Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2B - Public CommentTiffani Bailey From: Anthony Mejia Sent: Monday, January 10, 2022 12:08 PM To: Tiffani Bailey Subject: FW: Fulfullment Center Attachments: FULFULLMENT CENTER DHS M-1 100 FOOT HEIGHTLIMIT INCREASE APN 666370032.pdf, PALM SPRINGS FULFILLMENT CENTER SALES AND PROPERTY TAX FORECAST.pdf Agenda Correspondence Anthony J. Mejia, MMC City Clerk From: Fred Noble <fwnoble(ZDwintecenergy.com> Sent: Monday, January 10, 2022 12:01 PM To: Grace Garner<Grace.Garner@pal mspringsca.gov> Subject: Fulfullment Center NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Grace, The developer of the fulfillment center has an option to go to DHS, and I believe they will if the City does not enact the zone text amendments before it on Thursday and makes it clear that the suggestion from the rouge planning commissioners will be disregarded. Lest we think the DHS alternative site is a bluff, see attached, they are enabling an 100 acre parcel just over the border. Also find a forecast of the sales tax available from this project. Sincerely, Fred 1-13-?,a2z �-- ITEM NO. � 17 Riverside County, CA - Community: Property Search Property ID Number (PIN/APN): 666370032 Desert Hot Springs proposed Zoning Ordinance .Amendments January 18, 2022 APN: 666-370-032: Currently dual zoning as I -L/C -BP (Industrial - Energy Production) and Commercial Business Park (C-BP) to change to all I-L. General Plan Designation Industrial (1) Zoning Ordinance Amendment is to amend Table 17.16.01 (Industrial Development Standards) increasing the maximum height of structures from 2-stories/50feet to 5-stories/100 feet /111)u5'rXIAL 7-04E 14EI607- [ OQ / Public Hearing Notice: General Plan Amendment No. 21-2, Zone Change No. 21as1, Zoning Ordinance Amendment No. 21-1, and General Plan Update EIR Addendum DATLTuesdey. la% 18. 2022 WM& 6il0 P.M. (on asSomr thenahef asthe matter may b Recent news LtKA—W. Via Ydro{oNeresYa PuNiO Hearrna Notice- Aven7ula NOTIC4 q M®I18Y gVyN thatths WC'pu y ndl.10 conduct a Public PNmA II Hearingto—a&, the bgovdng aaierd: a) Oensfal Plan Amen= nt 21Z b) Zone Change T-1. c) Zoning Onlinama A —A. 2T-;—'ng Table r216,01,�P 'a NightjMaxanuMtaaq w ffee(S) staiasnw feet ante auntie Heazln9-l�pjEC6, adopt a General Plan.Plow OR y hahlm. fl�rSElOpfp Anrewmentc CAS4(s4—December M.+lOI,Plemeq Camfnsvon meeting, Me Review A,e3ldi{N Pbnning Commisiun mode a iecvmmaMadun that City Countd.nUept tiro rl—,catee al C—alMs. Axnantlment 21-2 b) Be— Charga Zl-1• tj 6!•fe2. Zoning Ordin•nta Amendment 2F2 amendug Table T7.1601, v.— height IMaxanu t—)M five i51 stor e:g00 tML and a! A0101 a C—NI rP11E6Ve Pear Uodnts OR Addondurn. Nerhea Nrall�ardlnance L(tCATIOrt Six Parcels dispersetl thmghout tM City mth the rdlDwing APN; to Q2m* E(-�A • Tha Wupesed hset ta,Pstsuf Bone changes and mncuneiu General -'c _,.•jai �.,w5. 11,`; Plan Desgna on for the Taff— g parCNa •A—Mlso-001 Currency apW as Pssid-4 twv(R-y to charge. VkRor SeMng Can .dal(VS-0.aawv ape use Pylr Hnan,ng Not l,e Zoning -�-- - Ivacantlarga,1..hhot Matar wee) Ceneral Msn oeslli-van drdlnenee Amrsndmanrlrcland vr,imr Se NCaminemal(VS-c) LIST TghF)'HefmpMzatldn far •APN WaXll-0.s'. Cu 11,a—I as Rsvdenbel Madlvm jR-M). Sedlon 171e0 chane•te Mero L)se Cwndor (MU-C) ro eDa+. auto has a, shm (HWbg)Ce 1Plan De 9--Nhro Use CarrlRW(..C) ha:r,.l �n r„n.i�r; �. 2J:i: • Al.e0-0aW2S Cumntty amro astiesie—W Medium lR.Ml. el,anga. MU-C. a7- adjatvnt ARCO a s;on IVaeant IoU Ca, h,I Plan Oasignatlon Mb ` Use Corrida(MlkCI Pu—Hearin Notiee C. 1 •APM6QCi2-Oo2: Cunanpyxhad as Reek'sheal Masan— UsMI. Plan AmMtlylteltt Np.27.22D0e change. DC(O .n Cen—m wg. b mmgtom whh Charge N0. 