HomeMy WebLinkAbout2020-07-07 PAC Meeting AgendaPUBLIC ARTS COMMISSION
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS, CALIFORNIA
SPECIAL MEETING AGENDA
Tuesday
July 7, 2020
Shawnda Faveau
Mara Gladstone
Tracy Merrigan, Vice-Chair
Alfonso Murray
5:30 PM
Russell Pritchard
Ann Sheffer, Chair
Thomas Yanni
Pursuant to Executive Order N-29-20, this meeting will be conducted by teleconference and there will
be no in-person public access to the meeting location.
• To join meeting, please use the following link:
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/83290795860?pwd=YzJ iMGw5 ODJXVk5 jYUIRdTRzWkNq UT09
• Public comment may also be submitted to jay.virata@palmspringsca.gov. Transmittal prior to the
meeting is required. Any correspondence received during or after the meeting will be distributed to the
Commission and retained for the official record.
CALL TO ORDER:
ROLL CALL:
ACCEPTANCE OF AGENDA:
PUBLIC COMMENTS:
This time has been set aside for members of the public to address the Public Arts Commission on items of general
interest within the subject matter jurisd iction of the Commission, and agenda items if the member of the public cannot be
present later in the meeting at the time the item is heard by the Commission. Additionally, members of the public may
address the Commission on each item listed on the posted agenda at the time each item is heard . Although the Public
Arts Commission values your comments, pursuant to the Brown Act, it generally cannot take any action on items not listed
on the posted agenda. Five (5) minutes are assigned for each speaker.
A. REPORT FROM THE CHAIR:
B. PUBLIC HEARING:
1. Open the Public Hearing for Public Testimony.
2. Adopt Resolution No. 20-001, "A RESOLUTION OF THE PUBLIC ARTS COMMISSION OF
THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS, CALIFORNIA, RECOMMENDING APPROVAL OF AN ART
MURAL ON THE EAST FACING WALL LOCATED AT 317 NORTH INDIAN CANYON DRIVE
(CASE 20-001 MUR)."
Public Arts Commission
Meeting Agenda -July 7, 2020
Page2
C. ITEMS FOR DISCUSSION/ APPROVAL:
1. Approval of Minutes from Study Session of June 2, 2020.
2. Review of Guidelines for CARES and Community Neighborhood grants.
3. Ad hoc sub-committees for project review and oversight.
D. ACTION ITEMS:
1. Approve Fiscal Year 2020-21 Budget.
2. Request for reimbursement of $2000 to Flat Black Paint for George Floyd mural.
3. Approve a one-year agreement with Coachellart/Patrick Sheehan as 'Artist-in-Residence' for Parks
and Recreation Department in an amount not to exceed $20,000.
4. Approve agreement with The Art Collective for continued maintenance and installation of artworks,
July 2020 -February 2021 -in an amount not to exceed $25,000.
E. COMMISSIONER COMMENTS/REPORTS/REQUESTS
F. REPORT FROM DIRECTOR/STAFF
ADJOURNMENT: The Public Arts Commission will adjourn to a Regular Meeting, date to be determined, at
Palm Springs City Hall, Large Conference Room, 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way, Palm Springs, CA 92262.
It is the intention of the City of Palm Springs to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) in all respects. If, as an attendee or a participant at
this meeting, or in meetings on a regular basis, you will need special assistance beyond what is normally provided, the City will attempt to accommodate
you in every reasonable manner. Please contad the Office of the City Clerk, (760) 323-8204, at least 72 hours prior to the meeting to infonn us of your
particular needs and to determine if accommodation is feasible.
Pursuant to G.C. Section 54957.5(b)(2) the designated office for inspection of records in connection with the meeting is the Office of
the City Clerk, City Hall, 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way (760) 323-8204.
AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING
I, ANTHONY J. MEJIA, City Clerk of the City of Palm Springs, California, hereby certify this Notice was delivered to each
Public Arts Commissioner, provided to all parties who have requested such notice and posted at City Hall and on the City website, on
or before 5:30 p.m. on July 6, 2020, as required by established policies and procedures.
317 N. Indian Canyon Drive Mural
George Floyd
The mural is located at 317 N. Indian Canyon Drive on the boarded-up east facing storefront wall. The
approximately 8' x 25' mural depicts George Floyd with the words "I Can't Breathe" in the foreground
and protester silhouettes in the background.
The artist is Mister Alek who is based in Watts area of Los Angeles. Mister Alek has recently completed
a mural of Kobe Bryant in Los Angeles, another mural of George Floyd in Watts, and is currently working
on another Los Angeles mural at Melrose and Fairfax.
In a recent episode of "MAKING ART PUBLIC," Mister Alek commented on his artwork, "I try to focus on
like community leaders and people that influence me and influence others, people that can relate to the
community, and people that have done good things; I try to focus on that, you know, cause I like to do
portraits, you know what better people to paint than people that you can relate to and that have done
something good in life."
317 N. Indian Canyon Drive Mural
George Floyd
Photo courtesy of Palm Springs Public Arts Commission
manatt
June 11, 2020
Dear Mr. Pritchard,
Jennifer J. Lynch
Manatt, Phelps & Phillips , LLP
Cell : (657) 217-7759
JLynch@manatt.com
It was a pleasure speaking with you this morning. As you know, I represent Mr. Nick Wolin,
property owner of the currently vacant Greyhound Bus Terminal building located at 317 N.
Indian Canyon Drive in the City of Palm Springs. Mr. Wolin would like to retroactively give his
permission for the City's commissioned Misteralek George Floyd memorial mural across the
front of the Greyhound Bus Terminal building.
Mr. Wolin's retroactive permission is for a temporary duration, as Mr. Wolin is currently seeking
development permits for the site. Our understanding is that when development permits are
issued for the property, the temporary plywood boards covering the front of the building (upon
which much of the mural is located) may be removed by Mr. Wolin. However, Mr. Wolin will
not remove the boards or otherwise remove or cover the mural without first notifying and
coordinating with the City.
Thank you again for selecting 317 N . Indian Canyon Drive for this beautiful project. If you have
any questions, please don't hesitate to reach to me at 657-217-7759.
Sincerely,
Jennifer J. Lynch
695 Town Center Drive, 14th Floor, Costa Mesa, California 92626 Telephone: 714.371 .2500 Fax : 714.371 .2550
Albany I Boston I Chicago I Los Angeles I New York I Orange County f Palo Alto I Sacramento I San Francisco I Washington, D .C ,
RESOLUTION NO. 20-001
A RESOLUTION OF THE PUBLIC ARTS COMMISSION OF
THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS, CALIFORNIA,
RECOMMENDING APPROVAL OF AN ART MURAL,
"GEORGE FLOYD -I CAN'T BREATH", ON THE EAST
FACING WALL LOCATED AT 317 NORTH INDIAN CANYON
DRIVE (CASE 20-001 MUR)
WHEREAS, the City Council created according to Chapter 2.24 of the Palm
Springs Municipal Code (Section 2.24.010) the Public Arts Commission; and
WHEREAS, the City Council created according to Chapter 5.81 of the Palm
Springs Municipal Code (Section 5.81.010) the process and procedures for the
installation of original art murals on private property; and
WHEREAS, at the July 7, 2020, Public Arts Commission Meeting, it was
determined that the "GEORGE FLOYD -I CAN'T BREATH" mural on the commercial
property located at 317 N. INDIAN CANYON DRIVE, meets the requirements set forth
in Chapter 5.81 of the Palm Springs Municipal Code, Art Murals on Private Property;
and
NOW, THEREFORE, be it resolved that the Public Arts Commission hereby
recommends:
SECTION 1. That the City Council approve an Art Mural application by the Palm
Springs Public Arts Commission for a mural by Artist Mister Alek on the commercial
building located at 317 North Indian Canyon Drive.
