jose Ruiz Rodney&Usclu Wilson
PO Bo 43 646 S El Cielo Rd 753 N Las Pahnas Ave
Pal prings, CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Los Angeles,CA 90038
68005 00 680 051 006 680 0 007
Peter&Ja t Trasoott Peter&Janet Truscott Edward e, nsky
3300 E Sum ones Rd 3300 E Sunny Dunes Rd 2638 S C oral Ave
Palm Spring C 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Ontario, 91761
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 3 of 24
680 051 00 680 051 009 1 680 051 010
Joyce sta Of Segundo Troy Johnson Armando&Guillermina Landeros
44440 A cia Dr 657 S Desert View Dr 641 S Desert View Dr
Palm Des rt,CA 92260 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
V
680 052 03 680 052 004 680 052 005
James Eaton&Ida Eaton Ernesto Carino&Betty Carino Ashley Bennett C
642 S Desert View Dr 1100 E Alejo Rd PO Box 4220
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92262 Pahn Springs,CA 92263
680 052 006 680 052 007 680 052 008
I Edgar&Joan Fergon Calum&Laura Hughes Theodore Malagar Jr.
3400 E Sunny Dunes Rd 695 S Highland Dr 677 S Highland Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
r
680 052 009 680 052 010 680 053 003
Theodore Malagar Jr. Steve&Michelle Abernathy Armando&Maria Alvarez
677 S Highland Dr 641 S Highland Dr 642 S Highland Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 053 004 680 053 005 680 053 006
Rick Richards&Ruth Richards Esther Malagar Novis Staashehm
656 S Highland Dr 670 S Highland Dr 39140 Ciega Creek Dr
Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Desert,CA 92260
680 53 00 680 053 008 680 053 009
Emelle o Guy Adl u sou Jose Rodriguez
PO Box 62 2101 2nd Ave N 657 Desert Way
Palm IS
n ,CA 92263 Saint Petersburg,FL 33713 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 053 010 680 054 003 680 054 004
Julian Queddeng&Herminia Quedden Norman Johns&Cindy Joins Herberto Griessmann
635 Desert Way 642 Desert Way 656 Desert Way
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 054 005 680 054 006 680 054 007
Terrel Crary&Minnie Crary Romeo&Imelda Mahasig Jose&Delmis Oliva
670 Desert Way 4273 E Calle San Raphael 3580 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 054 008 680 054 009 680 054 010
Wayne Roldau Alex Roldur Brian Beall&Martha Beall
246 E Avenida Granada PO Box 300 641 S Mountain View Dr
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Beverly Hills,CA 90213 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 055 003 680 055 004 680 055 005
Paul Winkler&Patricia Winkler Alexander Roldan Evelyn Henson Mills
642 S Mountain View Dr PO Box 4825 3354 Winter Wren PI
Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92263 Fremont,CA 94555
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 4 of 24
680 055 006 680 055 013 680 055 014
Homer&Cynthia Rivera i Novis Staashelan Clifford Gordon Christopher
688 S Mountain View Dr 39140 Ciega Creek Dr 677 El Placer Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Desert, CA 92260 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
l
680 055 015 680 055 016 680 065 001
Scott Beattie Ileana&Francisco Fernando Solis i Leonidas&Consuelo Poras
657 El Placer Rd 641 El Placer Rd 3731 E Camino San Miguel
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
I
680 065 002 680 065 003 680 065 04
Amado Salinas Schott Thomas E&S G Carmelo D' z
3761 E Camino San Miguel 3781 E Camino San Miguel 3711E C (, A
Miguel
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Sprin 2264
680 065 005 680 065 006 68006 007
Senner Gary&Seiner Gary Gary& cia F to Betty Jo&Charles Barnes
3831 E Camino San Miguel 3861 E Ca 'r San Miguel 1019 N Morris Ave
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs A 92264 West Covina,CA 91790
680 065 008 680 065 0 9 680 065 010
Gary&Judy Topolinski Ana Lozono&Carlos Barajas Joanne Plummer
3960 E Calle San Antonio 3862 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3832 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
I'I 680 065 011 680 065 012 680 065 013
Ramon&Maria Elena Gonzalez Jose&Evelia Jimenez Rafael&Eva Martin
Francisco Gonzalez 3782 E Sunny Dunes Rd 913 S Bamdal St
3812 E Sunny Dunes Rd Palm Springs, CA 92264 Santa Ana,CA 92704
Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 065 014 680 065 015 680 065 016
Garcia Rose&Joseph A&Anthony Regina Dipaola Amado &Ruth Pespes
Garcia 3711 E Camino San Miguel 4330 E Camino San Simeon
2099 E Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Palm Springs,CA 92262
680 066 001 680 066 002 6800 600
Ernesto Agtang Bert&Decie Bitanga Frontie-F imitation
4065 E Camino San Miguel 4012 E Camino San Miguel PO Bo 50
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Patto C 92369
680 066 004 680 066 005 680 066 006
Clayr Aralquez&Patema Ramoran Arnold&Luzcelia Acacio Arthur Alfred Jurado
3933 E Camino San Miguel 3910 E Sunny Dimes Rd 3920 E Sunny Dimes Rd
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 066 007 680 066 008 680 066 009
Robert Stover Julio&Jimenez Norma Cortes Richard&Julia Lopez Sr.
3940 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3952 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4012 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 5 of 24
680 066 010 680066011 680 066 012
Michelle Dickey Benjamin&Benamin Prieto Jr. Robert Pelton&Ruth Pelton
4030 E Sunny Dunes Rd Yolanda Scott 4082 E Sunny Dunes Rd
i Pahn Springs,CA 92264 I 31530 Whispering Palms Trl Palm Springs,CA 92264
Cathedral City, CA 92234
I
680 071 004 1 680 072 005 680 072 009
Weiner Brown Sungold Development Co Sungold velopment Cc
1 6400 Variel Ave PO Box 810490 PO B 810490
Woodland Hills,CA 91367 Dallas,TX 75381 D as,TX 75381
680 073 004 i 680 073 005 680 07 001
City Of Palm prings; City Of Palm S ' s Charlesy
I PO Box 2 3400 E T uitz Canyon Way 4499 E Carlos
Palm S mgs,CA 92263 Pa rings,CA 92262 Pahn Sp 92264
680 074 012 680 081 004 680 082 001
Rufmo Ag m Erlida Agriam Palm Springs fined School Dist Rely Rodas&Rosario Rodas
3130 Avenid o (none) - 3108 California St
Cathedral City, A 92234 Pa prigs,CA 92262 Oakland,CA 94602
680 082 012 680 083 001 680 083 12
Arnold Leon Carolyn Thomas Frances S it('
E Camino San Simeon 4485 E Camino San Simeon 1268 E Ra u Rd#59
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Spr' s,CA 92264
680 084 001 680 084 002 680 084 003
Janette Marie Ennis Henry Gonzales&Rafaela Gonzales Rogelio Agregado&Corazon Agregad
I 1010 Andreas Palms Dr 4441 E Camino San Miguel 4425 E Camino San Miguel
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 084 004 680 084 005 680 084 006
Arthur&Consuelo Godiez Amy Baggott Rudy Martinez&Antonia Martinez
4379 E Camino San Miguel 4341 E Camino San Miguel 4317 E Camino San Miguel
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 084 07 680 084 008 680 084 009
Rosalind- s ez&Olga Salinas Sto Este Cadang Juan hnus&G A Josephine
6780 Koster 4350 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4347 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Elk Grove,CA 758 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 084 010 680 084 011 680 084 012
Jose Gonzalez&Josefia Gonzalez Ben&Julie Baumer Alan Granger&Lydia Granger
4390 E Sunny Dunes Rd 68921 Risueno Rd 4466 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Cathedral City, CA 92234 Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264
680 091 005 680 091 006 680 091 007
Michael Sts&Romanian Orthodox Gab Shelby Coffey&Coffey Nancy Strong Shelby Coffey&C fey Nancy-Strong
PO Box 9197 300 E 62nd St#1503 300 E 62nd St 03
Palm Sprigs,CA 92263 New York,NY 10021 New Yor 10021
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 6 of 24
680 091 008 I 680 093 003 680 093 006
Whitehead Prop&Marion Leonard Son Wiefel Son Wie
4511 E Sunny Dunes Rd#B i 630 S V a Rd 630 ella Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pa prings,CA 92264 alm Springs,CA 92264
680 093 010 680 093 011 680 094 005
Son Wiefe Wiefels &Son Inc Scott Al&Teke
630 S ells Rd 630 S Vella Rd 1155 E Marion Way
Pa Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 094 006 680 102 006 680 103 009
Dilhnan Opal B Whitehead Properties Lie Northbrook Prop Inc
PO Box 8368 680 S Williams Rd PO Box 1287
Bend,OR 97708 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Northbrook,IL 60065
r
680 111 001 680 111 002 680 111 003
Bonifacio&Maria Perez Benjamin Iniguez&Graciela Iniguez Michael Gallagher
3531 E Sunny Dunes Rd 709 S Orange Ave 727 S Orange Ave
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,-CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 111 008 680 111 009 680 111 010
City Of Pa] Springs City Of Springs City Of P prings
PO Boyr43 PQ-Box 2743 PO 1786
PaIny9prings,CA 92263 --'Palm,Springs,CA 92263 - ahrn Springs,CA 92263
680 111 011 680 111 012 680 111 013
City Of Pa prings City Of Springs City Of Pa rings
PO Bo 43 P ox 2743 PO B 43
Pah prings,CA 92263 ahn Springs,CA 92263 PalmSprings,CA 92263
680 111 014 680 111 015 680 111 016
City ZPapr ngs City Of P Springs City Of Pa prings
PO B PO 2743PO2743
Palm CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92263 Pahn Springs,CA 92263
680 111 017 680 111 020 680 111 022
City Of P Springs Epifania Cardoza Drg
PO B 2743 708 S California Ave 3341 Seneca Dr
Pa Springs,CA 92263 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Las Vegas,NV 89109
680 111 023 680 111 024 680 111 027
Teen Challenge Of Southern California Antoine&Claire Mansour City Of P Springs
PO Box 5039 615 Clinton PI PO B 2743
Riverside,CA 92517 Beverly Hills, CA 90210 P Springs, CA 92263
680 111/27
680 Ill 029 680 111 030
City O1rings City Of Pa prings City Of Palm lings
PO Box PO Box 43 PO Box 3, 92263 Pain prings,CA 92263 Pa prings,CA 92263
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 7 of 24
680 111 032 680 111 033 680 111 034
City Of Pa prings Palm Springs ty City Of Pa rings
PO Bo 43 PO Box 6 PO Be 43
P prings,CA 92263 Pah prings,CA 92263 Pa Springs,CA 92263
680 111 035 680 111 036 680 111 037
Palmty Of City Of Pa prings City Of Palm S gs
3133 7 t PO B 786 PO Box 2
Riv side,CA 92507 Pa Springs,CA 92263 Pa prings,CA 92263
680 111 038 680 Ill 039 680 Ill 041
Palm Spr' City Of Palm Spr n ity Of Evangeline Cajucom
PO Bo 786 PO Bo 86 3714 Brilliant PI
Pa Springs,CA 92263 Pa prings,CA 92263 Los Angeles, CA 90065
680 111 042 680 111 043 110 11 044
City Of Palm rings Norman Canales&Pauline Canales David& Zane Farnsworth
PO Box 3 700 S California Ave 323 Broa ay E 91004
Pa . prings,CA 92263 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Seattle,W 98102
680 Ill 045 680 Ill 048 680 Ill 049
j Antoine&Claire Mansour City Of Pahn rings City Of Palm S ' s
615 Clinton PI PO Box 2 3 PO Box 2
Beverly Hills,CA 90210 Palm S rings, CA 92263 Palm, rings,CA 92263
680 111 050 680 111 051 680 Ill 052
Palm Sp ' s City Angl Corp Angl Co
PO Bo 786 2097 est Dr 2097 crest Dr
Palm prings,CA 92263 Glen e, CA 91207 ndale,CA 91207
680 Ill 053 611 111 �O54 680 111 055Fngl Corp City Of prings City Of P prings
2097 Rimcrest Dr PO Bo 743 PO B 43
Glendale, CA 91207 Pa Sprnigs,CA 92263 P Springs,CA 92263
680 112 001 680 112 002 680 112 003
Robin Garcia&Adela Garcia Richard Brown Nicholas Panzarini Jr.
3405 E Sunny Dunes Rd 707 S California Ave Susan Mari Panzarini
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 35062 Serenade
Thousand Palms,CA 92276
680 112 004 680 12 00 680 112 008
Nhu Tran Bob L ve I City Of Palm mgs
PO Box 27738 2857 D Rd E PO Bo 43
Las Vegas,NV 89126 MISSIS UGA ON P Springs,CA 92263
AN A C
680 112 009 685011201 680 112 Ol l
City Of Pahn rings Of ]m Springs City Of P Sprmgs
PO Box 2 3 ox 2743 PO 2743
Palm rings,CA 92263 Springs,CA 92263 E Springs,CA 92263
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 8 of 24
680 112 013 680 112 014 680 112015 ,
Samuel&Gloria Ramirez Dore David&Ronna Mee Brand Nikolova V8n&Current Resident
710 S Palm Ave Riki Barrett Brand 500 W Rafael#28
Palm Springs,CA 92264 720 S Palm Ave Palm Springs,CA 92262
Palm Springs,CA 92264
( 680 112 017 680 112 018 680 112 019
City Of Palm S mgs City Of Pa pr ngs City Of Pa pr ngs
PO Box 27 PO Box 86 PO Bo 43
Palm S gs,CA 92263 Pal prings,CA 92263 P prings,CA 92263
I
680 112 020 680 112 021 680 112 022
City Of P Springs City Of P Springs City Of Palm- rings
PO Bo 743 PO 1786 PO Box
Pa prings,CA 92263 Ett Springs,CA 92263 Pa prings,CA 92263
680 112 023 680 112 024 680 112 02
j City Of Palm S ' �s City Of P Springs Drg
PO Box 27 PO 2743 33 eneca Dr
Palm S mgs,CA 92263 P Springs,CA 92263 as Vegas,NV 89109
I
110 112 028 680 112 029 680 113 006
City Of P Springs M Max Eckert City Of P Springs
PO B 2743 2311 Berkeley Ave PO B 2743
Pa Springs,CA 92263 Los Angeles,CA 90026 Palm Springs,CA 92263
680 113 007 680 113 00 680 113 009
City Of P Springs City Of hn Springs Palm Sprin City Of
PO B 2743 PO x 2743 PO Bo 86
Pa Springs,CA 92263 Pa Springs,CA 92263 P rings,CA 92263
6/1130140s 680 113 0 680 113 012C ngy O alm Springs CityOf P prings
P x 1786 PO Box 43PA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92263 Palm rings,CA 92263
68/Bo743
680 113 014 680 113 015
Ciings City Of P Springs City Of P Springs
PO PO B 2743 PO Bo 43Pa 92263 Pah Springs,CA 92263 Palzn prhrgs,CA 92263
680 113 016 680 113 017 680 113 018
City Of Pa Springs City Of P Springs City Of Pain prings
PO Box 743 PO Bo 743 PO Box 6
Palm rings,CA 92263 Pa Springs,CA 92263 Palm rings,CA 92263
680 113 019 68/B7
680 113 021
City Of P Springs Citprings City Of P Springs
PO Box 743 PO PO B 2743Palm rings,CA 92263 PaCA 92263 P Springs,CA 92263
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 9 of 24
680 113 022 ' 680 113 023 680 113 024
City Of Palm rings City Of Pa priings City Of Pa prmgs
PO Box 27 PO Box 43 PO Bo 43
Palm S gs,CA 92263 Pala rings,CA 92263 Pa Springs,CI 92263
680 113 025 680 113 029 680 113 031
City Of Pa pr ngs Helen Calles&Edward Hill Jr. Arla Provo
PO Box 43 3305 E Sunny Dimes Rd 1 705 S Palm Ave
Palm S rings,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 113 032 680 113 033 680 120 001
George Hernandez Drg Keith&Chisholm John Pideock
3207 29th Ave W 3341 Seneca Dr 777 El Placer Rd
Seattle,WA 98199 Las Vegas,NV 89109 1 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 120 002 680 120 003 680 120 004
Cynthia Muller Aurelio&Esther Juan Josephine Kelly
PO Box 474 737 El Placer Rd 715 El Placer Rd
Rancho Mirage,CA 92270 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 120 005 680 120 006 680 120 007
Edward Scanlan&Patricia Scanlan Vincent Mcmunow-purcell Steven Hedge
1112 Wakefield 3633 E Sunny Dunes Rd 464 S Calla Encilia#A3
Anaheim, CA 92802 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92262
680 120 008 680 120 00 680 1 0 0 0
Hannes Scherber YIR
herber Great a fic Money Market Inc
68100 Ramon Rd#C10 mon Rd#C10 1059 a n St#R
Cathedral City, CA 92234 City,CA 92234 or
92867
680 120011 680 120 012 680 120 013
Hilda Rafull Isabelo Esteban&Eusebia Esteban Hann es Sc er
785 S Mountain View Dr 737 S Mountain View Dr 6810 amon Rd#C8
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 C edral City,CA 92234
680120 014 680 120 015 680 IN 016
Caroline Tis Patricia Tishko Shondrick William D &Survivors Karen Pope
717 S Mountain iew Dr 68144 Valley Vista Dr 3541 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs,C 264 Cathedral City,CA 92234 Paln Springs,CA 92264
680 120 017 680 120 018 680 120 019
Sofia Macavinta Anthony Savidge Dale Homer&lone Cather Thompson
710 Desert Way 720 Desert Way 722 Desert Way
Pain Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 120 020 680 120 021 680 120 023
David Lavigne&Lynn Yada Raul&Kimberly Licon Julie Rupp
736 Desert Way PO Box 2021 733 Desert Way
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 10 of 24
680 120 024 680 120 025 680 120 026
Toms&Candace Kay Brust Paul Yoh Pedro &Ontiveros Martha Gabriel
j 729 Desert Way 717 Desert Way 705 Desert Way
l
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 12 02 680 120 031 680 120 032
Carol W City Of Pal rings Palm Springs Youth Center
701 Desert ay PO Box 43 PO Box 9530
Palm Spring A 92264 Pah prmgs,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92263
680 120 034 680 131 001 680 131 002
Albert Howell Loreto&Jose Palafox Jaclyn&Kenneth Piner
PO Box 9288 932 S Calle Paul 3737 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 131 003 680131004 680131005
Carolyn Pellegrino William Legrave Adam Caudell
3767 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3787 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3817 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 131 006 680 131 007 680 131 008
Guillermo Jimenez&Esequiel Jimenez Rosalina Sally Stachowski Irma Flores
3837 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3867 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3887 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 131 009 680 131 010 680 131 011
Oscar Martin&Silvia Lizarraga Carlos&Sharon Abrille Jacquelyn Miller
3880 E Calle San Antonio 3860 E Calle San Antonio 255 N El Cielo No 140 242
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92262
680 131 012 680 131 013 680 131 014
Ruth Sale Angela&Brenagh Carl Pulido Jr. Joseph Barrett
PO Box 1154 3780 E Calle San Antonio 88 Madrone Ave
Pahn Springs,CA 92263 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 San Francisco,CA 94127
680 131 015 680 131 016 680 132 001
Jack Kilgore&Gail Kilgore Patrick&Jennifer Scanlan Ida Schwartz
1482 E Palm Tree Dr 3720 E Calle San Antonio 2321 S Araby Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 132 002 680 132 003 680 132 004
Manuel&Perlita Vega Nestor&Shirley Jove Arthur Studebaker&Hope Studebaker
3937 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3967 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3987 E Stnmy Dunes Rd
Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 132 005 680 132 006 680 132 007
Marc Bernstein&Jesus Perez Jose Gutierrez Bert Bitanga&Decie Bitanga
1060 Fulton St 4037 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4067 E Sunny Dunes Rd
San Francisco,CA 94117 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 11 of 24
680 132 008 I 680 132 010 680 132011
Michael Brady Marlem Guerra Rodriguez Graciela&Villalba Emidio
4087 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4060 E Calle San Antonio 4040 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
r
680 132 012 680 132 013 680 132 014
Quinonez Antonia Joann Sendejas Gary&Judy Topolinski
4020 E Calle San Antonio 77065 Florida Ave 3933 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Desert,CA 92211 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 132 015 680 132 016 680 133 001
Roger Jones&Fredrich Jones Magdalena Morlina Scott Krueger
3940 E Calle San Antonio 3920 E Calle San Antonio 3713 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 133 002 680 133 003 680 133 004
Luzv minda Madrid&Lemuel Madrid Gary&Kelly Phillips Carsolino Andrade&Guadalupe Andra
3733 E Calle San Antonio 3763 E Calle San Antonio 3032 Nevada Ave
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 El Monte, CA 91731
680 133 005 680 133 006 680 133 007
Alan&Janeth Agbayani Jerrell Williamson Thomas Eugene Flanagan Sr.
3813 E Calle San Antonio 3833 E Calle San Antonio 3863 E Calle San Antonio
Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 133 008 680 133 009 680 133 010
Thomas&Cynthia Flanagan Jr. Gene&Susan Buzard Patricia Hawkinson
3883 E Calle San Antonio 933 Kregmont Dr PO Box 1883
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Glendora,CA 91741 Rancho Mirage,CA 92270
680 133 011 680 133 012 680 133 013
Jorge Gomez William Olvera Donna Hart
3834 E Calle San Raphael 3814 E Calle San Raphael 3784 E Calle San Raphael
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 133 014 680 133 015 680 133 016
John Camangian Prado Filomena Del Donna Riley
3570 E Camino Rojos PO Box 446 3714 E Calle San Raphael
Palm Springs,CA 92262 Palm Springs,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 134 003 680 134 004 680 134 005
Allen Lettington Saul Zatarahr Ruel&Raymunda Malasig
3963 E Calle San Antonio 2322 N Deborah Rd 4411 E Calle De Carlos
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 134 006 680 1 *ael
680 134 008
Rebecca&Gross Jerry Hunter Rodney Midfirst Bk
881 Lawrence Ave 10945 HSt#101 4083 E Calle San Antonio
Westminster,CA 92683 WestHil91304 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 12 of 24
680 134 00 680 134 010 680 134 011
Janice Neil Juan&Laura Jimenez Aurora&Jorge Gomez
4084E Calle a Raphael 4064 E Calle San Raphael Maria Rose
Palm Spriu ,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 4034 E Calle San Raphael
Pahn Springs,CA 92264
I
680 134 012 680 134 013 680 134 014
Anastacia Tangeora Frank&Lugarda Reyes Jr. Amulfo&Joel Gutierrez
4014 E Calle San Raphael 3984 E Calle San Raphael Amulfo Gutierrez Jr.
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 3964 E Calle San Raphael
Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 134 015 680 134 016 680 134 017
Reginald Montoya Chun Kim Mike Delgado&Gloria Delgado
3974 E Camino San Simeon 3914 E Calle San Raphael 3913 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 134 018 680 135 001 680 135 002
Mark&Cynthia Crocker Michael&Mercelyn Gonzales Ruben Zepeda Ballesteros
3933 E Calle San Antonio 3935 E Calle San Raphael 3951 E Calle San Raphael
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 135 003 680 135 004 680 135 005
Esmeraldo&Victoria Coloma Katherine Serafm Maria Socorro Gerada
3991 E Calle San Raphael 4011 E Calle San Raphael Luz Bernardit Gerada
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 4015 E Calle San Raphael
Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 135 006 680 135 007 680 135 008
Scott Wendell&James Mechrre Denis&Baguette Choquette Sylvia Weathers&Mariel Solais
4019 E Calle San Raphael 4035 E Calle San Raphael 423 Myrdewood Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Calnnesa, CA 92320
680 135 009 680 135 010 680 135011
Richard Thibodeaux Benjamin Knight Richard&Cherie Pierce
Katherine Thibodeaux 4018 E Pasco Luisa 4008 E Pasco Luisa
4028 E Pasco Luisa Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 135 012 680 136 001 680 136 002
Martine&Jacques Guiragossian Pilareta Opaon Michael Gonzales&Mercelyn Gonzale
840 S Avenida Evelita 821 S Avenida Evelita 855 S Avenida Evelita
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 136 003 680 1361104 680 136 005
Solon Rodas&Agripina Rodas Solon Rodas gripina Rodas Emilio Coloma&Christina Colman
885 S Avenida Evelita 885 S Av da Evelita 891 S Avenida Evelita
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm rings,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 136 006 680 136 007 680 137 001
Remedios&Yarra Shirley Degma Steven Haynes &K Johnson Sugi Charles &Joy Brown
899 S Avenida Evelita 903 S Avenida Evelita 4003 E Pasco Luisa
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 13 of 24
680 137 002 680 137 003 680 137 004
Timothy&Magdalena Willey Carlos Reyes&Chun Reyes Rafael Jimenez
4029 E Pasco Luisa 4037 E Paseo Luisa 910 S Avenida Evelita
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 137 005 680 141 001 680 141 002
Julio&Alba Antunez Johnny&Josephine Imus Tante&Ricarte Agbayani
916 S Avenida Evelita 4309 E Sunny Dimes Rd Bienvenida
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 628 S Mountain View Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 141 003 680 141 004 680 141 005
Victoria Enriquez Vera Maravilla&Susan Marie Godinez Manuel&Alejandra Mercado
4237 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4217 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4187 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 141 006 680 141 007 680 141 008
Audrey Reimers John&Mary Greene Genaro &Maria Orozco
4167 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4137 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4117 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
1 680 141 09 680 141 010 680 141 011
Hess A Beattie Dorothy A Gerald Gillette&Janette Gillette
PO Box 446 4140 E Calle San Antonio 4160 E Calle San Antonio
Seal Bea A 90740 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 141 012 680 141 013 680 141 014
Fernando Jimenez&Juana Jimenez Benjamin&Yolanda Gonzalez Samuel Ortega
4180 E Calle San Antonio 4220 E Calle San Antonio 67205 Rango Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Cathedral City, CA 92234
680 141 018 680 141 019 680 142 001
Juan&Maria Ceron Steve&Antonette Husbands Aidamaiie Opleda
4260 E Calle San Antonio 4280 E Calle San Antonio 4283 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 142 002 680 142 003 680 142 004
Michael Verrochi Benita Campuzano &Jose Juan Campo Calarence Macy
4263 E Calle San Antonio 4233 E Calle San Antonio 4213 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 142 005 680 142 006 680 142 007
Antonio Ramil&Herminia Rattail Leonara Tintero&Maricel Agtang Rodolfo Armendariz&Trinidad Armen
4183 E Calle San Antonio 4163 E Calle San Antonio 4133 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 142 008 680 142 009 680 142 010
Trent&Allison Gibson Toney Cadang Mariquita Domingo
105 Winbeldon Ct 4114 E Calle San Raphael PO Box 486
Stafford,VA 22556 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Ridgecrest,CA 93556
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 14 of 24
680 142 011 680 142 012 1 680 142 013
Francisco&Henninia Cruz Vaughn&Veneita Brudvik Vaughn&Ve ita Brudvik
4164 E Calle San Raphael 1402 Via Roberto Miguel 1402 Vi oberto Miguel
lPalm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Pa prings,CA 92262
680 142 014 680 142 015 680 142 016
Armando&April Juarez Daniel Garcia&Virginia Garcia Amer Cara
4234 E Calle San Raphael 4264 E Calle San Raphael 4284 E Calle San Raphael
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 143 001 680 143 002 680 143 003
Carolyn Cara Benjamin&Elizabeth Soriente Ernest&Helen Otte
822 S Pasco Caroleta 4193 E Calle San Raphael 4211 E Calle San Raphael
Palm Springs,CA 92264I Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 143 004 680 143 005 680 143 006
Charito&Josefina Balanay Fidel Agriam&Milagros Agriam Norma Hines&Alden Hines
R Trinidad 4273 E Calle San Raphael 871 S Calle Santa Cruz
42355 E Calle San Raphael Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Pahu Springs,CA 92264
Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 143 007 680 143 008 680 143 009
Fernando Samsam&Cora Samsam Pauline Olvera&William Olvera Sharon Brennan
901 S Calle Santa Cruz 3814 E Calle San Raphael 955 S Calle Santa Cruz
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 143 010 680 143011 680 143 012
Victor Reyes&Mary Reyes Krouse Donald J Vince&Hang Lam
965 S Calle Santa Cruz 960 S Paseo Caroleta 958 S Pasco Caroleta
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 143 013 680 143 014 680 143 015
Marc Bernstein Norlito Agriam&Ofelina Agriam John&Sandra Rosson
956 S Pasco Caroleta 933 S Pasco Caroleta 7 Karlisa Cv
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 143 016 680 143 017 680 143 018
Kathy Ruiz ! Clarissa B Fawcett Pedro Angeles Jr.