21.1. Z llha Vnem uses Oananl elan Deag--Ca "--(Come DreinAntw Amendment N0. 21-1 •APN: fi"S'I mtltl ncmly zeeas Respential Fh,.. pesuM1 lsi RD)[o chergelo l-L (lipMlneumiNl 0-1Plen Deng-ve, arWGenerel Plan Update ElR I.Mustrdl gl Ael ene.m . �Fra ts(y-S'T0.R CvnentNduM xcNrg as l-UC-PP 1lMust.11 Emrgy PnMvc[vl; intl Caanmecid d.sim4 P.ve (C-em m change to end I-l. Genel tl Plan Dasgra0cm Indvsuul gl • ZonngrYdirvnC. Amerdmen h.anvnd Table ✓y1.:.m ilntlu4ral �°�' Dwelupmmt 6Mnoartbl nv:r any the .limo. h.�yh[urswaum erom 2staitaK0lec.�o sttuesTJll:eet 4PPNCY719R8PRESEMI'1TNE: Gry inRatM 6�6 Fp) Fvt,A "17` UIXA 51 G�// r pIWDOLLL:The WapaW eorwe¢ W me Mlaesng aeT1IX,R a) General qan Arnene,nenl 21.2, M Zane Change N-1. c) Zonng ad,nance Arnendrnent D .". omentlb,g Table 11.16.OT.sWnure Iwght IMas'anui Vrert) to riw (SI ItonesAwfeet, end el) Adage a Cmeal plan UWN.OR Adderalum OINIIOMMpITAL DETERM W IATRft An Addend— has ben W apafatl fa iha PropoWd Was P—ne. WCar. Cease. Reg,,—'.. mw(.)dehe CEDA GIA .%—ante an OR has bran e•rtttled ro aubsequen[ o entslrewew needs. W-0a dunless these am sutetuwal changes in the Wul.. ad met warrant di k hel review Men a dub nettled Publk hea,bgM26 , on ay ,2020, the City Coundl adoWad am/ apWavM a C.—I Plan Amendment Puiwant co m•CEOA. PUNT Raswrns Cetle SactlorK DWO, x sq. ana its m Impleanung rvrlubtior„ CNironeis cads ur "Was. S ,,h Sa00. at p. Ur Cie,.—N as lead Age-Y. rMeyed ant cerahM a tlree ErnhanmenMl ImpKi Reppr[ {qM[e Cbad�ghou» umbr2D19CBD1011 ProWrtd b U,e PfoP.oe Gene+al Plan ArnmtlmenC .nrl,teta maMd mat, blk—gthe—alsm mtoaor, of c•nnin —gatq ros arW aRer m• MaParotbn M aCDV E.Addwaaum thM• am nw sWnan[ial C,anges Uu[ wwram �lbrMl review, III711R6 PI RSOMENAYbhorees-aasncom—theyb su hlttecl Wlor.lho Pu01k Heafotg(al.Wntten—rhentswRbmodea pan of eh• puMk n.tpne.uya, Nallr,ga miamatmr in court, ears mar b amimd. raidrg only thorn ivaresyuu or ta,meone else mnlN at tM pubY hearing ties[daee In this rocice.or In wnnen cvnespWMence delbered m the City of DeseM1 Hot SWMgi.tor pqr.. cha pudk hearing The City CoumfI hoadng wag be—cled though Zoom The meebnq wdl also ha avaacan gvaan cha eltys vwrul»a,anr�et A� m me 2bnm, meeting+•ill be evadable with cha puthahe0 agenda an,n/ormation regangng cha Proposed p.jecc Is a ailsble lbr Pudk W— byappoin[mencathe City afG Hat Springscity Hall. hegg Palm W'e Oxcart Mot SpnngsG arA0. duntg Mgdar in sness rwua IMondsy ttvp h:1,urR)ay,'1W AM -an PMI QgESIIdIS AMDOSQIRRgStagaMa,gthiz RURttamrnAew of—Ifen for the Project' loan CanilW, Rir,dpal gannx Sing e Mlealems with D/seYtPofn AR (4D1b In Pe —banes, w:m the .Amerhans —Og f,11hes ACL tywn*eeF%wW atsfisfanwrdyx—arise.n teas ving, 0—ewi-1 tAe City Ckk gyae• at rw m5l itan w vu enMY ar/,Sp%A OAAIg NoprA-.Arbn Ar leas[ all faun PHkv.the s eyuhd meahng(sr iffemblems ClrymmaAe.essanable 3tYomnMOatN/Is rn cwwm"C." 'My Free i` evvsietter Sign Up Daily Tax Report Amazon Tax Change Sends Windfall To Some California Cities (1) By Laura Mahoney and jasmine Ye Han Oct. 13, 2021, 1:46 AM; Updated: Oct. 18, 2021, 1:04 PM o Tax floods into a few cities with fulfillment centers o But hundreds of other jurisdictions are losing out V �Z -. The Southern California city of Eastvale is so new its city hall is in a shopping center and its library is in a local high school. One thing it does have: an Amazon Inc. product -fulfillment center. Thanks to that facility and a tax allocation change the giant online retailer made in 2019, city officials project sales tax revenue will quadruple this year with an injection of $24 million to $30 million. That alone would be enough to cover the city's entire annual budget. Eastvale's gain —and gains among fewer than 20 cities with Amazon fulfillment centers in California —is a loss for ... C7� C a Cj 0.0c) Related Articles � � h j C� f 00 0 Newsom Vetoes Online Sales Tax Data Reporting BillOct. 