Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2000ORDINANCE NO. 2000 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS, CALIFORNIA, AMENDING THE PALM SPRINGS ZONING CODE CHAPTER 93.00 TO ADD SECTION 93.23.20 TO ESTABLISH REGULATIONS RELATED TO THE REDEVELOPMENT OF GOLF COURSE TO OTHER USES. City Attorney's Summary This Ordinance adds Section 93.23.20 to the Palm Springs Zoning Code, to regulate the redevelopment or conversion of golf course property to other uses. The Ordinance establishes a two-step entitlement process and creates development standards to maintain open space land. THE CITY COUNCIL FINDS AND DETERMINES AS FOLLOWS: A. Notice of a public hearing of the Planning Commission of the City of Palm Springs to consider a proposed ordinance on golf course conversions (Zone Text Amendment, Case 5.1444) was given in accordance with applicable law. B. On October 3, 2019, a public hearing on the proposed Zone Text Amendment, Case 5.1444, was held by the Planning Commission in accordance with applicable law, at which meeting the Planning Commission voted 5-0 to recommend approval of the proposed ordinance to the City Council. C. On July 24, 2019, the City Council held a noticed public hearing on the proposed Zone Text Amendment, Case 5.1444, in accordance with applicable law. D. The proposed Zone Text Amendment is considered a "project" pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). E. The City Council has carefully reviewed and considered all the evidence presented in connection with the hearing on the Zone Text Amendment, Case 5.1444, including but not limited to, the staff report, and all written and oral testimony presented. F. The City Council finds that approval of the proposed Zone Text Amendment, Case 5.1444, is consistent with the intent of the zoning code, because according to Section 91.00.00, the Zoning Code is adopted "For the purpose of promoting and protecting the public health, safety and welfare of the people of the city of Palm Springs and to provide for the social, physical and economic advantages resulting from comprehensive and orderly planned use of land resources... ". The proposed ordinance is consistent with this intent, as it seeks to protect the public health, safety and welfare through maintaining open space and establishing development standards for compatible and complementary land uses. In addition, the ordinance facilitates a neighbor and public scoping process. Ordinance No. 2000 Page 2 G. The City Council finds that approval of the proposed Zone Text Amendment, Case 5.1444, is consistent with the intent of the 2007 General Plan and the overall vision: The Palm Springs Vision A world-renowned desert resort community where residents and visitors enjoy safe neighborhoods, an exciting social environment.and a relaxing leisure experience. We enhance our natural, cultural, and historical resources with sustainable economic growth and high style. We provide responsive, friendly and efficient public services within a government that fosters unit among all our citizens, - The proposed ordinance would establish development standards to reduce impacts associated with the loss of golf course open space, which contribute to the City's image as a world-renowned desert resort community. THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM SPRINGS DOES HEREBY ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS: SECTION 1. That the findings and determinations reflected above are true and correct and are incorporated by this reference herein as the cause and foundation for the action taken by and through this Ordinance. SECTION 2. Chapter 93.00 of the Palm Springs Zoning Code is amended to add Section 93.23.20 as follows: 93.23.20 - Conversion of Golf Courses A. Purpose and Intent. The purpose of this ordinance is to assess and mitigate the impact of a golf course conversion on real property by establishing appropriate procedures, by requiring outreach with residents, property owners and community members and by establishing specific development standards to ensure compatibility with the existing land uses. The ordinance seeks to protect the public health, safety and welfare through the following- 1 . Maintain open space. Recognizing there may be certain loses of open space with any conversion, this ordinance is intended to maintain usable and passive open spaces in perpetuity. These spaces provide benefits to nearby residents impacted by such conversions as well as the community at large. 2. View preservation and access. This ordinance is intended to preserve open space views from public roads and residential property surrounding golf course property, while allowing public access to open space land to the maximum extent possible under law. 3. Neighbor outreach. The intent is to require extensive communication between the applicant and nearby residents, property owners and interested community members (collectively, "community members") on the proposed conversion. In particular, the ordinance is designed to address the conversion of golf courses Ordinance No. 2000 Page 3 surrounded, in whole or in part, by existing residential uses or lands zoned residential. 4. Public scoping process. The ordinance requires a two-step application process with the intent of resolving conflicts, addressing neighbor concerns and exploring project alternatives during the early stages of a proposed conversion. To that end, this ordinance requires an applicant to complete an intent to convert/scoping application process followed with the formal conversion application process for the applicable development entitlements to convert a golf course (see "conversion application" below). 