6 Karlisa Cv PO Box 914 4 Karlisa Cv
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Fall City,WA 98024 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 143 019 680 143 020 680 143 021
Sharon Quesada Oscar&Teresa Carnero Daniel&Maria Cook
3 Karlisa Cv 708 S Pasco Caroleta 890 S Pasco Caroleta
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 144 003 680 144 004 680 144 006
John&Laura Perez Donald Mendoza&Virginia Mendoza Santiago&Margaret Delgado
913 S Pasco Caroleta 925 S Pasco Caroleta 957 S Pasco Caroleta
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening-City of Palm Springs Page 15 of 24
680 144 007 680 144 008 680 144 009
Johnny Estate Of Isidoro Jon&Elaine Colbert Virginia Gross
Norman Lifpitz 969 S Pasco Caroleta 973 S Pasco Caroleta
36032 Donny Cir Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
Pahn Desert,CA 92211
680 144 010 680 144 011 680 144 012
Pablo Contreras Santos Santacmz Joshua&Hayley Crow
981 S Pasco Caroleta 987 S Calle Santa Cruz 982 S Pasco Dorotea
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 144 013 680 144 014 680 144 015
Victorio Ramones Barut Saturnino&Leticia Soto Enrique&Fortin Solis
Ramona Macadau Barut 950 S Pasco Dorotea 942 S Pasco Dorotea
970 S Pasco Dorotea Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 144 016 680 144 017 680 144 018
Michael Huckins Jr. &Peter Wells Richard Wilhelm Alicia Corpuz&Allan Ahorro
2428 Tamarisk Dr 930 S Pasco Dorotea 924 S Pasco Dorotea
Santa Rosa,CA 95405 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 144 019 680 144 021 680 144 023
Tiburcio Macavinta Tim Stewart Joaquin&Concepcion Fuster
912 S Pasco Dorotea 882 S Pasco Dorotea 804 S Pasco Dorotea
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 144 024 680 144 025 680 144 026
Carlos&Ramona Carrauza Charles Heinz&Martha Heinz Fidel&Cristeta Cabacungan
803 S Pasco Caroleta 816 S Pasco Dorotea Fr<ancisca
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 827 S Pasco Caroleta
Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 145 001 680 145 003 680 145 004
Carolyn Goodwin Kahnema Price Michael Woody&Mary Kristine Wood
915 S Pasco Dorotea 927 S Pasco Dorotea 939 S Pasco Dorotea
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 145 005 680 145 006 680 145 007
Charles Hughes&Vicki Hughes Manuel&Kara Montenegro III Kahnema Price
953 S Pasco Dorotea 957 S Pasco Dorotea 927 S Pasco Dorotea
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 145 009 680 145 010 680 145 011
Lorenzo Salvidar&Antonio Syl Salvid Antonio&Artemisa Sesma Jorge Rodriguez&Virginia Rodriguez
988 S Avenida Evelita 960 S Avenida Evelita 944 S Avenida Evelita
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 1450 680 145 013 680 145 014
Humberto De ant Perez Edner&Susan Agresor Richard Wolff
Egricelda&Hu Perez 928 S Avenida Evelita PO Box 2170
936 S Avenida Ev Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92263
Palm Springs,CA 2 4
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 16 of 24
680 145 015 680 151 001 680 151 002
Matthew Bamberg&Todd Larson David Buckles&Charles Hay Alexander Eros&Ofelia Eros
920 S Avenida Evelita 4489 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4465 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 I Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 151 003 680151004 680151005
Martin&Dora Villalobos Miller Florence L Juan&Josephine Imus
4433 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4411 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4347 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
I
680 151 006 680 151 007 680 151 008
Juan Imus&Jose ine Aveci Imus Juan Imus& sephine Ave Imus Juan Imus Josephine Imus
4309 E Sunny unes Rd 4375 E S y Dunes Rd 4347 unny Dunes Rd
Pahn Sp CA 92264 Pahn prings,CA 92264 Pa Springs,CA 92264
680 151 009 680 151 010 680 151 011
Thomas Bollinger Jr. Alma Berry Edward Allen
4310 E Calle,San Antonio 4344 E Calle San Antonio 4370 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 151 012 680 151 013 680 151 014
Anthony Taricco&Curtis Head Jr. Dennis Sonico &Jeanne Sonico Alicia Rodriguez
4388 E Calle San Antonio 4412 E Calle San Antonio 4424 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 151 015 680 151 016 680 151 017
Fon Young Park Marilyn Johnson James Cahill
4460 E Calle.San Antonio 740 S Calle Paul 762 S Calle Paul
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 151 018 680 151 019 680 151 020
Robert Harrison Leonard&Christine Ferro Felix &Isabel Rivera
784 S Calle Paul 812 S Calle,Paul 852 S Calle Paul
Patin Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 151 021 680 151 022 680 151 023
Jesus Orea Jose Luis&Alicia Escobar Christian&Corie Guillermo
886 S Calle Rd Alicia 932 S Calle Paul
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 906 S Calle Paul Palm Springs,CA 92264
Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 151 024 680 151 025 680 151 026
Spike Meyers&Peter Finley Carolyn Maglione Zulema Cantu
PO Box 2384 976 S Calle Paul 980 S Calle Paul
Palm Springs,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 151 027 680 151 028 680 151 029
Gerda Stefanoff Sylvia Gaumann Eric&Joseph Sander
998 S Calle Paul 4475 E Pasco Caroleta M Jeanie
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 4425 E Pasco Caroleta
Palm Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 17 of 24
680 151 030 680 151 031 680 151 032
Candace Knauf Federico Bulacan Patricia Stan
4385 E Pasco Caroleta 4361 E Pasco Caroleta 4355 E Pasco Caroleta
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 151 033 680 151 034 680 151 043
Roy Dolhnan Felipe Genera&Eva Genera Richard&Paulette Koenke
863 Wellesley Ave 4303 E Pasco Caroleta 4318 E Mesquite Ave
Los Angeles,CA 90049 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 151 044 680 151 045 680 151 046
Mary Lou Quintana Patrick Doane&Donna Doane Audrey Coleman
4344 E Mesquite Ave 4356 E Mesquite Ave 4388 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 151 047 680 151 048 680 151 049
Ireneo&Wehna Domingo Richard Golay&Carlota Golay Rene&Yolanda Floriano
4400 E Mesquite Ave 4420 E Mesquite Ave 4480 E Mesquite Ave
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 152 001 680 152 002 680 152 003
Stolp Estelle Vander Norlito &Ofelina Agriam Gerald Pelton&Pat Pelton
765 S Calle Paul 791 S Calle Paul 819 S Calle Paul
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 152 004 680 152 005 680 152 006
Gerald Pelton&Patsy Pollen Allen Davis Jr. Olive Barker
819 S Calle Paul 881 S Calle Paul 905 S Calle Paul
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 152 007 680 152 008 680 152 009
C Morton Cliff Enrique&Lydia Hernandez Rafael&Claudia Rodriguez
927 S Calle Paul 965 S Calle Paul 975 S Calle Paul
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 152 010 680 152011 680 152 012
Thomas Davies &Joseph Marvici Dennis Jay Richard Romero&Betty Romero
989 S Calle Paul 990 S Calle Tomas 1520 Rockwood St
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Los Angeles,CA 90026
680 152 014 680Z& enie
680 152 016
Virgil&Laverne Stevens Vir Stevens Juan Calleja&Alberto&M Perez
928 S Calle Tomas 928as 880 S Calle Tomas
Palm Springs,CA 92264 PalA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 152 017 680 152 018 680 152 019
Vicki&Mervin Epstein Darin&Rita Thompson Harry Albrecht&Barbara Albrecht
820 S Calle Tomas 802 S Calle Tomas 792 S Calle Tomas
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
� n,
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 18 of 24
680 152 020 680 153 001 680 153 002
Douglas Herrera&Ruth Mendez Iwao Kodama&Satsuko Kodama John&Lucy Cabacungan
766 S Calle Tomas 760 S Calle Santa Cruz 790 S Calle Santa Cruz
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 153 003 680 153 004 680 153 005
Lakshman&Nalini Abeyatunge David&Misty James William Gilliland
800 S Calle Santa Cruz 822 S Calle Santa Cruz 888 S Calle Santa Cruz
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
I
f i
680 153 006 680 153 007 680 153 008
Donald Hetrick&Hannelore Hetrick Sanchez Frank Pamela Kramos
900 S Calle Santa Cruz 1023 Via Grande 17337 Victory Blvd
Palm Spripa, CA 92264 Cathedral City,CA 92234 Van Nuys,CA 91406
680 153 009 680 153 010 680 153 Oil
Jeffrey Kraybill Julia Williams Juan Manuel Lopez&Eva Delia Lopez
540 Ofarrell St#306 918 Comanche Ct 999 S Calle Tomas
San Francisco,CA 94102 Camarillo,CA 93010 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 153 012 680 153 013 680 153 014
Victor Ormero Suzana Arellano Ronnie Hallett
987 S Calle Tomas 955 S Calle Tomas 16234 Bellflower Blvd 411
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Bellflower, CA 90706
680 153 015 680 153 016 680 153 017
Julio Cesar Solano Charles Muller Omar&Ellena Custodio
901 S Calle Tomas 889 S Calle Tomas PO Box 8506
Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264 Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264 Pahn Sprigs,CA 92263
680 153 018 680 153 019 680 153 020
BillyBitanga&Sonia Bitanga Melquiades&Elvira Cuevas Armando Arellano&Blanca Calleja
805 S Calle Tomas Elvira Cuevas 763 S Calle Tomas
Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264 791 S Calle Tomas Palm Springs,CA 92264
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 160 003 680 160 016 680 160 017
International Memorial Society Inc John Komer E-z Storage Of Palm Springs Llc
4707 E Sunny Dunes Rd 815 S Williams Rd 785 S Williams Rd
Pahn Sprigs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 160 018 680 160 020 680 160 024
Boclmer Lauren E&David Trus Bochn Eloyce 'ch dt Bochner Lauren E&David Trus Boclmr
771 S Williams Rd 75593 C o De Paco 740 S Vella Rd
Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264 Indian Wel , A 92210 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 160 025 680 160 026 680 160 027
Miller John&Mary Ann Jamison Whitehead Prop&Donald Williams
1014 23rd St PO Box 3191 4511 E Sunny Dunes Rd#B
Santa Monica,CA 90403 Pahn Sprigs,CA 92263 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 19 of 24
680 160 030 I 680 160 032 680 160 033
Palm Springs Disposal Services Pahn Springs Storage Partners Ltd Jack Haddad
PO Box 2711 4550 E Mesquite Ave#IA 2246 Betty Ln
Palm Springs,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Beverly Hills,CA 90210
680 160 036 680 160 037 680 160 040
Clyde&Cannella Lo Phillips I Donald&Emily Williams General Telephone Co Of Calif
424 N Monterey Rd 4511 E Sunny Dunes Rd#B PO Box 152206
Palm Springs,CA 92262 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Irving,TX 75015
680 160 042 680 160 043 680 160 047
Whitehead Pro &Donald Williams Whitehead Pr &Donald Williams Whitehead Jack D&Prop
4511 E Su Dunes Rd#B 4511 E S y Dunes Rd#B 3325 Monterey Rd
Palm Sp gs,CA 92264 Palm-Springs,CA 92264 San Marino,CA 91108
r
680 160 048 680 160 049 610 160 O50
Donald&Emily Williams Whitehead Pr Donald Williams Whitehead &Donald Williams
4511 E Sunny Dunes Rd#B 4511 E S y Dunes Rd#B 4511 rmny Dunes Rd#B
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm, rings,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 160 051 680 160 052 610 1 053
Donald Williams &Emily Williams Williams Donald E&E J Whritehea op
4511 E Sunny Dunes Rd#B 38-681 Bogert Trl 3325 me Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92262 Sa arino, C 91108
680 160 054 680 511 001 680 511 002
Whitehea rop Steven&Marta Loya Floyd Mcneley&Mary Mcneley
3325 nterey Rd 4080 E Mesquite Ave 4060 E Mesquite Ave
S arino,CA 91108 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 511 003 680 1 00 680 511 005
Jack&Helen Hinton Michae sters Hushang Shahidi
4040 E Mesquite Ave 950 S N4q Vista Dr 73985 Krug Ave
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Spr gs,CA 92264 Palm Desert, CA 92260
680 511 006 680 511 007 680 511 008
Juanita Baustista Janet Samuelian Lifpitz Nancy
930 S Nueva Vista Dr 14310 Chandler Blvd#6 36032 Donny Cir
Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Van Nuys,CA 91401 Palm Desert, CA 92211
680 511 009 680 51 01 680 512 002
Joseph Hopkins Vivienne glass R A Hackett&Joanne Hackett
900 S Nueva Vista Dr PO Box 369 3730 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Rutherford, 94573 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 512 003 680 512 004 680 512 005
Max&Lerma Carizon Taila&Reinikamen Hanni Ranta Deborah Barragan&Wanda Barragan
725 S Mountain View Dr Salla 3790 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 923 Arroyo Vista Dr Palm Springs,CA 92264
Palm Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening-City of Palm Springs Page 20 of 24
680 512 006 680 512 007 680 512 008
Paul Herlihy&Doris Herlihy Susanna Koo Rios P &P
3810 E Mesquite Ave 3830 E Mesquite Ave 69655 Hermosillo Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Cathedral City, CA 92234
680 512 009 680 512 010 680 512 011
Paul Poluburskas Otilia Hurtado Mary Schroeder
3870 E Mesquite Ave 3894 E Mesquite Ave 3910 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680512012 680512013 680512014
William Ransom Jr. Michael Perom&Cecelia Perom Ben&Rochelle Jones
3920 E Mesquite Ave 3940 E Mesquite Ave 3960 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
r
680 512 015 680 512 016 680 512 017
Virginia Ridgway Stuart&Koshnick Christine Punk Jackie Graham
3980 E Mesquite Ave 965 S Nueva Vista Dr 320 6th St
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Huntington Beach,CA 92648
680 512 019 680 521 001 680 521 002
I Carol Bray Robert Allen&Joanne Allen Hrair Avakian
PO Box 676 3532 E Mesquite Ave 801 S Mountain View Dr
1 Temecula,CA 92593 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 521 003 680 522 001 680 522 002
Sergio&Patricia Perez Jeanne Schwarz Roderick David Gehrke
877 S Mountain View Dr 15944 Snow Creek Rd 52295 Avenida Herrera
Palm Springs,CA 92264 White Water,CA 92282 La Quinta,CA 92253
680 522 003 680 522 004 680 522 005
Partington John R Pridel&Socorro Moms James Weidinger
19860 Sidcup Ln 891 El Placer Rd 867 El Placer Rd
Huntington Beach,CA 92646 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 522 006 680 522 007 680 523 001
Michael Wilke Mark Kress&Bruce Newman Maximo &.Amelia Jose
835 El Placer Rd 803 El Placer Rd 812 El Placer Rd
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 523 �02 680523003 680523 004
Tom&E R ifer Richard Hoban Boyd Poulsen&Stella Poulsen
265 ArabSt 812 Arroyo Vista Dr 804 S Nueva Vista Dr
Palm Springs,CA 9 4 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 523 005 680 523 006 680 523 007
Robert Olive Martin Curtis Debra Dew
806 S Nueva Vista Dr 2715 SE Spyglass Dr 814 S Nueva Vista Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Vancouver,WA 98683 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 21 of 24
680 523 008 680 52 009 680 523 010
Tracy Vernarsky Kenneth V 1 Horn Nedzad&Samija Ajanic
816 S Nueva Vista Dr 2390 E Nr la Rd N 820 S Nueva Vista Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Spr' g CA 92262 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680523011 680 523 012 680 523 013
Mark Sherwin Robert Hernandez Jesus Vega
1550 Erwin St#339 826 S Nueva Vista Dr 828 S Nueva Vista Dr
Van Nuys,CA 91411 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264
680 523 014 680 523 015 680 523 017
Kevin&Lisa Gillespie Joe Anchondo&Ernestine Anchondo Moses Esparza
j 830 S Nueva Vista Dr 842 S Nueva Vista Dr ''I 872 S Nueva Vista Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 i Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680523018 680 524 001 680 524 002
K pen Rae S Kurt Schmidt Evelyn Williams
1291 Hickory Dr 910 Arroyo Vista Dr 975 S Nueva Vista Dr
Basking Ridge,NJ 07920 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 524 003 680 524 004 680 524 005
Kurt Parish&J D Poyfair Larry Sieh&Judith Sieh Demos Philhart
865 S Nueva Vista Dr 855 S Nueva Vista Dr 845 S Nueva Vista Dr
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 524 006 680 524 007 680 524 008
Teresa Vasquez David Trsut Mathews Robert&Lymi Speck
835 S Nueva Vista Dr 67845 Carroll Dr 823 S Nueva Vista Dr
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Cathedral City,CA 92234 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 524 009 680 5 010 f 680 524 011
A Hess Fred Robert S ers Yolanda Schulte&Carol Swanney
PO Box 2168 9324 State 833 Greenridge Dr
Pahn Sprigs,CA 92263 Marysville, A 98270 La Canada Flintridge,CA 91011
680 524 012 680 524 013 680 524 014
Capps Beverly Jack Young Courtney Fetchenhier
826 Arroyo Vista Dr 830 Arroyo Vista Dr 836 Arroyo Vista Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 524 015 680 524 016 680 524 017
Rafael Loyola&Juvenal L Orduna Raymond&Carol Davis Robert Turchi
840 Arroyo Vista Dr 30003 SW Weaver Dr 1359 E Camino Primrose
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Newberg,OR 97132 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 524 018 680 524 019 680 524 020
Dan&Annida Faessler Clare Rifsdal Bradley&Shannon Wayne
3760 Lemon Ave 906 Arroyo Vista Dr 908 Arroyo Vista Dr
Long Beach,CA 90807 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Paint Sprigs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 22 of 24
680 525 001 680 525 003 680 525 004
Taila Rama Marshall Mccoy George Ligar II
923 Arroyo Vista Dr 915 Arroyo Vista Dr 913 Arroyo Vista Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 525 006 680 525 007 680 525 008
William&Ann Ingham Mary Holmes Paula&Williams Ronald Bacon
903 Arroyo Vista Dr I�, 899 Arroyo Vista Dr Janice
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 7527 Cowan Ave
Los Angeles,CA 90045
680 525 009 680 525 010 680525011
Juan Castaneda Lawrence&Shirley Ann Bertol ni Luiz Sampaio
i 855 Arroyo Vista Dr 835 Arroyo Vista Dr 259 Museum Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Los Angeles,CA 90065
680 525 012 680 525 013 680 525 014
Robert&Julia Philbrook Roy Pockett Donald Nagy
1 829 Arroyo Vista Dr 825 Arroyo Vista Dr 821 Arroyo Vista Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 525 015 680 525 016 680 525 017
Jorge&Elizabeth Nava Ruben&Alice Lugo Lolito Agresor
819 Arroyo Vista Dr 876 El Placer Rd 890 El Placer Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 525 018 680 525 019 680 525 020
Elizabeth Maxwell John Chaves Barbara Simpson
3650 E Mesquite Ave 3670 E Mesquite Ave 3690 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 550 002 680 570 001 680 570 002
City Of P Spr ngs Barber Dev Llc Blau Steven&Christine
PO Bo 743 2115 DhezemRd PO Box 757
Pa prhrgs,CA 92263 Blue Lake,CA 95525 Bigfork,MT 59911
680 570 003 680 570 004 680 0 00
Robert&Susan Stiff Kelly Pa bk &Margaret A Kelly r' k J&Margaret A
12315 S Gene Autry Trl Kelly 2846 Wa n Train Ln
Palm Springs,CA 92264 2846 Wagon in Ln Diamond Ba CA 91765
Diamond Bar,CA 91765
680 570 006 680 SNBcac ,
680 570 008
Joseph&Lucile Dennis III Joan Randy&Darlene Ernst
1237 S Gene Autry Trl 6282 67886 Jane Ln
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Long90815 Cathedral City,CA 92234
680 570 009 680 570 010 680570011
Ashwill Bruce&Barbara Auto Inn Inc Steven Lederman
3181 Cameron Park Dr#105 68351 Perez Rd 35200 Cathedral Canyon Dr#131
Cameron Park,CA 95682 Cathedral City,CA 92234 Cathedral City,CA 92234
•� I
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 23 of 24
680 590 001 6805 004 680 590 005
Rand Larson&David Atkisson Rams�if
y thy S I Charles &Patricia Purdy
1332 Crystal Ct 1261 fa Cir S 1361 Crystal Ct
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Spt s,CA 12212 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 590 006 680 590 007 680 590 008
Robert&Pamela Evans Romeo&Juliete Acorda Willard Livingstone&Hubert Gartingt
1351 Crystal Ct 1341 Crystal Ct 1331 Crystal Ct
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 590 009 6ZowAve#142
680 590 O11
El Sonora Assoc E Rand David Larson&David Atkisson
3002 Dow Ave 9142 3 1332 Crystal Ct
j Tustin,CA 92780 T Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 590 012 680 590 013 680 590 014
Rudolph&Marisela Daugcil Mantel Bomme&Joyce C Brown Charles H&Franklin Bertheau
1342 Crystal Ct PO Box 1984 1362 Crystal Ct
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Gresham,OR 97030 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 590 015 680 590 016 680 590 017
Lewis Morey&Aunrey Bubis Scott Cunningham
2943 E Las Palmas Cir 1382 Crystal Ct 1392 Crystal Ct
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 590 018 680 590 019 6" 59
El Sonora Assoc El Sonora ssoc El:Onu�
3002 Dow Ave#142 3002 w Ave#142 30 ow Ave#142
Tustin,CA 92780 Tu, n,CA 92780 Tui,CA 92780
680 590 021 680 590 022 680 590 023
Edward Lopatin Wilczak Thomas Contopulos
1395 Emerald Ct 1385 Emerald Ct 1375 Emerald Ct
Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 590 024 680 590 025 680 590 026
C D Ewer&M J Paurowski El Sonora Associates Starr Nicholas&Yolanda M
1365 Emerald Ct PO Box 2743 Stair
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92263 1024 Peninsula St
Ventura,CA 93001
680 590 027 680 590 028 680 590 029
Rafael Arellano El Sonora Assoc Cook Larry E
2217 Lone Tree St 3002 Dow Ave#142 6902 Pflumm Rd
Corona, CA 92880 Tustin,CA 92780 Shawnee,KS 66216
680 590 030 680 590 031 680 590 032
El Sonora ssoc El Senor ssoclates Glen&Brenda Marti
3002 w Ave#142 PO B 2743 1011 S Valentin St#63
Tus '1,CA 92780 P Sprigs,CA 92263 Denver,CO 80247
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening-City of Palm Springs Page 24 of 24
Neighborhood Coalition List
as of October 1, 2003 MR PETER DIXON MR BILL DAVIS AND
Case 5,0965 431 SOUTH MONTE VISTA DRIVE MS TRISHA DAVIS
P.C. Hearing for 11-12-03 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 227 SOUTH CAHUILLA
City of Palm Springs PALM SPRINGS CA 92262
MR FRANK TYSEN MR BOB WEITHORN MR TIM HOHMEIER
C/O CASA CODY COUNTRY INN 261 SOUTH BELARDO ROAD 1387 CALLE DE MARIA
175 SOUTH CAHUILLA ROAD PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264
PALM SPRINGS CA 92264
I
MS CHRISTINE HAMMOND MR PHIL TEDESCO MR MARSHALL ROATH
1155 SOUTH CAMINO REAL 1303 WEST PRIMAVERA DRIVE MS SHERYL HAMLIN
PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 565 WEST SANTA ROSA DRIVE
PALM SPRINGS CA 92262
MS MARGARET PARK
MS ROXANNE FLOSS AGUA CALIENTE BAND OF
930 cHIA AGUA CALIENTE INDIANS REP CAHUILLA WDIANs
PALM SPRINGS, CA 92262 650 E TAHOUITZ CANYON WAY
PALM SPRINGS CA 92262
SENIOR SECRETARY
DEPT OF PLANNING &ZONING
CITY OF P.S. REP CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
PO BOX 2743
PALM SPRINGS CA 92263-2743
17976 VO SJNRidS INIVd b9"cZ6 VO`s3u?sdS aged
V310b00 03SVd Hinos qZ6
a3NHOIG J VINIOZIIA SW 1D 18£T
i0NHO13 d lNV)i 2iW au??yQ sVu[ogl,W fa?uspOW pteuo�j
800-9171-089 L£0 065 089
08LZ6 'VD 'u'jS1!T OSLZ6 V0` . sn,L b9ZZ6 VO`s;IuudS mIl2d
ZbI#o^V MO ZOOE ZbT#QA oQ ZOOE 3D Pfuzau a 06ET
0o wouos fg o sV ezouos tg snTIUI&S
SEO 06S 089 bEO 065 089 EEO 069 089
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES %
December 10, 2003
Council Chamber, City Hall
3200 East Tahquitz Canyon Way
Palm Springs, California 92262
ROLL CALL Present Present FY 03-04
This Meeting to Date Excused Absences
Jon Shoenberger, Chair X 12 0
Dianne Marantz, Vice Chair X 11 1
Mark Matthews 10 2
Jerry Grence X 11 1
Tracy Conrad X 10 2
Ricky Wright X 12 0
Larry Hochanadel X 12 0
STAFF PRESENT:
Douglas R. Evans, Director of Planning &Zoning
Dave Barakian, City Engineer
Alex Meyerhoff, Principal Planner
Kathy Marx, Associate Planner
Michele Boyd, Administrative Coordinator
w w w w w
Chairman Shoenberger called the meeting to order at 1:37p.m.
w w w w w
The December 10, 2003 agenda was available for public access at the City Hall exterior bulletin
board and the Department of Planning &Zoning counter by 4:00 p.m., December 05, 2003.
w w w w w
M/S/C (Marantz/Hochanadel 5-0, 2 absent) to approve the minutes of October 08, 2003 as
presented.
w w w w w
Page 2 of 4
Planning Commission Minutes ' Lj,",
December 10, 2003
Case 5.0956 — (A) a General Plan Circulation Map Amendment to reclassify Mesquite Avenue
between South Palm Canyon Drive and Random Road from a Secondary Thoroughfare to a
Collector Street; and
Case 5.0956 — (B) Planned Development District 285 (PD-285) and Tentative Tract Map 31413
for the Huddle Springs, a mixed-use development consisting of 48 residential condominiums, 18
live/work lofts, 25,759 square feet of retail/food space, 9786 square feet of office space, and an
up to 8,000 square foot restaurant located on 11.1 acres bound by the Tahquitz Creek Channel to
the north, Random Road to the east, Mesquite Avenue to the south, and South Palm Canyon Drive
to the west, Zone C-1, Section 23.