4,2021, 7:38 PM California Cities With Online Hubs Fared Best on Tax in May 12, 2021, 5:52 Pandemic PM California City Revives With Tax Revenue Redirected from Feb. 8, 2021, 1:46 Rivals AM Apple Taps Covid Shopping Boom for Record Tax Haul in Jan. 13, 2021,1:46 Hometown AM Fred Noble From: McKenna, Kevin <Kevin.McKenna@colliers.com> Sent: Wednesday, January 5, 2022 4:11 PM To: Fred Noble; Fritz Noble; Chris Lucker Cc: Smith, Bo; Merrill, Greg; McKenna, Kevin Subject: RE: Palm Springs Zone Text Amendments for the E-1 and M-2 Zones Fred, Upon -completion of the buildings, the estimated assessed value would be approximately $600 Million ($200/SF). Frequently, buildings are sold when they are leased, the leased value double the value to $1.2 Billion for 3,000,000 SF of buildings. S`0 rAVP 7,4 Y 17, vE1 wo 7 F0 0 VJ U Awi)�J 5 T c zz`(l 01)C, PS —The Amazon buildings in Eastvale have not been reassessed for a sale since their completion in 2018. Therefore, their value is much lower. Today given current market conditions, the value of the two buildings is at least $500/SF or $1 Billion for a sale since their original construction. Thanks, Kevin McKenna Senior Executive Vice President I Greater Los Angeles — Inland Empire License No. 00887289 Direct: +1 909 937 6342 1 Mobile: +1 949 300 0084 2855 E Guasti Rd, Suite 401 1 Ontario, CA 91761 1 USA kevin.mckenna@colliers.comI Download V-card 60000 c Ihers,com %Aew tn,acY PCLN View our Team's recent transactions at: Recent Transactions From: Fred Noble <fwnoble@wintecenergy.com> Sent: Wednesday, January 5, 2022 2:44 PM To: McKenna, Kevin <Kevin.McKenna @colliers.com>; Fritz Noble <Fritz@wintecenergy.com>; Chris Lucker <clucker@luckeranderson.com> Cc: Smith, Bo <Bo.Smith@colliers.com>; Merrill, Greg <Greg.Merril I@colliers.com> Subject: RE: Palm Springs Zone Text Amendments for the E-1 and M-2 Zones Kevin, So if we end up with two 1,500.000 sq. ft. buildings the assessed value would be roughly $300,000,000? Tiffani Bailey From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachments: AC Anthony J. Mejia, MMC City Clerk Anthony Mejia Monday, January 10, 2022 2:03 PM Tiffani Bailey FW: Fulfillment Center PALM SPRINGS FULFILLMENT CENTER SALES AND PROPERTY TAX FORECAST.pdf From: Fred Noble <fwnoble@wintecenergy.com> Sent: Thursday, January 6, 2022 11:03 AM To: Grace Garner<Grace.Garner@palmspringsca.gov> Subject: Fulfillment Center NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Grace, This is a forecast of the revenue available to the City if the fulfillment center in your district north of the freeway is built. $45,000,000 per year in Sales Tax, which is two and a half times the entire Measure J revenue about $15,000,000 in annual property tax. The zone text amendment, to be voted on next Thursday, opens the way for project design, the Project itself will go to the Planning Commission. Some commissioners, speaking for themselves, will offer ill-advised amendments on Thursday that kill the deal. Their comments should be ignored, the time for their input is when the Project comes before the Commission, not