Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1/21/2004 - STAFF REPORTS (8) DATE: January 21, 2004 TO: City Council FROM: Director of Planning and Zoning CASE 5.935-PD-59, AN APPLICATION BY DESERT CHAPEL FOR REVISIONS TO THE DESERT CHAPEL MASTER PLAN, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT 59, TO INCLUDE: 1) THE ADDITION OF CLASSROOMS, A NURSERY, AN ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING AND A NEW SPECIAL EVENTS AREA; AND 2) THE ESTABLISHMENT OF REGULATIONS REGARDING THE TIME, PLACE AND MANNER OF SPECIAL EVENTS, INCLUDING NIGHT TIME FOOTBALL GAMES, LOCATED ON 10.16 ACRES,AT 630 SOUTH SUNRISE WAY,ZONE PD-59, SECTION 24. RECOMMENDATION The Planning Commission recommends that the City Council approve revisions to the Desert Chapel Master Plan, Case No. 5.935-PD 59, including: 1) the addition of classrooms, a nursery, and administrative building and new special events area; and 2)the establishment of regulations regarding the time, place and manner of special events, including night time football games; subject to conditions of approval. Christopher Mills, Architect, is the representative for Desert Chapel. SUMMARY At its meeting on August 27, 2003, the Planning Commission voted 7-0, to approve the final development plans for a 1,200 square foot storage building and on September 10, 2003 the Planning Commission voted 7-0 to establish a framework for conducting special events, including carnivals and football games, at the site. At that meeting, the Planning Commission also voted to continue the issues of the dedication of Sunny Dunes, to provide additional time for the applicant to meet with staff and representatives of the neighboring Mesquite Country Club HOA and Deep well Board of Directors. Public hearings on this matterwere conducted on August27,September 10, October8, October22,and November 12, 2003, November 26, 2003, and December 10, 2003. Neighborhood Meetings to discuss right of ways and insurance issues were held on ed on August 28, 2003 and on September 4, 2003. During the meetings Mesquite Country Club and Desert Chapel agreed to have their respective insurance agents meet to discuss options. To date, the involved parties have not been able to satisfy these requirements. Staff also provided a brief update on this project at a neighborhood meeting of residents in the Tahquitz River Estates neighborhood on November 20, 2003. As part of the establishment of the PD in 1999, the applicant was required to provide access to the historic users of the Sunny Dunes right of way.As a condition of approval (#34), the applicant had been required to provide access easements to Desert Water, National Golf Operating Partnership and Mesquite Country Club HOA. The HOA had asked, and the City Council agreed, that as a condition of vacating the public right of way, Desert Chapel indemnify the Mesquite Country Club during use of the easement. Condition #34b specifically requires that: "the applicant record a maintenance and "hold harmless"agreement for the users of the easement, thereby shifting a maintenance and insurance burden to the benefit of the users." The easement was to be utilized to provide access to the maintenance facility. Desert Chapel and the HOA have been unable to agree upon the terms of the insurance policy and related indemnification demands of both parties. However, Desert Chapel has recently withdrawn the request to rededicate Sunny Dunes and is in the process of providing an alternative access route through the golf course to the HOA.A new pedestrian and light vehicle bridge over portions of the wash may be installed to accomplish this and resolve conflicts between Mesquite Country Club and Desert Chapel. This option will not effect access easements to any other easement users. BACKGROUND The Desert Chapel Master Plan has evolved through a series of discretionary land use reviews. On January 7, 1976, the City Council approved Planned Development District 59 allowing a church in an R-1-C zone. On November 17, 1999, the City Council approved a revision to the Desert Chapel Master Plan, (PD 59),to include an expanded sanctuary, multi-purpose building, library/administrative building, K-12 private school, expanded parking facilities, day care operations, administrative building, modular classrooms, street vacation, and relocation of existing bike trail. The project was intended to be completed in two (2) major phases. The approved Master Plan includes the following phasing: Phase 1: Sanctuary addition foradditional seating and multi-purpose space,totaling 11,272 square feet. A 1,144 square foot storage building and a fifty (50) parking space temporary parking lot will be constructed. A fourteen thousand (14,000) square foot multi-purpose building for use as gymnasium and auditorium. A two(2)story mixed use building of approximately 8,093 square feet housing nursery/toddler care areas, additional classrooms, and school and church administration. Placing six (6) modular classrooms, 960 square foot in area, foundation mounted, on site. These structures would be similar to the existing modular classroom buildings. Phase 2: Completion of seventeen (17) modular classrooms for a total of 17,280 square feet. Redevelopment of the Sunrise Nursery area into a permanent parking area complete with landscaping and lighting. Relocation of the bike path, depending on easement availability. Phase 1, with the exception of the 1,144 square foot storage building, has been completed. Phase 2, with the exception of the relocation of the bike path, has also been completed. The bike path is now proposed to be relocated on to the vacated Sunny Dunes Right of Way via an easement. op? 200 " ANALYSIS The applicant seeks to amend the Planned Development District in order to add classrooms, a nursery, an administrative building and new special events area. The classrooms would be added directly to the east of the existing multi-purpose building. Classrooms would be added in two phases. Seven single story classrooms would be added at the outset.At a later date, six additional classrooms would be added.A future nursery/toddler and administrative building is also proposed east of the Sanctuary. A special events area is proposed on the parking lot located to the north of the Sunny Dunes Road. The applicant seeks to establish regulations regarding the time place and manner of special events and night time football games. The applicant proposes to hold three special events per year, with temporary lighting and generators, which would not extend past 9:00 pm. Specific events have not been proposed, however, in the past Desert Chapel has conducted a Harvest Festival. Staff recommends adding a condition prohibiting amplified outdoor concerts. The applicant proposes to hold up to ten football games annually, which occur in the fall. These events would start at 7:OOpm and run through 10:OOpm. These events would include the use of a temporary generator, PA system, lighting and bleachers.The applicant notes that games generally run 90 to 120 minutes. The field and parking lot should be cleared and lights off by 10:00pm. In order to approve this request, condition # 17(a) of the original conditions of approval would need to be eliminated. During the fall football season Desert Chapel conducted football games in accordance with these provisions. Temporary permits were issued for each football game. Several complaints about temporary light placement were received. Once light placement was adjusted, it appears that the criteria have worked reasonably well. ZONING/LAND USES North: PD 34 Seventh Day Adventist Church South: R-1-C/Sunrise Nursery East: PD 153 (R-1-C, R-G-8)/Mesquite Golf Course West: R-1-C/Single Family Residences CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL A Resolution with the related Conditions of Approval,which were approved on November 17, 1999, are attached for your review. ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS AND NOTIFICATION: On November 17, 1999, the City Council certified a Mitigated Negative Declaration for the subject project. At that meeting the City Council determined that with the environmental mitigation incorporated into the project, any environmental impacts resulting from the project would be reduced to a level of insignificance. Potential environmental impacts from the project include short term air quality during construction, and traffic. Future project construction and grading activities may produce short-term dust emissions from the site. As a mitigation measure the applicant will q1B be required to submit a Fugitive Dust Mitigation Plan, prepared in accordance with Chapter 8.50 of the Palm Springs Municipal Code regarding Fugitive Dust and Erosion Control. This document shall be submitted for review and approval to the Building Official prior to the issuance of grading, excavation or building permits. In this manner the short term environmental impacts will be mitigated to a level of insignificance. The development of this project and a related project on the west side of Sunrise Way were evaluated in a Traffic Study dated July 1999, which was prepared by Endo Engineering. The traffic study indicated that a signal would be required at the intersection of Sunny Dunes Road and Sunrise Way by 2004 with or without the Desert Chapel expansion. Desert Chapel was required to pay its fair share for installation of this signal. All property owners within a four hundred (400) foot radius of the subject parcel were notified. CORRESPONDENCE Neighbors of the project have reviewed the project plans and have submitted correspondence in opposition to the proposed project. The opposition includes opposition to the time, place and manner of the proposed special events. The letters also refer to past controversy regarding this applicant. /ice c / ?1' � 1 � Director c&lanning and Zoning City Manager ATTACHMENTS: 1. Vicinity Map 2. Planning Commission minutes, August 27, September 10, October 8, October 22, November 12, 2003, November 26, 2003, and December 10, 2003 3. Correspondence 4. Resolution 5. Conditions of approval qliy NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING CITY COUNCIL CITY OF PALM SPRINGS Case No. 5.935-PD-59 An application by Desert Chapel for an amendment to Planned Development District 59 to consider revisions to the master plan, including: 1)the addition of classrooms, a nursery, an administration building, and a new special events area; and 2) the establishment of regulations for the time, place, and manner of special events, including night-time football games, at 630 South Sunrise Way, Zone PD 59, Section 24. NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of the City of Palm Springs, California, will hold a public hearing at its meeting of January 21,2004: The City Council meeting begins at 7:00 p.m., in the City Council Chamber at City Hall, 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way, Palm Springs, California. The purpose of the hearing is to consider an application by Desert Chapel for an amendment to Planned Development District 59 for revisions to the master plan, including: 1) the addition of classrooms, a nursery, an administration building, and a new special events area; and 2) the establishment of regulations for the time, place, and manner of special events, including night-time football games. The property in question is located at 630 South Sunrise Way, Zone PD 59, Section 24. Pursuant to Section 15070 of the California Environmental Quality Act(CEQA)Guidelines,a Mitigated Negative Declaration was adopted by the City Council in 1999. The proposed application, site plan, and related documents are available for public review daily, between 8 am and 5 pm at the City of Palm Springs in the Planning and Zoning Department, located at 3200 Tahquitz Canyon Way. If any individual or group challenges the action in court, issues raised may be limited to only those issues raised at the public hearings described in this notice or in written correspondence at or prior to the City Council meeting. Notice of Public Hearing is being sent to all property owners within four hundred (400) feet of the subject property. An opportunity will be given at said hearings for all interested persons to be heard. Questions regarding this case may be directed to Alex Meyerhoff, Principal Planner, Department of Planning & Zoning, (760) 323-8245. Patricia Sanders City Clerk qlqs000 VICINITY MAP N W E S �4O 7-AOOUlTZ GAWON WAY � � Q K'AIION7 ROAD SUNNY DUNfS KID, \ - - - GONrPOL �, GI7M/N�L AVfNUE PPOJfCr I-oGhrIoN CITY Ur r-ALM SPRINGS CASE NO.: 5.935-PD-59 DESCRIPTION: Request for an amendment to Planned Development District 59, including the addition of classrooms,a APPLICANT: DESERT CHAPEL nursery, an administration building,and a new special events area,to regulate the time,place, and manner of special events, to consider the re-dedication of the Sunny Dunes Way right-of- way, and for final Planned Development District approval to construct an approximately 1,200 square foot storage building at 630 South Sunrise Way,Zone PD 59, Section 24. Page 6 of 11 Planning Commission Minutes August 27, 2003 Kathy Marx, Associate Planner, reported that the proposed by-right-of-zone project meets all property development standards for the City and for the Section 14 Master Plan and features a substantially lower density than allowed by-right-of-zone. She reported that the project will be gated and walled and feature a main entry on Hermosa Drive and an emergency entry on Amado Road (which will also provide an additional exit for residents). She reported that the project was very well received by the Design Review Committee. She reported that the Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians Planning staff is reviewing the landscape element. She reported that there was no landscape architect present at the Design Review Committee meeting; therefore, the applicant requested that the preliminary landscape plan be reviewed by staff and that committee at a later date. She reported that staff has received some public inquiry on the project and that four people came to City Hall to review plans and that, after their review, commented that they approved of the project. She reported that the project features two indoor parking spaces per unit, in addition to two exterior parking spaces within each driveway. She confirmed that the Fire Department has no concerns regarding access to the project. Chairman Shoenberger opened the Public Hearing. Mr. Dennis Freeman,applicant, addressed the Planning Commission to thank them for their review and answer questions, if any. There being no further appearances, the Public Hearing was closed. M/S/C (Matthews/Grence 5-0, 2 absent) to approve subject to Conditions of Approval in Staff Report with the following revisions: A. Revise Engineering Condition No. 7 (Amado Road) — Construct a five foot wide sidewalk separated from the curb by a four-feet wide planter area along the entire frontage. B. Add Condition 7a— Dedicate a one-foot wide sidewalk easement behind sidewalk in landscape, Lot D along entire Amado Road frontage. C. Landscape plans to be reviewed and approved by the Design Review Committee and staff. Case 5.935-PD-59—Application by Desert Chapel for revisions to the Desert Chapel Master Plan, Planned Development District 59, to include: 1) the addition of classrooms, a nursery, an administrative building and a new special events area; 2) regulations regarding the time place and manner of special events, including night time football games; 3) consideration of rededication of the Sunny Dunes right of way; and 4) final development plans for an approximately 1,200 square foot storage building, located on 10.16 acres at 630 South Sunrise Way, PD 59 Zone, Section 24. Alex Meyerhoff, Principal Planner, reported that the Design Review Committee supported approval of the addition of classrooms, nursery, administrative building, and new special events area at its meeting this week as consistent with original Planned Development District. q47 Page 6 of 11 Planning Commission Minutes August 27, 2003 Kathy Marx, Associate Planner, reported that the proposed by-right-of-zone project meets all property development standards for the City and for the Section 14 Master Plan and features a substantially lower density than allowed by-right-of-zone. She reported that the project will be gated and walled and feature a main entry on Hermosa Drive and an emergency entry on Amado Road (which will also provide an additional exit for residents). She reported that the project was very well received by the Design Review Committee. She reported that the Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians Planning staff is reviewing the landscape element. She reported that there was no landscape architect present at the Design Review Committee meeting; therefore, the applicant requested that the preliminary landscape plan be reviewed by staff and that committee at a later date. She reported that staff has received some public inquiry on the project and that four people came to City Hall to review plans and that, after their review, commented that they approved of the project. She reported that the project features two indoor parking spaces per unit, in addition to two exterior parking spaces within each driveway. She confirmed that the Fire Department has no concerns regarding access to the project. Chairman Shoenberger opened the Public Hearing. Mr. Dennis Freeman,applicant, addressed the Planning Commission to thank them for their review and answer questions, if any. There being no further appearances, the Public Hearing was closed. M/S/C (Matthews/Grence 5-0, 2 absent) to approve subject to Conditions of Approval in Staff Report with the following revisions: A. Revise Engineering Condition No. 7 (Amado Road) — Construct a five foot wide sidewalk separated from the curb by a four-feet wide planter area along the entire frontage. B. Add Condition 7a— Dedicate a one-foot wide sidewalk easement behind sidewalk in landscape, Lot D along entire Amado Road frontage. C. Landscape plans to be reviewed and approved by the Design Review Committee and staff. Case 5.935-PD-59—Application by Desert Chapel for revisions to the Desert Chapel Master Plan, Planned Development District 59, to include: 1) the addition of classrooms, a nursery, an administrative building and a new special events area; 2) regulations regarding the time place and manner of special events, including night time football games; 3) consideration of rededication of the Sunny Dunes right of way; and 4) final development plans for an approximately 1,200 square foot storage building, located on 10.16 acres at 630 South Sunrise Way, PD 59 Zone, Section 24. Alex Meyerhoff, Principal Planner, reported that the Design Review Committee supported approval of the addition of classrooms, nursery, administrative building, and new special events area at its meeting this week as consistent with original Planned Development District. q47 Page 7 of 11 Planning Commission Minutes August 27, 2003 He stated that the applicant has requested that the City accept a rededication of the Sunny Dunes Road right-of-way; however, the Engineering Department has concluded that there is no public benefit to accepting this previous portion of Sunny Dunes Road as a public street and; therefore, recommends eliminating Condition 34E from the Conditions of Approval. Director clarified that there are unresolved issues between the surrounding neighborhood and the church regarding events, especially night events. He stated that the applicant and the Mesquite Country Club worked diligently to obtain easements but the issue of Hold Harmless/insurance was notable to be resolved. He stated that applicant reports that the church's insurance will not provide a Hold Harmless clause;therefore, Mesquite Country Club felt the risk was too great. He reported that the church has chosen not to pursue alternate or additional insurance coverage. He reported that the only uses (other than by the church) of the easement is a Mesquite Country Club utility building and Desert Water Agency access. Chairman Shoenberger opened the Public Hearing. Ms. Marie Bochnewich, attorney for Mesquite Country Club Homeowners'Association, addressed the Planning Commission to state that, unfortunately,the Homeowners'Association had to engage the City repeatedly to enforce existing Conditions of Approval in addition to direct requests to Desert Chapel regarding noise and other disturbances after hours. She stated that the Homeowners'Association would prefer to be more neighborly regarding the proposed application but is being forced to deal with many concerns that the full-service private school creates. She stated that conducting the public hearing in Augustwhen many Homeowners'Association members are not available is unfortunate and asked that there be a 30-day continuance in order to better inform the Homeowners'Association and allowthe community to weigh in on having the equivalent of a high school football season immediately next door to them. She stated that she does not see the urgency of the request and that, if Desert Chapel wanted to start football activities this year,she feels they should have come forward much sooner. She stated that there is a need for a higher level of scrutiny than is being given. Mr. Roger Lubin addressed the Planning Commission to state that he is a member of the Board of Directors of the Mesquite Country Club Homeowners'Association and is shocked that the Desert Chapel could not procure the appropriate insurance. He stated that the essence of the easement requires them to do that (provide insurance) and their saying that they tried but the master insurance policy would not allow it, is insufficient response to this requirement. He stated that the mere act of trying and failing should not absolve them of this responsibility. Mr. Arthur MacMillan addressed the Planning Commission to state that he has been a Mesquite Country Club resident for 15 years and that the Noise and Lighting Ordinances are in effect 24/7 to guarantee that he has the right to the peaceful enjoyment of his home. He stated that his bedroom is very close to Desert Chapel property and that, at 10:00 p.m., he should not be kept awake by hundreds of screaming football fans, concerts, event lighting, train whistles, skateboarders, street sweepers, and 2:00 a.m. stage construction crews. He asked the Planning Commission to address these issues. Mr. Chris Mills, project architect, addressed the Planning Commission to state that he could not speak to the insurance issue but that the purpose of the application is to fine-tune the Master Plan by revising some buildings, to establish a program of events, and to outline what Desert Chapel Page 8 of 11 Planning Commission Minutes August 27, 2003 can do,where,and how long which will simplify things for everyone. He stated that the Master Plan has remained basically the same since 1995 and the storage building is in the same location as originally approved. He added that the special event area off of Sunrise Way to the west of the project is utilized only for play during the day for the school and is purely a parking lot at other times. He stated that there is no special lighting or a Public Address system in that special event area and that it is subject to the Conditions of Approval of the Planned Development District. He stated that Desert Chapel regrets having to abandon the street and asking the City to take it back due to the insurance issue with the Homeowners'Association. He stated that both Desert Water Agency and the golf course administration are comfortable with the existing situation. He asked the Planning Commission to approve the application. Mr. Frank Marshall, Desert Chapel Administrative Pastor, addressed the Planning Commission to state that the intent of the church is to get along with the neighborhood and try to serve the needs of the people who live in the community, He stated that the church desires to resolve issues and reviewed an incident when the Homeowners'Association complained about leaf blowers early in the morning and that the church worked to improve that situation. He stated that the one concert that was held was an aberration and that the church was led to believe that the concert people had obtained City approvals. He stated that the church has done a Harvest Festival on Halloween Day for the past 20 years and that it is always done by 8:30 p.m. He stated that the facility is not completely fenced in so people could come and play basketball or park their cars or anything without the church's knowledge during off-hours. He stated that there are probably only five or six home football games at which a couple hundred people attend and that games can only go 1.5 hours at the most and that the church is more than willing to lower all lights except one directed at the field in order to clean up after games. Mr. Mike Linley addressed the Planning Commission to state that he agrees that events should be done by 10:00 p.m. and that Desert Chapel would like to have ten football games a year. He stated that Desert Chapel is not self-insured and its insurance carrier is "Guide One" (although the insurance agent was asked to research other carriers in order to secure the requested liability coverage). He stated that Desert Chapel met with the City Attorney and resolved the insurance issue with both American Golf and Desert Water Agency as a letter of indemnification and proof of insurance was deemed sufficient. He stated that the insurance carrier requested a letter of reciprocity from Mesquite Country Club Homeowners' Association; however, that Association's insurance determined that the increased exposure to risk was unacceptable. He asked that the street vacation issue be removed from the application in order for the project to move forward. Ms. Bobbi Gaffney, Manager, Mesquite Condominium Homeowners' Association, addressed the Planning Commission to state that Mr. Linley is correct about the insurance and that, if rules are complied with (e.g. activities over and lights out by 10:00 p.m.), there should be no problems; however, events at Desert Chapel are running as late as 2:00 a.m. She asked who will ensure the 10:00 curfew of activities. She stated that her organization is also a non-profit and needs the protection from risk, as driving through a parking lot is increased exposure. There being no further appearances, the Public Hearing was closed. Commissioner Matthews commented that, in 1999, Desert Chapel was not going to have a football field so he is sympathetic to the lighting issue and concerns of the neighborhood but also noted that the increase in site intensity also provides a great community resource. He stated that he sees no a 04 Page 8 of 11 Planning Commission Minutes August 27, 2003 can do,where,and how long which will simplify things for everyone. He stated that the Master Plan has remained basically the same since 1995 and the storage building is in the same location as originally approved. He added that the special event area off of Sunrise Way to the west of the project is utilized only for play during the day for the school and is purely a parking lot at other times. He stated that there is no special lighting or a Public Address system in that special event area and that it is subject to the Conditions of Approval of the Planned Development District. He stated that Desert Chapel regrets having to abandon the street and asking the City to take it back due to the insurance issue with the Homeowners'Association. He stated that both Desert Water Agency and the golf course administration are comfortable with the existing situation. He asked the Planning Commission to approve the application. Mr. Frank Marshall, Desert Chapel Administrative Pastor, addressed the Planning Commission to state that the intent of the church is to get along with the neighborhood and try to serve the needs of the people who live in the community, He stated that the church desires to resolve issues and reviewed an incident when the Homeowners'Association complained about leaf blowers early in the morning and that the church worked to improve that situation. He stated that the one concert that was held was an aberration and that the church was led to believe that the concert people had obtained City approvals. He stated that the church has done a Harvest Festival on Halloween Day for the past 20 years and that it is always done by 8:30 p.m. He stated that the facility is not completely fenced in so people could come and play basketball or park their cars or anything without the church's knowledge during off-hours. He stated that there are probably only five or six home football games at which a couple hundred people attend and that games can only go 1.5 hours at the most and that the church is more than willing to lower all lights except one directed at the field in order to clean up after games. Mr. Mike Linley addressed the Planning Commission to state that he agrees that events should be done by 10:00 p.m. and that Desert Chapel would like to have ten football games a year. He stated that Desert Chapel is not self-insured and its insurance carrier is "Guide One" (although the insurance agent was asked to research other carriers in order to secure the requested liability coverage). He stated that Desert Chapel met with the City Attorney and resolved the insurance issue with both American Golf and Desert Water Agency as a letter of indemnification and proof of insurance was deemed sufficient. He stated that the insurance carrier requested a letter of reciprocity from Mesquite Country Club Homeowners' Association; however, that Association's insurance determined that the increased exposure to risk was unacceptable. He asked that the street vacation issue be removed from the application in order for the project to move forward. Ms. Bobbi Gaffney, Manager, Mesquite Condominium Homeowners' Association, addressed the Planning Commission to state that Mr. Linley is correct about the insurance and that, if rules are complied with (e.g. activities over and lights out by 10:00 p.m.), there should be no problems; however, events at Desert Chapel are running as late as 2:00 a.m. She asked who will ensure the 10:00 curfew of activities. She stated that her organization is also a non-profit and needs the protection from risk, as driving through a parking lot is increased exposure. There being no further appearances, the Public Hearing was closed. Commissioner Matthews commented that, in 1999, Desert Chapel was not going to have a football field so he is sympathetic to the lighting issue and concerns of the neighborhood but also noted that the increase in site intensity also provides a great community resource. He stated that he sees no a 04 Page 6 of 13 Planning Commission Minutes September 10, 2003 h. Add "if needed, applicant may propose custom street signage subject to approval by the City Engineer" to Engineering Condition No. 65. * W W W Planning Commission adjourned for a brief recess and was called back to order at 3:15 p.m. W * k W * Case 5.935-PD-59—Application by Desert Chapel for revisions to the Desert Chapel Master Plan, Planned Development District 59, to include: 1) the addition of classrooms, a nursery, an administrative building and a new special events area; 2) regulations regarding the time place and manner of special events, including night time football games; and 3)consideration of rededication of the Sunny Dunes right of way, located on 10.16 acres at 630 South Sunrise Way, PD 59 Zone, Section 24. Continued from the meeting of August 27, 2003. Director reported that all parties met to discuss the right-of-way issue and that both the Homeowners' Association and Desert Chapel agree that the best remedy is to have insurance representatives collaborate to find a solution and staff will report back to Planning Commission on this issue. Alex Meyerhoff, Principal Planner, reported that a revised set of Conditions of Approval has been distributed today and that the Homeowners'Association still has concerns regarding football games at this site but the applicant has agreed to control and closely monitor the site in response to those concerns. He reported that the approval could be revoked if Conditions of Approval are violated. He reviewed the site plan and parking areas. He reported that the football season has seven games scheduled; however, if the team makes the finals, there could be as many as 10 games onsite. Chairman Shoenberger opened the Public Hearing. Ms. Marie Bochnevitch, attorney for Mesquite Country Club Condominium Owner's Association, addressed the Planning Commission to state that she is pleased to report that, after meetings with Desert Chapel, the Homeowners' Association now feels its concerns are being addressed. She clarified that, if Conditions of Approval are not strictly adhered to, then the Homeowners' Association opposes football at this site. She stated that the Homeowners' Association is very disappointed that the use has been going on without permits for a number of years. She requested that the City require Desert Chapel to provide the Homeowners' Association with an emergency contact phone number. She stated that it would be premature to approve the classrooms and other uses without resolving the Sunny Dunes Road right-of-way issue first. She stated that the Homeowners'Association is happy that the proposed Conditions of Approval address oversight, security, and control which will give homeowners an avenue for reporting concerns. She stated that the Homeowners'Association will be carefully monitoring how football games are conducted at Desert Chapel and requested that she be afforded the opportunity to review the proposed lighting plan for the football area prior to staff approval. qJ4 // Page 7 of 13 Planning Commission Minutes September 10, 2003 Mr. Chris Mills, project architect, addressed the Planning Commission to state that the nursery/toddler areas have always been on the master plan and are in the same location as when the street was an actual street(and are 40-50 feet away from the curb at Sunny Dunes Road). He reported that Desert Chapel has indicated all lights and speakers on the site plan and asked that those locations be approved at today's meeting. He stated that the football lighting is oriented as far away from residential units as play will allow, adding that a lighting expert was consulted and confirmed that minimal lighting is being used. Mr. Gary Skinner addressed the Planning Commission to state that he has been a teacher and a coach for the past 30 years at Palm Springs High School and a football coach at Desert Chapel for several years. He stated that games were moved up from 7:30 to 7:00 to help alleviate the noise situation at night and that almost all games and clean up are over by 9:00 p.m. He stated that there was one game that ran an hour late because the other team showed up one hour late from San Pedro. He stated that the team has eight players, not 11, and that the Palm Springs High School ball field is too long for the Desert Chapel team to use. Mr. Frank Marshall, Administrator, Desert Chapel, addressed the Planning Commission to state that Desert Chapel wants to be respectful of its neighbors and do good work for children. He stated that Desert Chapel also wishes to do special events, such as the annual alternative Halloween celebration which is traditionally over by 8:30 p.m. but asked that this year it be allowed to go on until 10:00 p.m. as Halloween is on a Friday night. Mr. Charles Theodosio addressed the Planning Commission to state that he is the Chairman of the Deepwell Estates neighborhood organization and that there are a lot of complaints about special events arena which include concerns regarding proper land use in a residential neighborhood (e.g. noise, traffic, lights, unsupervised youth, decreased property values, and the reduced ability of residents to derive peaceful enjoyment from their homes). He asked that alternatives such as using the Palm Springs High School football field be considered, despite Mr. Skinner's comment that the field is too large. He stated that Desert Chapel has a history of ignoring rules and complaints in the past and that the City has not required compliance. He stated that, at the last concert held at Desert Chapel,there was no permit, it did not comply with noise levels, noise went unabated by the Police Department even though residents called to complain. He stated that, 2-3 years ago, Desert Chapel tore down the nursery next doorwithout a permit. He stated that, despite concerns from residents regarding Asbestos,the City did not do anything and ignored contractual obligations on Sunny Dunes Road. He stated that Desert Chapel receives preferential treatment from the Police Department which directs traffic on Sundays and thatthere is now a stop light being installed at Sunny Dunes Road and Sunrise Way,which, he stated, would have required approval from the City of an exemption as the Zoning Ordinance addresses stop lights into dead ends. He stated that Desert Chapel should not be given special treatment and that there are 350 homes in the Deepwell neighborhood and that those residents deserve to enjoy a peaceful neighborhood. He asked the Planning Commission to deny the application. Mr. Ken Husky addressed the Planning Commission to state that he has been a member of the Deepwell neighborhood for 25 years and commended the Desert Chapel for cleaning up the area. He stated that he approves of the youth football use and that he can't see the lights from his house, but can, however, hear the noise from Desert Chapel and from Palm Springs High School. He stated that Desert Chapel does not ask for money from the City but provides positive activities for area youth. He stated that, in his 30 years of coaching experience, he has found that active, Cr/T Page 8 of 13 Planning Commission Minutes September 10, 2003 engaged kids are good, productive kids,so the City should encourage this land use. He stated that the City also benefits as the kids and families who visit from out of town do spend money here. Ms. Sheila Wood addressed the Planning Commission to state that she is a Deepwell resident and has no complaints about the games. She stated that she is the mother of five boys so she sees the importance of having safe places for kids to go and participate in healthy activities and that, on that level alone, she encourages the Planning Commission to approve football games at Desert Chapel. Ms.Jeannie Dremmel addressed the Planning Commission to state that she is a Deepwell resident and lives only two streets away from Sunrise Way. She stated that she does not hear much noise from these events and is surprised that this is such a problem. She stated that she felt "happy noise"should be okay and that there is not enough going on for kids. She added that she can hear noise from Palm Springs High School. Ms. Marie Bochnevitch addressed the Planning Commission again to respond to Mr. Mills' request for an exemption for the lighting plan. She stated that the Homeowners' Association and Desert Chapel spoke at length regarding this subject and she has seen markings on the plans but those markings are not enough for determining a permanent change. She asked that Desert Chapel submit a lighting plan. There being no further appearances, the Public Hearing was closed. Director reported that staff will work with the Homeowners' Association and applicant regarding special events timing and lighting plans and specifications. He stated that staff will monitor compliance at this Friday night's game as there is a one-time permit approved for this game. Commissioner Marantz commented that it is unfortunate that the Palm Springs High School use is not an option for the football activity and that she would like to see a finalized lighting plan. She stated that she would also like to see the fifth-wheel travel trailer currently located onsite (on the wash side) removed. Commissioner Matthews commended the neighborhood and Desert Chapel for getting together to work things out better. Chairman Shoenberger thanked the Homeowners'Association and Desert Chapel for their mutual collaboration and assured the neighborhood members that the City will follow up if Conditions of Approval are not followed. M/SIC (Matthews/Marantz 7-0)to continue the public hearing for the establishment of regulations regarding the time, place, and manner of special events, including night time football games and the rededication of Sunny Dunes Road right-of-way to the Planning Commission meeting of September 24, 2003. M/S/C (Matthews/Wright 7-0) to approve the revisions to the Master Plan of PD 59, including nursery, administration building, and new special events area. i9A13 71T Page 4 of 8 Planning Commission Minutes October 08, 2003 Street is very supportive of the overall project. He stated that there are several minor issues to clarify including the actual utility poles to be undergrounded, the yellow painted loading zone adjacent to the ingress/egress into the City parking lot (may not be appropriate for"loading" use now and could more efficiently be used for two additional parking spaces). He stated that he has not had the opportunity to discuss with the ADA Coordinator yet; however, anticipates that the two existing spaces which are ideally located just off North Palm Canyon Drive in the City parking lot would be the most appropriate and will work with staff to include those two spaces in the applicant's parking count. He commented that, although staff commented that white Tivoli lights are not approved, he believes that the existing lighting was approved as white Tivoli lights and that Main Street is very supportive of this lighting if it is done in good taste. Director clarified that staff is requesting that the utility lines be undergrounded from the existing riser pole and across the back of the parking area to the existing pole on the north (moving the undergrounding to the next pole, as did the Lobster Company (moving to the next pole). He also noted that the area is in a redevelopment area and a portion of the utilities run across City property and stated that the applicant may wish to contact the RDA for possible assistance. He reviewed the exhibits of the location of the above-ground poles. Marcus Fuller, Senior Engineer, clarified that the utilities are on the western property line (not on the south as stated in the staff report). He also stated that staff will research the possibility of allowing parking in the existing loading spaces as they may not be necessary at this time. Director clarified that the City's policy regarding Tivoli outdoor lighting is that it is architectural only and does not hang between trees or buildings. M/S/C (Conrad/Marantz 7-0) to approve subject to Conditions of Approval and that applicant to work with staff regarding the ADA parking space location and the location of loading areas, and that utility lines will be undergrounded from the south of the northernmost pole to the adjacent property and that no Tivoli lighting be used outdoors. Case 5.935-PD-59 -Application by Desert Chapel for revisions to the Desert Chapel Master Plan, Planned Development District 59 for consideration of special events, nighttime football games, and rededication of the Sunny Dunes right of way located on 10.16 acres at 630 South Sunrise Way, PD 59 Zone, Section 24. Continued from the meeting of September 10, 2003. Director reported that the applicant has requested a continuation in order to complete research regarding the insurance/access easement issue with the Mesquite Homeowners' Association. M/S/C (Hochanadel/Grence 7-0) to continue to the meeting of October 22, 2003. 