��A/9
Page 3 of 4
Planning Commission Minutesii
December 10, 2003
Commissioner Marantz abstained due to a conflict of interest as her place of business is within 500
feet of the subject property and she left the meeting.
Jing Yeo, Principal Planner, reported that the subject 11 acres of property is currently vacant but
was previously the site of a supermarket, drug store, and restaurant which have since been
demolished. She reported that the project is divided between commercial and residential
components and that the commercial use will front on South Palm Canyon Drive with the residential
use on the eastern portion of the site. She reported that the condominium buildings will include
four 12-unit buildings and, in addition, there will be 18 live/work unit lofts. She confirmed that the
project will be gated which will separate the commercial and residential traffic,that there will be two
levels of parking (at and below street level)and that the a proposed project exceeds parking space
requirements. She reported that construction of traffic calming measures into the Mesquite Avenue
neighborhood are intended to discourage through-traffic into that residential area. She reported
that the Design Review Committee supported the project's conceptual architecture and suggested
additional solar control on some elevations (to which the project architect was amenable to
reviewing).
Chairman Shoenberger opened the Public Hearing.
Ms. Linda Kearney addressed the Planning Commission to state that she is a homeowner on
Mesquite Avenue and is concerned regarding the ingress/egress of the proposed development as
the headlights from traffic will beam directly into her living room. She stated that, ideally, she would
like the Mesquite Avenue entry/exit eliminated; however, the developer has agreed to meet with
her to work on a solution (e.g. moving the entry/exit eastward to face what is currently a vacant lot).
She stated that she felt the proposed amendment and approved traffic calming measures for
Mesquite Avenue will be a benefit to the neighborhood. She supported the project architecture and
asked that no utility poles be allowed on or near Mesquite Avenue or Random Road,
Mr. Paul Trippen addressed the Planning Commission to state that he is also a property owner on
Mesquite Avenue and that he supports the proposed development; however, has concerns
regarding parking and asked that the Planning Commission not allow red curbs where there is
currently on-street parking allowed in this neighborhood. He stated that he hopes the lighting will
not be intrusive and asked that large foliage be used for landscape/street buffer.
Mr. John O'Hiltner addressed the Planning Commission to state that he owns two homes east of
Random Road and supports the proposed project, stating that the architecture is excellent. He
thanked staff for their helpfulness when he was researching and evaluating the project. He asked
Planning Commission to clarify pages 16 and 17 of the Traffic Study as the mid-day and p.m. peak
counts seem illogical. He asked that, from Random Road eastward, sidewalks be allowed to be
more narrow and have more landscape features, leaving the eight foot width for sidewalks from the
project entrance to South Palm Canyon Drive. He asked that the 9,500 lumen street lamp
proposed for the street corner be reconsidered and perhaps increased architectural entryway
lighting be used to supply necessary illumination. He asked that the City Engineer require the
developer to put in a stop light at the South Palm Canyon Drive entrance and that the stop light at
Mesquite Avenue and South Palm Canyon Drive be removed.
Mr. Tim Homeier, Chairman of the Deepwell Estates Neighborhood Organization, addressed the
Planning Commission to state that the City has worked for the past three years with the
fa4�v
Page 4 of 4 „<�7
Planning Commission Minutes
December 10, 2003
neighborhood to establish an appropriate traffic calming program. He stated that the neighborhood
has worked with the project architect for the past six months regarding Huddle Springs. He stated
that the architect and the City Engineer agreed to design a gateway at Mesquite Avenue into the
project and thanked the project architect. He stated that he supports the project and feels it is very
well designed and will be a benefit to the City.
Ms. Jessica Scarffe, Executive Director of the Palm Springs Economic Development Corporation,
addressed the Planning Commission to state that the PSEDC supports the project and has
submitted a letter to that effect to the City (on file in the Department of Planning and Zoning). She
stated that the by-right-of-zone project is particularly remarkable given its size and how well it fits
into the neighborhood. She stated that the dynamic,mixed use will be beneficial to the City, as well
as the site improvement. She stated that she felt the architecture is outstanding and incorporates
the design elements of historical Palm Springs well.
Mr. Jim Cioffi, project architect, addressed the Planning Commission to thank the neighborhood
members who attended today's meeting and stated that there have been a number of good,
productive neighborhood meetings on the project and that he thinks all neighborhood issues have
been addressed. He asked that the high-pressure sodium street light at Random Road and
Mesquite Avenue not be required due to glare problems and stated that a palm tree effect at
Random Road may be more effective, for example. He stated that the eight-foot wide sidewalk
from the driveway east on Mesquite Avenue is probably not necessary and added that, if the street
designation is downgraded, more landscaping and a sidewalk five feet in width may be preferable.
He confirmed that he will work with staff and property owners regarding the driveway alignment.
He stated that, as a resident of the subject neighborhood, he is proud to bring this project forward.
There being no further appearances, the Public Hearing was closed.
Commissioner Conrad asked Mr. Cioffi to return to the podium and asked him if any study has
been made of separating the residential and commercial entrances. Mr. Cioffi stated that he was
asked to not do that by the neighbors on Riverside and San Lorenzo, and that, due to left-hand turn
conflicts, a grading differential of 15 feet, and minimum setbacks for entrances, it was not possible.
He deferred traffic signal issues to the City Engineer.
Marcus Fuller, Senior Engineer, reported that, unfortunately, the City cannot remove a signalized
intersection after it has been constructed. He stated, however,that future development in the area
of South Palm Canyon Drive and Mesquite Avenue will utilize the existing traffic signal. He also
noted that, in the near future, traffic signals on Sunrise Way will be adjusted to make north-south
travel quicker and slow the east-west signals. He also confirmed that there is no redline curb
proposed and that there will be public parking in the street to the east of the entrance.
Director clarified that the future of the South Palm Canyon Drive area (e.g. Fairfield Resort
timeshare project, the Rock Garden Cafe, etc.) will create a more downtown-like feel to the area
and encourage more pedestrian activity.
M/S/C (Conrad/Grence 5-0, 1 abstention, 1 absent) to approve General Plan Amendment and
Planned Development District and Tentative Tract Map subject to Conditions of Approval in Staff
Report and;
i�
Page 5 of 4 �
Planning Commission Minutes
December 10, 2003
1. That mitigation is made regarding the driveway access with the property owner directly
across the street; and
2. That the intersection lighting improvements at Mesquite Avenue and Random Road will not
include a street light but will include adequate lighting for demarcating traffic calming
measures to the approval of the Director of Planning and Zoning; and
3. The sidewalk width on Mesquite Avenue shall be five feet from the entrance east to
Random Road and eight feet from the entrance west to South Palm Canyon Drive.
Commissioner Wright thanked the developer and architect for their work with the neighborhood.
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES
November 26, 2003
Council Chamber, City Hall
3200 East Tahquitz Canyon Way
Palm Springs, California 92262
ROLL CALL Present Present FY 03-04
This Meeting to Date Excused Absences
Jon Shoenberger, Chair X 11 0
Dianne Marantz, Vice Chair X 10 1
Mark Matthews X 10 1
Jerry Grence X 10 1
Tracy Conrad X 9 2
Ricky Wright X 11 0
Larry Hochanadel X 11 0
STAFF PRESENT:
Douglas R. Evans, Director of Planning & Zoning
Dave Barakian, City Engineer
Alex Meyerhoff, Principal Planner
Kathy Marx, Associate Planner
Matthew Feske, Assistant Planner
Gabriel Diaz, Assistant Planner
Michele Boyd, Administrative Coordinator
Chairman Shoenberger called the meeting to order at 1:35.m.
The November 26, 2003 agenda was available for public access at the City Hall exterior bulletin
board and the Department of Planning & Zoning counter by 4:00 p.m., November 21, 2003.
M/S/C (Matthews/Marantz 4-0, 3 abstentions) to approve the minutes of November 19, 2003 as
presented.
Page 2 of 8
Planning Commission Minutes !' .
November 26, 2003
Case 5.0977 — PD 288 —TTM 31887 —Application by John Wessman for an amendment to the
General Plan Circulation Plan to remove Cahuilla Road's designation as a collector roadway
between Ramon Road on the south and Tahquitz Canyon Way on the north, Zones R-2 & R-3,
Section 15; and
5.0977, PD 288—TTM 31887—Application by Wessman Developmentfora Planned Development
District and Tentative Tract Map to construct 38 condominium units for the property at 284 South
Cahuilla Road, Zones R-2 and R-3, Section 15.
Commissioner Marantz abstained due to a business conflict of interest.
Commissioner Hochanadel abstained due to a property ownership conflict of interest.
Commissioner Matthews abstained due to a property ownership conflict of interest.
Chairman Shoenberger abstained due to a property ownership conflict of interest.
Director reported that, under California state law, a drawing will be held to determine a Planning
Commission member to participate and for purposes of a quorum. Commissioner Marantz drew
the straw.
Commissioners Hochanadel, Matthew, and Shoenberger left the meeting.
Kathy Marx, Associate Planner reviewed the site plan for the Planning Commission and reported
that in 1972 the subject portion of the wash was determined not buildable so the existing easement
was vacated. She reported that, as part of its 2002 approval to allow the applicant to pave the
roadway to allow for construction travel further up the hillside, the Planning Commission required
that a trail easement be dedicated. She clarified that the applicant has had the trail surveyed by
a trail consultant and has submitted it to the City Attorney. She reviewed maps showing trail
location and access and site plan and location of retaining walls. She reported that a
nonconforming, illegal structure located in the wash would be determined unsafe in flood
conditions. She reported that there have been inquiries regarding the proposed project from the
neighborhood and that staff has met with several neighbors to answer questions. She reported
there is some concern from an adjacent property owner regarding a potential structural impact to
his wall and that the applicant has agreed to lower the proposed wall height at the intersection by
two feet and step up to the existing house's wall. She reported that another concern expressed
is the narrowing of the channel and potential hydrological impacts (e.g. swifter water with less flow)
and that the applicant has had a hydrological study prepared which indicates construction of riprap
�p-A�
Page 3 of 8
Planning Commission Minutes � i'
November 26, 2003
U
on the north and west of the channel to act as a slowing mechanism, which mitigates any impact
downhill to negligible. She reported that another neighborhood concern was access to and parking
for the hiking trail. She confirmed that there is enough existing right-of-way to allow sufficient
parking for hikers.
Director reported that the only properties that take access from the subject roadway are that of the
applicant and his neighbor, Mr. Ealy, who is in support of the application. He noted that the City
does take access at this location but has an easement which would not be amended by approval
of the subject application. He clarified that, currently, the public walks on Camino Monte and goes
onto a private road to access Lykken Trail and that there are no easements for the walkway to the
trail and that, as part of the application, construction of a new trail that will provide legal access for
hikers, designed by the Desert Riders trail consultant, will begin. He clarified that Condition No.9
should be amended from approval by the City Attorney to approval by the City Council. He noted
that Condition No. 10 should be amended to add, "trail be constructed prior to final vacation of the
roadway" in order to assure continuous access for the public.
Chairman Shoenberger invited public comments.
Mr. John Wessman, applicant, addressed the Planning Commission to state that this has been a
very difficult situation. He stated that, six years ago, he bought 33 acres and sold one lot to Mr.
Ealy. He stated that people had walked up that roadway for years; however, there exists no
prescriptive easement because it was City property. He stated that, due to the Planning
Commission requirement to provide a trail, he discussed with the neighbor on Camino Descanso;
however,that property owner would not allow the easement. Instead, he stated that he purchased
the property from that neighbor. He stated that he will work with the City to construct a trail into the
wash on Camino Descanso and that he filed a lot line adjustment and plans to sell the recently
purchased house. He stated that he would not raise the level of the wall because it is a garden
wall.
Mr. Franklin Burns, addressed the Planning Commission to state that he owns the property directly
north of the Camino Descanso property and would like the property improved by modifying the wall.
He stated that the wall will have some impact on the naturalness of the area but that six feet in
height is acceptable. He stated that he was concerned regarding hydrology impacts and, although
the hydrology report indicates no impact, he still has some concern.
Mr. Wessman clarified that the wall starts at 6' on easterly boundary but, as it goes west it steps
and will have riprap at bottom.
Mr.Mark Matthews,addressed the Planning Commission to commend the applicant on his flexibility
in working with the neighborhood and trail users. He stated that this trail is on the earliest maps
recorded in Palm Springs and is the sole access to Lykken trail so is essential to keep the trail
access. He thanked the applicant for a terrific solution.
There were no further appearances.
Commissioner Conrad asked staff to address having the trail go through the wash.
"WO-/T e-2
f r..
Page 4of 8 -�; ;i��
Planning Commission Minutes '^ .
November 26, 2003
Director reported that, as it comes off of Camino Monte, a sloped traverse traditional hillside trail,
the bottom of the trail will be a combination of riprap and flat wash and then creep back up into
hillside—having only 100-150 feet on the soft wash bottom and then directly into rocks. He stated
that, at the Waterfall point(if flowing), hikers would need to work up and around. He confirmed that
the trail consultant (who is the same consultant as the Desert Riders use) will evaluate that fairly
narrow trail. He stated that there is a gate on the private property and a trail sign and most people
are very careful to stay on trails unless they get lost.
M/S/C (Conrad/Grence 4-0, 3 abstentions) to approve subject to Conditions of Approval and to
amend Condition No. 9 to require City Council approval and Condition No. 10 to be amended to
add, "trail be constructed prior to final vacation of the roadway."
Director thanked the neighborhood for their patience on the project and the applicant for
successfully managing such a challenging and expensive solution.
Commissioners Hochanadel, Shoenberger, and Matthews returned to the meeting.
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES ` ��1� .,,il I���•
November 12, 2003
Council Chamber, City Hall
3200 East Tahquitz Canyon Way
Palm Springs, California 92262
ROLL CALL Present Present FY 03-04
This Meeting to Date Excused Absences
Jon Shoenberger, Chair X 9 0
Dianne Marantz, Vice Chair X 8 1
Mark Matthews X 8 1
Jerry Grence 8 1
Tracy Conrad X 7 2
Ricky Wright X 9 0
Larry Hochanadel X 9 0
STAFF PRESENT:
Douglas R. Evans, Director of Planning & Zoning
Dave Barakian, City Engineer
Alex Meyerhoff, Principal Planner
Jing Yeo, Principal Planner
Kathy Marx, Associate Planner
Gabriel Diaz, Assistant Planner
Michele Boyd, Administrative Coordinator
w w w w w
Chairman Shoenberger called the meeting to order at 1:37 p.m.
w w w w w
The October 08, 203 agenda was available for public access at the City Hall exterior bulletin board
and the Department of Planning &Zoning counter by 4:00 p.m., November 07, 2003.
w w w w w
M/S/C (Marantz/Hochanadel 6-0, 1 absent) to approve the minutes of September 24, 2003 as
submitted.
w w w w w
;P/4 07
Page 6 of 8
Planning Commission Minutes
November 12, 2003
Case 5.0965 —Application by the City of Palm Springs for a Mitigated Negative Declaration and
an amendment to the General Plan Circulation Element to reclassify Mesquite Avenue between El
Cielo Road and Vella Road from a Secondary Thoroughfare to a Special Collector, and associated
landscape, traffic calming, drainage improvements, General Policy 7.1.5 is also proposed to be
amended to clarify the definition of"special street sections" and to add Policy 7.1.5.a. "Mesquite
Avenue Special Street Section" and approval of a revised street improvement plan, Section 19.
Director reported that the Planning Commission has reviewed the proposed General Plan
Amendment several times at Study Session and has had public testimony from neighborhood
residents. He stated that the Engineering Department has amended the proposed street
improvement plans approximately six times in order to most adequately address safety and
circulation concerns.
Jing Yeo, Principal Planner, reviewed exhibits of the proposed improvements which will provide
traffic calming in the Mesquite Avenue area.
Chairman Shoenberger opened the Public Hearing.
Mr. Richard L. Goulet addressed the Planning Commission to state that he is a Mesquite Avenue
resident and has been at every meeting the City has held for the past 2.5 years regarding these
street improvements. He stated that he is happy that the plan will address the ongoing and severe
safety concerns evident in this location and thanked staff and the Planning Commission for their
work on the project. He stated that,for safety sake, he hopes the project will move forward quickly.
Mr. Pat Doan addressed the Planning Commission to state that he is a Mesquite Avenue resident
and that he is also hopeful that improvements will be made immediately due to safety concerns.
There being no further appearances, the Public Hearing was closed.
Dave Barakian, City Engineer reported that the project design has been underway for some time
and that staff is working on an RFP with hopes that a contract can be awarded in time to begin
improvements in Summer 2004.
M/S/C (Wright/Marantz 6-0, 1 absent) to approve the proposed General Plan Amendment, street
plans, and order filing of a mitigated negative declaration. Final review and approval by the
Director of Planning and Zoning and City Engineer of landscape, irrigation, signage, and drainage
details.
IPAP9
No.6446 - --- - -- - - -- -
,,". `PAi NOTICE OF CITY COUNCIL MEETING
"/°�® 47 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
Pursuant to Section 21000 et.seq. of the Public �jf1 CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
Resources Code and Section 15063 of the Cali- rrn q
forts Environmental Quality Act, Mitigated Nega- Qr� 4[ General Plan Circulation Element Amendments
five Dr-Nitrations have been prepared for Case P�.h ad/y A) Case No. 5 0956 GPA, City of Palm Springs
Nos 5.0956 GPA, 5,0965 GPA, and 5.0977 GPA °7ce,p'�-,°zp�
and will be reviewed by the City Council at the �V--� Mesquite Avenue between South Palm Canyon
meeting Members of the public c may view the `'• �f, Drive and Random Read
documents m the Department of Planning and ti,-� ^(-, BI Case No. 5.0965 GPA, Qt of Palm S�rin s
Zoning, City
Hall, 3200E Tahquitz Canyon Way, °�. =1 'C�'' M y g
Palm Springs, and submit written comments to -- -- esqude Avenue between EI Cielo Roa and
the Ctty Clerk at or pi ror to the City Council hear- Vella Road
mg. C)) Case 5.0977 GPA, City of Palm Springs
The proposed General Plan Amendment Informa- Cahwila Road between To pull Canyon Way
tion and related documents are also available for and Raman Road
Public review Monday through Fnday, between 8
a.m.and 5 P.M.at the City of Palm Springs Plan- I NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council
ning and Zoning Department, located at 3200 E. of the City of Palm Springs, Califoi old, will hold a I
Tahquitz Canyon Way. public hearing at its meeting of December 17,
2003. The City Council public hearing meeting
If any Individual or group challenges the action in UTT T!', A TTO1�T begins at 7;00 p.m. in the City Council Chamber
court, issues raised may be limited to only those ALlCATI 1\ - at City Hall, 3200 E.Tahquitz Canyon Way, Palm
issues raised at the public hearings described in Springs, California
this notice or in written correspondence at or pri-ll " 1 C' Pl The purpose of the hearing is to consider:ar to the City Council meeting.An opportunity wi
be given at said hearings to, all interested per- A) Case 6.0956 GPA a request by Huddle
sons to he heard. Springs Development,GPA,
for an amendment to
Questions regarding Case Nos. 5.0956 and the General Plan Circulation Map to reclassify
50965 may be directed to Jing Yea, Princippal Mesquite Avenue between South Palm Canyon
Planner and questions iagarding Case No. 5.0977 I Drive and Random Road from a secondary thor-
may be directed to Kathy Marx, Associate Plan- oughfare to a collector street.The collector street
ner, DepPartment of Planning 8, Zoning, (760) will match existing street Improvements on Mes-
323-8245. quite Avenue with a right-cf-way width of 60 feet
and a street width of 40 feet with 2 travel lanes;
PATRICIA A. SANDERS I and
City Clerk B Case 5.0965 GPA, a request initiated b the
PUB: November 27, 2003 'A ) 9 Y
-----. City ra Palm Springs for an amendment to the
Cetinty of Riversi;lc - -General Plan Circulation Map o reclassify Mes-
coad Avefrom a Secoween thoroughfare
Cielroug Road and Vella.
Road from tr secondary thoroughfare Plan
n special
collector street, to clarify General Plan Policy
with regards to "special street program',
and t
and is add a new General Plan Polley 7"..The
aecia Re Avenue Special Street Program".The
special collector street will allow the existing
right wtf way width of 88 feet to be maintained
and will consist of an up to 60 foot wide street
I am a citizen of the United States and a resident of width with two travel lanes, a 12 foot wide land-
scaped median,and a frontage road abutting De-
the County aforesaid; I am over the age of eighteen muth Park on the south side of Mesquite Avenue;
and
years,and not a party to or interested in the - —--
CJ Case 5.0977 GPA, a request by Wessman De-
above-entitled matter.I am the principal clerk of a veto
Goupment Conrpan for anp amendment to the
printer of the,DESERT SUN PUBLISHING s Road between uT hquitNanyon Way and Ra-
COMPANY a newspaper of general circulation, iron Road from a collector street to a local street.
The local street will consist of a riffht-of-way width
printed and published in the city of Palm Springs, of 45 feet and a street width of 36 feet with two
travel lanes,each 18 feet wide.This street section
County of Riverside,and which newspaper has been will only apply where Cahuilla Road abuts the
adjudged a newspaper of general circulation by the proposed development.
Superior Court of the County of Riverside,State of VICINITY MAP "
California under the date of March 24, 1988.Case
Number 191236;that the notice,of which the
annexed is a printed copy(set in type not smaller i A "
than non pmriel,has been published in each regular
and entire issue of said newspaper and not in any 'i
supplement thereof on the following dates,to wit:
November 27"' - - -
- cm or Pum rreiH�s -
All in the year 2003 -
I certify(or declare)under penalty of perjury that the VICIINTYMAP
foregoing is true and correct.
1"
Dated at Palm Springs,California this--------day
of----------December-----------------------------2003
gl�L
Signature
non:winos
VICINITY MAP 1
g q.
I.. Y
n
Ati"m
' Na.6102 -
ti!i,l CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
NOTICE OF PLANNING COMMISSION
MEETING
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
Case No. 5.0965 GPA
Mesquite Avenue Traffic Calming Project
between El Claus Road and Vella Road
Applicant: City of Palm Springs
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Planning
PROOF OF PUBLICATION Commission of the of hearing at itsnmeetinlg oof nia, will hold a public
November 12, 2003 The Planning Commission
(201 5.5 C.! P meeting begins at 1.30 p m. Public Hearings be-
1J J 11.. ) gin at 2:00 ppm) in the City ounel Chamber at
City Hall, 3200 E Tahqutz Canyon Way, Palm
Springs, Callfornia
The ppurpese of the hearing is to consider an ap-
plicatJon initiated by the City of Palm Springs for
an amendment to the General Plan - Circulation
Element to downgrade Mesquite Avenue, be-
tween El Cielo Road and Vella Read,from a sec-
ondary Thoroughfare to a Special Collector desig-
nation. This designation would allow the existing
dt h right-of-way wiof 88 feet be maintained and
the widening of Mesquite Avaou between Mann-
STATE OF CALIFORNIA tarn View Drive andAvehida Li Evelita to con-
Count of Riverside struct a special street section consisting of two
Y e through traffic lanes (one in each direction) sepa-
rated by a 12-foot wide raised, landscaped medi-
an, antl a one-way local park access road with
lnrrallel parking. The designation would also al-
ow narrowed pavement 'chokers", curb "pop-
outs" and other traffic calming improvements,
landscaping improvements; and storm dram im-
provements.
