Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutNon-AgendaFrom:Abraham Ishaq To:City Clerk Subject:Public Comment - 10.10.2024 Date:Thursday, October 10, 2024 2:47:27 PM Attachments:Middleton Emails.pdf NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Hello, I would like to include this email exchange to the City Council's Non-Agenda Public Comments for October 10, 2024. I want the public to know what Lisa Middleton thinks of annexation of land. I wonder if she is going to support Russia if they win the war with Ukraine and Russia annexes land? Thank you, Abraham 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda Abraham Ishaq <abrahamishaq@gmail.com> Drafted Options to Address Resolution No. 25147 Lisa Middleton <Lisa.Middleton@palmspringsca.gov>Fri, Sep 6, 2024 at 4:38 PM To: Abraham Ishaq <abrahamishaq@gmail.com> Cc: Scott Stiles <Scott.Stiles@palmspringsca.gov>, Jeff Ballinger <jeff.ballinger@bbklaw.com> Mr. Ishaq Thank you for your thoughtful email. We have now exchanged multiple emails on this subject. Our differing viewpoints remain. Respectfully, we have reached a point where we each rephrase and effectively repeat what we have previously said to one another. Thank you, Lisa Middleton City of Palm Springs Council Member, District 5 3200 East Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, CA 92262 PO BOX 2743 Palm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Office: (760) 323-8200 Mobile: (760) 507-7851 Lisa.Middleton@palmspringsca.gov The Palm Springs 5th City Council District includes the following neighborhoods Historic Tennis Club, Parkview Mobile Estates, Warm Sands, Tahquitz River Estates, Deepwell Estates, Twin Palms, The Mesa, Canyon Palms, Canyon Estates, Canyon Corridor, Indian Canyons and Andreas Hills. 10/10/24, 2:36 PM Gmail - Drafted Options to Address Resolution No. 25147 https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=9777348c63&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-f:1809491884861715687&dsqt=1&simpl=msg-f:1809491884861715687 1/7 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda This account is for official City of Palm Springs business only. Please direct all CalPERS related correspondence to my CalPERS email address: lisa.middleton@ calpers.ca.gov Please do not send personal correspondence to my official accounts. From: Abraham Ishaq <abrahamishaq@gmail.com> Date: Thursday, September 5, 2024 at 4:22 AM To: Lisa Middleton <Lisa.Middleton@palmspringsca.gov> Cc: Scott Stiles <Scott.Stiles@palmspringsca.gov>, Jeff Ballinger <jeff.ballinger@bbklaw.com> Subject: Re: Drafted Options to Address Resolution No. 25147 NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Dear Council Member Middleton, Thank you for your thoughtful response. I appreciate the opportunity to engage on this issue. While I understand that the U.S. supports UN Resolution 497, I’m sorry, but I’m a little confused. Are you saying that you support the U.S. government’s stance, which currently backs Israel’s annexation of land in Syria? This position was notably changed during the Trump administration, making the U.S. the first and only major country to recognize Israel’s sovereignty over the Golan Heights. I want to ensure there’s no misinterpretation, so I’d like to ask clearly: Are you or are you not okay with Israel’s annexation of the Golan Heights? For the public’s understanding, I believe it's essential to make your position on this matter clear, particularly given the humanitarian fallout from this annexation. The annexation of the Golan Heights has led to numerous human rights violations, including the displacement of Syrian Druze communities, restrictions on their movement, the destruction of their homes, and the denial of access to basic services. These residents were given the difficult choice of taking Israeli citizenship or becoming stateless, and many chose the latter, leaving them in a precarious and vulnerable situation. I hope that, by clarifying your stance, we can have a more transparent discussion on this issue and what it means for the values we aim to represent as a community. You are correct in saying that the City of Palm Springs does not have a direct role in advancing the two-state solution, but it was your Council that decided to include "the aspirations of the Palestinian people" in its resolution. By voting in favor of Resolution No. 25147, the Council explicitly voiced support for the State of Israel, despite numerous reports from reputable sources labeling Israel as an apartheid state. Israel's destruction of infrastructure in the West Bank, ongoing settlement expansion, and violence toward Palestinians raise serious questions about how it can truly support a two-state solution. As the saying goes, "actions speak louder than words." How can the destruction of Palestinian infrastructure and the continued annexation of land be seen as a commitment to peace or a two-state solution? While the current U.S. administration may voice concerns about Israel’s actions in Gaza, Israel has a long history of violence toward Palestinians, land theft in the West Bank and Syria (the country from which both my parents come), and significant humanitarian violations. Yet, your Council chose to disregard these facts and release a resolution in support of Israel. 10/10/24, 2:36 PM Gmail - Drafted Options to Address Resolution No. 25147 https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=9777348c63&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-f:1809491884861715687&dsqt=1&simpl=msg-f:1809491884861715687 2/7 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda Your silence on these issues, while it may not be interpreted as “comfort with” or “ignoring” the humanitarian violations, is ultimately overshadowed by your vote in support of a resolution that endorses Israel. That vote, in effect, signals a green light for the Israeli government to continue its actions—actions that, throughout its history, have included the displacement of over 700,000 Palestinians during the Nakba in 1948, the illegal occupation of the West Bank, and the ongoing expansion of settlements condemned by the international community. Moreover, Israel has conducted several major military campaigns in Gaza long before the events of October 7, 2023, including Operation Cast Lead in 2008-2009, Operation Pillar of Defense in 2012, and Operation Protective Edge in 2014, all of which resulted in the deaths of thousands of civilians and significant destruction of Gaza’s infrastructure. These repeated assaults on Gaza’s population have killed countless civilians, including children, destroyed hospitals, schools, and homes, and displaced thousands. By voting for this resolution, you and the Council disregarded all of this history—history that clearly demonstrates a pattern of human rights violations. The humanitarian toll of these policies is undeniable, and by supporting the resolution, the City Council has, in essence, aligned itself with these ongoing atrocities. I hope you’ll consider the implications of the Council’s resolution and whether it still aligns with the values of our city. Thank you for your time and for continuing to engage in this important discussion. Best regards, Abraham Ishaq On Fri, Aug 30, 2024 at 5:46 PM Lisa Middleton <Lisa.Middleton@palmspringsca.gov> wrote: Mr. Ishaq Thank you for your thoughtful reply. As I understand it the United States has supported UN Resolution 497 and the United States Government across many administrations has supported a two-state solution in Palestine and Israel. I personally support both positions of my government. I do not believe the City of Palm Springs has a role to play in moving forward the work of the United States Government to advance the two-state solution. To the best of my knowledge, notwithstanding our October 2023 Council Resolution, I have not publicly commented on the actions of the Israeli government over the past year in Gaza. My public silence should not be interpreted as “comfort with” or “ignoring” of the reputable reports of the numerous people killed, maimed and displaced in Gaza. 10/10/24, 2:36 PM Gmail - Drafted Options to Address Resolution No. 25147 https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=9777348c63&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-f:1809491884861715687&dsqt=1&simpl=msg-f:1809491884861715687 3/7 