HomeMy WebLinkAbout12/6/2006 - STAFF REPORTS - 2.U. �O�ppG.M3p� -
iy
41
I.1 N
W T'
* °horen�
cq<IFOR��p CITY COUNCIL STAFF REPORT
DATE: December 6, 2006 CONSENT CALENDAR
SUBJECT: CITY OF PALM SPRINGS DEVELOPMENT PROJECT FEE REPORT
FOR FISCAL YEAR 2005106
FROM: David H. Ready, City Manager
BY: Department of Finance and Treasury
SUMMARY
The City is required by Government Code Section 66000 to annually prepare a report
for the proceeding fiscal year concerning the activity of the City's development project
fees. The report must be submitted to the City Council within 180 days of the end of the
Fiscal year.
RECOMMENDATION:
Receive and File the City's Development Project Fee Report for Fiscal Year 2005/06
STAFF ANALYSIS:
In 1987, Government Code Section 66000 became effective with the passage of
Assembly Bill 1600. AB 1600 was enacted to regulate the establishment of any
new development fee or fee increase after January 1, 1989.
A key provision of the legislation, namely, Section 66006 (b) (1) of the
Government Code requires that local agency shall, within 180 days of the close
of each fiscal year, make available to the public the following information for each
separate account or fund:
(a) A brief description of the type of fee in the account-
(b) The amount of the fee.
(c) The beginning and ending balance of the account.
(d) The amount of fees collected and interest earned.
ITEM NO.��
City Council Staff Report
December 6, 2006 -- Page 2
Development Project Fee Report for FY 2005/06
(e) An identification of each public improvement on which fees were
expended and the amount of the expenditures on each improvement,
including the total percentage of the cost of the public improvement that
was funded with fees.
(f) An identification of an approximate date by which construction of the
public improvement will commence if the local agency determines that
sufficient funds have been collected to complete financing on an
incomplete public improvement, as identified in paragraph (2) of
subdivision (a) of Section 66001, and the public improvement remains
incomplete-
(g) A description of each interPund transfer or loan made from the account,
including the public improvement on which the transferred or loaned flees
will be expended. In the case of an interfund loan, an identification of that
date on which the loan will be repaid, and the rate of interest the account
will receive on the loan.
In FY 2005/06, the City has four developer project fees subject to the
requirements of Government Code Section 66000 -- Drainage Construction,
Public Arts, Quimby Act Park and Sewer Connection Fees. Staff has prepared
the reports that provide an analysis of each fee.
The attached reports have been submitted to the Building Industry Association
(BIA) for their review.
No other action is required by Council except to receive and file the report.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The City must expend or commit developer fees from Drainage Construction
Fund, Sewer Fund, Quimby Act Park Fund and Public Arts Fund within five years
of their receipt and these fees must be accounted for in a separate fund.
Craig A. raves, irector of Finance and L. Butzla istant City Manager-
Treas er 4drkinistrative, ; ices
f
David H. Ready, City Man
Attachments: Report
City of Palm Springs 1 1 11 5/2006
Government Code 66000 Calculation _
Wastewater Treatment Fund - # 420
Fiscal Year 2005106
The Wastewater Treatment Fund is used to account for revenue received from sewer connection fees. Fee calculation - see @Etched fee structure.