General Policy 71.5. is also proposed to be
I alit a citizen of the United States and a resident of amended to clarify the definition of'special street
programs". This clarification/definition of "special
the County aforesaid; I am over the age of eighteen street programs" will allow greater flexibility for
special pavement sections to be achieved and
years,and not a party to or Interested In the still be consistent with the General Plan. A new
above-entitled matter.I am the principal cleric of a General Plan Policy 1.1.5.a "Mesquite AvenueSpecial street Program" will also be created to
printer of the,DESERT SUN PUBLISHING provide a reference to the proposed project
COMPANY a newspaper of general circulation, The City intends to implement Line,22 and a par-
don of Line 21 of the Master Drainage Plan for
printed and published in the city of Pallas Springs, the Palm Springs Area, dated November 1982,
County of Riverside,and Which newspaper has been W
prepared by Riverside County Flood Control and
ater Conservation District.Vim drain improve-
adjudged a newspaper of general circulation by the ments nelude new catch basins, storm drain lat-
c als to collect and convey stormwater runoff
Superior Court of the County of Riverside,State of from various intersecting streets along Meaqulte
Avenue, through a 66" tliameter storm drain that
California under the dale of March 24, 1988.Case will convey runoff south to the Tahquitz Creek
through an outlet structure to be located within
Number 191236; that the notice,of which the the existing Palm Sprigs municipal golf course,
annexed Is a tinted co (set in type not Smaller !in m ediately upstream from the Gene Autry Trail
p copy( yP I bridge across the Tam itz Creek.
than non pariel,has been published in each regular
and entire issue of said newspaper and not in any VlbV/VTYMAP
supplement thereof on the following dates,to wit:
tT�
October 23i° I
-- --- -------- `--
- '
' J
All in the year 2003
I certify(or declare)under penalty of perjury that the
foregoing is true and correct.
24a1 �i,v oFPasssisv=
Dated at Palm Springs,California this---------day I
Pursuant to Section 15063 of the California Envi-
ronmental Quality Act, an Environmental Assess-
of -OClober -12003 merit has been prepared and be reviewed by
the Planning Commission at the meeting. A draft
— Mitigated Negative Declaration
of Environmental
Impact has been prepared for the subject proper-
al.
Members of the public may view this docu-
ment docu
merit in the Department of Planning and Zoning,
City Hall, 3200 E. Taliquitz Canyon Way, Palm
Signature Springs, and submit written comments at or pnor
to the Planning Commission hearing.
If any group challenges the action in court, issues
raised may be limited to only those Issues raised
at the public hearing described in this notice or in
written correspondence at, or prior to the Plan-
ning Commission hearing.
An will
nterested persons ns toebei heard-Questions ven at said hearing
eggor all
ard-
ig this case mayy be directed to Jing Yen,Asso-
ciate Palmer, (760) 323-8245.
PLANNING COMMISSION
/a/Douglas R Evans
Dlr r P ring er lug'
S13
40 slslo
77
pes
C,y �,r
_ 92162
680
AF��✓? O"3
aL A '�
hsorcall�Sa°la��
a
G
�lgS Cq�22 rlloh2aJe2
680
A83 ep��3O F
OS, I
a�s�Ue also G,
I
680
S
A39 Ord clj 011
Oe
aJ�`�F�es94oer
�das ICE
C" 9pE
680
Geo S2S
-9J3 fge OOF
a
o Leg r Jr
Arid st
ds Cad
5 r
9�26F
6�10
S
h06 2F
I3S9 oe't TIOJ>
Sir"7 Z?0
s C 9 °se
6y
508 162 008 1 q ti
Valorienodgert
412 Lemon Grove Ln -'
Santa Barbara, CA 9;1u
31lQ=
:a i:)e'30a:'^_- -p SEND
j ODGL-GtDi"d i�WTS fp,4A17 R'959u
ig26 �S hlk�.�- CA 93�+ram
SANiA SENDER
Rc='ruRD,1 'ro
�80143 013
pa 6S g, Srei
a
SArm� C�19226¢
Bj ti' o
eC }
923�s
680
3 BchQOr 003
A ! ha
aJ'b,n C'�'has�
o
92�S�Gel
st
T
Y�NO SUCH INUM5'C A U DECEASED �d0
f0 flT'I'PP^.:'i;_L7 N0; �,n;C�YVra U VACANT Q. I3
Q INSUP'i'L1L`CIv f At PRESS 0 EFUSED
,$44101 AS ADDRCBSED
UNABLC'c PDHW ID
680 153 014 h bs
Romue Hallett 922 Ala
16234 Bellflower Blvd#11 sg
Bellflower,CA 90706
_ - 680522007
00
M41k ?
'03 E1 reSs &
P P1$ ace N ablh ce S!rinocr pd eyVjna.
gs, CA
680 522 0
ell avid Gehrke
5229 venida Her era
La rota, 92253
«��: J SENDER LQ
S1v�136009
41' n s0hla4 Villas
o C g's°w St
2
201
AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING
STATE OF CALIFORNIA )
COUNTY OF RIVERSIDE )
I, the undersigned, say: I am and was at all times herein mentioned, a citizen of the United States and
employed in the County of Riverside,overthe age of eighteen years,and not a party to the within action
or proceeding; that my business address is 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Drive, Palm Springs, California;
that on the 23`d day of October, 2003, 1 served the within NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING for
PLANNING COMMISSION CASE NO. 5. 0965 to consider an application initiated by the City of Palm
Springs for an amendment to the General Plan--Circulation Element to downgrade Mesquite Avenue,
between EI Cielo Road and Vella Road from a secondary thoroughfare to a special collector
designation to allow the existing right-of-way width of 88 feet to be maintained and the widening of
Mesquite Avenue between Mountain View Drive and Avenida La Evelita to construct a special street
section consisting of two through traffic lanes(one in each direction)separated by a 12 foot wide raised,
landscaped median,and a one-way local park access road with parallel parking. The designation would
also allow narrowed pavement "chokers" curb "pop-outs" and other traffic calming improvements;
landscaping improvements; and storm drain improvements.
This Notice was served on persons contained in Exhibit"A"attached hereto in said action or proceeding
by depositing a true copy thereof, enclosed in a sealed envelope with postage thereon fully prepaid, in
a mailbox, sub-post office, substation or mail chute, or other like facility, regularly maintained by the
Government of the United States in the City of Palm Springs,California, addressed to the list of persons
or firms indicated on the report received from the title company dated October 16,2003 and certified by
the City's Planning Technician, and attached hereto as Exhibit"A".
I hereby declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Loretta D. Moffett
Dated at Palm Springs, California, this27th day of October, 2003.
Public Hearing Notices Notification Information
for Planning Commission Hearing on November 12, 2003
Case No. 5.0965
Applicant Name: City of Palm Springs
Address 3200 E Tahquitz Canyon Way
Palm Springs, CA 92262
Project Location & Mesquite Avenue between El Cielo Road and Vella Road
Description: General Plan Amendment to reclassify Mesquite Avene Between El
Cielo Road and Vella Road frm a secondary to a special collector;
Clarification of Policy 7.1.5 various traffic calming measures,
landscape and storm drain improvements; implementation of Line 22
of the Master Drainage Plan for the Palm Springs area.
Assigned Planner: Jing Yeo, Principal Planner
Labels Prepared by: Yoav Shernock, Planning Technician
Certification to
City Clerk Date: November 21, 2003
Property Owners / Groups / Date Notices Number of Notices
Organizations Mailed Mailed
Applicant/Sponsors October 23, 2003 1
Property Owners:
Land Owner (master lessor) October 23, 2003 593
Master Lessor (sub-lessor)
Sub-lessee (unit owner)
Indian Land Owners N/A
Neighborhood Coalition October 23, 2003 9
Homeowners Association N/A
ONIPP N/A
Agua Caliente Band of October 23, 2003 1
Cahuilla Indians Rep
City Rep for Verification October 23, 2003 1
Public Agencies - IS or EA October 23, 2003 18
Other Interested Parties- InternalEAs October 23, 2003 1 6
TOTAL NUMBER MAILED: 629
O ?�
City of Palm Springs
Department of Planning &Zoning
�LIFOR�
MEMORANDUM
Date: October 24, 2003
From: Yoav Shernock
Planning Technician
Subject: Mailing Labels for Notice of Public Hearing
Planning Commission Case No. 5.0965, November 12, 2003
City of Palm Springs - Mesquite Traffic Calming
This is to certify that the attached labels were created on October 16, 2003 using the most current
information available. To the best of my knowledge, the labels are complete and accurate.
441
Yoaav Shernock, Planning Technician
October 24, 2003
Adm
RESOLUTION NO.
OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS,
CALIFORNIA, APPROVING AMENDMENTS TO THE GENERAL
PLAN CIRCULATION ELEMENT AS FOLLOWS:
(A)5,0956-A REQUEST BY HUDDLE SPRINGS DEVELOPMENT,
LLC FOR AN AMENDMENT TO THE GENERAL PLAN
CIRCULATION MAP TO RECLASSIFY MESQUITE AVENUE
BETWEEN SOUTH PALM CANYON DRIVE AND RANDOM ROAD
FROM A SECONDARY THOROUGHFARE TO A COLLECTOR
STREET; AND
(B) 5.0965 - A REQUEST INITIATED BY THE CITY OF PALM
SPRINGS FOR AN AMENDMENT TO THE GENERAL PLAN
CIRCULATION MAP TO RECLASSIFY MESQUITE AVENUE
BETWEEN EL CIELO ROAD AND VELLA ROAD FROM A
SECONDARY THOROUGHFARE TO A SPECIAL COLLECTOR
STREET, TO CLARIFY GENERAL PLAN POLICY 7.1.5. WITH
REGARDS TO "SPECIAL STREET PROGRAM", AND TO ADD A
NEW GENERAL PLAN POLICY 7.1.5.A. "MESQUITE AVENUE
SPECIAL STREET PROGRAM"; AND
(C) 5.0977 - A REQUEST BY WESSMAN DEVELOPMENT
COMPANY FOR AN AMENDMENT TO THE GENERAL PLAN
CIRCULATION MAP TO RECLASSIFY CAHUILLA ROAD
BETWEEN TAHQUITZ CANYON WAYAND RAMON ROAD FROM
A COLLECTOR STREET TO A LOCAL STREET.
WHEREAS, Huddle Springs Development, LLC (the "applicant') has filed Case 5.0956 for an
amendment to the General Plan Circulation Element so as to reclassify Mesquite Avenue between
South Palm Canyon Drive and Random Road from a secondary thoroughfare to a collector street;
and
WHEREAS,the City of Palm Springs(the"applicant')has initiated Case 5.0965 for an amendment
to the General Plan Circulation Element so as to reclassify Mesquite Avenue between El Cielo
Road and Vella Road from a secondary thoroughfare to a special collector street, clarify General
Plan Policy 7.1.5. with regards to "special street program", and add a new General Plan Policy
7.1.5.a. "Mesquite Avenue Special Street Program"; and
WHEREAS, Wessman Development Company (the "applicant') has filed Case 5.0977 for an
amendment to the General Plan Circulation Element so as to reclassify Cahuilla Road between
Tahquitz Canyon Way and Ramon Road from a collector street to a local street; and
WHEREAS, notice of a public hearing of the Planning Commission of the City of Palm Springs to
consider Case Nos. 5.0956, 5.0965, and 5.0977, requests to amend the General Plan Circulation
Element, was given in accordance with applicable law; and
I � I�
WHEREAS, on November 12, 2003 a public hearing to consider Case 5.0965, a request to amend
the General Plan Circulation Element, was held by the Planning Commission in accordance with
applicable law; and
WHEREAS, on November 26, 2003, a public hearing to consider Case 5.0977, request to amend
the General Plan Circulation Element, was held by the Planning Commission in accordance with
applicable law; and
WHEREAS, on December 10, 2003, a public hearing to consider Case 5.0956, request to amend
the General Plan Circulation Element, was held by the Planning Commission in accordance with
applicable law; and
WHEREAS, notice of a public hearing of the City Council of the City of Palm Springs to consider
Case Nos. 5.0956, 5.0965, and 5.0977, requests to amend the General Plan Circulation Element,
was given in accordance with applicable law; and
WHEREAS, on December 17, 2003 a public hearing to consider Case Nos. 5.0956, 5.0965, and
5.0977, requests to amend the General Plan Circulation Element, was held by the City Council in
accordance with applicable law; and
WHEREAS, in accordance with Section 15063 of the California Environmental Quality Act, an
Environmental Assessments have been prepared forthe proposed General Plan Amendments and
have been distributed for public review and comment in accordance with CEQA; and
WHEREAS, the City Council has carefully reviewed and considered all of the evidence presented
in connection with the hearing on the project, including but not limited to the staff report, all written
and oral testimony presented.
THE CITY COUNCIL HEREBY FINDS AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1: Pursuant to CEQA, the City Council finds that the current environmental
assessments for Case Nos. 5.0956, 5.0965, and 5.0977 adequately address the
general environmental setting of the proposed Project, its significant environmental
impacts, and the mitigation measures related to each significant environmental
effect for the proposed project. The City Council further finds that with the
incorporation of proposed mitigation measures, potentially significant environmental
impacts resulting from this project will be reduced to a level of insignificance and
therefore recommends adoption of a Mitigated Negative Declaration forthe project.
Section 2: With regards to Case 5.0956, the proposed project is to amend the General Plan -
Circulation Element in order to reclassify Mesquite Avenue between South Palm
Canyon Drive and Random Road from a secondary thoroughfare to a collector
street. Mesquite Avenue is currently improved to collector street standards at this
location with a 60 foot right-of-way and a 40 foot wide pavement width. A secondary
thoroughfare would require an 80 to 88 foot right-of-way with a pavement width of
64 feet. Mesquite Avenue east of Random Road is already designated a collector
street and traverses a single family residential neighbourhood. Due to the need to
transition from a commercial to residential uses, downgrading Mesquite Avenue at
this location will contribute to the overall traffic calming program currently being
proposed and implemented in the Deepwell/Tahquitz River Estates neighbourhood.
The traffic study completed for the associated Huddle Springs project also shows
that there is no need to improve Mesquite to secondary thoroughfare standards
because a collector street could support the projected traffic volume.
Section 3: With regards to Case 5.0965, the proposal is to amend the General Plan —
Circulation Element to downgrade Mesquite Avenue, between El Cielo Road and
Vella Road, from a Secondary Thoroughfare to a Special Collector designation.
This designation would allow the existing right-of-way width of 88 feet to be
maintained and the widening of Mesquite Avenue between Mountain View Drive and
Avenida La Evelita to construct a special street section consisting of two through
traffic lanes (one in each direction)separated by a 12-foot wide raised, landscaped
median, and a one-way local park access road with parallel parking.
Traffic calming features will be implemented to encourage low-speed,thus deterring
through travel. Commuters that use Mesquite Avenue for through travel will seek
other paths of travel that are designed to accommodate these movements more
efficiently.
The proposed General Plan Amendment will also improve local access between the
residential community and the recreational land uses to the south of Mesquite
Avenue, reduce roadway capacity, and discourage high speed commuter traffic.
This portion of Mesquite Avenue is adjacent to Palm Springs Youth Center and
Demuth Park. Special design and control features would be incorporated in the
improvement plan to define, enhance and reinforce the local-access character of
Mesquite Avenue. The proposed improvements would provide an "inner" and
"outer" roadway on the south side of Mesquite Avenue in order to separate Focal
activities, parking, land use and future bicycle and transit facilities, and other traffic
on Mesquite.
Section 4: With regards to Case 5.0977, the amendment to the General Plan Circulation
Element is being requested in conjunction with PD-288 and TTM 31887, a request
to construct 38 condominium units. To remove Cahuilla Road's designation as a
collector roadway between Ramon Road and Tahquitz Canyon Way will reduce the
right-of-way from sixty(60)feet to fifty (50)feet. The narrowed roadway will allow
bay parking on the west side of Cahuilla Road at the 284 Cahuilla Road location
and a modified street design. The bay parking proposed is consistent with other
bay parking areas for both single-family residences and multi-family residences
within the area pertinent to this General Plan amendment request and is consistent
with the General Plan objective of providing an adequate supply of on and off street
parking for residential parking needs and to overcome perceived deficiencies in
existing facilities.The modified design consists of decorative paverfive(5)foot wide
pedestrian walkways separated from the bay parking by a two foot planter.
Additionally, in response to neighborhood concerns,this amendment to the General
Plan Circulation Element to remove Cahuilla Road's designation as a collector
roadway from Ramon Road to Tahquitz Canyon Waywill allow for a narrower street
section that will aide in traffic calming. General Plan policy 7.4.1 indicates that the
modification of internal traffic patterns is a method of accomplishing that objective.
Section 5: The proposed amendments to the General Plan are necessary and proper at this
time, and are not likely to be detrimental to the adjacent property or residents.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that, based upon the foregoing, the City Council hereby
approves the amendments to the General Plan Circulation Element as shown in Exhibits A, B, C,
and D.
ADOPTED THIS_day of , 2003.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
ABSTENTIONS:
ATTEST: CITY OF PALM SPRINGS, CALIFORNIA
City Clerk City Manager
Reviewed and Approved as to Form:
EXHIBIT A
PROPOSED GENERAL PLAN CIRCULATION MAP AMENDMENT
MESQUITE AVENUE BETWEEN SOUTH PALM CANYON DRIVE AND RANDOM ROAD
, -• • , •-- is '—�- ra w � IS I I r
66D 0 K Nas" M
tS G4
44 44
4G
, SUNNY DUNl6
AC R
M/
�$ 40 K4i/si c4 4
I
AC MIS 44
c
I c4
al
E TRY to 4 r be reclassified,from secondary thoroughfare to collector street
Iw y
{-.
Afqk
V L* A.4 i h
RL /'
cRG 5J4 c4lp� jc
#43/21
vl c S`
f �-
r
EXHIBIT $
PROPOSED GENERAL PLAN CIRCULATION MAP AMENDMENT
MESQUITE AVENUE BETWEEN EL CIELO ROAD AND VELLA ROAD
Al I
MIA
——— ———— NCC —�
7 ' b MIS "-- I
1
sl I
44 FR /No j IND
I A4 I3 A
—�uN12 I Cuw
I
IR IW 4(o 44 IW a I
w I Aw M
\ I
I to be reclassified from secondary thoroughfare to special collector(88•.dw)
PrR /
44
I/ar I A4
EXHIBIT C
PROPOSED GENERAL PLAN POLICY AMENDMENT
GENERAL PLAN POLICY 7.1.5. AND 7.1.5.A.
7.1.5. Cross-section standards may be modified by the Planning Commission and/or City Council
to take into consideration the need for special right-of-way widths, street improvements, or
pavement widths: where property cannot be feasibly acquired and/orwithin the downtown
to facilitate traffic calming and public parking facilities and/or where the street will scar the
landscape due to the nature of the terrain and/or the nattire of the terrain through whicfithe
street passes to prevent scarring of the landscap's to create area needed to provide linear
parks, bicycle or other alternative transportation facilities and/or achieve an urban design
and special street program such as traffic calming programs, pedestrian oriented
streetscapes bike or alternative transportation paths, and/or other coordinated programs
as proposed; or in response to a specific plan or planned development district. In addition,
the determination of the Planning Commission and/or City Council shall conclude that there
are no significant impacts to health, safety, and welfare of the residents of Palm Springs.
7.1.5.a. Mesquite Avenue Special Street Program - Mesquite Avenue between El
Cielo Road and Vella Road shall be designated a special collector street
with a right-of-way width of 88 feet and a pavement width of up to 60 feet
with two travel lanes one in each direction, a frontage road, and a parking
lane. A 12-foot wide landscaped median shall separate the through traffic
lanes from the new frontage road on the south side of Mesquite Avenue
abutting Demuth Park.Various traffic calming measures such as curb"pop
outs" "chokers" and channelization shall be implemented in orderto reduce
traffic speed and discourage through traffic while creating a more pedestrian
friendly street character.
EXHIBIT D
PROPOSED GENERAL PLAN CIRCULATION MAP AMENDMENT
CAHUILLA ROAD BETWEEN TAHOUITZ CANYON WAY AND RAMON ROAD
� y
j„. TMlAR15K Rp, i
Cc4e4. `IF cl G �f wI�E ._ Yu� p i l~l ) I F 4 49/j0 4s Flo I- . 4s%jo �� lg � � I ' c °lp g c RC W 40/0N i N•J�/s05 I Rc 0150 I N4.t/!o U � I G' G ANs 16
1 • G fzc Rc K4s/so
P fa a r RG XC f
_ Ncc
X A' % /� RC RG RG I ftG RC
�, 7 0 ' n G * o a0 N�3js0 114s/7o f,
C N' W ff4►/so Cyr ryq ARENgb �) Ita,
c o c �wfs/iora -- —�J Ht�lsa �f/sa M
En0 430 I lW S
a p F', 1 c sSrvwNa N43lJO ' I
c f
fi I , c ` 44a1/3o H4s/160 1>•
N w I�
0 o I��' 0 ! o • A 431/ajjo _ 3
0 0, . ' 1 0 f I H421so I ,s 114xio M ado M NCG 1
8N
C•0 o K N!S M MfSy Mif v)
44 r--- ^--
Q ?ALM Sp
City of Palm Springs
* * Department of Planning& Building
ti
* COR,ORAiEO�4 * 3200 Tahqu¢z Canyon Way• Palm Springs,California 92262
TEL:(760)323-8245 • FAX(760)322-8360 •TDD(760)864-9527
MEMORANDUM
From: Director of Planning and Zoning
To: Distribution
Subject: Notice of Availability of an Initial Study/Environmental Assessment that evaluates an application
initiated by the City of Palm Springs for: an amendment to the General Plan — Circulation Element
to reclassify Mesquite Avenue, between El Cielo Road and Vella Road, from a Secondary
Thoroughfare to a Special Collector Street; an amendment to General Plan Policy 7.1.5. to clarify
the definition of "special street programs"; the addition of General Plan Policy 7.1.5.a. "Mesquite
Avenue Special Street Section"; and associated landscape, traffic calming, and storm drain
improvements.
The City of Palm Springs has prepared an Initial Study/ Environmental Assessment (IS/EA), which evaluates a
proposal to amend the General Plan — Circulation Element to reclassify Mesquite Avenue, between El Cielo Road
and Vella Road, from a Secondary Thoroughfare to a Special Collector designation. This designation would allow
the existing right-of-way width of 88 feet be maintained and the widening of Mesquite Avenue between Mountain
View Drive and Avenida La Evelita to construct a special street section consisting of two through traffic lanes (one
in each direction) separated by a 12-foot wide raised, landscaped median, and a one-way local park access road
with parallel parking. The designation would also allow narrowed pavement "chokers", curb "pop-outs' and other
traffic calming improvements; landscaping improvements; and storm drain improvements.
The second request is a proposal to amend General Plan Policy 7.1.5. to clarify the definition of "special street
programs". This clarification/definition of "special street programs' will allow greater flexibility for special pavement
sections to be achieved and still be consistent with the General Plan. A new General Plan Policy 7.1.5.a. "Mesquite
Avenue Special Street Program"will also be created to provide a reference to the proposed project.
The third request is the City's intention to implement Line 22 and a portion of Line 21 of the Master Drainage Plan
for the Palm Springs Area, dated November 1982, prepared by Riverside County Flood Control and Water
Conservation District. Stone drain improvements include new catch basins, storm drain laterals to collect and
convey stormwater runoff from various intersecting streets along Mesquite Avenue, through a 66" diameter storm
drain that will convey runoff south to the Tahquitz Creek through an outlet structure to be located within the existing
Palm Springs municipal golf course, immediately upstream from the Gene Autry Trail bridge across the Tahquitz
Creek.
The City has authorized the release of the IS/EA for public review and comment for the project summarized above.
Mitigation measures addressing Air Quality and Noise are contained in the IS/EA. A copy of the IS/EA and related
processing materials can be reviewed or obtained from City at the address above. The period of review and
comment will be from October 23, 2003 to November 12, 2003. Written comments on the IS/EA should be
submitted to Jing Yen, Associate Planner Department of Planning and Zoning, City of Palm Springs, at the above
address no later than November 12, 2003.
The Planning Commission will review the proposed project at its meeting on November 12, 2003. At that meeting
the Planning Commission may recommend that the City Council adopt a mitigated negative declaration at a later
date. Please contact Jing Yeo, Associate Planner at (760) 323-8245, if you have any questions regarding the City's
review process for considering the IS/EA.'
Post Office Box 2743 0 Palm Springs, California 92263-2743
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ZONING
INITIAL STUDY
1. Case No: 5.0965 GPA
Project title: City Project No. 94-17,Mesquite Avenue Street Improvement Plan
2. Lead agency name and address:
City of Palm Springs
3200 E.Tahquitz Canyon Way
Palm Springs, CA 92262
3. Contact person and phone number:
Douglas R.Evans,Director of Planning and Zoning
Tel: (760) 323-8245
4. Project location:Mesquite Avenue between Mountain View Drive and Vella Road
5. Project sponsor's name and address:
City of Palm Springs
3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way
Palm Springs, CA 92262
6. Description of project: (Describe the whole action involved, including but not limited to later
phases of the project, and any secondary, support, or off-site features necessary for its
implementation. Attach additional sheets if necessary.)
The proposed project is to amend the General Plan — Circulation Element to downgrade
Mesquite Avenue, between El Cielo Road and Vella Road, from a Secondary Thoroughfare to a
Special Collector designation. This designation would allow the existing right-of-way width of
88 feet to be maintained and the widening of Mesquite Avenue between Mountain View Drive
and Avenida La Evelita to construct a special street section consisting of two through traffic
lanes (one in each direction) separated by a 12-foot wide raised, landscaped median, and a one-
way local park access road with parallel parking. Traffic calming features would be
implemented to encourage low-speed, thus deterring through travel. Commuters that use
Mesquite Avenue for through travel will seek other paths of travel that are designed to
accommodate these movements more efficiently. Traffic calming strategies are as follows:
provision of a raised median with curb cuts for access to Demuth Park and at intersections,
provide on-street parking on Frontage Road— south side of Mesquite Avenue and provide only
two 12-foot wide travel lanes along this section of Mesquite Avenue. Design features will be as
follows: channelization, curb"pop-outs", and"chokers"that narrow the roadway and discourage
through traffic on Mesquite Avenue.