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda The Biden/Harris Administration has made clear its support of Israel’s right to exist and to defend itself. It has also made clear its concerns regarding some of the present Israeli government’s actions in Gaza, the necessity to reach a ceasefire, return the hostages and repair the suffering in Gaza. I do not believe my Council or I have more to publicly say on these issues at this time. Thank you, Lisa Middleton City of Palm Springs Council Member, District 5 3200 East Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, CA 92262 PO BOX 2743 Palm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Office: (760) 323-8200 Mobile: (760) 507-7851 Lisa.Middleton@palmspringsca.gov The Palm Springs 5th City Council District includes the following neighborhoods Historic Tennis Club, Parkview Mobile Estates, Warm Sands, Tahquitz River Estates, Deepwell Estates, Twin Palms, The Mesa, Canyon Palms, Canyon Estates, Canyon Corridor, Indian Canyons and Andreas Hills. This account is for official City of Palm Springs business only. Please direct all CalPERS related correspondence to my CalPERS email address: lisa.middleton@ calpers.ca.gov Please do not send personal correspondence to my official accounts. From: Abraham Ishaq <abrahamishaq@gmail.com> Date: Thursday, August 29, 2024 at 6:36 PM To: Lisa Middleton <Lisa.Middleton@palmspringsca.gov> 10/10/24, 2:36 PM Gmail - Drafted Options to Address Resolution No. 25147 https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=9777348c63&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-f:1809491884861715687&dsqt=1&simpl=msg-f:1809491884861715687 4/7 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda Cc: Scott Stiles <Scott.Stiles@palmspringsca.gov>, Jeff Ballinger <jeff.ballinger@bbklaw.com> Subject: Re: Drafted Options to Address Resolution No. 25147 NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Dear Council Member Middleton, Thank you for your thoughtful response and for taking the time to consider this matter. I understand your position and appreciate your perspective on the broader geopolitical context. Regardless of whether a ceasefire is agreed upon, the city is currently on record supporting a foreign state—a state that has illegally annexed land, such as the Golan Heights, which has been condemned by the UN in Security Council Resolution 497. Israel continues to conduct raids in the West Bank, including one as recent as last night (source). These actions raise serious concerns, as highlighted in a recent New York Times article titled, "Palestinians Face Israeli Raids During Ramadan at Al-Aqsa Mosque" (source), which details the increasing tensions and violence during a time of significant religious observance. I believe the drafted resolutions offer the City Council an opportunity to review what was written last October and release a more considered and less emotional resolution. Additionally, I came across an NPR article, a trusted news source, discussing Amnesty International’s findings that label Israel’s practices as apartheid (source). I would like to ask directly: Do you disagree with Amnesty International’s findings? Are you openly ignoring these findings? Would you be OK with these practices occurring in our country or any other country? That said, if you are comfortable with the actions that Israel is taking, then I respect your position and understand that your stance is clear. Please let me know if there are any further discussions or revisions you'd be open to, as I believe constructive engagement is crucial in these matters. Thank you again for your time and consideration. Best regards, Abraham Ishaq On Mon, Aug 19, 2024 at 1:59 PM Lisa Middleton <Lisa.Middleton@palmspringsca.gov> wrote: Mr. Ishaq Thank you for reaching out. It remains my hope that the negotiations led by the Biden Administration will soon result in a Cease Fire in Gaza, a return of the hostages to their homes, a re-building of Gaza and a return of Gazans to their homes. 10/10/24, 2:36 PM Gmail - Drafted Options to Address Resolution No. 25147 https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=9777348c63&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-f:1809491884861715687&dsqt=1&simpl=msg-f:1809491884861715687 5/7 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda That said, I do not believe that at this time the City Council of Palm Springs weighing-in on this issue serves a broad public purpose within our city. I appreciate that you and your colleagues believe the City Council should not have weighed-in last October. Your argument has been respectfully heard. Respectfully, I do not conclude that we should revisit the City Council resolution of October 2023. Thank you, Lisa Middleton City of Palm Springs Council Member, District 5 3200 East Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, CA 92262 PO BOX 2743 Palm Springs, CA 92263-2743 Office: (760) 323-8200 Mobile: (760) 507-7851 Lisa.Middleton@palmspringsca.gov The Palm Springs 5th City Council District includes the following neighborhoods Historic Tennis Club, Parkview Mobile Estates, Warm Sands, Tahquitz River Estates, Deepwell Estates, Twin Palms, The Mesa, Canyon Palms, Canyon Estates, Canyon Corridor, Indian Canyons and Andreas Hills. This account is for official City of Palm Springs business only. Please direct all CalPERS related correspondence to my CalPERS email address: lisa.middleton@calpers.ca.gov Please do not send personal correspondence to my official accounts. From: Abraham Ishaq <abrahamishaq@gmail.com> Date: Sunday, August 18, 2024 at 5:15 PM To: Lisa Middleton <Lisa.Middleton@palmspringsca.gov> Subject: Drafted Options to Address Resolution No. 25147 10/10/24, 2:36 PM Gmail - Drafted Options to Address Resolution No. 25147 https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=9777348c63&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-f:1809491884861715687&dsqt=1&simpl=msg-f:1809491884861715687 6/7 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Dear Councilmember Middleton, I hope you’re doing well. It was suggested that I draft some options for addressing Resolution No. 25147, and I wanted to share them with the entire council. One of the attached documents includes a table to make the comparison of the three options easier, along with references and links to support the statements in the resolutions. The three options presented are as follows: 1. Rescind the Resolution 2. Rescind the Resolution and Release a New One 3. Amend the Existing Resolution I appreciate your willingness to discuss these options, and I’d love to hear your thoughts. I hope one of these options (or an iteration of them) will be suitable for inclusion on a City Council agenda. Please feel free to reach out if you have any questions or need further clarification. Best regards, Abraham Ishaq 10/10/24, 2:36 PM Gmail - Drafted Options to Address Resolution No. 25147 https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=9777348c63&view=pt&search=all&permmsgid=msg-f:1809491884861715687&dsqt=1&simpl=msg-f:1809491884861715687 7/7 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda From:Abraham Ishaq To:City Clerk Subject:Public Comment - 10.10.2024 Date:Thursday, October 10, 2024 2:32:08 PM NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Hello, I would like to include these headlines to the City Council's Non-Agenda Public Comments for October 10, 2024. AP News At least 22 killed in airstrikes in central Beirut, with Israel also firing on U.N. peacekeepers AP News Middle East latest: Dozens killed as Israeli troops pound central and northern Gaza Washington Post North Gaza hospitals ordered to evacuate; U.S. backs Israel’s ground offensive in Lebanon Sky News Middle East latest: Two peacekeepers injured by Israeli tank, UN says - as it warns of possible international law violation CNN October 9, 2024: Netanyahu warns Lebanon of destruction ‘similar to what we see in Gaza’ Thank you, Abraham 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda From:Abraham Ishaq To:City Clerk Subject:Public Comment - 10.10.2024 Date:Thursday, October 10, 2024 2:26:48 PM Attachments:image.png image.png image.png image.png NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Hello, I would like to include these images to the City Council's Non-Agenda Public Comments for October 10, 2024. These images show only some of the Terror and Bloodshed by Israel. The City Council continues to stand by its support for Israel regardless of these human rights violations. 