ADOPTED BY THE PUBLIC ARTS COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF PALM
SPRINGS THIS __ DAY OF ____ , 2020 .
ATTEST:
Jay Virata, Director
Community & Economic Development
Ann Sheffer, Chair
Public Arts Commission
CERTIFICATION
STATE OF CALIFORNIA )
COUNTY OF RIVERSIDE )ss.
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS)
I, JAY VIRATA, hereby certify that Resolution No. ___ is a full, true and
correct copy, and was duly adopted at a regular meeting of the Public Arts Commission
of the City of Palm Springs on ___ , 2020, by the following vote:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
ABSTAIN:
Jay Virata, Director
Community & Economic Development
PUBLIC ARTS COMMISSION
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS, CALIFORNIA
STUDY SESSION MEETING MINUTES
TUESDAY, JUNE 2, 2020, 4:00 p.m.
ZOOM TELECONFERENCE
CALL TO ORDER: Chair Sheffer called the June 2, 2020, Study Session of the Public Arts
Commission of the City of Palm Springs to order at 4:03 p.m.
ROLL CALL:
PRESENT:
ABSENT:
Commissioners Faveau, Gladstone, Murray, Pritchard, Yanni, Vice-Chair
Merrigan, and Chair Sheffer.
None.
ALSO PRESENT: Cindy Cairns, Special Assistant to City Manager, acted as Staff Liaison.
ACCEPTANCE OF THE AGENDA: Approve the Agenda as presented. Motion Commissioner
Yanni, seconded by Commissioner Pritchard and unanimously carried.
PUBLIC COMMENT: None.
A. REPORT FROM THE CHAIR:
Chair Sheffer provided a verbal report on four pieces of art discovered downtown on City
property. The Commission discussed the Crushing Inertia artwork on loan at the Airport, and
agreed to request an extension of the art loan, free of charge, until renovations at the Airport
begin at which time it will need to be de-installed. The Commission commented on the Chihuly
artwork at the Airport, which is undergoing cleaning, as well as the big horn sheep sculptures
which are to be relocated.
The Commission briefly discussed the Arts Commission budget, which anticipates reduced
revenue this year in light of the COVID-19 pandemic, and a carry-over into the new fiscal year
of any remaining unspent funds.
B. ITEMS FOR DISCUSSION/APPROVAL:
1. Agreement with Scene Creative for Project Management and Consulting Services.
ACTION: The Commission discussed the term and scope of work for Scene Creative,
including management of the mini-grant program and art projects. Chair Sheffer to
revise scope for contract to provide more clarity. Agreement is for term of six months,
in an amount not to exceed $20,000. By consensus of the Commission.
2. Agreement with The Very Best Services for Social Media Strategy and Web
Management Services.
ACTION: The Commission discussed agreement with The Very Best Services for
social media and web management, and reviewed project proposal. Vendor also to
coordinate Artists Talks. Agreement is $1,000/month for a total of seven months
beginning in July 2020. By consensus of the Commission.
T~ Cl
Public Arts Commission Study Session Minutes
June 2, 2020
Page 2
3. Extension of Agreement with The Art Collective for one year at a cost of $30,000 for
Continuing Maintenance of Art.
ACTION: No action taken.
4. Discussion of "Community Art Responds to Economic Shutdown" (CARES) Mini-Grant
Program.
ACTION: The Commission discussed the mini-grant program and process, the
importance of at least two Commissioners being involved in the process, and
publicizing the program on the Public Arts website. No action taken.
5. Discussion of Neighborhood Grants Program.
ACTION: The Commission discussed the neighborhood grants program. Chair Sheffer
commented on looking at revising the public arts ordinance in the fall. No action taken.