5.0870-GPA-PD-268/TTM 31318, an Application by Ernie Noia for an amendment to the Planned Development District for the Indian Oasis Resort, a General Plan Amendment, a Tentative Tract Map and a Tentative Parcel Map, and approval of final development plans for the corporate business park. The project is located at the intersection of Mesquite Avenue and Crossley Road, %7rT Page 4 of 8 Planning Commission Minutes October 08, 2003 Street is very supportive of the overall project. He stated that there are several minor issues to clarify including the actual utility poles to be undergrounded, the yellow painted loading zone adjacent to the ingress/egress into the City parking lot (may not be appropriate for"loading" use now and could more efficiently be used for two additional parking spaces). He stated that he has not had the opportunity to discuss with the ADA Coordinator yet; however, anticipates that the two existing spaces which are ideally located just off North Palm Canyon Drive in the City parking lot would be the most appropriate and will work with staff to include those two spaces in the applicant's parking count. He commented that, although staff commented that white Tivoli lights are not approved, he believes that the existing lighting was approved as white Tivoli lights and that Main Street is very supportive of this lighting if it is done in good taste. Director clarified that staff is requesting that the utility lines be undergrounded from the existing riser pole and across the back of the parking area to the existing pole on the north (moving the undergrounding to the next pole, as did the Lobster Company (moving to the next pole). He also noted that the area is in a redevelopment area and a portion of the utilities run across City property and stated that the applicant may wish to contact the RDA for possible assistance. He reviewed the exhibits of the location of the above-ground poles. Marcus Fuller, Senior Engineer, clarified that the utilities are on the western property line (not on the south as stated in the staff report). He also stated that staff will research the possibility of allowing parking in the existing loading spaces as they may not be necessary at this time. Director clarified that the City's policy regarding Tivoli outdoor lighting is that it is architectural only and does not hang between trees or buildings. M/S/C (Conrad/Marantz 7-0) to approve subject to Conditions of Approval and that applicant to work with staff regarding the ADA parking space location and the location of loading areas, and that utility lines will be undergrounded from the south of the northernmost pole to the adjacent property and that no Tivoli lighting be used outdoors. Case 5.935-PD-59 -Application by Desert Chapel for revisions to the Desert Chapel Master Plan, Planned Development District 59 for consideration of special events, nighttime football games, and rededication of the Sunny Dunes right of way located on 10.16 acres at 630 South Sunrise Way, PD 59 Zone, Section 24. Continued from the meeting of September 10, 2003. Director reported that the applicant has requested a continuation in order to complete research regarding the insurance/access easement issue with the Mesquite Homeowners' Association. M/S/C (Hochanadel/Grence 7-0) to continue to the meeting of October 22, 2003. 5.0870-GPA-PD-268/TTM 31318, an Application by Ernie Noia for an amendment to the Planned Development District for the Indian Oasis Resort, a General Plan Amendment, a Tentative Tract Map and a Tentative Parcel Map, and approval of final development plans for the corporate business park. The project is located at the intersection of Mesquite Avenue and Crossley Road, %7rT Page 5 of 9 Planning Commission Minutes October 22, 2003 Planning Commission was recessed briefly and called back to order at 2:30 p.m. Commissioners Matthews and Shoenberger returned to the meeting. Commissioner Wright left the meeting. PUBLIC HEARINGS: Case 5.935-PD-59-Application by Desert Chapel for revisions to the Desert Chapel Master Plan, Planned Development District 59 for consideration of special events, nighttime football games, and rededication of the Sunny Dunes right of way located on 10.16 acres at 630 South Sunrise Way, PD 59 Zone, Section 24. Continued from the meeting of October 08, 2003. Director reported that the applicant is working on revised exhibits and requests a continuance to the meeting of November 12, 2003. Chairman Shoenberger opened the Public Hearing. There were no appearances. M/S/C(Marantz/Grence 5-0, 2 absent)to continue the Public Hearing to the meeting of November 12, 2003. Case 5.0974 — Application for a Conditional Use Permit by John & Janet McSweeney for construction of a casita located at 5200 Menlo Circle, R-1-C-Zone, Sections 24 and 25. Matthew Feske, Assistant Planner, reviewed the plans for the proposed casita and reported that it is adjacent to the existing tennis court. He reported that the intent of the property owner is to utilize the casita for family and occasional guests. Chairman Shoenberger opened the Public Hearing. There being no appearances, the Public Hearing was closed. M/S/C (Matthews/Marantz 5-0, 2 absent) to approve subject to Conditions of Approval in Staff Report. Sign Program—Application by Riofine Sign Company for a Sign Program amendment for 254-260 North Palm Canyon Drive (Enzo's), CBD Zone, Section 16. Director reviewed the existing restaurant's second floor, formerly the location of the St. James Cafe, noting that the location is a challenge for attracting the public. He reported that in February the applicant applied for a sign which would project into the public right-of-way but that application was denied by the Planning Commission. He reported that the applicant subsequently installed a channel letter non-lit sign on the building and plans to do an awning program. He confirmed that staff will work with the applicant on the blade sign that would hang below the awnings. He reviewed the logo script and the salmon color of the proposed signage stating that it will give an outstanding opportunity for the restaurant to have more public recognition. ^�/� Page 4 of 8 Planning Commission Minutes November 12, 2003 Mr. Sam Rasmussen addressed the Planning Commission to state that he is the new owner of the Courtyard project and that Ocean Property Development is the parent company. He stated that the theater is currently undergoing a $2 million remodel and will be a high end theater. M/S/C (Matthews/Conrad 4-0, 2 abstentions, 1 absent) to approve subject to using a metal cove (painted to match building) to cover exposed neon. Commissioners Shoenberger and Hochanadel returned to the meeting. w w w + w PUBLIC HEARINGS: Case 5.935-PD-59-Application by Desert Chapel for revisions to the Desert Chapel Master Plan, Planned Development District 59 for consideration of special events, nighttime football games,and rededication of the Sunny Dunes right of way located on 10.16 acres at 630 South Sunrise Way, PD 59 Zone, Section 24. Continued from the meeting of October 22, 2003. Director reported that the applicant has requested a continuance to the meeting of November 26, 2003 and confirmed that staff will send an additional hearing notice to all property owners within 500 feet for that meeting. M/S/C (Marantz/Hochanadel 6-0, 1 absent)to continue to the meeting of November 26, 2003 per applicant request. wwwww Case 5.0978 — Application by Jane Owen and Jeanne Burke for a Conditional Use Permit for approval of a multi-family residential use in an R-1-C Zone for property located at 2388 Sunrise Way, R-1-C Zone, Section 1. Kathy Marx, Associate Planner, reviewed photographs of the subject building and explained that on September 3,2003, City Council amended the Zoning Ordinance to provide a relief mechanism for multi-family residential uses affected by the 1973 and 1995 down-zoning. Chairman Shoenberger opened the Public Hearing. There being no appearances, the Public Hearing was closed. M/S/C(Conrad/Marantz 6-0, 1 absent)to approve subject to Conditions of Approval in Staff Report. w w w w w Case 5.0842 (PD-77) —Application by Christopher Mills Architect, Inc. for Maurice Refoua for an amendment to the existing Planned Development Districtto add to existing retail centerand expand parking for retail use at 611 South Palm Canyon Drive, PD-77 Zone, Section 22. Matthew Feske, Assistant Planner, reviewed the Staff Report and exhibits for the Planning Commission. /CO Page 4 of 13 Planning Commission Minutes November 26, 2003 Commissioner Conrad asked staff to address having the trail go through the wash. Director reported that, as it comes off of Camino Monte, a sloped traverse traditional hillside trail, the bottom of the trail will be a combination of riprap and flat wash and then transition up into hillside (having only 100-150 feet on the soft wash bottom). He stated that, at the Waterfall point (if flowing), hikers would need to work up and around. He confirmed that the trail consultant (who is the same consultant as the Desert Riders use)will evaluate that fairly narrow trail. He stated that there is a gate on the private property and a trail sign and most people are very careful to stay on trails unless they get lost. M/S/C (Conrad/Grence 4-0, 3 abstentions) to approve subject to Conditions of Approval and to amend Condition No. 9 to require City Council approval and Condition No. 10 to be amended to add, "trail be constructed prior to final vacation of the roadway." Director thanked the neighborhood for their patience on the project and the applicant for successfully managing such a challenging and expensive solution. Commissioners Hochanadel, Shoenberger, and Matthews returned to the meeting. w w w w w PUBLIC HEARINGS: ! Case 5.935—PD 59—Application by Desert Chapel for revisions to the Desert Chapel Master Plan, Planned Development District 59 for consideration of special events, nighttime football games, and rededication of the Sunny Dunes right of way located on 10.16 acres at 630 South Sunrise Way, PD 59 Zone, Section 24. Continued from the meeting of November 12, 2003. Director confirmed that all property owners within 400 feet were noticed of today's public hearing and that the applicant is working with Mesquite Homeowners'Association to resolve the easement and insurance issue. Commissioner Marantz commented that she would like to see the site cleaned up in the nearfuture (e.g. the cargo container and trailer). Chairman Shoenberger opened the Public Hearing. There were no appearances. M/S/C (Hochanadel/Matthews 7-0)to continue the Public Hearing to the meeting of December 10, 2003 per applicant request. w w w w w Case 5.0842— PD 77—Application by Christopher Mills Architect, Inc. for Maurice Refoua for an amendment to the existing Planned Development District to add to existing retail center and expand parking for retail use at 611 South Palm Canyon Drive, PD-77 Zone, Section 22. Continued from the meeting of November 12, 2003. Gabriel Diaz, Assistant Planner, reviewed the staff report, exhibits, and previous meeting Page 2 of 7 Planning Commission Minutes December 10, 2003 PUBLIC HEARINGS: Case 5.935—PD 59—Application by Desert Chapel for revisions to the Desert Chapel Master Plan, Planned Development District 59 for consideration of special events, nighttime football games,and rededication of the Sunny Dunes right of way located on 10.16 acres at 630 South Sunrise Way, PD 59 Zone, Section 24. Continued from the meeting of November 26, 2003. Staff reported the Desert Chapel has withdrawn their request to rededicate the Sunny Dunes Road right-of-way and is working on an alternative solution with Mesquite County Club Homeowners' Association. R E ,],EN, Octobox 6, 2003 OCT 7 2003 IVIS o:, [PLANN:1NLGG DIVISION G'sulml'y Pali i Spthigsi Plmiribctp-, Depl- 'J'Alis C-a(Dbtv ii"' lbc� IJOK-110J all bold" U-A-s were. orq, eTe � 1 J - 1" afl-lenjjug10Q ihU ill the footbaft fick1j., :riho,i II re,0 .,o.tjc)nO It iivas past 930 PP%4 Y%-hleirtl I veeflt 0`Fv(Y 10- lftqlftN vj.lb"y thc, fight, g WQVU Q 1h I,quire a I x \�II'Jjdft I ejjtkered J111c -rbLCJ113a' li�-Id, i C--wE-iotxl sfudo-iit iWUIL�Tc, vvlalrs an adulfl- supell-iskig the 'actiOdes ori ifie fbnflhall- 1it-1,1- one adult 1-ho wa's on the fiieldL With the stud'etits, ickAitifled hersloff a's 1312-te"! Plctclier. She eel l -1 � -1 -1 f I e Id alo id tj,�C, I ly! s, r"In r1j C"d t I'Le reo�,cin, IL-o�x k lg�C?" o r1l,"S (i]961� I""'I T 9 is that they were going to be constructing their Homecoming Floats that evening on the football field. I asked Ms. Fletcher who authorized the use of tine football field fights to be turned on and who approved the evening outdoor activity — her response: "Frank Marshall". Arthur MacMillan Mesquite Country Club 2001 Camino Parocela K77 Z2A Palm Springs, Ca. 92264 7f 7f 09/30/2003 08:45 760-325-7048 DESERT CHAPEL PAGE 7 02 `l 75 DESERT CHAPEL "ASMIr-FILLED FELLOWSHIP" September 30,2003 City of Palm Springs Department of Planning&Zoning ATTN:Doug Evans,Director of Planning&Zoning 3200 F. Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, CA 92262 VM FACSIMILE Re: PD#59 Dear Mr. Evans: We are requesting a further continuance of our PPD to October 22,2003 in order to prepare more detailed drawings of the street map in question. Thank you for your assistance. Sincerely, Frank Marshall Administrator 9 �Zo 630 South 3undse Way• Palm Springs, California 92264 • Phone (760) 327.2772 • Fax (760) 325-7048 www.desertchapel.aV S, �56 1: 3 September 2003 To: Mr. Alex Meyerhoff Commission of Planning&Zoning City of Palm Springs 3200 East Tahquitz Canyon Way RECEIVED Palm Springs, CA 92262 From: Andres/Margot Gurs-Melber j =r' — R n"il 2001 E Camino Parocela(B-12) Palm Springs, CA i1 P,#PtPp`° �!i r f C, g q` Certified Mail Ref.: Case No. 5.935-PD-59 Dear Mr. Meyerhoff, We are property owners at 2001 E. Camino Parocela, our condominium being adjacent to Cannhno Parocela and perhaps furthest away from the Desert Chapel. We hereby strongly object to the proposed expansion by the Desert Chapel for the following reasons: • Gaines, concerts and ball games being held on the grounds of the Chapel near our residential compound are causing noise and light pollution that make life in our unit next to unbearable. High decibel levels coupled with the relentless spillover originating from broad-beam illumination of the planned special events area most definitely will prevent us from enjoying the outdoors and/or our deck. • Stadiums should not be built in close proximity of residential housing and certainly no stadium should be allowed near a church when it is obvious that the ill-effects on a large number of residents resulting from the noise and light pollution created by high-volume church/school activities clearly outweigh the benefit a comparatively small number of fans will draw from such activities. The chinch is a place of worship, a heaven for people seeking help, solace and quietude. Some activities going on from time to time and those now planned for the fixture by the Church are in stark contrast to everything the House of God stands for. Our children should not be used as a front for pushing undue requests that are totally out of bound with the essence of a sound residential neighborhood. qflR 1 1 My wife was told by a game official to whom she had complained in October 2002 that the special events area "is for our children". "They need to have fun". She replied that she is a teacher and mother herself understanding children very well, but that we adults deserve consideration, too, adding that the adverse impact on all entire neighborhood brought about by excessive noise and lighting spillover associated with large-scale sports activities and outdoor concerts at the Desert Chapel is simply unacceptable. Therefore, it is respectfully requested that the Planning Commission and the Honorable Mayor's Council do not approve the proposed expansion project of the Desert Chapel. An approval of the current application by Desert Church would mean a denial of the adjacent property owners' right to a peaceful and relaxed life on the grounds of their property, and if this were not bad enough in and of itself, it would also rnore likely than not erode the market value of their real estate. As an alternative to what Desert Chapel is plamling to do we suggest it rent existing facilities for their sports events and similar functions so that the children can still enjoy their extra-curricular activities. With best regards, ,_,/�ad*-r -DAndres and Margot( urs-Melber 1015 Pico Avenue Pacific Grove, CA 93950 — 381372-6530 CC: The Honorable Mayor Will Kleindienst/City Council Me tubers. fi Me Folder) d (Palm Springs ngs Polderr)) 2 0840-08 04169pm From-OIIRALNICK OILLILAND +7805683063 T-092 P.02/16 F-768 GURALNICK & GILLILA.ND ATTORNEYS AT LAW .ATTORNEYS SERVING 74.399 MIGMWAY 111, SUITE M TEMECULA OFFICE GOMM4NITY ASSOCIATIONS PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA 92260 (909) 298.6629 TELEPHONE: (760) $40-1515 FACSIMILE, (760) 566.3053 EMAIL. G000Gn0ALAw.COM PLEASE RFFER To W:99.163 August 26,2003 City of Palm Springs Planning Commissioners 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs,CA 92262 Crry of Palm Springs City Clerk 3200$.Tahqultz Canyon Way Palm Spnngs,CA 92262 City of Palm Springs Planning&Building Department Attn: Alex Meyerhoff 3200 E.72hquiEz Canyon Way Palm Springs, CA 92262 all via facsimile and first class mail(760)322-8360 Re: Case No.5,935-PD-59 Desert Chapel Application for Revisions to Desert Chapel Master Plan,Planned Development District 59 Dear Commissioners: This law firm represents the Mesquite Country Club Condorturriirra Homeowners Association. Mesquite Country Club is situated to the northeast and east of the Desert Chapel campus. Approximately 32 individual Mesquite Country Club condominium units are located directly adjacent to many of the applicant's proposed improvements. 1. REQUEST FOR CONTINUANCE Thu timing of this important hearing in August, in light of Elie long history of disputes between the applicant and the Association, has the effect of minimizing the ability Of Mesquite residents to participate in the process and voice their Objections and concerns before the 3 0140.08 04:60pm From-GURALNICK GILLILAND +T605688058 T-002 P.005 F-768 GURALNICK & OILLILANA ATTORNEYS AT LAW August 26,2003 City of Palm Springs planning Commission Re: Case No, 5.935-1?1)-59 Desert Chapel Application for Revisions to Desert Chapel Master Plan,Planned Development District 59 Page 2 Commission, Many of the Mesquite residents are seasonal residents residing in other states and Canada. Their concerns deserve to be heard. However,every effort has been made here To present the known concerns of the community. V!e respectfully request a continuance of at least 30 days to permit greater participation by The Mesquire community. 2. BACKGROUND The Association opposed Desert Chapel's application in 1999 to vacate and abandon portions of Sunny Dunes Road, and to construct various amenities and improvements directed towards providing classrooms,nursery/Toddler care, sports and playground facilities for its members. The Association's opposition was in part due to concerns regarding noise levels from sporting events, concens,etc, A rue and correct copy of the letter submiued by the Association in September 1999, stating concerns regarding noise levels,is attached hereto as Exhibit"A"for your reference. The Association also opposed the vacation of Sunny Dunes Road due to hubihty issues impacting tho Association relating to use of Sunny Dunes Road by church members,students, and particulurly toddlers and young children, h order to address the concerns of the Association and its members regarding noise from the Desert Chapel campus associated with general use and with "special events," the Conditions of Approval adopted November 17, 1999 include: Condition 17,requiring submission of an exterior lighting plan, and requiring all lights to conform to the City's non-glare standards; Condition 17(a), prohibiting lighting on the large playing field located in the southeast Portion of Tile property; Condition 39,prohibiting evening outdoor activities which extend past 10:00 p.m.; and Condition 40, prohibiting the use of a public address system for any reason other than emergency service. 9 es-26-03 06:00pm From-OURALNICK CILLILAND +7005883068 T-032 P.04/16 F-768 ❑URALNICK & GILLILAND ATrapnl:Vt AT LAW August 26,2003 City of Palm Springs Planning Commission Re: Case No. 5.935-PD-59 Desert Chapel Application for Revisions to Desert Chapel Master Plan,Planned Development District 59 Page 3 After being repeatedly disappointed in Desert Cnapol's numerous violations of the above conditions dunng amplified sporting events,concerts,and unsupervised use of the sports facilities by youths after hours,causing a great deal of disturbance to Mesquite residents, the Association formally complained to rho City Manager by its letter dated October 31. 2002. A true and correct copy of that letter is attached hereto as Exhibit"B". In response,Mr.Doug Evans,Director of Planting& Zoning,sent Desert Chapel a letter dated December 16, 2002, derailing Desert Chapel's numerous violations of its Conditions of Approval regarding noise levels,lighting,and event cutoff times. ('That letter is attached hereto as Exhibit "C"). Rather than insist upon compliance with the existing Conditions of Approval,Mr. Evans invited Desert Chapel to apply for revisions to its Planned Development District. With respect to the issue of access over Sunny Dunes Road, we respectfully disagree with the stamrnent in the Staff Report that the HOA and Desert Chapel have bcea unable to agree on the rams of the easement. The Conditions of Approval regarding the vacation of Sunny Dunes Road require that there be a recorded Easement Agreement in afortn approved by the City Manager. The parties executed a binding Easement Agreement which was recorded on September 4,2001. The present dispute between Desert Chapel and the Association concerns Desert Chapel's failure to comply with a specific requirement in the Easement Agreement concerning Desert Chapel's obligation to procure insurunce for the benefit of the Association. This requirement was included to protect the Association from the obvious substantial additional risks imposed by the mcreascil use of die Desert Chapel campus for playground, school, and sports activities. The Association stands by its rights under the Easement Agreement and intends to enforce them by all legal means. 3. ASSOCIATION'S CONCERNS REGARDING NOISE AND LIGHT DISTURBANCE The Association's fundamental concerns have always been that the greatly increased use of The Desert Chapel campus,expanding from church use to essentially that of a sports stadium and preschool/elementary school, causing a great deal of disturbance to the residents of Mesquite Country Club. Although the units which are closest to the Desert Chapel campus are most greatly 08�0-08 05:00pm From-GURALNICK GILLJLAND +7000688058 T-002 F.05/15 F-T08 GURA1,N0 d GILLILAND ATTORNEYS AT 4Aw August 26,2003 City of Palm Springs Planning Commission Re, Case No. 5.935-PD-59 Desert Chapel Application for Revisions To Desert Chapel Master Plan,Planned Development District 59 Page 4 affected, the noise carries quite well across the golf course into units throughout the Mesquite community. The City's noise ordinances provides. Section I1.74.043(f) Loudspeakers and Other Sound Amplifying Dgvices/Musical Instruments.It shall be unlawful for any person it)play,use,operate or permit to be played, used or operated, any radio receiver, musical instrument, phonograph, loudspeaker, sound amplifier, or other machine or device for the producing or reproducing of any sound upon any public street, alley, sidewalk, passageway or thoroughfare, or in or upon any public purk or other public place so as to unreasonably interfere with the peace and quiet of any other person;or if such act is done upon any private property,so as to unreasonably interfere with the peace and Quiet of any person outside the boundary of such private property. A. MESQUITE'S REQUESTED CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL 1- Limitation on Special Events. We agree with the proposed condition of not more than 3 special events per year, no amplified concerts under any circumstances,with The following modification: a. ncc term "special event"means an evenr nor longee rhan 1 day in duration, WithouT this modification, the "3 special events" may well Curti into multiple-day long disturbances to the Association. 2. Limitation on Football Games. The Association believes that the requested special event football season permit is, by definition, an unreasonable interference with the peace and quiet enjoymem of the Mesquite residents, The residents purchasing units at Mesquite certainly did not have notice that in purchasing their property,they would be subjected to noise and activity levels equivalent To a public high school and football stadium. Many residents would have chosen to live elsewhere rather than 08-20,08 06:00pm From-OURALNICK MULAND +7606688068 T-002 P•06/15 F-708 GURALNICK& GILLIIAND ATTDAn EYS AT UAW August 26,2003 City of Palm Springs Planning Commission Re: Case No. 5.935-1?D-59 Desert Chapel Application for Revisions to Desert Chapel Master Plan, Planned Development District 59 Page 5 be subjected to the disturbance associated with football games for an entire season,during the part of the year most seasonal residents most expect to enjoy peace and quiet. Having said That,the association opposes approval of the requested football season permit. However,if approved,[be Association's requested conditions of approval are as follows: u. n specific lighting plan must be submirred, with an opportuntty for the Association To review prior to approval. b. Rather rhan eliminating Condition 17(a),the Association recartmends that it be amended to provide thai all lights used for special event football games on The large playing field at the sourheasi portion of the properry shall be directed away from the Mesquite community and the Mesquite units which are located directly north ofthe proposed football field in order ro prevent light pollution and disturbance to the Mesquite Country Club community, c. No amplified music at the football games. 3. Storage facility, a. No activity in or around the storage facility before 8:00 a m, or after 8:00 p.m- This is to protect the queer enjoyment of the adjacent Mesquite condo units. 4. Noise Control•Maintenance and Landscape;.Hard Courts. With the continuing expanded multiple uses of the Desert Chapel campus,the Association is concerned that problems regarding noise will increase. although the City's noise ordinances ought to control the problem,in fact historically they have not,(Palm Springs Ordinance 11,74,041) There have been incidents of maintenance or landscape workers causing noise from equipment as early as 5:30 a,m, Additionally,unsupervised and unregulated use of the existing hardcouits has caused ongoing disturbance to Mesquite residents adjacent to the bardcoun facility, Complaints to Desert Chapel have been ignored. a. Use of blowers, electric Trimmers, mowers, street sweepers, landscape equipment, construction and utility vehicles on The Desert Chapel property is prohibited priorio 8:00 a.m. and t{fier B:QO p.m.. 7 n 01-26.03 05:01rM From-OURALNICK 01LLILAND +T606683053 T-092 P.OT/15 F-768 GURAI NICK di GILLILAND ATTORNEYSAt LAW August 26,2003 CiTy of Palm Sprigs Planning Commission Re, Case No. 5.935-PD-59 Desert Chapel Application for Revisions to Desert Chapel Master Plan,Planned Development District 59 Page 6 b. Use of the hard cuurn is prohibired prior to 8:00 a.m. and after 8:00 p.m. 4. RE•DEDICATION OF SUNNY DUNES SHOULD J3E.REJECTED The Association and the City worked long and hard to effect the vacation of the Sunny Dunes RAad right of way. At present, the Association believes that the Easement AgreemcM between Desert Chapel and the Association is vital to protecting it from, increased liability for injury associated with the multiple uses of the Desert Chapel campus. The proposal to add classrooms, nurserylToddler child care facilities and playground facilities merely emphusize the Association's need for increased protection from liability. There are no grounds To re-dedicate Sunny Dunes Road to public use. The Association supports the position of the City's Engineering Doparrment in this respect, Very truly yours, �GURALNICK&GILL0.AND Mamie A.Eochnewich /ms 94-1531403201v*pa 08-26.19 ' 06:01Pm From-OURALNICK OILL,11ANO +7606888068 T-002 P.08/16 F-768 GURALNICK & GILLILAND ATTORNEYS AT ,,AW WAYNO S. frURALfgICK 74.399 HIGHWAY 117, SutTE M TEMECULA OFFICE gOBERT C O. r R. MARIE A. @oCKNEWtcn PALM DESERT, CALIrORNIA 92260 (600) 239-7627' ANNE 1-. AAUCH TELEPHONE. (760) 340.1515 SAN DIEGO OFFICE ANOREW F. LINEHAN FACSIMILE. (760) 508.8053 fa131 a3:•t3oo E-MAIL' GGOGGHOALAW COM PLEASE REFER To FOE September 21, 1999 HAND DELIVERED Chrisrophet MiUs, Chairman Jeffrey laresky PAL14A SPRINGS PLANNING PALM SPRINGS PLANNING COMMISSION COMMISSION 3200 1-- Tahquitz Canyon Way 3200 1-, Tahqui z Canyon Way Palm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Palm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Mike FoaTana, Vice Chairman Ralph Raga PALM SPRINGS PLANNING PALM SPRINGS PLANNING COMMISSION COMMISSION 3200 E. rahqurtz Canyon Way 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Palm Springs, CA 92263.2743 Philip Sla tchko John CafPcry PALM SPRINGS PLANNING PALM SPRINGS PLANNING COMMISSION COMMISSION 3200 F— Tahquim Canyon Way 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Spnrrgs, CA 92263.2743 Palm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Mark Matthews Dave Dawson, AICP PALM SPRINGS PLANNING ASSOCiate Planner COMMISSION CITY OF PALM SPRINGS 3200 F. Tahquitz Canyon Way 3200 V. Tahquim Carryon Way Palm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Palm Springs, CA 92263.2743 Douglas R. Evans Director of Planting & Building CITY OF PALM SPRINGS 3200 E, Tahquirz Canyon Way Pslm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Re: Case No. 5.0788 - PD $9, Applicant: Desert Chapel Revision to Existing Desert Chapel's Master Plan to Include, .Among Other Things, Street Vacation and Abandonment for Portions of Sunny Dunes Road and .Expansion of Private School to Include Grades 9 - 12 Dear Honorable Commission Members, Messrs. Evans and Dawson: Our office is general counsel to Mesquite Country Club Condominium Holne0%UerS Association ("Association"), In this regard, we res��iest a 417 08-26.19 ' 06:01Pm From-OURALNICK OILL,11ANO +7606888068 T-002 P.08/16 F-768 GURALNICK & GILLILAND ATTORNEYS AT ,,AW WAYNO S. frURALfgICK 74.399 HIGHWAY 117, SutTE M TEMECULA OFFICE gOBERT C O. r R. MARIE A. @oCKNEWtcn PALM DESERT, CALIrORNIA 92260 (600) 239-7627' ANNE 1-. AAUCH TELEPHONE. (760) 340.1515 SAN DIEGO OFFICE ANOREW F. LINEHAN FACSIMILE. (760) 508.8053 fa131 a3:•t3oo E-MAIL' GGOGGHOALAW COM PLEASE REFER To FOE September 21, 1999 HAND DELIVERED Chrisrophet MiUs, Chairman Jeffrey laresky PAL14A SPRINGS PLANNING PALM SPRINGS PLANNING COMMISSION COMMISSION 3200 1-- Tahquitz Canyon Way 3200 1-, Tahqui z Canyon Way Palm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Palm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Mike FoaTana, Vice Chairman Ralph Raga PALM SPRINGS PLANNING PALM SPRINGS PLANNING COMMISSION COMMISSION 3200 E. rahqurtz Canyon Way 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Palm Springs, CA 92263.2743 Philip Sla tchko John CafPcry PALM SPRINGS PLANNING PALM SPRINGS PLANNING COMMISSION COMMISSION 3200 F— Tahquim Canyon Way 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Spnrrgs, CA 92263.2743 Palm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Mark Matthews Dave Dawson, AICP PALM SPRINGS PLANNING ASSOCiate Planner COMMISSION CITY OF PALM SPRINGS 3200 F. Tahquitz Canyon Way 3200 V. Tahquim Carryon Way Palm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Palm Springs, CA 92263.2743 Douglas R. Evans Director of Planting & Building CITY OF PALM SPRINGS 3200 E, Tahquirz Canyon Way Pslm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Re: Case No. 5.0788 - PD $9, Applicant: Desert Chapel Revision to Existing Desert Chapel's Master Plan to Include, .Among Other Things, Street Vacation and Abandonment for Portions of Sunny Dunes Road and .Expansion of Private School to Include Grades 9 - 12 Dear Honorable Commission Members, Messrs. Evans and Dawson: Our office is general counsel to Mesquite Country Club Condominium Holne0%UerS Association ("Association"), In this regard, we res��iest a 417 08-26'03 WOW From-WALNICK MULAND +T606683068 T-002 P.00/16 F-Tee GURA.LNICK & GILLILAND ATTORNEYS AT LAW Planning Commission CITY OF PALM SPRINGS Page 2 continuance of the above referenced matter, or in the alternative, a denial of Desert Chapel's request for abandonment of a portion of Sunny Dunes Road, 1. BACKGROUND It is our understanding That Desert Chapel is seeking approval to expand its current facility to include the acquisition of additional properties to the south• as well as overall goal modifications including a high school. Part of the approval is the request that a portion of Sunny Runes Road be vacated (approximately 690 feet). This portion. of Surrtty Dimes Road dead ends into the Mesquite Country Club maintenance facility which is owned and jointly used by both the Association and Mesquite Country Club (American Golf is the owner of the Country Club). 2. ABANDONMENT OF SUNNY DUNES ROAD AND EASEMENT ACCESS OVER PARKING LOT TO MAINTENANCE BUILDING Desert Chapel, as applicant, is proposing that a portion of Sunny Dunes Road be abandoned. We believe that the proposed abandonment is inconsistent with the City of Palm Springs' General Plan, Objective 7.2. Objective 7.2 seeks to provide improved levels of service and safety over current traffic operations. For the reasons outlined below, it is our belief that abandonment of Sunny Dunes Road does not improve levels of service and safety over current traffic operations. There is currently a maintenance building located at the east end of Sunny Dunes that is utilized by both the .Association and Mesquite Country Club. The only access to the maintenance building is off of Sunny Dunes Road. Desert Chapel has offered to grant the Association an access easement C,easement") through its' parking lot to gain access to the maintenance facility. However, the Association has several concerns regarding this Easement. The Association's main concern is safety for students, children and other patrons of Desert Chapel and the Association's members and employees_ Once the project is completed, there will be a large number of children walking through the parking lot to and from their classrooms and arriving at and leaving school. Very few children pay attention to where they are going. While most adults are cautious when operating a motor vehicle in the vicinity of children, there is always the risk of injury. By having a parking lot act as an roadway for access to the Assoclation's maintenance facility unnecessarily increases risk of liability and child endangerment. The Association is also concerned with the fact that if several large commercial vehicles are using the parking lot at the same time, there will not be enough room for the vehicles to go by one another. 03-20.03 01:02PM From-OURALNICK CILMAND +750W3053 T-302 P.12/15 F-T03 1 MESQUITE �.)i7NTRY CLUB CONDO HO. ..,EuWNFIRS ASSOCIATION P.O. Box 2342 Palm Springs, CA 92263 October 31,2002 Mr, David d,Aleshire City Attorney,City of Palm Springs 119301 Von Karntan Ave.,Suite 1050 Irvine,CA 92612 a Re: Desert Chapel Dear Mr. Aleshire: The purpose of this letter is rmdti of several areas.of Pan-..compliance by Desert Chapel,with the Conditians'of Approya*fox its espagsion: The Conditions of Approval,,as.prbAdelt to us bylpduglas R, Ey4s,'Director of PlanaingandBuilding,.specificallystate "The pleah4ersereening.dlo4g the northern property line shall be mointained to the satisfactida of the Director of Planning and Building, The minimum height at'trimining shall b'e seven t71 ifI'm All dead plants shall be realaced with mature here material with d mintmuin height of seven lZ� feet" I can assure you that,at no time,has this section�beea complied with. Either we have had to contend with dead plant material,missing plant material,or short plant material. The Conditions of Approval further state ".evening-outdoor activities at the subject site shall cease at 1 Pr00 RM. unless special time extensions are granted by the Director of Planning and Building and/or the thief afPolice";and"Na Public address system shall be allowed other Than for emer eng service_" During the early morning hours(2:00 A.M.)of Saturday,October 26,2002,there was a full crew working outside on the property at Desert Chapel, Field lights were on, generators were punning,large trucks were corning acid going and approximately fourteen workers were busy hattuneting and installing a stage in preparation for a concert. That evening,during the concert,a public address system was used. Needless to say,many residents at Mesquite were disturbed by the noise. The Homeowners' Association office received three telephone calls from residents in our I,d and K Buildings. I received a now,doctuneming the activities,fromm a resident in the K Building, Was Desert Chapel granted a special time extension by the Director of Planning and Building,or the Chief of Police? Perhaps but,if so,we were not aware of it and neither 760-322-5950 v Fax 760-323.3IS 08-26-03 05:02pm From-WRALNICK GILLILAND +760503053 T-802 P.13/16 F-768 October 31,2002 Mr.David J. Aleshire Page 2 was the City,as evidenced by the enclosed entails. We certainly do not believe that a concert qualities as"emergency service"to allow the use of a public address system. During our negotiations over the easement with Desert Chapel,we constantly heard the ward"neighborly". It was used particularly to state that Mesquite Country Club.' Condominium HOA was not being neighborly. We are not trying to be unneighborly. However,we are asking for a little compassion and communication from Desert Chapel, and the City of Palm Springs. It is apparent that outdoor events are going to continue at Desert Chapel. it also appears apparent that the City of Palm Springs is going to do nothing to enforce its Conditions of Approval. During the early morning hounwof concert set-up,the police were called by one of our homeowners. The homeowner was told that the police were working on other matters and would send someone if they could. -The pOUCe neVeT WTiVed in TeSponSC to tl1C homeoWaCr'5 Complaint. It's ironic,though,that the police department had several officers available the evening of the concert to direct traffic. I believe the City and the police department need to get their priorities in order. As a homeowners' association,we have rules and regulations whicb must be enforced, Our policy is that if it is a bad rule,eliminate it. However,until it is eliminated,we have an obligation to enforce it. Failure to enforce subjects the Board of Directors to liability. Why would the City adopt Conditions of Approval if it had no intention of enforcing them? Anti,does its failure to enforce not subject the City to potential litigation?. As City Attorney,I would hope that you would understand the seriousness of•the above. It appears to many that Desert Chapel is receiving preferential treatment,due w ties which many City officials have to Desert Chapel. The City's failure to act in enforcing its Conditions of Approval only lends credence to This belies: Very truly yours, MESQUITE C(OOUUNNT�rR•-Y CLUB CONDOMINIUM HOA ItonNovy /i q/ President Cc: Douglas R.Evan,Director of Planning and Building Frank V.Marshall,III,Administrator,Desert Chapel City of Palm Springs Council Members Wayne Gmalnick 08-26.03 0543m From-GORALNICK GIV 1LAND +7005683068 T-882 P.15/15 F-708 Page 2 of 2 Revised Planned Development District and Activities—Desert Chapel December 16. 2002 On November 12, 2002, 1 sent you a letter regarding approval of football games. The football season was well underway when the City received its first complaint. The complaint was received soon after the youth concert. The temporary approval was handled by staff in the interest of allowing the scheduled games to continue and impose certain restrictions on lighting and operations. Night football games were not contemplated in the original Planned Development District permit. The temporary approval is rescinded and the Planned Development District needs to be amended to include night sporting events. Options range from amending the Planned Development District, rescheduling games to afternoons, or using an alternate venue. This needs to be resolved as soon as possible since schedules need to be completed for next year. The last issue we need to discuss is the Ciry's Noise Ordinance. The Ordinance is in effect 24 hours per day. Desert Chapel needs to evaluate its activities and review activities which are conducted outdoors. The Ordinance does not differentiate types of noise. There are several issues that could be addressed in the short-term.The train whistle could be modified to make it quieter. Also,outdoor activities could be located and oriented away from the neighboring residential properties. Additionally, more landscape materials, including larger trees, could help with some of the complaints. Balancing the needs of the community and churohischool will be an ongoing challenge. Revising the Planned Development District will clarify the allowable church activities and create a better understanding for neighbors and church officials. If you have any questions,please give me a call. Sincerely, Douglas R. Evans Director of Planning &Zoning cc: Mayor and City Council David Ready,City Manager Dave Aleshire, City Attorney Gary Jeandron, Police Chief Arthur MacMillan Mesquite Homeowners'Association 103Y 08-26.03 0543m From-GORALNICK GIV 1LAND +7005683068 T-882 P.15/15 F-708 Page 2 of 2 Revised Planned Development District and Activities—Desert Chapel December 16. 2002 On November 12, 2002, 1 sent you a letter regarding approval of football games. The football season was well underway when the City received its first complaint. The complaint was received soon after the youth concert. The temporary approval was handled by staff in the interest of allowing the scheduled games to continue and impose certain restrictions on lighting and operations. Night football games were not contemplated in the original Planned Development District permit. The temporary approval is rescinded and the Planned Development District needs to be amended to include night sporting events. Options range from amending the Planned Development District, rescheduling games to afternoons, or using an alternate venue. This needs to be resolved as soon as possible since schedules need to be completed for next year. The last issue we need to discuss is the Ciry's Noise Ordinance. The Ordinance is in effect 24 hours per day. Desert Chapel needs to evaluate its activities and review activities which are conducted outdoors. The Ordinance does not differentiate types of noise. There are several issues that could be addressed in the short-term.The train whistle could be modified to make it quieter. Also,outdoor activities could be located and oriented away from the neighboring residential properties. Additionally, more landscape materials, including larger trees, could help with some of the complaints. Balancing the needs of the community and churohischool will be an ongoing challenge. Revising the Planned Development District will clarify the allowable church activities and create a better understanding for neighbors and church officials. If you have any questions,please give me a call. Sincerely, Douglas R. Evans Director of Planning &Zoning cc: Mayor and City Council David Ready,City Manager Dave Aleshire, City Attorney Gary Jeandron, Police Chief Arthur MacMillan Mesquite Homeowners'Association 103Y HUG.CJ.0 1G:41F'M I*G HKUHK iNf:;W1*' F1MHM(. NU..J1.:� H.4 LC a.Y RECEIVED Ron and Gina Youngren 911A Arlene nave AUG 2 5 2003 Palm Springs,CA 92264 (760)416-1890 August 25, 2003 PLANNING DIVISION RE: Planning Commission Hearing on August 27,2003 Regarding Cue No. SS35-PD-59 Desert Chapel-Located at 630 South Sunrise Way,Zone PD 59,Section 24 We wish to bring to the Planning Commission of the City of Palm Springs the following concerns: • Along the south side of the existing structure directly adjacent to the Baristo Control Channel,is stored a large motor home. • Also at this location,over the past year there has been storage of various appliances and construction material. • We and neighbors are concerned that Desert Chapel will continue to store these items (and more)at this location. • Exterior storage along the Baristo Control Channel and Desert Chapel property has been a visual blight to neighbors located on Mesquite Avenue and we are concerned that approval of additional classrooms, administration and a"storage buildiu"will result in additional exterior storage of large motor hoaxes and other school/church related equipment. • If exterior storage will continue, as has been the practice for the past year or more,we respectfully request the Planning Commission to deny the request for a zoning change, • Alternatively,if approval is granted we request that the Planning Commission require the following remediation: 1. The new classrooms,administration,special events area and"storage building" be constructed of materials suitable and compatible for the area, and not a metal structure, 2. No exterior storage of vehicles,appliances or equipment along the Baristo Control Channel, 3. The planting of large/mature vegetation and appropriate irrigation systems to screen both the existing facility and the new construction of classrooms, administration,special events area and storage building along the Baristo Control Channel/Mesquite Avenue homes. Sincero R .and gren 9 AUG-02-2003 02:59 PM P. el cc ' �C RECEIVED AUG 2 5 W FACSIMILE TRANSMISSION PLANNING DIVISION PHONE/FAX;907-789.9702 PAGES (including this one): 1 TO, Alex P. Meyerhoff, Principal Planner �— -- -- - — --_ City of Palm Springs 760-322-8360 FROM; Karleen and Roger Grummett, Owners Unit J72,Phase 3, Mesquite Golf and Country au b SUBJECT. Case No. 5.935•PD-59 DATE: August23,2003 LANNI �SC' aIVI i �� Dear Mr.Meyerhoff, You have toad letters and heard from neighbors of Desert Chapel who have tried to bring to your attention the refusal of that church to be a good neighbor and how their actions are eroding our quality of life.Some neighbors have already been forced to move.As shown by their letters and testimony,it isn't as though neighbors are unreasonable in their requests,ifs that the church completely ignores them. For example,during the past year,many of us have registered our concerns,as have Doug Evans and the Mesquite Golf and Country Club's HOA,However,now Desert Chapel is not only continuing to press for their orlgml requests which violate city codes and ordinances and for a plan they were asked to amend,they ate proposing new ones.These Chapel requests go way beyond their original plane.At best,they are deceiving not only to their neighbors,but to city planners as well. As you know,City ordinances should not be amended for the benefit of Desert Chapel at the expense of homeowners who are entitled to live in peace In their residences.We,of course,oppose the continuance of illegal lighting standards and amplified sound and request that Desert Chapel be asked to get In compliance with dty codes and ordinances once and for all. We also request that they relocate their proposed hard mart surface,nursery and storage badings elsewhere on church property so they will not abut windows of neighboring bedrooms causing disturbances during either early morning or fate night hours, tie ,�d9t.rr7� 4en4m Ro er q1413& Weaneaday,August 20,2003 6;25 PM Robert E.Pailthorp 1541765002 P,02 Ce, 19c— RECEIVED h . ,;EIVE[`" 'I August 20,2003 AUG 2 5 2003 „JG 15 2006 AlePrincipal ipalPla Planner PLANNING DIVISION n Principal Planner City of Palm Springs I'L - ` ., kNi�iG DIVI 3 .1 Subject: Case No, 5.935-PD-59 Desert Chapel application to amend PDD 59 Dear Mr.Meyerhoff: Our living unit is K-73 Phase 3 of Mesquite Home Owners County Club. Our patio faces the current play area/parking lot of Desert Chapel. During the past year we have been exposed to the lighting and noise of special activities at the Chapel. Our past complaints are on record with your office. We oppose the additional building units on the site. We are impacted most by the lighting glare and amplified sound from the site. SPECIAL EVENTS The tern"special event"suggests that they would not occur frequently, If they are permitted,we ask that the frequency be limited and specified. LIGHT GLARE We ask that all Desert Chapel lighting conform to the non-glare standards of the City. The portable lights,with their associated engine generators,that have been used for special Chapel events are not appropriate. if special event lights are to be permitted we ask that they be permanent and be non-glare, In the past the portable lights have been moved from the football field to the play arealparking lot for special events. The people locating them have not been sensitive to the glare they create at our living unit. It is unrealistic to assume that people will be able to reposition portable lights of this size and type without creating glare that will result in violations of City non-glare standards. AMPLIFIED SOUND We ask that amplified sound not be allowed. We were subjected to sound from one special Desert Chapel music event that was heard many blocks away. The amplified sound that is used during football games is particularly objectionable, In the past, after main events ended on time other activities such as dismantling the stage,getting to cars,and out of the parking lot continued, if the City sets time limits on special events, please define in some detail what ends the event. Ro ert E.Pailthorp Dorthea M.Pailthorp g,� 37 3-16-1995 2:56AM FROM P. 1 Augur:,, 25, 2003 Alex 14eyerhoff Princi;:N:d Planner, City of Palm Springs Dept.,,Dept. ,,&Planning & Zoning 32001:. Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm �"a;)rings, CA 92262 Re: C;.1se No. 5.935-PD-59 Dear I am calmpletely against an amendment to Planned Development District 59: T!.:�y have not beautified previous developments in the past as promi :4:d. Since:°e.ly, Arlen-:: Rosen `39 %Ijof 00/26/2009 09:49 7603233189 MESQUITE HDA PAGE 01 From:VVIhm(a S Far'OMM2711071 Ta:soebb ramay FWC (70s)3W3189 Page '2 Sunday,fWDU:t N,"088S PM August 24,2003 Mr.Douglas R.Evans Director of Planning and Zoning City of Palm Springs 3200 E Taliquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs,CA,92263 Ref Case No.5.935-PD-59 Dear Sir, This is in response to your notice of Public Hearing in the referenced case as I am a.homeowner within 400 feet of the proposed development. Since we will be unable to attend the public hearing on August 27,1 wish to enter the,following comments into the record. Special Events:Outdoor special events should include athletic competitions(Le,Football games) and be limited to one per week.They should be required to end by I OPM and the use of public address systems should be forbidden due to the close proximity of residential housing.(on the North. anal West sides of the Church). Sunny Dunes right-of-way:In the event Sunny Dunes is closed to public access, iron clad provision must be made for the continuation of and public access to the bike/walking path which runs along the north side of the Mesquite Country Club golf course and then continues up Tahquitz Carryon wasin. Traffic,Consideration should be given to closing the parking lot exits north ofthe Church. During the week when children are being dropped offand picked up for school,access to Sunrise from Camino Parocela is very difficult due to traffic entering Sunrise from the Church. The nursery should also have its own separated drop off area. General:Adding all the proposed buildings,unless they are high rises, would result in.the site being developed to a very high density. In the interests of avoiding the diminishing of adjacent property values,I hope You will consider the above items, William and Cortsuclo Gills 8832 Sovereign Road 2001 Camino Parocela San Diego,CA.97123 Palm Springs,CA.92264 Cr,Mesquite Country Club HOA q1139 CC t'C RECEIVED RESIDENTS OF MESQUITE COUNTRY CLUB PHASE III,K•75 AUG 2 5 2003 August 22,2003 PLANNING DIVISION Dear Planning Board: As close residents of the Desert Chapel, we are very concerned by their expansion plans (Case No. 5.985-PD-59). These plans include areas that border the Baristo Control Channel. The Channel area is in direct view of approximately 16 of the homes at Mesquite. As I now understand the Desert Chapel Plan, there will he a"special events area", a nursery and a 17-ft high storage building, all in the small area that is near an existing playground and parking area (nearest to Mesquite Condos). It is unclear what and when the "special events"would be, how many children in the nursery and what types of items would be stored in the storage facility and when it could be accessed, etc. The Chapel has not proven themselves to be good responsible neighbors. I understand that they agreed to Strict noise and light restrictions at the time they were granted a permit to construct the Chapel and school. There have been noise and bright light problems due to un-permitted night sport activities in their football field. Nothing has changed. They still have residential neighbors that have an equal right to peaceful enjoyment of their property. Additionally,the chapel did not adhere to their responsibility of maintaining a 7-ft Oleander fence along the Baristo channel,to help muffle the noise and block the parking lot view. Earlier this year after many of the plants had died and homeowners complained to the Chapel, the Condo association was able to get the Chapel to re-plant some bushes. I am surprised at what seems to me as a lack of a neighbor friendly master plan. I would think the Chapel architects would want to keep potential noise problems closer to the wide open Tahquitz Creek area and to the street adjacent area of Sunrise Way. There is a very large open area at the SW area of their property and I cannot help wondering why these spaces are not better utilized. I am not an architect or planner but the development of the school functional areas seem to lack common sense cohesion. Please do not consider passing the request for a permit until other areas of the property are considered for potential noise events. I believe all phases of the "End State Campus"should be identified and given noise, time and lighting limits, We should all be concerned by the parking, Baristo channel access(near a nursery and special events area)and traffic flow issues. I ask that all property owners be advised of what impact the Chapel's additional areas and buildings will have on their neighbors prior to any approval. SincerelyG�� k John Dominge and Ernest Sabo Residents of Mesquite Phase III 00126/2003 09:49 7603223189 MESQUITE HOA PAGE 01 From;VMliam Gilla FUr,+1(ESB)2700fl TO:eobbk Galmy FAX: (Ta0)3M378P Pape'- 2 Wndny,Aug"d 20.2W e:]e PM August 24,2003 Mr.Dousim I Evans Director of Planning and Zoning City of Palm Springs 3200 E Taliquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs,CA,92263 Ref:Case No. 5.935-PD-59 Dear Sir, This is in response to your notice of Public Hearing in the referenced ease as I am a.homeowner within 400 feet ofthe proposed development.Since we will be unable to attend the public hearing on ,August 27,I wish to enter the,following comments into the record. Special Events:Outdoor special events should include atliletic competitions (i.e,rootball games) and be limited to one per week,They should be required to end by I OPM and the use of public address systems should be forbidden due to the close proximity of residential housing.(on lire North and West sides of the Church). Suxmy Dunes right-of-way:In the event Sunny Dunes is closed to public access, iron clad provision must be made for the continuation of and public act:eas to the bike/walking path which runs along the north side ofthe Mesquite Country Club golf course and then continues up Tahquitz Canyon Wash, 'franc.Consideration should be given to closing the parking lot exits north efthe Church.During the week when children are being dropped off and picked up for school,access to Sunrise from Camino Parocela is very difficult due to traffic entering Sunrise from the Church.The nursery should also have its own separated drop off area. General:Adding all the proposed buildings,unless they are high rises, would result in the site being developed to a very high density. In the interests of avoiding the diminishing of adjacent property values,I hope you will consider the above items. William and Consuolo Gilts 9832 Sovereign Road 2001 Camino Parocela San Diego,CA.921.23 Palm Springs,CA-92264 Co.Mesquite Country Club HOA August 20, 2003 F,)CEIVv-D Alex Meyerhoff, Principal Planner AUG 2 9 2 00' Department of Planning and ZoningCity of Palm p �`ti t 3200 E. T hqupt ti L Canyon Way l� l\[�JI NG Palm Springs, CA 92262 _____.i RE: Case 5.935-PD-59, Desert Chapel Dear Sirs, I am in receipt of a vicinity map as documentation for an amendment to PD for the above referenced case. Based on the description provided, it is insufficient to determine the affect this request will have on my residence (located within 400 feet of the proposed outlined actions). I am very concerned about any further changes that Desert Chapel may be requesting as their prior and current use of the property has exceeded the commitments they have made in the past. Specifically: ❑ The noise level exceeds that which is acceptable for a residential area during weekdays ❑ They have violated city ordinance by having evening events with excessive noise ❑ They have not built proposed barriers between their property and the adjacent residential community to mitigate noise, etc. To further aggravate the current situation (and hence my position that any further development be prohibited) is the fact that their membership consists of various city officials. When city police are called for noise violations,they fail to respond to address the complaint. I request that this letter opposing any changes to the use be entered into the hearing (and any amendments thereto) as noticed to be held on August 27, 2003. Thank You, Joseph Ji'V+f 11 Unit K74 2001 Camino Parocella Palm Springs, CA 92264 tfVV Page 1 of I Alex Meyerhoff From: I.D. Weiner [malibudave@earthlink.net] Sent: Wednesday, August 20, 2003 9:06 AM To: alexm@ci.palm-springs.ca.us Subject: case#5.935-PD-59 Dear Mr. Meyerhoff, We take this opportunity to respond to the Notice of Public Hearing Planning Commission case# 5.935-PD-59 We are unable to attend the meeting of August 27, 2003 so, as you suggested, we are submitting this objection in writi ig. We have no objections to the Desert Chapel expanding classrooms and constructing buildings as needed, BUT WE OBJECT STRONGLY TO THE RE-DEDICATION OF THE SUNNY DUNES WAY, RIGHT OF WAY.. To the Desert Chapel. As owners at Mesquite Cotmtry Club, Phase 3, we observe frequent foot traffic on the area in question. This is yet another attempt by Desert Chapel to commandeer this public access which services pedestrians, cyclists and limited vehicle traffic. Surety Dunes Way is used daily by many traversing the path from Farrell to Sunny Dunes and should not be relinquished to serve the desire of a private enterprise. As a religious organization the Desert Chapel already posesses a tax free status and another try at 'ownership" of a public access is unacceptable. This roadway must be maintained as public property for the enjoyment of the Palm Springs citizens who wish to use it, anytime they wish to use it. PLEASE REGISTER OUR OBJECTION TO THE RIGHT OF WAY PHASE OF THE DESERT CHAPEL AMMENDMENT, Irving D and Gayle Weine ,� 28032 Sea Lane Malibu, Ca. 90265 310 457 3436 We also are owners of units C17 and I61,Phase 3,Mesquite Country Club qfi43 8/20/2003 internal noise(t.v. or radio)it is not enough to block out the noise that emanates from the church property. What the Commission also needs to be aware of is Desert Chapel's responses to requests from homeowners whenever their noise becomes intolerable. Whenever homeowners such as me make a visit to the church officials to request that noise be abated(after 1 OPm Y at night, sometimes at 1:00 in the morning, the response from Desert Chapel Administration is consistent: "You are on private property,We can do what we want, You must leave our property now." A firm letter from Doug Evans (after previous numerous complaints from homeowners to the City Chief of Police, City Attorney, Mayor and City Council and Doug Evans) instructed Desert Chapel on November 5u` 2p02 to cease with all violations of City Codes and Ordinances,but went on to suggest that the Desert Chapel amend its Planned Development District so that their special events can continue,which is why they are before you today,to get the Planning Commission's blessing to be able to assault their neighbors with noise and light pollution. This brings us to the current date. Desert Chapel is now before you, despite their awareness of their impact on their neighbors and their awareness of how their refusal to be good neighbors has eroded the quality of life of it's neighbors—they are now requesting that you allow them to: 1)Use generated lights in the evening for their evening events that will continue to light up the entire City block, (Doug Evans instructed Desert Chapel to face their generated lights away from our homes-this resulted in blinding all bike riders on the City bike trail that passes thru Mesquite Golf Course and our homes.) (2) Use outdoor P/A systems that will blare into all of our bedrooms and living rooms into the evening 3) Have evening events that will need to end by 1 OPM but in reality will take much longer for crowds to dissipate and for knockdown and actual peace and quiet to not occur until probably around midnight. And lastly,what is most distasteful is that: Desert Chapel is requesting that the City allow them to construct a Hard Court special event field directly adjacent to our bedroom windows so that their special events will be located as close as possible to our windows. Also. Please be aware that when the church is closed at night, the property still attracts youths that congregate late into the evening(sometimes after midnight) where they come to play basketball, tapping their balls onto the pavement with their car stereos with music turned up. Also the church is requesting that a nursery be constructed as close as possible to our windows. For the past four years we have had to endure the school children being dropped in the morning at 7AM on church property that is closest to our windows. The children play outside for an hour at this early hour before they enter the school and then come back out for their gym and recesses,playing alongside the property line that adjoins our condos. The storage shed that Desert Chapel wants to construct is(not surprisingly) going to be located against the fence that adjoins our condos. This will block our remaining views of the mountains,that their Multi Purpose building and other buildings haven't already blocked. There are other areas of their property where this unsightly building can be located. JJ6 t,benefit of to fight a war in ou,<, dnsmvusu- who willbelefthereinthe",.ited tects them rlttrmg r city rather States to protect us,if we ,en- time. place- We`ate taxpayers itporo usu- gaged' nxxr��i0 iaacl? Remember also,that the worst ers, in a democracy, voters between'tthe dtt EDwARD JmtlNso wrong ever committed on earth, rule, teachers. ddd increase Desert Hot Springs- to the most wonderful gill'of We will do anything and every- The hard feeling is Goachel all e. God,always has a plan; thing within our means to fight being created by ad at be er Noisy neighbor and hi ]an is always best. this proposed project] including bate will live Ion riddle o the F,M G. JENSEN picketing and demonstrating if 'pute is resolved,: The successful Desert Chapel Bermuda Dunes necessary, We cannot afford to are caught in the R. G EMM enlarged its campus with a multi- have our property values go perintendent an, Patin S rings 'purpose building, classrooms, Xnm r term down. We will not be forced to ration are here P parking, and sports fields. The live in fear. schools and teat ;rve_ city approved a Planned Devel- In response the Nov.22,let- MARcoT S. HERTZ dren.. The teat: opment District for expansion of ter"Remeutb Christ," Actual- Palm springs teach our.childr filetter `Inpo- the chapel campus. Plan provi- ly, Xmas is a ost as old as How do our ven me a im- sions do not allow amplified Christmas. . Thanks,film sponsors when these two I am n t a gay sound. TheXis a athrowbackto posim sides?Tl lefend a rights On Oct. 26,the chapel hosted the Greek letter ',part of Chi- I was fortunate to be invited to don't. mgs to a 'st with an amplified music event on its Rbo,the symbol f Cluist.Thus, the first Indian Film Festival.The LK rights y and I sports field. Our home is 100 Mans is a legi ' ate word for opening night film, "Doe Boy," iarassm nt and yards from this field. The previ- Christians. was a good dramatic piece by it- ous night, stage-building activi- The word Chr stmas means self. Adding the Indian element Ah'ing dirl list the f Mowing ties lasted until 1.30 a.m. Sound "mass of Christ," ter shortened and perspective made it quite awes for parades system testing began the after- to Christ-Mass, a even shorter unique and entertaining. Every- It seems Or jay Pride parade: noon of the performance.Follow- form Xmas — t used in Eu- one seemed to enjoy it rather upset ride, Peilophile ing the performance, take-down rope in the 1500 — is derived As you know,many people are even so much ¢er Pride. Imight and loading of the stage, sound from the Greek alphabet, in on the film festival bandwagon, der fuhrerand Bigots P 'de Pa- and lighting system lasted until which X is the trst letter of including the neighboring cities. with convict e he mig t enjoy 1:30 a.m. Christ's name: sips, therefore However,none of these have the "trrassive do use he fits e dic- On Oct. 31,a Halloween parry .X-Mass. prestige of Palm Springs and sounds like th Gription: a erson was held in the Chapel parking lot Xmas has bee used for cen- none of them have a cultural mu- tle black if ye itoleratit erson- adjacent to its. Announcements turies as a very r spectful term. seum with the foresight to help Does At C and music were amplified. Today,we ka that Chrstwas the city by building a distinct film temple ring a the surgeo who On Nov. 8, there was a high- not bom on c. 25. The date festival. Wen Ho Le Orating on , the scoring football game and queen was chosen to coincide with the I believe that the sponsors,the contact with ie visits,the a omey selection ceremony with ampli- pagan Rom celebrations hon- Agua Caliente Cultural Museum rent,whieb is he might n d,or fied commentary, whistles, elec- on Saturn s (the harvest god) board and the Supples,should be in 1995. C ",, ighi appear efore ironic horns, and power genera- and Mitma (the ancient god of commended for their willingness March 199S Ad be gay, and ome tors for lights. light),a fo of sun worship. and determination to contribute b er, and F Pt even have gay Unlike church members who These ebrations came on or to the well-beingof-theentrmgrty felony—oi p can chgose what they attend,we ltlst after a winter solsucei, the The addition of sttrt Z rare }rt It as clew lktgget,alrfe Wi o fzhQ�r i a� ppt r d ma's Yii# ti,r r" festival in-, vS rm wtll;ot is sic"lr_a:plea rile [aats�seC- ,' etJ."oim'ati"c ' �rkli r1 TJ'er7�iip'hele" '-".viare""t`�' e' owt v,he is in a r- take-downs,and comings and go- noun that winter is not forever, ''more than the Cultural Museum, the wheel t ings. that a continues, and an invi- again showing that we all should Regardir RHoDA BRo I aslc Desert Chapiy ors-to to nttts5"in good spirit. be proud to call the members of $7 trillion Indian wells please honorits agr0el�tt l, f+ } ,t. lll,4fit LiGON the Agrra Cali be our eryone kn the eommutrity. r m f° teuad Tatms neighbors. was overvl C Bible res)Ele�l RNESC Ited anotl P t'utm spf+njtt dirty laun Springs City Council $ 'a '4 ,w fie I doubt (and any government Don culll lire Noel It again should ]mow that Ro- Richard Zabgr, "Safety ft$t' �"" Ad 1* �:7 commands their re- How soon Christians and others right on the in We urgentlydp: a,F,di n g the Pastor h ' and they have shown forget that there is a devil. The 'hued standardized speed limits 1lTdISL ', $tit[twest Community years:; S their recent decision re Bible says the devil is m a lion,on here in the valley. Clturelt 8oanrlai,I have one thing w mat � the yowl to devour all that is We five off CookStreetinares tas'a} IfCve'saiditonI ee, 'vesaid � .a_ ,� The speed rt a thOn9alld times, whilYeurs NE1N6AkTEN ;1q,J 41OUGH Insurance Agents and Brokers E. Brent Hough Greg Hough David Therioult January 18, 2003 International Church of the Foursquare Gospel, DBA-.* Desert Chapel 630 S. Sunrise Way Palm Springs, Ca., 92264 Dear Frank: This letter will address our discussion regarding the easement and the discussions you have had with the City of Palm Springs and the Mesquite Country Club Homeowners Association regarding the naming of Mesquite Country Club Homeowners Association as Additional Insured on the Desert Chapel liability insurance policy. I have not been privy to the meetings of the Mesquite Country Club Homeowners Association and Desert Chapel, and do not have a copy of the contract that was signed. We were asked last March to issue an endorsement naming the Mesquite Country Club Homeowners Association as an additional insured under our liability insurance policy. After several discussions with our company underwriter and the Company Regional Vice President regarding the various parties and the requests being made, the company said that they would issue the requested Additional Insured Endorsement if the Mesquite Country Club Homeowners Association would reciprocate and issue one to us. This is only proper since they are using our premises to drive through and to park their vehicles as well. I have contacted Hartford Insurance Company, who also has a school program, as well as Zurich Insurance Company, and Westchester Fire Insurance Company, but none will rcomilh-tbis request. All their comments�wer l0a if someone else is using our property, we would expect to receive a Certificate of Insurance and Additional Insured Endorsement from them. If we are using their property, then We would give them one, but in this case, the solution would be for each party to reciprocate with a Certificate of Insurance and Additional Insured Endorsements. After several scathing conversations with the Mesquite Country Club Homeowners Association attorney, Wayne Guralnick, it was obvious that he didn't understand and did not want to cooperate. As additional attempts to negotiate with him have been met with foul language and improper accord, I have abandoned my attempt to deal with him. In the beginning, I reviewed this not only with the underwriter, but also the supervisor of underwriting for the insurance company that provides the liability coverage for Desert Chapel. Their position was and remains firm--as it would be with any carrier--that they will agree to provide a Certificate of Insurance with the Additional Insured endorsement favoring the Mesquite Country Club Homeowners Association, only if we can obtain the same. Not withstanding the agreement that was signed, the position of any insurance carrier in this instance would be to protect itself from a known entity using their property. Certificates of Insurance with additional insured endorsements are required as a normal scope of business in situations like this. In summary, I will be more than happy to meet with the City if you wish, but the circumstance hasn't changed relative to use of our property by others. Your insurance company is there to protect you, not to just fall prey to an attorney attempting to satisfy his client at everyone else's expense. The Church has been more than willing to let people from the association walk through their property, as well as on the vacated street, without any request of Certificates of Insurance in the past, however, if the requirement is now to provide a Certificate of Insurance, Desert Chapel's insurance carrier will require Mesquite Country Club Homeowners Association to reciprocate. Sincerely, f , Hugh K. Curtis �'� (17 �> N City of Palm Springs * Department of Planning and Zoning * a .^' * 3200 E.Tahquitz Canyon Way • Palm Springs,California 92262 C araRnzeu �P q< TEL:(760)323-8245 • FAX(760)322-8360 • TDD(760)864-9527 /PORN January 03, 2003 Robert E. Pailthorp 2001 Camino Parocela Palm Springs, CA 92262 Re: Desert Chapel Dear Mr. Pailthorp: Thank you for your letter dated December 31, 2002. In response to your question, the City Ordinance requires a public hearing to revise or amend a Planned Development District. Public hearings before the Planning Commission and City Council will be required. Sincerely, Douglas Evans Director of Planning & Zoning cc: Pastor Fred Donaldson � co co Post Office Box 2743 0 Palm Springs, California 9226'�-2743 RECEIVED Karleen Grummett 2001 Camino Paroeela,J72 JAN 14 2Q03 Palm Springs, CA 92264 January 7, 2003 PLANNING DIVISION Bobby gaffney Associate Manager Mesquite Country Club Condo HOA P.O.Box 2342 Palm Springs, CA 92263 Dear Bobby, I'm writing to add my voice (and my husband,Roger's) to condo owners in Phase Ill-who have been adversely affected by the ongoing development of Desert Chapel. We began renting in this phase 15 years ago and bought our condo seven years ago. We enjoy the sound of children piaying_at-recess so.thathas never beertan issueforus_Wbat haG hemme-an issue is the noise generated and multiplied by the building of a football field 300 feet from our front deck, which is in the part of our phase most effected by Desert Chapels'infringements 6ne`cvald almost excuse the decibels of the cheering fans,but the volume of the speaker microphone goes over the top. When the vision for this field and the ensuing permits were allowed,what was the City of Palm Springs thinking? Certainly not of this longstanding neighborhood. Many condo owners have made personal appeals to Chapel leaders to make some concessions regarding noise abatement to i o avail. I think our personal tolerance finally boiled over when street cleaning machinery showed up at 2am one Sunday morning in order to clean the parking lot before church services. I'm sorry to have to repert, based on our-experiencesand-that-o€ but Christian in giving credence to their closest neighbors' concerns. Isn't there anything to be done about their flagrant abuses? We're not unreasonable people complaining unreasonably. I would happily invite the City Council and Desert Chapel leaders to come stand in our-living-room some-eveningwherran—=Tvitygis occurringin-that eld so they can experiencewhatieslike for us_And.wefre-noteverahe closest condo building to be affected. Sincerely, K�arleen and tt Phase III„U tit J72 Page 1 of 1 Alex Meyerhoff From Robert Pailthorp[bobpail@teleport.com] Sent: Tuesday, December 31, 2002 3:29 PM c —� —� To: Mesquite Home Owners Association Cc: Alex Meyerhoff Subject: Desert Chapel P�EDEC 3 1 2002 I December 31, 2002 PL A 4;, i� I— I, /I :]f�) Douglas R. Evans, Director of Planning and Zoning City of Palm Springs PO Box 2743 Palm Springs, California 92263-2743 Subject: Exterior lighting at Desert Chapel Dear Mr. Evans: I have expressed my concern that the lighting of the football field and the parking lot closest to us result in glare at our residence. The Planned Development District#59 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL, item 17 refers to the City's non-glare standards. I do not believe the Outdoor lighting standards 93.21.00 contain a specific reference to a non-glare standard. They do however contain requirements that the Desert Chapel is not observing. I believe it is unreasonable to permit the lighting of the football field as currently being done by the Chapel. It seems that the City standards do not allow such lighting. I also ask that the city review the lighting used in the parking lot adjacent to our residence. In a recent letter to the Chapel you referred to a hedge. While a hedge would reduce light glare from low lights it will do nothing for the elevated football field lighting. Also, a hedge will do very little to reduce sound that reaches our residence. Only solid sound barriers would be effective and then only if of sufficient height. I do not believe it is reasonable to expect to hold high school football games in the evening adjacent to a residential area. Neither the lighting nor the amplified sound used by the chapel seems to be permitted. I hope the Chapel will be required to comply with current City standards. Sincerely, Robert E. Pailthorp 2001 Camino Parocela Palm Springs 12/31/02 Tuesday,December$I,200212:0s PM Robert E,Paighorp 15417e58902 p 02 December 31,2002 Dear Mr, Evans: A copy of your letter to the Pastor of the Desert Chapel has been shared with us. I believe you are aware that our residence is adjacent to the Chapel, In addition to the noise from the Chapel we draw your attention to the lighting used for the football games and other activities. Thoy do not seem to comply with the Cities non-glare standards. In addition these lights are powered with internal combustion engines that run all the time the lights are in use, The wording of your letter suggests to us that all the Chapel needs to do to continue with their activities and is to get them approved. I hope this is not the.case, We are concerned about the activities that do not comply with the Master Plan Revisions,PD59,CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL, October 13, 1999. Will there be an opportunity for public input to the process of changing the Conditions of Approval? If the current activities are approved then what can we look forward to in the future? Robert E.Pailthotp Dorthea M, Pailtborp �001 Camino Parocela Palm Springs,CA 9/� Tuesday,December 31,2002 3;32 PM Robert E.Pailthorp 15417656902 p,01 December 31,2002 Douglas R. Evans,Director of Planning and Zoning City of Palm Springs PO Box 2743 Palm Springs, California 92263-2743 Subject: Exterior lighting at Desert Chapel Dear Mr.Evans: I have expressed my concern that the lighting of the football field and the parking lot closest to us result in glare at our residence. The Planned Development District#59 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL, item 17 refers to the City's non-glare standards. I do not believe the Outdoor lighting standards 93.21.00 contain a specific reference to a non-glare standard. They do however contain requirements that the Desert Chapel is not observing. I believe it is unreasonable to permit the lighting of the football field as currently being done by the Chapel. It seems that the City standards do not allow such lighting. I also ask that the city review the lighting used in the parking lot adjacent to our reaidemoe. In a recent letter to the Chapel you referred to a hedge. While a hedge would reduce light glare from low tights it will do nothing for the elevated football field lighting. Also, a hedge will do very little to reduce sound that reaches our residence. Only solid sound barriers would be effective and then only if of sufficient height. I do not believe it is reasonable to expect to hold high school football games in the evening adjacent to a residential area. Neither the lighting nor the amplified sound used by the chapel seems to be pertnitted. I hope the Chapel will be required to comply with current City standards. Sin" ly, 13 .bert E.Pailthorp 2001 Camino Parocela Palm Springs g�.s� O�QALMgA� N City of Palm Springs * Department of Planning and Zoning 3200 E.Uliquitz Canyon Way • Palm Springs, California 92262 O rpo"n*E� P TEL:(760)323-8245 • FAX(760)322-8360 • TDD(760)864-9527 g41FORN� December 16, 2002 Pastor Fred Donaldson Desert Chapel 630 Sunrise Way South Palm Springs, CA 92264 Re: Revised Planned Development District and Activities Dear Pastor Donaldson: Thank you for taking the time to meet with City staff to discuss recent complaints regarding Desert Chapel and revisions to the Planned Development District No. 59. During the meeting, provided copies of complaint letters that have been sent to the City. Complaints have been received regarding football games at night, evening outdoor activities, amplified music, the miniature train, landscaping, and a concert. I have written several letters regarding complaints and have discussed these issues with you. In order to deal with these issues, we discussed submitting a revised Planned Development District request which would address the following: 1. Sunny Dunes Road street vacation. 2. Temporary lighting for special events. 3. Football games, lighting, and other athletic events. 4. Outdoor activities. 5. Public address system for events. 6. Other activities and programs as needed. It is apparent that there is a need to more clearly define Desert Chapel activities, programs, and appropriate conditions of approval. This will allow Desert Chapel, its neighbors, and the City to have a better understanding of what is permitted. Currently, City staff(Planning, Police, and City Attorney) is spending a substantial amount of time to balance community and church issues. 1 W 3 Post Office Bo- z743 • P^Irn Snrin2s ('nlifnrnia nl')�A '» r Page 2 of 2 Revised Planned Development District and Activities — Desert Chapel December 16, 2002 On November 12, 2002, 1 sent you a letter regarding approval of football games. The football season was well underway when the City received its first complaint. The complaint was received soon after the youth concert. The temporary approval was handled by staff in the interest of allowing the scheduled games to continue and impose certain restrictions on lighting and operations. Night football games were not contemplated in the original Planned Development District permit. The temporary approval is rescinded and the Planned Development District needs to be amended to include night sporting events. Options range from amending the Planned Development District, rescheduling games to afternoons, or using an alternate venue. This needs to be resolved as soon as possible since schedules need to be completed for next year. The last issue we need to discuss is the City's Noise Ordinance. The Ordinance is in effect 24 hours per day. Desert Chapel needs to evaluate its activities and review activities which are conducted outdoors. The Ordinance does not differentiate types of noise. There are several issues that could be addressed in the short-term. The train whistle could be modified to make it quieter. Also, outdoor activities could be located and oriented away from the neighboring residential properties. Additionally, more landscape materials, including larger trees, could help with some of the complaints. Balancing the needs of the community and church/school will be an ongoing challenge. Revising the Planned Development District will clarify the allowable church activities and create a better understanding for neighbors and church officials. If you have any questions, please give me a call. Sincerely, 4 Douglas R. Evans Director of Planning & Zoning cc: Mayor and City Council David Ready, City Manager Dave Aleshire, City Attorney Gary Jeandron, Police Chief Arthur MacMillan Mesquite Homeowners'Association � � � Qa � IIInIII tl 2002 December 1, 2002 1k F�L/AIMING DIVISION Mr. Douglas Evans Director of Planning &Zoning City of Palm Springs 3200 Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, Ca. 92262 Re: Desert Chapel - Case No. 5.0788/PD-59 Dear Mr. Evans: Your letter to Desert Chapel dated 11/05/02: "I would recommend that starting immediately, all future outdoor activities involving amplified music and/or public address systems be relocated inside the Multi-Purpose Building or be canceled. Your letter to me dated 11/13/02: "I have discussed outdoor events with Desert Chapel representatives. I have been assured that there will be no further outdoor concerts or similar large-scale events. Desert Chapel does not have any further events scheduled" November 22nd, 2002 Another football game consisting of tower lights, sound amplification and cheering crowds lasting until 10:55 PM(reference my previous letter to you dated 11/24) Sunday Evening, December 1st 2002 At approximately 4:30 PM, rehearsal began in the outdoor courtyard of Desert Chapel for the evenings Christmas concert which was prominately advertised in the Desert Sun newspaper on November 30th (page D4) as "Christmas in the Courtyard". This event involved amplified music and/or a public address system, a live choir, a train ride with a realistic sounding train whistle(for the children) and a audience of approximately two hundred attendees. The courtyard (which is adjacent to our homes) caused the amplified music to increase and echo around the neighborhood, again subjecting the residents to the loud music, whether one wanted to listen or not - we had no choice. This event could very easily have been located inside the Multi-Purpose building. I phoned the Police Department at approximately 5:15 PM and spoke to Commander Starrs. He had no knowledge of any letter(s) to the Police Chief from you regarding Desert Chapel and said "nothing has trickled down to any of us". I drove my car to the Police Department to hand deliver copies of your letters to Mr. Starts so he could be aware of your concerns and warnings to the church. I asked him to please send an officer over to make a report and document the noise so that it could be on record and come from someone other than myself-He said he would. I asked that the officer come around 6PM as the newspaper ad ?Ao� a stated the event would start at that time. The rehearsal and the event came to an end prior to 7PM- The police officer (badge#58) arrived at my home at 8:34 PM after the event had already concluded. Any suggestions how to resolve our ongoing concerns? Sincerely, i"a" Arthur MacMillan 2001 Camino Parocela#I--77 Palm Springs, Ca. 92264 cc: Mesquite Country Club HOA David Ready, City Manager Gary Jeandron, Police Chief City Council Members 9�� ....... ......_..