The proposed General Plan Amendment will also improve local access between the residential
community and the recreational land uses to the south of Mesquite Avenue, reduce roadway
capacity, and discourage high speed commuter traffic. This portion of Mesquite Avenue is
City of Palm Springs Initial Study 1 10/2t/2003
adjacent to Palm Springs Youth Center and Demuth Park. Special design and control features
would be incorporated in the improvement plan to define, enhance and reinforce the local-access
character of Mesquite Avenue. The proposed improvements would provide an "inner" and
"outer" roadway on the south side of Mesquite Avenue in order to separate local activities,
parking, land use and future bicycle and transit facilities, and other traffic on Mesquite.
General Plan Policy 7.1.5. is also proposed to be amended to clarify the definition of"special
street programs". This clarification/definition of "special street programs" will allow greater
flexibility for special pavement sections to be achieved and still be consistent with the General
Plan. A new General Plan Policy 7.1.5.a. "Mesquite Avenue Special Street Program" will also
be created to provide a reference to the proposed project.
The City intends to implement Line 22 and a portion of Line 21 of the Master Drainage Plan for
the Palm Springs Area, dated November 1982,prepared by Riverside County Flood Control and
Water Conservation District. Storm drain improvements include new catch basins, storm drain
laterals to collect and convey stormwater runoff from various intersecting streets along Mesquite
Avenue, through a 66"diameter storm drain that will convey runoff south to the Tahquitz Creek
through an outlet structure to be located within the existing Palm Springs municipal golf course,
immediately upstream from the Gene Autry Trail bridge across the Tahquitz Creek.
7. Present Land Use: Secondary Thoroughfare
8. General Plan designation: Secondary Thoroughfare 8.a) Zoning:N/A
Proposed General Plan designation: Special Collector Proposed Zoning: N/A
9. Is the proposed action a "project" as defined by CEQA? (See Section
2.6 of State CEQA Guidelines. If more than one project is present in Yes Q No ❑
the same area, cumulative impact should be considered)
10. If"yes"above, does the project fall into any of the Emergency Projects Yes ❑ No 0
listed in Section 15269 of the State CEQA Guidelines?
11. If"no" on 10., does the project fall under any of the Ministerial Acts Yes ❑ No 9
listed in Section 15268(b) of the State CEQA Guidelines?
12. If "no" on 11., does the project fall under any of the Statutory Yes ❑ No Z
Exemptions listed in Article 18 of the State CEQA Guidelines?
13. If "no" on 12., does the project qualify for one of the Categorical
Exemptions listed in Article 19 of the State CEQA Guidelines?(Where
there is a reasonable probability that the activity will have a significant Yes ❑ No 0
effect due to special circumstances, a categorical exemption does not
apply).
City of Palm Springs Initial Shady 2 10/21/2003
14. Surrounding land uses and setting(briefly describe the proj ect's surroundings):
North: Existing Single Family Residential
South: Existing community park and recreation area—"Demuth Park"
East: Commercial and Industrial
West: Existing municipal golf course—"Tahquitz Creek Golf Coarse" and vacant land
15. Surrounding General Plan and Zoning:
North: L4 (Low Density Residential 3-4 mots/acre),L6 (Low Density Residential 5-6 units/acre)
/R-1-D,R-1-C,PD-60
South: PR(Parks and Recreation)/W-O, O
East: IND (Industrial)/M-1
West: PR(Parks and Recreation)/W-O
16. Is the proposed project consistent with(if answered"yes"or'Wa",no
explanation is required):
City of Palm Springs General Plan* Yes ❑ No ❑x N/A❑
Applicable Specific Plan Yes ❑ No ❑ N/A 9
City of Palm Springs Zoning Ordinance Yes ❑ No ❑ N/A ❑x
South Coast Air Quality Management Plan Yes ❑O No ❑ N/A ❑
Airport Part 150 Noise Study Yes ❑ No ❑ N/A ❑X
Draft Section 14 Master Development Plan Yes ❑ No ❑ N/A O
*The General Plan Circulation Element is proposed to be amended to
reclassify Mesquite Avenue, between El Cielo Road and Vella Road,
from a secondary thoroughfare to a special collector. General Phan
Policy 7.1.5 will be clarified with regards to special street programs. If
the General Plan Amendment is approved, the project will be
consistent with the General Plan.
City of Palm Springs Hiitial Study 3 10/21/2003
17. Are any of the following studies required?
Soils Report Yes ❑ No 19
Slope Study Yes ❑ No 19
Geotechiucal Report Yes 0 No ❑
Traffic Study Yes 0 No ❑
Air Quality Study Yes ❑ No 0
Hydrology Yes 0 No ❑
Sewer Study Yes ❑ No 9
Biological Study Yes ❑ No 0
Noise Study Yes ❑ No 19
Hazardous Materials Study Yes ❑ No 9
Housing Analysis Yes ❑ No 19
Archaeological Report Yes ❑ No 0
Groundwater Analysis Yes ❑ No 0
Water Quality Report Yes ❑ No 0
Other Yes ❑ No 0
18. Other public agencies whose approval is required(e.g., pennits, financing approval, or
participation agreement.)
Riverside County Flood Control and Water Conservation District
19. Incorporated herein by reference are:
Mesquite Avenue Traffic Calm n and Circulation Element Amendment Traffic Irnnact Study
prepared by Endo Engineering. June 2003
Final Environmental Impact Report on the General Plan Update
Master Dra Wage Plan For the Pahn Springs Area prepared b Riverside County Flood Control
and Water Conservation District.November 1982
City of Patin Springs Initial Study 4 10/21/2003
ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS POTENTIALLY AFFECTED
The environmental factors checked below would be potentially affected by this project,involving at least
one impact that is a"Potentially Significant hnpact" as indicated by the checklist on the following pages.
❑ Aesthetics ❑ Agriculture Resources ❑ Air Quality
❑ Biological Resources ❑ Cultural Resources ❑ Geology/Soils
❑ Hazards &Hazardous ❑ Hydrology/Water ❑ Land Use/Planning
Materials Quality
❑ Mineral Resources ❑ Noise ❑ Population/Housing
❑ Public Services ❑ Recreation ❑ Transportation/Traffic
❑ Utilities/Service Systems ❑ Mandatory Findings of Significance
EVALUATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
1. AESTHETICS --Would the project:
a) Have a substantial adverse effect on a ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x
scenic vista?
b) Substantially damage scenic resources,
including, but not limited to, trees, rock ❑ ❑ ❑
outcroppings, and historic buildings within a
state scenic highway?
c) Substantially degrade the existing visual
character or quality of the site and its ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑O
surroundings?
d) Create a new source of substantial light or
glare, which would adversely affect day or ❑ ❑ ❑ Z
nighttime views in the area?
La-d) NO IMPACT. The project will improve the visual character of Mesquite Avenue, between El
Cielo Road and Vella Road, and improve the aesthetic quality of Mesquite Avenue. Mesquite Avenue
will be reduced from a four-lane to a two-lane roadway and will be enhanced by landscaped medians, a
series of chokers, and other traffic calming measures. Any proposed lighting will comply with Section
93.21.00 of the Zoning Ordinance. Therefore, the project will not damage scenic resources, degrade the
visual quality of the surroundings, or create a new source of light or glare.
City of Palm Springs Initial Study 5 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
2. AGRICULTURE RESOURCES: hi
determining whether impacts to agricultural
resources are significant environmental
effects, lead agencies may refer to the
California Agricultural Land Evaluation and
Site Assessment Model (1997) prepared by
the California Dept. of Conservation as an
optional model to use in assessing impacts
on agriculture and farmland. Would the
proj ect:
a) Convert Prime Farmland, Unique
Farmland, or Farmland of Statewide
huportanee (Farmland), as shown on the
maps prepared pursuant to the Farmland ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x
Mapping and Monitoring Program of the
California Resources Agency, to non-
agricultural use?
b) Conflict with existing zoning for
agricultural use, or a Williamson Act ❑ ❑ ❑ l7
contract?
c) Involve other changes in the existing
environment which, due to their location or ❑ ❑ ❑
nature, could result in conversion of
Farmland, to non-agricultural use?
2.a-c) NO IMPACT. The project is not located on prime farmland, lutique farmland or farmland of
statewide importance. The project is not subject to a Williamson Act contract; therefore, the proposed
uses would not conflict with agricultural zoning or other agricultural regulations. There is no farmland
or agricultural land in the immediate vicinity of the project; therefore, the project could not result in
conversion of farmland to non-agricultural uses.
3. AIR QUALITY -- Where available, the
significance criteria established by the
applicable air quality management or air
pollution control district may be relied upon
to make the following determinations.
Would the project:
a) Conflict with or obstruct implementation ❑ ❑ ❑
of the applicable air quality plan?
City ofPahn Springs Initial Study 6 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
b) Violate any air quality standard or
contribute substantially to an existing or ❑ ❑x ❑ ❑
projected air quality violation?
c) Result in a cumulatively considerable net
increase of any criteria pollutant for which
the project region is non-attainment under an
applicable federal or state ambient air quality ❑ ❑ ❑ Z
standard (including releasing emissions
which exceed quantitative thresholds for
ozone precursors)?
d) Expose sensitive receptors to substantial ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x
pollutant concentrations?
e) Create objectionable odors affecting a ❑ ❑ ❑ 0
substantial munber of people?
3.a) NO IMPACT. The applicable air quality plan for the project area is the 2003 Air Quality
Management Plan (2003 AQMP). CEQA requires that projects be consistent with the applicable
AQMP. The proposed project will conform to the SCAQMD 2003 AQMP. The SCAQMD CEQA Air
Quality Handbook indicates in Chapter 6 that the SCAQMD considers a project to be less than
significant if its impact is mitigated below the identified thresholds. Additionally, the project site is
located in the Coachella Valley, which is under the recently adopted 2002 Coachella Valley PMro State
Implementation Plan. The CVPMtoSIP requires the development and implementation of a dust control
plan for all grading activities in the Coachella Valley requiring a grading permit. A dust control plan
shall be developed prior to issuance of any grading permits.
This project proposes to reclassify Mesquite Avenue between Mountain View Drive and Vella Road
from a secondary thoroughfare to a collector street with a special street section that will have the effect
of reducing the ultimate number of through traffic lanes from four(two in each direction)to two (one in
each direction). The"Mesquite Avenue Traffic Calming and Circulation Element Amendment Traffic
Impact Study", dated June 2003, prepared by Endo Engineering, analyzes the proposed project and its
impacts. The Study finds that the benefits of Mesquite Avenue and El Cielo Road as an alternative to
Gene Autry Trail and Ramon Road will be substantially reduced by this project. It is expected that
approximately three-fourths of the reduced traffic volume on Mesquite Avenue will use Ramon Road.
The results of reduced volumes of traffic traveling through the Mesquite Avenue corridor between
Mountain View Drive and Vella Road will have a positive impact, in that reduced levels of noise and
air pollution attributed to vehicles will result. Therefore, since the proposed project is considered
consistent with the region's air quality plan and a dust control plan will be developed and implemented
prior to grading activities, the project will result in no impact on the SCAQMD's AQMP or the
CVPMtaSIP.
City of Palm Springs Initial Study 7 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
3.b) LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT IMPACT WITH MITIGATION INCORPORATED. This project
will, during the short term period of construction, have the potential of exposing existing residential
properties adjacent to Mesquite Avenue to higher levels of dust emissions normally expected to occur
during construction activities. However, construction of this project will be regulated between the
regular City-permitted working hours of 7:00 A.M. to 3:30 P.M., Monday through Friday only.
Emissions associated with construction include: any demolition, grading or excavating activities. Dust
emissions also vary depending on the level of activity, the specific operations and weather conditions.
Since the project is located in the Coachella Valley, which has significant problems with PM10
generation, a dust control-plan will need to be developed and implemented in accordance with the 2002
Coachella Valley PM10 State Implementation Plan. In the long term, this project will actually have a
positive impact, in that reduced volumes of traffic to be expected as a result of the project will reduce
the level of air pollution attributed to vehicles.
3.c-e)NO IMPACT. With the incorporation of construction related mitigation measures, the proposed
project would not result in any significant air quality impacts and therefore would not contribute to a
cumulatively considerable net increase of any: criteria pollutants or ozone precursors, substantial
pollutant concentrations and/or objectionable odors.
Mitigation Measures
1. Prior to beginning construction activities, a dust control plan will be developed in accordance with
the 2002 Coachella Valley PM10 State Implementation Plan.
2. The project shall compliance with Palm Springs Municipal Code Title 8, Chapter 8.50 — Fugitive
Dust and Erosion Control.
3. During construction,the site shall be watered and equipment cleaned in the morning and evening.
4. BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES -- Would
the project:
a) Have a substantial adverse effect, either
directly or through habitat modifications, on
any species identified as a candidate,
sensitive, or special status species in local or ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑X
regional plans, policies, or regulations, or by
the California Department of Fish and Game
or U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service?
City of palm Springs Initial Study 8 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
b) Have a substantial adverse effect on any
riparian habitat or other sensitive natural
community identified in local or regional ❑ ❑ ❑
plans, policies, regulations or by the
California Department of Fish and Game or
US Fish and Wildlife Service?
c) Have a substantial adverse effect on
federally protected wetlands as defined by
Section 404 of the Clean Water Act
(including, but not limited to, marsh, vernal ❑ ❑ ❑ O
pool, coastal, etc.) through direct removal,
filling, hydrological interruption, or other
means?
d) Interfere substantially with the movement
of any native resident or migratory fish or
wildlife species or with established native ❑ ❑ ❑ [7
resident or migratory wildlife corridors, or
impede the use of native wildlife nursery
sites?
e) Conflict with any local policies or
ordinances protecting biological resources, ❑ ❑ ❑
such as a tree preservation policy or
ordinance?
f) Conflict with the provisions of an adopted
Habitat Conservation Plan, Natural
Community Conservation Plan, or other ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑O
approved local, regional, or state habitat
conservation plan?
4.a,b, d-f) NO IMPACT. This project occurs within an existing street corridor, currently used by the
general public. There are no existing plant or animal wildlife habitats, wetlands, or other areas that
where plant or animal wildlife would be expected. All new improvements are proposed within existing
disturbed or improved areas that are used continuously by the general public.
4.e)NO IMPACT. This project proposes to implement Line 22 and a portion of Line 21 of the Master
Drainage Plan for the Palm Springs Area, dated November 1982, prepared by Riverside County Flood
Control and Water Conservation District. Storm drain improvements include new catch basins, storm
drain laterals to collect and convey stormwater runoff from various intersecting streets along Mesquite
Avenue, through a 66" diameter storm drain that will convey runoff south to the Tahquitz Creek
through an outlet structure to be located within the existing Palm Springs municipal golf course,
City of Palm Springs Initial Study 9 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
immediately upstream from the Gene Autry Trail bridge across the Tahquitz Creek. Although the
Tahquitz Creek is a natural dry watercourse, subject to Section 404 of the Clean Water Act,this portion
of the Tahquitz Creek has been developed as a municipal golf course by the City of Palm Springs. In
order to construct the golf course,the City received a permit from the Army Corps of Engineers(Permit
No. 92-358-RS) on August 20, 1993, as well as a Streambed Alteration Agreement (Agreement No. 5-
271-92) on May 20, 1992, from the California Department of Fish and Game. These permits regulated
the construction of the Tahquitz Creek Golf Course and all associated improvements. The proposed
storm drain outlet structure will be located entirely within a portion of the Tahquitz Creek that is
currently used and developed for golf course recreation purposes, and not within any existing
undisturbed area subject to a new Section 404 permit.
Additionally,Riverside County Flood Control and Water Conservation District adopted Resolution No.
F83-18, approving the Revised Master Drainage Plan for the Palm Springs Area on November 8, 1983,
which included a required an Initial Study, the findings of which supported a Negative Declaration,
which was submitted through the regulatory process as SCH#83060601 on May 27, 1983. This project
will implement improvements previously found to have no impact on the environment.
5. CULTURAL RESOURCES -- Would the
project:
a) Cause a substantial adverse change in the
significance of a historical resource as ❑ ❑ ❑ []
defined in §15064.5?
b) Cause a substantial adverse change in the
significance of an archaeological resource ❑ ❑ ❑ N
pursuant to §15064.5?
c) Directly or indirectly destroy a unique
paleontological resource or site or unique ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑X
geologic feature?
d) Disturb any human remains, including ❑ ❑ ❑
those interred outside of formal cemeteries?
5.a-c) NO IMPACT. The General Plan shows the project site is not located in an area that may have
historical, archeological or paleontological resources. Mesquite Avenue is currently a fully improved
secondary thoroughfare adjacent to a well-used public park.This project occurs within an existing street
corridor, currently used by the general public. There are no historical, archaeological, paleontological
resources within the project area. Furthermore, there are no known human remains, burial sites, or
formal cemeteries within the project area. All new improvements are proposed within existing
disturbed or improved areas that are used continuously by the general public.
6. GEOLOGY AND SOILS -- Would the
project:
City of Palm Springs Initial Study 10 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
a) Expose people or structures to potential
substantial adverse effects, including the risk
of loss, injury, or death involving:
i) Rupture of a known earthquake fault, as
delineated on the most recent Alquist-Priolo
Earthquake Fault Zoning Map issued by the
State Geologist for the area or based on other ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑O
substantial evidence of a known fault? Refer
to Division of Mines and Geology Special
Publication 42.
ii) Strong seismic ground shaking? ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x
iii) Seismic-related ground failure, including ❑ ❑ ❑ 0
liquefaction?
iv)Landslides? ❑ ❑ ❑ 191
b) Result in substantial soil erosion or the ❑ ❑ ❑ z
loss of topsoil?
c)Be located on a geologic unit or soil that is
unstable, or that would become unstable as a
result of the project, and potentially result in ❑ ❑ ❑ 0
on- or off-site landslide, lateral spreading,
subsidence, liquefaction or collapse?
d)Be located on expansive soil, as defined in -
Table 18-1-B of the Uniform Building Code ❑ ❑ ❑
(1994), creating substantial risks to life or
property?
e) Have soils incapable of adequately
supporting the use of septic tanks or
alternative waste water disposal systems ❑ ❑ ❑ l7
where sewers are not available for the
disposal of waste water?
6.a-e)NO IMPACT. The General Plan shows that the project site's location is not known to be subject
to liquefaction or landslides. The project site is located on flat land and surrounded by single family
residential or public recreational uses. The project does not involve the construction of any structures
and only entails street and drainage improvements. All new improvements are proposed within existing
disturbed or improved areas that are used continuously by the general public. A geoteclmical report will
be required to ensure the street and Master Plan Drainage lines are designed for site specific soil
City of Palm Springs Initial Study 11 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
conditions. Therefore, the project would not expose people or improvements to adverse effects due to
soil erosion,unstable soil, expansive soil and/or soil incapable of supporting waste water disposal.
7. HAZARDS AND HAZARDOUS
MATERIALS—Would the project:
a) Create a significant hazard to the public or
the environment through the routine ❑ ❑ ❑ 17
transport, use, or disposal of hazardous
materials?
b)Create a significant hazard to the public or
the environment through reasonably
foreseeable upset and accident conditions ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x
involving the release of hazardous materials
into the environment?
c) Emit hazardous emissions or handle
hazardous or acutely hazardous materials, ❑ ❑ ❑ 0
substances, or waste within one-quarter mile
of an existing or proposed school?
d)Be located on a site which is included on a
list of hazardous materials sites compiled
pursuant to Government Code Section ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑X
65962.5 and, as a result, would it create a
significant hazard to the public or the
environment?
e)For a project located within an airport land
use plan or, where such a plan has not been
adopted, within two miles of a public airport ❑ 0
or public use airport, would the project result
in a safety hazard for people residing or
working in the project area?
f) For a project within the vicinity of a
private airstrip, would the project result in a ❑ ❑ ❑ 0
safety hazard for people residing or working
in the project area?
g) Impair implementation of or physically
interfere with an adopted emergency ❑ ❑ ❑ 0
response plan or emergency evacuation plan?
City of Patin Springs Initial Study 12 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
h) Expose people or structures to a
significant risk of loss, injury or death
involving wildland fires, including where 17 ❑ ❑ ❑x
wildlands are adjacent to urbanized areas or
where residences are intermixed with
wildlands?
7.a-h)NO IMPACT. The project does not involve the use or introduction of hazardous materials to the
area and is not located in an area known to have hazardous materials. This project occurs within an
existing street corridor, currently used by the general public. The propose project will not cause to be
generated or create opportunities for public exposure to additional or increased levels of hazardous
materials. There are no known hazardous material sites within the project area. All new improvements
are proposed within existing disturbed or improved areas that are used continuously by the general
public. The Fire Department has reviewed the project and determined that the new street improvements
will not impair the implementation of an emergency response or evacuation plan. Although the project
site is located within two miles of Palm Springs International Airport, the project does not abut
wildlands or involve the construction of residences and therefore, could not have the potential to expose
people or strictures to airport hazards or wildland fires.
8. HYDROLOGY AND WATER
QUALITY--Would the project:
a) Violate any water quality standards or ❑ ❑
waste discharge requirements?
b) Substantially deplete groundwater
supplies or interfere substantially with
groundwater recharge such that there would
be a net deficit in aquifer volume or a
lowering of the local groundwater table level ❑ ❑ t]
(e.g., the production rate of pre-existing
nearby wells would drop to a level
which would not support existing land uses
or planned uses for which permits have been
granted)?
c) Substantially alter the existing drainage
pattern of the site or area, including through
the alteration of the course of a stream or ❑ ❑x
river, in a manner which would result in
substantial erosion or siltation on- or off-
site?
City of Palm Springs Initial Study 13 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
d) Substantially alter the existing drainage
pattern of the site or area, including through
the alteration of the course of a stream or ❑ ❑ ❑
river, or substantially increase the rate or
amount of surface runoff in a manner which
would result in flooding on-or off-site?
e) Create or contribute nmoff water which
would exceed the capacity of existing or
planed stormwater drainage systems or ❑ ❑ ❑ 1]
provide substantial additional sources of
polluted runoff?
f) Otherwise substantially degrade water ❑ ❑ ❑ (]
quality?
g) Place housing within a 100-year flood
hazard area as mapped on a federal Flood ❑ ❑ ❑
19
Hazard Boundary or Flood Insurance Rate
Map or other flood hazard delineation map?
h) Place within a 100-year flood hazard area
structures which would impede or redirect ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x
flood flows?
i)Expose people or structures to a significant
risk of loss, injury or death involving ❑ ❑ ❑ Z
flooding, including flooding as a result of the
failure of a levee or dam?
j) Inundation by sciche, tsunami, or ❑ ❑ ❑ N
mudflow?
8.a j) NO IMPACT. This project proposes to construct Line 22 and a portion of Line 21 of the Master
Drainage Plan for the Palm Springs Area, dated November 1982, prepared by Riverside County Flood
Control and Water Conservation District. Storm drain improvements include new catch basins, storm
drain laterals to collect and convey stormwater runoff from various intersecting streets along Mesquite
Avenue, through a 66" diameter storm drain that will convey runoff south to the Tahquitz Creek
through an outlet structure to be located within the existing Palm Springs municipal golf course,
immediately upstream from the Gene Autry Trail bridge across the Tahquitz Creek. Although the
project proposes additional landscape improvements, the expected water requirements to irrigate and
maintain the landscaping improvements are a normal and expected use of existing water resources. The
existing drainage pattern will be improved for the entire area, by redirecting surface stormwater runoff
into catch basins and underground storm drain systems, thereby reducing the nuisance that surface
City of Palm Springs Initial Study 14 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
runoff has on the environment and the general public. Improvements will be constructed at the storm
drain outlet structure to eliminate soil erosion and other effects expected from the constant nuisance
water runoff through the system into the Tahquitz Creek Golf Course. This project will have a positive
impact, in that implementation of this portion of the Master Drainage Plan will continue to direct
stormwater runoff away from people and structures from the potential risk of loss, injury or death
involving flooding.
9. LAND USE AND PLANNING - Would
the project:
a) Physically divide an established ❑ ❑ ❑
community?
b) Conflict with any applicable land use
plan, policy, or regulation of an agency with
jurisdiction over the project (including, but
not limited to the general plan, specific plan, ❑ ❑ ❑O ❑
local coastal program, or zoning ordinance)
adopted for the purpose of avoiding or
mitigating an environmental effect?
e) Conflict with any applicable habitat
conservation plan or natural community ❑ ❑ ❑ 0
conservation plan?
9.a,c) NO IMPACT. This project is being initiated in response to requests from the adjacent
neighborhood community, and will have the result of reducing the volume and speed of traffic traveling
on Mesquite Avenue between Mountain View Drive and Vella Road. The project will visually enhance
the established community through the installation of new landscaping improvements, as well as
decorative street improvements used for traffic calming purposes. The project does not divide an
established community nor does it conflict with any habitat conservation plan or natural community
plan. The proposed improvement plan will reduce traffic and create a buffer between Demuth Park and
the single-family residences to the north. The plan will create a better relationship between the street,
park, and single-family residences.
9b) LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT IMPACT. The project proposes to amend the General Plan
Circulation Amendment to reclassify Mesquite Avenue between Mountain View Drive and Vella Road
from a secondary thoroughfare to a collector street with a special section that will have the effect of
reducing the ultimate number of through traffic lanes from four (two in each direction) to two (one in
each direction). The reduction in the number of traffic lanes wilt have the effect of reducing or limiting
the traffic allowed on Mesquite Avenue, between El Cielo Road and Vella Road,while maintaining the
right-of-way width of eighty-eight feet (88'). This would allow for the proposed traffic calming
features, circulation improvements, and on-street parking. The 88' right-of-way width allows for the
proposed landscaped median and landscaped/shaded parking on the south side of Mesquite Ave along
City of Patin Springs Initial Study 15 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
with room for a fitture bike trail, which is located on the south side of Mesquite Avenue on the General
Plan.
The "Mesquite Avenue Traffic Calming and Circulation Element Amendment Traffic Impact Study",
dated June 2003, prepared by Endo Engineering, analyzes the proposed project and its impacts. The
Shady finds that the project will reduce traffic volumes on Mesquite Avenue between IT Cielo Road and
Vella Road, with the following effects:
1.Provide an adequate Level of Service for future year 2020 traffic volumes, such that the requirement
for traffic signalization at Mesquite Avenue at El Cielo Road, and at Mesquite Avenue and Vella Road
is avoided;
2. Redistribute approximately 6,000 through trips projected to occur on Mesquite Avenue without the
project. Furthermore, redistributed trips in the future year 2020 will not cause any of the studied
intersection to fall below acceptable levels of service (LOS D)during peak hours.
