HomeMy WebLinkAbout10/21/2015 - STAFF REPORTS - 5.A.4��pp`M SA4
iy
V N
w
c44
1F0 %V1 CITY COUNCIL STAFF REPORT
DATE: OCTOBER 21, 2015
CONSENT CALENDAR
SUBJECT: MEASURE J "COMMUNITY PROJECTS" RECOMMENDATIONS —
APPROVAL OF THREE YEAR PLAN
FROM: David H. Ready, City Manager
SUMMARY
At its September 17, 2015 meeting, the Measure J Commission recommended a list of
Community Projects under the theme of "Pedestrian, Bicycle and Traffic Hot Spots" to
be funded by the City Council over a three fiscal year period. This recommendation is
the culmination of a lengthy Measure J Commission evaluation process, resulting from
their solicitation of community projects.
RECOMMENDATION:
Approve Measure J recommended three year "Community Projects" plan:
a) Fiscal Year 2015-16: Seventeen (17) projects estimated at $1,028,000;
b) Fiscal Year 2016-17: Twenty (20) projects estimated at $965,000;
c) Fiscal Year 2017-18: Nine (9) projects estimated at $1,202,000;
2. Authorize the City Manager to execute all budget transfers and amendments
necessary to effectuate the City Council actions, subject to annual budget
appropriations.
STAFF ANALYSIS:
In Fiscal Year 2014-15, the City Council approved the Measure J Commission's concept
of a $1,000,000 annual set -aside for Community Projects. As part of this process, the
Commission voted to endorse the theme "Pedestrian, Bicycle and Traffic Hot Spots" for
the initial round of applications.
Applications for these new projects were made available to the public and a total of 288
capital project suggestions were received from individuals, neighborhood organizations,
and businesses. Additionally, for project ideas that met the theme, the Measure J
Commission considered applications received during the previous round of funding in
ITEM NO. �L
aPA`M Spy
iZ
c
V N
Rx °O"roauco 0 »
Cq4 FOR N�P CITY COUNCIL STAFF REPORT
DATE: OCTOBER 21, 2015 NEW BUSINESS
SUBJECT: MEASURE J "COMMUNITY PROJECTS" RECOMMENDATIONS —
APPROVAL OF THREE YEAR PLAN
FROM: David H. Ready, City Manager
SUMMARY
At its September 17, 2015 meeting, the Measure J Commission recommended a list of
Community Projects under the theme of "Pedestrian, Bicycle and Traffic Hot Spots" to
be funded by the City Council over a three fiscal year period. This recommendation is
the culmination of a lengthy Measure J Commission evaluation process, resulting from
their solicitation of community projects.
RECOMMENDATION:
Approve Measure J recommended three year "Community Projects" plan:
a) Fiscal Year 2015-16: Seventeen (17) projects estimated at $1,028,000;
b) Fiscal Year 2016-17: Twenty (20) projects estimated at $965,000;
c) Fiscal Year 2017-18: Nine (9) projects estimated at $1,202,000;
2. Authorize the City Manager to execute all budget transfers and amendments
necessary to effectuate the City Council actions, subject to annual budget
appropriations.
STAFF ANALYSIS:
In Fiscal Year 2014-15, the City Council approved the Measure J Commission's concept
of a $1,000,000 annual set -aside for Community Projects. As part of this process, the
Commission voted to endorse the theme "Pedestrian, Bicycle and Traffic Hot Spots" for
the initial round of applications.
Applications for these new projects were made available to the public and a total of 288
capital project suggestions were received from individuals, neighborhood organizations,
and businesses. Additionally, for project ideas that met the theme, the Measure J
Commission considered applications received during the previous round of funding in
Item No. 5.A.
City Council Staff Report
October 21, 2015 -- Page 2
Measure J Funding
2013. Due to the amount of applications, the Commission decided to recommend that
the City Council approve a three-year plan utilizing the same theme.
It should be noted that several of the recommended projects still require additional
review by Public Works; further, some projects may also require additional Engineering
studies.
