HomeMy WebLinkAbout2018-14-05 HRC Regular Minutes FINAL
Human Rights Commission
CITY OF PALM SPRINGS, CALIFORNIA
0
MINUTES
Regular Meeting
Monday, May 14, 2018
Palm Springs City Hall 3200 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way
Council Chamber
Present Present FY 2017/2018 FY 2017/2018
This Meeting to Date Excused Absences Unexcused Absences
Terri Andrade X 2
Jilska Chandrasena X 10
Denise Chappell, Vice Chair 9 1
Sam Ciraulo 7 2 1
Ron deHarte, Chair X 10
Jim Gross X 9 1
Ryan Miccio X 2
David Morgan X 10
Nicki Randolph X 10
Other Staff Present:
Dale Cook, Community Development Administrator, Staff Liaison
1. CALL TO ORDER: Chair deHarte called the meeting to order at 3:00 P.M.
2. MISSION STATEMENT: “The mission of the Palm Springs Human Rights Commission is to promote and
protect the diversity of our community and to improve human relations through ed ucation and community
awareness”
3. ROLL CALL: Vice Chair Chappell not present, excused absence; Commissioner Ciraulo not present,
unexcused absence, Commissioner Andrade arrived late, not present during roll call.
4. PUBLIC COMMENTS:
Renato De Moraes – Shared information about two non-profit organizations. 1) Insurance Counseling &
Advocacy (HICAP) which provides free and objective information and counselling about Medicare 2)
Senior Medicare Patrol (SMP) that helps Medicare and Medicaid beneficiaries avoid, detect an d report
health care fraud. Flyers and brochures were distributed to all Commissioners.
Commissioner Andrade arrived at 3:06 P.M.
A very brief period of questions and comments among Commissioners and Renato took place. Chair
deHarte indicated that because there were no other speakers in the queue they spent a little extra time on
that segment.
Human Rights Commission
Regular Meeting Minutes
May 14, 2018
Page 2
5. COMMISSIONER, STAFF AND STUDENT COMMENTS:
Commissioner Morgan – Commented on his very first Table Talk interaction with a resident who identified
herself as a lesbian Latina whose family was being tormented in their neighborhood. Commissioner
Morgan emphasized that the Commission discuss representing as many diverse communities out there as
possible not just the majority of the population. He welcomed any Commissioner who would like to
discuss bringing something forward to speak with him afterwards.
Mr. Cook – Shared that City Council does look at the diversity and current make -up of all Commissions
when reviewing applications to serve on Boards and Commissions. The Commission has had experience
with neighborhood discrimination and hate crimes and has been in cooperation with the PSPD LGBT
Liaison and neighborhood groups to try to mediate. Mr. Cook suggested the need to be more involved to
get greater awareness of those incidents happening in the neighborhoods and bring them forward.
6. PRESENTATION: Community Recognition
Chair deHarte announced the presentation was being postponed until later in the meeting.
7. GUEST SPEAKER: Jewish Family Services of the Desert, Maureen Forman, CEO
Chair deHarte announced that the guest speaker Ms. Maureen Forman had a family emergency and was
not going to make her presentation. Ms. Forman was willing to reschedule her presentation for the June
meeting.
8. ITEMS FOR DISCUSSION AND/OR VOTE:
A. Master Calendar – Commissioner Chandrasena
Commissioner Chandrasena – The next big event is the Harvey Milk Diversity Breakfast on May 18,
2018. Save the Date for the Elder and Dependent Adult symposium.
Chair deHarte – Gathered pending confirmations to the upcoming events. Commissioner
Chandrasena will be representing the Commission at the symposium.
Commissioner Randolph will be participating at the Harvey Milk Diversity Breakfast. No further
confirmations were pending. All Commissioners will be participating in the breakfast.
B. Subcommittees – Chair deHarte and Vice Chair Chappell
Internal:
Community Outreach & Marketing – Commissioners Chandrasena, Gross, Morgan and Randolph
Commissioner Morgan – Explained the subcommittee’s Table Talk outreach efforts and
reported on the upcoming dates and locations scheduled for Table Talk s. A volunteer sign-
up sheet was passed around for other Commissioners that wished to participate in the
upcoming dates. A general flyer with just the information of the upcoming dates Table Talk
dates was also distributed.