__ ! NOV 2 5 20 02 November 24 2002 -- p Mr. Frank Marshall, Administrator Desert Chapel 630 Sunrise Way South Palm Springs, Ca. 92264 Re: Case No. 5.0870 Desert Chapel/PD-59 Dear Mr, Marshall: In the hope that Desert Chapel is attempting to be a little more sensitive to the concerns from your neighbors regarding late evening noise emanating from church property, I would like to bring to your attention some observances from this past Friday's football game that took place on the evening of November 22nd. The football game in the playing field, which consisted of evening lighting, sound amplification and cheering crowds, came to a conclusion after 10:00 PM. After the game concluded around 10:15 and crowds started to disperse, several of the attendees with their families stayed on and walked over to the North side of SunnyDunes near the border fence which is adjacent to our homes. As the families loitered in the parking area after the game, a childs game of football began in the parking lot and lasted until 10:50 pm. Around 10:55, the parking lot became quiet. At this time I heard the sound of a motorcycle start up in the parking lot. I believe this motorcycle belongs to your groundsman who was leaving for the night. He raced the motorcycle engine for five to seven minutes in the parking lot before driving away. It was 11:00 PM when it became quiet and I could then at least go to the bedroom and attempt to fall asleep after five hours of what was just described above. Sincerely, Arthur MacMillan 2001 Camino Parocela K-77 Palm Springs, Ca. 92264 cc: Douglas R. Evans ity`C�nn ' embers Mesquite HOA Association qo#of RECEIVED NOV 2 2 2002 November 21, 2002 PLANNING DIVISION Mr. Douglas Evans Director of Planning&Zoning City of Palm Springs 3200 Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, Ca. 92262 Re: Desert Chapel - Case No. 5.0788/PD - 59 Dear Mr. Evans: I have received your letter and appreciate you taking the time to visit the athletic field for the Friday night football game and for explaining the lighting setup that you have approved. By facing the lights east and west, I assume you feel comfortable that positioning the lights this way helps eliminate the glare problem. You also mentioned that there may or may not be additional games this season. That is a response we usually hear when we discuss our concerns directly with the church, but the outdoor "events" keep coming and with more frequency as the church continues to grow. This evening when I came home from work and looked out my living room window, there are the nine light towers positioned for another weekend of outdoor events. Since there are obviously outdoor events that will be going on this weekend (I don't know the church's schedule) with the light towers in position, I would like to invite you to come out and see OUR perspective of what we must endure while these events occur. Since you have visited the church and worked with them, is it not fair that you also visit with the homeowners impacted by these events and see firsthand from our perspective. By positioning the lights cast/west, you have created a safety hazard on the city bike trail that runs between Farrell and Sunrise. If you are riding a bicycle or walking on the trail after sunset and the tower lights are on, you are 100% blinded by the lights where you cannot even put your hand out in front of your face and see it. It is at it's worst when you are on the bike trail (in phase III of Mesquite) near the tennis courts that are closest to the church. Is this acceptable to the city and is there not a liability issue involved if one is so blinded by the lights that an accident can occur between bicycles or a bicycle/pedestrian? Also your letter to me makes no mention of the outdoor p/a system during the football games. Allowed or not allowed? According to the Conditions of Approval for Desert Chapel, this is not allowed. What is the measure for when it becomes a violation of the noise ordinance after 5pm and what is the penalty to the church for violating this noise ordinance to deter them from continuing to violate? Are you willing to "measure" the noise level that these events create, or is it just assumed that with a few hundred people being encouraged to scream and yell along with music and a outdoor p/a system that any fA56 acceptable level has been exceeded, however the city is allowing this to continue? How do we know at what degree of noise level the police will respond, if at all, or are they instructed not to intervene with any football games? Were noise levels not measured and documented when the Tennis Club homes were complaining about the late night noise coming from the Palm Canyon restaurants that have the outdoor bands? It seemed everyone from the City Council on down worked hard to help those homeowners get back their right to peace and quiet. When Angel stadium sits empty on the nights the church has these football games, why can't the city work with the church and relocate these games in that stadium which is designed and located for such large scale crowds? It just baffles me that our paradise and right to peace and quiet can be destroyed by one groups desire to "entertain" themselves, without any regard to the rights of the rest of the citizens of the community. When the church expansion was in the planning stage, I made frequent visits to your planning department to review blueprints and layouts for the church as I live closest to the church property and plan on remaining living here the rest of my years. I was assured by the person in the planning department that the playing field was being allowed for daytime activities only. That was the reason no permanent lighting was allowed on the field. When I inquired about crowds on the field, I was told no bleachers were going to be allowed. I was told that was the reason for the multi purpose building - this was supposed to "contain" the crowds and noise from the rest of the communty and evening events would be illuminated within the confines of the building. I told the planning department gentlemen (Mr. Meyerhoff has now taken his place) to please be sure the multi purpose building did not have door openings on the side that faced our condos. Needless to say, the side the faces our condos has a large garage style roll down door, that is often left open for their indoor events, such as band practice and games. This then causes a amplification effect that bellows out right towards our windows. Since the church has also used the tower lights in other areas of the property (in the parking lots that adjoin Sunrise during large events-where the lights are facing our condo windows, and on the property north of Sunny Dunes, up against the fence that borders the Baristo Storm channel and our condos, such as they did for the recent Halloween event that had hundreds of participants outdoors in the parking lot along with amplified music and a p/a system only yards from our windows. Is this going to continue with the city's blessing or will this be considered a violation in the future. Since I am not convinced the church will cease these activities and expect they will continue, at what level of noise/lighting/etc, will a police response or code enforcement response be deemed appropriate. Also for your information, I did contact a code enforcement person for the last football game. The person (Carol?) told me that she was aware the church was in violation of city codes, however, she was informed by you to not take any action and to advise me that you were working with the church on the issues that concerned us. So we don't need to cormnunicate again when Suimner arrives, what can we expect when the church begins the weekend teenager hangout which goes on well past midnight from )01 x � / June into September? This is supervised by only one person (the son of one of the administrators who is barely a teenager himself) who can be found indoors in a large classroom with about 50 teens. The door to this room is always left open, with the music and noise from that room bellowing out towards our homes. The rest of the church grounds outdoors are not supervised by anyone. The teens come and go in their cars, hang out in the parking lots, car radios blasting,jumping over fences, running into the golf course or the city well property, skate boarding between the portable classrooms on the sidewalk, and taking rides on portable steel bookcases with wheels down the parking lot, screaming when they get dumped off the carts. Some of them even walls around the border fence into the Baristo Storm creek and sit on the large rocks, which is very close to our windows. I have even smelled marijuana on more than one occasion when the teens are sitting in the City well property or along the wash. Even though this is not considered an outdoor"event", it creates the same amount of disturbance and noise. When I walk over and ask that the noise be kept down, or if it's close to 1:30 in the morning, I'm told by the one person in charge that it's their private property and they can do what they want. If I then phone the police, since it's a weekend, my calls go to the bottom of their list. The church won't even keep their own security guard on duty to watch the teens past 9:00 or 10:00 PM, even though the teens are there until 2:00 am. Can you name even one other place in the city where so many city code violations occur in one location that go unchecked? We need clear and concise information from the city Mr. Evans about our concerns and we are being told by the city manager and city attorney that we are to work with you. The church is not going to go away and neither are many of us homeowners that love this area and plan to stay for many years. I realize how busy you must be with the growth of this city and the issues you must face on a daily basis. I am sure you don't want to keep writing letters regarding Desert Chapel...... however to us, as I'm sure you understand, this is an issue of great concern, and according to the Conditions of Approval in regards to lights, P/A system and city codes regarding noise, many of these occurrences are clear violations. Sincerely, Arthur MacMillan 2001 Camino Parocela K-77 Palm Springs, Ca. 92264 (daytime phone between 10-5pm: 323-2979) CC: Mesquite Country Club HOA Association City Council 9�� hp4 PALM sp�,c City of Palm Springs Department of Planning &Zoning 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, CA 92262 Aurovt (760) 323-8245 —direct (760) 322-8360—facsimile Pages (including cover): 2 Date: November 15, 2002 To: Mr. Bob Pailthorp Fax number: (541) 765-8902 From: Douglas R. Evans, Director of Planning & Zoning Re: Desert Chapel Dear Mr. Pailthorp: Following is a copy of my letter to Mr. Arthur MacMillan from November 13, 2002 regarding Desert Chapel which I hope will address the same issues you raised in your November 09, 2002 e-mail. Thank you for faxing this e-mail to the City. Please call me if you have any further questions or concerns. Thank you. Sincerely, Douglas R. Evans Director of Planning &Zoning Monday, November 11, 2002 9:49 AM Robert E, Pailthorp 15417658902 p.01 Attention: Mr. Douglas Evans Date: 11/11/2002 Company: City of Palm Spruigs Number of Pages: 4 Fax Number: 322-8360 Voice Number: From: Robert E. Pailthorp �'� , ,�.,,1•" Company: Fax Number: 15417658902 Voice Number: 15417652483 Subject: Desert Chapel Comments: Mr, Evans: If the Chapel has received your letter of Nov. 5th they had not taken any notice as of Nov.8th. the pictures were taken from our back yard on Nov 8th. Our unit is 100 yards from the foot ball field and the site of the stage for the music concert. Robert Pailthorp K-73 Mesquite Monday,November 11,20029:49 AM Robert E.Pailthorp 15417658902 p.02 Hurl} Nee 1 of'4 of I y�Lj Robert Pailthorp r From: "Robert Pallthorp"-4bobpailatelepon,com� To: "Bob Pailthorp"4obpail@teleport.com} Cc: "Mesquite Home owners Assoclsllon"<MCCHOA@GTE.NET> Sent; Saturday,November 00,2002 9:38 PM Attach: Desert Chapel lighting 11.8-02.jpg;Desert Chapel 6PM 11.8.02.jpg; Desert Chapel lights 11-8- 02.jpg Subject: Daaert Chapel Nov.6,2002 The following is for my records. There was a football game and the selection of a queen at half time, The game started about 6:00 PM and ended at 10:00 PM. The flood lights went out shortly after the game ended and cars left the parking lot. The activity and the sounding area was lighted with portable light units that cast light onto our building and onto the golf course. See the attached pictures. These flood lights are powered by internal combustion engines with their associated noise. Amplified speaker was used for player Introductions,play-by -play comments, announcements, Introduction of several candidates for queen. An electronic siren was used to start and end the game as well as to start and end the half time, Game officials used whistles though out the game. Amplified rock music was played several times during the game. Each touchdown,there were about 12, resulted in amplified comments and announcements, 1t was announced the a queen will be selected each year, The noise level was great enough many times to make it difficult to carry on a conversation on our patio. The cheering crowd Was at times as loud as the amplified sound, Bob Pailthorp, K-73 11/9/2002 rvw.? p � Y i 1,n t ionm Monday,November 11,2002 9,49 AM Robert E, Pailthorp 15417658902 p.03 Page 3 of 4 i'. Tit l... rt,•"•iM.sSity"r� �n4.�'� l'.�'i¢i, . 1...:. :',1 Fd, 1 q 7 t/r i tonno c � 2 . � y , � } • : , - � � � OF PAL_ Sp City of Palm Springs V rn * * Department of Planning & Building b * �rObognlav a9h 'F 3200 Tahquitz Canyon Way 4 Palm Springs,California 92262 Cq�1 TO RN�P TEL:(760)323-8245 • PAX(760)322-8360 -TDD(760)864-9527 November 13, 2002 Arthur MacMillan 2001 Camino Parocela K-77 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Re: Desert Chapel — Case No. 5.0788/PD —59 Dear Mr. MacMillan: I have received your letter dated November 08, 2002 regarding various outdoor events and temporary lighting at Desert Chapel. I appreciate your ongoing concerns and hope that this letter clarifies Desert Chapel activities. First, the mobile tower lights were placed on the athletic field for Friday night's football game. There were four light towers located on the east side of the field and five light towers located on the west side of the field. On Friday afternoon, I worked with Desert Chapel representatives to submit for approval a temporary lighting plan for football games only. In addition to reviewing the plan, I personally inspected the athletic field prior to the game. The lights were placed in accordance with the plan and all lights were facing east and west. The temporary lighting plan has been approved for football games only. The season is almost over and there may or may not be additional games this season. Secondly, I have discussed outdoor events with Desert Chapel representatives. I have been assured that there will be no further outdoor concerts or similar large-scale events. Desert Chapel does not have any further events scheduled. Furthermore, I have discussed the City Noise Ordinance with Desert Chapel representatives and they are aware of its provisions and the fact that Desert Chapel must comply with its provisions. Noise Ordinance violations that occur after 5:00 p.m. during the weekdays need to be reported to the Police Department at (760) 323-8115 or 327-1441. Noise complaints during the week, during normal business hours, should be reported to the Community Preservation section of the Department of Building & Safety at (760) 323-8245. 1 hope this letter clarifies activities at Desert Chapel. Additionally, I am keenly aware that you have had ongoing concerns and City staff will continue to work with homeowners and Desert Chapel representatives to work out as many issues as possible. Sincerely Dou las . Evans 9 Director of Planning & Zoning CC: David Ready, City Manager Gary Jeandron, Police Chief Post Office Box 2743 0 Palm Springs, California 92263-2743 RECEIVED November 8, 2002 2002 NOV - 8 Douglas R. Evans PLANNING DIVISION Director of Planning and Zoning 3200 Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, Ca. 92262 Re: Case No. 5 0870 Desert Chapel/PD-59 Dear Mr. Evans: Despite your letter to Desert Chapel regarding violation of City Codes, the church is continuing to conduct various outdoor events without any sign of their willingness to comply. Yesterday afternoon, five mobile tower lights were brought in to the outdoor field and positioned so that all of them face the Mesquite Country Club Condos in Phase III. Each of these tower lights contain FOUR bulbs. They were in use throughout the evening and will be probably be used throughout the weekend. At least fifty homeowners have living room and bedroom windows which directly face these light towers. Again we must close our windows and drop our blinds so that we are not blinded by these light bulbs. This is in violation of Condition #17 of the Planned Development District. Sincerely, Arthur MacMillan 2001 Camino Parocela K-77 Palm Springs Ca. 92264 (760) 323-2979 q407 L li r J �f 9 1 L l r., 1 L f KII A I cL I _� L 1 pyT 61 pt � 4 E V 8 2002 �� NOV �I L�-� �F PALM Sp City of Palm Springs V (A Department of Planning&Building r + Planning Division rC1aAl EO 3200 Tahquia Canyon Way • Palm Springs,California 92262 Cq�l PO RN�P TEL:060)323-8245 • PAX(760)322-8360 •TDD(760)864-9527 November 5, 2002 Mr(,Frank Marshall; Administrator ' Dese�r Chapel � 630 Sunrise Way South Palm Springs, CA 92264 Re: Case No.5 �0e i Dear Mr. Marshall, On October 26, 2002, and again on October 31, 2002, the Desert Chapel hosted outdoor events with amplified music and/or speakers. The City has received a number of complaints regarding noise, light and traffic generated by this event, from as far as 1.25 miles away from the facility. Although no noise readings were conducted, the event constitutes a violation of the noise ordinance, as the noise ordinance essentially prohibits loud outdoor amplified music. In addition, because the event included amplified music and/or speakers using a public address system, the event was in violation of Condition# 40 of the Planned Development District (attached). Staff understands that sporting events are regularly conducted at the facility, which similarly use a public address system and are also likely in violation of the noise ordinance and Condition #40, In addition, lighting is strictly regulated by City code and may have been used or installed without City approval (Condition #17 of the Planned Development District). These issues need to addressed by the Desert Chapel. It is important that the Desert Chapel operate in compliance with City Codes and Ordinances, with the conditions of the Planned Development District and in good faith with the rest of the community. If the Desert Chapel intends to conduct special events in the future, Desert Chapel may need to amend its Planned Development District and needs to meet to discuss City Codes, Ordinances and overall permits. In the future any activities which violate City Codes and Ordinances may be subjectto enforcement action by the City, which could include citations, event cancellation and/or revocation of permits. If you wish to discuss outdoor activities please contact my office. I would recommend that, starting immediately, all future outdoor activities involving amplified music and/or public address systems be relocated inside the Multi-Purpose Building or be cancelled. A69 Pr-r Offi— Rm, 97,43 0 Polm Snrinvs C-lifornia 92263-2743 ?ALM Sp City of Palm Springs * * Department of Planning & Building e * ~�R^oeATca`3 * 3200 Tahquiez Canyon Way• Palm Springs,California 92262 /r° \p' TEL:(760)323-8245 • FAX(760)322-8360• TDD(760)964-9527 November 12, 2002 Frank Marshall Desert Chapel 630 Sunrise Way South Palm Springs, CA 92264 Re: Desert Chapel Temporary Lighting Plan for Football Games Only— Case No. 5.0788/PD—59 Dear Frank: I have reviewed the proposed lighting plan and conducted a site inspection on Friday, November 08, 2002 at 6:00 p.m. The lighting diagram is approved for football games only. All lights shall be directed due east and west and at no time shall the lights be directed north or south. Lighting shall be turned off within 30 minutes of the end of the game. Two lights may be used to assist in cleanup and clearance of the field but shall be turned off by 11:00 p.m. The use of a temporary public address system (PA) is approved for football games only. The PA shall comply with the City Noise Ordinance at all times. A copy is attached. I appreciate your assistance in responding to Community issues and concerns. Sincerely, Douglas R. Evans Director of Planning & Zoning CC: David Ready, City Manager �� �O Gary Jeandron, Police Chief o� PALM s, vSprings � Cit of Palm, * * Department of Planning & Building b * �C�RPORATEO,yA * 3200 Tahquitz Canyon Way • Palm Sprigs,California 92262 C"�I FO?, TEL:(760)323-8245 • FAX(760)322-8360 •Too(760)864-9527 November 12, 2002 Pastor Fred Donaldson Desert Chapel 630 Sunrise Way South Palm Springs, CA 92264 Re: Outdoor Activities at Desert Chapel —Case No. 5.0788/PD — 59 Dear Pastor Donaldson: I want to confirm the items discussed during our telephone conversation on November 08, 2002. During our conversation, we discussed outdoor activities, outdoor concerts, and football games. All outdoor activities need to comply with the conditions of approval for Planned Development District No. 59. If Desert Chapel desires to alter its operation and City permits, we will need to discuss the process to amend PD No. 59. Since the Sunny Dunes street vacation needs to be resolved, this would be a good opportunity to amend the Planned Development District. During our discussions, you indicated that the outdoor concert held on October 26, 2002 was not a Desert Chapel sponsored event and that there are no further outdoor concerts scheduled or planned in the future. Outdoor concerts will likely violate the City's Noise Ordinance anytime during the day, evening, or night. The Noise Ordinance is in effect 24 hours per day. Our experience at various venues throughout the City is that outdoor concerts violate the Noise Ordinance and are unacceptable to surrounding residents. If Desert Chapel wants to pursue outdoor concerts, please contact me since your Planned Development District permit would need to be amended and the City Noise Ordinance would also have to be amended. On a cautionary note, Desert Chapel needs to be aware that the indoor concerts could also result in complaints and may also violate the Noise Ordinance. Concert-level sound -- especially base drums and other instruments -- cause lower frequency sounds which may not be contained in the building. Low-frequency sound travel great distances and passes through building walls. Lastly, I have reviewed and approved a temporary lighting plan for the football games only. A copy of this approval is attached. I A 071 Post Office Box ?743 0 Palm Snrinnc Cglifnrnia n77F° 9710 f 2 1 appreciate your efforts and those of your staff to work with the City to address community and neighborhood concerns. If you have any questions, please give me a call. Sin cerel �G Douglas R. Evans Director of Planning & Zoning CC: David Ready, City Manager David Aleshire, City Attorney Gary Jeandron, Police Chief O� PALM SA City of Palm Springs * * Department of Planning & Building * roRRORpTEO\p * 3200 Ta6quaz Canyon Way • Palm Springs,California 92262 Cq!I F0 RN�P TEL:(760)323-8245 • FAX(760)322-8360• TDD(760)864-9527 November 12, 2002 Frank Marshall Desert Chapel 630 Sunrise Way South Palm Springs, CA 92264 Re: Desert Chapel Temporary Lighting Plan for Football Games Only- Case No. 5.0788/PD - 59 Dear Frank: have reviewed the proposed lighting plan and conducted a site inspection on Friday, November 08, 2002 at 6:00 p.m. The lighting diagram is approved for football games only. All lights shall be directed due east and west and at no time shall the lights be directed north or south. Lighting shall be turned off within 30 minutes of the end of the game. Two lights may be used to assist in cleanup and clearance of the field but shall be turned off by 11:00 p.m. The use of a temporary public address system (PA) is approved for football games only. The PA shall comply with the City Noise Ordinance at all times. A copy is attached. I appreciate your assistance in responding to Community issues and concerns. Sincerely, Douglas R. Evans Director of Planning & Zoning CC: David Ready, City Manager Gary Jeandron, Police Chief IA73 Post Offin- Bo- ?743 • P-lm Snrinsrs r�lifnrni 9,)?(,'� )-7/° O� PA LM S City of Palm Springs City Attorney RPOPP1t° 3200 Tahqui¢Canyon Way` Palm Springs,California 92262 '14I FO?, TEL:(760)323-8211 •TDD(760)864-9527 November 12, 2002 Mr. Ron Novy,President Mesquite Country Club Condominium HOA P.O. Box 2342 Palm Springs, CA 92263 Re: Complaint of October 31 re Desert Chapel Dear Mr. Novy: Thank you for your letter of October 31, 2002 concerning your complaint that Desert Chapel has not complied with various conditions of approval. Of course,I agree with your point that the City must either enforce its rules or change them. It does appear that there is administrative authority to approve extensions in time for outdoor activities past 10:00 P.M.,but it appears from the correspondence and e-mails that these were neither sought nor given. The question is one of proper administrative response. It is the City's policy to attempt to work in a non coercive manner with its constituents to resolve issues, and this is why the wheels of government can sometimes appear to move slowly. I can see you have been communicating with the Planning Department and have sent a copy of your letter to Doug Evans. I will also copy this letter to the City Manager,the head of the administrative organization. I'm sure that if the City staff feels that legal action is necessary to assure compliance, they will refer the matter to our office. However,I believe that Desert Chapel is a responsible organization and this will not prove necessary. Please continueto work with the Planning Department unless the City Manager directs otherwise,and letthe City Manager and me know if the situation is not resolved in the near future. Very truly yours, David J. Aleshire City Attorney DJA:mme cc: David Ready, City Manager (w/letter of 10/31/02) Mayor and City Councilmembers Doug Evans, Director of Planning&Zoning Frank V. Marshall, III, Administrator, Desert Chapel 7 Post Office Box 2743 0 Palm Springs, California 92263-2743 MESQUITE E COUNTRY CLUB CONDO HOMEOWNERS _AS80OI'ATIION . P.O. Box�2342 - Palm Springs; CA 92263 RECEIVED NOT 1 3 2002 October 31, 2ooz PLANiVIIVG D SION Mr. David J. Aleshire City Attorney, City of Palm Springs 118301 Von Karman Ave., Suite 1050 Irvine, CA 92612 Re: Desert Chapel Dear Mr. Aleslure: The purpose of this letter is td inform you gf5evergl areas of npn',cornpliance by Desert Chapel, with the Conditiori"s of 1�'�Ppoval for'1 expansion ti The Conditions of Approval ae provided tows bylDouglas R E�anS;rDirector of Planning and Building, specifically State "T/ae3oleantYer s(reenuzg along the northern property line shall be trla-infithicd l¢tlae sa`tasfactton of_=,the°Ihre�tor`of Planning and Building. The nil nimui-weighia'f•"trtmmui shall'be sevens(7 feel. All dead plants shall be replaced with innture hedge materiel with..drrr Itudni"iRot of seven (7) feet." I can assure you that, at n ......Vie,has thus seatiori been complied with, -Either We have had to contend with dead plant material, missing planbmate'rial„or short plant material. The Conditions of Approval further state"Evening ouCd;oor activities at the subject site shall cease at I0:00 P.M. unless special'time extensions are granted by the Director of Planning and Building and/or the Chief of Police'; and "No public address system shall be allowed otter than for emergency service." During the early morning hours (2:00 A.M.) of Saturday;October 26, 2002; there was a full crew working outside on the property at Desert Chapel. Field lights were on, generators were running;large trucks were coming and going and approximately fourteen workers were busy hammering and installing a stage,in preparation for a concert. That evening, during the,concert, a public address system was used. Needless to say, many residents at Mesquite were disturbed by.the noise. The'Homeowners' Association office received three telephone calls from residents in our I; J and K Buildings. I received a note, documenting the activities, from a resident in the K Building. Was Desert Chapel granted'a special time extension by the Director of Planning and Building, or the"Chief of Police? Perhaps but, if so, we were not aware of it and neither qtt7r 760-322-5950 • Fax 760-323-318 October 31,2002 Mr. David J. Aleshire . Page 2 was the City, as evidenced by the enclosed emails. We,certainly do not believe that a concert qualifies as "emergency service to allow the use of a public address system: During our negotiations over the easement with Desert Chapel, we constantly heard the word"neighborly". It was used 'particularly to state that Mesquite Country Club Condominium HOA was not being neighborly. We are not trying to be unneighborly. However, we are asking for a little compassion and commtuucation from Desert Chapel and the City of Palm Springs. It is apparent that outdoor events are going to continue at Desert Chapel. It also appears apparent that the City of Pahn Springs is going to,do nothing to enforce its Conditions of Approval.• During the early morning hoursiof concert set-up, the police were called by one of our homeowners. The homeowner was told that the police were working on other matters and would send someone if they could. The police never arrived in response to the homeowner's complaint. It's ironic;though, that the police department had several officers available the evening of the concert to direct traffic. I believe the City and the police department need to get their priorities in order.. As a homeowners' association, we have rules and regulations which must be.enforced. Our policy is that if it is a bad rule, eliminate it. However, until it is eliminated, we,have an obligation to enforce it. Failure to enforce subjects the Board of Directors to liability. Why would the City adopt Conditions of Approval if it had no intention of enforcing them? And, does its failure to enforce not subject the City,to potential litigation? As City Attorney, I would hope that you would understand the seriousness of the above. It appears to many that Desert Chapel is receiving preferential treatment, due to ties which many City officials have to Desert Chapel. ,The City's failure-to act in enforcing its Conditions of Approval only lends credence to this belief. Very truly yours, MESQUITE COUNTRY CLUB CONDOMINIUM,HOA Ron Novy President Cc: Douglas R. Evans, Director of Planning and Building . Frank V. Marshall, III, Administrator, Desert Chapel- City of Palm Springs Council Members Wayne Gurahnick Page 1 of 1 Mesquite HOA From: Robert Pailthorp [bobpail@teleport.com] Sent: Friday, November 01, 2002 10:44 AM To: Bob Pailthorp Cc: Mesquite Home Owners Association Subject: Desert Chapel Halloween Party 2002 This is for my record. On the after noon and evening of Oct.31, 2002 (Halloween) the church held a party in their paved lot across form phase three. At 5:00 PM they started engine generators on portable flood light units. I have taken pictures of one of these units which was across the ditch from us and next to the west wall of the water district well/pump station. I also took pictures of the light glare from the lights. The engines were operating and lights were still on at 10:00 PM when we went to bed. During the evening a loudspeaker address system was used several times for announcements. Music recordings were played all evening. A fire truck and police car were present as a public education display (I suspect). A rubber wheel ride made to resemble a train was used. It had a Toot-toot whistle that was used repeatedly. Robert Pailthorp Nov. 1st, 2002 I, 11/4/02 Page 1 of 1 Mesquite HOA From: Robert Pailthorp [bobpail@teleport.com] Sent: Wednesday, October 30, 2002 6:06 PM To: Bob Pailthorp Cc: Mesquite Home Owners Association Subject: Desert Chapel record of conversation Record of telephone conversation with Alex Meyerhoff, Principle Planner, City if Palm Springs I called Mr. Meyerhoff on October 30 as I said I would. He had determined that the Church did not have a permit for the concert and had violated City ordinances. They are not allowed to use amplify sound. I told Mr. Meyerhoff they also amplify sound for their football games. He also made a statement related to noise restrictions after 10 PM. He is writing a letter to the church that will be given internal reviews. I can have a copy of this letter. He said to call next week to make arrangement to get a COPY. He commented that the letter would be widely read. I ask why. He said because many,people were interested in the activities of the Church. Bob Pailthorp I1/1/02 October 31, 2002 Alex Meyerhoff Principal Planner City of Palm Springs 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, Ca. 92263 Re: DESERT CHAPEL VIOLATIONS Dear Mr. Meyerhoff I am writing this letter to again bring to your attention numerous and serious code violations that are continuing at Desert Chapel which have seriously eroded the quality of life for us residents at Mesquite Country Club which adjoins the church property. I have communicated with you previously over the past couple of years both in person and over the phone about ongoing violations, however they not only continue, they just keep getting more frequent and more serious. In my condo building alone (which consists of eight units) in the past two years, six of our residents have sold their condos and moved out, all because the church activities have made it impossible to live adjacent to their property. One long time seasonal renter from Canada, who no longer rents in the phase that adjoins the church, I recently ran into on the bike trail along the golf course. She explained to me that the church noise not only made it impossible to sit out on the patio, but she couldn't even sit inside her unit without being disturbed by the church noise. To quote her words to me "what contempt the church must have for the homeowners at Mesquite". The Conditions of Approval from the City dated 10/13/99 specifically stated: All lighting shall be in accordance with the City's non-glare standards. All unpernzitted night lighting shall be renzoved or permitted in compliance with the City's non-glare standards. The church continually rents portable light towers from Brudvik Electric rental division (phone 320-9221 - speak to Rich) for their evening activities on the church, property. Since the bleachers (and are the bleachers permitted?) face our condos, the lighting towers are located so that all lighting faces OUT from the bleacher area and INTO our condo windows, which by the way, also lights up the entire Mesquite Golf Course between Sunrise and Farrell Drive so that one could play nighttime golf. Most evenings these light remain on well after midnight, usually being turned off around 1:30 am. No public address system shall be allowed other than for enzergency service. r The church continually uses a public address system not only for iw their football games, (which they also use amplified sirens when their teams score), but for other events on the property. The oleander screening along the northern property line shall be maintained to the satisfaction of the Director of Planning and Building. the minirnurrr height at trininring shall be seven (7)feet. All dead plants shall be replaced with mature hedge material with a mininiuni height of seven (7)feet. Not only are the plants not being maintained - (they are never trimmed, dead plants, open spaces where plants were never put in, some weeds are growing higher than seven feet, exceeding the height of the existing shrubs), the church has put a waste disposal dumpster up against the fence that adjoins my condo. This dumpster is the larger size that is rented from the city - and is uncovered. And of course, the most recent event at the church, the Concert that was held this past weekend. The night before the concert, there was a football game that ended around 9:00 pin.........minutes after game ended, workers began arriving in big rig trucks and their cars. There were around twenty men who began to remove pieces of a large metal stage from the trucks. All night long they were working, hammering and installing the stage until I could no longer stand the noise. I made two phone calls to the Palm Springs Police, being told both times "we are out on emergencies sir, if we can send someone out we will'. Finally at 1:55 am, I got dressed and walked over to the property and asked the workers to stop and come back the next day. They told me they had to get the stage up for the concert the next day and had a lot of work to do. Then of course the same thing was repeated AFTER the concert. I also understand the church did not have a permit for the concert, although half of the Palm Springs police department was around the property, helping them direct traffic on Sunrise, in the parking areas and on the grounds. During the summer months, the church holds weekend evening gatherings to allow teens to stay off the streets. This is usually only supervised by a teenage son of one of the church administrators. Every weekend, the teens come and ago in their cars beginning at 8:00 pm and continuing well after midnight, usually ended around 2:00 am. Most of the teenagers are out on the church property, playing games such as jumping over chain link fences, giving rides to each other up and down the church parking lot on top of metal book carts on wheels, roller blading across the parking lot, chasing each other into the dark golf course and hiding out in the city water district property, in the dark where noone can see what they are doing. Teenagers usually have car stereos, which of course must be played at top volume - which we all get to enjoy over here at Mesquite. The many attempts I have made to ask the church to cut down of this noise is always the same response "this is private property, we can do what we want". Then there is also the allowed functions which we also must tolerate - such as the school children being dropped off just after 7:00 am - playing in the parking lot that adjoins our condos all day long - the Sunday morning early live band practice prior to church starting which usually begins around 8:00 am. and all the other church activities that create noise all day long, seven days a week. Gardeners starting at 6:00 am on Saturdays, with the lawn movers and blowers - evening building cleaning which on many occasions goes on after 9 midnight-where generators are used outside to power cleaning machines being used in the buildings. How many more homeowners are going to be forced to move before the city takes the appropriate steps to insure the church complies with the conditions of approval? This is my question to you, Mr. Meyerhoff. Sincerely, Arthur MacMillan 2001 Camino Parocela I{-77 Palm Springs, Ca. 92264 1 October 31, 2002 Alex Meyerhoff Principal Planner City of Palm Springs 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, Ca. 92263 Re: DESERT CHAPEL VIOLATIONS Dear Mr. Meyerhoff This morning I dropped off a letter to you at your office regarding ongoing Desert Chapel city code violations. Just this evening, after returning home from working today, I arrived home to find the following ongoing on the Desert Chapel property throughout the evening: Three portable tower lights shining into my condo windows A outdoor church function going on which included: train rides around the parking lot with a blowing train whistle amplified music being broadcast outdoors a loudspeaker system outdoors addressing the crowds around the church grounds. As is usually the case, this activity tonight is well attended by Palm Springs city employees: several police cars on the property the city DARE automobile two policemen on horses one city fire truck I am looking forward to your response as to how these violations will be addressed by you. Sincerely, Arthur MacMillan 2001 Camino Parocela K-77 Palm Springs, Ca. 92264 08/27/2002 17:13 760-325-7048 DESERT CHAPEL PAGE 04 LAW OFFICES BURKEs WILLLAMS& SORVIVSEN,LLP WS Maus 0mcE 18341 VON KARMAN AVENUE tANalEaneuurmaFFlcE au Wray SM"REet SUrrE 2wa aso TVEST w 'sYREEr iunE 2M11 unANCE(E9 cAUFORruA9tllar7olox SUITE 1050 UN000G tAUFORNIA991014M Tel: (2rT)2x46ou IRVINE,CALIFORNIA 92612.1009 am (aa)4184on Fim (2r1}235.47W (Slfq�ISa4d75 Tel: (949)$63-3363 ft Fax: (949)$63.3350 ' OWMIOE COUNTY OFRCE www.I wslaw.com VENTURAMUN!"WICE Wa TENTH SttiFn sum>SOP "10 EAST FaNOEIIOSA DMM 1urre 25 AWASIOE.CAUF MA92501.7529 GAMW".CAV"1AM1"747 AI: (909)7#"X80 TWA (M)9e7 am Fa (9O9)I SM Irex(W)Ia'M"M iYmAti 6wFinumw UE N R FILE rely 1,2002 Mr.Charles Koller Middlebrook,Kaiser&Popka 1800 Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs,CA 92262 Re: Desert C} pa_ 1 IesquitF H"Sunny Dunes Street'Vacation Dear Chuck: I am disappointed but not surprised at your client's decision and I am very-appreciative of your kind words. I figured the final request that you pay their legal fees for the last year's uufruitful correspondence was going to put things over the top. Dedication of public right-of-way is normally handled through the City Engineer, Dave Barakian, so I'd refer you to him. Thinking this might go this way, I did mention the issue to him and was not surprised that he is not enthusiastic about taking the street back. Given all that has happened, the Council would probably consider removing the insurance requirement from your conditions of approval, but it appears this will not solve your problem with the Mesquite HOA. In fact, there may be legal issues even if we rededicate the street. In any event, I believe the City would ultimately cooperate is trying to get the parties back where they started front. Let me know if you need help with Public Works. Very truly yours, Da vt .Aleshite,City Attotmey" ofBURKE,WILLIAMS&SORENSEN,LLP DJA/dlc cc: Mr.Dave Barakla n vft.Fred Donaldson �.lglr.Frank Marshall RY tE22910 vl _ 09/97/2003 17:13 760-328-7040 DESERT CHAPEL PAGE 03 06/26/2002 14,16 • 760-3225979 MIDDLEBROOK KAISER WAGE 03 David Aleshire Juno 26, 2DD2 Re: Desert Chape"squite HOA :_ Page 2 Crttmwak's threats of litigation. And it is clear that reasonableness is not a word that exists in Mr. Cstu4nick's vocabulary since he beLievos Desert Chapel is required to pay"whatever is to cassatw"to obtain a completely emnet"sary piece of in.Umce coverage. All of this despite the fact that it is they who are coming on our property,property occupied by our atndeats and parisbioms,and it is their use that increases the risk, It is they who should be pro;Et'eaCin g the additional inured endarserntmt to us. I regret that an attenm&e solution could not be reached but with the association's infltxibility as presented through its attormey requiring an additional insured endorsement (coverage they do not have with Sunny D mta as a public street) surd refusing to provide a ra ipracal one,the b=1=of the comditiou imposed by the City Carr OR to carry much an endoraemerrt far outweighs*0 benefit of the vsueated street- A,gaiu,I thank you for all of your hard work. It is greatly appreciated. I am Sending a copy of this letter to Mr. Cnualniuk(so that he can informs his client to cease world ug on finding insurance)as well as to the Citv's Ride Manager,Nancy.Jo McIntosh,who went above and beyond the'4WI of duty with her vary kind and getwous offer to assist us. Should you have any questions or desire arty further infcnmatioty please do not hesitate to call or write. Sirtcereiy, M ODI"ROOK,KAISER& POP" Charles U. Koller CWjs W. Fred Donaldson Frank Marshall Church Council Wayne Ouralaick Nancy 3b Mclmosh(by FAx 322.8323) The Honorable Will Klicndeinst,Mayor The Honorable Ieanie Reiter-Spurpin,Mayor Pro Teat The Honorable Ron Aden,Councilman The Honorable ChM Mills,C:ouacrlman The Honorable Dayna Hodl ek Cotrncilwotnan January 11, 2004 � Palm Springs City Council JAN 1 5 2604 cc Palm Springs, CA RECRjVED Re: Case No.5.935-PD-59 January 21, 2004 Meeting To the Honorable Mayor and City Council Members of the City of Palm Springs: We recently received"another"notice of Public Hearing"regarding the Desert Chapel for the amendment to the Planned Development District 59 to consider revisions to the master plan. Including: 1)the addition of classrooms, a nursery, an administration building, and a new special events area; and 2)the establishment of regulations for the time,place, and manner of special events, including night-time football games,at 600 South Sunrise Way, Zone PD 59, Section 24." We would like to request that the City Council DENY this and any other future amendments requested by the Desert Chapel to the master plan. We say"Enough is Enough!"We have patiently stood by and watched as the Council and The Department of Planning and Zoning approved modification upon modification requested by the Desert Chapel during the past few years -to the point where it has severely degraded our way of life and style of living at Mesquite Condominiums We have not complained in the past,but can no longer refrain from doing so.We had not voiced our opinions before because as we understand it,prior approvals were a shoe in because of some prior Council member's relationships and associations with the Desert Chapel. The noise factor has gotten so bad that during the day,all we hear is noise due to the school and kid factors outside and during the night/evenings - the football games that ALREADY are being played at night and often times last beyond 11 PM in violation of the current master plan.This noise factor has already caused numerous neighbors to sell their Condos and move out, as well as, been a factor of propci ty devaluation in this time of prosperity. We purchased our condominium at Mesquite well over 12 years ago so we could have a place to unwind, enjoy the serenity of Palm Springs, and enjoy the desert way of life. Until the Desert Chapel began it's expansions,we had been able to enjoy the peace and quiet we were looking for,providing us an avenue to unwind and reflect on the beauty of the Palm Springs area. Our peaceful and serene way of life today is being threatened by the ever changing environment being caused by modifications to the master plan being requested by the Desert Chapel and the contributing noise factors that result from these modifications being detrimental to the wonderful and peaceful way of life we have enjoyed for so many years in our home in the Desert... We respectfu% request that the Palm Springs City Council vote against approval for Case Number 5.935-PD-59 on January 21,2004 and any other future requests for modifications to the master plan. Re �ectfiilly Submitted, Fred and Lulae Luevano I Mailing Address: Unit E. Cam no Parocela 1166 Arroyo Pacifica t n Unit.1.64 Fall CA 92 Palm Springs, CA 92263 emailil:: fluevano@pcmagic.net 760-7.23-9991 TO: Mayor Ron Odom, City Council Members City Planners of Palm Springs, CA FROM: Karleen and Roger Grummett 2001 E. Camino Parocela J72, Phase 3, Mesquite HOA Palm Springs, CA SUBJECT: Case No. 5.935-PD-59, Desert Chapel Application to Amend PDD 59 HEARING DATE: January 21, 2004 Dear Ladies and Gentlemen, The following addresses only one of Desert Chapel's ongoing lighting, noise, and permit violations. It concerns the football/special events field location and attendant noise. We invite you to visit this site and cross the footbridge to see for yourselves the closeness of our building to this field and how it impacts our property's value: The Problems: We don't know what upsets us more, 1. that someone would build a football/special event field 250 feet from our residence, 2. that this field was constructed below the radar, without notice, to the City or to neighboring residences, 3. that Desert Chapel is asking for approval of this field for special events that go beyond the ten football games per year they are requesting, and that already occur, 4. that the request for approval asks permission to use a public address system, 5. that events continue to be staged in an unapproved venue, 6. or that Desert Chapel has continued to violate city ordinances without penalty. We are reasonable, fair-minded people. We enjoy children and knew when we bought our condominium in 1996 there was a small school next door. But no one could have bargained for the unannounced and sometimes illegal expansion of the school and the insensitivity of Desert Chapel as a neighbor, all of which has been previously documented. And noise violations continue. For example, one morning on November 2003 we were wakened at 5 a.m.by a leaf blower in Desert Chapel's parking lot near the field. Then in December, we were subjected to a long Christmas special event at the field. It was more than a simple tree lighting ceremony. It was a full-fledged choral concert with public address system at full tilt. In both cases, the ensuing noise was like hosting the event in our living room. Though we've never done this before, but because we are given no d� g- � other recourse for immediate help, we called the police department citing violations of the noise ordinance. Solutions:It's unreasonable to expect the people in Phase 3 of the Mesquite Homeowners Association to be any more understanding. We strongly oppose the approval of this special event/football field. In the interest of fairness and to rectify past injustices,we request that Desert Chapel be required to do the following: 1. Conduct special events inside the multi-purpose building to contain them as Chapel originally said they would. (This does not effect playground areas.) 2. Find another appropriate venue for football games or redraft field plans to a site near the street area adjacent to Sunrise Way or closer to the wide-open Tahquitz Creek area and away from our phases' residences. 3. Use the public address system only for emergency services. Directing speakers away from residences has little, if any, affect and is unenforceable. 