HomeMy WebLinkAbout6/23/2016 - STAFF REPORTS - 1.C. iy
e
V N
q c qr
.Ogq(f0
c4<I�oaN`P CITY COUNCIL STAFF REPORT
DATE: June 23, 2016 STUDY SESSION
SUBJECT: DISCUSSION REGARDING MANDATORY SOLAR INSTALLATION
POLICY FOR NEW CONSTRUCTION.
FROM: David H. Ready, City Manager
BY: Office of Sustainability
SUMMARY
This item is being presented to discuss mandating solar energy installations for new
construction by amendment of certain provisions of chapter 8.04 and adding section
8.04.71 relating to mandating.
RECOMMENDATION:
Provide direction to staff as appropriate.
BACKGROUND
The California Building Standards Commission approved the 2016 California Building
Standards Code and this code will become effective on January 1, 2017. Health and
Safety Code Sections 17958.7 and 18941.5 provide that the City may make changes or
modifications to the building standards contained in the California Building Standards
Code based upon express findings that such changes or modifications are reasonably
necessary because of local climatic, geological or topographical conditions. Section
101 .7.1 of the California Green Building Standards Code further provides that for the
purposes of local amendments to the California Green Building Standards Code, local
climatic, geological or topographical conditions may include local environmental
conditions as established by the City.
On May 17, 2016, the Palm Springs Sustainability Commission discussed making
recommendations to the City Council regarding proposed local amendments to the 2016
California Green Building Standards Code, and local climatic, geological and
topographical conditions as related to mandating solar energy installations on new or re-
modeled construction projects. At that meeting, the Sustainability Commission Green
Building/Solar Subcommittee recommended that the City Council adopt a resolution to
ITEM NO. -' 'Co '
City Council Staff Report
June 23, 2016- Page 2
Discussion of Solar Energy Ordinance Chapter 8
mandate solar making necessary local findings and adopt local amendments to the
2016 California Green Building Standards Code.
STAFF ANALYSIS:
The production of electricity by solar energy systems provides an environmentally
friendly source of renewable energy thereby reducing the City's dependency on fossil
fuels and greenhouse gas emissions. In 2016, California has seen a growing trend in
the number of cities passing ordinances requiring all new buildings and additions to put
up solar voltaic panels. The City's Sustainability Commission Subcommittee on Green
Building/Solar began discussion of this issue and started researching green building
and solar policies towards the end of 2015.
The Sustainability Commission's Green Building/Solar Subcommittee met on May 18,
2016 with the City's Director of Building and Safety, Solar Plans Examiner and
Sustainability Manager to review a proposed ordinance. It was suggested that a
phased approach to implementing new solar mandates affect single family new
construction first. In addition, the Desert Valley Builders Association (DVBA) was
contacted and met with staff on May 25, 2016 to review the proposed regulation. The
DVBA preferred a phased approach a and requested that a number of public input
meetings including all stakeholders such as the building industry, chamber of commerce
and neighborhood groups be conducted prior to potential adoption. The DVBA also
stated that they would like to see more remodels and old housing stock be upgraded to
meet the new energy efficiency standards.
On June 15, 2016 the Sustainability commission Green Building/Solar Subcommittee
met again with City Staff and the City Council subcommittee on sustainability. At that
meeting further recommendations were made and revisions to a draft ordinance
prepared by the Sustainability Commission Sub-Committee were recommended. The
draft ordinance prepared by the subcommittee requiring solar systems has not yet been
reviewed by the City Attorney.
The Sustainability Commission Green Building/Solar Subcommittee has reviewed the
existing city building code as well as examples of solar mandates brought forward by
other California cities. Other California cities have considered the advantages of solar
installations and have adopted ordinances requiring them in new construction.
Lancaster and Sebastopol adopted mandatory solar ordinances in 2013, and San
Francisco and Santa Monica have also recently adopted ordinances. The Sebastopol
ordinance requires solar to be installed in the event of large additions, remodels,
alterations or repairs to an existing building.
In light of these recent ordinance adoptions across the state, the Sustainability
Commission Green Building/Solar Subcommittee has provided a proposed draft
ordinance which limits the proposed mandate to residential construction for staff to
review and consider. The new regulation proposes that new residential buildings, and
specific alterations, additions and remodels require the installation of a solar electric
02
City Council Staff Report
June 23, 2016- Page 3
Discussion of Solar Energy Ordinance Chapter 8
photovoltaic (PV) energy generation system with a nameplate wattage 2.0 times or
greater than the square footage of the home (2.0 watts per square foot). These projects
include:
• All new residential construction; i.e., one-and-two family dwellings, multi-family
dwellings (three stories or less), and high-rise residential dwellings.