Beginning Ending
Fund FY 05106 Fund
Account Description Balance Transactions Balance
Revenues & Other Sources
Sewer Connection Fees 1,702,118
Total Sources
1,702,118
Expenditures & Other Uses
Total Uses
Total Available 1 (11,069,793) 1,702,118 {9,367,675)
Five Year Test T Using First In First Out Method
Expendit Net Not
andures Spent or
Collections Commitments Committed
Revenues collected from FY 90 1,499,505 336,261 1,163,244
Revenues collected from FY 91 948,013 665,989 282,024
Revenues collected from FY 92 1,036,148 652,458 383.690
Revenues collected from FY 93 268,821 637,986 (369,165)
Revenues collected from FY 94 163.751 622,457 (458,706]
Revenues collected From FY 95 896,218 2,138,856 (1,242,638]
Revenues collected from FY96 494,370 2,112,791 (1,618,421)
Revenues collected from FY97 446,938 2,163,155 (1,716,217]
Revenues collected from FY 98 583,414 2,227,765 (1,644.351)
Revenues collected from FY 99 666,435 2,155,890 (1,549.455]
Revenues collected from FY 00 628,288 2,235,000 {1,606,712]
Revenues collected from FY 01 621,709 2.225,000 (1,603.291) �—
'. Revenues collected from FY 02 _ 585,998 2.215,000 (1,629,002)
Revenues collected from FY 03 1,131,034 2,235,000 (1,103,986)
Revenues collected from FY 04 1.881.734 2,220.000 [338,267]
Revenues collected from FY 05 1,981.440 _ - 1.981,440
Revenues collected from FY 06 1,702,118 1,702,118
Total 15,475,934 24,843,608 {9,367,fi75]
Result: Five Year Spent or Committed Test Met
I �
Breakdown of Expenditures % Funded
Improvements FY 05l06 With Fee
100.00%
Total
7
ul
Jt � zcc5
WASTEWATER
Sewer Facility Fee (exclusive of street main charges or street lateral fee)
New construction shall pay the sewer facility fee in effect at the time a building permit is issued by
the City, and said facility fee shall be paid prior to the granting of a building permit. SaId facility fees
shall be deposited in the Sewer Fund
a) Residential units 7-1-05-6-30-06 Eff. 7-1-06
(including single-family dwellings, apartments, co-op apartments, condominiums, and mobile home park spaces) OOlunit 4,Oi4.001unit
1) If the cost of on-site sewer construction and connection, exclusive of sewer facility fee, shall exceed the
Sum of$4,776 per dwelling unit, or such greater sum as shall hereafter be determined by resolution
of the City Council, amounts shall be adjusted annually in accordance with the Engineering News Record
Construction Cost Index. {Refer to R19795, R20650, R20778, R21289)
2) If the cost of sewer main construction, in the event no sewer main exists in proximity to said property,
Shall exceed $7,960 per dwelling unit, or such greater sum as shall hereafter be determined by resolution
of the City Council, amounts shall be adjusted annually in accordance with the Engineering News Record
Construction Cost Index. (Refer to R19795, R20650, R20778, R21289)
b) Commercial and industrial units (R21289) 203.00lfxture unit 388.00Ifixture unit
c) Hotel rooms (as defined by the Zoning Ordinance) (R21289)
Without kitchens With kitchens 1,046.001unit 1,744.001unit
1.198.001unIt 1,998.001unit
d) Recreational Vehicle Space (for building permits) (R21289) 1,873.001space 3,121.001space
e) Assessment Districts
The sewer facility fee to be paid for premises with service made available by an assessment district shall be the
fee in effect at the time a petition representing 60% sufficiency is filed with the City, provided said connection
occurs during the course of construction but in no event later than 30 days after filing of notice of completion of
the assessment district. Should a permit not be secured within the time frame set forth herein, the facility fee to
be paid shall be that fee in effect at the time the permit for connection is secured.
- Comprehensive Fee Schedule
Page - 67 -
WASTEWATER
Sewer Facility Fee (Continued)
fl Properties adjacent to City
Properties outside of the City shall pay a sewer facility fee equal to twice the rate established for properties within
the City limits.
Sewer Main Surcharge Fee
In addition to Sewer Street Main Charge, Inspection Fee and any other applicable fees, when a sewer reimbursement
agreement requires the collection of a Sewer Main Surcharge Fee, the Building Division shall collect and remit the amount
prescribed by such agreement, (including interest, if required by the subject agreement).
Sewer Street Main Charges
In addition to the inspection fee and any other applicable fees, when a property connecting to a City sewer has
not paid its share of the cost of said sewer, there shall be paid a street main charge. Said street main charge
shall be determined by the Building Division, based upon one of the following formulae, whichever is the greater:
(1) Sixteen dollars ($16) per lot front foot along said sewer, or (R20362) 16.00 per foot
(2) At the rate established in a sewer reimbursement agreement adopted by resolution of the City Council for sewers
constructed by a developer, or
(3) At the rate established by resolution of the City Council for sewers andlor sewage collection system constructed
by the city in a specified applicable area.
Said street main charges shall be deposited in the Sewer Fund, except for those charges collected through
a sewer reimbursement agreement wherein the original costs plus interest are reimbursed to the second
party of said agreement.