Commissioner Randolph – Has reached out to a former ex-client from television and radio
advertising to ask if he would consider possible pro-bono work to create an identity for the
Palm Springs Human Rights Commission that is separate from the national Human Rights
Campaign (HRC) logo. More information to be forthcoming.
Commissioner Randolph – Reported working on the Human Rights Commission’s $2000.00
financial budget for next year. She will bring forth a proposed budget draft that she would like
to have on the Agenda to discuss for next year. Commissioner Randolph expressed interest
in allocating funds for an awareness campaign in social media and creating an identify for the
Commission. Comments and questions were presented and discussed.
Mr. Cook will be working on setting-up a meeting between the Community Outreach and
Marketing Subcommittee and the Director of Communications and the Director of Fund
Development.
Human Rights Commission
Regular Meeting Minutes
May 14, 2018
Page 3
Student Representatives – Vice Chair Chappell, Commissioners Chandrasena, Ciraulo, and Morgan
Commissioner Morgan – The committee is excited to meet with Michael Ventura, Vice
Principal at Palm Springs High School on May 17, 2018 at 12:15PM. Different student groups
will also be present during the meeting to discuss what the Commission is looking for in the
Student Representative.
Senior and Dependent Adult Bill of Rights – Chair deHarte, Commissioners Gross and Ciraulo
Commissioner Gross – Reinforced that the term Senior Expo will be used for the event. At a
recent planning meeting, there was consensus to push for a much better and larger scale
event and they are now looking to move the event into October. A date has not been
identified. Other elements of discussion that occurred during the planning meeting was
having the Commission and the City take a fresh look at contributing financially. Two-to-three
budget items have come-up and those will be forwarded to the Community Outreach and
Marketing Subcommittee to incorporate. Comments and questions were presented and
discussed.
Commissioner Randolph remarked on affordable housing that led into a brief period of
comments and questions being presented and discussed. She will be attending the
Affordable Housing Standing City Council Subcommittee on May 15, 2018 at 4:00PM. She
will also be meeting with Councilmember Holstege next week to discuss some out of the box
ideas that she has.
It was agreed that a new Housing Subcommittee would be formed. Commissioners Randolph
and Andrade volunteered to serve on the Committee.
Chair Deharte – Stated anyone who has an idea for a July Speaker or if there’s a resource
out there that they would like the Commission to hear about please let him or Mr. Cook know
so they can work together to get an invitation out for July’s meeting. A summary of the
remaining steps were mentioned, with a final target of getting some form of recommendation
to City Council’s hand by the fourth quarter regarding Senior Bill of Rights.
External:
Desert Highland Gateway Estates Community Association – Commissioner Chandrasena
Commissioner Chandrasena – Was not present at the meeting last month. Meetings are held
every other month. Their next meeting is in June and she will be attending.
Homelessness Task Force – Commissioner Andrade
Commissioner Andrade – Reported the meeting being the first meeting under new leadership
with Councilmembers Kors and Holstege. The Task Force is meeting every 3 months.
Commissioner Andrade felt that some of the business items on the Agenda were not
finalized, such as the discussion of subcommittee structure and assignments. The meeting
entailed hearing about what Path Of Life Ministries (POLM) has been doing up to the present
point. Comments and questions were briefly discussed regarding the POLM’s Housing First
Model.
Main Street Palm Springs – Chair deHarte - No report updates.
Human Rights Commission
Regular Meeting Minutes
May 14, 2018
Page 4
Organized Neighborhoods of Palm Springs (ONE-PS) – Commissioner Gross
Commissioner Gross – No updates. One-PS will have a sponsorship table at the Harvey Milk
Diversity Breakfast as well.
PSPD LGBT Outreach Committee – Chair deHarte
Chair deHarte – Reported that Captain Peeters will be retiring. The new Staff Liaison has not
yet been announced. The conversation continues on hate crime speech and graffiti occurring
throughout the City and Valley; and concern on whether that’s a growing hate crime i ncrease
to LGBT or hate crime across the board (ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation). Comments
and questions were presented and discussed regarding the report given.
.
C. Instagram Usage
Commissioner Morgan brought-up the suggestion of being engaged in social media to promote
what the Commission is accomplishing at no cost. He would like to take the lead on starting an
Instagram page if the Commissioners agree and if it is allowed per City procedures. Mr. Cook will
be following-up on the policies and procedures surrounding social media for further discussion.