• Any addition to an existing residential building that increases the square footage
by 25% or greater, provided that the increase is at least 500 square feet
• All residential remodels, alterations or repairs that are made involving demolition,
remodel or repair of more than 50% of the structure or that have a permit
valuation of$200,000 or more.
If any of the above criteria are met then at the time of submittal of a building permit
application an applicant would be required to submit plans and specifications for a solar
photovoltaic system to be included with application.
As an alternative for new one-and-two family dwellings and significant single-family
additions and alterations, the builder / homeowner could install a solar system or other
renewable energy system that will offset 75% - 100% of anticipated energy usage, or
design single-family home or duplex to reduce annual energy usage below the allowed
energy budget established by the California Energy Code by same amount of kilowatt
hours as would be produced by solar system of 2.0 watts per square foot.
FISCAL IMPACT
Unknown at this time.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT:
Staff finds that discussion of implementing requirements for solar installations is not a
"project" under the California Environmental Quality Act, because the adoption of the
ordinance does not involve any commitment to a specific project which may result in a
potentially significant physical impact on the environment, as contemplated by Title 14,
California Code of Regulations, Section 15378(b)(4). Therefore no negative
environmental impact is noted.
03
City Council Staff Report
June 23, 2016 - Page 4
Discussion of Solar Energy Ordinance Chapter 8
SUBMITTED:
A 4L
Ichele Mi ian, LEED GA Marcus Fuller, PE, PLS
Manager, Office of Sustainability Assistant City Manager
David H. Ready, Es .
City Manager
Attachments:
1. Draft Ordinance
2. Sustainability Commission Green Building / Solar Subcommittee Recommendations
for Joint Study Session with City Council June 23, 2016
04
06-23-2016
ATTACHMENT 1
DRAFT SOLAR ORDINANCE
05
ORDINANCE NO.
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS,
CALIFORNIA, UPDATING CHAPTER 8.04 OF THE PALM
SPRINGS MUNICIPAL CODE, RELATING TO SOLAR
ENERGY SYSTEM INSTALLATION REQUIREMENTS.
City Attorney's Summary
This Ordinance amends Chapter 8.04 of the City's Municipal Code to require the
installation of a solar electric photovoltaic (PV) system in all new residential
construction. It also requires the installation of a PV system in the case of significant
additions, remodels, alterations or renovations to existing single-family residential
buildings.
The City Council of the City of Palm Springs ordains:
SECTION 1. Chapter 8.04 of the Palm Springs Municipal Code is amended to
add:
8.04.071. Solar Requirements.
The California Green Building Standards Code adopted herein by reference is
hereby modified by the following additions:
4.201.2 Residential Solar Photovoltaic Installations.
1. All new one-and-two family dwellings are required to install a solar electric
photovoltaic (PV) system. The required installation of the PV system shall be
implemented using one of the following methods:
(a) Install a solar PV system with a minimum total wattage 2.0 times
the square footage of the dwelling (2.0 watts per square foot); or
(b) Install a solar PV system or other renewable energy system that will
offset 75-100% of the Time Dependent Valuation (TDV) energy budget; or
(c) Demonstrate that the Time Dependent Valuation (TDV) energy
budget is reduced by the same wattage required by 1(a).
2. The requirements set out in subdivision 1 of this Section shall also apply in
the following cases:
(a) Any addition to an existing single-family residential building that
increases the square footage by 25% or greater, provided that the
increase is at least 500 square feet; or
(b) All single-family residential remodels, alterations or renovations that
06
are made involving demolition, remodel or renovation of more than 50% of
the structure or that have a permit valuation of $200,000 or more.
3. At the time of submittal of a building permit application for a project
meeting the thresholds set out in subdivisions 1 and 2 of this Section, an
applicant shall be required to submit plans and specifications for a solar
photovoltaic system included in the submittal application.
4.201.3. Low-Rise Residential Solar Photovoltaic Installations.
All new Low-Rise Residential dwellings are required to install a solar electric
photovoltaic (PV) system. The required installation of the PV system shall be
implemented by installing a solar PV system with a minimum total wattage 2.0
times the square footage of the building footprint (2.0 watts per square foot). The
provisions of subdivision 3 of Section 4.201 shall also apply.