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda Thank you, Abraham 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda From:Abraham Ishaq To:City Clerk Subject:Public Comment - 10.10.2024 Date:Thursday, October 10, 2024 2:23:16 PM Attachments:The Desert Sun - Abraham Ishaq.docx Option 3 - Amend Resolution.docx Option 1 - Rescind Resolution.docx Option 2 - Rescind Resolution and Release New Resolution.docx NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Hello, I would like to include the attachments to the City Council's Non-Agenda Public Comments for October 10, 2024. The attached includes a wonderfully written article and it also includes the draft resolutions noted in the article. Thank you, Abraham 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda The Desert Sun Palm Springs council passed resolution supporting Israel. One man is pushing to change it Sam Morgen, Palm Springs Desert Sun Fri, October 4, 2024 at 2:39 PM PDT·9 min read Almost every two weeks for the last 10 months, Abraham Ishaq has attended meetings of the Palm Springs City Council and urged them to reconsider a resolution it passed last year in support of the State of Israel. The 38-year-old finance worker says he is giving voice to a sizeable group of locals who believe the resolution is not only unfair, but improperly ignores those residents who take issue with Israel's treatment of Palestinians. As the son of Syrian immigrants, he has a personal connection to the ongoing war in the Middle East that has spread now from Gaza and the West Bank to Lebanon. He says some friends are afraid to speak out for fear of retribution. One person interviewed by The Desert Sun later retracted their statement because of worries about their safety. Abraham Ishaq, a Palm Springs resident, is seen Oct. 3 outside city hall. 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda So far, the council has appeared resolute in its backing of the resolution, although that may be changing. Ishaq said he has spoken with several councilmembers, who have indicated they would be open to considering making changes. However, only Councilmember Lisa Middleton responded to questions from The Desert Sun. She said she was not inclined to revisit the issue. Ishaq remains committed, even if it could be futile. He has submitted a proposed amendment to the council as the one-year anniversary of the resolution's passage approaches and he says he will continue to advocate on its behalf. "Every time I want to skip the city council meeting, I tell myself the people in Gaza don’t get a choice to leave Gaza," he said. "I can go spend a couple hours sitting in a chair twice a month. It’s the least I can do to show my support for Gaza." The days following Oct. 7 The city council unanimously passed its Israel resolution on Oct. 12, 2023, less than a week after Hamas militants broke through barriers separating Israel from the Gaza Strip, a small territory on the eastern Mediterranean home to Palestinian refugees and their descendants. The attack resulted in around 1,200 Israeli deaths along with about 240 captured hostages, according to figures reported by Israeli authorities. The sudden nature of the Oct. 7 attack shocked many in Israel and beyond. The death toll, which included women and children, was the deadliest massacre against Jews since the Holocaust, according to multiple media reports. The New York Times reported in early September 2024 that more than 60 living hostages remained in Gaza, along with the bodies of 35 others. The Palm Springs council appears to have acted quickly in an attempt to make statement during a trying time for the city's Jewish population. The resolution was passed using an emergency provision that allows an item to be added to the agenda after it has already been publicized. The resolution gained little publicity at the time, and few people spoke specifically about it during the meeting, possibly because it was not initially published on the agenda. (The city did post a public advisory the day before the meeting noting it would be discussed.) Councilmember Jeffrey Bernstein, who is Jewish, choked up while reading the draft he had written with the help of Councilmember Christy Holstege, who said during the meeting she had converted to Judaism. "Regardless of what people think about Israel and Palestine or a one-state or two-state solution, there’s no justification for a terrorist act against civilians, women and children, and for the taking of hostages," Bernstein said at the time. "I know that our Jewish community is worried. I know that as somebody who has lived in Israel, who is Jewish, who was in New York City during 9/11, that terrorism is something that does effect our residents. I think that it is important to have this resolution, that our residents know that we take a stand." 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda The resolution The five-paragraph resolution expresses the city's "steadfast and united support to the State of Israel" as well as a condemnation of Hamas. One section of the resolution recognizes the "legitimate aspirations of the Palestinian people, and support equal measures of justice and freedom for Israelis and Palestinians alike." The resolution draws a distinction between Hamas and the aspirations of the Palestinians, saying Hamas offers nothing for Palestine "other than more terror and bloodshed." The resolution ends by saying, "We, the City Council of the City of Palm Springs, will remain united and coordinated, together as allies, and as common friends of Israel to condemn terrorism and supported efforts to set the conditions for a peaceful and integrated Middle East region." Aftermath Initially, Palm Springs appeared to be in line with a trend among municipalities who passed pro- Israel resolutions. Among others, city councils in Indio, Beverly Hills and Chicago, and the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors, all passed similar resolutions. However, as the the war between Hamas and Israel expanded, the Israeli government began to draw criticism for its tactics. The United Nations says more than 41,689 Palestinians have been reported killed since Oct. 7, along with around 96,625 reported injured. More than 70,000 housing units have been destroyed in Gaza, according to the UN, and 1.9 million people have been displaced. Recently, Israel has attacked Hezbollah, an Islamist political party and militant group in neighboring Lebanon, in an attempt to destroy the group that violently opposes its existence. The vast scale of the war has impacted not only Palestinian and Lebanese people, but their family members abroad. The ongoing destruction has added to the criticism against the city's resolution as some see Israel's actions as inhumane. The Indio council rescinded its resolution condemning the Hamas attack in February after a community outcry. Many other cities have passed cease-fire resolutions in an attempt to make statements in support of ending the war. Personal connections Ishaq receives texts from friends in Lebanon who witness Israeli airstrikes in their country. Sunny Berro, a 33-year-old Palm Springs resident whose parents immigrated to America from Lebanon, said he worries about his extended family still in the country. He said one of his cousins died from an Israeli bomb in May and his aunt refuses to leave the southern part of the country that has been subjected to Israeli attacks. "It feels like a backpack of bricks on your chest at all times," he said. "You wake up in the morning and the first thing on your mind is, 'God, I hope they’re still alive,' and I’m so afraid to call and check. Some days I won’t even call because I know I won’t be able to handle bad news." 