now when the enabling text amendment is up for vote. If the staff proposal isn't approved as is, believe the project will be moved to Desert Hot Springs, where the developer has optioned land. Best, 1 ` I S- ZD22 Fred The material sent to the staff for your consideration on Thursday isa poison pill that will kill the deal for Palm Springs. Free Newsletter :sign Up Daily Tax Report Amazon Tax Change Sends Windfall To Some California Cities (1) By Laura Mahoney and jasmine Ye Han Oct. 13, 2021, 1:46 AM; Updated: Oct. 18, 2021, 1:04 PM o Tax floods into a few cities with fulfillment centers But hundreds of other jurisdictions are losing out The Southern California city of Eastvale is so new its city hall is in a shopping center and its library is in a local high school. One thing it does have: an Amazon Inc. product -fulfillment center. Thanks to that facility and a tax allocation change the giant online retailer made in 2019, city officials project sales tax revenue will quadruple this year with an injection of $24 million to $30 million. That alone would be enough to cover the city's entire annual budget. Eastvale's gain —and gains among fewer than 20 cities with Amazon fulfillment centers in California —is a loss for ... n 3, © 6 OOV IV Related Articles $t h� l90a or) S 6 r,4x14,vv,4t1 L/ Newsom Vetoes Online Sales Tax Data Reporting BillOct. 4, 2021, 7:38 PM California Cities With Online Hubs Fared Best on Tax in May 12, 2021, 5:52 Pandemic PM California City Revives With Tax Revenue Redirected from Feb. 8, 2021,1:46 Rivals AM Apple Taps Covid Shopping Boom for Record Tax Haul in Jan. 13, 2021,1:46 Hometown AM Fred Noble From: McKenna, Kevin <Kevin.McKenna@colliers.com> Sent: Wednesday, January 5, 2022 4:11 PM To: Fred Noble; Fritz Noble; Chris Lucker Cc: Smith, Bo; Merrill, Greg; McKenna, Kevin Subject: RE: Palm Springs Zone Text Amendments for the E-1 and M-2 Zones Fred, Upon coMotetion of the buildings, the estimated assessed value would be approximately $600 Million ($200/SF). Frequently, buildings are sold when they are leased, the leased value wo double the value to $1.2 Billion for 3,000,000 SF of buildings. P 7,4 >�V "r %7 1�`L% 0 0." r) A,00 (ft 15 � dC 0 6 �('J PS —The Amazon buildings in Eastvale have not been reassessed for a sale since their completion in 2018. Therefore, their value is much lower. Today given current market conditions, the value of the two buildings is at least $500/SF or $1 Billion for a sale since their original construction. Thanks, Kevin McKenna Senior Executive Vice President I Greater Los Angeles — Inland Empire License No. 00887289 Direct: +1 909 937 6342 1 Mobile: +1 949 300 0084 2855 E Guasti Rd, Suite 401 1 Ontario, CA 91761 1 USA kevin.mckennaCc)colliers.coml Download V-card 60000 colt mcom "Q_ Pnvacv Pottcv View our Team's recent transactions at: Recent Transactions From: Fred Noble <fwnoble@wintecenergy.com> Sent: Wednesday, January 5, 2022 2:44 PM To: McKenna, Kevin <Kevin.McKenna@colliers.com>; Fritz Noble <Fritz@wintecenergy.com>; Chris Lucker <clucker@luckeranderson.com> Cc: Smith, Bo <Bo.Smith@colliers.com>; Merrill, Greg <Greg.Merrill@colliers.com> Subject: RE: Palm Springs Zone Text Amendments for the E-1 and M-2 Zones Kevin, So if we end up with two 1,500.000 sq. ft. buildings the assessed value would be roughly $300,000,000? Brent Rasi To: Anthony Mejia Subject: RE: Distribution Centers From: Kathleen Weremiuk <kathy.weremiuk@icloud.com> Sent: Tuesday, January 11, 2022 6:04 PM To: Anthony Mejia <Anthony.Melia@palmspringsca.gov> Cc: Justin Clifton <Justin.Clifton@palmspringsca.gov>; Flinn Fagg < Flinn. Fagg@paImspringsca.gov>; Lisa Middleton <Lisa.Middleton@ pa lmspringsca.gov>; Geoff Kors <Geoff.Kors@palmspringsca.gov>; Christy Holstege <Christy. Holstege@pal mspringsca.gov>; Grace Garner <Grace.Garner@palmspringsca.gov>; Dennis Woods <Dennis.Woods@palmspringsca.gov>; Lauri Aylaian <lauriaylaian@gmail.com>; J R Roberts <ir66@mac.com>; Kathy Weremiuk <kathy.weremiuk@icloud.com> Subject: Distribution Centers NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Anthony, can you please share this with the city council Dear Members of the Palm Springs City Council, Re: Item 2 B ZONE TEXT AMENDMENT CASE 5.1547 ZTA, RELATING TO DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR WAREHOUSE/ FULFILLMENT CENTERS As a subcommittee of the Planning Commission, JR Roberts, Lauri Aylaian and I did a considerable research on development standards, location, environmental and traffic impacts, and available mitigations for issues raised by permitting Fulfillment Centers and Last Minute Distribution Centers. We did not study the economic impact, job creation potential and the tax revenue potential of allowing permitting of these centers. If you have any questions regarding our research or the recommendations forwarded to you, we will be available to answer your questions by telephone, or if you request, we can make ourselves available this Thursday evening during council deliberations to answer any questions you may have. ITBIJt NO. Respectfully, Kathy Weremiuk, Chair Palm Springs Planning Commission, 310-663-0002 JR Roberts, Vice- Chair Palm Springs Planning Commission 1-415-297-9309 Lauri Aylaian, Planning Commissioner 1-760-898-1155 Brent Rasi To: Anthony Mejia Subject: RE: ONE MORE IMPORTANT THING From: Fred Noble <fwnoble@wintecenergy.com> Sent: Tuesday, January 11, 2022 3:45 PM To: Dennis Woods<Dennis.Woods@palmspringsca.gov> Subject: ONE MORE IMPORTANT THING NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Dennis, This is the map from the planning commission subcommittee proposal, it is their proposed area for the overlay. Can't do an overlay now as it opens up process for litigation. If the E-I and M-2 amendments are limited to this area we are ok. You can even eliminate the top portion as indicated on map. I am not the majority land owner in even this reduced area. If City can't legally limit these text amendments to this small portion of the E-I and M-2 it is still safe to do the amendments as proposed by Staff which includes a large E-1 area to the west, as the E-1 zone to the west is all under long term leases to windfarms, and the City has plenty of time to do an overlay to limit area of increased height limit, to deal with the Planning Commission fear that "these buildings will go for miles along the freeway," AFTER we get these two text amendments done. I appreciate your willingness to be informed as to the ramifications of these text amendments and the ill-advised subcommittee poison pill proposals. Best, Fred e�z.l �f)u�iG C'AMmorifi i Z UJI TIFFANY WAY 14 UJI ix `-j o �- 1-7 0 El ~G4 W I =THUMB_DR rY .. AGARDEN`DR- 18TH AYE= le f 1 2 A— 19TH►AVE I I rd -W -z ---,i. —z ...-.