5. Development standards. It is the intent of the specific development standards contained herein to encourage the applicant to propose a conversion project with land uses and amenities that are compatible and complementary to existing neighborhoods. Further, the applicant is encouraged to incorporate reasonable input provided by nearby residents, property owners and community members into the development proposal. B. Applicability. 1. This ordinance applies to golf courses that are currently developed in the City of Palm Springs, to the extent permitted by law, including those that are both operational and non -operational. 2. The following zoning actions and General Plan Amendments, hereafter collectively referred to as "conversion applications," shall be subject to this section. A conversion application shall be required when an applicant seeks to change a constructed golf course to a non -golf course use. a. General Plan Amendments. This section applies to a golf course constructed in any general plan designation where the proposed non -golf course use is not permitted by the Land Use Element. Amendments to the General Plan shall be subject to requirements and procedures described in the General Plan and California Government Code Sections 65300 et. seq. b. Zoning actions. This section applies to a golf course constructed in any zoning district where the proposed non -golf course use is not permitted, accessory, or conditional in the zoning district or tract for which an entitlement is sought. i. Specific Plan. A specific plan shall be prepared and adopted for the entire golf course site to provide a comprehensive land use plan complying with the goals and policies of the general plan and the requirements of this ordinance. A specific plan is required to address the unique characteristics and qualities of a project site. The specific plan may refer to and incorporate uses and standards outlined in the zones established by the zoning code, such as the R-1, R-2 or R-3 zoning districts. ii. Development Agreement. In addition to a specific plan, a development agreement shall be prepared for a conversion that requires a transfer of development rights (density transfer). The development agreement shall specify the development rights transaction consisting of either in -kind replacement of such open space elsewhere in the City, payment of in -lieu fees, or replacement of converted open space through the use of density transfer, in accordance with General Plan policies and any applicable city Ordinance No. 2000 Page 4 ordinances. The development agreement shall define public access to open space trails to the extent permitted by law and include date certain timeframes for payments and land transfers, if applicable. The development agreement shall be prepared in accordance with the requirements and procedures set forth in this section and Zoning Code section 94.08.00. 3. Notwithstanding the applicability of Section 93.23.20(B)(2) of the Zoning Code, the City is not precluded from enforcing local codes requiring regular maintenance of a golf course, including the issuance of warnings, citations, etc. The golf course property owner(s) shall continue to maintain golf course property in accordance with Section 93.19.00 of the Zoning Code. C. Intent to convert application procedures. 1. Intent to convert application. The applicant shall submit an "Intent to Convert" application to the City prior to submitting a formal conversion application. The Director of Planning Services shall establish the procedure and application submittal requirements, including but not limited to: a. A title report that identifies the current owner of the property and all encumbrances, including covenants, leases, easements, rights to purchase and any other legally binding instrument, against the property; b. A property owner statement shall be submitted that expressly identifies any and all master leases, recreational leases, private use restrictions, covenants and open space easements that may impact and/or are within the chain of title to any portion of the golf course property (hereinafter, collectively referred to as the "Existing Agreements"). To the extent there are any Existing Agreements, the applicant shall attach such Existing Agreements to the Intent to Convert application and shall further identify whether or not the Existing Agreements impact any maintenance obligations and/or use of the golf course property. The applicant will further identify whether or not they are in default of any Existing Agreements (such as failure to maintain the golf course property) as well as the names, addresses, telephone number and contact persons of any and all parties (other than the applicant) to such Existing Agreements; c. The Developer's Alternatives Statement, as provided for in paragraph (C)(2) below; d. A statement describing the methods to be used to engage community members at the Neighbor Outreach Meetings, as provided for in paragraph (C)(3) below; e. Within 15 days after submitting the Intent to Convert Application, the applicant shall post on -site signage to inform the public that an Intent to Convert application has been submitted to the City. The applicant shall install one a- foot by 4-foot sign per street frontage and an additional sign every 300 lineal feet along such streets to the satisfaction of the Director of Planning Services. The sign design shall be similar to the signage required in Section 94.09.00(F) of the Zoning Code, with project information, developer and city contact information and other criteria, as specified by the Director of Planning Services; f. A fee shall be paid in such amount as has been prescribed by resolution of the city council for the purpose of defraying the City's costs of processing the application; and Ordinance No. 