4. Provide security of the whole school area 24/7. We would also request a contact for Mesquite residents to report incidents so the City can get a feel for how many violations occur at or near this field on a regular basis. We respectfully appreciate your time, attention, and interest in rectifying these disturbing developments of Desert Chapel. arleen Gnunmett Rog rummett Copies to: Mayor Ron Odom Alex P. Meyerhoff, Principal Planner, Dept. of Planning & Zoning, Douglas R. Evans, Director of Planning and Zoning, City of Palm Springs Monday, January 12, 2004 5.08 PM Robert E. Pailthorp 17603203203 p.02 To: Mayor and Citv Councuors C�z f3 City of Palm Springs JAN i 2 2m Subject: Case No. 5.935-PD-59 4 Desert Cliapol application to amend PDD 59 �5 ,,�dECC VED Hearing date, January 21,20o4 Dear Mayor and Councilors: Once again we express our opposition to approval of the amendments to the Planned Development District 59 We are one of the closest neighbors to the Chapel. Our past complaints about violations of the existing regulations and our opposition to amendments are on record with the City Planner. We ask the Council to consider what has and is transpiring, The Chapel has not complied with the existing City standards for amplified sound,permitted events, or light glare. Now The Chapel is asking for approvals of the events that have caused these violations, The Chapel leadership has repeatedly demonstrated their unwillingness or inability to have their membership,and employees comply with existing City regulations. Instead, they violate the current regulations and then ask the City to approve their activities, We as their neighbors are asked to be understanding(to preserver). A recent and small example of insensitivity to neighbors is teachers using bull homs during the day to direct student activities on the play ground. A bull horn is amplified sound and should not be needed to be heard over the playful sounds of their students. Past experience shows that the City does not have the ability to monitor or police the activities at the Chapel, We as neighbors end up having to document violations and report them to the City. Based on past experience we have no hope that anything will happen other than another request from the Chapel for approval of the activities that resulted in the violations. We ask the council to carefully review the proposed amendment. The Chapel representatives have presented the justification for football games and other special activities, It is our hope that the number and type of special activities be specified in detail. What is a football game? Last year one of the"football games"included the election and installation of the home coming queen. We heard all these activities as a result of the continual and detailed coverage over a public address (amplified sound)system. At present football played by an eight (9)man team on a small field. While this fits the current needs of a few male students we wonder what will happen when girls and adult church members wish to use the current field or an expanded field for other teams or other field sports. Soo their current web site:ht n/hvww,desortobai)el orn/dchs/ for their presentation of the activities at the Chapel. We appreciate the Church members' interest in their youth. However,they have options for conducting these activities in more appropriate settings if they cannot conduct them at this site without violating existing ordinances. We suggest these amendments be set aside until the Chapel demonstrates their ability to comply with current City regulations for noise and light glare. ert E.Pailthorp Dorthea M,Pailthorp Camino Parocela Unit Unit K-73 Phase 3 Mesquite HOA http://www.dcsertchapeI,org/dchs/ City Council January 8, 2004 City of Palm Springs C/o Office of the City Clerk Re: Case No. 5.935-PD-59 JAN 13 200� a Desert Chapel request to amend PD 59 _ RECs�RlGp 0 Dear Council Members: I strongly object to that portion of the Desert Chapel application that would allow them to conduct nighttime football games(or any other night time outdoor activities) on a special events field. The noise of the extra traffic, the noise of the fans, the noise of the loud speaker and the bright lights would absolutely ruin a currently bucolic evening setting. I am a co-owner of a condominium at 2001 Camino Parocella, #G-44, which, apparently, is within 400 feet of the proposed site. When I lived at Lake of the Pines in Auburn, CA, in the mid-1990s, our home was more than 2,000 feet from a local high school, at which nighttime football games were played. Even from that far away, and inside a well-insulated house, we were bothered by the sounds of the crowd and the loud speaker announcing everything that was happening. It absolutely makes me shudder to imagine how magnified the noise will be when we are only 400 feet away! One of the reasons we bought into our unit in the Mesquite Country Club was its location, overlooking a golf course and away from the hustle, bustle and noise of other Palm Springs locations. I cannot attend the public hearing on January 21, 2004, so I guess it is up to you to help us retain our ability to enjoy our condominium all year long, but, especially during lovely fall weekend evenings, when the views fiom our balcony are quite majestic. I implore you to disapprove any nighttime outdoor events, and if that means disapproving the construction of the special events area entirely, then so be it. Sincerely, M. Wayne Thush(502 561 044) 4400 Hollingsworth Court Rohnert Park, CA 94928 707-586-8321 Fax 707-586-9331 A"Jo ' wayneandnancyt@prodigy.net "///`- �?,eu,,�ei�' �.✓ir,2��a-� o "Y� ✓/t a-.��.�t✓ :'•iar_ea:-,;r�.�t.e_:� � �t� C�.l /L2G—: �i.y.,e. �p /G/L6' �•�=R+6/�/ �j l�il"l::.l + ti�'W �/f:i!/(/�i-.2•'� G')J 1F/ r� Y.�;.�� :J%(iJ� ��r Jli.C"A_r� Desert Chapel - 630 South Sunrise Way Case No 5.935 - PD 59 G ✓7,i/ J! iG wr a Master Plan Revision 71d� vr�,=Z otv i ✓g ° , 1°. s fl,«✓e September 10, 2003 /'IT 12, i : ' £' REVISED CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL A:C'r .S Before final acceptance of the project, all conditions listed below shall be completed to the satisfaction of the City Engineer,the Director of Planning, the Chief of Police, the Fire Chief or their designee, depending on which department recommended the condition. Any agreements, easements or covenants required to be entered into shall be in a form approved by the City Attorney. Cvc,�/TC /VcT PE0e_11 sG� Pf, Special Events _ 1110t,J _fro t✓' x'N6'j CTA/C3 JI N� 3�C/✓T '/S '—I 1 The applicant may conduct a maximum of three special events per year, with temporary /',9f F 11 v n_ lighting and generators, which shall not extend past 9:00 pm. Amplified outdoor concerts o.✓ , are prohibited. Tear-down of special events shall not extend past 9 00 pm. 2. A lighting plan for special event lighting shall be reviewed and approved by the Director of P� Planning and Zoning. 7 �P MP, M_ C2(-1D c+�J 1- 62-� 0-n.•r:y 'gal 7,�.,� q`FAeti�,�-,v y /,h3S �£�--/ TatJ'ca,-,c.l s'G' -` 3 Special events shall be limited to one day in duration. �¢ ",d>`✓j - tvN ✓2/v 7 3 4. Loudspeakers and any other noise shall not reasonably interfere with the peace and quiet n� _-,SF, of any person outside the boundary of the site and shall comply with the City Noise Ordinance. 2 q/l h ��o ' Z,�6✓✓F��� an/ r'v zl . a6 5. Desert Chapel shall provide written notice of any special events, by mail, two weeks prior 1-1 o.D F to the event, to Mesquite Country Club property owners in the Phase Adjacent to Desert Chapel, V,'VCA, V o /c To +)n s t• 6. Should any of these conditions be violated, the Planning Commission reserves the right to revoke the right of Desert Chapel to conduct future special events. Football Games 7 The applicant may host up to ten football games annually. These events would shall end by 10:OOpm. These events may include the use of a temporary generator, PA system, lighting and bleachers. The field and parking lot shall be cleared with all lights off by 10:OOpm. Tear-down of football games shall not extend past 10:00 pm Special dispensation will be made to game delays caused by injuries, power outages or timeouts beyond reasonable control of Desert Chapel. 8. A lighting plan for football field lighting shall be reviewed and approved by the Director of� � ) Planning and Zoning. 9. � Lighting and the PA system shall be directed away from adjacent residential properties. off/GSP ,rj F'✓✓C� sill N£. � /C>'Q/'AJ /Ci. �✓�J � I-,V,,l ✓ 7�64,✓C d 'if S �Jo,✓.-7 <J % lni 0c Rrd(✓✓%L )lam,$ 10. Amplified music shall be limited to 15 minutes before game and 15 minutes at half time. 11. Desert Chapel shall provide written notice of the football season schedule, by mail, two weeks prior to the start of football season, to Mesquite Country Club property owners in the Phase Adjacent to Desert Chapel. 1,1, _,fL Gz^y j 12. Provide a list of "key administrative personnel', including cell phone numbers, such that should any concerns arise, the matter could be brought to the immediate attention of these "key administrative personnel." The list shall be kept updated and shall be provide by Desert ChapeL.to-the-•City Planning and Zoning Department, Police Department ant CMesqui et Count Club HOA and shall be responsible for enforcement of these conditions of approval: evb`' JG 13. Security personnel shall be required and shall be on duty until 11:00pm. .r G3r 1'�`% yL N 6 14. Desert Chapel shall utilize the northeast parking lot for overflow parking only. Driveways I'�LA.iES to this area shall be barricaded or otherwise controlled by Desert Chapel staff to ensure c" compliance. av� ALA 15 Should any of these conditions be violated, the Planning Commission reserves the right to revoke the right of Desert Chapel to conduct future football games at this site. General 16. Construction activities and the use of landscape equipment on site, including but not limited to blc,,vers, trimmers, mowers, street sweepers, landscape equipment and general construction and landscape maintenance activities shall conform to permitted construction work hours in the City of Palm Springs, Monday- Friday 7 am - 7 pm, Saturday 8 am - 5pm and prohibited on Sundays, per the Municipal code. 17, Late night use of the sports courts, after the use of 10 pm, shall be prohibited. 18 Desert Chapel shall provide adequate adult supervision to minors on site during all activities and events. 19. The Planning Commission reserves the right to adjust the Conditions of approval in response to operation, activities and community concerns. The process to modify shall require public notice to Mesquite Country Club HOA, one meeting with Desert Chapel and Mesquite Country Club HOAand a Planning Commission action.The Planning Commission reserves the right to require a formal public hearing prior to considering changes to the approved conditions of approval for special events and football games. The Planning Commission decision can be appealed per Palm Springs Municipal Code Section 2.05.030. January 15, 2003 To: Honorable Mayor and City Council Re: Desert Chapel From: Arthur MacMillan I would like the Council to address a serious concern of mine about Desert Chapel. Why does the school find it necessary to have the morning drop off of all it's elementary students occur as close to our border fence as possible. This occurs Monday thru Friday beginning at 7:OOAM. Cars continuously enter the parking lot near our condos where the children are "urrloaded" from cars and are kept in this area playing until the 8:15am bell. Then throughout the day,the play continues nearest our fence as the recesses occur. The church is bordered on the South by the Tahquitz wash and golf course,the East by the Mesquite Golf Course and maintenance shed, and the West by the five lane Sunrise Way and property owned by Desert Chapel. WHY MUST THEY DIRECT THIS ACTIVITY NEAREST THE POINT IN THEIR PROPERTY THAT IS CLOSEST TO OVER 100 CONDOS ON THE NORTHERN SIDE OF THEIR PROPERTY WITH THE CLOSEST CONDOS ONLY EIGHTY (80) FEET FROM THE CHILDREN DROP OFF POINT? THIS CAN AND MUST BE CHANGED. PLEASE ADDRESS THIS CONCERN. THANK YOU. Pa`�`pa€1 Subj: Re: Desert Chapel Date: 1/15/2004 11:44:01 AM Pacific Standard Time From: bobpail To: ARTHUR �i Sent from the Internet(Details) Arthur: We purchased an aerial print the was flown 4/1/03. This shows that the south west corner of building K is 80 feet from the Chapel property line. I Dot& Bob ; 4 5 i r I �fi r�hr8'�e.G m,F`,-i, �•. ���. z..�� � Q !� :. �:,i l/';m '0.rtr f^i�'^ �A A w < -- h � zF 1 Ai 61 St. Clair Avenue West Suite 603 Toronto, Ontario, Canada M4V 2Y8 December 3, 2002 City of Palm Springs Attention: Mr. Douglas R. Evans Director of Planning and Zoning Re Desert Chapel; Case No. 5.0788/PD-59 Dear Mr. Evans: We have heard from friends in Mesquite Country Club phase 3 that the negative effects of the adjacent Desert Chapel school are continuing and increasing. We moved from phase 3 because of the racket from the school and are writing to bring our experience t o your attention. We are Canadians who enjoyed wintering in Palm Springs for the last 14 years. We rented condos in Mesquite phase 3 from 1989 until 3 years ago and moved away because the noise from the expanded Desert Chapel school was unbearable. It was hard to feel that the school administration or the city zoning authorities had any regard for the quality of life of the neighbors Playground activity persisted unabated for about 12 hours a day; the school contracted-to-have carpet cleaning carried out late at night; when an alarm malfunctioned in one school building it was allowed to ring from Friday evening until Sunday morning. Fortunately, we had not bought property in phase 3 and were able to flee as soon as our lease expired. We hear that the noise continues unabated. Our sympathies are entirely with the owners in the afflicted area. Sincerely, 'f 6 = . Alfred Rudin Pearl Rudin Cc Palm Springs City Council members 9 ! �ulirt i �,v� l�v .r.'.. � .r1 4..e �l J' � ��Q.( �� ��G�i:�'a. AiY l^t l Y) / 11 � ✓f'y U..) ./.'u�i.11/n.ie' These "Teen nights" which have no ending time and run on weekends Throughout the summer are supervised by only one church official (a son of the Administrator)who is Usually inside a lounge room or in the multi purpose building. Desert Chapel likes to keep the teens off the streets, so invite them to be on the School property late into the night. There is No one outside supervising the youths playing all around the church Property (security guard, if on duty, goes home at 1 Opm) Some of the youths are skateboarding in the parking lot at IAM, or giving each other rides in the parking lot On top of metal rolling book carts. Car stereos are loudly playing, cars are skreetching in and out of the parking Lot throughout the night, and many of the teenagers seek out the dark areas Of the church property to be alone or unseen with some of them moving Onto the dark Mesquite Golf Course. I have smelled marijuana in the air More than once on these evenings. hfer>fenmrsa �� urs�n� august so. Gym Nih> -� � oJn*eNEW YM 0-pen Gym Night Au�u I0in• eeANCTUARY93eizroo m the SANCTUARY s.N,n.C.afterly"hW WOOMP Friday, August 8th Aupst 1P# Bible study y:oo 3n the NEW GX1M Are you getting lazy? Are you getting fat from all those summer Au . . In teNEWorship popsicles and moms home cooking? Pastor Houston is here to take "o/Ii:lust �in the SANCTUARY care of us - not only spiritually - but physically also. On Friday &NA.0 Eveniugw0ff* night, August 8th, we will be opening up the new gym for a night August 18`� of fun and fellowship. The volleyball & basketball courts will be open. Put a team together or just show up and we'll put you on a Deep Sea Fishing TVip team that night. Either way, we're all looking at a night full of fun. Meet at DC @$49#A We will start at 6:30 pm and go until nobody wants to play August 2e R Bible Study anymore. You better get ready for a physical challenge. poo in the NEW GYM H � Augast 20 •Morning warship 9 3o/zl oo in the SANCTUARY S.N.A.C.afterEveNns WorshiF Dee ea - � - Agguyt 2'lth• Bible Study G7(M s . 7:00 10 the NEW R AU St 311 " Morning WOnNp Au ust 18th q�/IpooinMeSANCMUY Monday, g �4tP B.N.A.C.afterEvenlnJrwor+Ih1Y 'Well just;sit right back and you'11-hear a tale... That's right! You've you read about all these terrorist guessed it, we're going fishing. We'll be heading out to Dana Point on most of them came here legally, bi August 18th, and going deep„ sea fishing. This is always a fun trip they hang around on these expire visas, some for as long as 10-1 because We like to tell all the fish tales we know. We plan to leave the years. Now, compare that to Bloc] church by 9:00 am and return that night at 9:00 pm. The cost is $30.00 buster; you are two days late with and that will cover your fishing license, tackle and boat fees-We'll eat video and these people are all ovi you. Let's put BlocAbuster in harg on the boat and stop on the way home for dinner so bring extra money of immiarntinn, l /J�1, q 4 . a Al ..4 � e i * � gym+ �.�'k.,Y"aj� "S �•A. us I ' � "� +,�i"�;F r y, '^'V, mac "• � r A""#'IS 1. w , a ...dTM sN - ......, ,k... .,k,.-_,-L;Mr; -ar^^-,.+w•. r,C"°"- �^--^IL*as;+�--, s - '�:. t � r January 15,2004 Dear Council Member Gamy Foal, At the January 21,2004 City Council meeting,you will be presented with a proposed plan for development of the property at the northwest corner of Sunrise Way and Sunny Dunes Road. This proposal,presented by the Desert Chapel,calls for a variance to change the General Plan's zoning of more than one half of the property from residential to professional office buildings. We are concerned about the proposed change in zoning for several reasons. One is that two years ago residents of the neighborhood worked with City Council Members and the Engineering Department on traffic calming measures on Sunny Dunes Road. With this proposed variance,the Engineering Department conducted a traffic study,which indicates the Professional Office Buildings will generate 661 vehicle trips per day. The study used a 24-hour day model,but as most professional buildings operate during an eight- hour workday,these vehicle trips translate to an additional 1.3 vehicles per minute. With one parking lot port at the north end of the project on Sunrise Way and a second port two hundred feet west of Sunrise Way on Sunny Dunes Road,the neighborhood is very concerned that we will feel the impact of most of the additional traffic. We are also concerned with maintaining the general integrity of the neighborhood. Tahquitz River Estates is one of the oldest developments in the City of Palm Springs. Residential Real Estate in this neighborhood and in the adjacent Warn Sands neighborhood is very strong. The Planning Commission told us when they approved this project that the loss of residential property in this area would be inconsequential because "nobody wants to live on Sunrise Way." Anybody,who is familiar with Sunrise Way,knows that most of the street is residential and has residential amenities(Library, Senior Center,Churches,and Grocery Stores). Another concern is that Palm Springs has in place a General Plan for development. During the Planning Commission meeting(Dec. 17,2003),Doug Evans said that in spite of California's recommendation that cities review their General Plans once every 5 years,Palm Springs has not reviewed its General Plan in over ten years. We are asking for your support to keep the integrity of our neighborhood intact. We will be attending the City Council Meeting on January 21 to further explain our concerns. Attached is a brief but more detailed list of issues regarding this proposal. We understand that you have little time between now and the January 21 meeting but hope you will review the information. Sincerely, rr i a � --� Peter Intravartolo '^ Steve Rossel 1425 E. Sunny Dunes Road Palm Springs,Ca 92264 322-0601 APPLICATION BY DESERT CHAPEL FOR A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT AND RESIDENTIAL VARIANCES Case#5.09564-PD-242 LOCATION OF PROPERTY AT ISSUE: FROM CALLE AMIGOS TO SUNRISE WAY ALONG THT NORTH SIDE OF SUNNY DUNES ROAD AND THE PARCEL OF VACANT LAND ALONG SUNRISE WAY FROM SUNNY DUNES ROAD NORTH TO THE BARISTO WASH—3.22 ACRES WHAT THE GENERAL PLAN(LAND DEVELOPMENT)OF PALM SPRINGS CALLS FOR: Property north side of Sunny Dunes Rd from Calle Amigos to Sunrise Way(1000ftx10111): single family residential lots(L-4),a maximum 4 per acre,mirroring 9 residential lots on south side of Sunny Dunes Rd. The remaining property on Sunrise Way to the Baristo Wash:medium density residential housing(M-15), a maximum 15 residential units per acre. Lot size allows a maximum of 15 units. WHAT THE DESERT CHAPEL AND ITS SPOKESPERSON CHRIS MILLS PROPOSED FOR THE PROPERTY: 8 single family residential lots using 65811 of the 1000ft(L-4)east from Calle Amigos,all 15-25%smaller than the General Plan's guidelines. Remaining L-4 property on Sunny Dunes Rd and all residential M-15 property(53%of the land)changed to"P"zone standards(professional services building development). This change for construction of 3 professional buildings(2 medically designated)with 3 parking lots/78 vehicle spaces. 2 entry/exits: one on the north end of the property on Sunrise Way and one on Sunny Dunes Rd 200 ft east of traffic signal. WHAT THE PLANNING COMMISSION UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED AT ITS MEETING ON DECEMBER 17,2003: One major change to the Chapel proposal:instead of 8 residential lots along the 658 feet of Sunny Dunes Rd east of Calle Amigos,only 7(L-4)residential lots. These lots: still smaller than the L-4 requirement. RESIDENTS' CONCERNS ABOUT THE PROSPOSAL AND COMMISSION VOTE: Tire impact on the residential character of the Warm Sands/Tahquitz River Estates neighborhood by changing 53%of the land in this proposal from residential to business development. The Planning Department and Desert Chapel said residential use of land along Sunrise Way is less than desirable. 3 easternmost residences south side of Sunny Dunes Rd and homes on the southeast side of Ramon Senior Mobile Home Park will face an office building and 3 parking lots instead of single family residences. These homes will experience increased car exhausts/noise,trash dumpster activity and car headlights shining into their living spaces. Mr.Mills said the Chapel would work with one resident owner to remedy the fight inconvenience. The owner of Ramon Park saw no impact on Park residents. A City Engineering Department traffic survey of the professional development projected 661 daily vehicle trips during business hours. Residents said that the professional development would increase traffic on Sunny Dunes Rd more than residential development on the full site and would diminish the traffic calming efforts the neighborhood had effected with City Council members and the Engineering Department. A request to close the entry/exit on Sunny Dunes Rd and put 2 ports on Sunrise Way similar to Sunrise Plaza was rejected by Mr.Mills as unsafe for business patrons and impossible in light of the traffic signal at Sunrise and Sunny Dunes Rd. THE PALM SPRING CITY COUNCIL WILL VOTE ON THIS PLANNING COMMISSION PROPOSAL ON WEDNESDAY JANUARY 21,2004 7PM AT THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS. � i i s LOT ib I I LOT 2m t neu Si I � w\a\wo! g0 0.(i"mtc 4s\.aRo-no\ 1 449.03.04 i Y I DWIN6 AC.]RAWAY I OWW AC,NaWAY d i It • , � ant n 5 I u, t a' �+„_. I 1 LOT 7 LOT LOT a LaT! q 47T U Lg 0 r3 E.aT 7 A L02 f, LO vA. LO 2 O a Bttl •A, CI v F. BI01 R.f. Biel z.P. 8189 4 WR•6AF BR!C\I BY fCM 851n !§iMa Wa•C3.0 IfI .t v of uu✓ —�raimro e'Aa.ecRu SUNNY UNEB FORD r •Iro av-ax w Re\.aY*m ( 1.11,71 R maw4m !BB•IlLm vcc e j W�QR•eca \sovf•ea i eya•ixkBw \c;+rl.Rsl 1 ea\•CrtC4 I I 1 I co 32160.71 1 im.1 llP4E-''•Y �. Nwle R[Y f R» y. w' tVu C yf RFs Aelwl[:ZJfI+ Yl t? SY raa t• (:ttR] �`> C4 CM tr t � 9' ,�1,� �� Y ^R i FL N.IIe! 7 euraP}�!n—e�a3� mum L f1 A`a •rts C,�� m- !: T'�.�evK,a cs• e✓r'� wCm°�\ =Fast 1% ��F F.SV2S:r]iP 4 fas,vn c^ - raF-_n' EU,? ,0u^•^•a� tivaA@ C;e.!RM�,�:�, eiLY?1�A9AY €r�tx ea:x s.F. WI..1•B�IN.i D January 15,2004 Dear Mayor Ron Oden, At the January 21,2004 City Council meeting,you will be presented with a proposed plan for development of the property at the northwest corner of Sunrise Way and Sunny Dunes Road. This proposal,presented by the Desert Chapel,calls for a variance to change the General Plan's zoning of more than one half of the property from residential to professional office buildings. We are concerned about the proposed change in zoning for several reasons. One is that two years ago residents of the neighborhood worked with City Council Members and the Engineering Department on traffic calming measures on Sunny Dunes Road. With this proposed variance,the Engineering Department conducted a traffic study,which indicates the Professional Office Buildings will generate 661 vehicle trips per day. The study used a 24-hour day model,but as most professional buildings operate during an eight- hour workday,these vehicle tips translate to an additional 1.3 vehicles per minute. With one parking lot port at the north end of the project on Sunrise Way and a second port two hundred feet west of Sunrise Way on Sunny Dunes Road,the neighborhood is very concerned that we will feel the impact of most of the additional traffic. We are also concerned with maintaining the general integrity of the neighborhood. Tahquitz River Estates is one of the oldest developments in the City of Palm Springs. Residential Real Estate in this neighborhood and in the adjacent Warm Sands neighborhood is very strong. The Planning Commission told us when they approved this project that the loss of residential property in this area would be inconsequential because "nobody wants to live on Sunrise Way." Anybody,who is familiar with Sunrise Way,knows that most of the street is residential and has residential amenities(Library, Senior Center,Churches,and Grocery Stores). Another concern is that Palm Springs has in place a General Plan for development. During the Planning Commission meeting(Dec. 17,2003),Doug Evans said that in spite of California's recommendation that cities review their General Plans once every 5 years,Palm Springs has not reviewed its General Plan in over ten years. We are asking for you support to keep the integrity of our neighborhood intact. We will be attending the City Council Meeting on January 21 to further explain our concerns. Attached is a brief but more detailed list of issues regarding this proposal. We understand that you have little time between now and the January 21 meeting but hope you will review the information. Sincerely, Peter hitravartolo Steve Russel 1425 E. Sunny Dunes Road Palm Springs,Ca 92264 322-0601 APPLICATION BY DESERT CHAPEL FOR A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT AND RESIDENTIAL VARIANCES Case#t 5.09564-PD-242 LOCATION OF PROPERTY AT ISSUE: FROM CALLE AMIGOS TO SUNRISE WAY ALONG THE NORTH SIDE OF SUNNY DUNES ROAD AND THE PARCEL OF VACANT LAND ALONG SUNRISE WAY FROM SUNNY DUNES ROAD NORTH TO THE BARISTO WASH—3.22 ACRES WHAT THE GENERAL PLAN(LAND DEVELOPMENT)OF PALM SPRINGS CALLS FOR: Property north side of Sunny Dmies Rd from Calle Amigos to Sunrise Way(1000fix101ft): single family residential lots(L-4),a maximum 4 per acre,mirroring 9 residential lots on south side of Sunny Dunes Rd. The remaining property on Sunrise Way to the Baristo Wash:medium density residential housing(M-15), a maximum 15 residential units per acre. Lot size allows a maximum of 15 units. WHAT THE DESERT CHAPEL AND ITS SPOKESPERSON CHRIS MILLS PROPOSED FOR THE PROPERTY: 8 single family residential lots using 658 ft of the 1000ft(L.-4)east from Calle Amigos,all 15-25%smaller than the General Plan's guidelines. Remaining L-4 property on Sunny Dunes Rd and all residential M-15 property(53%of the land)changed to"P"zone standards(professional services building development). This change for construction of 3 professional buildings(2 medically designated)with 3 parking lots/78 vehicle spaces. 2 entry/exits: one on the north end of the property on Sunrise Way and one on Sunny Dunes Rd 200 ft east of traffic signal. WHAT THE PLANNING COMMISSION UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED AT ITS MEETING ON DECEMBER 17,2003: One major change to the Chapel proposal:instead of 8 residential lots along the 658 feet of Sunny Dunes Rd east of Calle Amigos,only 7(L-4)residential lots. These lots: still smaller than the L-4 requirement. RESIDENTS'CONCERNS ABOUT THE PROSPOSAL AND COMMISSION VOTE: The impact on the residential character of the Warm Sands/Tahquitz River Estates neighborhood by changing 53%of the land in this proposal fiom residential to business development. The Planning Department and Desert Chapel said residential use of land along Sunrise Way is less than desirable. 3 easternmost residences south side of Sunny Dunes Rd and homes on the southeast side of Ramon Senior Mobile Home Park will face an office building and 3 parking lots instead of single family residences. These homes will experience increased car exhausts/noise,trash dumpster activity and car headlights shining into their living spaces. Mr.Mills said the Chapel would work with one resident owner to remedy the light inconvenience. The owner of Ramon Park saw no impact on Park residents. A City Engineering Department traffic survey of the professional development projected 661 daily vehicle trips during business hours. Residents said that the professional development would increase traffic on Sunny Dunes Rd more than residential development on the full site and would diminish the traffic calming efforts the neighborhood had effected with City Council members and the Engineering Department. A request to close the entry/exit on Sunny Dunes Rd and put 2 ports on Sunrise Way similar to Sunrise Plaza was rejected by Mr.Mills as unsafe for business patrons and impossible in light of the traffic signal at Sunrise and Sunny Dunes Rd. THE PALM SPRING CITY COUNCIL WILL VOTE ON THIS PLANNING COMMISSION PROPOSAL ON WEDNESDAY JANUARY 21,2004 7PM AT THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS. zxl� - i fi F �� LOy 5D uwwu��I n+eas � � wrroleaa kA8S14 KQ�rJ aarAlneea r 1'�� If I LL3r.dL'Mb I ! EaSDND AQ.DArvlWAY II i 1 + EAY A.C.PiMWhY n• u a o,i n r✓ ar ar ar rr ;� I I LOT 1 § LOT 2 LOT D LOT i `'� LOT s LOT k _ LO'Y 7 e L09'[7 pE6T F3 a.i. ew a.l. ne: ..:. nat r.r. a:ar cA. :.r, a:ar w. :A`eD a.r. I 3 M 1%1 Pa lE&0 F[{O4 R ms m AfiOA P^Aee.O Eh CDa,e m f as 404.D a'&c.e7u! _ _�BSk'NY�UNEB FORD � Saiw+a r., `� { I aarrtOPasa I wa•aaiaat I wai rcaa I wrnswoa I ewmaor I wonw.a ; wa1'�v>•aa9k+ 4, '/�(• `.`'•mil I ' t t IS4 22182-71 t im=FAMLY Vo a y �. er ra. ar D .�. rtM A6€3pavlllSn°�$ p A^..z aSlFe.IT ry a cL03irmAR Cci r r Y Y aF.011Y.a0ll1a1'Rf f!.! 2�G.A n�csa rr \7 t /r A ^• p•n a ; ' T z , C•cmm CI:EtT .�ro a/ �'��rLtxT"5 a'��'��grtrtc.P -t /`'' '�-.�'�''n�_ iu,_`^"fms`^ �;*:r-�/fir t�er'�'•N.a.,�-�e'a f�'�i�}pr�^�v!1� � �k.a..-a fL� �P.��Ckrul�JR pu tie. � �ti �.�v � `n� n.. `�' �f" `' I t�""l`: -✓. -S �'�"' �_'l IL r iab4'HF➢E^JA` it S�C510`i A'�mw!ciID c'mu:c ' Rr�;�Rr.�A"�.;.;vcm c[+t: �s�;•�� cJR`_F `*� azti�mr'a '�'�'�1 cu.wAna ea[fk u c� $IN�Mf Ol:!'E8 ROAD C r A 'l"£; rxx axX.'ac "MGi PqM j.o }Pfra =n J4+1 -F •'� L a IflMali yv.=, CH,.�,.a k•�H `qi V• 1 ;, 502 562 026 Jan Stalnps �./ PO Box 1953 zti ; Palm Springs, CA 92263 508 271 012 OaYid JosepjieTes`[5 PO Bos�5501 ro —PaLn Springs',}CA,o�� 6Bl J08 5. 2) )4fdk r)E Ul 2q6. Bp 1 t �85�,7�klClIS 009 611 180 V Jatren7�,�anagemenf Ltd 499 ON D�undas 51 W Trenton CANADA - I urlllrrllll IIIrIrIPII���rnlllhhlllnlPlllllr V MOVED / UNKNOWN // DEMENAGE II RETURN TO SENDER RENVOI A P EXPEDITEUR CA 92263 USA January 19, 2003 _ L SAN" 02004 ei To: City Council Members RJ_CEI ED Palm Springs �y Re: Desert Chapel Case No. 5. 935-PD-59 Dear Council Members : I am writing to request that the Council NOT approve an amendment to Planned Development District 59 for the following reasons : I object to evening football at Desert Chapel since it interferes with the peace and quiet of our neighborhood. There is no way the school can hold a "quiet" football game whether they have restrictions on the night games or not. The school must abide by the original master plan concerning evening lighting. The light towers used for evening football and special events force the neighbors to have to close our blinds because of the light being so bright. The school must be more sensitive to their neighbors and relocate the student morning drop off and play area to another location on their property that is not so close to our homes . I object to the new special events area being located so close to our homes . This will only add to the existing noise and light problems. There must be another area on the school grounds where this can be located. The school must be required to hire a twenty four hour employee to enforce compliance with the school regarding night time noise since their record shows they are not willing/capable of being responsible for what occurs on their property. Sincerely, Elkee Jast 2001 Camino Parocela #Q119 Palm Springs, Ca. 92264 -1M QL Q; ' sa January 15, 2003 7PAL44, 4 - TO: Palm Springs City Council Members DESERT CHAPEL CASE#5.935-PD 59 Dear Council Members: I am one of the closest neighbors to Desert Chapel School. I am writing to object to your approval of nighttime football games. I am retired and enjoy going to sleep at 8:0o PM. When the school has their evening concerts,carnivals,football games and many other evening events,their noise makes it impossible to be able to sleep until their events are over. If I had any idea that the school was going to operate as a evening community center for the City,I would certainly not have purchased my home at Mesquite Country Club back in October 2002. I am very concerned about the schools request to add a new special event area approximately eighty feet from my residence. I feel this is much too close and find no reason why it cannot be located elsewhere on their property. This will only add to the existing problem of daytime and evening noise that is not controlled. If there is any way you can encourage or see to it that the children's play area can be relocated elsewhere on school property I would be most appreciative. Currently it is located immediately across from my bedroom and living room forcing me to keep my windows closed throughout they day and preventing me from enjoying my outdoor patio. With all the property the school owns, I am sure their expansion plans can be written so that the concerns of the neighborhood can also be considered. I am not opposed to children or to schools. However, after living next to Desert Chapel for over one year now,I feel that they are unwilling to address their noise issues that are often out of control. Perhaps the school can be required to employ a twenty four hour security guard that can monitor and enforce excessive noise and other violations of City codes. I feel existing problems with the school must be addressed and resolved before any approval is given for their expansion. Your assistance with my concerns is most appreciated. Sincerely, ;2 6-6. 7 !1 Bob Aiken 2001 Camino Parocela K78 Palm Springs, Ca. 92264 i S08234 $ichar 1612 - 7,0 �>614A�Pree o 14, 1� cf•'_ f `�j 4 ._"f: / 7clno C�c� 1K vtlueeitpr�e� SO Ida ? 00 7 0 8 1 alb SO al Rrro%,O� �aR` '`IIRSR SOS 271005 S02 Donald$ell vay S Box 2203 Ecru 610j8 PO S CA 92263 6 and c� Call r lAAAl Feugerli ar! f a .&1oeApe rlacC cl/i 9 t.&lwi�N 4A' 1'P'l U4 5� rA CC. ?' f, pAI_ti `�pRNEYURN -ro is iV 3 k\ ` 502 561 Oli EXf'111� John&Margaret McglYmi „ 1 Peter _ 502 561 1 15196 SW Keaiton Dr r Despim_ apapelra Tigard;Ox y ltLw 3262 94t1t ---- r')f r, ' - �, << - l AID 502 460 045 Lot Common e O r 502561097522 S Sepulveda Blvd 9110 - " ". V T Deremer Jr. Los Angeles, CA 90049 2001 E Camino Parocela#N97 _Palin Springs. CA 9Z64 f:iui�'LntfEF(rl L AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING NOTICES I, the undersigned City Clerk of the City of. Palm Springs, California, do hereby certify that a copy of the Notice of Public Hearing before the City Council of the City of Palm Springs, in conjunction with Desert Chapel, Case No. 5.935 and PD 59, to consider revisions to the master plan for the addition of classrooms, a nursery, and administration building and a new special events area; and the establishment of regulations for the time, place and manner of special events, including night time football games, Section 24, was mailed to each and every person set forth on the attached list on the 6th day of January, 2004. A copy of said Notice is attached hereto. Said mailing was completed by placing a copy of said Notice in a sealed envelope, with postage prepaid, and depositing same in the U.S. Mail at Palm Springs, California. I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Dated at Palm Springs, California, this 6th day of January, 2004. PATRICIA A. SANDERS City Clerk J �ti NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING CITY COUNCIL CITY OF PALM SPRINGS Case No. 5.935-PD-59 An application by Desert Chapel for an amendment to Planned Development District 59 to consider revisions to the master plan, including: 1)the addition of classrooms, a nursery, an administration building, and a new special events area; and 2) the establishment of regulations for the time, place, and manner of special events, including night-time football games, at 630 South Sunrise Way, Zone PD 59, Section 24. NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of the City of Palm Springs, California, will hold a public hearing at its meeting of January 21,2004..' - The City Council meeting begins at 7:00 p.m., in the City Council Chamber at City Hall, 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way, Palm Springs, California_ The purpose of the hearing is to consider an application by Desert Chapel for an amendment to Planned Development District 59 for revisions to the master plan, including: 1) the addition of classrooms, a nursery, an administration building, and a new special events area; and 2) the establishment of regulations for the time, place, and manner of special events, including night-time football games. The property in question is located at 630 South Sunrise Way, Zone PD 59, Section 24. Pursuantto Section 15070 of the California Environmental Quality Act(CEQA)Guidelines,a Mitigated Negative Declaration was adopted by the City Council in 1999. The proposed application, site plan, and related documents are available for public review daily, between 8 am and 5 pm at the City of Palm Springs in the Planning and Zoning Department, located at 3200 Tahquitz Canyon Way. If any individual or group challenges the action in court, issues raised may be limited to only those issues raised at the public hearings described in this notice or in written correspondence at or prior to the City Council meeting. Notice of Public Hearing is being sent to all property owners within four hundred (400) feet of the subject property.An opportunity will be given at said hearings for all interested persons to be heard. Questions regarding this case may be directed to Alex Meyerhoff, Principal Planner, Department of Planning & Zoning, (760) 323-8245. Patricia Sanders City Clerk VICINITY MAP N w E S t -ri1ourrz GrWYON W/ly rl"ON 90LI0 SUNNY DUNE5 PO, \ pit�15t0 GOMWOL GI7MlNL MESC.?UITE liV..CNUC PPOJrGT /1OGA7/0N CITY OF PALM SPRINGS ASENO.: 5.935-PD-59 DESCRIPTION: Request for an amendment to Planned Development District 59, including the addition of classrooms,a APPLICANT: DESERT CHAPEL nursery,an administration building,and a new special events area,to regulate the time, place,and manner of special events, to consider the re-dedication of the Sunny Dunes Way right-of- way,and for final Planned Development District approval to construct an approximately 1,200 square foot storage building at 630 South Sunrise Way,Zone PD 59,Section 24. M E M O R A N D U M DATE: January 7, 2004 TO: Bureau of Indian Affairs - Margaret Park FROM: Office of the City Clerk RE: CASE NO. 5.935-PD 59—DESERT CHAPEL—630 S. SUNRISE WAY,SECTION 24 CC: File Enclosed are the following: Notices of the Public Hearing (53), as some of the property in the above referenced project is within Section 24. Envelopes w/postage (53) It is our understanding that the Bureau will forward these notices to the landowners. Thank you, �V PATRICIA A. SANDERS Assistant City Clerk s - - 5� ��S MR BILL DAVIS AND MR PETER DIXON MS TRISHA DAVIS TENNIS CLUB AREA TENNIS CLUB AREA 431 SOUTH MONTE VISTA DRIVE 227 SOUTH CAHUILLA PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 I PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 MR FRANK TYSEN C/O CASA CODY COUNTRY INN MS. CHRISTINE HAMMOND MR BOB WEITHORN SMALL HOTELS TAHQUITZ RIVER ESTATES TENNIS CLUB/SMALL HOTELS 175 SOUTH CAHUILLA ROAD 1155 SOUTH CAMINO REAL 261 SOUTH BELARDO ROAD PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 MR TIM HOHMEIER MS ROXANNE FLOSS MR PHIL TEDESCO 1 DEEPWELL I OLD LAS PALMAS DEEPWELL RANCH 1387 CALLE DE MARIA 930 CHIA 1303 WEST PRIMAVERA DRIVE PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 MR MARSHALL ROATH MS MARGARET PARK MS SHERYL HAMLIN AGUA CALIENTE BAND OF HISTORIC TENNIS CLUB AREA AGUA CALIENTE BAND OF CAHUILLA INDIANS 565 WEST SANTA ROSA DRIVE CAHUILLA INDIANS-J --J-0 =J--D - 650 E TAHQUITZ CANYON WAY PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 CITY OF PALM SPRINGS VERIFICATION NOTICE -J=J=J PLANNING & ZONING DEPT ATTN: SENIOR SECRETARY PO BOX 2743 PALM SPRINGS CA 92263-2743 MR FRANK MARSHALL SPONSORS -D DESERT CHAPEL C/O DESERT CHAPEL 630 SOUTH SUNRISE WAY 630 SOUTH SUNRISE WAY PALM SPRINGS, CA 92264 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 MR CHRISTOPHER MILLS CHRISTOPHER S MILLS ARCHITECT 1255 EAST RAMON ROAD PALM SPRINGS CQ 92264 Smooth Feed SheetsTM Case 5.935 Use template for5160m 502 460 001 502 460 0 502 460 003 Charles Thomas&John Shryock James&Su 11 dell Charles&Patricia Leviton PO Box 9077 1783 E Ramo Rd 1789 E Ramon Rd Palm Springs, CA 92263 Palm Spring , .A 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 004 502 460 005 502 460 006 Hamer Edgar E&Betty A Singer Mihata Rose E E&B 1752 E Canino Parocela 468 W Tahquitz Canyon Way 12501 Foster Rd Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Los Alamitos, CA 90720 502 460 007 502 460 008 502 460 9 Jack Atwell Richard Mcginness Matthew T 1748 E Camino Parocela 1742 E Camino Parocela#8 PO Box 132 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Sunset Beacl, CA 90742 502 460 010 502460011 502 460 012 Inez Pullen Cecelia Spellman Marcluck Sharon L&Marcluck Sharo 1766 E Camino Parocela 750 N Palm Carryon Dr 1738 E Camino Parocela Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 013 502 460 014 502 460 015 Rooney A Alice Dennis Karen Po ell 511 S Coast Highway 101 114 Aliso Dr 1728 E Can 'ro Parocela Encinitas, CA 92024 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Spring , CA 92264 502 460 016 502 460 017 502 460 018 Jefferson Hills Marion&Mary Valvo Shipe Lewis Glenn&James Spivey 1726 E Camino Parocela 1722 E Camino Parocela 1720 E Camino Parocela Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 019 502 460 020 502 460 021 Greg Kiper&A ret e Kiper George Salvo&Gerald Salvo Richard Kief&Bell Kief 3822 242nd Ave S 1716 E Camino Parocela #20 1712 E Camino Parocela Issaquah, WA 980 9 I Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 022 502 460 023 502 460 G24 Valdez Murray Paul Stoddard William Lovett Jr. &Arline Lovett 2420 NW 59th St 586 S Sunrise Way 14 Simpson St Miami,FL 33142 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Geneva, IL 60134 502 460 025 502 460 026 502 460 027 Carlston Emil&Velasquez-ruby Helman John Asher PO Box 7233 9602 Orange Ave 546 S Sunrise Way Carmel, CA 93921 Anaheim, CA 92804 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 028 502 460 029 502 460 030 Edward H Cunningl n Scott&Erin""-' om Leograndis Stephen&Florence 552 N Sunrise Way#2 16824 Carl H Rd NW 14851 W Sunset Blvd Palm Springs, CA 922 Seattle, WA 98 77 Pacific Palisades, CA 90272 Ap AVERYO Address Labels I - - • Z ''f)TM Smooth Feed SheetsTM Case 5.935 Use template for5160© 502 460 031 502 46 03 502 460 033 Norman Phares Gloria Wonderly Eric P 526 S Sunrise Way#31 15523 Vr la Vicente Dr 26505 Briarwood Ln Palm Springs, CA 92264 Raniona, A 92065 San Juan Capistrano, CA 92675 502 460 034 502 460 035 502 460 036 William Bowen Gregory&Geraldine Siverly Fernando Ramirez&Melissa Ramirez 506 S Sunrise Way 5811 N Drumheller St 1223 E Grovecenter St Palm Springs, CA 92264 Spokane,WA 99205 West Covina,CA 91790 502 460 037 502 460 038 502 460 039 Norman Freedberg Deanna Lawrence Cooper Lewis 226 N Palm Canyon Or PO Box 942 1751 E Ramon Rd Palm Springs, CA 92262 Pine Valley, CA 91962I Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 040 502 460 041 502 460 042 Alfred Kendall&Patricia Jea Orsatti Brenda Scott Shaun Lether 8348 Jason Ave 1761 E Ramon Rd#41 1765 E Ramon Rd West Hills, CA 91304 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 043 502 460 044 502 460 045 Joan Elizabeth Cheatham Donna Prada Lot Common 1775 E Ramon Rd 854 Diamond St 522 S Sepulveda Blvd 4110 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Monrovia, CA 91016 Los Angeles, CA 90049 502 560 001 502 560 005 502 560 009 SE Calif Assn Of 7th Day Adventists Desert Water Agency Riverside County Flood Cont PO Box 8050 PO Box 1710 1995 Market St Riverside, CA 92515 1 Palm Springs, CA 92263 Riverside, CA 92501 502 560 014 502 560 016 502 560 018 Usa 502 Riverside Comity Flood Cont Riverside County Flood Cent Unknown S 1995 Market St 1995 Market St CA Riverside, CA 92501 Riverside, CA 92501 502 560 020 502 560 025 502 560 