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda To Berro, who has spoken out against the city's resolution, the city's action does not align with his feelings and has added to an already-painful situation. "I’m not angry that they passed this. It’s not surprising to me," Berro said. "I think if anything, after a year of what’s happening, I’m numb and desensitized and disassociated." A rabbi's perspective If the city council rescinds or changes the resolution, it risks alienating Palm Springs' Jewish community. Rabbi Steven Rosenberg, of Temple Isaiah, said many took comfort in the city's resolution, and he questioned why anyone would take issue with the city's wording. "The Jewish community felt that the city council was reaching out to them in solidarity and saying that, 'we stand with you,' which is important," he said. "Why anyone would not agree with that, to me, is just baffling." The city's action took place during a heightened period of antisemitism. The FBI reported 343 anti-Jewish hate crime offenses nationally in October 2023, more than three times the amount from the previous October. Israel has argued its efforts in Lebanon and Gaza are meant to stamp out terrorist organizations intent on destroying their country. It has positioned its actions as legitimate operations against security threats. "It makes me very, very, sad that Israel is not afforded the same kind of accommodation with respect to when tragedy happens than any other country," Rosenberg said. "When 9/11 happened, there was no one calling for a ceasefire. We went and found the people that did this horrible terrorist act, and we destroyed them. And so today, with Hamas and Hezbollah especially, there will only be peace when these two terrorist organizations are completely rooted out." Closing the door Typically, cities do not comment on foreign policy. Their resolutions have little if any impact on international affairs, but Ishaq argues the city opened itself to criticism when it passed the resolution in support of Israel, and has a responsibility to acknowledge those who do not agree with it. "They opened the door and they don’t want to close it," he said. "It’s basically saying Israeli lives matter more than Palestinian lives. It’s not inclusive. It’s not balanced. If you are going to comment on a terrorist attack, then you have to comment on all terrorist attacks going forward." He has proposed an amended resolution that adds a condemnation of Islamophobia and antisemitism. However, the proposal also has language acknowledging Israeli military actions have resulted "in the deaths of many civilians" as well as a condemnation of apartheid. 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda Apartheid is a widely condemned system of racial segregation in South Africa that ended in the 1990's. Israel, with its separation of Palestinians and Israelis, has been accused of having an apartheid system, although it disputes this claim. Some members of the council may be uncomfortable including such references in an amended resolution. However, Ishaq said he is open to his proposal being changed. "As a community let’s join together and support each other," he said. "It should have been worded that way instead of steadfastly in support the state of Israel." His amended resolution attempts to bridge the gap. "The City Council recognizes the need to amend (the Israel resolution) to better reflect inclusive and broader humanitarian principles," Ishaq wrote as part of his proposal, adding, "the City Council is committed to promoting peace and equality for all people, irrespective of their nationality, religion, or ethnicity." Ishaq plans on speaking at the next council meeting on Thursday, Oct. 10, almost one year to the day of the original resolution. He hopes an amended resolution will be brought up. 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda Option #1 - Draft for a resolution to fully rescind Resolution No. 25147: --- RESOLUTION NO. [New Number] A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS, CALIFORNIA, RESCINDING RESOLUTION NO. 25147 WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Palm Springs adopted Resolution No. 25147 on October 12, 2023, expressing support for the State of Israel and condemning Hamas for terrorism; and WHEREAS, since the adoption of Resolution No. 25147, Israel has engaged in military actions against Hamas, resulting in the deaths of many civilians 1, including elderly women, children, and entire families2, raising serious humanitarian concerns3 and leading to accusations of war crimes by recognized international entities4; and WHEREAS, after further reflection, meetings with the public, and public testimony given at subsequent city council meetings, and WHEREAS, the City Council acknowledges that the nature in which Resolution No. 25147 was released as an emergency resolution allowed little time for public input and review; and WHEREAS, the City Council recognizes the importance of addressing the concerns and sentiments of all community members, including those directly affected by the conflict in the region; and WHEREAS, the City Council is committed to promoting peace and equality for all people, irrespective of their nationality, religion, or ethnicity; and WHEREAS, the City Council unequivocally condemns all acts of terrorism, violence, anti- Semitism, and Islamophobia, recognizing that such acts are detrimental to the pursuit of peace and justice; and WHEREAS, the City Council acknowledges the importance of diplomatic efforts and dialogue in resolving conflicts and maintaining peace; and 1 Gaza death toll: how many Palestinians has Israel's campaign killed 2 The war in Gaza has wiped out entire Palestinian families. AP documents 60 who lost dozens or more 3 Details of the humanitarian crisis in Gaza 4 UN inquiry says Israel and Hamas have both committed war crimes since October 7 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda WHEREAS, the City Council condemns apartheid 5 and genocide6 in all forms, recognizing the suffering of communities affected by such injustices; and WHEREAS, the City Council affirms that Palm Springs remains dedicated to promoting balanced and inclusive approaches to international issues, ensuring that the city's resolutions reflect the broad principles of human rights and justice rather than unwavering support for any specific state or entity, and believes in the importance of thoughtful consideration before issuing resolutions related to international affairs, especially as emergencies, emphasizing the need for public comment and review in such cases; and WHEREAS, the City Council reaffirms its commitment to the Palm Springs motto: "Palm Springs is an inclusive world-class city dedicated to providing excellent and responsive public services to enhance the quality of life for current and future generations"; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS AS FOLLOWS: SECTION 1. Resolution No. 25147, adopted on October 12, 2023, is hereby rescinded in its entirety. SECTION 2. This resolution shall take effect immediately upon its adoption. ADOPTED THIS [Day] DAY OF [Month], [Year]. ATTEST: [City Clerk's Name], City Clerk [Mayor's Name], Mayor 5 H.R.4868 - Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act of 1986 6 US Government Statements on Genocide 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda Option #2 - Draft for a resolution to fully rescind Resolution No. 25147 and release a new resolution: — RESOLUTION NO. [New Number] A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS, CALIFORNIA, RESCINDING RESOLUTION NO. 25147 AND PROMOTING PEACE, EQUALITY, AND CONDEMNATION OF ALL FORMS OF HATE AND VIOLENCE WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Palm Springs adopted Resolution No. 25147 on October 12, 2023, expressing support for the State of Israel and condemning Hamas for terrorism; and WHEREAS, since the adoption of Resolution No. 25147, Israel has engaged in military actions against Hamas, resulting in the deaths of many civilians 1, including elderly women, children, and entire families2, raising serious humanitarian concerns3 and leading to accusations of war crimes by recognized international entities4; and WHEREAS, after further reflection, meetings with the public, and public testimony given at subsequent city council meetings, and WHEREAS, the City Council acknowledges that the nature in which Resolution No. 25147 was released as an emergency resolution allowed little time for public input and review; and WHEREAS, the City Council recognizes the importance of addressing the concerns and sentiments of all community members, including those directly affected by the conflict in the region; and WHEREAS, the City Council recognizes the need for a resolution that is inclusive of the entire community and addresses