The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2024-11-14 (2)From:Doni Hubbard via constituent@civiclick.com To:City Clerk Subject:Action Requested for Frank Bogert’s Legacy Date:Monday, November 11, 2024 8:47:37 PM NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Dear City Clerk, Dear City Council Members, As a member of the community, I urge you to take action to honor Frank Bogert’s legacy by: 1. Removing the HRC Frank Bogert Monument Report from the city’s website due to its inaccuracies. 2. Apologizing to the Bogert family for any harm caused by misinformation. 3. Relocating the statue to Village Green at the city’s expense. 4. Correcting historical records on Section 14 to remove false references about Mayor Bogert. 5. Disclosing the authors of the HRC Frank Bogert Monument Report and addressing its plagiarism for transparency. Thank you for taking steps to respect Frank Bogert's contributions and our city’s heritage. Sincerely, Doni Hubbard 70395 Placerville Rd Rancho Mirage, CA 92270 Siddoni65@gmail.com 11/14/2024 Public Comment Item 3A From:Elaine Hill To:City Clerk Subject:Frank Bogert Statue Date:Tuesday, November 12, 2024 7:33:57 AM NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. As a 35 year Palm Springs resident who knew Frank and read his several books, I urge the City Council to place the Statue in the downtown “green” so residents and visitors can view this historical art and learn of his unparalleled contribution to this wonderful city. Elaine E. Hill Sent from my iPhone 11/14/2024 Public Comment Item 3A From:Jeffrey Bernstein To:City Clerk Subject:Fwd: Frank Bogert Date:Monday, November 11, 2024 8:48:34 AM Thank you! Jeffrey Jeffrey Bernstein Mayor City of Palm Springs 442-305-9942 Jeffrey.Bernstein@palmspringsca.gov Begin forwarded message: From: STACEY JOHNSON <rekasta@aol.com> Subject: Frank Bogert Date: November 11, 2024 at 8:32:11 AM PST To: Jeffrey.Bernstein@palmspringsca.gov NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Dear City Council Members and Mayor Bernstein, I am writing to you with a heavy heart and a deep sense of urgency to address the recent treatment of Frank Bogert’s legacy and the impact it has had on his family, friends, and the countless individuals he touched throughout his life in this community. My husband has known Frank and his family since childhood. My husband’s own family lived on Section 14 from 1946 to 1952 before leaving when asked to return the land to the Tribe. Over the years, Frank, along with his beloved wife Negie and his children including our dear friends Donna and Jose Higueras, welcomed 11/14/2024 Public Comment Item 3A me with open arms into their family when I moved to Palm Springs in 1996, not knowing a single soul other than my husband. They offered me a place to belong, to feel rooted and connected in this community. Frank’s kindness, generosity, and inclusivity were at the core of his character, and he became family to us. When I hear accusations that Frank was racist or antisemitic, it truly strikes a painful and dissonant chord. As a first-generation American from a North African Sephardic Jewish family, my heritage and identity are deeply rooted in the values of tolerance, respect, and inclusivity. Frank embodied these values in ways that profoundly impacted my life and my family’s. Frank’s first wife, Janet, was from a respected Western Jewish family, and he fully embraced her heritage. Negie, born and raised in Mexico came from a rich traditional Mexican background. I was raised in a conservative/orthodox Jewish household, and Frank welcomed me with open arms. He not only attended our wedding but also actively participated in it, honoring the traditions of a conservative Moroccan Jewish ceremony. Frank introduced me to his best Friend Rabbi Joseph Horowitz to possibly officiate our wedding, However Rabbi Horowitz refused as my husband had not yet converted. I remember Frank being a bit annoyed at his friend as he felt we should be embraced and welcomed. Frank treated our children as if they were his own grandchildren, even including them in his book. Frank often spoke about his wish to live long enough to see our son’s bar mitzvah, and although he passed before he could be there, his presence was keenly felt that day. My son, Brian, remembered him with warmth and gratitude, and we all raised a glass to Frank, honoring the deep bond he shared with our family. These memories paint a vivid picture of a man who loved deeply and welcomed people from all walks of life. Frank’s character was defined by compassion and acceptance, not by the traits that these recent accusations attempt to ascribe to him. It’s a profound injustice to portray him in such a distorted light, and it’s a disservice to the legacy of someone who genuinely valued and celebrated diversity and worked tirelessly for this community. Thank you for considering my perspective as someone who knew Frank well and experienced firsthand his unwavering kindness and respect for our diverse cultures and traditions. In light of this, I respectfully request that you take the following actions to preserve the truth and restore Frank’s legacy: 1. Remove the HRC Frank Bogert Monument Report from the city’s website and publicly acknowledge that the report contains inaccuracies and misrepresentations. 