__.ORR,WAY HC:-'6-- — 1-10 W BCC N 7-7 jilp HC ti mi P HC w~"�., m1p HC �.020' LOGISTICS CENTER OVERLAY ZONE 01 E-1 Zone M-2 Zone ■ Overlay Zone �—�*-- City Boundary Line Legislative From: kimffloyd@fastmail.com <kimffloyd@fastmail.com > Sent: Tuesday, January 4, 2022 6:34 AM To: City Clerk <CityClerk@palmspringsca.gov> Subject: 2022-01-04 City Council Finance Subcommittee Special Meeting Agenda NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs --DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. Dear Mayor Middleton and Mayor Pro Tern Garner, Happy new year! The Sierra Club appreciates Palm Springs' climate leadership and 2021 was no exception. You made bold climate decisions, including a goal of carbon neutrality by 2030. Thank you! Today, we'd like to ask the City to take climate action on investments. Looking at the Treasurer's Report dated July 31, 2021 on the 11/18/2021 Council agenda, we don't identify any direct investment in fossil fuels, but there are investments in Bank of America, JP Morgan Chase and Citi, which are the world's top fossil banks according to the annual report Banking on Climate Chaos: Fossil Fuel Finance Report 2021 . Forbes stated in The Case For Fossil Fuel Divestment: "divestment must be considered within the broader ecosystem of climate action." Recently, Wall Street Journal's article The Year Money Met Climate gave the good news on investment options: "There's a lot of money-from companies, institutional investors and individual investors-riding on a belief in the opportunities associated with a carbon-constrained world." An increasing number of public entities have divested from fossil fuels. Sierra Club's multi-tab divestment spreadsheet has links to various policies and resolutions, and other references. For instance: • In Berkeley's Investment Policy : "Divestment from Publicly Traded Fossil Fuel Companies and Banks that Finance Pipelines and Fossil Fuel Infrastructure." • In Encinitas's recent resolution : "Encinitas does not currently hold direct fossil fuels investments. However, the City does bank and invest in firms and funds that do through its participation in 'pooled funds' ... send formal communications to pooled fund managers requesting that pooled funds, including the California Pooled Money Investment Accounts/Local Agency Investment Funds (PMIA/LAIF), California Public Employees' Retirement System (CalPERS), the California Asset Management Program (CAMP) ... divest current holdings from fossil fuel companies over the next 5 years and ban future investments in such companies." We suggest adding fossil fuel divestment in the City's Investment Policy under Section 9.4 Social Responsibility. And, please send a fossil fuel divestment request to Cal PERS, as Encinitas and some other agencies have done. According to the report The Quiet Culprit: Pension Funds Bankrolling the Climate Crisis , CalPERS has over $27 billion invested in fossil fuel companies. Its 2020 Investment Report shows investments in ExxonMobil as well as other oil and gas companies. Please let us know how the Sierra Club can provide assistance. Kim F Floyd Conservation Chair Sierra Club San Gorgonio Chapter 7 60-680-94 79 Anthony Mejia From: Merritt Paul <merrittmaster@yahoo.com> Sent: Friday, January 14, 2022 9:34 AM To: James Kersey, Ray Sharifi Subject: Usa our PALM SPRINGS CITY COUNCIL VOTED w/o public comment to approve "fulfillment center" umm PAUL NOTICE: This message originated outside of The City of Palm Springs -- DO NOT CLICK on links or open attachments unless you are sure the content is safe. THE PICTURES BELOW could be the downside./// note the rendering of the CENTER huge parking lot SNOWS No LANDSCAPING ?? paul merritt Sent: Friday, January 14, 2022, 02:22:46 AM PST Subject: Usa Video captures thousands of damaged packages on LA train tracks https:l_/mol.im/a/104013_51_ via h ttps:11d a i ly m. a ilarl d roLd J, Jb,�, I PL bi. C, eAW,44