5.201.2 High-Rise Residential Solar Photovoltaic Installation.
All new high-rise residential buildings are required to install a solar electric
photovoltaic (PV) system. The required installation of the PV system shall be
implemented by installing a solar PV system with a minimum total wattage 2.0
times the square footage of the building footprint (2.0 watts per square foot). The
provisions of subdivision 3 of Section 4.201 shall also apply.
8.04.072. Appeals.
A person aggrieved by an action taken by the city may appeal the action
pursuant to Chapter 2.05 of the Palm Springs Municipal Code.
SECTION 2. EFFECTIVE DATE. The Mayor shall sign and the City Clerk shall certify
to the passage and adoption of this Ordinance and shall cause the same, or the
summary thereof, to be published and posted pursuant to the provisions of law and this
Ordinance shall take effect thirty (30) days after passage.
SECTION 3. SEVERABILITY. If any section, subsection or clause of this Ordinance
shall be deemed to be unconstitutional or otherwise invalid, the validity of the remaining
section, subsection and clauses shall not be affected thereby.
SECTION 4. The Mayor shall sign and the City Clerk shall certify to the passage and
adoption of this Ordinance and shall cause the same, or the summary thereof, to be
published and posted pursuant to the provisions of law and this Ordinance shall take
effect thirty (30) days after passage.
07
PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED BY THE PALM SPRINGS CITY
COUNCIL THIS DAY OF , 2016.
ROBERT MOON, MAYOR
ATTEST:
JAMES THOMPSON, CITY CLERK
CERTIFICATION
STATE OF CALIFORNIA )
COUNTY OF RIVERSIDE ) ss.
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS )
I, JAMES THOMPSON, City Clerk of the City of Palm Springs, California, do
hereby certify that Ordinance No. is a full, true, and correct copy, and introduced
by the City Council at a regular meeting held , and adopted at a regular meeting of
the City Council held on this _, by the following vote:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
ABSTAIN:
JAMES THOMPSON, CITY CLERK
City of Palm Springs, California
08
M
Sustainability Commission Green Building / Solar Subcommittee
Recommendations
for Joint Study Session with City Council June 23, 2016
I. Introduction
The Sustainability Commission Green Building / Solar Subcommittee, together
with Planning Commission liaison Lisa Middleton has met several times over the
past few months to consider recommendations to the full Commission and City
Council on ways to establish the City as a leader in energy efficient and
environmentally sustainable development and planning practices, in line with the
objectives set out in the General Plan adopted in 2007, the 2013 Climate Action
Plan and the new Sustainability Plan. The Subcommittee has also received input
from Sustainability Manager Michele Mician, Building Director Jim Zicaro,
Assistant City Manager / City Engineer Marcus Fuller, and Mayor Robert Moon
and Councilmember Geoff Kors, the members of the City Council's Sustainability
Subcommittee.
The 2007 General Plan establishes ambitious objectives for green building and
planning practices. In particular, the General Plan sets out as policy goals
requiring the use of energy-efficient and green building practices and requiring
the use of green building techniques in the design and construction of public
buildings and facilities (Goal CD29, page 9-62). The 2013 Climate Action Plan
also suggests that we advance the voluntary green building program to a
mandatory green building requirement for residential buildings, with technical
support services (pages 25 - 26).
The Sustainability Plan calls on the City to develop strategies to reduce
community-wide contributions to greenhouse gas emissions to 1990 levels by
2020 and 80% below 1990 by 2050, encourage the building or retrofitting of one
million square feet of green buildings, reduce the total energy use by all buildings
built before 2012 by 10%, reduce energy use and carbon use from new homes
and buildings, and supply 50% of all energy from renewable sources by 2030
(pages 18, 33 and 50 - 51).
As noted in the Climate Action Plan, "building it right the first time" makes sense
from all kinds of standpoints. A 2013 study of the cost-effectiveness of rooftop
solar systems prepared in 2013 for the California Energy Commission confirmed
that installing solar electric systems on new residential and non-residential
buildings in the Palm Springs climate zone will be cost-efficient in 2017 and
2020. Indeed, the estimated return on investment for a solar installation new
construction over a 20-year period is five times the cost of the initial installation.
09
II. Solar Recommendations
Other California cities have considered the advantages of solar installations and
have adopted ordinances requiring them in new construction. Lancaster and
Sebastopol adopted mandatory solar ordinances in 2013, and San Francisco and
Santa Monica have just done so. The Sebastopol ordinance also requires solar
to be installed in the event of large additions, remodels, alterations or repairs to
an existing building. With its constant sunshine and deep local pool of solar
installers, it is time for Palm Springs to lead the way in the Coachella Valley on
this issue.