Measure J Funding Recommendations to the City Council:
2015-2016 Recommendations:
Project
Project
Recommended
Title
Notes
for 2015-2016
Alvarado / E Alejo
Red curbs needed at intersection to
improve visibility / safety
$ 625
Amado / Alvarado
Stop Signs
2,500
Arenas / Baristo between Belardo & Tennis
Club Hotel / Baristo
Sidewalks and lighting
33,750
Baristo between Farrell & Sunrise
Sidewalks and lighting
96,250
Baristo from Belardo to Spencers
---------------------------------------------- - - --
Sidewalks and lighting
96,250
Extend red painted curbs: improve
Camino Real / Twin Palms by ACE Hotel
intersection visibility / safety
625
Cahuilla Elementry, curbs sidewalks -
Camino Real between S Riverside / Indian Trail
W side of Camino Real
273,500
Sidewalks: fill in this busy pedestrian
E. Palm Canyon, N side, Deepwell to Marcos
corridor
89,100
Indian Cyn Between Mel & Vista Chino
Sidewalks - fill in gaps
96,250
Traffic Calming Study for various
Ryan Snyder Traffic Calming Study
listed locations
60,000
ISaturmino / Arenas
SSignage caution or slow children
16,000
ISonora between Farrell / El Cielo
Signs/limiting vehicle weight on street
1,250
Dunes between Palm Cyn / Calle Amigo
Tachevah / Sunrise
Tahquitz / Caballeros
Tamarisk at Indian Canyon
JVia Escuela / N Palm Canyon
Sidewalks & Bike Lanes consistency /
traffic calming 256,250
Signage for dip as Tachevah enters
and exits Sunrise intersection 625
Red curbs at 4 corners of
intersections for visibility 625
Generous red curbs for increased
visibility 625
l Warrant analysis for potential signal 3,000
Total) $ 1,027,225
02
City Council Staff Report
October 21, 2015 -- Page 3
Measure J Funding
2016-2017 Recommendations:
Project
Project
Recommended
Title
Notes
for 2016-2017
jAmado between Farrell -I Sunrise
Sidewalks (north side)
$ 213,750
Andreas Hills Drive
Replace signs with -Stop signs
2,500
- -----------------_-_-_-------------
E Palm Canyon / LaVerne/Sunrise
-Yield
Right turn on red after stop
625
E. Palm Canyon / S Palm Canyon
Crosswalk mid -block with beacons.
43,750
lEastgate / Rosa Parks
Traffic Calming and 4 Way stop sign
2,500
Farrell / Ramon
Mesquite CC trail crossing
75,000
Yellow signs with black arrows
Farrell / San Joaquin
(flashing beacon)
12,500
�La Verne / Lilliana
Crosswaand lk stop sign
7,500
�La Verne / S. Palm Canyon
4-way stop
2,500 1
Traffic Signal to facilitate pedestrian
La Verne / Twin Palms
and / or bicycle crossing
200,000
Murray Canyon / S. Palm Canyon
3-Way Stop Sign
3,750
Murray Canyon 16. Palm Canyon
--- -- ------ - - - - -- - - - - - ---- - - -
Sidewalk Kings to Toledo
- - - - -- -- ----------- - -- - -- -- - - - -
173,750
---------------------------
Palo Fierro between Twin Palms / LaVerne
Traffic Calming
15,000
Racquet Club / Indian
Crosswalks
5,000 1
Racquet Club between Farrell / Cerritos
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sidewalks - fill in gaps
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
54,900
-----------------------------------
S Palm Can on -Drive
- ------------ ---y---------------------------------------------------------
Bike lanes, sidewalks
- -- -- ----- ---- - -- -- ---------- ------ --- -- ---- --
26,200
Sonora (Sunrise
Crosswalk &Pedestrian Crossing Lt
68,750
------------------ ----- ---_ _ _ _
Sonora I Palo Fierro
_
4-Way Stop
_ _
3,750
Pedestrian lighting continuous along
Tahquitz Cyn / Indian to Renaissance Hotel
sidewalk
51,7-50
-- ---
-----------
-- i---hun---only
g----------
_----------------------------------
- -
625
Totall $ 964,100
2017-2018 Recommendations:
Project
Title
Project
Notes
Recommended
for2017-2018
Crossley / 34th Marked Crosswalk $ 5,000
- ----- ---- - ------------------------------------------------- - 7,7 0
Crossley /Dinah Shore Sidewalks 327,700
Paseo El Mirador between Sunrise I Sidewalks & bike lanes; traffic calming
Caballeros
business travel, no bike lanes
Racquet_Club I Cerritos ----------- Traffic Signal . _
----- - - ------------------------------------------------------------------
Racquet Club N Palm Cyn west to Cardillo Sidewalks
Racquet Club to Sunrise Sidewalks
Riverside Dr: Sunrise to S. Random Rd
/ Capri Circle_
I Farrell
ADA Curb Cuts on sidewalks
Crosswalk ------ --------------------- with -mid-block with beacons
Total
252,800
375,000
76,250
96,125
20,000
8, 000
---------------------------
41,250
$ 1,202,125
03
City Council Staff Report
October 21, 2015 -- Page 4
Measure J Funding
FISCAL IMPACT:
For the current Fiscal Year 2015-16, $1,000,000 is appropriated in the Measure J
Community Projects account. The Commission recommends transferring an additional
$28,000 from the Measure J Project Contingency Reserve to complete funding for
projects this year.