2. Issue an apology to the Bogert family for endorsing and promoting misleading information as part of a political agenda that has unfairly marred Frank’s reputation. 11/14/2024 Public Comment Item 3A 3. Relocate Frank’s statue to the Village Green at the city’s expense, honoring his contributions in a respectful and inclusive way. 4. Correct the city records on Section 14 and all references to Mayor Frank Bogert, removing any false and misleading statements, including references to the discredited 1968 Attorney General Report. 5. Disclose the authors of the HRC Monument Report and address the issue of plagiarism within the report to ensure transparency and accountability. Frank dedicated his life to serving and uplifting the people of Palm Springs. He welcomed everyone, regardless of background, and was an integral part of our community’s history and growth. Please, let us honor his memory in a manner that reflects the true nature of his character and his contributions. Thank you for your consideration and commitment to truth and fairness. Sincerely, Stacey Johnson 11/14/2024 Public Comment Item 3A From:Betsy Ceccanti via constituent@civiclick.com To:City Clerk Subject:Action Requested for Frank Bogert’s Legacy Date:Monday, November 11, 2024 4:27:46 AM NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Dear City Clerk, Dear City Council Members, As a member of the community, I urge you to take action to honor Frank Bogert’s legacy by: 1. Removing the HRC Frank Bogert Monument Report from the city’s website due to its inaccuracies. 2. Apologizing to the Bogert family for any harm caused by misinformation. 3. Relocating the statue to Village Green at the city’s expense. 4. Correcting historical records on Section 14 to remove false references about Mayor Bogert. 5. Disclosing the authors of the HRC Frank Bogert Monument Report and addressing its plagiarism for transparency. Thank you for taking steps to respect Frank Bogert's contributions and our city’s heritage. Sincerely, Betsy Ceccanti 40740 Glenwood lane Palm Desert , CA 92260 ridetw@me.com 11/14/2024 Public Comment Item 3A From:Susan To:City Clerk Subject:FOIA Date:Sunday, November 10, 2024 10:02:37 AM NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Please provide City Council meeting Justin Clifton comments regarding giving funds for Section 14 is not legal since personal property; i.e. in other words there existed NO real property rights, eminent domain or the like. Then the city charter where property tax payer funds may only be used for city maintenance and city management (not gifts- for example giving funds for other than city maintenance or city owned property, etc. Thank you. Always~ Go placidly amid the noise and the haste, and remember what peace there may be in silence. As far as possible, without surrender, be on good terms with all persons.Desiderata Susan 760/567 8867 Susan Smith Cogliano Emeritus* Realtor, Broker G.R.I DRE#00575036 destoseaproperties@gmail.com Desert to Sea Properties Realtor since 1976 *Emeritus 40+ yrs NAR honors Palm Springs- Desert Resident 1957 11/14/2024 Public Comment Item 3A From:J.M. Salaberry To:City Clerk Subject:Francine Bradley re Mayor Bogert Date:Thursday, November 14, 2024 3:54:09 PM NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. To: Palm Springs Council Members From: Francine A. Bradley, Ph.D. Deep Well Ranch, Palm Springs Re: Mayor Bogert controversy I continue to be disturbed by the falsehoods being spread about the late, Mayor Frank Bogert. As someone who first came in contact with him over 60 years ago and who has heard so many stories about his efforts to promote Palm Springs and his quietly done good deeds, I urge you to remove the Frank Bogert Monument Report that is on the City’s website. Also let the citizens see who actually drafted this erroneous report. It is a pity that Mayor Bogert’s widow and family have been exposed to this smear campaign. They are owed an apology. The City should also correct its records on Sec. 14. Please remove the falsehood about Mayor Bogert. Finally, please put the statue of Mayor Bogert in the Village Green. Many of us know and appreciate the history of the city’s pioneers. The City can take the lead in educating new residents. jmsalaberry@ucdavis.edu Sent from my iPad 11/14/2024 Public Comment Item 3A From:lori russell To:City Clerk Subject:Frank Bogert/Section 14 Date:Thursday, November 14, 2024 3:02:56 PM NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Hello, My name is Lori, I am Frank Bogert's oldest grandaughter. I, as well as my 84 year old mother - and the rest of our family -still live here in Palm Springs. His wife still lives a stones throw away from City Hall. Since the first time I saw a Facebook post a few years ago, regarding the petition