The Green Building / Solar Subcommittee thus recommends that the City require
the installation of a solar electric photovoltaic (PV) system with a nameplate
wattage 2.0 times or greater than the square footage of the home (2.0 watts per
square foot). This requirement would be applicable to all new residential
construction; i.e., one-and-two family dwellings, multi-family dwellings (three
stories or less), and high-rise residential dwellings. The installation of a solar
electric photovoltaic system should also be required for any addition to an
existing single-family residential building that increases the square footage by
25% or greater, provided that the increase is at least 500 square feet, and all
single-family residential remodels, alterations or renovations that are made
involving demolition, remodel or renovation of more than 50% of the structure or
that have a permit valuation of $200,000 or more.
The Subcommittee also recommends requiring solar installation on commercial
building and will work with City staff to develop appropriate recommendations.
As an alternative for new one-and-two family dwellings and significant single-
family additions and alterations, the builder / homeowner could install a solar
system or other renewable energy system that will offset 75% - 100% of
anticipated energy usage, or design single-family home or duplex to reduce
annual energy usage below the allowed energy budget established by the
California Energy Code by same amount of kilowatt hours as would be produced
by solar system of 2.0 watts per square foot.
III. Green Building Recommendations
In September 2012, Palm Springs adopted the CVAG Green for Life Green
Building Program on a voluntary basis to increase building efficiency 15% over
current state requirements. The Program is in essence a LEED program that
CVAG has adapted to reflect the specific climate of the Coachella Valley. The
Palm Springs City Council recently decided to require the downtown
redevelopment project follow the "Green Tree" level of standards, and the
Planning Commission has done the same for the proposed Serena Park
development on the site of the former Palm Springs Country Club.
2 10
The Green Building Program Manual is an excellent resource for residents,
homeowners, building owners, designers, architects, contractors, developers and
building officials determine how they can design their building or remodeling
plans to include green building techniques and products. The City should require
its use (at the "Green Leaf' level) for significant single-family residential
additions, alterations remodels or renovations. As set out in the Sustainability
Plan (page 50), the City should also partner with CVAG to increase educational
and outreach efforts to the construction industry and local developers to
participate in the Green Building Program, with additional training as necessary
for relevant City staff so that they are familiar with the program and can provide
counter assistance on what measures are available to increase building
efficiency.
In addition to the above compliance with the Green Building Program, certain
energy and water efficiency measures should be made mandatory for significant
single-family additions, remodels, alterations or renovations. The Building
Department has proposed a list of measures in consultation with the Green
Building / Solar Subcommittee, as identified in the accompanying Staff Report.
IV. Procedural Recommendations
Taking account of feedback on the above recommendations from the full
Sustainability Commission and City Council at our joint study session on June
23. the Green Building / Solar Subcommittee will work over the summer with
relevant City staff to refine the proposals and review draft green building and
solar ordinances and accompanying findings resolutions. The Subcommittee will
also liaise as appropriate with the Planning Commission.
Study sessions with stakeholders should be scheduled for the fall, prior to
submitting draft texts to the full Sustainability and Planning Commissions and
City Council for their consideration. The green building standards described
above should take effect on January 1, 2017, simultaneously with the
effectiveness of the 2016 Building Codes. Final adoption of the solar ordinance
would most likely be in late 2016, following the required approval by the
California Energy Commission.
Respectfully submitted,
Sustainability Commission Green Building / Solar Subcommittee
David Freedman
Nate Otto
Lisa Middleton, Planning Commission liaison
3 � 1
Mandatory Solar is a Benefit for the Consumer and the
Developer
Based on 2000 Sqft house using 15,000 kWh of power per year—The typical range is from
10,000-20,000kWh per year for a 2000 sqft energy efficient home.The Cost of house or
amount financed on house is based at$350,000-
The Proposed Mandatory Solar Initiation is 2 watts per Sqft—2 x 2000=4000=4 kW solar
system.
System cost concurrent with new construction would be$15,000 minus a $4,500 Federal Tax
Credit. Giving a Net cost to the consumer of$10,500.
A 4 kW system will produce 6,000 Plus kilowatt hours per year
Current Cost of electricity is$0.16-$0.29 a kW ($0.18 was used for estimations.)