3. Proposed traffic calming, raised cross-walks, and installation of an All-Way Stop controlled
intersection at Mesquite Avenue and Mountain View Drive and at Mesquite Avenue and Nueva Vista
Drive is expected to have a beneficial impact on pedestrian safety.
4.No significant adverse impacts on local circulation or access are expected to result from the proposed
project. The proposed project provides adequate access to accommodate the projected year 2020 traffic
volumes at acceptable levels of service.
5. No significant adverse impacts on local circulation or access are anticipated from the proposed
Circulation Element Amendment and "special collector" street improvements for Mesquite Avenue,
between El Cielo Road and Vella Road.
General Plan Policy 7.1.5. is also proposed to be amended to clarify the definition of"special street
programs". The policy is clear on intention, but not on definition. This clarification/definition of
"special street programs"will allow greater flexibility for special pavement sections to be achieved and
still be consistent with the General Plan. Due to the dramatic change in the street character and the
reduced roadway capacity as a result of the project, a new General Plan Policy 7.1.5a. "Mesquite
Avenue Special Street Program" is proposed to be created. The new policy is intended to highlight the
unique street improvements that are being proposed as a part of this project. If the proposed General
Plan Amendments are approved,the project will not result in any conflicts with the General Plan.
10. MINERAL RESOURCES -- Would the
project:
a) Result in the loss of availability of a
known mineral resource that would be of 0
value to the region and the residents of the
state?
City of Palm Springs Initial Study 16 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
b) Result in the loss of availability of a
locally-important mineral resource recovery ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x
site delineated on a local general plan,
specific plan or other land use plan?
10.a-b) NO IMPACT. This project occurs within an existing street corridor, currently used by the
general public. There are no known mineral resources within the project area. All new improvements
are proposed within existing disturbed or improved areas that are used continuously by the general
public.
11.NOISE—Would the project result in:
a) Exposure of persons to or generation of
noise levels in excess of standards
established in the local general plan or noise ❑ 17 ❑ ❑
ordinance, or applicable standards of other
agencies?
b) Exposure of persons to or generation of
excessive groundborne vibration or ❑ ❑ 17 ❑
groundborne noise levels?
c) A substantial permanent increase in
ambient noise levels in the project vicinity ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x
above levels existing without the project?
d) A substantial temporary or periodic
increase in ambient noise levels in the ❑ ❑ 0 ❑
project vicinity above levels existing without
the project?
e)For a project located within an airport land
use plan or, where such a plan has not been
adopted, within two miles of a public airport ❑ ❑ ❑ 1]
or public use airport, would the project
expose people residing or working in the
project area to excessive noise levels?
I) For a project within the vicinity of a
private airstrip, would the project expose ❑ ❑ ❑
people residing or working in the project
area to excessive noise levels?
I l.a) LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT WITH MITIGATION INCORPORATED. The impacts related to
noise would be associated with short-term construction activities.Although periodic noise levels have a
City of Palm Springs Initial Study 17 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
potential to be higher during periods of construction, this will be temporary in nature and all vehicles
will be required to have adequate muffling devices to ensure compliance with the City's Noise
Ordinance. With the incorporation of mitigation measures during construction activities, the impacts
will be reduced to a less than significant level.
I Lb, d) LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT IMPACT. The proposed project site would not be expected to
result in exposure of persons to or generation of groundborne vibration or noise levels. No sources of
groundborne noise are proposed as part of the project. This project will during the short term period of
construction,have the potential of exposing existing residential properties adjacent to Mesquite Avenue
to higher levels of noise pollution normally expected to occur during construction activities.The City of
Palm Springs' noise ordinance regulates construction hours and acceptable noise levels in residential
areas based on the time of day. In the long term,the reduction in capacity of Mesquite Avenue between
El Cielo Road and Vella Road could potentially reduce the number of cars traveling on Mesquite
Avenue, thus reducing noise pollution attributed to vehicles in the neighbourhood. Therefore, the
project will have a less than significant impact on ambient noise levels in the area.
1 l.c, e, f)NO IMPACT. This project proposes to reclassify Mesquite Avenue between Mountain View
Drive and Vella Road from a secondary thoroughfare to a collector street with a special street section
that will have the effect of reducing the ultimate number of through traffic lanes from four(two in each
direction) to two (one in each direction). The "Mesquite Avenue Traffic Calming and Circulation
Element Amendment Traffic Impact Study", dated June 2003,prepared by Endo Engineering, analyzes
the proposed project and its impacts. The Study finds that the benefits of Mesquite Avenue and El
Cielo Road as an alternative to Gene Autry Trail and Ramon Road will be substantially reduced by this
project. It is expected that approximately three-fourths of the reduced traffic volume on Mesquite
Avenue will use Ramon Road. The results of reduced volumes of traffic traveling through the Mesquite
Avenue corridor between Mountain View Drive and Vella Road will have a positive impact, in that
reduced levels of noise pollution attributed to vehicles will result. Although the project site is located
within two miles of Palm Springs International Airport, the project does not involve the construction of
any residential structures and therefore, could not expose people residing or working in the project area
to excessive noise levels.
Mitigation Measures
1. During construction phases, the contractor shall ensure that all construction is performed in
accordance with the applicable City of Palm Springs noise standards. This measure shall be added to
the construction contract.
2. All internal combustion powered equipment shall be equipped with properly operating mufflers and
kept properly timed to alleviate backfires. This measure shall be added to the construction contract.
3. During construction activities, the contractor shall locate portable equipment as far as possible from
the adjacent residences. This measure shall be added to the construction contract.
City of Patin Springs Inami Study is 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
12. POPULATION AND HOUSING --
Would the project:
a)Induce substantial population growth in an
area, either directly (for example, by
proposing new homes and businesses) or ❑ ❑ ❑ 17
indirectly(for example, through extension of
roads or other infrastructure)?
b) Displace substantial numbers of existing
housing, necessitating the construction of ❑ ❑ ❑ O
replacement housing elsewhere?
c) Displace substantial numbers of people,
necessitating the construction of replacement ❑ ❑ ❑ 17
housing elsewhere?
12.a-c) NO IMPACT. This project occurs within an existing street corridor, currently used by the
general public. The street improvements and reclassification serve to calm traffic on Mesquite Avenue
between El Cielo Road as well as reducing roadway capacity. This project does not affect the ability of
existing governmental facilities to provide current services, response times, or perform in any other
matmer for the general public. All new improvements are proposed within existing disturbed or
improved areas that are used continuously by the general public. Therefore,the project could not induce
population growth or displace people or existing housing.
13. PUBLIC SERVICES
a) Would the project result in substantial
adverse physical impacts associated with the
provision of new or physically altered
governmental facilities, need for new or
physically altered governmental facilities,
the construction of which could cause
significant environmental impacts, in order
to maintain acceptable service ratios,
response times or other performance
objectives for any of the public services:
Fire protection? ❑ ❑ ❑ IO
Police protection? ❑ ❑ ❑ O
Schools? ❑ ❑ ❑ I]
Parks? ❑ ❑ ❑ I]
City of Pahn Springs Initial Study 19 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
Other public facilities? ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑O
13.a)NO IMPACT. This project occurs within an existing street corridor, currently used by the general
public. This project does not affect the ability of existing governmental facilities to provide current
services, response times, or perform in any other manner for the general public. All new improvements
are proposed within existing disturbed or improved areas that are used continuously by the general
public.
14. RECREATION
a) Would the project increase the use of
existing neighborhood and regional parks or
other recreational facilities such that ❑ ❑ ❑X ❑
substantial physical deterioration of the
facility would occur or be accelerated?
b) Does the project include recreational
facilities or require the construction or
expansion of recreational facilities which ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x
might have an adverse physical effect on the
environment?
14.a) LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT IMPACT. The project abuts Demuth Park, an existing, well-used
commumity park. The project will increase the linkage between the park and the residential
neigbourhood to the north while also improving pedestrian and traffic safety around the park. An
additional 132 striped,parallel parking spaces are proposed as part of this project. The parking lane will
create a buffer from through traffic and will reduce the potential for children chasing soccer balls into
the street. The traffic calming measures and reduced roadway capacity are intended to discourage
commuters from using Mesquite Avenue as an east-west alternative route. It may be expected that as a
result of this project, increased attendance at the community recreation area"Demuth Park"will occur.
Improved access to the park area, increased parking access, and the overall improvement to the
Mesquite Avenue corridor adjacent to Demuth Park may attract additional park users, however, any
increase in park use directly attributed to this project is expected to be minimal, and below any level of
significance.
14.b) NO IMPACT. The project is a street improvement project with all improvements to occur within
an existing public right-of-way. The project does involve the construction or expansion of recreational
facilities.
15. TRANSPORTATION/TRAFFIC --
Would the project:
City of patio Springs Initial Study 20 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
a) Cause an increase in traffic which is
substantial in relation to the existing traffic
load and capacity of the street system (i.e.,
result in a substantial increase in either the ❑ ❑ ❑O ❑
number of vehicle trips, the 'volume to
'capacity ratio on roads, or congestion at
intersections)?
b) Exceed, either individually or
cumulatively, a level of service standard
established by the county congestion ❑ ❑ ❑ X
management agency for designated roads or
highways?
c) Result in a change in air traffic patterns,
including either an increase in traffic levels ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x
or a change in location that results in
substantial safety risks?
d) Substantially increase hazards due to a
design feature (e.g., sharp curves or ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x
dangerous intersections) or incompatible
uses (e.g., farm equipment)?
e)Result in inadequate emergency access? ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x
f)Result in inadequate parking capacity? ❑ ❑ ❑
g) Conflict with adopted policies, plans, or
programs supporting alternative ❑ ❑ ❑ Z
transportation (e.g., bus turnouts, bicycle
racks)?
15.a)LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT IMPACT. This project will have the result of redistributing current
traffic volumes on Mesquite Avenue between El Cielo Road and Vella Road to other roadways.
Specifically, the redistributed traffic is expected to increase traffic use of Gene Autry Trail,Vella Road,
Sunny Dunes Road and Ramon Road, however this increase in traffic will not affect the capacity of
these roadways to carry the projected year 2020 traffic volumes at acceptable levels of service.
15.b-g) NO IMPACT. This project proposes to reclassify Mesquite Avenue between Mountain View
Drive and Vella Road from a secondary thoroughfare to a collector street with a special section that will
have the effect of reducing the ultimate number of through traffic lanes from four (two in each
direction) to two (one in each direction). The proposed improvements are inconsistent with the current
Circulation Element of the General Plan for the City of Palm Springs. This project proposes to amend
City of Patin Springs Initial Study 21 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
the Circulation Element in order to construct the special street sections proposed for Mesquite Avenue.
The "Mesquite Avenue Traffic Calming and Circulation Element Amendment Traffic Impact Study",
dated June 2003, prepared by Endo Engineering, analyzes the proposed project and its impacts. The
Study finds that the project will reduce traffic volumes on Mesquite Avenue between El Cielo Road and
Vella Road, with the following effects:
1.Provide an adequate Level of Service for future year 2020 traffic volumes, such that the requirement
for traffic signalization at Mesquite Avenue at El Cielo Road, and at Mesquite Avenue and Vella Road
is avoided;
2. Redistribute approximately 6,000 through trips projected to occur on Mesquite Avenue without the
project. Furthermore, redistributed trips in the future year 2020 will not cause any of the studied
intersection to fall below acceptable levels of service(LOS D) during peak hours.
3. Proposed traffic calming, raised cross-walks, and installation of an All-Way Stop controlled
intersection at Mesquite Avenue and Mountain View Drive and at Mesquite Avenue and Nueva Vista
Drive is expected to have a beneficial impact on pedestrian safety.
4.No significant adverse impacts on local circulation or access are expected to result from the proposed
project. The proposed project provides adequate access to accommodate the projected year 2020 traffic
volumes at acceptable levels of service.
5. No significant adverse impacts on local circulation or access are anticipated from the proposed
Circulation Element Amendment and "special collector" street improvements for Mesquite Avenue,
between El Cielo Road and Vella Road.
16. UTILITIES AND SERVICE SYSTEMS
—Would the project:
a) Exceed wastewater treatment
requirements of the applicable Regional ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x
Water Quality Control Board?
b) Require or result in the construction of
new water or wastewater treatment facilities
or expansion of existing facilities, the ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑
constriction of which could cause significant
environmental effects?
c) Require or result in the construction of
new storm water drainage facilities or
expansion of existing facilities, the ❑ ❑ ❑ O
constriction of which could cause significant
environmental effects?
City of Patin Springs Initial Shady 22 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
d)Have sufficient water supplies available to
serve the project from existing entitlements ❑ 0 ❑ 9
and resources, or are new or expanded
entitlements needed?
e) Result in a determination by the
wastewater treatment provider which serves
or may serve the project that it has adequate ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑x
capacity to serve the project's projected
demand in addition to the provider's existing
commitments?
f) Be served by a landfill with sufficient
permitted capacity to accommodate the ❑ ❑ 0 O
project's solid waste disposal needs?
g) Comply with federal, state, and local
statutes and regulations related to solid ❑ __ 191
waste?
16.a, c-g) NO IMPACT. The proposed project involves widening and modification of an existing
regional roadway adjacent to a residential neighborhood and community recreation area "Demuth
Park"; and the project proposes to implement Line 22 and a portion of Line 21 of the Master Drainage
Plan for the Palm Springs Area, dated November 1982, prepared by Riverside County Flood Control
and Water Conservation District. Storm drain improvements include new catch basins, storm drain
laterals to collect and convey stormwater runoff from various intersecting streets along Mesquite
Avenue, through a 66" diameter storm drain that will convey runoff south to the Tahquitz Creek
through an outlet structure to be located within the existing Palm Springs municipal golf course,
immediately upstream from the Gene Autry Trail bridge across the Tahquitz Creek. The project does
not generate any wastewater, nor require the construction of new or expanded wastewater treatment
facilities. The project in itself includes construction of new storm water drainage facilities, however,
these facilities will not cause any significant environmental effects. Although the project proposes
additional landscape improvements, the expected water requirements to irrigate and maintain the
landscaping improvements are a normal and expected use of existing water resources. The project does
not require wastewater treatment service, nor will the project generate solid waste that would require
service from a landfill or compliance with applicable statutes and regulation.
16 b) LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT IMPACT. The Desert Water Agency (DWA) currently owns,
operates, and maintains water distribution and pumping facilities within the project area. Project
proponents will be required to connect to existing DWA water infrastructure to provide water to the site
for construction and domestic water service. The developer will be required to comply with all rules,
regulations, and other requirements of the DWA in order to provide water service to the site. Water
service requirements may include, but are not limited to, upgrades, modifications, replacement, and
City of Patrn Springs Initial Study 23 10/21/2003
Less Than
Significant
Potentially with Less Than
Significant Mitigation Significant No
Impact Incorporated Impact Impact
abandomnent of existing DWA facilities. These improvements may require constriction within and
adjacent to public rights-of-way and exiting and/or proposed easements. Construction will occur in
accordance with DWA and City requirements and will not cause any significant effects upon the
environment.
17. MANDATORY FINDINGS OF
SIGNIFICANCE
a) Does the project have the potential to
degrade the quality of the environment,
substantially reduce the habitat of a fish or
wildlife species, cause a fish or wildlife
population to drop below self-sustaining 9
levels, threaten to eliminate a plant or animal
community, reduce the number or restrict the
range of a rare or endangered plant or animal
or eliminate important examples of the major
periods of California history or prehistory?
b) Does the project have impacts that are
individually limited, but cumulatively
considerable? ("Cumulatively
considerable" means that the incremental 0
ffl
effects of a project are considerable when
viewed in connection with the effects of past
projects, the effects of other current projects,
and the effects of probable future projects)?
c) Does the project have environmental
effects which will cause substantial adverse 9
effects on human beings, either directly or
indirectly?
17.a-c) NO IMPACT. The project has the potential to improve the neighbourhood environment by
decreasing traffic volume on a residential street, reducing roadway noise and congestion, improving the
visual character of the street,making the street more pedestrian friendly, and increasing the potential for
alternative modes of transportation. Therefore, the project will not degrade the quality of the
environment or have adverse effects on human beings.
City of Palm Springs Initial Study 24 10/21/2003
18. LISTED BELOW ARE THE PERSON(S)WHO PREPARED OR PARTICIPATED IN THE
PREPARATION OF THE INITIAL STUDY:
Douglas R. Evans,Director of Planning and Zoning
Matthew Feske, Assistant Planner
Jing Yee, Associate Planner
Marcus Fuller, Senior Civil Engineer
DETERMINATION
On the basis of this initial evaluation:
❑ I find that the proposed project COULD NOT have a significant effect on the environment,
and a NEGATIVE DECLARATION will be prepared.
I find that although the proposed project could have a significant effect on the environment,
❑x there will not be a significant effect in this case because revisions in the project have been
made by or agreed to by the project proponent. A MITIGATED NEGATIVE
DECLARATION will be prepared.
El I find that the proposed project MAY have a significant effect on the environment, and an
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT is required.
I find that the proposed project MAY have a"potentially significant impact'or"potentially
significant rmless mitigated" impact on the environment, but at least one effect 1) has been
adequately analyzed in an earlier document pursuant to applicable legal standards, and 2)
has been addressed by mitigation measures based on the earlier analysis as described on
attached sheets. An ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT is required, but it must
analyze only the effects that remain to be addressed.
I find that although the proposed project could have a significant effect on the environment,
because all potentially significant effects (a) have been analyzed adequately in an earlier
FIR or NEGATIVE DECLARATION pursuant to applicable standards, and (b) have been
avoided or mitigated pursuant to that earlier EIR or NEGATIVE DECLARATION,
including revisions or mitigation measures that are imposed upon the proposed project,
nothing farther is required.
ko,o /0- 12 /- 03
Douglas R. Avans Date
Director of Planning and Zoning
City of Palm Springs Initial Study 25 1012l/2003
Gase 5.0569 ,,ulu 17 . k ,.� r It Glen �I+1Cy • _ rlr/l�j03 Page 1 of 24
502 301 '08 502302001 502 302 002
14a At Ke e Ele Etc Robert Eichel Lily Rath
98005 Sepu da Blvd#720 603 S El Cielo Rd 2958 Guadalupe Rd
Los Angel , C 90045 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
502 302 003 502 302 004 502 302 0 5
Kelly Thomas Coleman Carozza Darcy Ruiz Edwu'd M na &Christopher Sloan
655 S El Cielo Rd 677 S El Cielo Rd PO Box 8
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm ring CA 92263
502 302 006 502 590 005 502 590 011
Rosalie Damore Desert Water Agency Dahoon Investment Co
695 S El Cielo Rd PO Box 1710 77200 California Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92263 Palm Desert,CA 92211
502 591 001 502 591 002 502 591 003
William Sperling&Charlotte Cc Antho Danny Duran Jose&Yolanda Sander
PO Box 2400 8225 Santa Monica Blvd PO Box 266
Idyllwild, CA 92549 West Hollywood,CA 90046 Romeo,MI 48065
502 591 004 502 591 005 502 591 006
Hennes Albert N&Pique Edward&Judith Moomaugh Juan Magunagoicoechea& Sabine Atw
1720 Chevy Chase Dr 2700 E Mesquite North Ave 4A5 2700 E Mesquite Ave#A6
Beverly Hills,CA 90210 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
502 591 007 502 591 008 502 591 009
Conley Frederick Z&Elizabeth K 1 Lance Wood Barbara Many
Frederick Conley PO Box 217 10930 NE 1571h St
PO Box 88 Winter Park,CO 80482 Bothell,WA 98011
Pahn Springs,CA 92263
502 591 010 502 591 Ol l 502 591 012
Dahoon Investment Co Inc Hampton&Linda Gaskins Don Gaidano
43350 Tennessee Ave 261 Browning St BRISTOL AVON BSI 4PB
Palm Desert,CA 92211 Upland, CA 91784 UNITED KINGDOM
502 591 013 502 591 014 502 591 015
Alice Mitchelk
r Western Precooling Systems Gene&Patsy Seymore
555 S Palm CDr#350 PO Box 1338 1024 Brooke Ln
Pahn Springs, 2264 Fremont,CA 94538 Fullerton, CA 92264
502 591 0 7 502 591 018 502 591 019
Mal"thI Mol Joseph&Christine Carrick James &Diane Craft
324 N Oakhu t Dr#304 1710 Via Allondra 42 Drakes Bay Dr
Beverly Hills 90210 San Marcos,CA 92069 Corona Del Mar, CA 92625
502 591 020 502 591 021 502 591 022
Gonzalo Romero&Ann Romero Billy& Shirley Lyon Irma Salinas
1970 Del Mar Ave 7231 Palm Ave 1180 Eaay St#C
San Marino,CA 91108 Highland,CA 92346 San Francisco,CA 94109
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 2 of 24
502 591 023 502 591 024 502 591 025
Patricia Watford Vern&Mary Vilhauer Gary James Wilcox
25447 Via Novia 2700 E Mesquite North Ave#D24 4513 Cove Dr
Valencia, CA 91355 Palm Sprigs, CA 92264 Carlsbad,CA 92008
502 591 026 502 591 027 502 591 028
Friedland Michael&Rebecca Mcclelland Min Hung
95 S Market St#640 Barbara Madrid 7231 Palm Ave
San Jose, CA 95113 PO Box 502348 Highland,CA 92346
San Diego,CA 92150
502 591 029 502 591 030 502 591 031
391259 Alberta Ltd Harold&Bettie Johnson Clarence Haack
139 Hampton Park N W Alb 2731 Brierhaven Dr 2112 Linda Flora Dr
CALGARY AB T3A 5A6 La Crescents,CA 91214 Los Angeles,CA 90077
CANADA
502 591 034 502 591 035 502 591 036
Kenneth Waltz&Amin Marie Waltz Carol Newton Glaser Roland D&Inge H
6445 E Oakview Ln 12113 Beverly Blvd#Q Glaser
Anaheim Hills,CA 92807 Whittier,CA 90601 607 S Glenwood PI
Burbank,CA 91506
502 591 037 502 591 038 502 591 039
Larry&Mary Lou Halfon Randall&Yvonne Brown Snyder Wendell K&Peggy J
1709 128th Ave SE 2700 E Mesquite Ave#F36 Snyder
Bellevue,WA 98005 Palm Springs,CA 92264 1377 Via Esperanza
San Dimas,CA 91773
502 591 040 502 591 041 680 020 004
Alan&Helen Smith James Temple City Of Pa prat
2700 E Mesquite North Ave#F40 74924 Country Club Dr#130 PO B 743
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Desert,CA 92260 Pa m Springs,CA 92263
680 020 010 680 020 036 680 020 038
City Of Pahn rings City Of Pa Springs Southern California Edison Cc
PO Box 2 PO B 743 PO Box 800
Palm S rings,CA 92263 P Springs,CA 92263 Rosemead,CA 91770
680 020 039 680 020 043 680 020 051
Ciry Of Pah prings City Of Springs City Of Pa rings
PO Box 43 PO x 2743 PO B 43
Pal prings,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92263 P Springs, CA 92263
680 020 052 680 051 003 680 051 004
Cl
Of Pa pr ngs Carmen Ruiz&Jose Ruiz Rodney&Uschi Wilson
PO Bo 43 646 S El Cielo Rd 753 N Las Palmas Ave
Pa prings,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Los Angeles, CA 90038
680 OS 00 680 051 006 680 0 1 0
Peter&J t Trascott Peter&Janet Truscott Edwar ervmsky
3300E Sum unes Rd 3300 E Sunny Dunes Rd 2638 S lonial Ave
Pahn Spring C 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 on
, 91761
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 3 of 24
n
680"I 8 680051009 680051010
7oyce Estat f Segundo Troy Johnson Armando&Guillermina Landeros
44440 Acaci Dr 657 S Desert View Dr 641 S Desert View Dr
Palm Desert, V 92260 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Springs, CA 92264
680 052 003 680 052 004 680 052 005
James Eaton&Ida Eaton Ernesto Carino&Betty Carina Ashley Bennett C
642 S Desert View Dr 1100 E Alejo Rd PO Box 4220
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92262 Pahn Springs, CA 92263
680 052 006 680 052 007 680 052 008
Edgar&Joan Fergon Calum&Laura Hughes Theodore Malagar Jr.
3400 E Sunny Dunes Rd 695 S Highland Dr 677 S Highland Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 052 009 680 052 010 680 053 003
Theodore Malagar Jr. Steve&Michelle Abernathy Armando&Maria Alvarez
677 S Highland Dr 641 S Highland Or 642 S Highland Or
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 053 004 680 053 005 680 053 006
Rick Richards&Ruth Richards Esther Malagar Nevis Staashehn
656 S Highland Dr 670 S Highland Dr 39140 Ciega Creek Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Desert,CA 92260
680 053 0 7 680 053 008 680 053 009
Emelle Sonh Gary Adkinson Jose Rodriguez
PO Box 5662 2101 2nd Ave N 657 Desert Way
Palm Springs, A 92263 Saint Petersburg,FL 33713 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 053 010 680 054 003 680 054 004
Julian Queddeng&Henninia Quedden Norman Johns&Cindy Johns Herberto Griessmann
635 Desert Way 642 Desert Way 656 Desert Way
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 054 005 680 054 006 680 054 007
Terrel Crary&Minnie Crary Romeo&haelda Malasig Jose&Dehnis Oliva
670 Desert Way 4273 E Calle San Raphael 3580 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 054 008 680 054 009 680 054 010
Wayne Roldan Alex Roldan Brian Beall&Martha Beall
246 E Avenida Granada PO Box 300 641 S Mountain View Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Beverly Hills,CA 90213 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 055 003 680 055 004 680 055 005
Paul Winkler&Patricia Winkler Alexander Roldan Evelyn Henson Mills
642 S Mountain View Dr PO Box 4825 3354 Winter Wren PI
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92263 Fremont,CA 94555
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 4 of 24
680 055 006 680 055 013 680 055 014
Homer& Cynthia Rivera Novis Staashelm Clifford Gordon Christopher
688 S Mountain View Dr 39140 Ciega Creek Dr 677 El Placer Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Desert,CA 92260 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 055 015 680 055 016 690 065 001
Scott Beattie Ileana&Francisco Fernando Solis Leonidas &Consuelo Porras
657 El Placer Rd 641 El Placer Rd 3731 E Camino San Miguel
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 065 002 680 065 003 680 06 004
Amado Salinas Schott Thomas E&S G Carmelo z
3761 E Camino San Miguel 3781 E Camino San Miguel 3711 E ro San Miguel
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm S CA 92264
680 065 005 680065006 1 680 065 007
Senner Gary&Senner Gary Gary&Lu is Yonata Betty Jo&Charles Barnes
3831 E Camino San Miguel 3861 E C ' o San Miguel 1019 N Morris Ave
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Sprig , A 92264 West Covina,CA 91790
680 065 008 680 065 009 680 065 010
Gary&Judy Topoliski Ana Lozono&Carlos Barajas Joanne Plummer
3960 E Calle San Antonio 3862 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3832 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Sprigs, CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 065 011 680 065 012 680 065 013
Ramon&Maria Elena Gonzalez Jose&Evelia Jimenez Rafael&Eva Martin
Francisco Gonzalez 3782 E Sunny Dunes Rd 913 S Bamdal St
3812 E Sunny Dunes Rd Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264 Santa Ana, CA 92704
Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 065 014 680 065 015 680 065 016
Garcia Rose &Joseph A&Anthony Regina Dipaola Amado&Ruth Pespes
Garcia 3711 E Camino San Miguel 4330 E Camino San Simeon
2099 E Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Sprigs, CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
Palm Sprigs,CA 92262
680 066 001 680 066 002 68006 003
Ernesto Agtang Bert&Decie Bitanga Frontier undation
4065 E Camino San Miguel 4012 E Camino San Miguel PO Box 0
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Patton, A 92369
680 066 004 680 066 005 680 066 006
Clayr Aralquez&Paterna Ramoran Arnold&Luzcelia Acacio Arthur Alfred Jurado
3933 E Camino San Miguel 3910 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3920 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 066 007 680 066 008 680 066 009
Robert Stover Julio&Jimenez Norma Cones Richard&Julia Lopez Sr.