2000 Page 5 g. Environmental Constraints. The applicant shall provide preliminary analyses and environmental studies that identify and evaluate environmental constraints on the project site. At a minimum, the submittal shall contain preliminary environmental analyses that address the following criteria: i. Biological resources (potentially affected wetlands or waterways, potentially affected endangered/threatened species, wildlife migration); ii. Cultural resources (prehistoric and/or historic resources/structures); iii. Floodwaters (creeks, washes and/or water channels that cross the site, 100-year floodplains, delineation of federal and state waters, etc.); iv. Geotechnical (earthquake faults, landslides, liquefaction); v. Hazardous materials on site or proposed to be used in construction on site; vi. Required permits and permitting agencies for the project (including compliance with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), if required); and vii. Water quality (surface and groundwater usage/depletion, Regional Water Quality Control Board or other agency compliance). h. The owner shall attest that there are no active or outstanding code enforcement activities on the golf course. 2. Developer's Alternatives Statement. The purpose of the Developer's Alternatives Statement (Alternatives Statement) is to serve as a tool to inform community members and the City about the applicant's development options and intentions. It is intended to encourage communication and cooperation between the applicant, community members, and the City. The Alternatives Statement shall be prepared by the applicant and shall clearly identify the goals and objectives for the conversion project. The Alternatives Statement shall address, at a minimum, the four alternatives noted below. Each alternative shall be accompanied with an economic analysis that details its viability. The alternatives are not intended to be mutually exclusive; the conceptual development plan described below may incorporate one or more of the alternatives in the conversion project. a. No conversion: The applicant shall examine opportunities to retain all or part of the golf course. The following considerations are to be assessed: i. Whether any of the existing property owners' association(s) with an Existing Agreement and/or which owns or manages any residential unit or common area within 500-feet of the golf course property, are willing and able to purchase all or part of the golf course; and ii. Whether any of the existing property owners' association(s), City - recognized Neighborhood Organizations and/or any new association with an Existing Agreement and/or which owns or manages any residential unit or common area within 500-feet of the golf course property, can coordinate joint control for all or part of the golf course. iii. The economic feasibility of continuing to operate the golf course. b. Partial conversion: The applicant shall prepare a conceptual development plan where a nine -hole and/or par three course is part of the project and provide a narrative that describes the operational aspects of the course and its Ordinance No. 2000 Page 6 compatibility with existing and proposed uses, and the economic feasibility of partial conversion. c. Donation or purchase: The applicant shall coordinate with the City, local land conservancy agencies and abutting homeowners or homeowner's associations to determine if there is interest on the applicant's part to donate or sell, and the city's, land conservancy's, and/or homeowner's associations' part to accept a donation or purchase ownership, or maintain a portion or all of the property for a public or private use, such as a public or private park, open space, civic use, or other facility. This section shall not require the City, land conservancy or homeowner's association to purchase or accept a donation of any lands, nor shall this require the property owner to donate or sell any land. d. Full conversion development plan: The applicant shall prepare one or more proposed conceptual development plans, consistent with the development standards established in section 93.23.20(F) of the Zoning Code, depicting the proposed conversion. The applicant shall share the conceptual development plan with the neighboring residents at the Outreach Meetings as described in paragraph (C)(3) below. The conceptual development plan shall depict the retained and proposed land uses, including residential, non-residential, and preserve areas; existing and proposed roadway and pedestrian systems; existing and proposed trees and landscaping, including the study and preservation of specimen trees; and the proposed location for the desert greenway, including any passive recreational uses. The narrative shall identify the intensity of the proposed land uses; how the proposed conversion is compatible with the existing surrounding land uses and any methods to provide benefits or mitigate impacts to the community members. It shall also identify any proposed deviations from the General Plan or Zoning Code. Visual exhibits to describe the conceptual development plan and amenities, including the desert greenway, shall also be provided. 