broader humanitarian principles; and WHEREAS, the City Council is committed to promoting peace and equality for all people, irrespective of their nationality, religion, or ethnicity; and WHEREAS, the City Council unequivocally condemns all acts of terrorism, violence, anti- Semitism, and Islamophobia, recognizing that such acts are detrimental to the pursuit of peace and justice; and 1 Gaza death toll: how many Palestinians has Israel's campaign killed 2 The war in Gaza has wiped out entire Palestinian families. AP documents 60 who lost dozens or more 3 Details of the humanitarian crisis in Gaza 4 UN inquiry says Israel and Hamas have both committed war crimes since October 7 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda WHEREAS, the City Council acknowledges the importance of diplomatic efforts and dialogue in resolving conflicts and maintaining peace; and WHEREAS, the City Council condemns apartheid 5 and genocide6 in all forms, recognizing the suffering of communities affected by such injustices; and WHEREAS, the City Council affirms that Palm Springs remains dedicated to promoting balanced and inclusive approaches to international issues, ensuring that the city's resolutions reflect the broad principles of human rights and justice rather than unwavering support for any specific state or entity, and believes in the importance of thoughtful consideration before issuing resolutions related to international affairs, especially as emergencies, emphasizing the need for public comment and review in such cases; and WHEREAS, the City Council reaffirms its commitment to the Palm Springs motto: "Palm Springs is an inclusive world-class city dedicated to providing excellent and responsive public services to enhance the quality of life for current and future generations"; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS AS FOLLOWS: SECTION 1. Resolution No. 25147, adopted on October 12, 2023, is hereby rescinded in its entirety. SECTION 2. The City Council of the City of Palm Springs affirms its commitment to promoting peace, equality, and justice for all people. SECTION 3. The City Council condemns all acts of terrorism, violence, anti-Semitism, and Islamophobia, and calls for diplomatic resolutions to conflicts to maintain peace. SECTION 4. The City Council condemns apartheid and genocide in all forms, recognizing the historical and ongoing suffering of all affected communities. SECTION 5. The City Council will ensure that future resolutions related to international affairs are thoughtfully considered, allowing for adequate public comment and review before adoption. SECTION 6. This resolution shall take effect immediately upon its adoption. ADOPTED THIS [Day] DAY OF [Month], [Year]. ATTEST: [City Clerk's Name], City Clerk [Mayor's Name], Mayor 5 H.R.4868 - Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act of 1986 6 US Government Statements on Genocide 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda Option #3 - Draft for a resolution to amend Resolution No. 25147 and replace with the following: — RESOLUTION NO. [New Number] A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS, CALIFORNIA, AMENDING RESOLUTION NO. 25147 TO PROMOTE PEACE, EQUALITY, AND CONDEMNATION OF ALL FORMS OF HATE AND VIOLENCE WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Palm Springs adopted Resolution No. 25147 on October 12, 2023, expressing support for the State of Israel and condemning Hamas for terrorism; and WHEREAS, since the adoption of Resolution No. 25147, Israel has engaged in military actions against Hamas, resulting in the deaths of many civilians 1, including elderly women, children, and entire families2, raising serious humanitarian concerns3 and leading to accusations of war crimes by recognized international entities4; and WHEREAS, after further reflection, meetings with the public, and public testimony given at subsequent city council meetings, and WHEREAS, the City Council acknowledges that the nature in which Resolution No. 25147 was released as an emergency resolution allowed little time for public input and review; and WHEREAS, the City Council recognizes the importance of addressing the concerns and sentiments of all community members, including those directly affected by the conflict in the region; and WHEREAS, the City Council recognizes the need to amend Resolution No. 25147 to better reflect inclusive and broader humanitarian principles; and WHEREAS, the City Council is committed to promoting peace and equality for all people, irrespective of their nationality, religion, or ethnicity; and WHEREAS, the City Council unequivocally condemns all acts of terrorism, violence, anti- Semitism, and Islamophobia, recognizing that such acts are detrimental to the pursuit of peace and justice; and 1 Gaza death toll: how many Palestinians has Israel's campaign killed 2 The war in Gaza has wiped out entire Palestinian families. AP documents 60 who lost dozens or more 3 Details of the humanitarian crisis in Gaza 4 UN inquiry says Israel and Hamas have both committed war crimes since October 7 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda WHEREAS, the City Council acknowledges the importance of diplomatic efforts and dialogue in resolving conflicts and maintaining peace; and WHEREAS, the City Council condemns apartheid 5 and genocide6 in all forms, recognizing the suffering of communities affected by such injustices; and WHEREAS, the City Council affirms that Palm Springs remains dedicated to promoting balanced and inclusive approaches to international issues, ensuring that the city's resolutions reflect the broad principles of human rights and justice rather than unwavering support for any specific state or entity, and believes in the importance of thoughtful consideration before issuing resolutions related to international affairs, especially as emergencies, emphasizing the need for public comment and review in such cases; and WHEREAS, the City Council reaffirms its commitment to the Palm Springs motto: "Palm Springs is an inclusive world-class city dedicated to providing excellent and responsive public services to enhance the quality of life for current and future generations"; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS AS FOLLOWS: SECTION 1. Resolution No. 25147 is amended to replace its original statements with the following: • The City Council of the City of Palm Springs affirms its commitment to promoting peace, equality, and justice for all people. • The City Council condemns all acts of terrorism, violence, anti-Semitism, and Islamophobia, and calls for diplomatic resolutions to conflicts to maintain peace. • The City Council condemns apartheid and genocide in all forms, recognizing the historical and ongoing suffering of affected communities. • The City Council will ensure that future resolutions related to international affairs are thoughtfully considered, allowing for adequate public comment and review before adoption. SECTION 2. This amendment shall take effect immediately upon its adoption. ADOPTED THIS [Day] DAY OF [Month], [Year]. ATTEST: [City Clerk's Name], City Clerk 5 H.R.4868 - Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act of 1986 6 US Government Statements on Genocide 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda [Mayor's Name], Mayor 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda From:Jules Ogaard To:City Clerk Subject:Public Comment Letter on PS Fulfillment Center Project Date:Wednesday, October 9, 2024 8:23:42 PM Attachments:Public Comment Letter_Juliana Freese.pdf NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Please find my public comment letter attached, concerning the proposed Palm Springs Fulfillment Center Project. -Juliana Freese 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda Juliana Freese 61115 Deronda Ave Whitewater, CA 92282 (760)641-6820 julzfreese@gmail.com 9th October 2024 I am writing to express my strong opposition to the proposed Palm Springs Fulfillment Center project on Indian Canyon Dr and 19th Ave. As a native-born citizen of Palm Springs and current resident of Whitewater, I have a strong connection to the beauty and unique character of our local desertscape, and this project lies in direct opposition to this natural beauty. My concerns over this proposed project are centered around the potential environmental impact and a disturbing