WASTEWATER
Comprehensive Fee Schedule
Page - 68 -
s�7
City of Palm prings 1111512006
Government Code 66000 Calculation
Quimby Act Fees Fun - #1 22
rsca ear 1
The Quimby Act Fees Fund is used to account for revenue received from fees assessed on new construction For the purpose of
public Improvement.
Beginning Ending
Fund an 05f06 Fund
Account Description Balance Transactions Balance
Revenues & Other Sources
Developer Fees 992,550
Interest Income 33,533
Total Sources 1,026,083
Expenditures&Other Uses
Total Uses -
Total Avatlable 655,980 1,026,083 1,682,Ofi3 I
Five Year Test
Using First In First Out Method
Expenditures Net Not
and Spent or
Collections Interest Total Commitments Committed
Revenues collected from FY 05 645.05011 10,930 655.980 655,980
Revenues collected from FY 06 992,550 33,533 1,026,083 1,026.083
Total 1,637,600 44,463 1,682,063 1,682,063
Result: Five Year Spent or Committed Test Met
Breakdown of Committment °1�Fundecf
-3
City of Palm Springs
Quimby Act Fee Schedule
Fees
Apartment Unit $4,850.00
Single-family Unit $5,602.00
Improvements FY 05106 % Completed With Fee
Total -'
r
I
-1
"3
C�
City of Pam prings 1 111 51200 6
Government Code 66000 Calculation
Drainage-Construction Fund - # 135 j
Isca ear j
The Drainage Construction Fund is used to account for revenue received from toes assessed on new construction For the purpose of
building and maintaining a drainage and flood control system within the City. Fee calculation - see attached Fee structure.
Beginning Ending
Fund FY 05106 Fund
Account Description Balance Transactions Balance
Revenues & Other Sources
Developer Fees 684.445
Interest Income 157,185
Other -
Total Sources 841,630
Ex enditures & Other Uses
Capital Projects 1,356,265
Total Uses 1,356,265
Total Available J 5,789,930 (514,635)1 5,275,295
Five Year Test
Using First In First Out Method
Expenditures Net Not
and Spent or
Collections Interest Total Commitments Committed
Revenues collected from FY 89 427,167 207.053 634.220 634,220
Revenues collected from FY 90 402.698 290.788 693,486 693,486
Revenues collected from FY 91 316.947 302,782 619,729 619.729
Revenues collected from FY 92 216.272 212,475 422,747 422,747
Revenues collected from FY 93 61,740 119,546 181.286 181,286
Revenues collected from FY 94 120,144 76,610 196.754 196,754
Revenues collected From FY 95 258,764 59,619 318.383 318,383
Revenues collected From FY 96 230,776 75,395 306,171 306,171
Revenues collected from FY 97 106,632 75.836 182,4fi8 182.468
Revenues collected from FY 98 171.263 90,348 261,611 261.611
Revenues collected from FY 99 150,629 83,783 234,412 234.412
Revenues collected from FY 00 365,496 102,870 468,366 468,366
Revenues collected from FY 01 278,438 168,679 447.117 447.117
Revenues collected from FY 02 237,755 132,196 369.951 369,951
Revenues collected from FY 03 361,932 110,028 471,960 471,960
Revenuas col[aCled from FY04 1,137,699 51,313 1,189,012 11189.012 (0]
'! Revenues collected from FY 05 1.066,367 127.051 1,193,418 633.714 559.704
Revenues collected from FY06 684,445 157,185 841,630 841,630
Total 6,589,164 2,443,557 8,191,091 7,631,387 1,401,334
Result: Five Year Spent or Committed Test Met
I
Breakdown of Committment % Funded
Improvements FFY I % Completed 11 With Fee
Vista ChinolFarrall Basin LDSC 8,030 70.00% 100.Oo% _
Palm Canyon &Tahquitz Creek 371,203 12.78% 100.00%
North Zone Projects 212,360 0.00% 100.00%
Central Zone Projects _ 28,935 0.009% 100.00%
South Zone Projects 98,371 0.00% 100.00%
East Zane Projects 106,372 0.00% 100.00%
Southeast Zone Projects 34,427 0.00% 100.00% [
Storm Drain Line 23 400,000 0.00%1 100.00% 1
Line41 1,131.548 0.00% 100.00%
Storm Drain Line 20 584.476 0.00% 100.00%
Storm Drain Line 22 5,000 o.o0°/0 100.00%
Amado/Alverado 1,037 0.00% 100.00%
Eagle Canyon Drainage 10,000 0.00% 100.00%
South Palm Canyon Drainage 40,000 0.00% 100.00%
Storm Drain Line 6A 124,823 0.00°I° 100.00%
Storm Drain Line 8 717,379 0.00% 100.00°/0
Total 3,873,961
City of Palm Springs
Drainage Fee Schedule
Fees per Zone
North Zone $6,511 per acre
Central Zone $9,212 per acre
South Zone $7,271 per acre
East Zane $4,117 per acre
Southeast Zone $7,522 per acre
Eagle Canyon $7,020 per acre
Drainage fees shall apply to all existing vacant properties which are not pan of an existing
subdivision or that are legal lots of record having been part of a subdivision recorded prior to
the effective date of Resolution No. 14082. Drainage fees shall be required for all developed
properties a)when an addition of impervious surface exceeds 50% of the existing impervious
surface and b)the drainage fee for the property was not paid previously. The drainage fee shall
be paid prior to the issuance of the Building Permit.