6. Discussion of Mural on West Elm Building.
7. ACTION: The Commission commented on Patrick Sheehan's Coachellart proposal for
a mural project and discussed three locations (West Elm Building; Accelerator Campus
off Alejo Rd.; and the City's Cogeneration Plant), as well as involving children from the
Boys & Girls Club and the City Parks & Recreation For Kids Only program. Coachellart
to provide revised proposal reflecting Commission direction. Chair Sheffer and
Commissioner Gladstone to steer program. By consensus of the Commission.
C. COMMISSIONER COMMENTS/REPORTS/REQUESTS:
Commissioner Yanni and Commissioner Faveau commented on the Gerald Clark art in
Wellness Park. Commissioner Murray commented on the idea of a memorial, murals on
basketball courts, and hopes to get a sculpture on the north end on Indian which leads into
Palm Springs. Chair Sheffer commented that ideas need to be posted on the website for
people to comment or provide feedback. Chair Sheffer suggested a short meeting on June 17
but will work with Commission to confirm . Vice-Chair Merrigan thanked the commission for all
the work behind the scenes.
D. REPORT FROM DIRECTOR/STAFF: No report.
ADJOURNMENT: The Study Session of the Public Arts Commission of the City of Palm Springs
adjourned at 6: 13 p.m. to a date uncertain. Motion Commissioner Yanni, seconded by
Commissioner Murray and unanimously carried.
APPROVED BY A MOTION OF THE PUBLIC ARTS COMMISSION THIS 7th DAY OF July,
2020.
Cindy Cairns
Process for CARES and Neighborhood Grants:
1. Mini-grant proposals must be reviewed and recommended by at least two Public Arts
Commissioners.
2. All art installations or murals funded through mini-grants will be temporary until
December 31, 2020 when they will be reviewed by the Commission for longer term
arrangements.
3. Any applications for placement of art on City property must be reviewed by the Planning
Department for safety and structural issues, to be addressed before proceeding.
4. Any applications for placement of art or murals on private property must have the
permission of the owner.
5. Contracts and/or invoices from sponsoring organizations or artists must be approved by
the City Manager, however projects may be managed by independent contractors
within their scope of work.
6. No public hearings will be held, but all projects will be publicized through our website
and social media for public comment.
7. Projects should be fully funded when contracts are approved, however, grant recipients
must submit a report of expenditures and outcomes when the project has been
completed.
8. These special processes will remain in effect until December 31, 2020.
Funding for CARES grants will range between $500 -$1000*
Funding for Neighborhood grants will range between $2500 -$5000
*Types of CARES projects:
1. Artwork to enliven re-opened businesses and draw foot traffic, as request by owners
2. Storefront installations on temporarily or permanently closed businesses/community a
3. Loan of artwork for storefronts, medians, empty lots, or other public places
Reviewed by Public Arts Commission, June 2, 2020
City of Palm Springs
Public Arts -Fund 150
Account
42100 OFFICE SUPPLIES
Description
42195 SPECIAL DEPT SUPPLIES
42490 NON CAPITAL EQUIPMENT
43160 ARTS MAINTENANCE
43200 CONTRACTUAL SERVICES
TOTAL MTRLS, SUPPLIES & SVCS
56034 PUBLIC ART -ACQUISITION
65209 PS ART MUSEUM
65214 KENNEDY BUST (ART ON LOAN -AIRPORT)
TOTAL CAPITAL
FY 2020-21 Budget
TOTAL PUBLIC ARTS
FY 2020-21
Available
Balance
$ 715.14
5,000.00
1,000.00
30,000.00
51,171.00
$ 87,886.14
175,800.50
50,000.00
1,500.00
$ 227,300.50
$ 100,000.00
$ 415,186.64
:C~ b\
Exhibit A
Coachella rt
Scope of Services/Work
This is an agreement with Patrick Sheehan of Coachellart, as Artist-in-Residence for the
Department of Parks and Recreation from July 15, 2020 to July 15, 2021. The Artist-in-
Residence will work with the Director of the Parks Department, with the assistance
of the Public Arts Commission, to plan and execute projects that restore and add artwork in
Parks facilities, with a goal of offering opportunities for young people to participate.