lack of evidence that the City of Palm Springs and local residents will gain any worthwhile benefits. As a child I recall the countless times I traversed the 1-10 corridor in our valley, taking solace in the untouched wild nature around me. When I later attended College of the Desert and took my first Natural Resources course, the wonders of our local ecosystem were made clear to me. From our sand dunes to the many critters that inhabit our desert flora, there is no place like the Coachella Valley - and our residents and tourists know that our scenic beauty is worth preserving. While reading through The General Plan (2007) for Palm Springs, I found repeating language that highlights the city's original intention to focus future industrial plans for this area on businesses that would "serve a regional population" (pg 2-9), envisioning wind energy facilities and generation of energy resources and jobs as an "excellent example of how the integration of compatible uses can provide multiple benefits." (pg 2-20) Being a giant, ambiguous warehouse with no guaranteed tax windfalls (no defined function) or jobs (undefined percentage of automated function), I find this project in opposition to these stated goals. What benefits can our residents be guaranteed in the approval of this project? I urge the city to note the original intent of The General Plan to preserve our natural beauty and promote growth through the careful balance of regional benefits while minimizing environmental disruption. As listed in the comment letter by South Coast Air Quality Management District (SCAQMD), the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) for the project is rife with presumptions that are used to calculate greenhouse gas emissions. I am disturbed to learn that a project which includes a two‐story, 739,360‐square‐foot structure for industrial warehouse use could be approved without knowing what the building will specifically be used for. The amount of truck traffic coming to and from the proposed site is especially concerning to me because of the tremendous impact vehicle traffic has on the production of Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions. The encapsulating topography of 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda our surrounding mountain ranges make the Coachella Valley especially susceptible to adverse air quality if we invite infrastructure that brings GHG and ozone problems. All of us have felt the cruel touch of climate change through the effects of Hurricane Hilary, altering our landscape and our lives through flooding and recurring massive dust storms thereafter. Interrupting the delicate balance of our ecosystem through the unsubstantiated increase of GHGs from this project will only add into the feedback loop of climate change, further encouraging extreme weather events such as this. I highly encourage the city to explore alternatives to this project that align with the values of our desert community. Any projects that the city considers in the proposed location needs to provide more guaranteed benefit and raise less environmental concerns to win over our community. The spectacular views that exist along our highway are precious to me, to longtime and newly settled residents, and to our many yearly tourists and visitors. As this is the first giant warehouse proposal for our area, I believe it is our duty to look with critical eyes before we allow this project to set a precedent in our community. Juliana Freese 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda Jarvis Crawford President Jody Diaz Vice-President Evernell Black Treasurer Deiter Crawford Financial Secretary Janel Hunt Secretary Al Murray Parliamentarian Brian Jackson Corresponding Secretary Annjohnnette Collins Linda Gray Good evening, Mayor Bernstein and City Councilmembers, We, the Palm Springs Black History Committee would like to address a few items with regards to the Lawrence Crossley Street sign on Hwy 111, the shrub behind the houses on Lawrence Crossley Rd. that border the Tahquitz Creek Golf course off 34th Avenue, the missing flags that we requested to be flow throughout the month of February from Demuth Community Center and Palm Springs International Airport, and the request of the Juneteenth flags to be flown throughout all of the City of Palm Springs buildings throughout the month of June. It was shared with the city of Palm Springs residents as well as the Palm Springs Black History Committee that the street name change would happen given a certain amount of time for the residents that resided on Golf Club Dr. to address the address changes for their mail and then the name of the street would change to Lawrence Crossley not Lawrence Crossley/Golf Club Dr. We understand that this process typically lasts about a calendar year. However, it has been well over a calendar year since the street name change took place. Can you please provide the City of Palm Springs residents and the Palm Springs Black History Committee with an update of when the permanent street change is to take place. The next topic is the shrubs that border the Tahquitz Creek Golf course and the houses on Lawrence Crossley Rd. The tamarisk trees were removed and there were shrubs planted. When speaking with one homeowner, he stated the city didn’t ask the residents, but he just happened to see someone setting the shrubs near where the tamarisk trees were removed, and he stated I don’t want those planted behind my house. So, the question is, were you the City of Palm Springs aware of the shrubs being planted and did you have any involvement in planting the shrubs? Next, we would like to discuss the Black History flags that were missing from the Demuth Community Center and the Palm Springs International Airport. We are aware that there was a motion passed in February of 2024 stating that the Black History flags were going to be flown each year for the month of February at all city buildings. We want to ensure that the African American flag is flown again for the upcoming years in the month of February. Lastly, we are asking that the Juneteenth flag be purchased and flown throughout all the City of Palm Springs buildings throughout the month of June each year. If we need to submit a formal letter in writing for the Juneteenth flags. Please let us know by emailing us at info@palmspringsblackhistory.org. We would like to thank you for your time, and we look forward to hearing from you. Sincerely, Palm Springs Black History Committe 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda From:Dorrie Rosenstein To:Jeff Ballinger-C Subject:Protect our community! VOTE NO on ceasefire resolution, BDS, etc. / Protect our community from terrorist propaganda and violence Date:Tuesday, October 8, 2024 12:55:46 PM NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. cc: Christians United for Israel Press State House and Senate Representatives U.S. Representative U.S. Senators Honorable City Council Members, We are your constituents, Americans across this great nation, and worldwide citizens who are asking you to vote NO on the ceasefire resolution, NO to BDS, NO to divesting from Israel bonds, NO to withholding military aid to Israel, and NO to dropping charges against those arrested in the illegal, discriminatory encampments. Please read this document in its entirety. The defined role of your council is to value and protect your city and not engage in international affairs. Have you wondered why this is the only issue that ignites such passion when numerous other global crises demand attention? Are you addressing the following humanitarian disasters with the same urgency? (1)Rohingya Crisis in Myanmar (2017-Present): Myanmar Buddhist military massacred, raped and displaced over 700,000 Rohingya Muslims. [1]. (2)Uyghur Detention Camps in China (Ongoing): China has put 1 million Muslim Uyhgurs in mass detention camps where they are subject to forced labor and sterilization [2]. (3)Yemini Civil War (Ongoing): Muslim civil war. More than four million displaced. Attacks on civilians, hunger, disease. [3]. (4)Syrian Civil War (Ongoing): Muslim civil war. Widespread atrocities, chemical attacks on civilians; shooting protesters. 