3940 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3952 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4012 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
Lase o.uboo Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 5 of 24
680 066 010 680 066 011 680 066 012
Michelle Dickey Benjamin&Benamin Prieto Jr. Robert Pelton&Ruth Pelton
4030 E Sunny Dunes Rd Yolanda Scott 4082 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 31530 Whispering Palms Trl Pahn Springs,CA 92264
Cathedral City,CA 92234
680 071 004 680 072 005 680 072 009
Weiner Brown Sungold Development Co Sungold velopment Co
6400 Variel Ave PO Box 810490 PO B 810490
Woodland Hills,CA 91367 Dallas,TX 75381 D as,TX 75381
680 073 004 680 073 005 680 07 001
City Of Pahn prings City Of Palm S ' gs Charles sley
PO Box 2 3400 E T uitz Canyon Way 4499 E C e De Carlos
Palm S Angs, CA 92263 Pahl rings,CA 92262 Pahn Sp ng CA 92264
680 074 Od2 680 081 004 680 082 001
Rufmo Ag &EA nda Agriam Palm Springs died School Dist Rely Rodas &Ros, o Rodas
3 Aveni Dimino (none) 3108 California St
Cathedral CA 92234 Pa pr ngs,CA 92262 Oakland,CA 94602
680 082 012 680 083 001 680 083 012
Arnold Leon Carolyn Thomas Prances ford
4480 E Camino San Simeon 4485 E Camino San Simeon 1268 E R on Rd#59
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Sp CA 92264
680 084 001 680 084 002 680 084 003
Janette Marie Ennis Henry Gonzales&Rafaela Gonzales Rogelio Agregado&Corazon Agregad
1010 Andreas Palms Dr 4441 E Camino San Miguel 4425 E Camino San Miguel
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 084 004 680 084 005 680 084 006
Arthur&Consuelo Godinez Amy Baggott Rudy Martinez&Antonia Martinez
4379 E Camino San Miguel 4341 E Camino San Miguel 4317 E Canino San Miguel
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 084 007 680 084 008 680 084 009
Rosalinda V qu z&Olga Salinas Sto Este Cadang Juan Imus &G A Josephine
6780 Koster N 4350 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4347 E Smmy Dunes Rd
Elk Grove,CA 58 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 084 010 680 084 011 680 084 012
Jose Gonzalez&Josefma Gonzalez Ben&Julie Bauumer Alan Granger&Lydia Granger
4390 E Sunny Dunes Rd 68921 Risueno Rd 4466 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Cathedral City,CA 92234 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 091 005 680 091 006 680 091 007
Michael Sts&Romanian Orthodox Gab Shelby Coffey&Coffey Nancy Strong Shelby Coffey&C fey Nancy Strong
PO Box 9197 300 E 62nd St#1503 300 E 62nd St 03
Palm Springs,CA 92263 New York,NY 10021 New Yor Y 10021
Case 5,0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 6 of 24
680 091 008 680 093 003 680 093 006
Whitehead Prop&Marion Leonard Son Wiefel Son Wie
4511 E Sunny Dunes Rd#B 630 S V a Rd 630 ella Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pa pangs,CA 92264 ahn Sprhigs, CA 92264
680 093 010 680093011 680 094 005
Son Wiefe Wiefels&Son Inc Scott Al&Teke
630 S ella Rd 630 S Vella Rd 1155 E Marion Way
Paltif Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 094 006 680 102 006 680 103 009
Dilhnan Opal B Whitehead Properties Llc Northbrook Prop Inc
PO Box 8368 680 S Williams Rd PO Box 1287
Bend,OR 97708 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Northbrook,IL 60065
680 111 001 680 111 002 680 111 003
Bonifacio &Maria Perez Benjamin Iniguez&Graciela Iniguez Michael Gallagher
3531 E Sunny Dunes Rd 709 S Orange Ave 727 S Orange Ave
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 111 008 680 111 009 680 111 010
City Of Pa prings City Of Springs City Of Pal pr ngs
PO Be 43 P ox 2743 PO 1786
P prings, CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92263 ahn Springs,CA 92263
680 111 011 680 Ill 012 680 111 013
City Of Pal prings City Of Springs City Of Pa rings
PO Bo 43 P ox 2743 PO B 43
Pa prings,CA 92263 ahn Springs,CA 92263 Pa n Springs,CA 92263
680 111 014 680 Ill 015 680 111 016
City Of Pa prings City Of P Springs City Of Pa prings
PO Box 43 PO 2743 PO 2743
Pahn prings,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92263
680 111 017 680 111020 680 Ill 022
City Of P Springs Epifania Cardoza Drg
PO B 2743 708 S California Ave 3341 Seneca Dr
Pa Springs, CA 92263 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Las Vegas,NV 89109
680 111 023 680 111 024 680 Ill 027
Teen Challenge Of Southern California Antoine&Claire Mansour City Of P Springs
PO Box 5039 615 Clinton PI PO B 2743
Riverside,CA 92517 Beverly Hills,CA 90210 P Springs,CA 92263
680 111 028 680 111 029 680 111 030
City Of Palm rings City Of Pa prings City Of Palm rugs
PO Box 27 PO Box 43 PO Box 3
Pahn Sp as,CA 92263 Palm rings, CA 92263 Pa prings,CA 92263
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 7 of 24 y
680 111�Paprings
680 111 033 680 111 034
City Of Palm Spritgs 'ty City Of Pal r ngs
PO Bo PO Box 6 PO Bo 43
Palm prangs, CA 92263 Pa pr ngs,CA 92263 Pa Springs,CA 92263
680 111 035 680 111 036 680 111 037
Palm Spain ity Of City Of Pa pangs City Of Palm S gs
3133 7t t PO B 786 PO Box 2
Riv side,CA 92507 Pa Springs,CA 92263 Pa pangs,CA 92263
680 111 038 680 111 039 680 111 041
Palm Sp City Of Palm Spain tty Of Evangeline Cajucom
PO Bog 786 PO Bo� 86 3714 Brilliant PI
Pal�Springs, CA 92263 Pahu ?Ipn.ngs,CA 92263 Los Angeles,CA 90065
680 ill 042 680 111 043 6801 1 0
City Of Palm rings Norman Canales&Pauline Canales David ys Zane Farnsworth
PO Box 3 700 S California Ave 323 Bro way E#1004
Pal prings, CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Seattle W 98102
680 111 045 680 111 048 680 111 049
Antoine&Claire Mansour City Of Palm rings City Of Palm SVPAS
615 Clinton PI PO Box 2 3 PO Box 2
Beverly Hills, CA 90210 Palm ran s,CA 92263 PahuRt5rings,CA 92263
6801/051680111O51 111052Palm Angl CorpAngl CoPO B 2097 Ri est Dr 2097 crest Dr
Palm92263 Glen e,CA 91207 (146dale,CA 91207
680 111 053 680 111 054 680 111 055
Angl Corp City Of Pa pr ngs City Of Pah prangs
2097 Rnncrest Dr I Bo 743 PO B 43
Glendale, CA 91207 Pah Springs,CA 92263 P Springs,CA 92263
680 112 001 680 112 002 680 112 003
Robin Garcia&Adela Garcia Richard Brown Nicholas Panzarim Jr.
3405 E Sunny Dunes Rd 707 S California Ave Susan Mari Panzarim
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 35062 Serenade
Thousand Palms,CA 92276
680 112 004 680 112 OS 680 112 008
Nhu Tran b Lo e II City Of Palm ngs
PO Box 27738 285 ny Rd E PO Bo 43
Las Vegas,NV 89126 MISS AUGA ON P Springs, CA 92263
CAN
680 112 009 680 O1 680 112 O11City Of Palm rings :112
Of Springs City Of P Springs
PO Box 2 3 ox 2743 PO 2743
Palm, rings,CA 92263 Springs,CA 92263 Springs,CA 92263
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs ,Page 8 of 24
680 112 013 680 112 014 680 112 015
Samuel&Gloria Ramirez Dore David&Ronna Mee Brand Nikolova Von&Current Resident
710 S Palm Ave Riki Barrett Brand 500 W Rafael#28
Palm Springs,CA 92264 720 S Palm Ave Patin Springs, CA 92262
Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 112 017 680 112 018 680 112 019
City Of Palm S mgs City Of Pa prings City Of Pati prnrgs
PO Box 27 PO Box 86 PO Bo 43
Palm S 'ngs, CA 92263 Pa prings,CA 92263 Pal prings, CA 92263
680 112 020 680 112 021 , 680 112 022
City Of P Springs City Of P Springs City OF Palm. 'rmgs
PO Bo 743 PO 1786 PO Box
Pali prings,CA 92263 Springs, CA 92263 Pa prings,CA 92263
680 112 023 680 112 024 6804as89109
City Of Palm S gs City Of P Springs �33
PO Box 27 PO 2743 Palm S gs,CA 92263 P Springs,CA 92263 ,
t
680 112 028 680 112 029 680 113 006
City Of P m Springs M Max Eckert City Of P Springs
PO B 2743 2311 Berkeley Ave PO B 2743
Pa Sprmgs,CA 92263 Los Angeles,CA 90026 Palm Springs,CA 92263
680 113 007 680 113 00 680 113 009
Ciry Of P Springs City
Of m Sprmgs Palm Sprin City Of
PO B 2743 PO x 2743 PO Bo 86
P Springs,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92263 P prings, CA 92263
680/113 680 113 0 680 113 012Citings City Of alm Springs CityOfPa prings
PO PO x 1786 PO Box 43
PalA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92263 Palm rings, CA 92263
680 1130 13 680 113 014 680 113 015
City Of P m Springs City Of P m Springs City Of Pal Springs
PO Bo 743 PO B 2743 PO Bo 43
Pah prings, CA 92263 P Springs,CA 92263 Palm prings,CA 92263
R
680 113 016 680 113 017 680 113 018 1
City Of Pa r Springs City Of P Springs City Of Pa prmgs
PO Box 743 PO Bo 743 PO Box 6
Palm rings,CA 92263 Pal , Springs,CA 92263 Palm rings, CA 92263
680 113 019 680 113 02 680 113 Z
City Of P n Springs City Of atin Springs City Of s
PO Box 743 PO B 1786 PO B 2743
Palm rings,CA 92263 Pa Springs,CA 92263 Pa Springs, CA 92263
case 5.U96b Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 9 of 24
680 113 022 680 113 023 680 113 024 ..
City Of Palm rings City Of P pr ngs City Of Pah prings
PO Box 27 PO Box 43 PO Bo r43
Palm S tgs, CA 92263 Palm rings,CA 92263 Pa Springs,CA 92263
680 113 025 680 113 029 680 113 031
City Of PalipeSprings Helen Callies&Edward Hill Jr. Arla Provo
PO Box 743 3305 E Sunny Dimes Rd 705 S Palm Ave
Palm S rings, CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 113 032 680 113 033 680 120 001
George Hernandez Dig Keith&Chisholm John Pidcock
3207 29th Ave W 3341 Seneca Dr 777 El Placer Rd
Seattle,WA 98199 Las Vegas,NV 89109 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 120 002 680 120 003 680 120 004
Cynthia Muller Aurelio&Esther Juan Josephine Kelly
PO Box 474 737 El Placer Rd 715 El Placer Rd
Rancho Mirage,CA 92270 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 120 005 680 120 006 680 120 007
Edward Scanlan&Patricia Scanlan Vincent Mcmurrow-purcell Steven Hedge
1112 Wakefield 3633 E Sunny Dunes Rd 464 S Calle Encilia#A3
Anaheim, CA 92802 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92262
680 120 008 680 120 00 680 120 0 0
Hannes Scherber Hannes herber Great a fic Money Market Inc
68100 Ramon Rd#C10 681 Ramon Rd#C10 1059 aim St#R
Cathedral City,CA 92234 thedral City,CA 92234 Orange, 92867
680 120 011 680 120 012 680 120 013
Hilda Rafull Isabelo Esteban&Eusebia Esteban Hannes Sc er
785 S Motmtain View Dr 737 S Mountain View Dr 6810 amon Rd#C8
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Ca edral City,CA 92234
680 120 014 680 120 015 680 120 016
Caroline Tisl Patricia Tisliko Shondrick William D& Survivors Karen Pope
717 S Monntam iew Dr 68144 Valley Vista Dr 3541 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs,C 2264 Cathedral City,CA 92234 Pahn Springs, CA 92264
680 120 017 680 120 018 680 120 019
Sofia Macavinta Anthony Savidge Dale Homer&Ione Cather Thompson
710 Desert Way 720 Desert Way 722 Desert Way
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 120 020 680 120 021 680 120 023
David Lavigne&Lynn Yada Raul&Kimberly Licon Julie Rupp
736 Desert Way PO Box 2021 733 Desert Way
Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 10 of 24
680 120 024 680 t20 025 680 120 026
Toms& Candace Kay Brust Paul Yoh Pedro&Ontiveros Martha Gabriel
729 Desert Way 717 Desert Way 705 Desert Way
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 12 02 680 120 031 680 120 032
Carol Wa 't City Of Pa rings Pahn Springs Youth Center
701 Desert ay PO Box 43 PO Box 9530
Palm Spring , A 92264 Pa prings,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92263
680 120 034 680 131 001 680 131 002
Albert Howell Loreto&Jose Palafox Jaclyn&Kenneth Piner
PO Box 9288 932 S Calle Paul 3737 E Sunny Dimes Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 131 003 680 131 004 680 131 005
Carolyn Pellegrino William Legrave Adam Caudell
3767 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3787 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3817 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 131 006 680 131 007 680 131 008
Guillermo Jimenez&Esequiel Jimenez Rosalina Sally Stachowski Irma Flores
3837 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3867 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3887 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 131 009 680 131 010 680 131 Ol l
Oscar Martin&Silvia Lizarraga Carlos&Sharon Abrille Jacquelyn Miller
3880 E Calle San Antonio 3860 E Calle San Antonio 255 N El Cielo No 140 242
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92262
680 131 012 680 131 013 680 131 014
Ruth Sale Angela&Brenagh Carl Pulido Jr. Joseph Barrett
PO Box 1154 3780 E Calle San Antonio 88 Madrone Ave
Palm Springs,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264 San Francisco,CA 94127
680 131 015 680 131 016 680 132 001
Jack Kilgore&Gail Kilgore Patrick&Jennifer Scanlan Ida Schwartz
1482 E Palm Tree Dr 3720 E Calle San Antonio 2321 S Araby Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 132 002 680 132 003 680 132 004
Manuel&Perlita Vega Nestor&Shirley Jove Arthur Studebaker&Hope Studebaker
3937 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3967 E Sunny Dunes Rd 3987 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 132 005 680 132 006 680 132 007
Marc Bernstein&Jesus Perez Jose Gutierrez Bert Bitanga&Decie Bitanga
1060 Fulton St 4037 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4067 E Sunny Dunes Rd
San Francisco,CA 94117 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 11 of 24
680 132 008 680 132 010 680 132011
Michael Brady Marleni Guerra Rodriguez Graciela&Villalba Emidio
4087 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4060 E Calle San Antonio 4040 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 132 012 680 132 013 680 132 014
Quinonez Antonia Joarm Sendejas Gary&Judy Topolinski
4020 E Calle San Antonio 77065 Florida Ave 3933 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Desert,CA 92211 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 132 015 680 132 016 680 133 001
Roger Jones &Fredrich Jones Magdalena Morlina Scott Krueger
3940 E Calle San Antonio 3920 E Calle San Antonio 3713 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 133 002 680 133 003 680 133 004
Luzviminda Madrid&Lemuel Madrid Gary&Kelly Phillips Carsolino Andrade&Guadalupe Andra
3733 E Calle San Antonio 3763 E Calle San Antonio 3032 Nevada Ave
Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 El Monte,CA 91731
680 133 005 680 133 006 680 133 007
Alan&Janeth Agbayam Jerrell Williamson Thomas Eugene Flanagan Sr.
3813 E Calle San Antonio 3833 E Calle San Antonio 3863 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 133 008 680 133 009 680 133 010
Thomas&Cynthia Flanagan Jr. Gene& Susan Buzard Patricia Hawkinson
3883 E Calle San Antonio 933 Kregmont Dr PO Box 1883
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Glendora,CA 91741 Rancho Mirage, CA 92270
680 133 Ol l 680 133 012 680 133 013
Jorge Gomez William Olvera Donna Hart
3834 E Calle San Raphael 3814 E Calle San Raphael 3784 E Calle San Raphael
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 133 014 680 133 015 680 133 016
John Camangian Prado Filomena Del Donna Riley
3570 E Camino Rojos PO Box 446 3714 E Calle San Raphael
Palm Springs,CA 92262 Palm Springs,CA 92263 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 134 003 680 134 004 680 134 005
Allen Lettington Saul Zatarain Ruel&Raymunda Malasig
3963 E Calle San Antonio 2322 N Deborah Rd 4411 E Calle De Carlos
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92262 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 134 006 680 1 00 680 134 008
Rebecca&Gross Jerry Hunter Rodney a e Midf rst Bk
881 Lawrence Ave 10945 Ho se St 9101 4083 E Calle San Antonio
Westminster,CA 92683 West Hills, 91304 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 12 of 24
680 134 00 680 134 010 680 134 011
Janice Neil Juan&Laura Jimenez Aurora&Jorge Gomez
4084 E Calle a Raphael 4064 E Calle San Raphael Maria Rose
Palm Sprin , CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 4034 E Calle San Raphael
Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 134 012 680 134 013 680 134 014
Anastacia Tangeora Frank&Lugarda Reyes Jr. Arnulfo&Joel Gutierrez
4014 E Calle San Raphael 3984 E Calle San Raphael Anmlfo Gutierrez Jr.
Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 3964 E Calle San Raphael
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 134 015 680 134 016 680 134 017
Reginald Montoya Chun Kim Mike Delgado&Gloria Delgado
3974 E Camino San Simeon 3914 E Calle San Raphael 3913 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 134 018 680 135 001 680 135 002
Mark&Cynthia Crocker Michael&Mercelyn Gonzales Ruben Zepeda Ballesteros
3933 E Calle San Antonio 3935 E Calle San Raphael 3951 E Calle San Raphael
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 135 003 680 135 004 680 135 005
Esmeraldo&Victoria Coloma Katherine Serafin Maria Socorro Gerada
3991 E Calle San Raphael 4011 E Calle San Raphael Luz Bernardit Gerada
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264 4015 E Calle San Raphael
Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 135 006 680 135 007 680 135 008
Scott Wendell&James Mcclure Denis&Hugaette Choquette Sylvia Weathers&Mariel Solais
4019 E Calle San Raphael 4035 E Calle San Raphael 423 Myrdewood Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Calimesa,CA 92320
680 135 009 680 135 010 680 135 011
Richard Thibodeaux Benjamin Knight Richard&Cherie Pierce
Katherine Thibodeaux 4018 E Paseo Luisa 4008 E Paseo Luisa
4028 E Paseo Luisa Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 135 012 680 136 001 680 136 002
Martine&Jacques Guiragossian Pilareta Opaon Michael Gonzales&Mercelyn Gonzale
840 S Avenida Evelita 821 S Avenida Evelita 855 S Avenida Evelita
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264
680 136 003 680 136 004 680 136 005
Solon Rodas &Agripina Rodas Solon Rodas gripI Rodas Emilio Coloma&Christina Coloma
885 S Avenida Evelita 885 S Av a Evelita 891 S Avenida Evelita
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm rigs, CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 136 006 680 136 007 680 137 001
Remedios&Yarm Shirley Deguia Steven Baynes&K Johnson Sugi Charles &Joy Brown
899 S Avenida Evelita 903 S Avenida Evelita 4003 E Paseo Luisa
Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 13 of 24
680 137 002 680 137 003 680 137 004
Timothy&Magdalena Willey Carlos Reyes&Chun Reyes Rafael Jimenez
4029 E Pasco Luisa 4037 E Pasco Luisa 910 S Avenida Evelita
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 137 005 680 141 001 680 141 002
Julio&Alba Antunez Johnny&Josephine Imus Tante&Ricarte Agbayam
916 S Avenida Evelita 4309 E Sunny Dunes Rd Bienvenida
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 628 S Mountain View Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 141 003 680 141 004 680 141 005
Victoria Entiquez Vera Maravilla& Susan Marie Godinez Manuel&Alejandra Mercado
4237 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4217 E Sunny Dimes Rd 4187 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 141 006 680 141 007 680 141 008
Audrey Reimers John&Mary Greene Genaro&Maria Orozco
4167 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4137 E Sunny Dimes Rd 4117 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 141 009 680 141 010 680 141 O l l
Hess A Beattie Dorothy A Gerald Gillette&Janette Gillette
PO Box 446 4140 E Calle San Antonio 4160 E Calle San Antonio
Seal Bea r, A 90740 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 141 012 680 141 013 680 141 014
Fernando Jhnenez&Juana Jimenez Benjamin&Yolanda Gonzalez Samuel Ortega
4180 E Calle San Antonio 4220 E Calle San Antonio 67205 Raugo Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Cathedral City,CA 92234
680 141 018 680 141 019 680 142 001
Juan&Maria Ceron Steve&Antonette Husbands Aidamatie Opleda
4260 E Calle San Antonio 4280 E Calle San Antonio 4283 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 142 002 680 142 003 680 142 004
Michael Verrochi Benita Campuzano&Jose Juan Campu Calarence Macy
4263 E Calle San Antonio 4233 E Calle San Antonio 4213 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 142 005 680 142 006 680 142 007
Antonio Ramil&Hemuma Ramil Leonam Tintero&Maricel Agtang Rodolfo Armendariz&Trinidad Armen
4183 E Calle San Antonio 4163 E Calle San Antonio 4133 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 142 008 680 142 009 680 142 010
Trent&Allison Gibson Tenoy Cadang Mariquita Domingo
105 Wimbeldon Ct 4114 E Calle San Raphael PO Box 486
Stafford,VA 22556 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Ridgecrest,CA 93556
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 14 of 24
680142011 680 142 012 680 142 013
Francisco&Herm nia Cruz Vaughn&Veneita Brudvik Vaughn&Ve rta Brudvik
4164 E Calle San Raphael 1402 Via Roberto Miguel 1402 Vi oberto Miguel
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92262 Pa "rings,CA 92262
680 142 014 680 142 015 680 142 016
Armando &April Juarez Daniel Garcia&Virginia Garcia Amor Cara
4234 E Calle San Raphael 4264 E Calle San Raphael 4284 E Calle San Raphael
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 143 001 680 143 002 680 143 003
Carolyn Cara Benjamin&Elizabeth Soriente Ernest&Helen Otte
822 S Paseo Caroleta 4193 E Calle San Raphael 4211 E Calle San Raphael
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 143 004 680 143 005 680 143 006
Charito &Josefma Balanay Fidel Agriam&Milagros Agriam Norma Hines&Aldon Hines
R Trinidad 4273 E Calle San Raphael 871 S Calle Santa Cruz
42355 E Calle San Raphael Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Pahn Springs, CA 92264
680 143 007 680 143 008 680 143 009
Fernando Samsam&Cora Samsam Pauline Olvera&William Olvera Sharon Brennan
901 S Calle Santa Cruz 3814 E Calle San Raphael 955 S Calle Santa Cruz
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 143 010 680 143 011 680 143 012
Victor Reyes&Mary Reyes Krouse Donald J Vince&Hang Lam
965 S Calle Santa Cruz 960 S Paseo Caroleta 958 S Paseo Caroleta
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 143 013 680 143 014 680 143 015
Marc Bernstein Norlito Agriam&Ofelina Agiam John&Sandra Rosson
956 S Paseo Caroleta 933 S Paseo Caroleta 7 Karlisa Cv
Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 143 016 680 143 017 680 143 018
Kathy Ruiz Clarissa B Fawcett Pedro Angeles Jr.