Annual cost of Electricity Without Solar $3,196 Monthly $266
Annual cost of Electricity With Solar $1,620 Monthly $135
Net Savings $1,576 $131
$350,000 House Cost $350,000 @ 4%for 30 years=$1,670 per month
$15,000 Solar system $15,000 @ 4%for 30 years = $72 per month
$365,000 House Cost w/Solar $365,000 @ 4%for 30 years =$1,742 per month
Monthly cost of home No Solar (Mortgage and Electrical) $1,936
Monthly cost of home With Solar(Mortgage and Electrical and Solar) $1877
Net Savings Year 1 $59.00 per month $709 per year
Net Savings Year 5 $95.00 per month $1,140 per year
Net Savings Year 10 $150.00 per month $1,800 per year
Plus upon close of escrow you qualify for a $4,500 Federal Tax Credit!!!
,yam /. G
jv,dM r Trap 4%V
�oK,til;sio.�esL o rt0
2016 BOARD OF DIRECTORS
PRESIDENT
31"ncc)lai,e desert valleys builders association
Discocen Bilifdcc:
I" LICE PRESIDF.A'f'
Fred Bell June 22,2016
\obeli Pnerav Solutions
1"" VICE PRES/DEP'1'
City of Palm Springs
SECRETAR 11TREASURER Mayor Robert Moon, Honorable Members of the Council
Fileen eekc 3200 East Tahquitz Canyon Way
Pacific Premier Bank
VECE PRESIDENT Palm Springs, Ca 92262
OF ASSOCIATES
.Allan Le)in RE: Mandating Solar Installation—New Residential Construction
Allan Levin &Associates
PAST PRESfDLYT
Joseph hinties Dear Mayor Moon,
-first Bank
CHIEF E.IECL'T/VE OFFICER Thank you for including the Desert Valleys Builders Association in this discussion
Grcrchcn Gutierrez regarding the proposed mandating of solar installation on all new Single Family
Residences.
DIRECTORS
Brian Benedetti Construction
Benedetti
Brian Bene While recognizing the City of Palm Springs' desire to become a leader in
Mark Benedetti sustainability to both its residents and outside the community, mandating solar
BNIC Select Build onto the backs of one segment of users is not going to accomplish the City's
rn'n DuBn`c goals&objectives for reductions in greenhouse gas emissions for the entire
Development De>ien & @ngineerin�
Margaret Drurs community.
;Margaret Drun COn3trnn114111
.Mario Gonzales • The communities referenced in the presented Staff Report draw largely on
GHA Companies
Mark Gran, Coastal Communities and their specific needs. The Coachella Valley& its
Sd 14aok<ix Bwiness Censuhing
Toddd H residents have a unique weather climate unlike significant parts of the rest
Agun Caliente Band ofCahuilla lndians of California. Those communities have spent years in developing their
Da%"e Lippert programs and in one case—the City of Lancaster—has actually become their
Lippert Construction, htc own utility district, with direct energy purchased from So. California Edison
Heather Loutsenhizer
Petta Building group in an effort to assist all residents& businesses with their energy usage.
Paul Mahoncy
PMra Advsnising Deborah bicGarrer • Further,the proposed requirements for solar panel sizing& KwH generation
he Gas Company will, in all likelihood not be accepted by the current utility during an
Dan flie \fuaicr Uli'ucr e
Kethen application process. The current standard of practice is acceptance of 70-
Alan Pace 80%of generation from the individual applicant to the grid. Based on the
Petra Geotedinical proposal, each applicant will be overproducing to the grid,thereby negating
John Pookell.Jr.
Coachella vahec taaler Dish;ct any savings to the consumer and in all likelihood, possible rejection by the
Phil Smith utility.
Sunrise Contpam"
Ryan Smith
Shea Itomes
Patrick Soanhout
Habitat for Humanity
Jeff N attenhar?er
ll'atienbar_ger COn SlrUeLion
75100 Mediterranean • Palm Desert • CA 92211
(760) 776-7001 office • (760) 776-7002 fax � ' e
www.thedvba.org
2016 BOARD OF DIRECTORS R%A
PRESID /e
H,aee Maiw desert valleys builders association
Discocen Builders
1" VICE PRF.SIDQ:E
I ied Bell • Additionally, the cost of a fully installed,energized system will run from
\obeli Enerec Solutions
?^" 1 uE PR%smEa r $30K and up, depending on the total square footage of the residence.
SECRETARY/TREASURER While the initial costs would be borne by the homebuilder,the ultimate cost
Eileen EAe would be borne by the new homebuyer, thus continuing to drive home
Pacific Premier Bank pricing upwards within the City.