3. Neighbor outreach meetings. The Neighbor Outreach Meetings (Outreach Meetings) are intended to engage the residents, property owners and interested community members, early in the conversion project and inform the applicant as to what these parties find important in the neighborhood, what they consider compatible with the neighborhood, and what types of land uses they would support to be added to the neighborhood. An assigned City planner shall attend the Outreach Meetings and observe the process. The following is required of the applicant: a. The applicant shall conduct a minimum of two in -person Outreach Meetings in accordance with the procedures outlined by the Director of Planning Services. One of these two meetings shall be conducted as a city-wide neighborhood outreach meeting in a form and format approved by the Director of Planning Services. Notification of these meetings shall be provided to surrounding residents (including renters/occupants and property owners) and community associations that are located within 500-feet of any boundary of the subject golf course. When a portion of a community association is within 500-feet of a boundary, the notice shall be provided to all residents and property owners within the association. Notification of these meetings shall also be provided to Ordinance No. 2000 Page 7 all Neighborhood Organizations through the Office of Neighborhood Involvement. Additionally, the applicant shall host a website that provides information on Outreach Meetings and conceptual plans at any time there is an Intent to Convert application submitted to the City. The website address shall be incorporated in the mailings notifying the residents, community members and Neighborhood Organizations of the in -person Outreach Meetings. All costs of the Outreach Meetings shall be borne exclusively by the applicant. b. At the Outreach Meetings, the applicant shall, in good faith, provide information to the residents, property owners and community members about the purpose of the meeting, including a presentation on the goals and objectives of the conversion project, the conceptual development plan, the desert greenway concept, and the measures taken to ensure compatibility with the existing surrounding neighborhood. c. Outreach Meetings report for conversion applications. After completing both Outreach Meetings the applicant shall prepare an Outreach Meetings report. The report shall include a list of attendees, a description of the public outreach methods used, results from outreach methods, and copies of the materials used during the Outreach Meetings. The applicant shall also include a point - counterpoint list, identifying input from the community members and how and why it was or was not incorporated in the conversion application. The report shall be organized such that the issues and ideas provided by the community members are clearly labeled by the applicant in the list and the conversion application. d. In addition to the above outreach requirements, the applicant shall, at the request of the City, hold additional meetings after the formal conversion application(s) is submitted. 4. Planning Commission Scoping Meeting. Once the requirements of Sections (C)(1) through (C)(3) have been completed as determined by staff, the Planning Commission shall review the Intent to Convert application materials at a study session. The Commission may provide comments to the applicant, but shall not take any action on the Intent to Convert application, nor shall it preliminarily indicate approval, conditional approval or disapproval of the proposed project at this stage. D. Formal conversion application procedures. 1. Application. An applicant shall not submit a conversion application (e.g. specific plan, development agreement, General Plan Amendment) until the Intent to Convert process outlined in subsection (C) is deemed complete. An Intent to Convert application may not be deemed completed unless and until all outstanding issues relating to any Existing Agreements have been resolved between/among the parties to such Existing Agreements. Thereafter, the applicant may proceed by submitting a formal conversion application with the City as follows: a. General Plan Amendments. For projects subject to 93.23.20.B.2.a., the applicant shall file a General Plan Amendment application. b. Other actions. For projects subject to 93.23.20.B.2.b., the applicant shall file a specific plan application and an application(s) for applicable entitlement(s). The Ordinance No. 2000 Page 8 specific plan shall include text and diagrams specifying (1) the distribution, location, and extent of uses of land, including open space, (2) standards by which development will proceed, (3) location of public and private improvements, (4) design guidelines, and (5) other criteria specified in Government Code Section 65451. In addition, the applicant shall file an application for a development agreement for a density transfer, in -kind replacement of open space or payment of in -lieu fees, as required by Policy LU 2.2 of the General Plan. Deviations from Zoning Code section 93.23.20 shall be prohibited, further, proposed deviations from the other sections of the Zoning Code shall be described in these applications when proposing development that deviates from the City's zoning districts. c. Environmental documentation. The project will require environmental analysis and documentation, in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). The City shall be the lead agency for the CEQA document and shall direct its preparation, as permitted under state law. The type of environmental document will be determined to be consistent with Section 15064 of the CEQA Guidelines. Environmental analysis for any federal approvals that require review under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) should be coordinated with the federal agency with jurisdiction. d. Fees. When the conversion application is filed, a fee shall be paid in such amount as has been prescribed by resolution of the city council for the purpose of defraying the City's costs of processing the application. The applicant shall be responsible for paying fees associated with the review of the application, including but not limited to costs for third party consultants, staff and the city attorney's office. 