470,000 dead, 1 million injured; 13.1 million need humanitarian aid [4]. (5)Sudanese enslavement (Ongoing): Arab Muslims have slaughtered 2.5 million black Sudanese Christians and enslaved 200,000. Jihadists have kidnapped many black Christian girls [5]. (6)Gender apartheid: Hundreds of millions of women in Muslim countries are second class citizens subject to beatings, sexual violence, honor killings, and genital mutilation [6]. These crises describe the offensive targeting of innocents perpetrated by Buddhists, the Chinese, and Muslims. In response to these crises, it would be absurd to justify harassment, segregation, and violence towards Buddhist, Chinese, or Muslim Americans on U.S. campuses, K-12 schools, social media, restaurants, subways, and streets. Unlike the abovementioned crises, the Israel-Hamas conflict is a DEFENSIVE war that Hamas thrust on the 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda democratic country of Israel on October 7th – targeting and murdering 1,200 civilians and taking hundreds of hostages (American, Israeli, and Foreign Nationals) after firing over 30,000 rockets into Israel for decades [7]. Notably, this was after Israel moved out of Gaza in 2005 – as one of its numerous gestures of peace that have been rejected and met with increased violence [8]. The innocent lives lost in this war is tragic. However, under International Law and ethics, Israel has a duty and right to protect its civilians from these attacks by defeating Hamas and rescuing the hostages [9]. Hamas ADMITS to burrowing itself within the civilian Palestinian population to increase civilian deaths in order to create world protests and delegitimize Israel [10]. However, according to International Law and ethics the responsibility for ALL lives lost falls squarely on Hamas’ shoulders. Does this council realize that when America fights against terrorists, they accidentally kill 4 to 60 civilians per terrorist eliminated? Israel’s ratio is 1:1. While all innocent deaths are a tragedy, Israel’s commitment to fighting ethically outshines every military in the world [11]. These ceasefire resolutions, BDS campaigns, fervor to interfere with Israel bonds, military aid to Israel, and pressure to drop the charges against those arrested in the illegal encampments, are part of a global agenda – to delegitimize and destroy the one Jewish State and justify harassment, segregation, and violence towards Jews on U.S. campuses, subway cars, restaurants, and the world [12-15]. Just listen to the chants: “From the river to the sea;” We don’t want a two-state;” “Long live October 7th;” “October 7th again;” “Long live the intifada!” In fact, Article 7 of the Hamas Charter states: “The Day of Judgment will not come about until Muslims fight Jews and kill them. Then, the Jews will hide behind rocks and trees, and the rocks and trees will cry out, ‘O Muslim, there is a Jew hiding behind me, come and kill him’” [16]. This hate has no boundaries. If you think they stop at targeting Jews, listen carefully to the rest of their chants like, “Death to America!” [17] THE GREAT MISCONCEPTION It is a misconception that the Nazis were solely responsible for the murder of six million Jews. The Nazis had collaborators – willing executioners - men and women in communities, towns, cities, and across all of Europe who believed the propaganda and justified slaughtering their neighbors. [18-19]. Like them, you are being given a grave responsibility to choose noisy hate and lies or clear truth and morality. If you want this war to end, vote NO on an Israeli ceasefire, NO to BDS, NO to divesting from Israel bonds, NO on withholding military aid to Israel, and NO to dropping charges against those arrested in the illegal, discriminatory encampments. These resolutions will allow Hamas to retrench and re-strengthen. Instead, call for Hamas to surrender and release all the hostages. By keeping yourself and your council on the right side of history, your Creator and humanity will judge you as a hero. Sincerely, Dorrie “Those who do not learn history are doomed to repeat it” – George Santayana. References: 1 Council on Foreign Relations, The Rohingya Crisis, 1-23-2020 2 US Holocaust Museum, Chinese Persecution of Uyghurs 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda 3 Council on Foreign Relations, Yemen’s Tragedy: War, Stalemate, and Suffering 5-1-23 4 History.com Why is there a civil war in Syria? 8-25-23 5 The Tablet, Arab enslavement and slaughter of black Africans must stop, 12-13-23 6 TND, Bill Maher grills anti-Israel protesters for ignoring gender apartheid in the Middle East, 6-3-24 7 NY Times, Hamas and other militant groups are firing rockets into Israel every day, 12-27-23. 8 Dershowitz, A. (2014). Terror tunnels: The case for Israel’s just war against Hamas. New York, NY: Rosetta Books. 9 Ibid. 10 Foundation for Defense of Democracies, Hamas officials admit its strategy is to use Palestinian civilians as human shields, 11-1-23 11 Sky News, Erin Molan interviews American Military Expert M. Pregent, 6-16-24, https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://www.facebook.com/SkyNewsAustralia/videos/israels-hostage-rescue-operation- was-done-the-best-way-they-could/972155304390046/__;!!KOzBxd2Nyq5BRg!i8GFiMQNv5bAlbIfcYlai- lmZP85hNFMPzmq3qzgePWHFKSI44hGMef5fAg5HRukLSq3MgiZB-csDSZPhXE002CX_1GAiDc1A9E3$ 12 CNN, I have become traumatized: Jewish students describe campus anti-Semitism, 2-29-24 13 NY Post, Jewish man harassed by anti-Israel mob on NYC subway recalls masked protester’s cruel taunt, “Bro, if you only knew who I was.” 14 Eyewitness News, NYC Jewish restaurant owner says swastikas painted over Israeli flag, 6-5-24 15 NBC News, 2 boys accursed or raping 12-year-old Jewish girl in an act that has sparked outrage in France, 6-20- 24 16 Wilson Center, Doctrine of Hamas, 10-20-23 17 NY Post, Anti-Israel protesters chant ‘Death to America’ and ‘Death to Israel’ at rally in Michigan, 4-8-24 18 Goldhagen, D. (1996). Hitler’s willing executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust. 19 Dershowitz, A. (2014). Terror tunnels: The case for Israel’s just war against Hamas. New York, NY: Rosetta Books. 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda From:Andrew Archdale To:Grace Garner; Christy Holstege; Llubi Rios; Lisa Middleton; CityManager; City Clerk; Ron deHarte; Jeffrey Bernstein; ADA Coordinator; Joel Montalvo; Scott Stiles Subject:Mayor and Council Members re crosswalks - disabled access -follow up URGENT Date:Monday, October 7, 2024 3:40:19 PM NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Dear All Further to the large sun of money spent on upgrading the stretch of road on East Palm Canyon from July to September 2024 including the section of the crossing I have been talking about for over a year, since May 2023 for the disabled crossing, nothing was done to upgrade. As a former Civil Servant and Chief Auditor in London it would be useful for you to watch the film “ Living” 2022 starring Bill Nighy and was Oscar nominated. It is now available on Netflix. Ironically the scenes shot at County Hall opposite The Houses of Parliament and looking at Big Ben is exactly as I remembered working there in my office in the early 1970s. The last quarter of the film is a lesson that all public servants should absorb, reflect and act on, especially as salaries and pensions are paid by the local taxpayers. Enjoy the movie! Further to my original letter to you all onMay 30th 2023 re the crosswalk and subsequent follow up by Scott Stiles asking the City Engineer Joel Montalvo to look specifically at the cross walk on Palm Canyon opposite Smoketree Ranch for disabled use, this is the update; Due to my own health issues I was unable to meet Joel earlier this year after several emails back and forth last year who had offered to visit the site with me.However, my friend Jim met Joel onsite and explained the difficulties of that specific crossing for disabled users, specifically the height of the push buttons , awkward positioning of ramps on the sidewalk and the diagonal positioning of the crossing on what is a very wide road. Joel explained that when originally constructed the crossing did meet all City ADA standards but agreed that crossings on Federal crossings such as on Gene Autry are much more user friendly, and safer considering traffic speeds. As reported in the Desert Sun today significant road works will be conducted on Palm Canyon especially road resurfacing over the next two months. Could immediate consideration be