Specific responsibilities include:
1. Identifying locations in City parks facilities where art could be added or
repaired/restored.
2. Coordinating with the Director of Parks and Recreation, who must approve all projects.
3. Plan and schedule times when young people can participate in painting.
4. Assemble all materials and support equipment.
5. Provide materials to publicize projects on social media, through the Public Arts
Commission and the Parks and Recreation Department.
6. Report monthly to both the Public Arts and Parks and Recreation Commissions.
7. Submit detailed invoices for Coachellart activities monthly, including a breakdown of all
work performed.
Payment:
1. Contractor will be paid $45/hour for Consulting Artistic Services as Artist-in-Residence
for the Parks and Recreation Department, as billed each month, in an amount not to
exceed $20,000, including materials and supplies.
2. All invoices for time and materials must be reviewed by the Director of Parks and
Recreation and the Chair of the Public Arts Commission.
Coachella rt
PO Box 414
Palm Springs, CA 92263
TAX EIN: 84-3425677
A 501 (c)(3) non-profit organization
:t:~ D3
&
coachell art
Potential Artwork Locations-City of Palm Springs-Parks and Rec, Dept.
Ramon Road @ Sunrise Park-Swim Center Wall
Swim Center-Ticket and Concession Building
Palm Spring Leisure Center-Interior Courtyard (preschool area)
Palm Spring Leisure Center Entry Wall-East Side of Entrance
I (
Palm Springs Leisure Center-Mural Restoration Project
Detail photo of deterioration & severe fading
of paint on mural
Detail photo of deterioration & severe fading of paint on mural
Demuth Park Youth Center
Demuth Park Youth Center
James O. Jesse-Desert Highland Center Mural by Richard Wyatt
(Mural is faded and in need of repainting)
This could be a community revitalization project under the guidance of Coachellart's
artist team and with the blessing of the artist.
Park Bench Projects:
The majority of our parks in the City have concrete benches that need repainting (and
skateboard guards) and could be used as community/youth art projects under the
guidance of Coachellart.
Sample photos:
Victoria Park (6 benches)
Ruth Hardy (4-6 benches)
Desert Highland Center (4-5 benches)
Sunrise Park (5-6 benches)
Demuth Park (5-6 benches)
Exhibit A
The Art Collective -Scope of Work July 15, 2020 -January 15, 2021
A. Installation of Gerald Lebrejia sculpture (details attached) $20,000
B. Maintenance, Repair, or Relocation of Artwork $5,000
Based on report from conservator on damaged pieces and repairs needed for full restoration, with
estimate of costs and suggested repairs on damaged pieces.
Recommendations on pieces needed preventative measures (moving sprinklers, adding pedestals, etc).}
Pieces scheduled for repair:
#3 Charlie Farrell
-Bronze needs specified care to restore the sculpture
# 7 Wave Rhythms
-Considerable repair needed , loss of paint, former graffiti damage
# 15 Standing Woman
-Large accrual of white deposits that could not be removed with cleaning, Concern of possible
bronze disease.
# 16 Whirlwind VI
-Foreign contaminants needs to be addressed and determination on repair
# 8 R. Hero -Chipped paint, have contacted artists for suggestions/repair
Pieces suggested for repainting:
# 6 The Batter
# 17 Nines and Elevens
# 18 John Clement works
Pieces under consideration for relocation:
John Clements, Mayor Bogert statue, Lawn Chair
The Art Collective will provide the requested reports that will include before and after images of the work
prior to initial cleaning and any additional repairs or maintenance. Arlene Amick is the Project Manager for
RFP #07-19 and will be the main point of contact to the City of Palm Springs' appointed liaison. Kyle
Elder and Matt Roberts will be the point of contact during cleaning and maintenance and will adhere to a'II
city requirements for proposed cleaning and maintenance scheduling. The Art Collective will need
additional information for any sculpture that requires road closures or permits; the cost associated with
such requirements is not included in the scope of work.