City of Palm Springs _ 1111512006..
Government Code 66000 Calculation
Public Arts Fund-#150
Fiscal Year 2005106
Public Arts Fund is used to account for development fees paid In lieu of placement of an approved artwork at approved sites and in a manner consistent with Chapter 3.3-7 0€the
Municipal Code. The funds are used solely for the acquisition, installation,improvement,maintenance and insurance or artwork to be displayed in the city and the administration
of the arts program as defined in the Code. Fee calculation-see attached fee strnEing
I
Beginning j
Fund FY 05106Account Descripton Balance Transactions
Revenues&Other Sources
Public Arts Fee 445,476 j
Interest Income 24.3fi0
Miscellaneous 1.968 I
Total Sources 471,804
Expenditureditures&Other Uses I
Capital Projects&Maintenance -
Operating Expenses 410,785 j
I I '
Total Uses 410,785 _
I i I i
Total Available 920,419 61,019 981,438
Five Year Test I l
Using First in Flrstuat method
i I
- Amount
Collections Interest Total Expenditures Not Spent I ��
Revenues collected from FY 89 17,010 179 17,189 77,189 -
Revenues collected from FY 90 _ 249,109 16,741 265,850 265,850
Revenues collected from FY 91 183,954 33.293 217.247 217,247 I I
Revenues collected From FY 92 89.820 34,497 124,326 124,326 -
Revenues collected from FY 93 249,083 27.580 276,663 276.663
Revenues collected from FY 94 95,704 26,130 121,834 121,834114
Revenues collected from FY 95 93,t 57 30,270 123,427 123.427
Revenues collected from FY 96 91,941 31,265 123,206 123,206
Revenues collected from FY 97 78,862 34.390 113,252 113,252 -
Revenues collected from FY 98 67.501 25,098 92,599 92.599 _
Revenues collected from FY 99 96,521 19,684 116.205 116,205
Revenues collected from FY 00 180,761 19,183 208,944 208,944
Revenues collected from FY 01 142,924 19,784 162,708 162,708
Revenues collected from FY 02 247,707 12.321 260,028 660,028 _
Revenues collected from FY o3 _ 359,655 7,558 367.213 367,213 - 4
Revenues collected from FY 04 520,336 9,335 529.670 529,670 0 _ !