033 Dahoon Investment Co Usa 502 Usa 502 77200 California Dr Unknown S Unknown S Palm Desert, CA 92211 , CA , CA 502 560 034 502 560 038 502 560 039 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 02-27-87 S Unknown 02-27-87 S CA , CA , CA 502 5 0 04 ` 502 561 001 502561002 Riversi C rmty Flood Cont Whiteside Stephen L&D C Marilyn di g 1995 Mar St 2310 Nicolas Dr 2001 E Car no Parocela#2 Riverside, A 92501 Fullerton, CA 92833 Palm Sp ' gs, A 92264 MuF12yn pddrACC 1 ^hr+lc Laser 5960Tm Smooth Feed SheetSTM Case 5.935 Use template for 516O 3 502 561 003 502 561 004 502 561 005 Robert Kastinng Ronnie Reichgelt&James Horan Ruth Ruiz 2001 E Camino Parocela#A3 839 W Lakeside PI 78520 Avenida La Fonda Palm Springs, CA 92264 Chicago,IL 60640 La Quinta, CA 92253 502 561 006 502 561 007 502 561 008 Kathleen Bill Timothy&Dawn Silva Andrew&Vicki Garbely PO Box 854 376 Virginia Dr 3536 NE Hancock St Manhattan Beach, CA 90267 Livermore, CA 94550 Portland, OR 97212 502 561 009 502 561 01 502 561 011 Richard Sears&Loretta Sears Jamie R ' eau Overgaauw& Cornelius 810 NW 176th Ave 21515 orne Blvd 4840 6143 Capetown St Beaverton,OR 97006 Tor , CA 0503 Lakewood, CA 90713 502 561 012 502 561 013 502 561 014 Andres M Baric John&Margaret Meglynn Barbara Kabus&Patricia Friesen 115 Pico Ave Peter 2001 E Camino Parocela 4B14 Pacific Grove, CA 93950 15196 SW Kenton Dr Palm Springs, CA 92264 Tigard,OR 97224 502 561 015 502 561 016 502 561 017 Joseph Mas &Maureen Massey Francine Heser I D & Gayle Weiner 2001 E Camin arocela#C15 20109 Mildred Ave 28032 Sea Lane Dr Palm Springs, A 2264 Torrance, CA 90503 Malibu, CA 90265 502 561 018 502 561019 502 561 020 Donald Anderson&Arlene Rose Ande Stephen Morrow&April Barry Henry Ali ch 4813 Marblehead Bay Dr 2007 W Hedding St#100 2001 E Can o Parocela#C20 Oceanside, CA 92057 San Jose, CA 95128 Palm Spri gs, A 92264 502 561 021 502 561 022 i 502 561 023 William&Consuelo Gills Joseph Hug John Jordan 8832 Sovereign Rd 2001 E Ca mi ocela#C22 10080 W Suburban Dr San Diego, CA 92123 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Miami,FL 33156 502 561 024 502 561 025 502 561 026 James&Becky Zopolis Roland&Mary Stewart Gus Stevenson&Leona Stevenson PO Box 2083 3275 Dogwood Dr S 3660 Bluebell St Palm Springs, CA 92263 Salem, OR 97302 Seal Beach, CA 90740 502 561 027 502 561028 502 561 029 Jensen Mary Lou&Jensen Ruth Anderson Gregory&Monica Keehfass 226 W E St PO Box 652 7148 Wood Rd Ontario, CA 91762 Palm Springs, CA 92263 Riverside, CA 92506 502 561 030 502 561 031 502 561 032 Nicholas Tricarico Despina Papapetru Boyle Daniel B &Boyle Cathy A 6 Gravel Hill Ter 3262 N 94th St Boyle Kinnelon,NJ 07405 Milwaukee, WI 53222 31 Ticknor PI Laguna Niguel, CA 92677 -11-17yo eddr 14 l r 496(iTM Smooth Feed SheetsTM Case 5.935 Use template for5160® 1I 502 561 033 I 502 561 034 502 561 35 Mcmillan Holdings Ltd Lambert Jack&Lambert Jack Leonard C 'e Bart 4 650 Harrington Rd Kamloops 2001 E Canino Parocela#E34 2001 E Cal ' o Parocela BC V2B 6T7 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Spri CA 92264 CANADA 502 561 036 502 561 037 502 561 038 Ruel Longfellow&Mercedes Longfello Darell&Mary Schregardus Kent&Dorothy Roberts 21 Muriel Rd 1711 S Shore Dr 720 Greenway Ter Swampscott,MA 01907 Holland,MI 49423 La Habra, CA 90631 502 561 039 502 561 040 502 561 041 Joseph&Delores Young Jack Lambert Julius& ne ummerman 21672 Kaiser Rd 2001 E Canino Parocela#F40 2001 E Ca Parocela 4G41 Gregory,MI 48137 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Sprin CA 92264 502 561 042 502 561 043 502 561 044 1 Phillip Rose Helmut Bauch Thush 21617 Woodland Crest Dr Birnauer Str 12 G-7750 Konstanz 4400 Hollingsworth Cir Woodland Hills, CA 91364 GERMANY Rohnert Park, CA 94928 502 561 045 502 561 046 502 561 047 Hobert& lee Herber Transport Sorenson Ladd 2001 E Canrin arocela#G45 PO Box 311 24813 Outlook Ct Palm Springs, 92264 Chehalis,WA 98532 Cannel, CA 93923 502 561 048 502 561 049 502 561 050 James& Sandra Giefer William&Tamaralee Cox E Budd&Paulette Simpson 3752 Village Ct 1032 Bayside Cv 135 Camellia Ct Saint Paul, MN 55125 Newport Beach, CA 92660 Upland, CA 91786 502 561051 502 561 052 502 561 053 John&Nancy dd Keudell David J&Keudell David J Michael Teagle 2001 E Carnino ocela#H51 1104 Main St 4200 2001 E Canino Parocela#H53 Palm Springs, 2264 Vancouver, WA 98660 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 561 054 502 561 055 502 561 056 Jerkins Cheryl Agee&Glen Jenkins Lawrence&Lola Otoole Myron Filipoft 440 N Hayden Island Dr 17352 Rainglen La 20503 Shepherd Hills Dr Portland, OR 97217 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Walnut, CA 91789 502 561 057 502 561 058 502 561 059 Ferrari Donna&Ferrari Donna Bernard&Eugenia Bernacchi Cal-wai Properties 1675 Cherry Ave 176 Appletree Ave 6070 Calle De Prospero San Jose, CA 95125 Camarillo, CA 93012 San Jose, CA 95124 502 561 060 502 561 061 502 561 062 Michael Agee&Sheri Benetreu I D&Gayle Weiner Michael Torhan 386 SW 37th Cir 28032 Sea Lane Dr 38094 3rd St Gresham,OR 97080 Malibu, CA 90265 Fremont, CA 94536 A VERY@ Addracc I laic Laser 5960TM Smooth Feed SheetsTM Case 5.935 Use template for5160M 502 561 063 502 561 064 502 56XO Gerald Ford Chappelle Ler &Vera C&Chapp Betty Wk231 Avenida Majorca#3 2001 E Camino arocela#I64 2001Euno Parocela#J65 Laguna Hills, CA 92653 Palm Springs, A 92264 Palm Ss, CA 92264 502 561 066 502 561067, 502 561 068 j Marie Bro Edward Bobb tt Martina Bobbett Gallagher Joseph A&P A 717 Strand St 1609 Beechwo Ave PO Box 401037 Santa Monica, CA 90405 Fullerton, CA 2835 Hesperia, CA 92340 502 561 069 502 561 070 502 561 071 Fred&Lupe Luevano Jr. i Randy&Je e Price Paul&Kathryn Alle Goodman 1166 Arroyo Pacifica 2001 E Camino arocela#J70 PO Box 2127 Fallbrook, CA 92028 Palm Springs, A 92264 La Habra, CA 90632 I li I 502 561 072 502 561 073 502 561 074 J Roger Grummett&Karleen Grummet Robert&Dorthea Pailthorp Joseph Wild II&Leroy Bontrager 4195 Lake Shore Dr PO Box 713 761 Hillpine Ter NE Juneau, AK 99801 Depoe Bay, OR 97341 Atlanta, GA 30306 502 561 075 502 561 076 502 561 077 Jotm Dominge&Ernest Sabo Gray Leslie M&Helen Adina Arthur Macmillan 4663 Vista St Leslie&Helen Gray 2001 E Camino Parocela#K77 San Diego, CA 92116 1112 Rio Cidade Way Palm Springs, CA 92264 Sacramento, CA 95831 502 561 078 502 561 K9 502 080 Akin Robert D Stanley 1 &Scott Mcdonald Henry B Jody Basile PO Box 2542 2001 E C o Parocela 2244 13t W 4 403 Wrightwood, CA 92397 Palm Spring , A 92264 Seattle, A 98119 502 561 081 502 561 082 502 561 083 Patti Lee Phillips&James Waydelich D Dean&IaWinghaia William&Phyllis Stewart 1752 Miramar Dr 10041 Ech 4797 W Phillips St Newport Beach, CA 92661 Brookville, 7012 Ontario, CA 91762 502 561 084 502 561 085 502 561 086 Gordon&Marcia Thompson Marilyn Milrnan Laurie&Michael Bardkas 16215 NE Eugene Ct 2001 E Camino Parocela#L85 Morgan &Barba Bardkas Portland,OR 97230 Palm Springs, CA 92264 675 S Sierra Ave 028 Solana Beach, CA 92075 502 561 087 502 561 $8 502 561-089 Sydney&Ann Ackerman Novy Ron d &Novy Ronald R&D Holum a ley Wayne 2001 E Camino Parocela#L87 7284 Ced od PI 1136 Cor z Ave Palm Springs, CA 92264 Highland, CA 2346 Burlinga , CA 94010 502 561 090 502 561 091 502 561 092 George Goy Charles Leroy Hansen Doolittle N ma P&Doolittle 1909 Shell Ave 2001 E Camino Parocela#M91 2001 E Cana Parocela#Ivl92 Venice, CA 90291 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, 92264 `9 AVERY@ Address Labels I -c,er 5960'r Smoeth Feed SheetsTM Case 5.935 Use template for5160@� 502 561 093 502 561 094 502 561 095 Howard&Sonja Hoch Timothy L &Stuart Berger John&Norma Marrin 952 W Cumberland St 1359 25th A 1225 Cajon St Upland, CA 91786 San Francis , CA 94122 Redlands, CA 92373 1 502 561 096 502 561 097 502 561 098 Non arvey&Mary Patricia Haako V T Deremer Jr. Felix&Mary Lom Junonville Jr. 812 D wood Ln 2001 E Camino Parocela#N97 2001 E Camino Parocela#N98 VICT ABC Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 CAN 502 561 099 502 562 001 502 562 002 Michael Gee&Phillip Hager Brian&Roslyn Lloyd Diana Meyer 9401 Castlewood St 404 E 131h St 2001 E Camino Parocela 4101 Oakland, CA 94605 Vancouver,WA 98660 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 562 003 502 562 004 502 562 005 Lester Ga M R Marlene Lucretia Woldgemuth Muriel Bell 1227 NW Nor ss Way 2001 E Camino Parocela#N103 19191 Harvard Ave 4404 Seattle, WA 1 7 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Irvine, CA 92612 511 562 006 502 562 007 502 562 00 Richard Schle 1 James Odell Scott John Pa &S Co-trustees Marilyn 2001 E Camino rocela#0105 22962 Orangewood Ct 15120 M sta St Palm Springs, A 2264 Grand Terrace, CA 92313 Whittier CA 90605 502 562 009 502 562 010 502562011 Gonzalez Angel& Grace Villa Patricia Boren Crestline Inv Group hic 731 Iliff St 1609 Michael Ln Michele Artukovich Pacific Palisades, CA 90272 Pacific Palisades, CA 90272 4417 E Village Rd Long Beach, CA 90908 502 562 012 502 562 013 502 562 014 Vincent&Brenda Nardolillo Russel& Sheila Hamelin Margaret Levinson 6462 E Via Arboles 1159 W Molly Ct 2001 E Camino Parocela Anaheim, CA 92807 Upland, CA 91786 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 562 015 502 562 016 502 562 017 Maria Oms Randal&Sally Jo Largent Ardean William&Marla Jean Ladd 2008 Calle Francesca 15114 206th Ave SE 12710 Spindlewood Dr San Dimas, CA 91773 Renton, WA 98059 La Mirada, CA 90638 502 562 018 502 562 019 502 562 020 Darlene Ruth Roc Ira Golchehreh&D B Carolita Elko Just 2001 E Camino ro In 4 Q117 15 Madeline Lu 611 S Palm Canyon Dr#260 Palm Springs, C 92264 San Rafael, CA 94901 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 562 021 502 562 022 502 562 023 Jolty Kanocz&Patricia Kanocz Barbara Mckerma Arthur Gittehnan&Rosemary Gittelrn 2001 E Canino Parocela#Q120 2001 E Camino Parocela#Q121 3300 Darby Rd#3208 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Haverford,PA 19041 v V eddr • I at I car ca16pTM Smooth Feed SheetsTM Case 5.935 Use template for516Om-� 502 562 024 502 562 2 502 562 026 Henderson Roy&Frances Carol Robert& ion Da al Jan Stamps Roy&France Henderson 2001 E C 'no Parocela#Q124 PO Box 1953 113 N Equestrian Way Palm Sp ' gs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92263 Prescott, AZ 86303 502 562 027 502 562 028 502 562 029 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa Bin Unknown S Unknown 01-05-1998 S Unknown 11-07-97 S CA CA CA 502 562 030 502 562 031 502 562 032 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa Bia Unknown S Unknown S Unknown 11-23-98 S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 033 502 562 034 502 562 035 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 036 502 562 037 502 562 038 Usa Bin Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknow,n 04-24-97 S Unknown 04-29-98 S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 039 502 562 040 502 562 041 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown 08-28-98 S Unknown 12-07-1999 S Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 042 502 562 043 502 562 044 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown 04-17-98 S Unknown 08-03-98 S Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 045 502 562 046 502 562 047 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 048 502 562 049 502 562 050 Usa Bia Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknowns 10-13-98 S Unknown S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 051 502 562 052 502 562 054 Usa 502 Usa Bin Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 05-21-97 S Unknown S CA , CA CA 0 AVFRY® Addrp« l hale l 59 ,)TM Smooth Feed Sheets TM Case 5.935 Use template for5160@ 502 562 055 1 I 502 562 056 502 562 057 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa Bin Unknown 11-30-98 S I Unknown 06-06-97 S Unknown 11-03-97 S CA CA CA 502 562 058 502 562 059 502 562 060 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown 05-10-2001 S Unknown 11-08-95 S I Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 061 502 562 062 502 562 063 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 01-05-1999 S Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 064 502 562 065 502 562 066 Usa 502 Usa 502 Hudson Unknown S Unknown S 1194 Kingston Ln , CA , CA Ventura, CA 93001 502 562 067 502 562 068 502 562 069 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown S Unknown 12-29-1998 S Unknown 05-18-98 S CA CA CA 502 562 070 502 562 071 502 562 072 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 01-02-2002 S Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 073 502 562 074 502 562 075 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S CA CA CA 508 240 0 508 240 008 508 240 009 Riverside Co Flood Cont 555 Sunrise Randall W Guy Llc&Lisa Guy Llc 1995 Market S 1555 S Palm Canyon Dr#G106 PO Box 950 Riverside, CA 92:' 1 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Indianola, WA 98342 508 240 010 508 271 010 508 271 011 International Church Four Square Gosp Edward Taggart Acme Boukidis 630 S Sunrise Way 1629 E Sunny Dunes Rd 2469 S Caliente Rd Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 508 271 012 508 271 013 508 271 014 David Joseph Testa Noble Willingham&Willingham Anne Clarke PO Box 5504 69 Asilomar Rd 1654 E San Lucas Rd Palm Springs, CA 92263 I Laguna Niguel, CA 92677 Palm Springs, CA 92264 "ii" AVPMy® pddrpcs I -hpla Laser 5960'rm Smooth Feed SheetsTM Case 5.935 Use template for5160m r� i 508 271 015 508 272 010 508 272 011 Daniel Smith&K B Kandi Kim Chasen&Marian Moiseyev Jack Warren&Emilie Warren 2654 Crowthorne Ct i 1627 E San Lucas Rd 1653 E San Lucas Rd Vista, CA 92084 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 508 272 012 508 272 013 508 272 014 Chi&Frances Chung Hernandez Gus&J Laurie Stann 362 S Palm Canyon Dr 1672 N Riverside Dr 1650 N Riverside Dr Palm Springs, CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 508 272 015 508 273 0 508 281 012 Larry KaSt Riverside Co Flood Cont Housing&Finance Agency Corp 1626 N Riverside Dr 1995 Marke St 801 S Sunrise Way Palm Springs, CA 92264 Riverside, A 92 1 Palm Springs, CA 92264 /l� AVFQY® Addrp«, I -heel,, I -czpr S960TM 009 610 830 019 610$32 009 10 834 City Of Palm S gs New Mes Development Assoc Ltd Rivers e m ty Flood Control PO Box 2743 73080 El C P eo 1995 et St Palm Springs, 263 Pal Des A 92260 Riversi e, A 92501 009 610 835 009 610 838 009 610 839 Dahoon Investment Co Dahoon vRa lent Co D n Inv tment Co 77200 California Dr 77200 CDr 77200 omiaD.Palm Desert, CA 92211 Palm Des92211 Palm se CA 92211 009 611 1 4 009 611 167 009 611 169 Suzarme Co Shackford Joseph E&Kaye Edmund&Lees Eva Birch 13833 Rose Shackford 18 Saddle Rd San Leandro 94578 PO Box 5454 Rancho Palos Verdes, CA 90275 Incline Village,NV 89450 009 611 171 009 611 173 009 611 174 Clinton Miller Jr. &Karen Miller Seymour Lippert&Marcia Lippert Betty Krengel PO Box 399 20030 Inverness Ct 944 Saint Bimini Cir#A Watsonville, CA 95077 Olympia Fields, 1L 60461 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 611 176 009 611 179 009 611 180 Bert AM%& Paterson Jatren Management Ltd 16910 SE,;''S$th St 25123 Smokewood Way 499 Dundas St W Trenton Bellevuc,,WA,98006 Newhall, CA 91381 ON CANADA 009 611 182 009 611 184 009 611 185 John Rock David Green&Susan Green Charles Madill 900 Saint Bimini Cir#A 915 Saint Bimini Cir#B 501-35 Newcastle Ave Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 NANAIMO Be V9S 4H6 CANADA 009 611 188 009 6 1' 19 009 611 195 Hoffe-isengerg Barbara k Jack Goodale&Aletha Goodale 937 Saint Bimini Cir#B 937 Saint imini Cir#A 10181 Kenowa Ave SW Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Spr n CA 92264 Grand Rapids,MI 49544 009 611 196 009 611 197 009 611 198 Viola Mcmillan Wilbert&Dorothy Kunz Marney Reed PO Box 200547 954 Arlene Dr#B 954 Arlene Dr#A Anchorage, AK 99520 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 611200 009 611 202 009 611 203 Eugene&Jean Mary Bauer Charlotte Marie Spurgin Arlene Rosen 19 Catspaw Cpe 452 Pebble Beach Way PO Box 10775 Coronado, CA 92118 Eagle, ID 83616 Beverly Hills, CA 90213 009 611a OS 009 611 06 009 611`209 Harrison n H&Barbara J Ken Melvin Marie Alderman Kevin Harri Jr. 955 Arlene r#B 110 Alcor Cir 906 Arlene r Palm Sp gs, A 92264 Palm Deese ' A 92211 Palm Spring , CA 92264 009 611210 009 611212 009 611848 Robert Neuman&Barbara Neuman Brian Ellis Elaine Crane Baird 999 Arlene Dr#B 999 Arlene Dr#A 911 Arlene Dr WE l Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 611 849 009 611850 009 611 851 Ron&Gina Youngren Ken Bell&Kathryn Bell Curry Robert A 12362 Fairway Pointe Row 14016 NE 63rd Ct PO Box 22777 San Diego, CA 92128 Redmond,WA 98052 Long Beach,CA 90901 ( 009 611 852 009 611 853 009 611 854 Bernard&Helen Richter Jacklynn Ludwick E Randall Henderson Jr. 3285 Amethyst Dr 19725 SE 3lst PI 2400 Creslmoor Rd Cameron Park, CA 95682 Issaquah,WA 98075 Nashville,TN 37215 009 611 855 009 61 856 009 611"S57 Joan Hunisinger Charles a ens&Doris Stephens Dale&Bettiendrickson 950 Saint George Cir#A 916 Saint Ykeorge Cir#B 3416 24th Av6 W fit. Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Spri g , CA 92264 Seattle,WA( 98`l99 ✓, 009 611 858 009 611 859 009 61 86 Felicia Trader&Helen Barney James Hudson&Cheryl Ann Hudson Chaim o 901 Saint George Cir#B PO Box 2810 921 Sam eorge Cir#B Palm Springs, CA 92264 Ventura, CA 93002 Palm Sp 'n , CA 92264 009 611 61 009 611 862 009 611 863 Yvette S gy John&Marilyn Mack Geraldine&Arron Korach 921 Saint rge Cir#A 939 Saint George Cir#B 939 Saint George Cir#A Palm Sp 'igs, CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs,CA 92264 009 611 864 009 611 865 009 611 866 Thomas&Sharon Britz Wayne Guthrie IIl&Michael Geister New Me to Development Assoc Ltd 975 Saint George Cir#B PO Box 727 73080 EI seo Palm Springs, CA 92264 Kentfield, CA 94914 Palm De rt CA 92260 009 613 310 009 61 11 009 611 847 New Mesquite Dev Assoc Ltd DahoonI stmentCo MR DALE HENDRICKSON PO Box 1906 77200 Calif 'a Dr . MS BETTIE HENDRICKSON Palm Springs, CA 92263 Palm Deser, ' 92211 3612 26TH PLACE WEST#4 SEATTLE WA98199-2143 b 9 Smooth Feed SheetsTM Case 5.935 Use template for5160o 502 562 055 502 562 056 502 562 057 Usa Bia Usa Bin Usa Bin Unknown 11-30-98 S Unknown 06-06-97 S Unknown 11-03-97 S CA , CA CA 502 562058 502562059 059 502 562 060 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown 05-10-2001 S Unknown 11-08-95 S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 061 502 562 062 502 562 063 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 01-05-1999 S Unknown S , CA , CA CA 502 562 064 502 562 065 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S , CA , CA 502 562 067 502 562 068 502 562 069 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown S Unknown 12-29-1998 S Unknown 05-18-98 S CA CA CA 502 562 070 502 562 071 502 562 072 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 01-02-2002 S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 073 502 562 074 502 562 075 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S , CA CA CA 508 240 0 Riverside Co Flood Cont 1995 Market S Riverside, CA 92-3 1 n `•� V eddr - IaF "cer S960T" Smooth Feed SheetsTM Case 5.935 Use template for5160®-� 502 562 2 Robert& ion Da on 2001 E Ca no Paroce1 #Q124 Palm SP ' gs, CA 92264 502 562 027 502 562 028 502 562 029 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown S Unknown 01-05-1998 S Unknown 11-07-97 S , CA CA CA 502 562 030 502 562 031 502 562 032 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa Bia Unknown S Unknown S Unknown 11-23-98 S CA CA CA 502 562 033 502 562 034 502 562 035 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S , CA ,CA , CA 502 562 036 502 562 037 502 562 038 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown 04-24-97 S Unknown 04-29-98 S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 039 502 562 040 502 562 041 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown 08-28-98 S Unknown 12-07-1999 S Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 042 502 562 043 502 562 044 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown 04-17-98 S Unknown 08-03-98 S Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 045 502 562 046 502 562 047 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 _ Unknown S Unknown S i Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 048 502 562 049 502 562 050 Usa Bin Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown 10-13-98 S Unknown S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 051 502 562 052 502 562 054 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 05-21-97 S Unknown S CA , CA CA A ` F'r2Y® "ddr -- I -, '- I . - . ,:9.r)TM Smdeth Eeed Sheets TM Case 5.935 Use template for5160@) � 502 46 03 Gloria e 15523 V1 to Vicente Dr Ramona, A 92065 502 560 014 Usa 502 Unknown S CA 502 560 025 502 560 033 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S , CA , CA 502 560 034 502 560 038 502 560 039 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 02-27-87 S Unknown 02-27-87 S , CA CA , CA 512 5 0 04 ` 502 561 002 Rivers' C 'ally Flood Cont Marilyn di g 1995 Mar St 2001 E Cal no Parocela#2 Riverside, A 92501 Palm Sp'' gs, A 92264 .1 _ �, 1 ^vor ;960TM 111 PROOF OF PUBLICATION This is spare for County Clerks Filing Stamp (201S.S.C.C.P) STATE OF CALIFORNIA No 6514 CITY OF RINGS County of Riverside NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING PLANNING COMMISSION Case No. 5.0951 and Tentative Tract Map 28308 An appucation by Desert Chapel for a Planned Davellopment District and Tentative Tract Mapp app- proval to create 8 single family lots of 8,181 square feet or larger, and 3 lots for professional off I am citizen of the United States and a resident Of ice development under 'P" zone standards on assessor's parcel number 508-240-010, on a 2.54 the Count aforesaid;I am over the age of eighteen acre site at Sunrise way and Sunny Dunes Road, S' g g Zones R-1-C and R-MHP, Section 23. years,and not a party to or interested in the NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that Stheprings, Planning above-entitled matter.I am the principal clerk of a commission of the tic of Palm t As m, tingor- nia, rn hold a public hearing at As meeting of printer of the,DESERT SUN PUBLISHING Decemgber 17, 2003. The Planning Commission COMPANYCOMPANX a newspaper of general circulation, ginn art 2-009ins p.m.)tin hepCity ouncil Chain erbat printed and published in the city of Palm Springs, City Hall, 3200 E Tahyultz Canyon way, Palm Springs, California County of Riverside,and which newspaper has been The ppurpose of the hearing is to consider ap- adjudg¢d a newspaper Of general circulation by the phcatron by Desert Chapel for a Planned Devv elop- Superior Court of the County of Riverside,State of mert District and Tentative Tract Map approval to create 8 sin le family lots of 8,181 square feet or California under the date of March 24, 1988.Case larger, and 3q lots for professional office develop- ment under "i zone standards The property is Number 191236;that the notice,of which the question is located on a 2.b4 acre site near the corner of Sunrise Way and Sunny Dunes Road, annexed Is a printed copy(set in type not smaller Zones R-1-C and R-MHP, Section 23. than non pariel,has been published in each regular VICINITY MAP and entire issue of said newspaper and not in any supplement thereof on the following dates,to wit: ` December 5n' — - -------------'----'---- , All in the year 2003 — I certify(or declare)under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. �r>Y OF�A�hi sanrr,cs Sir y Dated at Palm Springs,California this------day This action Is categorically exempt from the provi- sions of the Gunforma Environmental Quality Act of--------Decemher----------------------------2003 (CEQA) per Section 15332 (In-Fill Development The proposed application, site pplaq and related documents are available far ublic review daily, between 8 am and 5 pm a the City of Palm Springs in the Planning and Zoning Department, Signature located at 2200 Tahqurtz Canyon Way. r If any individual or group challenges the action in court, issues raised may be limited to only those issues raised at the public hearings described in Ibis notice or in wntten-comagpondence afar prF- or to the Commission meeting. Netico of Public Hearing is being sent to all prop- erty owners wdhrn four hundred (400) feet of the subject property. An opportunity Will be given at said hearings for all interested persons to be heard. Queshan. regarding this case may be di- rected to Alex Meyerhoff, Puri pat Planner, De- partment of Planning &Zoning, P60)323-8245. r i . Isl Douglas R.Evans r AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF RIVERSIDE ) I,the undersigned,say: I am and was at all times herein mentioned, a citizen of the United States and employed in the County of Riverside, over the age of eighteen years, and not a party to the within action or proceeding; that my business address is 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Drive, Palm Springs, California;that on the 141h day of August,2003, 1 served the within NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING for PLANNING COMMISSION CASE NO. 5.935-PD-59 to consider an application by Desert Chapel for an amendment to Planned Development District 59, including the addition of classrooms, a nursery, an administration building, and a new special events area,to regulate the time, place, and manner of special events, to consider the re-dedication of the Sunny Dunes Way right-of-way, and for final Planned Development District approval to construct an approximate 1,200 square foot storage building at 630 South Sunrise Way, Palm Springs, CA. This Notice was served on persons contained in Exhibit "A" attached hereto in said action or proceeding by depositing a true copy thereof, enclosed in a sealed envelope with postage thereon fully prepaid, in a mailbox, sub-post office, substation or mail chute, or other like facility, regularly maintained by the Government of the United States in the City of Palm Springs,California, addressed to the list of persons or firms indicated on the report dated June 10,2003,'and certified by the City's Planning Technician, and attached hereto as Exhibit"A". I hereby declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Loretta D. Moffett Dated at Palm Springs, California, this 14th day of August, 2003 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING PLANNING COMMISSION Case No. 5.935-PD-59 An application by Desert Chapel for an amendment to Planned Development District 59, including the addition of classrooms, a nursery, an administration building, and a new special events area, to regulate the time, place, and manner of special events, to consider the re-dedication of the Sunny Dunes Way right-of-way, and for final Planned Development District approval to construct an approximately 1,200 square foot storage building at 630 South Sunrise Way, Zone PD 59, Section 24. NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Planning Commission of the Cityof Palm Springs, California, will hold a public hearing at its meeting of August 27, 2003. The Planning Commission meeting begins at 1:30 p.m., (public hearings begin at 2:00 p.m.), in the City Council Chamber at City Hall, 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way, Palm Springs, California. The purpose of the hearing is to consider an application by Desert Chapel for an amendment to Planned Development District59,including the addition of classrooms,a nursery,an administration building, and a new special events area,to regulate the time, place, and manner of special events, to consider the re-dedication of the Sunny Dunes Way right-of-way, and for final Planned Development District approval to construct an approximately 1,200 square foot storage building. The property in question is located at 630 South Sunrise Way, Zone PD 59, Section 24. Pursuant to Section 15070 of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines, a Mitigated Negative Declaration was adopted by the City Council in 1999. The proposed application, site plan, and related documents are available for public review daily, between 8 am and 5 pm at the City of Palm Springs in the Planning and Zoning Department, located at 3200 Tahquitz Canyon Way. If any individual or group challenges the action in court, issues raised may be limited to only those issues raised at the public hearings described in this notice or in written correspondence at or prior to the Commission meeting. Notice of Public Hearing is being sent to all property owners within four hundred (400) feet of the subject property.An opportunitywill be given at said hearings for all interested persons to be heard. Questions regarding this case may be directed to Alex Meyerhoff, Principal Planner, Department of Planning & Zoning, (760) 323-8245. MW6�J4 - Douglas k. Evans Director of Plannin and Zonin VICINITY MAP N f - �ar L 7—AtIOUtrZ CANYON WAY Q )F'AI.100 POAC) J SUNNY DUNES PD, L ` ^ t _ _ coNreo� GI7MINEI- ME50UIT�E � /fiVrNU� �� L.-OC/ir/ON CITY OF PALM SPRINGS CASE NO.: 5.935-PD-59 DESCRIPTION: Request for an amendment to Planned Development District 59, including the addition of classrooms, a APPLICANT: DESERT CHAPEL nursery, an administration building,and a new special events area,to regulate the time,place, and manner of special events, to consider the re-dedication of the Sunny Dunes Way right-of- way, and for final Planned Development District approval to construct an approximately 1,200 square foot storage building at 630 South Sunrise Way,Zone PD 59,Section 24. Public Hearing Notices Notification Information for Planning Commission Hearing on August 27, 2003 Case No. 5.935-PD-59 Applicant Name: Frank Marshall Desert Chapel 630 South Sunrise Way Palm Springs, CA 92262 Project Location & 630 South Sunrise Way, Palm Springs Description: Aan application by Desert Chapel for an amendment to Planned Development District 59, including the addition of classrooms, a nursery, an administration building, and a new special events area, to regulate the time, place, and manner of special events, to consider the re-dedication of the Sunny Dunes Way right-of-way, and for final Planned Development District approval to construct an approximate 1,200 square foot storage building at 630 South Sunrise Way, Palm Springs, CA., Zone PD 59, Section 24. Assigned Planner: Alex Meyerhoff, Principal Planner Labels Prepared by: First American Title Co. and Yoav Shernock, Planning Technician Certification to City Clerk Date: September 26, 2003 Property Owners / Groups / Date Notices Number of Notices Organizations Mailed Mailed Applicant/Sponsors August 14, 2003 3 Property Owners: Land Owner (master lessor) August 14, 2003 190 Master Lessor (sub-lessor) Sub-lessee (unit owner) 47 Indian Land Owners - BIA- 12 August 14, 2003 47 parcels notices for landowners of 47 APNS Neighborhood Coalition August 14, 2003 9 Homeowners Association ONIPP Agua Caliente Band of August 14, 2003 1 Cahuilla Indians Rep City Rep for Verification August 14, 2003 1 TOTAL NUMBER MAILED: 298 0.LlM SP �oF ♦c City of Palm Springs �'" •• ", ' Department of Planning & Zoning PlIF00.� MEMORANDUM Date: August 13, 2003 From: Yoav Shernock Planning Technician Subject: Mailing Labels for Notice of Public Hearing Planning Commission Case No. 5.935-PD-59 Desert Chapel Amendment to PDD This is to certify that the attached labels were created on June 10,2003 using the most current information available. To the best of my knowledge, the labels are complete and accurate. r 1l�1 Yoav S%hernock, Planning Technician August 13, 2003 :Idm 009 610 830 009110 832 009 10 834 City Of Palm S gs New Mesquite Development Assoc Ltd Rivers e ty Flood Control PO Box 2743 73080 El Pasco 199 i et St Palm Springs, C 263 Palm Desert,.CA 92260 Riversr e, A 92501 009 610 835 009 610 838 009 610 839 Dahoon Investment Co Dahoon ve cat Co D n Inv, tment Co 77200 California Dr 77200 Cal' 'a Dr 77200 ornia Dr Palm Desert, CA 92211 Palm Des , 92211 Palm se CA 92211 009 611 164 009 611 167 009 611 169 Suzanne Cowan Shackford Joseph E&Kaye Edmund&Lees Eva Birch 13833 Rose Dr Shackford 18 Saddle Rd San Leandro, CA 94578 PO Box 5454 Rancho Palos Verdes, CA 90275 Incline Village,NV 89450 009 611 171 009 611 173 009 611 174 Clinton Miller Jr. &Karen Miller Seymour Lippert&Marcia Lippert Betty Krengel PO Box 399 20030 Inverness Ct 944 Saint Bimini Cir#A Watsonville, CA 95077 Olympia Fields,IL 60461 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 611 176 009 611 179 009 611 180 Bert Atwater Paterson Jatren Management Ltd 16910 SE 58th St 25123 Smokewood Way 499 Dundas St W Trenton Bellevue,WA 98006 Newhall, CA 91381 ON CANADA 009 611 182 009 611 184 009 611 185 John Rock David Green&Susan Green Charles Madill 900 Saint Bimini Cir#A 915 Saint Bimini Cir#B 501-35 Newcastle Ave Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 NANAIMO BC V9S 4116 CANADA 009 611 188 009 611 190 009 611 195 Hoffe-isengerg Barbara Stark Jack Goodale&Aletha Goodale 937 Saint Bimini Cir#B 937 Saint Bimini Cir#A 10181 Kenowa Ave SW Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Springs, CA 92264 Grand Rapids,MI 49544 009 611 196 009 611 197 009 611 198 Viola Mcmillan Wilbert&Dorothy Kunz Marney Reed PO Box 200547 954 Arlene Dr#B 954 Arlene Dr#A Anchorage,AK 99520 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 611 200 009 611 202 009 611 203 Eugene&Jean Mary Bauer Charlotte Marie Spurgin Arlene Rosen 19 Catspaw Cpe 452 Pebble Beach Way PO Box 10775 Coronado, CA 92118 Eagle, ID 83616 Beverly Hills, CA 90213 009 611 205 009 611 206 009 611 208 Harrison Kevin H&Barbara J Kenron Melvin&Marie Alderman Kevin Harrison Jr. 955 Arlene Dr#B 110 Alcola Cir 906 Arlene Dr#A Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Desert, CA 92211 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 611 210 009 611212 009 611 848 Robert Neuman&Barbara Neuman Brian Ellis Elaine Crane Baird 999 Arlene Dr#B 999 Arlene Dr#A 911 Arlene Dr#B Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 611 849 009 611 850 009 611 851 Ron&Gina Youngren Ken Bell&Kathryn Bell Curry Robert A 12362 Fairway Pointe Row 14016 NE 63rd Ct PO Box 22777 San Diego, CA 92128 Redmond,WA 98052 Long Beach, CA 90801 009 611 852 009 611 853 009 611 854 Bernard&Helen Richter Jacklynn Ludwick E Randall Henderson Jr. 3285 Amethyst Dr 19725 SE 31st PI 2400 Crestmoor Rd Cameron Park, CA 95682 Issaquah,WA 98075 Nashville,TN 37215 009 611 855 009 611 856 009 611 857 Joan Huntsinger Charles Stephens&Doris Stephens Dale&Bettie Hendrickson 950 Saint George Cir#A 916 Saint George Cir#B 3416 24th Ave W Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Seattle,WA 98199 009 611 858 009 611 859 009 611 860 Felicia Trader&Helen Barney James Hudson&Cheryl Ann Hudson Chaim Bosnino 901 Saint George Cir#B PO Box 2810 921 Saint George Cir#B Palm Springs, CA 92264 Ventura, CA 93002 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 611 861 009 611862 009 611 863 Yvette Safargy John&Marilyn Mack Geraldine&Arron Korach 921 Saint George Cir#A 939 Saint George Cir#B 939 Saint George Cir#A Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 611 864 009 611 865 009 61 866 Thomas&Sharon Britz Wayne Guthrie III&Michael Geister New Me 'te Development Assoc Ltd 975 Saint George Cir#B PO Box 727 73080 EI seo Palm Springs, CA 92264 Kentfield,CA 94914 Palm De rt CA 92260 009 613 310 009 63t 1 New Mesquite Dev Assoc Ltd Dahoon I stment Co PO Box 1906 77200 Calif 'a Dr Palm Springs,CA 92263 Palm Dese 92211 502 460 001 502 460 002 502 460 003 Charles Thomas&John Sluyock James& Susan Odell Charles&Patricia Leviton PO Box 9077 1783 E Ramon Rd 1789 E Ramon Rd Palm Springs, CA 92263 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 004 502 460 005 502 460 006 Hamer Edgar E&Betty A Singer Mihata Rose E E&B 1752 E Camino Parocela 468 W Tahquitz Canyon Way 12501 Foster Rd Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Los Alamitos, CA 90720 502 460 007 502 460 008 502 460 009 Jack Atwell Richard Mcginness Matthew Tage 1748 E Camino Parocela 1742 E Camino Parocela#8 PO Box 132 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Sunset Beach, CA 90742 502 460 010 502 460 011 502 460 012 Inez Pullen Cecelia Spellman Marchick Sharon L&Marchick Sharo 1766 E Camino Parocela 750 N Palm Carryon Dr 1738 E Camino Parocela Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 013 502 460 014 502 460 015 Rooney A Alice Dennis Karen Powell 511 S Coast Highway 101 114 Aliso Dr 1728 E Camino Parocela Encinitas, CA 92024 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 016 502 460 017 502 460 018 Jefferson Hills Marion&Mary Valvo Shipe Lewis Glenn&James Spivey 1726 E Camino Parocela 1722 E Camino Parocela 1720 E Camino Parocela Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 019 502 460 020 502 460 021 Greg Kiper&Annette Kiper George Salvo&Gerald Salvo Richard Kief&Bell Kief 3822 242nd Ave SE 1716 E Camino Parocela 420 1712 E Camino Parocela Issaquah, WA 98029 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 022 502 460 023 502 460 024 Valdez Murray Paul Stoddard William Lovett Jr. &Arline Lovett 2420 NW 59th St 586 S Sunrise Way 14 Simpson St Miami,FL 33142 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Geneva,IL 60134 502 460 025 502 460 026 502 460 027 Carlston Emil&Velasquez-ruby Helman John Asher PO Box 7233 9602 Orange Ave 546 S Sunrise Way Carmel, CA 93921 Anaheim, CA 92804 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 028 502 460 029 502 460 030 Edward H Cunningham Scott&Erin Newcom Leograndis Stephen&Florence 552 N Sunrise Way#28 16824 Carlyle Hall Rd NW 14851 W Sunset Blvd Palm Springs, CA 92262 Seattle,WA 98177 Pacific Palisades, CA 90272 502 460 031 502 460 032 502 460 033 Norman Pliares Gloria Agee Wonderly Eric P 526 S Sunrise Way#31 15523 Vista Vicente Dr 26505 Briarwood Ln Palm Springs, CA 92264 Ramona, CA 92065 San Juan Capistrano, CA 92675 502 460 034 502 460 035 502 460 036 William Bowen Gregory&Geraldine Siverly Fernando Ramirez&Melissa Ramirez 506 S Sunrise Way 5811 N Drumheller St 1223 E Grovecenter St Palm Springs, CA 92264 Spokane,WA 99205 West Covina, CA 91790 502 460 037 502 460 038 502 460 039 Norman Freedberg Deanna Lawrence Cooper Lewis 226 N Palm Canyon Dr PO Box 942 1751 E Ramon Rd Palm Springs, CA 92262 Pine Valley, CA 91962 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 040 502 460 041 502 460 042 Alfred Kendall&Patricia Jea Orsatti Brenda Scott Shaun Lether 8348 Jason Ave 1761 E Ramon Rd#41 1765 E Ramon Rd West Hills,CA 91304 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 043 502 460 044 502 460 045 Joan Elizabeth Cheatham Donna Prada Lot Common 1775 E Ramon Rd 854 Diamond St 522 S Sepulveda Blvd 4110 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Monrovia, CA 91016 Los Angeles, CA 90049 502 560 001 502 560 005 502 560 009 SE Calif Assn Of 7th Day Adventists Desert Water Agency River e ounty Flood Cont PO Box 8050 PO Box 1710 1995 M et St Riverside, CA 92515 Palm Springs, CA 92263 Riversid , 92501 502 0 14 502 560 016 502 600 8 Usa 50 Riverside County Flood Cont Riversr Comity Flood Cont Unknow r 1995 Market St 1995 M or St , CA Riverside, CA 92501 Riversid , A 92501 502 560 020 502,.56P 025 502 60 33 Dahoon Investment Co Usa Usa 5 77200 California Dr Unkn S Ur kno� S Palm Desert, CA 92211 CA CA 502 0 0 4 502 60 038 502410039 Usa 50 Usa 5 U Unknow V Unklow 02-27-87 S UO2-27-87 S CA CA 502 5 04 502 561 001 502 561 002 Riversi ounty Flood Cont Whiteside Stephen L&D C Marilyn Ryding 1995 Mar St 2310 Nicolas Dr 2001 E Camino Parocela 42 Riverside, C 92501 Fullerton, CA 92833 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 561 003 502 561 004 502 561 005 Robert Kasting Ro mic Reichgelt&James Horan Ruth Ruiz 2001 E Camino Parocela#A3 839 W Lakeside PI 78520 Avenida La Fonda Palm Springs, CA 92264 Chicago, IL 60640 La Quinta, CA 92253 502 561 006 502 561 007 502 561 008 Kathleen Bill Timothy&Dawn Silva Andrew&Vicki Garbely PO Box 854 376 Virginia Dr 3536 NE Hancock St Manhattan Beach, CA 90267 Livermore, CA 94550 Portland, OR 97212 502 561 009 502 561 010 502561011 Richard Sears&Loretta Sears Jamie Roireau Overgaauw&Cornelius 810 NW 176th Ave 21515 Hawthorne Blvd#840 6143 Capetown St Beaverton,OR 97006 Torrance, CA 90503 Lakewood, CA 90713 502 561 012 502 561 013 502 561 014 Andres M Baric John&Margaret Mcglynn Barbara Kabus&Patricia Friesen 115 Pico Ave Peter 2001 E Camino Parocela#B 14 Pacific Grove, CA 93950 15196 SW Kenton Dr Palm Springs, CA 92264 Tigard, OR 97224 502 561 015 502 561 016 502 561 017 Joseph Massey&Maureen Massey Francine Heser I D&Gayle Weiner 2001 E Camino Parocela#C15 20109 Mildred Ave 28032 Sea Lane Dr Palm Springs, CA 92264 Torrance, CA 90503 Malibu, CA 90265 502 561 018 502 561 019 502 561 020 Donald Anderson&Arlene Rose Ande Stephen Morrow&April Barry Henry Alilovich 4813 Marblehead Bay Dr 2007 W Hedding St#100 2001 E Camino Parocela#C20 Oceanside, CA 92057 San Jose, CA 95128 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 561 021 502 561 022 502 561 023 William& Consuelo Gills Joseph Hughes John Jordan 8832 Sovereign Rd 2001 E Camino Parocela#C22 10080 W Suburban Or San Diego, CA 92123 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Miami,FL 33156 502 561 024 502 561 025 502 561 026 James&Becky Zopolis Roland&Mary Stewart Gus Stevenson&Leona Stevenson PO Box 2083 3275 Dogwood Dr S 3660 Bluebell St Palm Springs, CA 92263 Salem,OR 97302 Seal Beach, CA 90740 502 561 027 1 502 561 028 502 561 029 Jensen Mary Lou&Jensen Ruth Anderson Gregory&Monica Keelrfirss 226 WE St PO Box 652 7148 Wood Rd Ontario, CA 91762 Palm Springs, CA 92263 Riverside, CA 92506 502 561 030 502 561 031 502 561 032 Nicholas Tricarico Despina Papapetra Boyle Daniel B&Boyle Cathy A 6 Gravel Hill Ter 3262 N 94th St Boyle Kinnelon, NJ 07405 Milwaukee, WI 53222 31 Ticknor PI Laguna Niguel, CA 92677 r 502 561 033 502 561 034 502 561 035 Mcmillan Holdings Ltd Lambert Jack&Lambert Jack Leonard&Carrie Bart 4 650 Harrington Rd Kamloops 2001 E Camino Parocela#E34 2001 E Camino Parocela BC V213 6T7 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 CANADA 502 561 036 502 561 037 502 561 038 Ruel Longfellow&Mercedes Longfello Darell&Mary Schregardus Kent&Dorothy Roberts 21 Muriel Rd 1711 S Shore Dr 720 Greenway Ter Swampscott,MA 01907 Holland,MI 49423 La Habra, CA 90631 502 561 039 502 561 040 502 561 041 Joseph& Delores Young Jack Lambert Julius&Murnell Kummerman 21672 Kaiser Rd 2001 E Camino Parocela#F40 2001 E Camino Parocela#G41 Gregory, MI 48137 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 561 042 502 561 043 502 561 044 Phillip Rose Helmut Bauch Thush 21617 Woodland Crest Dr Birnauer Str 12 G-7750 Konstanz 4400 Hollingsworth Cir Woodland Hills, CA 91364 GERMANY Rohnert Park, CA 94928 502 561 045 502 561 046 502 561 047 Hobert& Colleen Herber Transport Sorenson Ladd 2001 E Camino Parocela#G45 PO Box 311 24813 Outlook Ct Palm Springs, CA 92264 Chehalis, WA 98532 Carmel, CA 93923 502 561 048 502 561 049 502 561 050 James& Sandra Giefer William&Tamaralee Cox E Budd&Paulette Simpson 3752 Village Ct 1032 Bayside Cv 135 Camellia Ct Saint Paul,MN 55125 Newport Beach, CA 92660 Upland, CA 91786 502 561 051 302 561 052 502 561 053 John&Nancy Todd Keudell David J&Keudell David J Michael Teagle 2001 E Camino Parocela#H51 1104 Main St#200 2001 E Camino Parocela#H53 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Vancouver,WA 98660 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 561 054 502 561 055 502 561 056 Jenkins Cheryl Agee&Glen Jenkins Lawrence&Lola Otoole Myron Filipoff 440 N Hayden Island Dr 17352 Rainglen Ln 20503 Shepherd Hills Dr Portland, OR 97217 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Walnut, CA 91789 502 561 057 502 561 058 502 561 059 Ferrari Donna&Ferrari Donna Bernard&Eugenia Bernacchi Cal-wai Properties 1675 Cherry Ave 176 Appletree Ave 6070 Calle De Prospero San Jose, CA 95125 Camarillo, CA 93012 San Jose, CA 95124 502 561 060 502 561 061 502 561 062 Michael Agee& Sherri Benetreu I D&Gayle Weiner Michael Torltan 386 SW 37th Cir 28032 Sea Lane Dr 38094 3rd St Gresham, OR 97080 Malibu, CA 90265 Fremont, CA 94536 502 561 063 502 561 064 502 561 065 Gerald Ford Chappelle Leroy A&Vera C&Chapp Betty Wasick 231 Avenida Majorca 43 2001 E Camino Parocela#I64 2001 E Camino Parocela 065 Laguna Hills, CA 92653 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Pahn Springs, CA 92264 502 561 066 502 561 067 502 561 068 Marie Bro Edward Bobbett&Martina Bobbett Gallagher Joseph A&P A 717 Strand St 1609 Beechwood Ave PO Box 401037 Santa Monica, CA 90405 Fullerton, CA 92835 Hesperia, CA 92340 502 561 069 502 561 070 502 561 071 Fred&Lupe Luevano Jr. Randy&Jennifer Price Paul&Kathryn Alle Goodman 1166 Arroyo Pacifica 2001 E Camino Parocela 070 PO Box 2127 Fallbrook,CA 92028 Palm Springs, CA 92264 La Habra, CA 90632 502 561 072 502 561 073 502 561 074 J Roger Grummett&Karleen Grummet Robert&Dorthea Pailthorp Joseph Wild II&Leroy Bontrager 4195 Lake Shore Dr PO Box 713 761 Hillpine Ter NE Ameau, AK 99801 Depoe Bay,OR 97341 Atlanta, GA 30306 502 561 075 502 561 076 502 561 077 John Doininge&Ernest Sabo Gray Leslie M&Helen Adina Arthur Macmillan 4663 Vista St Leslie&Helen Gray 2001 E Camino Parocela#K77 San Diego,CA 92116 1112 Rio Cidade Way Palm Springs, CA 92264 Sacramento, CA 95831 502 561 078 502 561 079 502 561 080 Akin Robert D Stanley Mallard&Scott Mcdonald Henry Basile&Jody Basile PO Box 2542 2001 E Canino Parocela 2244 13th Ave W#403 Wrightwood, CA 92397 