HomeMy WebLinkAbout2014-02-10 HRC Minutes FinalHUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION
of the
City of Palm Springs
Minutes from the February 10, 2014 Meeting
COMMISSIONERS
Present at
this Meeting
Present FY
Year-to-Date
FY 2013-14
Excused
Absences
FY 2013-14
Unexcused
Absences
Dee Dee Wilson Barton
David Brown
Jilska Chandrasena
Elena Chvany
Janel Hunt
Jack Newby
Wes Rankins
Deborah Sutton-Weiss
Les Zendle
Maddie Barton, Student rep.
Sunny Rolfs, Student rep.
0
X
X
X
0
X
X
X
X
X
X
6
7
7
7
6
7
6
7
7
6
3
1
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
The above roll call record is based on all meeting Minutes from July 8, 2013 thru Feb. 10, 2014
1. Vice Chair Newby called the meeting to order at 3 p.m.
2. Student representative Maddie Barton led the flag salute.
3. Commissioner Brown recited the Mission Statement.
4. Commissioners Present: Brown, Chandrasena, Chvany, Newby, Rankins, Sutton Weiss and Zendle.
Student representative Maddie Barton also was present.
Commissioners Absent: Wilson Barton and Hunt, both excused. Student representative Sunny Rolfs also
was absent.
5. POSTING OF THE AGENDA: The agenda was posted in accordance with the Brown Act on or before 6
p.m., on Feb. 6, 2014.
6. PUBLIC COMMENT: None
7. GUEST SPEAKER: None
8. APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES FROM THE DEC. 9, 2013 AND JAN. 13, 2014 MEETINGS: Following a
motion by Commissioner Rankins and second by Commissioner Brown, both sets of minutes were
unanimously approved (Wilson Barton and Hunt absent).
9. ITEMS FOR DISCUSSION / AND OR VOTE
9.A Participation in the Black History Month Parade, Saturday, Feb. 22, 2014, car(s) needed for the
parade, possible expenditure of funds: Staff said there is no cost for the Commission to participate in the
parade and the deadline to submit an application is Feb. 14. Chair Wilson Barton has a four-seater vehicle
without doors that Commissioners could ride in. The parade starts at 11 a.m. with check-in at 10 a.m.
Commissioners who will be participating in the parade include Newby, Brown, Chandrasena, Chvany,
Sutton-Weiss and Wilson Barton. Vice Chair Newby will be the lead person on this and submit the
application for the Commission. The Commission has a banner and Commissioners Sutton-Weiss and
Chandrasena said they would get a pole to attach the banner to and carry it in the parade.
Human Rights Commission Minutes Page 2 of 3
Meeting of Feb. 10, 2014
2
9.B Participation in the Palm Springs Neighborhood Involvement Committee’s Picnic & Community Expo,
11 a.m. to 2 p.m., Saturday, March 29, 2014, and review of handout materials: Staff said there is no cost
for the Commission to have a table at the picnic, which will be at Ruth Hardy Park again this year. Set-up
is at 9:30 or 10 a.m., with the event beginning at 11 a.m. Commissioner Zendle said somebody or a small
group of Commissioners needs to look at the materials to be handed out and think of strategies as to what
the Commission’s message is going to be at the event so those staffing the booth are not sitting passively
waiting for people to stop by. Instead of handout materials on possibly 20 different topics, he suggested
reducing that to the top six. Vice Chair Newby suggested focusing on the topics the Commission has
chosen to focus on this year and possibly develop a flier with the Commission’s calendar for the next three
to four months. He also volunteered to donate a couple bags of candy to be given out at the Commission’s
booth. The idea of having a suggestion box was discussed for people to submit topics that they are
interested in having the Commission address. Commissioners Brown and Sutton-Weiss will go through
the handout materials and determine what to have out on the Commission’s table at this event.
Commissioner Zendle said all the Commissioners who staff the booth should be prepared to answer the
question, “What does the Human Rights Commission do?”