Rove hues collected from FY O5 _ 566.410 20,073 _ 586,483 76,849 509,634
v, Revenues co]lected from FY 06 4 77,444 24,360 471,804 - _ 471,804
Total 3,786,907 391,74i I 4,178,848 3,t97,210 881.436f-
r
----
Result: Five Year Spent or Committed Test Met
T -
-
_ Total Year Year
Spent Future Past Expenditures Revenue Revenue Amount _ % %funded
Expenditures & Commitments FY05106 Commitments Payments Co mmitmenf Spent Ap pl fed Applied Complete with Fees
1 3 Door fa feral file - 556 556 91 89 556 100% 100%
2 Macro Josh LC Computer,secretarial desk w left return - 2,560 2,560 92 90 2,560 _ 100% 100%
3 Tony Beriant's"A Personal History of Palm Springs" - 100,000 100,000 _ 92 90 55,00D 1 g04o 100%
2 murals at the Convention Center 93 90 35,000 _
4 Walk of Stars-5 golden palm plaques - 10,OD0 10,000 92 90 10,000 100°/° 100°k
5 Joe Fay's"Hallmark Desert Wildlife"(2)dimensional animals - 44,086 24,086 93 90 24,086 100% 100%
6 Damian Pfleer'a"Flight"scut lure at Bird Center Dr - 50,000 50,000 93 90 50,000 100% 100% _
7 Bill Arms -The Bette f'sc ul lure al Baseba 11 Stadium 3,50D 3,500 93 91 3,000 100% 100%
01 98 500
8 Felipe Castaneda's"Standing Woman"at Historical Socfef 2,898 2,898 94 91 2,698 t00% 100%
9 Doug H de's "Aqua Calrente Women"at median of _ 449,334 _ 149,334 92 90 6 000
Tahquitz Canyon Wa &fndlan Canyon{2 sculptures} _ 93 90 57,299
94 91 51,812 --
951 92 33,354 - - --
98 94 869
t0 Children Arcs Project 34,027 34,027 93 91 13,800 100% 100%
_ 94 91 20,227 _
11 3 drawer f le cabfnet(putt color) 553 553 95 92 553 100% 100%
12 Epson stylus color pilnier 535 535 96 92 535 i0o°/° 100% -
13 Gate•.va P5-75 1,543 1,543 96 92 1,543 10D% 100%
14 Lucille Ball Bronze at Tahquitz Canyon&Palm Co Non 16,283 16,283 95 92 15,075 _ 100% 100%
97 93 308
15 Circle of Lire Sculp Lure at Desert Hospital 00,757 90,757 96 93 90,520 100% 100
97 93 237
16 Hollywood Sculpture Walk(3 pieces Iota led at Bl:mp:es} _ 61150_ 6,150 96 92 6,000 _ 100_% 10D%
01 98 150
17 Crouching Cougar Sculpture at J Behman Gallery __ 7,257 7,251 97 93 7,251 100% 100%
18 Police Memorial 20,ODO 20,000 97 93 20,000 100% 100% _
19 Desert Highland Mural ICAP) 32,111 32,111 97 93 8,850 100% 100%
98 94 17,144
99 95 138 - --
03 02 5,979
20 Plaza Mercardo Construction Fence Mural (ICAP) 99,200 19,200 98 94 19,200 100% i0D% _
21 Festival Center at Frances Stevens Park(Wa[edeamre Park) 284,337 284,337 98 94 1,000 1 DO°/° 100%
97 _ 93 4,800
_ 99 95_ 12,653
- 00 96 84,212
00 97 63,716
01 98 _ 4,529
01 99 48,197
02 DO 62,165 _
03 02 3,065 ___
22 Daimam XII sculpture lease 1,500 _ 20,000 21,500 96 92 00,000 100% 100%
located al Palm Springs Convention Censer .06 04 _ 1,500
23 Chadre Farrell ScuipWre 47,589 47,589 98 94 20,D00 100% 100°/°
- - 99 --- 95 1,725
00 97 25,266 _-
_ 01 _ 99 598 _
24 8:g Hom Sheep Painting 2000, _ 2,000 98 94 2,ODO 100% 100%
25 Camel Bench at Visitors Center _ _ _ 2,694 2,694 _98 _94_ 2,694 100% 100% _
26 Dog Park Fence 34,283 34,283 98 94 2,500 100% 100°/°
99 95 2fi,073 --- --
02 00 _ 960
_ -- - - 03 02 4,750
27 Recycled Art Show 10,000 10,000 98 94 i0,000 100% 100%
28 Epson color printer, bookcase and 2 file cabinets 1,189 _ 1,189 98 95 1,189 1On. 100%
29 Frame historic photos at CityHall _ i,8tl0 1,810 98_ _ 95 1,810 100% 100°/
30 Insurance 3,518 31,679 35,197 98 _ 95 2,635 We
99 95 2,625
00 97 2,463
_ 01 99 2,i75 --
02 00 4,497 _
_ 03 02 7,381
04 03 5,922
05 03 _ 3,981
06 04 3,518
31 Help is On The Way-Bronze Slatue 5,000 5,000 99 95 5,600 100Y° i00°k -
32 Demuth Park Sculpture 31,357 31,357 99 95 17,200 100% _ 100%
00 97 14,157
33 laminaled Tops 350 350 99 95 350 100% 100 -.