to remove my grandfathers statue. It was shocking and hurtful to my whole family. I was there when they dedicated that statue and I was there when the removed it. As was the rest of my family and friends. It is my hope that after all of this time, and after reading factual historical documentation of my grandfathers actions, that the City can apologize to all of us that were affected by the horrible things said about him. I also would love to be able to take his great grandkids to see his statue and the Village Green! Thank you for your time. Regards, Lori 11/14/2024 Public Comment Item 3A From:Jeffrey Bernstein To:City Clerk Subject:Fwd: Action Requested for Frank Bogert’s Legacy Date:Friday, November 8, 2024 9:24:15 PM Thank you! Jeffrey Jeffrey Bernstein Mayor City of Palm Springs 442-305-9942 Jeffrey.Bernstein@palmspringsca.gov Begin forwarded message: From: "Ken Garett via constituent@civiclick.com" <constituent@civiclick.com> Subject: Action Requested for Frank Bogert’s Legacy Date: November 8, 2024 at 6:43:16 PM PST To: jeffrey.bernstein@palmspringsca.gov NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Dear Jeffrey Bernstein, Dear City Council Members, As a member of the community, I urge you to take action to honor Frank Bogert’s legacy by: 1. Removing the HRC Frank Bogert Monument Report from the city’s website due to its inaccuracies. 2. Apologizing to the Bogert family for any harm caused by misinformation. 11/14/2024 Public Comment Item 3A 3. Relocating the statue to Village Green at the city’s expense. 4. Correcting historical records on Section 14 to remove false references about Mayor Bogert. 5. Disclosing the authors of the HRC Frank Bogert Monument Report and addressing its plagiarism for transparency. Thank you for taking steps to respect Frank Bogert's contributions and our city’s heritage. Sincerely, Ken Garett 225 S Civic Dr #211 Palm Springs , CA 92262 Doctork1955@aol.com 11/14/2024 Public Comment Item 3A From:Ken Garett via constituent@civiclick.com To:City Clerk Subject:Action Requested for Frank Bogert’s Legacy Date:Friday, November 8, 2024 6:43:34 PM NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Dear City Clerk, Dear City Council Members, As a member of the community, I urge you to take action to honor Frank Bogert’s legacy by: 1. Removing the HRC Frank Bogert Monument Report from the city’s website due to its inaccuracies. 2. Apologizing to the Bogert family for any harm caused by misinformation. 3. Relocating the statue to Village Green at the city’s expense. 4. Correcting historical records on Section 14 to remove false references about Mayor Bogert. 5. Disclosing the authors of the HRC Frank Bogert Monument Report and addressing its plagiarism for transparency. Thank you for taking steps to respect Frank Bogert's contributions and our city’s heritage. Sincerely, Ken Garett 225 S Civic Dr #211 Palm Springs , CA 92262 Doctork1955@aol.com 11/14/2024 Public Comment Item 3A From:Rich Pell via constituent@civiclick.com To:City Clerk Subject:Action Requested for Frank Bogert’s Legacy Date:Friday, November 8, 2024 3:14:33 PM NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Dear City Clerk, Dear City Council Members, My family have known the Bogert family going back eighty years. The unfounded actions with regard to section 14 must be addressed. I urge you to take action to honor Frank Bogert’s legacy by: 1. Removing the HRC Frank Bogert Monument Report from the city’s website due to its inaccuracies. 2. Apologizing to the Bogert family for any harm caused by misinformation. 3. Relocating the statue to Village Green at the city’s expense. 4. Correcting historical records on Section 14 to remove false references about Mayor Bogert. 5. Disclosing the authors of the HRC Frank Bogert Monument Report and addressing its plagiarism for transparency. Thank you for taking steps to respect Frank Bogert's contributions and our city’s heritage. Sincerely, Rich Pell 1400 E Palm Canyon Drive , Apt 115 Palm Springs, CA 92264 rpell8@gmail.com 11/14/2024 Public Comment Item 3A From:Larry Gouveia via constituent@civiclick.com To:City Clerk Subject:Action Requested for Frank Bogert’s Legacy Date:Friday, November 8, 2024 2:17:27 PM NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Dear City Clerk, Dear City Council Members, As a member of the community, I urge you to take action to honor Frank Bogert’s legacy by: 1. Removing the HRC Frank Bogert Monument Report from the city’s website due to its inaccuracies. 2. Apologizing to the Bogert family for any harm caused by misinformation. 3. Relocating the statue to Village Green at the city’s expense. 4. Correcting historical records on Section 14 to remove false references about Mayor Bogert. 5. Disclosing the authors of the HRC Frank Bogert Monument Report and addressing its plagiarism for transparency. Thank you for taking steps to respect Frank Bogert's contributions and our city’s heritage. Sincerely, Larry Gouveia 2415 S. Araby Dr Palm Springs, CA 92264 lgouveia@sbcglobal.net 11/14/2024 Public Comment Item 3A