City Council approval of this three-year plan will also earmark approximately $2,167,000
over the next two fiscal years to complete eighteen (18) projects (estimated cost
$965,000) for Fiscal Year 2016-17, and nine (9) projects (estimated cost $1,202,000) for
Fiscal Year 2017-18. Actual project bid prices will likely differ depending upon the
ultimate scope and timing of each project. Similarly, these "community projects," like
other "multi -year" projects approved by City Council (e.g. bike lanes, Buzz
transportation), will be designated as an earmark and require formal City Council
appropriation in each individual fiscal year.
Geoffrey KiA, David H. Ready, City
Director of Finance and Treasurer
Attachment:
Hot Spots 2015-2018 project worksheet
04
2015 Community Projects
Pedestrian, Bicycle and Traffic Hot Spots
10/15/2015
ITEM
2013
praj It
TITLE
Cost Estimate
COMMENTS
Staff Comments
$1 MM BUDGET
$1 MM BUDGET
$1 MM BUDGET
apes.
2015-2016
2016-2017
2017-2018
1
Alvarado / E Alejo during large events
$
625
Red curbs needed at intersection to improve visibility/safety
$
625
0
0
2
'•..__.
_ ..__.._..
274
_'---•--------'-'------------------------
Amado between Farrell /Sunrise
"-'------------
$
213,750
`--------------------------------------------'------------------------------------------------'--'-----------"`
Sidewalks (north side)
-----------'-------'----•-._.._.._......
$
-
$ 213,750
.
$ -
3
--'
- -----
47
'--------------"--'•----•----'-------------------
Amado / Alvarado
"------------"
$
2,500
.__.._.._.--•.___.___._.--•--•-......... -....-.-_----'-.....
Stop Signs
........... _..-..-_--------------------------------------- ---- --------
Study traffic when the Sorano project is underway.-
-----------------------------------
- '------------------
4
--
56
`--.
Andreas Hills Drive
. __...._._.............._._.._.. _ - -'"-'. _ ._.
$ 2,500
"- - - " -
Replace Yield signs with Stop signs Study required
- "- - - - -- - -"- - --- - - - - - - - - - - - "- - --------- ------_.---------------------•--.-----,
$
.__.._..__.._.......'•
-
$
2,500
- - -
$
- -
-
--'•-'••'
Arenas / Baristo between Belardo and Tennis Court
5
x
123
Hotel / Baristo
$
33,750
Sidewalks and lighting
Property owner concent: create Lighting Assessment District
$
33,750
$
-
$
-
276
Baristo between Farrell & Sunrise
96,250
Sidewalks and lighting
$
96,250
$
7
_ _
x
129
Baristo from Belardo to Spencers
p
�
96,250
Sidewalks and lighting
May require property owner consent_ Lighting Assessment Dist
$
96,250
$
- Y
-
$
-
8
-�
21
Camino Real / Twin Palms by ACE Hotel
$
625
Extend red painted curbs: improve intersection visibility/safety
$
625
$
-
$
-
9
-
86
Camino Real between S Riverside / Indian Trail
$
273,500
Cahuilla Elementry, curbs sidewalks-W side of Camino Real
Camino Real: San Lorenzo to Palo Fierro included in SRTS Grant
$ _-
-" 273,500-
$
_ -
$
-
10
_
91
Crossley / 34th
$
5,000
Marked Crosswalk
[Study required
$
-
$
-
$
5,000
11
_ -
- -
98
- - - - - - - - - -
Crossley / Dinah Shore
$
327,700
Sidewalks
Study required: Tribal land - South of Dinah Shore.