Gonzalo Lebrija Installation
--THEART
COLLECTIVE
PIii• .AaT HIWIC•I
Current:
Artist reviewing additional information on site location
Pending:
Artist confirmation on water footprint
Next Steps:
Water footprint information to Engineer
--THEART
COLLECTIVE
.... AIIT IIIIVICII
Engineer's completion of sculpture location and confirmation of installation clamp
needed to adhere sculpture
Fabrication of clamp
Preparation of site
-gravel removal
-installation of sculpture clamp and
-security installation for sculpture adherence to site
-installation of water footprint
Transport of sculpture
Installation
-Delivery of sculpture
-Site preparation
-Crane delivery
-Installation of artwork
-Art work secured
Project Owner:
Palm Springs Art Museum
--THEART
COLLECTIVE
1'111• A•T .. IIYICII
Rochelle Steiner, Chief Curator & Director of Curatorial Affairs and Programs
101 Museum Drive
Palm Springs CA 92252
Artist:
Gonzalo Lebrija
Installation Crew:
The Art Collective
Arlene Amick, Project Manager
34-330 Gateway Drive
Unit 110
Palm Desert CA 92211
Engineer:
PK Associates Consulting Structural Engineers
Valerie Granger, President
7434 East McDonald Drive
Scottsdale, AZ 85250
PROPOSED LOCATION FOR GONZALO LEBRIJA CAR INSTALLATION
Amado Center C, I Ji! I
The UPS Store a Bonita -s Y f!lkeout
e
WAmadoRd
Hyan Palm Springs f -t
EAmadoRd cp
'i)
' .-------------.eTonga Hut
Frey House II
l rmporarlly closed
';)
.,,
l
Art Museum
33°49'26 • 5"N 116.32'57.0'W
33.824028, -116.549177
m
'
Palm Springs
Deserf 1 iconic muaeum.
The O'Donnell ~
nouse at the Willows T I(
i MullCtlfflWfl'/
"' a.
Orbil In q
The WIiiows Historic
Palm Springs Inn
~
WTllhquluc ... yon'fl-1 Ci>
The Villas in Old Le Vollauris
Palm Springs french • ssss q
Kimpton Ro~on ~
Palm Spnngs T
w Tah11Jltz Canyon Way 9
Palm Mountain 8
Resort & Spt T Starbucks Reser
Takt:OIII • Dell'lel
Caso Cody Bed ~
& Breoklast T
Brickworks American m
Tnkeoul • Deli~ T
q Andalusian Court Hol,doy House ~
Palm Spnngs T
staurant and Til,, l
rail.an• S$
E Androa1Rd
ppert's Premiurt1
i<lurmet Ice Cream
~keoot
f Pinocchio I
Tueout
'' That
m Farm
T Pnm!f I
Greot Shake
18QOUl•~I
WArenas Rd W AtenH Rd 0 Lulu Cali for
Agua CoUente. ,,. Takeoul . Dell.er
Cultural Museum T A
01>JU>rl H,llt: e Q Old Ranch G o gle
PROPOSED LOCATION: 33°49'26.S"N 116°32'57.0"W
33.824028, -116.549177
"' t Exhib111 Ii Natfvt ...
Recommended Depth of Dirt -4" Gravel 12" fill dirt with the addendum that a radius of ~20' or
more of that dirt and gravel will be removed surrounding the sculpture. Exact dimensions of the
footprint of water TBD.
Other Loads -only the pool liner material, equivalent to thick tarpaulin and potentially a ring
around the pool of sandbags.
__ . ....,.._ .... _.....,... _______ ... ---
Crew is facing the museum . Camera looking East.
Camera looking South.
This image shows crew standing in proposed load bearing positions.