given to ensuring that the crossing at Smoketree on Palm Canyon is repositioned so that it is NOT diagonally positioned during road resurfacing and please add zebra stripes for added safety. This at the very least will not incur any additional costs. If the sidewalk is going to be torn up please also consider the ramps to be upgraded to Federal Standard which could be minimal cost Thank you for your consideration Andrew C Archdale Mayor and Council Members 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda I hope you enjoyed Memorial Day weekend and all that it stands for, especially our surviving disabled veterans. Their safety, and others with disabilities should always be a priority. Thanks for ensuring that controlled crosswalks are receiving attention in order for people to cross safely in particular wide major roads which you have already done on Highways but please can you now improve on streets like Ramon, Sunrise , Indian and Palm Canyon, with a few tweaks? The major issue is the height of the button to press, which in a number of instances are too high for someone sitting in a wheelchair to easily press such as this one on Palm Canyon opposite Smoketree Shopping center, see below. In addition, the markers and yellow pimples seem to direct one to go diagonally across the street which is confusing for a blind person Because of the width of the road many of my friends who are blind and or in a wheelchair feel very nervous crossing the road in the first place, please could you also consider painting the crosswalks with zebra stripes which would bring attention to the crosswalks, especially to folk from out of town who drive much faster and I have seen drive over the crosswalk when people are crossing or have come to a skidding stop only after seeing a person crossing late. The worst thing in the World is for a disabled person to feel isolated because they can’t go out or are frightened to cross the street safely. I would assume a person in the City can look at this quite quickly to reposition the press buttons and to also gauge the ease of crossing from the perspective of a person sitting in a wheelchair, ie the grade and the direction, so that folk that I have seen with difficulty walking and in wheelchairs will be able to confidently cross the street, like all able bodied persons. 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda I would very much appreciate your kind attention to this Kind Regards, Andrew C Archdale “You’ll Never Walk Alone” 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda From:pinyin_eaten_0j@icloud.com To:City Clerk Subject:The Garrisons Date:Sunday, October 6, 2024 8:29:24 AM NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. JEOPARDY QUESTIONS: Q: Name another full time Palm Springs owner that does not occupy their property full time. A: Who are Mark and Jane Garrison? Q: Name a critic of water guzzling golf courses (recycled water) that has a large swimming pool and waters a lush green lawn of an estate that can host nearly 1000 people. A: Who are Mark and Jane Garrison? Restoration begins at home. Walk Your Talk. 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda From:Eric Yoshimura Realtor To:Evelyn Beltran Cc:Brenda Pree; Scott Stiles; Jeffrey Ballinger, City Attorney; City Clerk Subject:Re: Cease and Desist Notice – Use of Palm Springs City Seal in Real Estate Advertising Date:Tuesday, October 1, 2024 11:46:58 AM Attachments:image001.png NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Also, I would like to provide my support for the settlement in favor of the people of section 14 that were discriminated against. It was a travesty what happened to them. Thank you, Eric On Tue, Oct 1, 2024 at 11:44 AM Eric Yoshimura Realtor <ericsellspalmsprings@gmail.com> wrote: I have taken down everything that I am aware of and that you referenced. Sorry, I was not aware of the city code. Have a great day! Eric On Tue, Oct 1, 2024 at 11:32 AM Eric Yoshimura Realtor <ericsellspalmsprings@gmail.com> wrote: I will take care of it. Thank you On Tue, Oct 1, 2024 at 10:37 AM Evelyn Beltran <Evelyn.Beltran@palmspringsca.gov> wrote: Eric Yoshimura, Enclosed for your attention, please find a cease and desist notice pertaining to the unauthorized use of the Palm Springs City seal in real estate advertising. Your prompt attention to this matter is greatly appreciated. cc: Scott Stiles, City Manager Jeffrey Ballinger, City Attorney 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda Office of the City Clerk Evelyn Beltran | Chief Deputy City Clerk | Office of the City ClerkEvelyn.Beltran@PalmSpringsCA.gov (760) 322-8356 (760) 219-60093200 E. Tahquitz Canyon WayPalm Springs, CA 92262www.PalmSpringsCA.govCONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE - This message is intended only for the addresses shown above. It may contain informationthat is privileged, confidential, or otherwise protected from disclosure. Any review, dissemination, or use of thistransmission or its contents by persons other than the addressee is strictly prohibited. If you have received thismessage in error, please notify the sender immediately at (760) 323-8204. Palm Springs City Hall is open Monday through Thursday, 7:30 a.m. - 5:30 p.m., closed Fridays. 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda From:City of Palm Springs To:City Clerk Subject:*NEW SUBMISSION* Submit Public Comment to the City of Palm Springs Date:Friday, September 27, 2024 4:34:58 PM NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Submit Public Comment to the City of Palm Springs Submission #:3514191 IP Address:47.145.25.111 Submission Date:09/27/2024 4:34 Survey Time:16 minutes, 5 seconds You have a new online form submission. Note: all answers displaying "*****" are marked as sensitive and must be viewed after your login. Full Name/Nombre Lavenda Adams-Saunders City of Residence/Ciudad de residencia Menifee, CA, Phone (optional) /Teléfono (opcional) (817) 657-9569 Email (optional/opcional) lfs0925@gmail.com Your Comments/Sus comentarios To the City of Palm Springs: I am a survivor of Palm Springs Section 14, and the group of survivors and decedents are requesting that the city consider the latest proposal submitted by our group. This has been a long hard battle, that is being rightfully fought. My family was up rooted from our multi-family home there on Section 14 without sufficient notice. The scramble to locate decent housing, resulted in a family of 7 living in the kitchen of a church, sleeping spaces divided by bed sheets. That alone was enough to send someone over the edge. My Dad who was a hard working man who was the sole supporter of our family took it the hardest. His dream of succeeding in California was pushed back before it could get started good. See we moved from East Texas and was living with my Dad's aunt on Section 14, hoping to save enough to purchase our own home. It took all the grit, perseverance and faith for my Dad to continue with his goal after that. I pray that the city do the right thing. Thank you, City of Palm Springs This is an automated message generated by Granicus. Please do not reply directly to this email. 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda From:gobananasnet@gmail.com To:City Clerk; Lindsey-Paige McCloy; Denise Goolsby; CityManager Cc:Dianne Nezgoda - Racquet Club West NOrg; Bob - Robert Howard Heinbaugh; Michelle Anguiano Subject:Palm Springs - A Smoke-Free City Date:Friday, September 27, 2024 8:39:19 AM Attachments:image.png Screenshot 2024-09-27 082132.png Screenshot 2024-09-27 082153.png NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Dear City Manager, Mayor, Mayor ProTem, City Council Members, Director of Sustainability, Director of Neighborhoods, As Bob and I once again battle the especially brutal beast named cancer, we are reminded that there is some critical very Very VERY long overdue City business that NEEDS to be taken care of. Please see all images below. Can we please stop kicking the can down the road. We wrote the ordinance back when Steve P. was a new mayor. Kicking the can should not become a hobby for something so critical. Thank you for reading, Your friends Bob Heinbaugh & Paul Hinrichsen - Upper West Side NOrg longtime leadership members and dedicated city volunteers. 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda 10/10/2024 Public Comment Non-Agenda