$
-
$
-
$
327,700
12
228
E Palm Canyon / LaVerne / Sunrise
$
625
Right turn on red after stop
Study required: E/S PC, LaVerne, Murray, Toledo Corridor project
$
-
$
625
$
-
13
'__.__.._----'-----------------"--'----------"--"-----•'---'---------'-----------------------------------------------
-" -
66/67
`-"-----
E. Palm Canyon / S Palm Canyon
$
43,750
-------------------- ----------------------------------'-'--'---'----------------
Crosswalk - mid -block with beacons
Study required
'---------------------'-----------------------'
$
-
$
43,750
--------'--------'----._-.
----------------'----
-
14
--------------------------'---""--"---"--"-"_ .'----"-..�_
E. Palm Canyon, N side, Deepwell to Marcos
$
89,100
__._"'_'_......._..._'_'__'_'
Sidewalks: fill in this busy_ pedestrian corridor
'._'_..-___.."-----___-•"--"--""-"-"--""--"---"-""--"--"-----"---
Sustainability Sidewalk survey
----------------
$
89,100
'--------"------------
$
-
- -
$
-
15
'------'
_
------28
Eastgate /Rosa Parks �--•------••_•••-'••-'-"•-•• •
$ _._.
2,500
_
Traffic Calming and 4 Way stop sign-_ __-.------------------------study
required. .-.._ ................ ' -'-• - --------. -• _.__._..
- -$. ------------
---
-$
-----------2,500-
- 5
-------------
16
'._._.__
.._'__._
209
.._._-"---"-----"-""----"-"-----"--"--"--"" -'"----"-----
Farrell / Ramon
$
75,000
---------------"--"---"---"---"--"-"------"----"--"-----
Mesquite CC trail crossing
-----------------------------------------_--------"
Study required: incorporate into the PW Farrell Corridor project
$
-
$
75,000
$
-
17
199
arrell / San Joaquin
$
Yellow signs with black arrows (flashing beacon)
tudy required: incorporate into the PW Farrell Corridor project
$
-
$
12,500
$
-
18
x
75
Indian Cyn between Mel & Vista Chino
$
-12_500
96,250
Sidewalks - fill in gaps
$
96,250
$
-
$
-
19
79
La Verne / Lilliana
$
7,500
Crosswalk and stop sign
Study required: E/S PC, LaVerne, Murray, Toledo Corridor proj
$
-
$
7,500
$
-
20
64
La Verne / S. Palm Canyon
$
2,500
4-way stop
Study required: E/S PC, LaVerne, Murray, Toledo Corridor prof.
$
-
$
2,500
$
21
43
La Verne / Twin Palms
$
200,000
Traffic Signal to facilitate pedestrian and/or bicycle crossing
Study required: E/S PC, LaVerne, Murray, Toledo Corridor proj
$
-
$
200,000
$
-
22
49
Mesquite between Farrell and Sunrise
$
10,000
Traffic calming
Road diet striping similar to El Cielo for traffic calming/pending
$
-
$
$
23
196
Mesquite W of Belardo
N/A
No place for pedestrians to walk
City PW Project No. 12--01 planned
- $
-
$
-
$
-
24
'-""--""
----'--"_
65
.-_----'--._----------------_-.------- - '
Murray Canyon / S. Palm Canyon
-"--"-"--"--,
$
3,750
..."-•--"----"-"-""-_•__•--_•----.- .-..-. .__..____..._..__..
3-Way Stop Sign
.___.._..-_-"------------"--"---------"--"---"--""---"-`
Study required: E/S PC, LaVerne, Murray, Toledo Corridor proj
` -----------'----'-
$
-
--------'--------"_-
$
3,750
- -------
$
------- -----------
-
25
---'
227
-----•-...-------------"--'--"••-""--._.•-•._.._.._.......-...r__..r
Murray Canyon / S. Palm Canyon
$ 173,750
Sidewalk Kings to Toledo
Study required: E/S PC, LaVerne, Murray, Toledo Corridor proj
$
-
$
173,750
$
----•-------------------
-
26
._..-....._...._.
166
.