VICE PRESIDEA`T
OFASSOC'IATES Current California Building Codes require homebuilders to provide a "solar
Allan L Cin
-
AIlan 1 n in ,Y.Associates ready zone" in compliance with California Title 24, Part 6 Energy Standards—
:
PAST PRESIDENT Section 110.10.
Joseuh Ha�cs
F'nt Bank The California Building Codes are regularly updated,every three years. Part of
CHIEF EAPCUTIE OFIICER that process is to meet State of California Legislated goals related to the
c,retchen Gmic ie7 reduction of energy use,dependence on fossil fuels and the reduction in the
DIRECTORS production of greenhouse gas emissions.The goal for new construction is net
Brian Beoedem zero energy NZE homes by 2020, requiring energy conservation and generation
Brian Benedetti C'onetrucuon on-site.
Mark Benedetti
BMc select 8nim Tom DuBace California has the most stringent and strictly enforced 'green' construction
Dei elopinent Design z r?rginderi nu, policies of the nation. The next set of new standards are right around the
Margaret Brun- corner.
Margarei Drun Cou,rruciion
Mario Gonzales
WIA Companies The Desert Valleys Builders Association recommends:
Mark Aran • Continued Compliance with the current &future California Building Codes
Strictl7 Business(onsujting
Todd nooks requirements.
Agua Caliente Band orC ai,uiva Indians • The City of Palm Springs, together with CVAG,work to promote the
Dare Lippert successful use of"HERO", "YGrene" and other financing programs with
Lippert Construction. Inc
Ileatlier I outsenhizer actual numbers and interviews from their clientele and to further expand
I Bolding Group the message to existing residences& business.
Paulul M Mahoney
PMA Adtertising
Deborah McGarrc,
f'he Gas Company The Desert Valleys Builders Association has been a supporter of the HERO &
Dan Ohvier Ygrene programs, along with other programs that CVAG is in the process of
Nether} Mueller Oln icy developing for existing homeowners&businesses to use for adopting their
lan Petra a Geotechnical energy efficient needs. These programs offer both a source of valuable
John Po,+cI7.Jr. information for homeowners, as well as a variety of financing options to make
Coachella Vane% Water District their homes & businesses more environmentally friendly. We believe those
s Phil Smith programs should be expanded to reach all segments of the community.
Sunr ise Compant-
Rran Smith
Shea Homes
Patrick S«arthout
Habitat for Humanity
Jeff Nattenhareer
Rk attenbareer Construction
75100 Mediterranean • Palm Desert • CA 92211
(760) 776-7001 office • (760) 776-7002 fax
www.thedvba.org
2016 BOARD OP DIRECTORS
PRESIDENT
Bruc ,-sane desert valleys builders association
Disconn 13 uildere
I" VICE_PRESIDENT
I'cd Bell Once again,thank you for inviting the Desert Valleys Builders Association into
\obell Bmrgy Solutions
rKE PRESIDENT this discussion.We are the local construction industry resource. With our offices
in Palm Desert,we are well aware of the challenges our desert climate presents.
SE•CRET4Rr1TREASI;RER We are available to assist yourselves&city staff as you continue discussiing this
%9A
Eileen Eske
Pacific Premier Bank issue.
UCE PRESIDENT
OFASSOCIATES
Allan Levin espedfull ,
Allan L.cvin& Associates
PAST PRESIDENT
Joseph Hascs �t
First Bank �Gre en u 'errez
CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER Chief Ex utiv Officer
Gretchen Gutierrez
DIRECTORS
Brian Benedetti
Brian Benedetti C'onsiruction
dark Benedetti
BMC Selcct Build
Tom DuBoSe
Development Desisn& L n ,ineenrw
Nlarearet Drur-
.Margaret Drury Construction
Mario Gonzales
GHA Companies
Mark Gran
StTiCth Business Consulting
Todd Hooks
Agua Caliente Band of( dwilla Indian:
Da%c Lippert
Lippert Construction. Inc
Ileather Loutsenhizer
Penns Building Group
Paul Mahoncv
PMA Advertising
Dehoiah McGanc%
the Gas Company
Dan Olivier
Vether Mueller 01n ier
Alan Pacc
Petra Gcolechnical
John Poe ell-31.
Coachella valley Water District
Phil Smith
Sunrise Company
Ryan Smith
Shea Ilomes
Patrick S%�arthout
Habitat for Humanity'
Jeff Wattenharner
U attenbareer Construction
75100 Mediterranean to Palm Desert • CA 92211
(760) 776-7001 office • (760) 776-7002 fax
www.thedvba.org