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Seattle, WA 98119 502 561 081 502 561 082 502 561 083 Patti Lee Phillips&James Waydelich D Dean&Mary Wmgham William&Phyllis Stewart 1752 Miramar Dr 10041 Echo Dr 4797 W Phillips St Newport Beach, CA 92661 Brookville, IN 47012 Ontario, CA 91762 502 561 084 502 561 085 502 561 086 Gordon&Marcia Thompson Marilyn Milman Laurie&Michael Bardkas 16215 NE Eugene Ct 2001 E Camino Parocela#L85 Morgan&Barba Bardkas Portland, OR 97230 Palm Springs, CA 92264 675 S Sierra Ave 428 Solana Beach, CA 92075 502 561 087 502 561 088 502 561 089 Sydney& Ann Ackerman Novy Ronald R&Novy Ronald R&D Holum Bradley Wayne 2001 E Camino Parocela#L87 7284 Cedarwood PI 1136 Cortez Ave Palm Springs, CA 92264 Highland, CA 92346 Burlingame, CA 94010 502 561 090 502 561 091 502 561 092 George Goy Charles Leroy Hansen Doolittle Norman P&Doolittle 1909 Shell Ave 2001 E Camino Parocela#M91 2001 E Camino Parocela#M92 Venice, CA 90291 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 e 502 561 093 502 561 094 502 561 095 Howard&Sonja Hoch Timothy Leary&Stuart Berger John&Norma Marrin 952 W Cumberland St 1359 25th Ave 1225 Cajon St Upland, CA 91786 San Francisco, CA 94122 Redlands, CA 92373 502 561 096 502 561 097 502 561 098 Norman Harvey&Mary Patricia Haako V T Deremer Jr. Felix&Mary Loud Jumonville Jr. 812 Dalewood Ln 2001 E Camino Parocela#N97 2001 E Camino Parocela#N98 VICTORIA BC Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 CANADA 502 561 099 502 562 001 502 562 002 Michael Gee&Phillip Hager Brian&Roslyn Lloyd Diana Meyer 9401 Castlewood St 404 E 13th St 2001 E Camino Parocela#101 Oakland, CA 94605 Vancouver,WA 98660 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 562 003 502 562 004 502 562 005 Lester Gamet&M R Marlene Lucretia Wolilgemuth Muriel Bell 1227 NW Norcross Way 2001 E Camino Parocela#N103 19191 Harvard Ave 9404 Seattle, WA 98177 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Irvine, CA 92612 502 562 006 502 562 007 502 562 008 Richard Schlegel James Odell Scott John Parker&S Co-trustees Marilyn 2001 E Camino Parocela 40105 22962 Orangewood Ct 15120 Mar Vista St Palm Springs, CA 92264 Grand Terrace, CA 92313 Whittier, CA 90605 502 562 009 502 562 010 502 562 011 Gonzalez Angel& Grace Villa Patricia Boren Crestline Inv Group Inc 731 IlifP St 1609 Michael Ln Michele Artukovich Pacific Palisades, CA 90272 Pacific Palisades, CA 90272 4417 E Village Rd Long Beach, CA 90808 502 562 012 502 562 013 502 562 014 Vincent&Brenda Nardolillo Russel& Sheila Hamelin Margaret Levinson 6462 E Via Arboles 1159 W Molly Ct 2001 E Camino Parocela Anaheim, CA 92807 Upland, CA 91786 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 562 015 502 562 016 502 562 017 Maria Oms Randal&Sally Jo Largent Ardean William&Marla Jean Ladd 2008 Calle Francesca 15114 206th Ave SE 12710 Spindlewood Dr San Dimas, CA 91773 Renton,WA 98059 La Mirada, CA 90638 502 562 018 502 562 019 502 562 020 Darlene Ruth Rockey Ira Golchehreh&D B Carolita Elke Jast 2001 E Camino Parocela#Q117 15 Madeline Ln 611 S Palm Canyon Dr#260 Palm Springs, CA 92264 San Rarael, CA 94901 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 562 021 502 562 022 502 562 023 John Kanocz&Patricia Kanocz Barbara Mckenna Arthur Gittelman&Rosemary Gittelm 2001 E Camino Parocela#Q120 2001 E Camino Parocela#Q121 3300 Darby Rd 43208 Palm Springs,CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Haverford,PA 19041 502 562 024 502 562 025 502 562 026 Henderson Roy&Frances Carol Robert&Marion Dahlgren Jan Stamps Roy&France Henderson 2001 E Camino Parocela#Q124 PO Box 1953 113 N Equestrian Way Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92263 Prescott, AZ 86303 502 562 027 502 562 028 502 562 029 Usa 502 Usa Bin Usa Bin Unknown S Unknown 01-05-1998 S Unknown 11-07-97 S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 030 502 562 031 502 562 032 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa Bia Unknown 5 Unknown S Unknown 11-23-98 S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 033 502 562 034 502 562 035 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 036 502 562 037 502 562 038 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown 04-24-97 S Unknown 04-29-98 S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 039 502 562 040 502 562 041 Usa Bia Usa Bin Usa 502 Unknown 08-28-98 S Unknown 12-07-1999 S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 042 502 562 043 502 562 044 Usa Bia Usa Bin Usa 502 Unknown 04-17-98 S Unknown 08-03-98 S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 045 502 562 046 502 562 047 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 048 502 562 049 502 562 050 Usa Bia Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown 10-13-98 S Unknown S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 051 502 562 052 502 562 054 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 05-21-97 S Unknown S CA CA CA n 502 562 055 502 562 056 502 562 057 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown 11-30-98 S Unknown 06-06-97 S Unknown 11-03-97 S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 058 502 562 059 502 562 060 Usa Bin Usa Bia. Usa Bia Unknown 05-10-2001 S Unknown 11-08-95 S Unknown S , CA ,CA , CA 502 562 061 502 562 062 502 562 063 Usa 502 Usa Bin Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 01-05-1999 Unknown S , CA ,CA , CA 502 562 064 502 562 065 502 562 066 Usa 502 Usa 502 Hudson Unknown S Unknown S 1194 Kingston Ln , CA , CA Ventura, CA 93001 502 562 067 502 562 068 502 562 069 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown S Unknown 12-29-1998 S Unknown 05-18-98 S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 070 502 562 071 502 562 072 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 01-02-2002 S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 073 502 562 074 502 562 075 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 508 240 007 508 240 008 508 240 009 Riverside Co ty lood Cent 555 Sunrise Randall W Guy Llc&Lisa Guy Lic 1995 Market St 1555 S Palm Canyon Dr 40106 PO Box 950 Riverside, CA 2501 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Indianola,WA 98342 508 240 010 508 271 010 508271011 International Church Four Square Gosp Edward Taggart Acme Boukidis 630 S Sunrise Way 1629 E Sumiy Dunes Rd 2469 S Caliente Rd Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 508 271 012 508 271 013 508 271 014 David Joseph Testa Noble Willingham&Willingham Anne Clarke PO Box 5504 69 Asilomar Rd 1654 E San Lucas Rd Palm Springs, CA 92263 Laguna Niguel, CA 92677 Palm Springs, CA 92264 508 271 015 508 272 010 508 272 011 Daniel Smith&K B Kandi Kim Chasen&Marian Moiseyev Jack Warren&Emilie Warren 2654 Crowthorne Ct 1627 E San Lucas Rd 1653 E San Lucas Rd Vista, CA 92084 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 508 272 012 508 272 013 508 272 014 Chi&Frances Chung Hernandez Gus&J Laurie Starm 362 S Palm Canyon Dr 1672 N Riverside Dr 1650 N Riverside Dr Palm Springs, CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 508 272 015 508 73 2 508 281 012 Larry Kast River ' County Flood Cont Housing&Finance Agency Corp 1626 N Riverside Dr 1995 rket St 801 S Sunrise Way Palm Springs, CA 92264 River nde, CA 92501 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Neighborhood Coalition List MR PETER DIXON MR BILL DAVIS AND Case 5.935-PD-59 431 SOUTH MONTE VISTA DRIVE MS TRISHA DAVIS Applicant: Desert Chapel PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 227 SOUTH CAHUILLA P.C. Hearing for August 27, 03 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 MR FRANK TYSEN MR JOHN HURTER MR BOB WEITHORN C/O CASA CODY COUNTRY INN PO BOX 2824 261 SOUTH BELARDO ROAD 175 SOUTH CAHUILLA ROAD PALM SPRINGS CA 92263-2824 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 MR TIM HOHMEIER MR BOB SEALE MR PHIL TEDESCO 1387 CALLE DE MARIA 280 CAMINO SUR 1303 WEST PRIMAVERA DRIVE PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 MR MARSHALL ROATH MS MARGARET PARK MS SHERYL HAMLIN AGUA CALIENTE BAND OF AGUA CALIENTE BAND OF 565 WEST SANTA ROSA DRIVE CAHUILLA INDIANS =J-J =;)4-0 =J CAHUILLA INDIANS PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 650 E TAHQUITZ CANYON WAY PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 CITY OF PALM SPRINGS VERIFICATION NOTICE =J-J PLANNING &ZONING DEPT ATTN: SENIOR SECRETARY PO BOX 2743 PALM SPRINGS CA 92263-2743 SPONSORS =o DESERT CHAPEL 630 SOUTH SUNRISE WAY 4. PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 MR FRANK MARSHALL Christopher S. Mills Architect, Inc. C/O DESERT CHAPEL 1255 E. Ramon Road 630 SOUTH SUNRISE WAY PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 4 pALM SA City of Palm Springs .X �'c Department of Planning & Zoning 3200 East Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, CA 92262 Telephone: 7 6 0-323.8 245 c-1L I POOO Fax: 760-322-8360 E-mail: LorettaM@ci.palm-springs.cams F A X TRANSMISSION Date: August 13, 2003 To: Claudia Salgado and Arvada Wilson Bureau of Indian Affairs From: Loretta Moffett, Senior Secretary Planning Department Subject: August 27, 2003 Planning Commission Hearings Cases: 5.935-PD-59 - Desert Chapel 5.0870-PD-268 - Ernest G. Nola's Indian Oasis Resort 3.2378 /TTM 31495 -Amado Road & Hermosa Drive Good morning Claudia and Arvada! Here are the APN numbers for Indian landowners within the 400' radius of the above-referenced projects who need to be notified of the August 27, 2003 Planning Commission Hearings. Case No. 5.935-PD-59 (Desert Chapel).' (12 Notices enclosed for Indian Landowners 502-560-014 502-560-025 502-560-033 502-560-034 502-560-038 502-560-039 See two pages attached for additional 47 APN numbers. Case No. 5.0870-PD-268 (Indian Oasis Resort): (15 notices enclosed for Indian landowners) 4 pages attached with 84 APN parcel numbers. Case No. 3.2378 /TTM 31495 (Amado Hermosa LLC): (4 notices enclosed) 508-550-052 508-550-069 508-071-006 We ask that you expedite mailing these notices to the appropriate landowners as soon as possible. If you need more notices or postage paid envelopes, please call me at 323-8245 and I will bring them over. Your assistance is always appreciated. Many thanks to you both! 502 562 027 502 562 028 502 562 029 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa Bin Unknown S Unknown 01-05-1998 S Unknown 11-07-97 S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 030 502 562 031 502 562 032 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa Bia Unknown S Unknown S Unknown 11-23-98 S CA CA CA 502 562 033 502 562 034 502 562 035 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S CA CA CA i 502 562 036 502 562 037 502 562 038 Usa Bia Usa Bin Usa 502 Unknown 04-24-97 S Unknown 04-29-98 S Unknown S 1 , CA CA CA 502 562 039 502 562 040 502 562 041 Usa Bin Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown 08-28-98 S Unknown 12-07-1999 S Unknown S ,CA , CA , CA 502 562 042 502 562 043 502 562 044 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown 04-17-98 S Unknown 08-03-98 S Unknown S ,CA ,CA ,CA 502 562 045 502 562 046 502 562 047 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 048 502 562 049 502 562 050 Usa Bia Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown 10-13-98 S Unknown S Unknown S ,CA CA , CA 502 562 051 502 562 052 502 562 054 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 05-21-97 S Unknown S CA „ CA CA Case 5.935 502 562 055 502 562 056 502 562 057 Usa Bin Usa Bin Usa Bin Unknown 11-30-98 S Unknown 06-06-97 S Unknown 11-03-97 S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 058 502 562 059 502 562 060 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown 05-10-2001 S Unknown 11-08-95 S Unknown S CA CA CA i 502 562 061 502 562 062 1 302 562 063 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 01-05-1999 S Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 064 502 562 065 502 562 066 Usa502 Usa 502 Hudson Unknown S Unknown S 1194 Kingston Ln CA CA Ventura, CA 93001 502 562 067 502 562 068 502 562 069 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown S Unknown 12-29-1998 S Uniniown 05-18-98 S , CA , CA ,CA 502 562 070 502 562 071 502 562 072 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 01-02-2002 S unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 073 502 562 074 502 562 075 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 unknown S Unknown S Unknown S CA CA CA i fi 3 we c�,dr Sps 27 f�FrJ�r' l �d 690b10 , il013 Lys s�oit�ai.Rdal�`� W " + 2677 CITE'COUNCIL OF PALM SPRINGS 3200 E. TA14QUITZ CANYON WAY PALM SPRINGS, CA January 21, 2004 HONORABLE COUNCIL MEMBERS Please know that I the undersigned to hereby lodge my protest against any change to the current Planned Development District 59 or its master plan. Desert Chapel would not be a neighborhood friendly partner in controlling noise, traffic and general nuisance as they would not be accountable to permit regulations and requirements, which currently safeguard the neighborhood. Especially, those residences physically close to the proposed building additions and unregulated activities would have their property values lowered and we would seek legal remedy against the city for any such damage both actual and punitive as might be prescribed by law. I sincerely urge the city council to make the right decision in this matter and not allow further development as requested in this change. Additionally, to safeguard the sanctity of the neighborhood and not allow the city's current power of permit of functions to fall to Desert Chapel, Respectfully Submitted, / .! ' -/ _.. L� r� Michael H. Connors 801 S. Sunrise Way Palm Springs, CA 92264 760-320-1163 f� To: Ionorable Mayor and City Council Members From: Arthur MacMillan 2001 Camino Parocela K77 Patin Springs, Ca. 92264 (Mesquite Country Club Phase III) Re: Desert Chapel Hearing Case#5.935-PD-59 Dear Honorable Mayor and Council Members: I am a fifteen year frill time resident at my current address at Mesquite Country Club. Back in 1999, I had major concerns about the expansion of Desert Chapel, which would take over land that was previously owned by Sunrise Nursery. The site plan showed that a playing field was going to be constructed very close to my living room and bedroom windows. I addressed the Council during hearings at that time regarding my concerns about anticipated noise, especially evening noise. I was assured by the Planning Dept. and by the City Council that this was going to be constructed only as a daytime playing field and that controls were in place to NOT turn it into a football field. The master plan was written prohibiting Desert Chapel from holding evening football games. The plaiming commission minutes dated August 27, 2003, stated that Commissioner Matthews remembered back in 1999 that Desert Chapel was NOT going to have a football field and that this was passed on to the concerned homeowners. Safeguards for the neighborhood were written into the plan: Condition 40: No public address system shall be allowed except for emergency purposes. Condition 17: All lighting shall be in accordance with the City's non glare standards. All unpermitted night lighting shall be removed. Condition 38: The oleander screening along the northern property line shall be maintained to the satisfaction of the Director of Planning and Building. The minimum height at trimming shall be seven (7) feet. All dead plants shall be replaced with mature hedge material with a minimtmi height of seven (7) feet. Condition 39: Evening outdoor activities at the subject site shall cease at 10:00 PM, tmless special time extensions are granted by the Director of Planning and Building and/or the Chief of Police. Condition 42: the location of trash enclosure is acceptable subject to approved construction details. Now, several years have passed. Desert Chapel now has a history and the plarming commission file on Desert Chapel is chock full of evidence that the Church has never followed the above conditions, still refused to follow the above conditions when the neighbors went to them asking them to comply, and STILL refused to follow the above conditions when the City (Planning Commission) approached the church warning them to follow the above conditions, or face action by the City. It is documentediin your � file by Mr. Evans that some Desert Chapel noise (as in their concerts) can be heard over 1.25 miles from the church. And just imagine, I live eighty (80) feet from their property line. So whats the solution? Well, if your Mr. Mills with cormections to the City Planning Dept.,and church member and architect of the church, you simply tell Desert Chapel "just approach the City to have your master plan revised so that all your violations can now be permitted and we'll take care of it... that should make the neighbors go away." I say: Oh no, it's not business as usual at City Hall anymore and the citizens are tired of their voices not being heard and addressed. This Desert Chapel situation is not much different from what happened at Araby Cove and should be examined and addressed in the same way the new City Council addressed the Araby Cove issue. For the record, Mr. Frank Marshal at the Planning Commission meetings stated "I can't be responsible for what happens on church property in the evening." Commissioner Mathews quickly responded and said he didn't buy that answer and Mr. Marshall better hire a security guard at night. (by the way, new Council members will not find these comments in the minutes of the meeting-they were oddly omitted, but viewing the video will confirm my statement. Has Mr. Marshall taken the city seriously and become responsible for what happens on his property? Just this January 3`d, it was after 1030 pm when I grew tired of listending to yelling and screaming coming from the church property. I dressed and walked over to the school and was appalled to find a dozen youths literally climbing up the outside wall of the three story multi purpose building, making then way to the roof, using the aluminum air conditioning vents as a ladder. Once up near the roof, they secured a rope to a air conditioning vent which sloped down towards the football field where it was secured to a football touchdown goal post. The students were jumping off the three story building and riding the rope using pulleys down towards the football field with absolutely no protection tinder them in case they fell onto a d1W*1W fence or the ground below. For the record, the students were being coaxed to jump by Pastor Houston, again the only Desert Chapel supervisor on the property. Another recent occurrance is Mr. Marshall is fully aware he's not to use unpernutted nighttime lighting. On 10/6/03 the football lights were on in the field to allow for the construction of floats throughout the evening for the homecoming parade. Diane Fletcher, in charge of those students stated she was told by Mr. Frank Marshall to use the football lights so that they could construct the floats. It was 1 OPm when I asked that the lights be turned off. Mr. Marshall also knows he's not supposed to be having any more outdoor concerts. On December 21, 2003. a concert was held in the outer courtyard of the church just adjacent to our bedroom windows, which created a echo effect as the loudspeakers and amplification system bellowed the music into the windows of our homes. As in the case of all their past concerts, neighbors have to endure the stage set up, amplified rehearsal sessions and finally the concert itself. Mr. Marshall refuses to understand that this concert could easily have been held inside the walls of the multi purpose building which is what this large building was constructed for.....to "contain" the noise of the school's student activities. Another point.....Desert Chapel has had FOUR YEARS to follow a simple Condition 38 and install live shrubs at a minimum of seven (7) feet along the border of their property that abuts our condos. Only recently (a few months ago) at the insistence of Mr. Evans, the church began to work on this area. The area of the shrubs near my condo still does not meet this condition. A view of the shrubbery from the Mesquite side is absolutely deplorable and has to be seen to be believed. When the church has overflow trash, it is stacked against the fence near my condo (against Condition#42). Please reference two previously submitted photos showing church trash under my condo windows. When Mr. Frank Marshall spoke at the Sept. 10, 2003 planning commission hearing, the one continent he made in response to the many complaints heard that day was that lie can't be all that bad, that the President of the Mesquite HOA called him and asked him to please not have the gardeners working with blowers on the church property before 6AM and that he was now complying with this request. If the Council will please read a letter in your file addressed to you by Mr/Mrs. Gru mnett dated 1/21/04 where they state the school still uses leaf blowers at 5AM. By the way, the President of the HOA at Mesquite has since moved out-being unable to tolerate living next to the church. For the record, since 1999, out of sixteen (16) Mesquite condos that are closest to Desert Chapel, twelve (12) homeowners have sold and moved out. (I am referring to the"K" and "L" buildings that contain 8 units each). Some of these condos have been sold more than once as homeowners quickly sell and move out, being unable to live with current Desert Chapel conditions. On any given day, the neighbors of Desert Chapel must endure concerts, carnivals, football games, weekend late night youth hangouts until 2:00 AM. Sunday morning live band practice at 8:00 am (this is every Sunday), leaf blowers at 5:00 AM and Monday thru Friday, youths being dropped off at the fence nearest our windows just after 7:00 AM where they play until the 8:00 bell goes off, followed by outdoor recess throughout the day. The weekend of January 3`d, a truck dropped off large blocks of ice/snow after 6PM (on the North side of Sunny Dunes near our condos) and 50 youths were invited to play in the snow until 9PM. I ask the Council, is this a Church and a school or should Desert Chapel be renamed Palm Springs Sports Stadium and Community Center? We, the neighbors of Desert Chapel can assure you that we are not against youths or Churches or Schools. However the facts show that the Chapel is unwilling or incapable of following City guidelines for noise and light pollution. I therefore recommend that prior to any Council approval of church expansion, that the school 1) Immediately cease all evening football games at their site as specified in the original master plan and promised to the surrounding neighbors. 2) Comply with City codes regarding lighting and noise ordinances. 3) Keep their security guard on duty 24/7 to prevent violations from occurring. { 4) That the City not allow the approval of a new special event area on the Northern side of church property eight (80) feet from our homes. 5) That the City demand that Desert Chapel relocate the 7AM children drop off point and play area away from the Northern side of their property to the Southern side, away from our homes. Council members, what you are being asked to approve tonight is a serious concern for neighbors of the school. Your decision will be permanent and forever is a long long time. I stand before you not only for myself but for those Desert Chapel neighbors that will follow me in the years and decades to come. Thank you and goodnight. J AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF RIVERSIDE ) I,the undersigned,say: I am and was at all times herein mentioned, a citizen of the United States and employed in the County of Riverside, over the age of eighteen years, and not a party to the within action or proceeding; that my business address is 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Drive, Palm Springs, California; that on the 141" day of November, 2003, 1 served the within NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING for PLANNING COMMISSION CASE NO. 5.935-PD-59 to consider An application by Desert Chapel for an amendment to Planned Development District 59 to considerthe re-dedication of the Sunny Dunes Way right-of-way at 630 South Sunrise Way, Zone PD 59, Section 24. This Notice was served on persons contained in Exhibit "A" attached hereto in said action or proceeding by depositing a true copy thereof, enclosed in a sealed envelope with postage thereon fully prepaid, in a mailbox, sub-post office, substation or mail chute, or other like facility, regularly maintained by the Government of the United States in the City of Palm Springs,California, addressed to the list of persons or firms indicated on the report dated June 10, 2003, and certified by the City's Planning Technician, and attached hereto as Exhibit"A". I hereby declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Lore D. Moffett Dated at Palm Springs, California, this 14th day of November 14, 2003 COURTESY NOTICE NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING PLANNING COMMISSION Case No. 5.935-PD-59 An application by Desert Chapel for an amendment to Planned Development District 59 to consider the re-dedication of the Sunny Dunes Way right-of- way, at 630 South Sunrise Way, Zone PD 59, Section 24. This is a courtesy notice that the Planning Commission of the City of Palm Springs, California, will hold a public hearing at its meeting of November 26, 2003. The Planning Commission meeting begins at 1:30 p.m., (public hearings begin at 2:00 p.m.), in the City Council Chamber at City Hall, 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way, Palm Springs, California. The purpose of the hearing is to consider an application by Desert Chapel for an amendment to Planned Development District 59 to consider the re-dedication of the Sunny Dunes Way right-of- way. The applicant requests that the City accept the dedication of forty-four (44) feet of right-of- way, for public circulation purposes, for a six hundred (600) foot long segment of Sunny Dunes Way, east of Sunrise Way. The property in question is located at 630 South Sunrise Way, Zone PD 59, Section 24. Pursuant to Section 15070 of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines, a Mitigated Negative Declaration was adopted by the City Council in 1999. The proposed application, site plan, and related documents are available for public review daily, between 8 am and 5 pm at the City of Palm Springs in the Planning and Zoning Department, located at 3200 Tahquitz Canyon Way. If any individual or group challenges the action in court, issues raised may be limited to only those issues raised at the public hearings described in this notice or in written correspondence at or prior to the Commission meeting. Notice of Public Hearing is being sent to all property owners within four hundred (400) feet of the subject property.An opportunity will be given at said hearings for all interested persons to be heard. Questions regarding this case may be directed to Alex Meyerhoff, Principal Planner, Department of Planning & Zoning, (760) 323-8245. Douyla . Evans Director of Planning and Zoning VICINITY MAP N rAtIOUrrz GAWON W/V � w w Q PANON I I'OfiD 5UNW DUNfS PO, \ p/ue15r0 — — — _ GONTIZOL � GhMINEL N�SC)Ul r� AVCNUl PPO. C07- 1.00APON CITY OF PALM SPRINGS CASE NO.: 5.935-PD-59 DESCRIPTION: Request for an amendment to Planned Development District 59, including the addition of classrooms, a APPLICANT: DESERT CHAPEL nursery,an administration building, and a new special events area,to regulate the time, place, and manner of special events, to consider the re-dedication of the Sunny Dunes Way right-of- way, and for final Planned Development District approval to construct an approximately 1,200 square foot storage building at 630 South Sunrise Way,Zone PD 59,Section 24. Public Hearing Notices Notification Information for Planning Commission Hearing on November 26, 2003 Case No. 5.935-PD-59 Applicant Name: Frank Marshall Desert Chapel 630 South Sunrise Way Palm Springs, CA 92262 Project Location & 630 South Sunrise Way, Palm Springs Description: An application by Desert Chapel for an amendment to Planned Development District 59 to consider the re-dedication of the Sunny Dunes Way right-of-way at 630 South Sunrise Way, Zone PD 59, Section 24. Assigned Planner: Alex Meyerhoff, Principal Planner Labels Prepared by: First American Title Co. and Yoav Shernock, Planning Technician Certification to City Clerk Date: November 17, 2003 Property Owners / Groups / Date Notices Number of Notices Organizations Mailed Mailed Applicant/Sponsors November 14, 2003 3 Property Owners: Land Owner (master lessor) November 14, 2003 150 Master Lessor (sub-lessor) Sub-lessee (unit owner) 39 Indian Land Owners - BIA- 12 November 14, 2003 47 parcels notices for landowners of 47 APNS Neighborhood Coalition November 14, 2003 9 Homeowners Association 1 ONIPP N/A Agua Caliente Band of November 14, 2003 1 Cahuilla Indians Rep City Rep for Verification November 14, 2003 1 Other Interested parties November 14, 2003 g TOTAL NUMBER MAILED: 259 tI.LM SA OF T City of Palm Springs �'`•M •`�" Department of Planning & Zoning �p FO0.N MEMORANDUM Date: November 14, 2003 From: Yoav Shernock Planning Technician Subject: Mailing Labels for Notice of Public Hearing Planning Commission Case No. 5.935-PD-59 Desert Chapel Amendment to PDD This is to certify that the attached labels were created on June 10, 2003 using the most current information available. To the best of my knowledge, the labels are complete and accurate. Yoav Shernock, Planning Technician November 13, 2003 :ldm 009 610 830 009 610 832 009 10 834 City Of Palm S gs New Mes Development Assoc Ltd Rivers e ty Flood Control PO Box 2743 73080 El P eo 1995 et St Palm Springs, C 263 Palm Des A 92260 Riversi e, A 92501 009 610 835 009 610 838 009 610 839 Dahoon Investment Co Dahoo ve tent Co D n Inv tment Co 77200 California Dr 77200 C 'a Dr 77200 ornia Dr Palm Desert, CA 92211 Palm Des 92211 Palm*seX CA 92211 0"611 1 4 009 611 167 009 611 169 Suzanne Co Shackford Joseph E&Kaye Edmund&Lees Eva Birch 13833 Rose Shackford 18 Saddle Rd San Leandro 94578 PO Box 5454 Rancho Palos Verdes, CA 90275 Incline Village,NV 89450 009 611 171 009 611 173 009 611 174 Clinton Miller Jr. &Karen Miller Seymour Lippert&Marcia Lippert Betty Krengel PO Box 399 20030 Inverness Ct 944 Saint Bimini Cir#A Watsonville, CA 95077 Olympia Fields,IL 60461 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 611 176 009 611 179 009 611 180 Bert Atwater Paterson Jatren Management Ltd 16910 SE 58th St 25123 Smokewood Way 499 Dundas St W Trenton Bellevue,WA 98006 Newhall, CA 91381 ON CANADA 009 611 182 009 611 184 009 611 185 John Rock David Green&Susan Green Charles Madill 900 Saint Bimini Cir#A 915 Saint Bimini Cir#B 501-35 Newcastle Ave Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 NANAIMO BC V9S 4116 CANADA 009 611 188 009 61 190 009 611 195 Hoffe-isengerg Barbarakk Jack Goodale&Aletha Goodale 937 Saint Bimini Cir#B 937 SainniCir#A 10181 Kenowa Ave SW Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm SpCA 92264 Grand Rapids,MI 49544 009 611 196 009 611 197 009 611 198 Viola Mcmillan Wilbert&Dorothy Kunz Marney Reed PO Box 200547 954 Arlene Dr#B 954 Arlene Dr#A Anchorage,AK 99520 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 611 200 009 611 202 009 611 203 Eugene&Jean Mary Bauer Charlotte Marie Spurgin Arlene Rosen 19 Catspaw Cpe 452 Pebble Beach Way PO Box 10775 Coronado, CA 92118 Eagle,ID 83616 Beverly Hills, CA 90213 009 611 05 ' 009 611 06 009 611 208 Harrison n H&Barbara J Keoron Melvin&Marie Alderman Kevin Harri Jr. 955 Arlene r#B 110 Alcola Cir 906 Arlene r Palm Spri gs, A 92264 Palm Desert, CA 92211 Palm Spring , CA 92264 009 611 210 009 611 212 009 611 849 Robert Neuman&Barbara Neuman Brian Ellis Elaine Crane Baird 999 Arlene Dr#B 999 Arlene Dr#A 911 Arlene Dr#B Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 611 849 009 611 850 009 611 851 Ron&Gina Youngren Ken Bell&Kathryn Bell Curry Robert A 12362 Fairway Pointe Row 14016 NE 63rd Ct PO Box 22777 San Diego, CA 92128 Redmond,WA 98052 Long Beach, CA 90801 009 611 852 009 611 853 009 611 854 Bernard&Helen Richter Jacklynn Ludwick E Randall Henderson Jr. 3285 Amethyst Dr 19725 SE 31st PI 2400 Crestmoor Rd Cameron Park, CA 95682 Issaquah,WA 98075 Nashville,TN 37215 009 611 855 00961 856f 009 611 857 Joan Huntsinger Charles a hens&Doris Stephens Dale&Bettie Hendrickson 950 Saint George Cir#A 916 Saint eorge Cir#B 3416 24th Ave W Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Spri g ,,CA 92264 Seattle,WA 98199 009 611 858 009 611 859 009 61 86 Felicia Trader&Helen Barney James Hudson&Cheryl Ann Hudson Chaim no 901 Saint George Cir#B PO Box 2810 921 Sain eorge Cir#B Palm Springs, CA 92264 Ventura, CA 93002 Palm Sp 'n , CA 92264 009 611 61 009 611 862 009 611 863 Yvetie S gy John&Marilyn Mack Geraldine&Arron Korach 921 Saint rge Cir#A 939 Saint George Cir#B 939 Saint George Cir#A Palm Sp ' gs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 009 611 864 009 611 865 009 6111866 Thomas&Sharon Britz Wayne Guthrie III&Michael Geister New Me to Development Assoc Ltd 975 Saint George Cir#B PO Box 727 73080 El sea Palm Springs, CA 92264 Kentfield, CA 94914 Pahn De rt, CA 92260 009 613 310 009 61 11 New Mesquite Dev Assoc Lid Dahom- stment Co PO Box 1906 77200 Cali* 'a Dr Palm Springs, CA 92263 Palm Des-4 92211 4 9 502 460 001 502 460 002 502 460 003 Charles Thomas&Jolm Sluyock James&Susan Odell Charles&Patricia Leviton PO Box 9077 1783 E Ramon Rd 1789 E Ramon Rd Palm Springs, CA 92263 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 004 502 460 005 502 460 006 Hamer Edgar E&Betty A Singer Mihata Rose E E&B 1752 E Camino Parocela 468 W Talrquitz Canyon Way 12501 Foster Rd Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Los Alamitos, CA 90720 502 460 007 502 460 008 502 460 009 Jack Atwell Richard Mcgimiess Matthew Tage 1748 E Camino Parocela 1742 E Camino Parocela 48 PO Box 132 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Sunset Beach, CA 90742 502 460 010 502 460 011 502 460 012 Inez Pullen Cecelia Spellman Marchick Sharon L&Marchick Share 1766 E Camino Parocela 750 N Palm Canyon Dr 1738 E Camino Parocela Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 013 502 460 014 502 460 015 Rooney A Alice Dennis Karen Powell 511 S Coast Highway 101 114 Aliso Dr 1728 E Camino Parocela Encinitas, CA 92024 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 016 502 460 017 502 460 018 Jefferson Hills Marion&Mary Valvo Shipe Lewis Glenn&James Spivey 1726 E Camino Parocela 1722 E Camino Parocela 1720 E Camino Parocela Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 019 502 460 020 502 460 021 Greg Kiper&Annette Kiper George Salvo&Gerald Salvo Richard Kief&Bell Kief 3822 242nd Ave SE 1716 E Camino Parocela 420 1712 E Camino Parocela Issaquah, WA 98029 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 022 502 460 023 502 460 024 Valdez Murray Paul Stoddard William Lovett Jr. &Arline Lovett 2420 NW 59th St 586 S Sunrise Way 14 Simpson St Miami, FL 33142 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Geneva,IL 60134 302 460 025 502 460 026 502 460 027 Carlston Emil&Velasquez-ruby Helman John Asher PO Box 7233 9602 Orange Ave 546 S Sunrise Way Carmel, CA 93921 Anaheim, CA 92804 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 028 502 460 029 502 460 030 Edward H Cunningham Scott&Erin Newcom Leograndis Stephen&Florence 552 N Sunrise Way 428 16824 Carlyle Hall Rd NW 14851 W Sunset Blvd Palm Springs, CA 92262 Seattle,WA 98177 Pacific Palisades, CA 90272 502 460 031 502 460 032 502 460 033 Norman Phares Gloria Agee Wonderly Eric P 526 S Sunrise Way#31 15523 Vista Vicente Dr 26505 Briarwood Ln Palm Springs, CA 92264 Ramona, CA 92065 San Juan Capistrano, CA 92675 502 460 034 502 460 035 502 460 036 William Bowen Gregory&Geraldine Siverly Fernando Ramirez&Melissa Ramirez 506 S Sunrise Way 5811 N Drumheller St 1223 E Grovecenter St Palm Springs, CA 92264 Spokane, WA 99205 West Covina, CA 91790 502 460 037 502 460 038 502 460 039 Norman Freedberg Deanna Lawrence Cooper Lewis 226 N Palm Canyon Dr PO Box 942 1751 E Ramon Rd Palm Springs, CA 92262 Pine Valley, CA 91962 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 040 502 460 041 502 460 042 Alfred Kendall&Patricia Jea Orsatti Brenda Scott Shaun Lether 8348 Jason Ave 1761 E Ramon Rd#41 1765 E Rarnon Rd West Hills, CA 91304 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 460 043 502 460 044 502 460 045 Joan Elizabeth Cheatham Donna Prada Lot Common 1775 E Ramon Rd 854 Diamond St 522 S Sepulveda Blvd#110 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Monrovia, CA 91016 Los Angeles, CA 90049 502 560 001 502 560 005 502 560 009 SE Calif Assn Of 7th Day Adventists Desert Water Agency River ' e ounty Flood Cont PO Box 8050 PO Box 1710 1995 M et St Riverside, CA 92515 Palm Springs, CA 92263 River si I , 92501 502 51 0 14 502 560 016 502 60 0 8 Usa 50 Riverside County Flood Cont Riversr Comity Flood Cont Unknow r 1995 Market St 1995 M et St CA Riverside, CA 92501 Riversid , A 92501 502 560 020 502F56 025 502 60 33 Dahoon Investment Co Usa Usa 5 77200 California Dr Unkn S Unknor S Palm Desert, CA 92211 CA CA 502 0 0 4 502 60 038 502 560 039 Usa 50 Usa 5 Usa Unknowr Urrknow 02-27-87 S Unkno 02-27-87 S , CA , CA , CA 502 5 04 502 561 001 502 561 002 Riversi ovary Flood Cont Whiteside Stephen L&D C Marilyn Ryding 1995 Mar t St 2310 Nicolas Dr 2001 E Camino Parocela 42 Riverside, C 92501 Fullerton, CA 92833 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 561 003 502 561 004 502 561 005 Robert Kasting Ronnie Reichgelt&James Horan Ruth Ruiz 2001 E Camino Parocela#A3 839 W Lakeside PI 78520 Avenida La Fonda Palm Springs, CA 92264 Chicago, IL 60640 La Quinta, CA 92253 502 561 006 502 561 007 502 561 008 Kathleen Bill Timothy&Dawn Silva Andrew&Vicki Garbely PO Box 854 376 Virginia Dr 3536 NE Hancock St Manhattan Beach, CA 90267 Livermore, CA 94550 Portland,OR 97212 502 561 009 502 561 010 502561011 Richard Sears&Loretta Sears Jamie Roireau Overgaauw&Cornelius 810 NW 176th Ave 21515 Hawthorne Blvd#840 6143 Capetown St Beaverton, OR 97006 Torrance, CA 90503 Lakewood, CA 90713 502 561 012 502 561 013 502 561 014 Andres M Baric John&Margaret Mcglynn Barbara Kabus&Patricia Friesen 115 Pico Ave Peter 2001 E Camino Parocela#B 14 Pacific Grove, CA 93950 15196 SW Kenton Dr Palm Springs, CA 92264 Tigard,OR 97224 502 561 015 502 561 016 502 561 017 Joseph Massey&Maureen Massey Francine Heser I D &Gayle Weiner 2001 E Camino Parocela#C15 20109 Mildred Ave 28032 Sea Lane Dr Palm Springs, CA 92264 Torrance, CA 90503 Malibu, CA 90265 502 561 018 502 561 019 502 561 020 Donald Anderson&Arlene Rose Ande Stephen Morrow&April Barry Henry Alilovich 4813 Marblehead Bay Dr 2007 W Hedding St#100 2001 E Camino Parocela#C20 Oceanside, CA 92057 San Jose, CA 95128 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 561 021 502 561 022 502 561 023 William&Consuelo Gills Joseph Hughes John Jordan 8832 Sovereign Rd 2001 E Camino Parocela#C22 10080 W Suburban Dr San Diego, CA 92123 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Miami,FL 33156 502 561 024 502 561 025 502 561 026 James&Becky Zopolis Roland&Mary Stewart Gus Stevenson&Leona Stevenson PO Box 2083 3275 Dogwood Dr S 3660 Bluebell St Palm Springs, CA 92263 Salem, OR 97302 Seal Beach, CA 90740 502 561 027 502 561 028 502 561 029 Jensen Mary Lou&Jensen Ruth Anderson Gregory&Monica Keehfuss 226 W E St PO Box 652 7148 Wood Rd Ontario, CA 91762 Palm Springs, CA 92263 Riverside, CA 92506 502 561 030 502 561 031 502 561 032 Nicholas Tricarico Despina Papapetru Boyle Daniel B &Boyle Cathy A 6 Gravel Hill Ter 3262 N 94th St Boyle Kinnelon,NJ 07405 Milwaukee,WI 53222 31 Ticknor PI Laguna Niguel, CA 92677 502 561 033 502 561 034 502 561 035 Mcmillan Holdings Ltd Lambert Jack&Lambert Jack Leonard&Carrie Bart 4 650 Harrington Rd Kamloops 2001 E Canino Parocela#E34 2001 E Camino Parocela BC V213 6T7 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 CANADA 502 561 036 502 561 037 502 561 038 Ruel Longfellow&Mercedes Longfello Darell&Mary Schregardus Kent&Dorothy Roberts 21 Muriel Rd 1711 S Shore Dr 720 Greenway Ter Swampscott,MA 01907 Holland,MI 49423 La Habra, CA 90631 502 561 039 502 561 040 502 561 041 Joseph&Delores Young Jack Lambert Julius&Murnell Kununerman 21672 Kaiser Rd 2001 E Camino Parocela#F40 2001 E Camino Parocela#G41 Gregory, MI 48137 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 561 042 502 561 043 502 561 044 Phillip Rose Helmut Bauch Thush 21617 Woodland Crest Dr Birnauer Str 12 G-7750 Konstanz 4400 Hollingsworth Cir Woodland Hills, CA 91364 GERMANY Rolmert Park, CA 94928 502 561 045 502 561 046 502 561 047 Hobert&Colleen Herber Transport Sorenson Ladd 2001 E Camino Parocela#G45 PO Box 311 24813 Outlook Ct Palm Springs, CA 92264 Chehalis, WA 98532 Carmel, CA 93923 502 561 048 502 561 049 502 561 050 James&Sandra Giefer William&Tamaralee Cox E Budd&Paulette Simpson 3752 Village Ct 1032 Bayside Cv 135 Camellia Ct Saint Paul,MN 55125 Newport Beach, CA 92660 Upland, CA 91786 502 561 051 502 561 052 502 561 053 John&Nancy Todd Keudell David J&Keudell David J Michael Teagle 2001 E Camino Parocela#1151 1104 Main St 4200 2001 E Camino Parocela#H53 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Vancouver, WA 98660 Pahn Springs, CA 92264 502 561 054 502 561 055 502 561 056 Jenkins Cheryl Agee&Glen Jenkins Lawrence&Lola Otoole Myron Filipoff 440 N Hayden Island Dr 17352 Rainglen Ln 20503 Shepherd Hills Dr Portland, OR 97217 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Walnut, CA 91789 502 561 057 502 561 058 502 561 059 Ferrari Dorma&Ferrari Donna Bernard&Eugenia Bernacchi Cal-wai Properties 1675 Cherry Ave 176 Appletree Ave 6070 Calle De Prospero San Jose, CA 95125 Camarillo, CA 93012 San Jose, CA 95124 502 561 060 502 561 061 502 561 062 Michael Agee&Sherri Benetreu I D&Gayle Weiner Michael Torhan 386 SW 37th Cir 28032 Sea Lane Dr 38094 3rd St Gresham, OR 97080 Malibu, CA 90265 Fremont, CA 94536 502 561 063 502 561 064 502 561 065 Gerald Ford Chappelle Leroy A&Vera C&Chapp Betty Wasick 231 Avenida Majorca 43 2001 E Camino Parocela#I64 2001 E Camino Parocela 065 Laguna Hills, CA 92653 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 561 066 502 561 067 502 561 068 Marie Bro Edward Bobbett&Martina Bobbett Gallagher Joseph A&P A 717 Strand St 1609 Beechwood Ave PO Box 401037 Santa Monica, CA 90405 Fullerton, CA 92835 Hesperia, CA 92340 502 561 069 502 561 070 502 561 071 Fred&Lupe Luevano Jr. Randy&Jennifer Price Paul&Kathryn Alle Goodman 1166 Arroyo Pacifica 2001 E Camino Parocela 070 PO Box 2127 Fallbrook, CA 92028 Palm Springs, CA 92264 La Habra, CA 90632 502 561 072 502 561 073 502 561 074 J Roger Grummett&Karleen Grommet Robert&Dorthea Pailthorp Joseph Wild II&Leroy Bontrager 4195 Lake Shore Dr PO Box 713 761 Hillpine Ter NE Juneau, AK 99801 Depoe Bay, OR 97341 Atlanta, GA 30306 502 561 075 502 561 076 502 561 077 John Domingo&Ernest Sabo Gray Leslie M&Helen Adma Arthur Macmillan 4663 Vista St Leslie&Helen Gray 2001 E Camino Parocela 4K77 San Diego, CA 92116 1112 Rio Cidade Way Palm Springs, CA 92264 Sacramento, CA 95831 502 561 078 502 561 079 502 5 1 080 Akin Robert D Stanley Mallard&Scott Mcdonald Henry Nile Ady Basile PO Box 2542 2001 E Camino Parocela 2244 13th W#403 Wrightwood, CA 92397 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Seattle, W 19 502 561 081 502 561 082 502 561 083 Patti Lee Phillips&James Waydehch D Dean&Mary Wingham William&Phyllis Stewart 1752 Miramar Dr 10041 Echo Dr 4797 W Phillips St Newport Beach, CA 92661 Brookville,IN 47012 Ontario, CA 91762 502 561 084 502 561 085 502 561 086 Gordon&Marcia Thompson Marilyn Milman Laurie&Michael Bardkas 16215 NE Eugene Ct 2001 E Camino Parocela#L85 Morgan&Barba Bardkas Portland, OR 97230 Palm Springs, CA 92264 675 S Sierra Ave 428 Solana Beach, CA 92075 502 561 087 502 561 088 502 561 089 Sydney&Ann Ackerman Novy Ronald R&Novy Ronald R&D Holum Bradley Wayne 2001 E Camino Parocela#L87 7284 Cedarwood P1 1136 Cortez Ave Palm Springs, CA 92264 Highland, CA 92346 Burlingame, CA 94010 502 561 090 502 561 091 502 561 092 George Goy Charles Leroy Hansen Doolittle Norman P&Doolittle 1909 Shell Ave 2001 E Camino Parocela#M91 2001 E Camino Parocela#M92 Venice, CA 90291 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 561 093 502 561 094 502 561 095 Howard&Sonja Hoch Timothy Leary&Stuart Berger John&Norma Marrin 952 W Cumberland St 1359 25th Ave 1225 Cajon St Upland, CA 91786 San Francisco, CA 94122 Redlands, CA 92373 502 561 096 502 561 097 502 561 098 Norman Harvey&Mary Patricia Haako V T Deremer Jr. Felix&Mary Lori Jumonville Jr. 812 Dalewood Ln 2001 E Camino Parocela#N97 2001 E Camino Parocela#N98 VICTORIA BC Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 CANADA 502 561 099 502 562 001 502 562 002 Michael Gee&Phillip Hager Brian&Roslyn Lloyd Diana Meyer 9401 Castlewood St 404 E 13ih St 2001 E Camino Parocela#101 Oakland, CA 94605 Vancouver,WA 98660 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 562 003 502 562 004 502 562 005 Lester Garnet&M R Marlene Lucretia Wohlgernuth Muriel Bell 1227 NW Norcross Way 2001 E Camino Parocela#N103 19191 Harvard Ave#404 Seattle, WA 98177 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Irvine, CA 92612 502 562 006 502 562 007 502 562 008 Richard Schlegel James Odell Scott John Parker& S Co-trustees Marilyn 2001 E Camino Parocela#0105 22962 Orangewood Ct 15120 Mar Vista St Palm Springs, CA 92264 Grand Terrace, CA 92313 Whittier, CA 90605 502 562 009 502 562 010 502 562 011 Gonzalez Angel& Grace Villa Patricia Boren Crestline Inv Group Inc 731 Iliff St 1609 Michael Ln Michele Arhrkovich Pacific Palisades, CA 90272 Pacific Palisades, CA 90272 4417 E Village Rd Long Beach, CA 90808 502 562 012 502 562 013 502 562 014 Vincent&Brenda Nardolillo Russel&Sheila Hamelin Margaret Levinson 6462 E Via Arboles 1159 W Molly Ct 2001 E Camino Parocela Anaheim, CA 92807 Upland, CA 91786 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 562 015 502 562 016 502 562 017 Maria Oms Randal&Sally Jo Largent Ardean William&Marla Jean Ladd 2008 Calle Francesca 15114 206th Ave SE 12710 Spindlewood Dr San Dimas, CA 91773 Renton, WA 98059 La Mirada, CA 90638 502 562 018 502 562 019 502 562 020 Darlene Ruth Rockey Ira Golchehreh&D B Carolita Elke Just 2001 E Camino Parocela#Q117 15 Madeline Ln 611 S Palm Canyon Dr#260 Palm Springs, CA 92264 San Rafael, CA 94901 Palm Springs, CA 92264 502 562 021 502 562 022 502 562 023 John Kanocz&Patricia Kanocz Barbara Mckenna Arthur Gittelman&Rosemary Gittelm 2001 E Camino Parocela#Q120 2001 E Camino Parocela#Q121 3300 Darby Rd#3208 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Haverford,PA 19041 502 562 024 502 562 025 502 562 026 Henderson Roy&Frances Carol Robert&Marion Dahlgren Jan Stamps Roy&France Henderson 2001 E Camino Parocela#Q124 PO Box 1953 113 N Equestrian Way Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92263 Prescott, AZ 86303 502 562 027 502 562 028 502 562 029 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown S Unknown 01-05-1998 S Unknown 11-07-97 S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 030 502 562 031 502 562 032 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa Bia Unknown S Unknown S Unknown 11-23-98 S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 033 502 562 034 502 562 035 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 036 502 562 037 502 562 038 Usa Bia Usa Bia. Usa 502 Unknown 04-24-97 S Unknown 04-29-98 S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 039 502 562 040 502 562 041 Usa Bia Usa Bin Usa 502 Unknown 08-28-98 S Unknown 12-07-1999 S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 042 502 562 043 502 562 044 Usa Bia. Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown 04-17-98 S Unknown 08-03-98 S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 045 502 562 046 502 562 047 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 048 502 562 049 502 562 050 Usa Bia Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown 10-13-98 S Unknown S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 051 502 562 052 502 562 054 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 05-21-97 S Unknown S CA CA CA h7- 502 562 055 502 562 056 502 562 057 Usa Bin Usa Bin Usa Bia Unknown 11-30-98 S Unknown 06-06-97 S Unknown 11-03-97 S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 058 502 562 059 502 562 060 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown 05-10-2001 S Unknown 11-08-95 S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 061 502 562 062 502 562 063 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 01-05-1999 S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 064 502 562 065 502 562 066 Usa 502 Usa 502 Hudson Unknown S Unknown S 1194 Kingston Ln , CA , CA Ventura, CA 93001 502 562 067 502 562 068 502 562 069 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown S Unknown 12-29-1998 S Unknown 05-18-98 S , CA , CA , CA 502 562 070 502 562 071 502 562 072 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 01-02-2002 S Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 073 502 562 074 502 562 075 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S , CA , CA , CA 508 240 007 508 240 008 508 240 009 Riverside Co ty lood Cout 555 Sunrise Randall W Guy Me&Lisa Guy Llc 1995 Market St 1555 S Palm Canyon Dr#G106 PO Box 950 Riverside, CA 2501 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Indianola, WA 98342 i 508 240 010 508 271 010 508271011 International Church Four Square Gosp Edward Taggart Anne Boukidis 630 S Sunrise Way 1629 E Sunny Dunes Rd 2469 S Caliente Rd Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 508 271 012 508 271 013 508 271 014 David Joseph Testa Noble Willingham&Willingham Acme Clarke PO Box 5504 69 Asilomar Rd 1654 E San Lucas Rd Palm Springs, CA 92263 Laguna Niguel, CA 92677 Palm Springs, CA 92264 y I n 508 271 015 508 272 010 508272011 Daniel Smith&K B Kandi Kim Chasen&Marian Moiseyev Jack Warren&Emilie Warren 2654 Crowthorne Ct 1627 E San Lucas Rd 1653 E San Lucas Rd Vista, CA 92084 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 508 272 012 508 272 013 508 272 014 Chi&Frances Chung Hernandez Gus&J Laurie Stann 362 S Palm Canyon Dr 1672 N Riverside Dr 1650 N Riverside Dr Palm Springs, CA 92262 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 508 272 015 508 73 2 508 281 012 Lary Kast River ' County Flood Cont Housing&Finance Agency Corp 1626 N Riverside Dr 1995 ket St 801 S Sunrise Way Palm Springs, CA 92264 River rde, CA 92501 Palm Springs, CA 92264 DESERT CHAPEL 5.935-PD59 Arthur MacMillan Karleen & Roger Grummett CORRESPONDENTS Mesquite Country Club 2001 Camino Parocela, J72 2001 Camino Parocela K77 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Robert& Dorthea Pailthorp Ron Novy, President Marie A. Bochnewich 2001 Camino Parocela Mesquite Country Club HOA GURALNICK&GILLILAND Palm Springs, CA 92262 P.O. Box 2342 74-399 Hwy 111 Suite M Palm Springs, CA 92263 Palm Desert, CA 92260 John Dominge & Ernest Sabo William & Consuelo Gills Ron & Gina Youngren Mesquite Country Club 8832 Sovereign Road 911A Arlene Drive 2001 Camino Parocela K-75 San Diego, CA 92123 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Irving D & Gayle Weiner Joseph J. Wild II Alfred & Pearl Rudin 28032 Sea Lane 2001 Camino Parocela, K-74 61 St. Clair Avenue West, Ste 603 Malibu, CA 90265 Palm Springs, CA 92264 Toronto, Ontario, Canada M4V2Y8 Neighborhood Coalition List as of October 1, 2003 MR PETER DIXON MR BILL DAVIS AND Case 5.935 431 SOUTH MONTE VISTA DRIVE MS TRISHA DAVIS P.C. Hearing for 11-26-03 PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 227 SOUTH CAHUILLA Desert Chapel PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 MR FRANK TYSEN MR BOB WEITHORN MR TIM HOHMEIER C/O CASA CODY COUNTRY INN 261 SOUTH BELARDO ROAD 1387 CALLE DE MARIA 175 SOUTH CAHUILLA ROAD PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 MS CHRISTINE HAMMOND MR PHIL TEDESCO MR MARSHALL ROATH 1155 SOUTH CAMINO REAL 1303 WEST PRIMAVERA DRIVE MS SHERYL HAMLIN PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 565 WEST SANTA ROSA DRIVE PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 MS MARGARET PARK MS ROXANNE FLOSS AGUA CALIENTE BAND OF 930 CHIA AGUA CALIENTE INDIANS REP CAHUILLA INDIANS PALM SPRINGS, CA 92262 650 E TAHQUITZ CANYON WAY PALM SPRINGS CA 92262 SENIOR SECRETARY DEPT OF PLANNING &ZONING =J�J�J�J CITY OF PALM SPRINGS CITY OF P.S. REP PO BOX 2743 PALM SPRINGS CA 92263-2743 DESERT CHAPEL MR FRANK MARSHALL SPONSORS 630 SOUTH SUNRISE WAY C/O DESERT CHAPEL PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 630 SOUTH SUNRISE WAY PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 CHRISTOPHER S MILLS ARCHITECT 1255 EST RAMON ROAD PALM SPRINGS CA 92264 04 pALM SAS City of Palm Springs h c Department of Planning &Zoning 3200 East Tahquitz Canyon Way ' Palm Springs, CA 92262 °+ Telephone: 760-323-8245 41 Fo0.N'* Fax: 760-322-8360 E-mail: LorettaM@ci.palm-springs.ca.us F A X TRANSMISSION Date: November 14, 2003 To: Claudia Salgado and Arvada Wilson Bureau of Indian Affairs From: Loretta Moffett, Senior Secretary Planning Department Subject: November 26, 2003 Planning Commission Hearing Cases: 5.935-PD-59 - Desert Chapel Good morning Claudia and Arvada! Here are the APN numbers for Indian landowners within the 400' radius of the above-referenced projects who need to be notified of the November 26, 2003 Planning Commission Hearing. Case No. 5.935-PD-59 (Desert Chapel): (12 Notices enclosed for Indian Landowners 502-560-014 502-560-025 502-560-033 502-560-034 502-560-038 502-560-039 See two pages attached for additional 47 APN numbers. We ask that you expedite mailing these notices to the appropriate landowners as soon as possible. If you need more notices or postage paid envelopes, please call me at 323-8245 and I will bring them over. Your assistance is always appreciated. Many thanks to you both! Enclosures Case 5.935 502 562 055 502 562 056 502 562 057 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa Bin Unknown 11-30-98 S Unknown 06-06-97 S Unknown 11.03-97 S , CA CA , CA 502 562 058 502 562 059 302 562 060 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown 05-10-2001 S Unknown 11-08-95 5 Unknown S CA CA CA i 502 562 061 502 562 062 _ 502 562 063 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown Unknown 01-05-1999 S Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 064 502 562 065 502 562 066 Usa 502 Usa 502 Hudson Unknown S Unknown 5 1194 Kingston Ln ,CA CA Ventura, CA 93001 502 562 067 562 562 068 502 562 069 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown S Unknown 12-29-1998 S Unknown 05-18-98 S CA CA CA 502 562 070 502 562 071 502562072 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown 01-02-2002 S Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 073 502 562 074 502 562 075 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown,S Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 027 502 562 028 502 562 029 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa Bia Unknown S Unknown 01-05-1998 S Unknown 11-07-97 S CA CA CA 502 562 030 502 562 031 502 562 032 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa Bia Unknown S Unknown S Unknown 11-23-98 S CA CA .CA 502 562 033. S02 562 054 .502 562 035 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S CA CA CA r 502 562 036 502 562 037 502 562 038 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa 502 I Unknown 04-24-97 S Unknown 04-29-98 S Unknown S l ,CA CA CA 502 562 039 502 562 040 502 562 041 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown 08-28-98 S Unknown 12-07-1999 S Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 042 502 562 043 502 562 044 Usa Bia Usa Bia Usa 502 Unknown 04-17-98 S Unknown 08-03-98 S Unknown S CA CA CA 502 562 045 502 562 046 502 562 047 Usa 502 Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown S Unknown S Unknown S ,CA , CA , CA 502 562 048 502 562 049 502 562 050 Usa Bia Usa 502 Usa 502 Unknown 10-13-98 S Unknown S Unknown s , CA , CA , CA 502 562 051 502 562 052 502 562 054 Usa 502 Usa Bia Usa 502 unknown S Unknown 05-21-97 S Unknown S CA CA CA Proof of Publication In Newspaper STATE OF CALIFORNIA County of Riverside Jacquelin K. Welch says: 1. I am a citizen of the United States a NOTICE OF C HEARING CITY COOfwrlca resident of the City of Desert Hot CITY OF PALM SPRINGS Springs, County of Riverside, State of Cute No 5.SO6POb9 California, and over the age of 18 years. An application by Dawn Chapel for an amendment to Planned Development District 59 to consider revisions to the 2. 1 am the Research & Production master plan,Including:1)the addition ofclassrooms,anurs- Assistant of The Public Record a ery,an administration building,and a new special events area;and 2)the establishment of regulation for the time, newspaper of general circulation printed place,and manner of special events,including not-lime fool- and published in the City of Palm ball games,at 530 South Senate Way,Zone PD 59 Springs, County of Riverside, State of NOTICE IS NE11ERY UMN that the City Council of the City of Penn Springs,California.will hold a publc hearing at as maat- California. Said The Public Record is a ing of January 21,SON.The City Council meeting begins at newspaper of general circulation as that 7:00p.m.,in the City Colsmtl Chamber at City Hall,3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way,Palm Sprigs.California. is defined in Government Code section 6000, Its status as such having The Purpose of Iran Amendment is to cans lerPlanned an application by nt y Desert Chapel for an amoxMment to Floored Development been established by judicial decree of the District 59 for revisions to Me master plan,rlct"rlg:1)the addition of classrooms,a nursery,an administration building, Superior Court of the State of California in and a new special events,including rght4ime football games. and for the County of Riverside in The PPD5t��a located at 630 South Sunrise Way, Proceeding No. Indio 49271, dated March 31, 1987, entered in Jud went Pursuant to Sermon ISD70 of to California Environmental g Quality Act (CEOA) Guidelines, a Mititgaled Negative Book No. 129, page 355, on March 31, Declination was adopted by the City Council in 1999. 1987. The proposed application,site plan,and related documents are 3. The Public Record is a newspaper of available for public review dairy,between Sam and 5pm at the general circulation ascertained and City of Palm Springs in the Planning Zoning Department,locaa ed at 3200200 Tahgwlz Canyon Way. established in the City of Palm Springs in If any individual of group challenges the action in court issues the County of Riverside, State of raised may be limited to only these issues raised at the public ase No. RIC 358286 Filed a[or sr to the ed City Councihis l eti in written correspondence California,, , al or poor to the City Cauncll meeting June 8, 2001 . Notice of Public Hearing is being sent to all property owners 4. The notice, of which the annexed is a within lour hundred(400)feet of[he subject property An hipper, true printed copy, was published in the be heard d Question.sag rding thi for call interested persons to r be ly wit egiven at regarding this case may to directed to newspaper on the following publication Alex Meyerboff, Principal Planner,Department of Planning& Zoning,(760)323-8245 dates to wit: Patricia Sanders City Cleric - January 6, 2004 I certify under penalty of perjury that the Q) January 6,2004 rrttourrZ cuJroN WAY above is true and correct. Dated at Palm Springs, California, 43 this 6TH day of January 2004. 3 a o RNION� ROAD A _ flUl y UNNr OUNP5 CPC) O�c Jacquelin K. Welch — — — 4 Research & Production Assistant rre50U17e AIMLIC l a�� f PP0Jrcr LOCATION _ RESOLUTION NO. OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING, SUBJECT TO THE CONDITIONS STATED, CASE 5.935-PD-59, AN APPLICATION BY DESERT CHAPEL FOR REVISIONS TO THE DESERT CHAPEL MASTER PLAN,PLANNED DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT 59,TO INCLUDE: 1) THE ADDITION OF CLASSROOMS, A NURSERY, AN ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING AND A NEW SPECIAL EVENTS AREA; AND 2) REGULATIONS REGARDING THE TIME, PLACE AND MANNER OF SPECIAL EVENTS, INCLUDING NIGHT TIME FOOTBALL GAMES; LOCATED AT 630 SOUTH SUNRISE WAY. ZONE PD-59, SECTION 24. WHEREAS, Desert Chapel (the "applicant") has filed an application with the City pursuant to Section 94.03.00 of the Zoning Ordinance relative to master plan revisions as represented in case No.5.935-PD-59, on a 10.16 acre parcel located at 630 South Sunrise Way, R-1-C Zone, Section 24; and WHEREAS, notice of public hearing of the Planning Commission of the City of Palm Springs to consider Applicant's application far a Master Plan Revision as represented in Case No. 5.935-PD- 59 was given in accordance with applicable law; and WHEREAS, on January 7, 1976, the City Council approved Planned Development District#59 providing for a church and school use in an R-1-C zone; and WHEREAS, the church and school have been in continuous operation and have received City Council approval for numerous additions; and WHEREAS, pursuantto Section 21064.5 of the California Environmental Quality Act("CEQA"), on November 17, 1999 the City Council certified a Mitigated Negative Declaration for the subject project. At that meeting the City Council determined that with the environmental mitigation incorporated into the project, any environmental impacts resulting from the project would be reduced to a level of insignificance; and WHEREAS, on August 27,2003,September 10,2003 September 26, 2003, November 12,2003, November 27, 2003 and December 10,2003 a public hearing on the application for a master plan revision, Case No. 9.935-PD-59 was held by the Planning Commission in accordance with applicable law; and WHEREAS, on December 10, 2003, the applicant withdrew their request for the re-dedication of the Sunny Dunes right of way; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission carefully reviewed and considered all of the evidence presented in connection with the hearing on the project,including,but not limited to the staff report, and all written and oral testimony presented; and t 9ew Case 5.935 Resolution January 21, 2004 Page 6 of 8 WHEREAS, on September 10, 2003,the Planning Commission voted to recommend that the City Council approve said project; and WHEREAS, on January 21, 2004 a public hearing on the application for a master plan revision, Case No. 9.935-PD-59 was held by the City Council in accordance with applicable law; and WHEREAS, the City Council carefully reviewed and considered all of the evidence presented in connection with the hearing on the project, including, but not limited to the staff report, and all written and oral testimony presented. THE CITY COUNCIL HEREBY FINDS AS FOLLOWS: Section 1: Pursuant to CEQA, the City Council finds as follows: Pursuant to Section 21064.5 of the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA"), on November 17, 1999 the City Council certified a Mitigated Negative Declaration for the subject project. At that meeting the City Council determined that with the environmental mitigation incorporated into the project, any environmental impacts resulting from the project would be reduced to a level of insignificance. Section 2: Pursuant to Zoning Ordinance Section 94.03.00, the City Council finds that: a. The use applied for at the location set forth in the application is properly one for which a Planned Development District Master Plan Revision is authorized by the City Zoning Ordinance. Pursuant to the Zoning Ordinance, Planned Development District 59 was legally created per these standards and the proposed revisions are in compliance with those standards. The expansion of the church and school is an appropriate development for the site and for the community. b. The use applied for is necessary and desirable for the development of the community, is in harmony with the various elements or objectives of the General Plan, and is not detrimental to existing uses or to future uses specifically permitted in the zone in which the proposed use is to be located. The existing church and school use is provided for in the R-1-C zone with a Planned Development District in the City of Palm Springs Zoning Ordinance. The project design parameters and conditions provide for lands use compatibility in the zone. Access and maintenance easements have been provided. c. The site for the intended use is adequate in size and shape to accommodate said use, including yards,setbacks,walls orfences,landscaping and otherfeatures required in order to adjust said use to those existing or permitted future uses of the land in the neighborhood. The 10.16 acre site is adequate in shape and size to accommodate the school and church. 41cy ' Case 5.935 Resolution January 21, 2004 Page 7 of 8 The site is located adjacent to a golf course and wash. This location provides for a maximum distance from residences across Sunrise Way and from the Mesquite Country Club Condominiums. d. The site for the proposed use related to streets and highways is properly designed and improved to carry the type and quantity of traffic to be generated by the proposed use. An environmental assessment and traffic study have previously been prepared for this project. A Mitigated Negative Declaration was adopted by the City Council on November 17, 1999.Specifictraffic mitigation have been applied tothis project,including contributions to the signalization of Sunrise Way and Sunny Dunes Road and the intersection improvements at Ramon Road and Sunrise Way. A traffic signal has since been installed at the intersection of Sunrise Way and Sunny Dunes Road. e. The conditions to be imposed and shown on the approved site plan are deemed necessary to protect the public health, safety and general welfare, including any minor modifications of the zone's property development standards. The conditions of approval address environmental concerns including traffic, planning standards, constriction standards, thereby creating improvements that are beneficial and are necessary to ensure public health and safety. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that, based upon the foregoing, the City Council hereby approves the Master Plan Revision, Case No. 5.935-PD-59, subject to those conditions set forth in Exhibit A, on file in the Department of Planning & Zoning office, which are to be satisfied prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy unless other specified. ADOPTED this 21st day of Janua , 2004. AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: ATTEST: CITY OF PALM SPRINGS, CALIFORNIA By City Clerk City Manager Reviewed and Approved as to Form: ��L� erPRQYF0 By PLANhIft GWW1wavun I Ttff}� ri t 7,91T quo-0 �1,'l Desert hap el - 630 South Sunrise Way 49W ,> 1—ofiw __ __ - Case No 5.935 - PD 59 Master Plan Revision tam 40_ ___Ordlume $-- September 10, 2003 WROYAL SUWIKCTCT TO ALL REQUIRED ('WITIONS RY VOW WWIFF REVISED CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL Before final acceptance of the project, all conditions listed below shall be completed to the satisfaction of the City Engineer,the Director of Planning, the Chief of Police,the Fire Chief or their designee, depending on which department recommended the condition. Any agreements, easements or covenants required to be entered into shall be in a form approved by the City Attorney. Special Events 1. The applicant may conduct a maximum of three special events per year, with temporary lighting and generators, which shall not extend past 9:00 pm. Amplified outdoor concerts are prohibited. Tear-down of special events shall not extend past 9:00 pm, or 10pm on Fridays and Saturdays. 2. A lighting plan for special event lighting shall be reviewed and approved by the Director of Planning and Zoning. 3. Special events shall be limited to one day in duration. 4. Loudspeakers and any other noise shall not reasonably interfere with the peace and quiet of any person outside the boundary of the site and shall comply with the City Noise Ordinance. 5. Desert Chapel shall provide written notice of any special events, by mail, two weeks prior to the event, to Mesquite Country Club property owners in the Phase Adjacent to Desert Chapel, and the HOA. 6. Should any of these conditions be violated, the Planning Commission reserves the right to revoke the right of Desert Chapel to conduct future special events. Football Games 7. The applicant may host up to ten football games annually. These events would shall end by 10:OOpm. These events may include the use of a temporary generator, PA system, lighting and bleachers. The field and parking lot shall be cleared with all lights off by 10:OOpm. Tear-down of football games shall not extend past 10:00 pm. Special dispensation will be made to game delays caused by injuries, power outages or timeouts beyond reasonable control of Desert Chapel. 8. A lighting plan for football field lighting shall be reviewed and approved by the Director of Planning and Zoning. 9. Lighting and the PA system shall be directed away from adjacent residential properties. 'v s � 9 10. Amplified music shall be limited to 15 minutes before game and 15 minutes at half time. 11, Desert Chapel shall provide written notice of the football season schedule, by mail, two weeks prior to the start of football season,to Mesquite Country Club property owners in the Phase Adjacent to Desert Chapel, and the HOA. 12. Provide a list of "key administrative personnel', including cell phone numbers, such that should any concerns arise,the matter could be brought to the immediate attention of these "key administrative personnel." The list shall be kept updated and shall be provide by Desert Chapel to the City Planning and Zoning Department, Police Department ant Mesquite Country Club HOA, and shall be responsible for enforcement of these conditions of approval. 13. Security personnel shall be required and shall be on duty until 11:OOpm. 14. Desert Chapel shall utilize the northeast parking lot for overflow parking only. Driveways to this area shall be barricaded or otherwise controlled by Desert Chapel staff to ensure compliance, 15. Should any of these conditions be violated, the Planning Commission reserves the right to revoke the right of Desert Chapel to conduct future football games at this site. General 16. Construction activities and the use of landscape equipment on site, including but not limited to blowers, trimmers, mowers, street sweepers, landscape equipment and general construction and landscape maintenance activities shall conform to permitted construction work hours in the City of Palm Springs, Monday- Friday 7 am- 7 pm, Saturday 8 am-5pm and prohibited on Sundays, per the Municipal code. 17. Late night use of the sports courts, after the use of 10 pm, shall be prohibited. 18. Desert Chapel shall provide adequate adult supervision to minors on site during all activities and events. 19. The Planning Commission reserves the right to adjust the Conditions of approval in response to operation, activities and community concerns. The process to modify shall require public notice to Mesquite Country Club HOA, one meeting with Desert Chapel and Mesquite Country Club HOAand a Planning Commission action.The Planning Commission reserves the right to require a formal public hearing prior to considering changes to the approved conditions of approval for special events and football games. The Planning Commission decision can be appealed per Palm Springs Municipal Code Section 2.05.030. L RESOLUTION NO. EXHIBIT ,t Desert Chapel-630 South Sunrise Way Master Plan Revision,PD59 November 17,1999 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL Before£oral acceptance of the project,all conditions listedbelow shall ba completed to the satisfaction of dae City Engineet,the Director o£Plaruung,dteClrie£ofPolice,the Fire Chiefortheirdesignee,depending on which department recommended the condition. Any agreements,easements or covenants required to be entered into shall be in a form approved by the City.Attomey. APPLICATION FOR ARCHITECTURAL APPROVAL OF DESERT CHAPEL MASTER PLAN LOCATED AT 630 AND 710 SUNRISE WAY SOUTH, (APN 502-560-004,006),SECTION 24, T 4 S,R 4 B,S.B.B.M,CASE NO.PD-59,ENG.PILE NO.E-2527 1. The proposed development ofthopremises shall conformto all applicable regulations ofthePahn Springs Zoning Ordinance,Municipal Code,or any other City Codes,ordinances and resolutions which supplement the zoning district regulations. Ia. The owner shall defend,indemnify,and hold hannloss the City of Palm Springs,its agents, officers,and employees from any claim,action,or proceeding againstthe City of Palm Springs or its agents,officers or employees to attach,set aside,void or annul,an approval of the City of Pahn Springs,its legislative body,advisory agencies,or administrative officers concerning Case No.5.0788,PD 59. The City of Palm Springs will promptly notify the applicant of any such claim,action,or proceeding against the City of Palm Springs and the applicant will either wndertakedefense ofthe matterand pay the City's associatedlegal costs or will advance funds to pay for defense ofthe rnatterbythe City Attorney.Ifthe City of Palm Springs fails topromptly notify the applicant of any such claim,action or proceeding or fails to cooperate fully in the defense,the applicant shall not,thereafter,beresponsibleto defend,indemnify,orholdhattnless the City ofPahn Springs.Notwithstandingthe foregoing,the City reminsthorightto settle or abandon thematterwithout the applicant's consentbutshouldit do so,the City shall waive the indemnification herein,except,the City's decision to settle or abandon a matter following an adversejurigement or failure to appeal,shall not cause a waiver ofthe indemnification rights herein. 2. The mitigationmeasures ofthe envhomnenial assessment shall apply.The appleantsball submit a signed agreementthatthe mitigation measures outlined as pariofthenegalive,declaration or E1R will be included in the plans priorto Planning Commission consideration ofthe environmental assessment. 3. The appeal period for the Master Plan Revision,Case No.5.0788-PI)59 application is 15 calendar days from the date ofproject approval.Permits willnotbe,issued until the appeal period has concluded. �� 7 4. The final developmentplansshallbesubmittedin accordance withSecflon9403.00oftasZoning Ordinance.Final dovelopmentplansshallincludesitoplans,building elevations,floorplans,roof plans,grading plans,landscape plans,irrigationplans,exteriorlightingplans,sign program, mitigation monitoring program,site cross sections,bikeway plans,property development standards andotber such docu ments as regititedbythePlanning Commission.Final development plans shall be submitted within two(2)years of the City Council approval ofthe preliminary planned development district. 5. Finallandscaping,hrigation,exteriorlighting,andfencingplansshallbesubmittedforapprovalby the Department of Planning and Building priortoissuance ofa building permit.Landscape plans shall be approvedby the Riverside County Agricultural Commissioner's Office prior to submittal. 6. The project is subjectto the City ofPahn Springs Water Efficient Lands cape Ordinance-The applicant shall submit an application for Final Landscape Document Package to(lie Director of Planning and Building for review and approvalpriorto the issuance ofabuildingpermit.Referto Chapter 8.60 of the Municipal Code for specific requirements. 7. Pdorto issuance ofa grading permit,aFngitiveDust and Erosion Control Plan shallbe subinitled and approved by the Building Official.Referto Chapter 8.50 ofthe Municipal Code forspecific requirements. 8. Tlhegradingplansballshowthedispositieno£allcutandfillmatorials.Licatsofsitedisumbance, shall be shown and all disturbed areas shall be fully restored or landscaped. 9. Drainage swalas shall beprovided adjacenito all curbs andsidewalks-Ywide and 6"deep.Tlhe irrigation system shall be field tested prior to final approval oftheproject.Section 14.24.020 of die Municipal Code proldbitsnuisance waterfromenteringthe public streets,roadways or gutters. 10. Allproposed from within thepublic right-of-way wd within 10 feet ofthepublic sidewalkand/or curb shall have City approveddeep rootban'iers installed per City of Palin Springs Engineering specifications. 11. Separate architectural approval and permits shall be required for all signs. A detailed sign program shallbe submitted forreviewand approvalby tiePlamilngConunissienpriorro issuance of building permits. 12. All materials on the flat portions of the roof shall be earfhtone colors. 13. All roofmountedmechanicalequipmentshallbescreeriedfromallpossiblevantagepointsboth existing and future per Section 9303.00 of the Zoning Ordinance. The screening shall be considered as anclementoftheoverall design andmustblend with the architectural design ofthe building(s).The exterior elevations and roofplans ofthebul(dings shall indicate any fixtures or equipmentto be located on the roorofthe building,the equipment heights,ancitype ofscreening. Parapets shall be at least 6"above the equipment for the purpose of screening. 14. No exterior downspouts shall he permitted on any facade crithe proposed building(s)which are visible from adjacent streets or residential and commercial areas. 15, The design height,texhrreandcolorofbuilding(s),fencesandwallsshallbesubirrittedforreview and approval prior to issuance of building permits. 16. The street address numbering/loitering shall not exceed eight inches in height. 17, An exterior lighting plan in accordance with thelighting ordinance in effect atthe time shall be submittedforreview and approval bythe Director of Plarudug&Buildnigprior to the issuanceof buildingpemxits,Aphotomehic study and nxanufacturer's out sheets of all exterior lighting on the building,htthe landscaping,andinthe parking lotsballbe submitted for approvalpriorto issuance of a building permit.If lights are proposed to be mounted on buildings,down-lights shall be utilized.All lighting shall be in accordance withthe City's non-glare standards.Allunpermitted /J night lighting shall be removed or permitted in compliance with the City's non-glare standards. ,.. r -aj�-�leligktsttgsha}lbeper[nittedrofll.[ra-large-playiagficid=locatedgrrthescrrdheast•-�• .---pexitm=of-thcprepertya- ��:.CI�l"'F=� A "�p'�t3'- 18. Illumination levels in the parking area shall be an average of one-fool candle with a rnflo of average light to minimum light of four to one(4:1). 19, Parking lot light fixtures shall align with stall striping and shall be located tweto three feet from curb face. 20. parking let lightfixtures shallalignwith stall striping and shall be locatedtwo to threefeetfram curb face. 21. Submit plans meeting City standardfor approval ontlreproposed trash andrecyclablematerials enclosure prior to issuance of a building permit. 22. No outside storage ofany kind shall be peraritted except as approved as a part ofthe proposed plan. 23. Priorto the issuance ofbuildingpetmits,locations of all telephone and electdcalboxes mustbe indicated onthebuAdingplaus and mustbe completely screenedandlocatedinthe interior ofthe building.ElectLicaltransformersmustbelocatedtowaxdtheinterioreftheprojectmaintaininga suffe,ientdistancefromthefrontage(s)ofiheproject. Safdtransfonner(s)mustbe adequately and decoratively screened. 24- Islands ofnotless than 9feetinwidthwithaminimumof6feetofplautershallbe provided every 10 parking spaces. 25. Shading requirements for parking lot areas as set forth in Section 9306.00 of the Zoning Ordinance shall be met. Details to be provided with final landscape plan. 26, Parkingstallsshatlbedelhteatedwilba4to6 inch double stripe-hairpin or elongated U,design. Individualwheel stops shall beprohibited;acontinuous 6"barrier curb shall providewheel stops. 27. Concrete walks with anduimumwidlh of two(2)feetsballbe installed adjacentto endparking spaces or end spaces shall be increased to eleven(11)feet wide. 28. Tree wells shall be provided within the parking Intend shall have a planting area of six feet in diameter/width. 29. Standard parking spaces shall be 17 feet deep by 9 feet wide;compactsizedspaces shall be13 feel deep by 8 feetwide.Handicap parking spaces shall be 18 feet deep by 9 feet wide plus a 5 footwalkway atthe rightside,oftheparkingspace;two(2)bandicap spaces can share a common ,9c 7 walkway.One in every eight(8)handicap accessible spaces,butnot less than one(1),shall be served by an 8 foot walkway on the right side and shall be designated as'ban accessible". 30. Handicapped accessibility shall be indicated onthesiteplantonicludethelocationofhandicapped parking spaces,the main entrance to the proposed structure and the path of travel to the main entrance.Considerationshallbegiveutopotentialdif&culfiogwiththebandicappedaccessibility to the building due to the future grading plans for the property. 31. Compact and handicapped spaces shall be appropriately marked per Section 9306.00C 10. 32. Curbs shall be installedata minimmnof five(5)feetflornface ofwalls,fences,buildings,or other structures.Areas that are notpadofthemancuvering area shall have curbs placed atarainimum of two(2)feet from the face of walls,fences or buildings adjoining driveways. 33. The project shall complywiththe City of Palm Springs TransportationDemand Management (TDM)Ordinance wliicli ss tablishes tramportation demand management requir ements for the City of Palm Springs. Refer to Chapter 8.4 of the Municipal Code for specific requirements. 34. Accessandnlilitymaildenance casements shallbeprovidedrelativeto the SumnyDunesRoad abandornneat in amanner consistentwiththe demoustratedueeds ofthe ldstorieal use by the Desert Water Agency,MesquiteCormtty Club Golf Club,Mesquite Country Club Homeowners Associationandany affectednTilities.These easements are subjectto the approval ofthe City of Patin Springs and shall be submiitedto the City Attorney for examination asto form and content prior to the issuance of any building permits. a. Employee parking shalt be provided by Desert Chapel for all legal users of the casement. b. The applicant shallrecord a maintenance and"hold harmless"agreementforthe users of the easamentthemby shifting a maintenance and insurance burden to the benefit of the users. c. TheapplicamshalldedicatetotheCityaneasemerrtforpedestrianandbikepathpuposes across that portion of Sunrise Way right-of-way vacated to the applicant, d. The applicant shall dedicate to the City an easement for pedestrian and bikepadi purposes,and construct abikepath across the applicant'spropertyin a location,width anal alignment approvedby the CityEngineerprior m vacation ofpedestrim andbikepadi rights from Sonny Dunes Road. - e. The applicant shall provide and enter into reciprocal access agreements across the applicant's property withtlre City andall affectedparties thatuse Smmy Dunes Road as legal access in a fonnapprovedby the City Attorney priorto vacation of Sunny Dunes right-of-way. 35. The design ofthe parkiriglot layouts,blkeways,ardsite driveways shall be subject to the review ofthe City Engineer and DirectorofPlanaing and Building during therivalPlamiedDevelopment District and construction documentreviewprocess to ensure cornpliancewith City access and design standards. qC8 L .I ... a. 13ikewayplans,including fencing,barriers arid signing shallbe submitted for review and approval of the Director of Planning and Building with proposed Phase I improvements installed prior to completion of Phase I. b, The bikeway alignment shall be subj cot to final approval by the Director of planning and Building and the City Engineer. The applicant shall seek an easementfrom the Iliverside County Flood Control Districtand any Indianland owners along the northern edge of the Tahquitz Wash to locate ameandedng bike path.Should thisbe unsuccessful,the bike path will be located on the southom perimeter of the Desert Chapel site as indicated on preliminary plans. C. A new bilce path ramp shall be installed over the curb where the Mesquite Country Clubbike path lntercepts flee bikepath on Desert Chapel property to the satisfaction of the Director of Planning and Building. d. A solid soreea shallbe installedbetweenthe school and the bikewaywhenthe bikeway is relocated. e. The area adjacent to thebikeway,(either attheTahquitzWashoratthe,soudtern perimeter oftheDesert Chapel site)shallbe efeaned and landscaped subjectto the approval of the Director of Planning and Building. 36. Thoproject propoocrushould coca dinato with SuaLine Transit agency regarding the need For transit facilities prior to plan submittal for Phase I. 37, An architectural embellishment,plan shallbe submitted fortheproposed modular buildings.The plan should include exterior finish materials,screening ofinecbanicalegiupment,and ascreenwall witlilandscapinginfrontofallmodularclassrooms.Theplan shallbe submitted for review and approvalby the Director of Planning and Building with Phase I final development plans and implemented in conjunction with the addition of any additionalmodular units.The Planting Cotnmissionreserves the rightto requiropermanambuildings for all classrooms ifit is determined That the existing and proposed modularclassroorns cannot meet community design standards comparable to new structures. 38. The oleander screening alongthe northcrnpropetyline shall be maintained to the satisfaction of the DirectorofPlamungand➢tdlding.Thernin'unumheightat tri n ningshallbesevea(7)feer.All deadplants sliallbereplacedwithmaturelredgematerial with aminffitumheightofseven(7)feet. 39. Evening outdoor activities at the subject site shall cease at 10:00 P.M.unless special time extensions are granted by the Director of Planning and Building and/or the Chief of Police. 40. No public address system shall be allowed other than for emergency service. POLICE DEPARTMENT: 41, Developer shall comply with section II of Chapter 8.04 of the Palm Springs Municipal Code, WASTE DISPOSAL SERVICES: 42, The location of the trash enclosure is acceptable subject to approved construction details approved by the Director of Building and Safety consistent with approved City details. BUILDING DEPARTMENT: 43. Prior to any construction on-site,all appropriate permits must be secured. FIRE: 44: Construction shall be in accordance with the 1994 Uniform Fire Code with 1995 California ameadnrents,1994U1iiformBuilding Codowith 1995 California amendments,City of Palm Springs Ordinance 1523,NFPA 13,NFPA 72 and Desert Water Agency requirements. 45: Submit detailedplans forreview,Plans fox both phases to be submitted separately.Plans must show type of construction and total square footage for each existing building with new construction square footage. 46. Fire Department Access Roads shall beprovided and maintained inaccordancewith the 1994 Uniform Fire Code,Article 9,Sections 902.1. 47. Construction site fencing required per City of Palm Springs Ordinance 1523 combustible construction is 5,000 Sq.Ft.or more or if the Fire Marshal dooms necessary. Aconstmetionsitu guard is required for combustible construction is over 10,000 Sq,Ft.or if the Fire Marshal deems necessary. 49. Fire apparatus access gate(s)areTNuired and shallbe a armitnum of 14'inwidth.Gate(s)shall be equipped with a KNOX locking device or key box per Uniform Fire Code,Article 9,Sec. 902.4. Contact this office for KNOX application Ibma. 49. Provide a garden base orhoses on constructionsito equipped with an adjustable spray nozzle capable of reaching all combustible construction. 50. An operational fire hydrant(&)capable ofprovidingrequirel GPM shallbe installed within 250 feet of all new combustible construction. 51. Contact Desert WaterAgencyto ascertain ifexisfing water system and fire hydrants as shown in Desert Water Agency Map BookPage 94-424-NW and fire hydraut#1256 can meet required fire flow. 52. ContactDesonWalerAgencyregazding proposed abandomneulofthe existing wateraminon Sunny Dnnes Rd,East of S.Sunrise,that supplies fire hydrants 41256 and#1907. 53, Portablefire extinguishers shallbe installed inacconlance with 1994Uniform Fire Code.Provide one 2-Ai10-13:C fire extinguisher for every 75'of floor or grade travel distance.a. 54. AnAutomaduBreextutguishingsysternequipped with 24homumonitoringregiuredinaccordance with 1994U&bmiFire Code Article 10.Sec.1003,and 1994UnifonnBuilding Code,Chapter 3,4,5,9 and 10. 55. Fire Alarm System required. Installation and maintenance of a fire alarm system shall be in accordance with 1994 Uniform Fire Code,Article to,Sec. tOC7 and NFPA Pamphlet 72. 56, Further comments as conditions warrant. 57. Access roadways to be aminimurnof20feetof unobstructed width.This would also apply to any"hammerhead design"used for turn-a-rounds. clv 58. All buildings to be within 150 feet ofall access roadways and accessible on aminimumofthree sides, 59. Fire hydrants located at 300 foot intervals and within 250 feet of all new construction. 60. Buildings spaced within 15 feet of eae11 other are considered one building for fire sprinkler purposes. Any building larger than 3000 square.leot is required to be fire sprinklered, Adjusting the distance onn the portable classrooms maybe alternative to be considered in lieu of this requirement. 61. Previous comments still pertain to this site plan. ENGINEERING: The Engineedng bivision recommends tlhat iftltis applicationis approved,such approval is subject to the fallowing conditions being completed in compliance with City standards and ordinances: Before fnialaceeptanm o£theproject,all conditions listed below shallbecompletedto the satisfaction of the City Engineer, PHASE I STREETS 62, Any improvements within the street right-of-way require a City of Palm Springs EneroachmentPcnnit.Work shallbe allowed aceordingto Resolution 17950-Restricting Street Work on Major and Secondary Thoroughfares. 63. Submit street improvement plans prepared by a Registered Civil Engineer to the EngineeriugDivision.The plair(s)shallbe appmvedbythe CiLyEngineerpriorlo issuance of any grading or building permits. Minimum submittal shall include the following,IF applicable: A. Copy of signed Conditions of Approval from Planning Department. B. Str'eetVacationplatand all agreements andimprovemeutplans approvedby City Engineer,IF applicable. C. Proof of processing dedications of right-of-way,easements,encroachment agree mentsflicenses,covenants,reimbursement agreements,etc.required by these conditions. 64. Submit bikeway and driveway routes and plans to the City Engineer for review and approval prior to issuance of any grading or building permits. 65. Subruitwrittenproof of coordination with SunLine Transit Agency for on-sitetransit facilities prior to issuance of grading or building permits. {,Th