Palo Fierro between Twin Palms / LaVerne
--- ------------- -----..._.---.._--------- - '
-.'--------`
$
---------
15,000
---"----"------"------"---------"--------"--------------"-----------'----------------------------_..__-__._..._.___.._...._.._...`
Traffic Calming
- ------------------------------------------------------'------------'-'-----------------------"-------
Study required: E/S PC, LaVerne, Murray, Toledo Corridor proj
- _.___..........---....
$
-
_
$
- -----------
15,000
-
$
-
193
Paseo El Mirador between Sunrise / Caballeros
$
252,800
Sidewalks & bike lanes; traffic calming- business travel, no bike
SW, C&G btw. Via Donna -Sunrise, Paving, & Bike lane striping.
27
lanes
Traffic calming study required ($24,000)
$
-
$
-
$
252,800
28
x
189
Racquet uetClub Cerritos
q /
Traffic Signal
tudy required -" -" "---"
$
-"
-
-
$
-
$
375,000
29
x
131
Racquet Club / Indian
_$ _-375,000
$
5,000
Crosswalks
_-"------_---"-"--"--"-"--
Approved SB821 Grant for Sidewalk-- funding for crosswalks_
-_
-
30
x
51
_
Racquet Club between Farrell / Cerritos
q
$
54,900
Sidewalks -fill in gaps
_
_ _$_ _ _
$
_
-
_ _$
� $
- _5_,0.00_
54,900
_ __$
$
-
31
x
229
Racquet Club N Palm n west to Cardillo
q Cy
$
76,250
Sidewalks
$
-
$
-
$
76,250
32
x
84
Racquet Club to Sunrise
$
96,125
Sidewalks
$
-
$
-
$
96,125
33
Ryan Snyder Traffic Calming Study
$
60,000
Traffic Calming Study far various listed locations
$
60,000
$
-
$
-
34
181
S Palm Canyon Drive
$
26,200
-------------------
Bike lanes, sidewalks
Estim. for SW. - Bike lanes on CP.14-14 (Murray-Belardo)
$
-
$
26,200
- $
-
35
'"--"_"--
-
240
..____..__.-_.-.
5 Riverside Or: Sunrise to S. Random Rd
$
20,000
__r.-..-._'._.'._.'-'_M"'_'__...__.._._.___._..--_.._..�..__'-_....-.___'•-"-_..._..__.__.__.___..--"---"-"------"-
Traffic calming
Study required: traffic calming
-'._--------"--'
$
-
^ ""------"-""--------'
$
-
--------------'
$
20,000
36
'---------
--------
182
-_.._..-_-_.__..__..__.._...._..._..___.-_---".....'-'-•.-.-_.--
Saturmino / Arenas
^-------------- --- ----------------------
$
"-•------'--
16,000
----------------------"---------------------"--------------------"----------------_--
Signage caution or slow children
............._.__._._..._..__.r...---'--'_-_._
Signage and traffic calming
......_..........._.._......._.
- $
16,000
_ _.._...�..-•-'--'-...
$
^ '---
-
------ ----------
_ __._.__----'------'•'
$
- -------------""__••..__
-
37
210
Sonora / Sunrise
$
68,750
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------'-----------------------"------`
Crosswalk & Pedestrian Crossing Lt
Study required .
----------------------------
$
-
$
68,750
$
-
38
'-"--'
_ --"----
58
--_._..--"---------- --------------"-"--"
Sonora / Capri Circle
"-"---"----"-"
$
8,000
----"•-" ._..___.__...--"_____.___.__._____..�..__.-.___..-'-"- _
ADA Curb Cuts on sidewalks 'Two ADA Ramps
-----_.___------------'
$
-
- "--"------------------
$
-
- ---------------"-"__.....
$
8,000
39
.03/105
Sonora / Farrell
$
41,250
Crosswalk- mid -block with beacons
Study required: incorporate into the Farrell Corridor project
$
-
$
-
$
41,250
40
250
Sonora between Farrell / El Cielo
$
1,250
Signs/limiting vehicle weight on street
post signage limiting truck traffic on Sonora
$
1,250
$
-
$
-
41
----.,.