2. Staff Investigation. After the application is deemed complete, staff shall make an investigation of the facts bearing on the case to provide the information necessary for action consistent with this ordinance and shall report the findings to the Planning Commission and City Council. Staff shall provide an analysis of the Guidelines as provided in subsection (E) below and any other findings applicable to the development entitlements being sought by the applicant. 3. Planning Commission. a. Public hearing. The Planning Commission shall hold a public hearing in the manner provided for in Section 94.09.00. b. Review and recommendation. After holding a public hearing and deliberating the facts of the conversion application, the Commission shall make a recommendation to the City Council, including conformity recommendations related to findings of related project development entitlements, if applicable. In the event the Commission is unable to make a favorable recommendation and denies the conversation application, the applicant may appeal the decision to the City Council in accordance with the procedures of Section 2.05 of the Palm Springs Municipal Code. 4. City Council. a. Public hearing. The City Council shall hold a public hearing in the manner provided for in Section 94.09.00. Ordinance No. 2000 Page 9 b. Review and decision. After holding a public hearing, considering the Planning Commission's recommendations and deliberating the facts of the applications, the City Council may approve or deny the conversion application. E. Compatibility review guidelines. The staff report shall evaluate, and the Planning Commission and City Council shall make written findings on each of the following: 1. Whether the applicant has met the requirements established in this section and development standards in the Zoning Code. In particular, that the proposed design and use(s) of the open space and desert greenway, as applicable, meet the standards as described in paragraph (F)(3) and the minimum fifty percent (50%) open space described in paragraph (F)(5) below. 2. Whether the Outreach Meetings report and point -counterpoint list described above reasonably reflect the discussions that took place at the Outreach Meetings. 3. Whether the applicant incorporated reasonable input provided by the community members to address impacts of the golf course conversion on community members' real property. 4. Whether the applicant provided an explanation as to why input from the community members was not incorporated into the conceptual development plan. 5. Whether the applicant appropriately demonstrated opportunities and constraints of an existing site and economic viability of the chosen proposal. 6. Whether the applicant complies with other required findings for the requested development entitlements. 7. Whether there are any Existing Agreements that would prevent the application from moving forward. 8. Whether there are significant environmental impacts that cannot be mitigated with the proposed project. 9. Whether the proposed development adequately provides for the maintenance of the open space and desert greenway, flood zones, and washes. 10. Whether the applicant has demonstrated good faith in the maintenance of the property since acquisition by not allowing the property to deteriorate, or otherwise violated applicable State and local maintenance codes. 11. Whether the proposed development is compatible with the existing adjacent residential development. 12. Whether the proposed development is adequately set back from the existing residential development, or is buffered by desert greenway. F. Development standards. The following are additional minimum design standards for General Plan Amendments and/or other zoning actions that propose to convert a golf course. 1. Previously approved open space. Golf course acreages utilized to meet the minimum open space requirements for a previously approved project shall be retained as open space and shall not be included in open space calculations for any subsequent conversion projects. Ordinance No. 2000 Page 10 2. Design guidelines. In addition to the requirements of Government Code Section 65451, a specific plan shall include design guidelines that specify the form and type of design intended for the development. 3. Open space requirements. Minimum Required. At least half (50%) of any conversion project shall remain as open space. The open space shall include desert greenways (as required in paragraph F.4. below), landscape buffers, accessible and naturalized water channels and waterways, and to the extent feasible artificial ponds, and will be based on the project's gross acreage. For the purposes of this section, open space does not include: a. Streets (pavement and curbs), b. Driveways, c. Concrete waterway channels, d. Private residential yards for single family homes, e. Setbacks for all new uses (R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, commercial and hotel zones), f. Public and private open space required for new R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, commercial and hotel uses, including but not limited to pool areas, clubhouses, tennis courts, playgrounds, parks, etc. that are exclusive to those uses. The open space shall be a separate parcel(s) from other parcels used for private development. 