D. Changing Meeting Time
It was discussed among the Commission to change the meeting time as a trial period (June –
September) to make the Commission more available to the Community and increase the level of
participation. There was a consensus to have 6:00PM and 5:00PM as the two possible start times
considerations. Mr. Cook will relay the time frame recommendations with the Cit y Clerk’s office and
cable access staffing to see how structurally it would fit with scheduling. Mr. Cook will keep the
Commission updated on whether the time change would be set for June’s meeting.
Chair deHarte – Announced the Community Presentations would be postponed for the next meeting
since the Student Representative was not present. A special acknowledgement was given to
Councilmembers Kors and Holstege who were present to be part of the presentation for the
students who organized the March For Our Lives rally held on March 24, 2018. Councilmember
Kors on behalf of City Council prepared certificates of acknowledgement for the students in addition
to the Commission’s plaques. The Commission will endeavor to get all eight students together to
make the presentation.
Chair deHarte – Shared that 80 community members were being recognized as part of Palm
Springs 80th birthday as outstanding voices of Palm Springs who are standing for LGBTQ rights and
equality. Four students from Palm Springs High School were to be part of that recognition.
E. Topical Newsworthy Items
Commissioner Chandrasena – Commented that she toured the Mizell Senior Center and came
across a scam pyramid flyer for elder populations. The f lyer was passed around the Commission
to view.
Commissioner Randolph expressed wanting to comment on a positive note and shared comments
regarding women’s rights are human rights and people standing-up for themselves.
Commission Gross – Commented on Pride Prom being a great event last Saturday night. It was
successfully run with over 350 students attending from 15 to 17 High Schools and 1 Middle School.
Chair deHarte announced that the Commission start thinking of an Annual Retreat date and set
time period of 2-3 hours to discuss the make-up of the Commission. It was agreed that they will be
doing a doodle poll and get a date agreed before the next meeting.
Human Rights Commission
Regular Meeting Minutes
May 14, 2018
Page 5
Commissioner Gross initiated the conversation of expiring Commissioners terms. Mr. Cook
reported that two Commission seats have an expiration of June 30. He will be getting in contact
with the City Clerk’s office to see when the HRC representative recruitment process will begin.
Applications are currently being solicited and City Clerk will contact those currently seated if they
wish to reapply.
8. AGENDA ITEMS FOR THE NEXT HRC MEETING:
Chair deHarte asked if there were any other agenda items that needed to be brought up next month other
than finance/budget. No other items were requested to be added.
The meeting proceeded back to Agenda item number 6. Presentation – Community Recognition
Chair deHarte on behalf of the Commission welcomed once again Councilmember Holstege and Kors
who were in attendance to present the community recognition. Chair deHarte commented on the
Commission direction to thank the student organizers of the March 24, 2018 rally that took place across
the country and locally. He introduced John Terry, a student representative from Desert Hot Springs High
School and all the students as organizers who participated, for displaying leadership, courage, and
activism during the ambitious student driven movement that emerged after the South Florida High School
Massacre and has elevated gun control as a key issue and inspired generation of peers to register to vote .
The Commission is proud of the local students from high schools throughout that valley who participated
in organizing one of the 800 protests that occurred around the world.
Councilmember Kors and Holstege presented Certificate of Recognition from the City and the Human
Rights Commission Award plaque to John Terry, thanking him for his leadership and organization on
important social issues. John Terry accepted the honor and made brief closing comment s of the
experience.
9. ANNOUNCEMENTS:
Councilmember Kors commented on Commission vacancies. He and Councilmember Middleton will be
asking at the next City Council meeting that terms be extended for people whose terms are expiring, if
they are willing to serve until the end of the year. They are recommending that the City hire a diversity
consultant to do a broader outreach. Councilmember Kors suggested that the Commission appoint a
Commissioner to work with Councilmember Middleton and Himself in the Diversity Ad Hoc group when
appropriate. Mr. Cook will be informed of the next Diversity Ad Hoc meeting.
10: ADJOURNMENT: The Commission adjourned at 4:21 P.M. to a Regular Meeting, Monday, June 11, 2018,
at 3:00 P.M. or yet to be scheduled in the Large Conference Room, City Hall, 3200 East
Tahquitz Canyon Way, Palm Springs, California.
Respectfully submitted,
Annie J. Rodriguez
Housing Program Assistant