9.C Update on mediation training: Commissioner Sutton-Weiss said she and Commission Brown are
scheduled to begin the training in March.
9.D Review of the Community Service Awards process and presentation – Commissioner Zendle: Chair
Wilson Barton prepared a list of suggestions that Commissioner Zendle went over. They included:
a. The letter to the recipients needs to go out right after they are chosen, informing them that they
have been selected to receive the award and asking them for information.
b. Obtain photos of the recipients and logos from the organizations.
c. A clear statement to the recipients to limit their comments to one to two minutes.
d. Make sure people stay to the end so a photo can be taken.
e. Is 3 p.m. the best time for the presentations? Should it be later in the day?
f. Possibly have a photographer there and perhaps take photos of the recipients before the program
starts.
g. Review the responsibilities of the Commissioners making the nominations, follow through getting
the pertinent information, greet awardees when they arrive and to be able to present the awards.
Commissioner Zendle said it was a wonderful event and there was a lot of publicity this year. He called it
one of the highlight events of the year. He said he can see pros and cons with changing the time of the
program and doesn’t think it is a big issue that gave the Commission problems. However, he said the
Commission does need to tighten up what each person’s responsibilities are as well as what information
needs to be given to the recipients and the presenters beforehand so maybe things run more smoothly.
Commissioners reviewed the event and possible changes. Commissioner Rankins suggested having an
outline for the day so Commissioners are all on the same page knowing what’s going to happen. Vice
Chair Newby suggested working on the process so that the Commission knows that the persons and
organizations nominated will accept the nominations. He also said the Commission should have complete
nomination forms for everyone who will be receiving an award. Vice Chair Newby also said he did not
know if changing the time would make that much of a difference. He also read a statement from Chair
Wilson Barton:
I am very proud of this year’s Human Rights Commission Community Service Award Ceremony.
Our Commissioners were well prepared and polished! Every nominator did a great job of introducing
their award winner, especially our two Student Reps who were poised and composed!
It was a standing-room-only crowd, meaning we had more than 120 people in attendance. Several
of the award winners were quite moving in their remarks. It was a refined, interesting, very smooth
event. Thank you so much for really demonstrating what an amazing community we live in!
I personally appreciated all the work that was put in to this event. And a special thanks to Lee
Bonno and Councilmember Paul Lewin!
Commissioner Zendle summarized the discussion saying the Commission needs to look at the application
and nomination process again and tighten it up, including communication. There wasn’t consensus
regarding changing the time of the presentations from the current 3 p.m., although Commissioner Zendle
said most Commissioners are willing to consider doing it at 5 p.m. All Commissioners felt there should be
a professional photographer, he said. The Commission needs to do more scripting, he said, possibly
putting a program together for at least the Commissioners.
Human Rights Commission Minutes Page 3 of 3
Meeting of Feb. 10, 2014
3
9.E Ongoing calendar review, topics and discussion: The topic for March is immigration and
Commissioner Chandrasena said they have a guest speaker who will address immigration and the Dream
Act. The topic for April is women’s issues, with Chair Wilson Barton as the point person. Human trafficking
will be addressed in May with Commissioner Sutton-Weiss as the point person. June’s topic is
homelessness/poverty with Commissioner Brown as the point person and in July religious intolerance will
be addressed with Commissioner Zendle as the point person. Vice Chair Newby is the point person
putting together a program on senior issues/the stigma of ageism. This topic will be addressed at an
offsite event and not during an HRC meeting. It is on the calendar to occur in April.
10. STUDENT COMMENTS: None
12. COMMISSIONER COMMENTS: None
13. AGENDA ITEMS FOR THE MARCH 10, 2014 HRC MEETING: Calendar review of topics and the
Commissioners assigned as the lead persons. Participation in the Palm Springs Neighborhood Involvement
Committee’s Picnic & Community Expo. Mediation training update.
14. ADJOURNMENT: The meeting was adjourned at 3:38 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Lee A. Bonno
Staff Human Rights Commission Liaison
Director of Neighborhood & Community Relations