6 Karlisa Cv PO Box 914 4 Karlisa Cv
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Fall City,WA 98024 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 143 019 680 143 020 680 143 021
Sharon Quesada Oscar&Teresa Camero Daniel&Maria Cook
3 Karlisa Cv 708 S Paseo Caroleta 890 S Paseo Caroleta
Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 144 003 680 144 004 680 144 006
John&Laura Perez Donald Mendoza&Virginia Mendoza Santiago&Margaret Delgado
913 S Paseo Carolem 925 S Paseo Caroleta 957 S Paseo Caroleta
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
lase o.U96o Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 15 of 24
680 144 007 680 144 008 680 144 009
Johnny Estate Of Isidore Jon&Elaine Colbert Virginia Gross
Norman Lifpitz 969 S Pasco Caroleta 973 S Pasco Caroleta
36032 Donny Cir Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
Pahn Desert, CA 92211
680 144 010 680 144011 680 144 012
Pablo Contreras Santos Santacruz Joshua&Hayley Crow
981 S Pasco Caroleta 987 S Calle Santa Cruz 982 S Pasco Dorotea
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 144 013 680 144 014 680 144 015
Vittorio Ramones Barut Satumino&Leticia Soto Enrique&Fortina Solis
Ramona Macadan Barut 950 S Pasco Dorotea 942 S Pasco Dorotea
970 S Pasco Dorotea Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 144 016 680 144 017 680 144 018
Michael Huckins Jr. &Peter Wells Richard Wilhelm Alicia Corpuz&Allan Ahorro
2428 Tamarisk Dr 930 S Pasco Dorotea 924 S Pasco Dorotea
Santa Rosa,CA 95405 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 144 019 680 144 021 680 144 023
Tiburcio Macavinta Tim Stewart Joaquin&Concepcion Faster
912 S Pasco Dorotea 882 S Pasco Dorotea 804 S Pasco Dorotea
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 144 024 680 144 025 680 144 026
Carlos&Ramona Carranza Charles Heinz&Martha Heinz Fidel&Cristeta Cabacungan
803 S Pasco Caroleta 816 S Pasco Dorotea Francisca
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 827 S Pasco Caroleta
Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 145 001 680 145 003 680 145 004
Carolyn Goodwin Kahnema Price Michael Woody&Mary Kristine Wood
915 S Pasco Dorotea 927 S Pasco Dorotea 939 S Pasco Dorotea
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 145 005 680 145 006 680 145 007
Charles Hughes&Vicki Hughes Manuel&Kara Montenegro III Kahnema Price
953 S Pasco Dorotea 957 S Pasco Dorotea 927 S Pasco Dorotea
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 145 009 680 145 010 680 145 011
Lorenzo Salvidar&Antonio Syl Salvid Antonio&Artemisa Sesma Jorge Rodriguez&Virginia Rodriguez
988 S Avenida Evelita 960 S Avenida Evelita 944 S Avenida Evelita
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 14501 680 145 013 680 145 014
Humberto De ant Perez Eduer&Susan Agresor Richard Wolff
Egricelda&Hu Perez 928 S Avenida Evelita PO Box 2170
936 S Avenida Ev Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92263
Palm Springs,CA 2 4
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 16 of 24
680 145 015 680 151 001 680 151 002
Matthew Bamberg&Todd Larson David Buckles&Charles Hay Alexander Eros&Ofelia Eros
920 S Avenida Evelita 4489 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4465 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Patin Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 151 003 680 151 004 680 151 005
Martin&Dora Villalobos Miller Florence L Juan&Josephine Imus
4433 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4411 E Sunny Dunes Rd 4347 E Sunny Dunes Rd
Patin Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 151 006 6" 151 007 "0 151 008
Juan Imus&Jose ine Aveci Imes Juan Imus& -Sep hine Ave Imus Juan Imus Josephine Imus
4309 E Sumry unes Rd 4375 E S y Dunes Rd 4347 unny Dunes Rd
Palm Sp ' ', CA 92264 Patin prings,CA 92264 Pa Springs,CA 92264
680 151 009 680 151 010 680 151 O l l
Thomas Bollinger Jr. Alma Berry Edward Allen
4310 E Calle San Antonio 4344 E Calle San Antonio 4370 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 151 012 680 151 013 680 151 014
Anthony Taricco&Curtis Head Jr. Dennis Sonico &Jeanne Sonico Alicia Rodriguez
4388 E Calle San Antonio 4412 E Calle San Antonio 4424 E Calle San Antonio
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 151 015 680 151 016 680 151 017
Fon Young Park Marilyn Johnson James Cahill
4460 E Calle San Antonio 740 S Calle Paul 762 S Calle Paul
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 151 018 680 151 019 680 151 020
Robert Harrison Leonard&Christine Ferro Felix &Isabel Rivera
784 S Calle Paul 812 S Calle Paul 852 S Calle Paul
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 151 021 680 151 022 680 151 023
Jesus Orea Jose Luis &Alicia Escobar Christian&Corie Guillermo
886 S Calle Rd Alicia 932 S Calle Paul
Palm Springs,CA 92264 906 S Calle Paul Patin Springs,CA 92264
Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 151 024 680 151 025 680 151 026
Spike Meyers&Peter Finley Carolyn Maglione Zulema Cantu
PO Box 2384 976 S Calle Paul 980 S Calle Paul
Palm Springs, CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Patin Springs,CA 92264
680 151 027 680 151 028 680 151 029
Gerda Stefanoff Sylvia Gaumann Eric&Joseph Sander
998 S Calle Paul 4475 E Pasco Caroleta M Jennie
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 4425 E Pasco Caroleta
Palm Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 17 of 24
680 151 030 680 151 031 680 151 032
Candace Kuauf Federico Bulacan Patricia Stair
4385 E Paseo Caroleta 4361 E Paseo Caroleta 4355 E Paseo Caroleta
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 151 033 680 151 034 680 151 043
Roy Dollman Felipe Genera&Eva Genera Richard&Paulette Koerie
863 Wellesley Ave 4303 E Paseo Caroleta 4318 E Mesquite Ave
Los Angeles,CA 90049 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 151 044 680 151 045 680 151 046
Mary Lou Quintana Patrick Doane&Donna Doane Audrey Coleman
4344 E Mesquite Ave 4356 E Mesquite Ave 4388 E Mesquite Ave
Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 151 047 680 151 048 680 151 049
Ireneo& Wehna Domingo Richard Golay&Carota Golay Rene&Yolanda Floriano
4400 E Mesquite Ave 4420 E Mesquite Ave 4480 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264
680 152 001 680 152 002 680 152 003
Stolp Estelle Vander Norlito&Ofelina Agriarn Gerald Pelton&Pat Pelton
765 S Calle Paul 791 S Calle Paul 819 S Calle Paul
Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 152 004 680 152 005 680 152 006
Gerald Pelton&Patsy Pelton Allen Davis Jr. Olive Barker
819 S Calle Paul 881 S Calle Paul 905 S Calle Paul
Pahn Sprigs, CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264
680 152 007 680 152 008 680 152 009
C Morton Cliff Enrique&Lydia Hernandez Rafael&Claudia Rodriguez
927 S Calle Paul 965 S Calle Paul 975 S Calle Paul
Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 152 010 680 152 011 680 152 012
Thomas Davies&Joseph Marvici Dennis Jay Richard Romero&Betty Romero
989 S Calle Paul 990 S Calle Tomas 1520 Rockwood St
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Sprigs,CA 92264 Los Angeles,CA 90026
680 152 014 68Z& emrne
680 152 016
Virgil&Laverne Stevens Vi Stevens Juan Calleia&Alberto&M Perez
928 S Calle Tomas 92as 880 S Calle Tomas
Palm Springs,CA 92264 PaA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 152 017 680 152 018 680 152 019
Vicki&Mervin Epstein Darin&Rita Thompson Harry Albrecht&Barbara Albrecht
820 S Calle Tomas 802 S Calle Tomas 792 S Calle Tomas
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Sprigs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs, CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 18 of 24
680 152 020 680 153 001 680 153 002
Douglas Herrera&Ruth Mendez Iwao Kodama&Satsuko Kodama John&Lucy Cabacungan
766 S Calle Tomas 760 S Calle Santa Cruz 790 S Calle Santa Cruz
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 153 003 680 153 004 680 153 005
Lakshman&Nalini Abeyatunge David&Misty James William Gilliland
800 S Calle Santa Cruz 822 S Calle Santa Cruz 888 S Calle Santa Cruz
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 153 006 680 153 007 680 153 008
Donald Hetrick&Hannelore Hetrick Sanchez Frank Pamela Kramos
900 S Calle Santa Cruz 1023 Via Grande 17337 Victory Blvd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Cathedral City,CA 92234 Van Nuys,CA 91406
680 153 009 680 153 010 680 153 011
Jeffrey Kraybill Julia Williams Juan Manuel Lopez&Eva Delia Lopez
540 Ofarrell St#306 918 Comanche Ct 999 S Calle Tomas
San Francisco,CA 94102 Camarillo, CA 93010 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 153 012 680 153 013 680 153 014
Victor Ormero Suzana Arellano Ronnie Hallett
987 S Calle Tomas 955 S Calle Tomas 16234 Bellflower Blvd#11
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Bellflower,CA 90706
680 153 015 680 153 016 680 153 017
Julio Cesar Solano Charles Muller Omar&Ellena Custodio
901 S Calle Tomas 889 S Calle Tomas PO Box 8506
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92263
680 153 018 680 153 019 680 153 020
Billy Bitanga&Sonia Bitanga Melquiades&Elvira Cuevas Armando Arellano&Blanca Calleja
805 S Calle Tomas Elvira Cuevas 763 S Calle Tomas
Palm Springs,CA 92264 791 S Calle Tomas Palm Springs,CA 92264
Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 160 003 680 160 016 680 160 017
International Memorial Society Inc John Kerner E-z Storage Of Palm Springs Lle
4707 E Sunny Dunes Rd 815 S Williams Rd 785 S Williams Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 160 018 680 160 020 680 160 024
Bochner Lauren E&David Tms Bochn Eloyc ch 'dt Bochner Lauren E&David Tors Boclui
771 S Williams Rd 75593 C o De Paco 740 S Vella Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Indian Wel A 92210 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 160 025 680 160 026 680 160 027
Miller John&Mary Ann Jamison Whitehead Prop&Donald Williams
1014 23rd St PO Box 3191 4511 E SLmny Dunes Rd#B
Santa Monica,CA 90403 Palm Springs,CA 92263 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 19 of 24
680 160 030 680 160 032 680 160 033
Palm Springs Disposal Services Palm Springs Storage Partners Ltd Jack Haddad
PO Box 2711 4550 E Mesquite Ave#lA 2246 Betty Ln
Palm Springs, CA 92263 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Beverly Hills,CA 90210
680 160 036 680 160 037 680 160 040
Clyde& Cannella Lo Phillips Donald&Emily Williams General Telephone Co Of Calif
424 N Monterey Rd 4511 E Sunny Dunes Rd#B PO Box 152206
Palm Springs, CA 92262 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Irving,TX 75015
680 160 042 680 160 043 680 160 047
Whitehead Pro &Donald Williams Whitehead Pr &Donald Williams Whitehead Jack D &Prop
4511 E S Dunes Rd#B 4511 E S y Dunes Rd#B 3325 Monterey Rd
Pahn Sp gs, CA 92264 Palm prings,CA 92264 San Marino,CA 91108
680 160 048 680 160 049 680 160 050
Donald&Emily Williams Whitehead Pr Donald Williams Whitehead P &Donald Williams
4511 E Sunny Dunes Rd#B 4511 E 5 y Dunes Rd#B 4511 mry Dunes Rd#B
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm rings,CA 92264 PaH Springs,CA 92264
680 160 051 680 160 052 680 1 053
Donald Williams &Emily Williams Williams Donald E&E J Whitehea op
4511 E Sunny Dunes Rd#B 38-681 Bogert Trl 3325 me Rd
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92262 S armo,C 91108
680 160 054 680 511 001 680 511 002
Whitehea top Steven&Marta Loya Floyd Meneley&Mary Mcneley
3325 onterey Rd 4080 E Mesquite Ave 4060 E Mesquite Ave
5 armo,CA 91108 Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 511 003 680 1 00 680 511 005
Jack&Helen Hinton Michae sters Hnshang Shahidi
4040 E Mesquite Ave 950 S Nu Vista Dr 73985 Krug Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Spr' gs, CA 92264 Palm Desert,CA 92260
680 511 006 680 511 007 680 511 008
Juanita Baustista Janet Samuetian Lifpitz Nancy
930 S Nueva Vista Dr 14310 Chandler Blvd#6 36032 Donny Cir
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Van Nuys,CA 91401 Palm Desert,CA 92211
680 511 009 68051)369
680 512 002
Joseph Hopkms Vivienlass R A Hackett&Joanne Hackett
900 S Nueva Vista Dr PO Bo 3730 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Ruther94573 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 512 003 680 512 004 680 512 005
Max&Lenna Carizon Taila&Remikamen Hanni Ranta Deborah Barragan&Wanda Barragan
725 S Mountain View Dr Salla 3790 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 923 Arroyo Vista Dr Palm Springs,CA 92264
Palm Springs, CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 20 of 24
680 512 006 680 512 007 680 512 008
Paul Herlihy&Doris Herlihy Susanna Koo Rios P&P
3810 E Mesquite Ave 3830 E Mesquite Ave 68655 Hermosillo Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Cathedral City,CA 92234
680 512 009 680 512 010 680512011
Paul Polubinskas Otilia Hurtado Mary Schroeder
3870 E Mesquite Ave 3894 E Mesquite Ave 3910 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 512 012 680 512 013 680 512 014
William Ransom Jr. Michael Peroni&Cecelia Perom Ben&Rochelle Jones
3920 E Mesquite Ave 3940 E Mesquite Ave 3960 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 512 015 680 512 016 680 512 017
Virginia Ridgway Stuart&Koshnick Christine Funk Jackie Graham
3980 E Mesquite Ave 965 S Nueva Vista Dr 320 6th St
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Huntington Beach,CA 92648
680 512 019 680 521 001 680 521 002
Carol Bray Robert Allen&Joanne Allen Hrair Avakian
PO Box 676 3532 E Mesquite Ave 801 S Mountain View Dr
Temecula,CA 92593 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 521 003 680 522 001 680 522 002
Sergio&Patricia Perez Jeanne Schwarz Roderick David Gehrke
877 S Mountain View Dr 15944 Snow Creek Rd 52295 Avenida Herrera
Palm Springs, CA 92264 White Water,CA 92282 La Quinta,CA 92253
680 522 003 680 522 004 680 522 005
Partington John R Pridel&Socorro Moms James Weidinger
19860 Sideup Ln 891 El Placer Rd 867 El Placer Rd
Huntington Beach, CA 92646 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 522 006 680 522 007 680 523 001
Michael Wilke Mark Kress&Bruce Newman Maximo&Amelia Jose
835 El Placer Rd 803 El Placer Rd 812 El Placer Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 523 02 680 523 003 680 523 004
Tom&Ele *Rifer Richard Hoban Boyd Poulsen& Stella Poulsen
265 Araby St 812 Arroyo Vista Dr 804 S Nueva Vista Dr
Pahn Springs Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 523 005 680 523 006 680 523 007
Robert Olive Martin Curtis Debra Dew
806 S Nueva Vista Dr 2715 SE Spyglass Dr 814 S Nueva Vista Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Vancouver,WA 98683 Palm Springs,CA 92264
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 21 of 24
680 523 009 680 52 00� 680 523 010
Tracy Vernarsky Kemieth V HOT
Nedzad& Saxnija Ajanic
816 S Nueva Vista Dr 2390 E Nr la Rd N 820 S Nueva Vista Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Spri gs CA 92262 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 523 011 680 523 012 680 523 013
Mark Sherwin Robert Hernandez Jesus Vega
1550 Erwin St#339 826 S Nueva Vista Dr 828 S Nueva Vista Dr
Van Nuys,CA 91411 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 523 014 680 523 015 680 523 017
Kevin&Lisa Gillespie Joe Anchondo&Ernestine Anchondo Moses Esparza
830 S Nueva Vista Dr 842 S Nueva Vista Dr 872 S Nueva Vista Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 523 018 680 524 001 680 524 002
Kipen Rae S Kurt Schmidt Evelyn Williams
1291 Hickory Dr 910 Arroyo Vista Dr 875 S Nueva Vista Dr
Basking Ridge,NJ 07920 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 524 003 680 524 004 680 524 005
Kurt Parish&J D Poyfair Larry Sieh&Judith Sieh Dennis Philhart
865 S Nueva Vista Dr 855 S Nueva Vista Dr 845 S Nueva Vista Dr
Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 524 006 680 524 007 680 524 008
Teresa Vasquez David Trsut Mathews Robert&Lynn Speck
835 S Nueva Vista Dr 67845 Carroll Dr 823 S Nueva Vista Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Cathedral City,CA 92234 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 524 009 680 5 010 680 524 011
A Hess Fred Robert S ers Yolanda Schulte&Carol Swanney
PO Box 2168 9324 Stale 833 Greenridge Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92263 Marysville, A 98270 La Canada Flintridge,CA 91011
680 524 012 680 524 013 680 524 014
Capps Beverly Jack Young Courtney Fetchenhier
826 Arroyo Vista Dr 830 Arroyo Vista Dr 836 Arroyo Vista Dr
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 524 015 680 524 016 680 524 017
Rafael Loyola&Juvenal L Orduna Raymond&Carol Davis Robert.Turchi
840 Arroyo Vista Dr 30003 SW Weaver Dr 1359 E Camino Primrose
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Newberg,OR 97132 Palm Springs, CA 92264
680 524 018 680 524 019 680 524 020
Dan&Annida Faessler Clare Rifsdal Bradley&Shannon Wayne
3760 Lemon Ave 906 Arroyo Vista Dr 908 Arroyo Vista Dr
Long Beach, CA 90807 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264
Case 5,0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 22 of 24
680 525 001 680 525 003 680 525 004
Taila Ranta Marshall Mccoy George Ligar II
923 Arroyo Vista Dr 915 Arroyo Vista Dr 913 Arroyo Vista Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 525 006 680 525 007 680 525 008
William&Arm Ingham Mary Holmes Paula&Williams Ronald Bacon
903 Arroyo Vista Dr 899 Arroyo Vista Dr Janice
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 7527 Cowan Ave
Los Angeles,CA 90045
680 525 009 680 525 010 680525011
Juan Castaneda Lawrence&Shirley Ann Bertolim Luiz Sampaio
855 Arroyo Vista Dr 835 Arroyo Vista Dr 259 Museum Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Los Angeles,CA 90065
680 525 012 680 525 013 680 525 014
Robert& Julia Philbrook Roy Pockett Donald Nagy
829 Arroyo Vista Dr 825 Arroyo Vista Dr 821 Arroyo Vista Dr
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 525 015 680 525 016 680 525 017
Jorge&Elizabeth Nava Ruben&Alice Lugo Lolito Agresor
819 Arroyo Vista Dr 876 El Placer Rd 890 El Placer Rd
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 525 018 680 525 019 680 525 020
Elizabeth Maxwell John Chaves Barbara Simpson
3650 E Mesquite Ave 3670 E Mesquite Ave 3690 E Mesquite Ave
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 550 002 680 570 001 680 570 002
City Of P Springs Barber Dev Llc Blair Steven&Christine
PO Bo 443 2115 Dhezem Rd PO Box 757
Pa prmgs, CA 92263 Blue Lake,CA 95525 Bigfork,MT 59911
680 570 003 680 570 004 680 0 00
Robert& Susan Stiff Kelly Pa 'ck &Margaret A Kelly k J&Margaret A
12315 S Gene Autry Trl Kelly 2846 Wa Train Ln
Palm Springs, CA 92264 2846 Wagon in Ln Diamond B CA 91765
Diamond Bar, CA 91765
680 570 006 680 0 07 680 570 008
Joseph&Lucile Dennis III Joan Ka Randy&Darlene Ernst
1237 S Gene Autry Trl 6282 Rivi C r 67886 Jane Ln
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Long Beac 90815 Cathedral City,CA 92234
680 570 009 680 570 010 680 570 011
Ashwill Bruce&Barbara Auto Inn Inc Steven Lederman
3181 Cameron Park Dr#105 68351 Perez Rd 35200 Cathedral Canyon Dr#131
Cameron Park,CA 95682 Cathedral City,CA 92234 Cathedral City,CA 92234
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 23 of 24
680 590 001 680 5 004 680 590 005
Rand Larson&David Atkisson Ramsey i thy S Charles &Patricia Purdy
1332 Crystal Ct 1261 Tiff Cir S 1361 Crystal Ct
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Spr n ,CA 92262 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 590 006 680 590 007 680 590 008
Robert&Pamela Evans Romeo&Juliete Acorda Willard Livingstone&Hubert Garlingt
1351 Crystal Ct 1341 Crystal Ct 1331 Crystal Ct
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 590 009 680 590 010 680 590 011
El Sonora Assoc El Sonor ssoc Rand David Larson&David Atkisson
3002 Dow Ave#142 3002 ow Ave#142 1332 Crystal Ct
Tustin,CA 92780 T_ n,CA 92780 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 590 012 680 590 013 680 590 014
Rudolph&Marisela Dangcil Mantel Homme&Joyce C Brown Charles H&Franklin Bertheau
1342 Crystal Ct PO Box 1984 1362 Crystal Ct
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Gresham,OR 97030 Pahn Springs,CA 92264
680 590 015 680 590 016 680 590 017
Lewis Morey&Aunrey Bubis Scott Cunningham
2943 E Las Palmas Cir 1382 Crystal Ct 1392 Crystal Ct
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 590 018 68Z
680 590 020
El Sonora Assoc E1 E15onor ssoc
3002 Dow Ave#142 302 3002 ow Ave#142
Tustin,CA 92780 Tu T in,CA 92780
680 590 021 680 590 022 680 590 023
Edward Lopatin Wilczak Thomas Contopulos
1395 Emerald Ct 1385 Emerald Ct 1375 Emerald Ct
Palm Springs,CA 92264 Pahn Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264
680 590 024 680 590 025 680 590 026
C D Ewer&M J Paurowski El Sonora Associates Starr Nicholas&Yolanda M
1365 Emerald Ct PO Box 2743 Starr
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92263 1024 Peninsula St
Ventura,CA 93001
680 590 027 680 590 028 680 590 029
Rafael Arellano El Sonora Assoc Cook Larry E
2217 Lone Tree St 3002 Dow Ave#142 6902 Pflnmun Rd
Corona,CA 92880 Tustin,CA 92780 Shawnee,KS 66216
680 590 030 680 590 031 680 590 032
EI Sonora ssoc El Sonor ssociates Glen&Brenda Martin
3002 w Ave#142 PO B 2743 1011 S Valentia St#63
Tus r,CA 92780 P Springs, CA 92263 Denver, CO 80247
Case 5.0965 Mesquite Avenue Widening- City of Palm Springs Page 24 of 24
680 590 033 680 590 034 680 590 035
Septnnus Sonora A c El Sonora oc
1390 Emerald Ct 3002 D Ave#142 3002 w Ave#142
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Tus ' ,CA 92780 tstin, CA 92780
680 590 037 680-145-008
Ronald Mcdaniel&Thomas Milne MR KARL P EICHNER
1381 Crystal Ct MS VIRGINIA G EICHNER
Palm Springs, CA 92264 975 SOUTH PASEO DORO,TEA
PALM SPRINGS CA 92264'
Neighborhood Coalition List
as of October 1, 2003 MR PETER DIXON MR BILL DAVIS AND
Case 5.0965 431 SOUTH MONTE VISTA DRIVE MS TRISHA DAVIS
P.C. Hearing for 11-12-03 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 227 SOUTH CAHUILLA
City of Palm Springs PALM SPRINGS CA 92262
MR FRANK TYSEN MR BOB WEITHORN MRTIM HOHMEIER
C/O CASA CODY COUNTRY INN 261 SOUTH BELARDO ROAD 1387 CALLE DE MARIA
175 SOUTH CAHUILLA ROAD PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264
PALM SPRINGS CA 92264
MS CHRISTINE HAMMOND MR PHIL TEDESCO MR MARSHALL ROATH
1155 SOUTH CAMINO REAL 1303 WEST PRIMAVERA DRIVE MS SHERYL HAMLIN
PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 565 WEST SANTA ROSA DRIVE
PALM SPRINGS CA 92262
MS MARGARET PARK
MS ROXANNE PLOSS AGUA CALIENTE BAND OF
930 CHIA AGUA CALIENTE INDIANS REP CAHUILLA INDIANS
PALM SPRINGS, CA 92262' 650 E TAHQUITZ CANYON WAY
PALM SPRINGS CA 92262
SENIOR SECRETARY
DEPT OF PLANNING&ZONING
CITY OF P.S. REP CITY OF PALM SPRINGS
PO BOX 2743
PALM SPRINGS CA 92263-2743
5.0965 GPA Desert Water Agency The Gas Company
Local Agencies & Utilities 1200 South Gene Autry Trail 211 North Sunrise Way
9 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92262
Palm Springs Disposal Services Palm Springs Unified School District South Coast Air Quality Management
4690 E. Mesquite Avenue 980 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way District
Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92262 21865 East Copley Drive
Diamond Bar, CA 91765-4182
Southern California Edison Southern California Edison Time Warner Cable
36100 Cathedral Canyon Drive Environmental Affairs Administrative Office
Cathedral City, CA 92234 P.O. Box 800 41725 Cook Street
Rosemead, CA 91770 Palm Desert, CA 92260
Verizon Verizon-Environmental Projects Riverside County Flood Control and Water
195 South Sunrise Way Ms.Jacque McCormack Conservation District/Regulatory
Palm Springs, CA 92262 700 Hidden Ridge 1995 Market Street
MC:W01J05 Riverside, CA 92501
Irving, TX 75038
Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla The Sierra Club Bureau of Indian Affairs
Indians Ms. Joan Taylor Mr. Kim Snyder, Director
Tribal Planning Director-Tom Davis 1800 South Sunrise Way P.O. Box 2245
650 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, CA 92264 (1EIR&1 TECH) Palm Springs, CA 92263
Palm Springs, CA 92262
Bureau of Indian Affairs US Army corps of Engineers State of California
Regional Director Los Angeles District Department of Fish&Game-Region 6
ATTN: Natural Resources P.O. Box 532711 Eastern Sierra &Inland Desert
2800 Cottage Way Los Angeles,CA 90053-2325 4775 Bird Farm Road
Sacramento, CA 95825 Chino Hills, CA 91709
State of California Department of State of California
Transportation District 8 Water Quality Control Board
464 West4"Street, 6`h Floor, MS 72 73720 Fred Waring Drive ECONOMIC
San Bernardino, Ca. 92401-1400 Palm Desert, CA 92260 DEVELOPMENT
\f
BUILDING ENGINEERING & PUBLIC FIRE
WORKS
PARKS, RECREATION POLICE
& FACILITIES
ifzgsi',
rlc
92263-2743 Y
�) W
680 153 00'.
. ° Jeffrey Kraybill a
5 farr #306C/ d �
- Sat�ancisco, 94102
i