---286
Sonora/Palo Fierro"-•"_'�__..-..-------'-$----3,750
_
4-Way Stop ---------------------'•-----------study
required------------------------------------------------------....5-•--•---'-.---"-$.__..-_...__3,750
-'$••-•'•'•--------
85/270
Sunny Dunes between Palm Cyn / Calle Amigo
$
256,250
Sidewalks & Bike Lanes consistency/ traffic calming
Bike lanes will be added following slurry seal/road diet with bike
42
lane stripping/lower speed limit
$
256,250
$
-
$
-
43
46
Sunrise & Francis
$
375,000
Traffic Signal
Study required
$
-
$
-
$
-
44
'-'--•..
87
--------------------- -------__.'-------------- '
Sunrise North to San Raphael
p
-------------
$
102,500
_ - -
Sidewalks
-
$
-
$
-
$
-
45 33 Tachevah / Sunise $ 625 Signage for dip as Tachevah enters and exits Sunrise Intersection Install "dip" signage on Tachevah alerting drivers to the dip $ 625 $ - $ -
2015 Community Projects 10/15/2015
Pedestrian, Bicycle and Traffic Hot Spots
ITEM
2013 proj k
TITLE Cost Estimate
COMMENTS
Staff Comments
$1 MM BUDGET
$1 MM BUDGET
$1 MM BUDGET
apps.
1
2015-2016
2016-2017
2017-2018
46
150
Tahquitz / Caballeros $
625
Red curbs at 4 corners of intersections for visibility
$
625
$
-
$
-
47
2
Tahquitz Canyon and Palm Canyon Dr $
-
Pedestrian all walk all directions at intersection
Included in synchronization project
$
-
$
-
$
-
48
23
Tahquitz Cyn / Indian to Renaissance Hotel $
51,750
Pedestrian lighting continuous along sidewalk
5luminaires north side, 7 south side
$
--••---........._...--`----
-
$
._...—.__.._...._-..----------------------
51,750
$
-
49
'---'---------------------------------------------'------------`------------.—_----_.-------------------__._.__...—._—.—..r__.._.W_-•--•---•-••---••--•.._...—•••-••—•--••--•---
279
Tamarisk at Indian Canyon $
625
Generous red curbs for increased visibility
$
625
$
-
$
-
50
Via Escuela / N Palm Canyon $
3,000
Warrant analysis for potential signal
Funding for Signal warrant for crosswalk
$
3,000
$
-
$
-
51
44
Via Escuela / Sunrise Way $
625
Right Turn only
---------------------
$
-
$
625
$
-
52
--_" —__--'-..
x 147
_------__.__.._—.__------•---__._.._.—_.__..
Via Roberto Miguel (VRM) $
_
-
'.----------------------------......-.-_-_........._..._--....-_..._-._-----------------------------------------------------------------'
Traffic Calming
Done: Speed Bumps at 4locations _
$
-
- ---
$
--------------------- -
-
----------'---'
$
-
53
....................--'--.....
x 146
Vista Chino South side btn Farrell / VRM $
262,500
-.....................................................__........._—._.._...—._._......................._.....
Sidewalks between VC and wall of neighborhood
._....................__................................_.—.__.._........................—.........._................._-
more information needed!
•-•--•._------.----------
$
-
--....._.........I..........I........—
$
..... .... _
-
....
$
...__........_...._.._.....--
-
-
- --- —
_Total for recommendations $
-
3 943 450
$
1,027,225
$
964,100
$
1,202,125
------------ ------------- -------- ------- -•...`•`-"`_-`-........ ..........._....._.......__......._.._...
_........._.__.—.._..._------.__.._____._.------------------ ----
--'---------------------------------------- ------------------------- ------- -
--------------
-----------
- �--------------------
-
'-----------------
Total of budgeted recommendations: $
3,193,450
$
1,027,225
$
964,100
$
1,202,125
Traffic Study needed or other funding available
added theme appropriate 2013 MJOC projects
& Sustainability sidewalk survey
added additional 2015 projects
projects that are scheduled by PW, completed,
located on Tribal land, funded through different programs or grants.
Please Note: Many projects are suggested by an individual or a neighborhood. Public Works will vet each project with the neighborhood or the residents in the area
surrounding the suggested project as required by ordinance. Before starting a project and in consideration of all the variables, Public Works will determine the best
remedy for the issue submitted. Many projects will require additional study. Projects may also be re -prioritized if Engineering determines that it is a more cost-effective approach.
06