34 Art Show Awards&Sup lies 12,250 16,728 28,978 99 95 1,709 100% 100%
00 97 1,492
01 99 1,898
02 00 2,537 _
03 03 4,603
04 03 2,186 _
_ 05 03 2,303 j
06 04 12,250
35 Computer&Monitor 1,339 1,339 00 97 1,068 100% 100%
04 03 271 L
36 Proposed Airport Sculpture 2,5D0 2,500 00 97 2,500 1 D01° 100%
37 Photos-Historic and Art 090 990 00 97 990 1 DO% 100%
38 Historic Site Maps _ 15,287 15,287 01 99 2,215 100°I° 100%
03 02 13,672
39 Computer Soitvare&Memary 1,236 1,236 01 99 650 100°/° _ 100°/ _
_ 02 00 369
03 02 208 _
40 City Signage Competition 6,500 61500 01 99 2,000 100% 100%
02 OD 4,500
41 Chihuly Glass Scu liplure 245,604 245,604 01 99 58,463 100%. 10D%
_ 91 00 12,742
02 _ 00 11,713
03 02 155,728 _
04 03 6,958
42 Joshua Tree Mural 7,140 _7,140 02 00 7,140 100%
43 Bono Slatue 17,59D 17,590 02 00 2,133
03 02 15,080
44 Midnight Blue Artwork 367 367 02 00 367 100%
04 03 377
45 Misc Artwork Maintenance 82,382 116,386 198.768 02 01 1,338
_ 03 03_ 54,146 _
04 _ 03 34,775-- _
05 03 26,127
06 __ 04 82,382
461nlerchange Aesthetic Treatment Redesign 4,620 1i,524 16,994 03 __ 03 19,524 _ _
_ __ 06 _ 04 4,620
47 Palm Canyon Theatre _ 7,604 7,604 03 03 _ _7,604 __ L
48 Palm S nn s Efltry Sm n 1 22,278 22,278 04 03 14,834
Ke OS 03 _ 7,494 _40 Chairman
❑fIlle Lin 8,252 8,252 05 03 8,252
50 Chairman of the Links 50,000 50,000 05 03 20,285 _
File
05 04 29,715
Stainless Ss Ststeel 200 200 06 04 _ 200
Kinelec ScuEtpure 15,000 15,000 06 04 15,000
Impossible Lawn Chair 8,660 8,660 06 04 8,660
Ruth Hardy Park-Whirlwind VI 13,000 13,000 06 04 i3,000
Bucated n KlIktt Gallery-Fahr7 pieces 3} 70,000 70,000 06 04 70,000 located on Kirk Douglas Way -
Salala=es&Aaminislra[ive Costs _ 199.654 1,211,467 1,411,121 90 89_ 572 nla 100%
91 _ 89 66.061
91 90 _ 785
92 90 15,120
92 91 2,227
93 91 38,756
94 91 51,906
95 91 32,621 --
95 92 40,410
96 ]94
5,956
96 50,090
97 75,153 -
98 10,454
98 46,42798 10,999993299 36,994
00 97 1,600
00 98 87,420 _
01 00 99,335
02 _ 01 110,623
03 01 51,233
03 03 73,418
04 _ 03 136,966 --
05 04 166,019
06 04 122,800"
06 05 76,848 --
Total 410,784 - 2,786,424 3,197,208 3,197,208 _ --�
L�
City of Palm Springs
Public Arts Fee Calculation
Commercial & Industrial
One half of one percent (1/2%) of value.
Residential
One quarter of one percent (1/4%) of value for new residential subdivisions or developments
of two or more units.
One quarter of one percent (114%) of value for new individual single-family residential units
exceeding $100,000.
Activities Not Subject to public arts program requirements:
1 public projects undertaken by any agency;
2 remodeling, repair or reconstruction of structures to comply with seismic safety code, or
which have been damaged by fire, flood, wind, earthquake or other Calamity;
3 remodeling, repair or reconstruction of residential units,
4 nonprofit social service or cultural institution projects,
5 low to moderate housing projects as defined by household income Health &Safety Code
Section 50093;
a affordable housing developments receiving City, State or Federal assistance;
7 private educational institutions which provide general education equivalent to the public
school system (kindergarten through high school or any part thereof);
8 architectural rehabilitation or historical preservation of properties which are designated
as Class 1 Historic Sites by the City Council,