4. Desert greenway. The purpose of the greenway is to retain an open space view for community members, support active/passive recreational uses, preserve specimen trees, and support existing wildlife habitat, to the maximum extent possible. For the purposes of this section the desert greenway shall be identified as a continuous strip of land set aside for passive recreational uses, such as: open space, nature trails, parks, playgrounds, golf courses, disc golf courses, exercise equipment, appropriate urban agriculture, landscape buffers and multi -use paths. The City Council may approve other passive recreational uses that were considered by the Planning Commission. The desert greenway shall not include required yards (setbacks) of any individual lots. a. The desert greenway shall be contiguous to the existing residential properties surrounding the golf course and generally located along the perimeter of the proposed development. The Council may approve an alternative design that was considered by the Planning Commission. b. The greenway shall have a minimum average width of 100 feet, and a width of no less that than 75 feet at any one location. The greenway shall span the length of the property to the greatest extent possible. c. Maintenance of the greenways, artificial ponds, flood channels and floodways, shall be identified through the specific plan review process. d. Existing trees and understory (shrubs and groundcover) shall be preserved and maintained to the greatest extent possible within the desert greenway. The site plan shall identify all existing trees, identify those trees that will be kept in current locations, those that will be transplanted to the desert greenway from other locations, and those that are proposed to be removed. New trees shall also be identified on the site plan. Trees should be sited along biking and walking paths in the desert greenways. Ordinance No. 2000 Page 11 e. The proposed new plant materials within the desert greenway shall be selected from the Lush and Efficient Landscape Guidelines, published by the Coachella Valley Water District. The use of native plants is strongly encouraged. The design shall be consistent with water efficient landscape standards found in Section 8.60 of the Municipal Code. f. A portion of the greenway may provide stormwater management. g. The applicant shall record a restrictive covenant in the County's official records describing the use and maintenance of the greenway as described in the zoning action. The covenant shall to the extent feasible contain a provision that provides the public with a non-exclusive easement over the paths, walkways and bike trails within the desert greenway. The greenway shall retain its zoning designation as open space. 5. Building setbacks. a. Single -story Structures. All one-story non -golf course uses, except for the Desert greenway, shall provide a minimum average 50-foot setback from the property line of existing lands zoned residential or with residential uses, however the setback shall be no less than 35 feet at any one location, except where a single fairway is lined with existing homes on both sides. In that case, the setback requirement may be reduced on one side of the fairway by City Council. b. Multi -story Structures. All structures exceeding one-story within the project area shall provide a minimum setback of 150 feet from the property line of existing lands zoned residential or with residential uses. This setback may be reduced to 100 feet if the area is buffered by a desert greenway. c. The area between the structures and perimeter property line shall be landscaped and maintained. If unobstructed by walls/fences and consistent with Desert Greenways, this landscape buffer may be included in the open space standards identified in paragraph F.3. above. 6. Stormwater management requirements. The applicant shall demonstrate that the stormwater management for the surrounding uses will be maintained at an equivalent or improved level of service. This shall be demonstrated by a pre versus post development stormwater runoff analysis. 7. Floodplain review. In accordance with Riverside County Flood Control and FEMA, the project shall address all issues related to floodplain management. Any areas proposed for structures shall be outside the 100-year floodplain after development. The post development condition shall not increase flood risk for any existing structures. 8. All other development standards. The conversion of golf courses shall be consistent with the development standards in the Zoning Code, as amended. Building heights, open space and other development standards shall comply with one or more of the zones listed in the Zoning Code. However, an alternative land plan with site specific standards may be considered when vetted through the process outlined in this ordinance, provided open space is preserved. 9. Existing roadways identified by the General Plan as Major or Secondary Thoroughfares, if previously interrupted by the existing golf course, shall be reconnected during the conversion process. Ordinance No. 2000 Page 12 SECTION 3. If any section or provision of this Ordinance is for any reason held to be invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, or contravened by reason of any preemptive legislation, the remaining sections and/or provisions of this ordinance shall remain valid. The City Council hereby declares that it would have adopted this Ordinance, and each section or provision thereof, regardless of the fact that any one or more section(s) or provision(s) may be declared invalid or unconstitutional or contravened via legislation. SECTION 4. The proposed Zone Text Amendment, Case 5.1444, is deemed Categorically Exempt from the provisions of CEQA under Section 15305 (Minor Alterations in Land Use Limitations) of the CEQA Guidelines. The proposed zone text amendment proposes new regulations that will expand the process by which an entitlement application is considered and maintain open space land previously used for recreational purposes. SECTION 5. The Mayor shall sign and the City Clerk shall certify to the passage and adoption of this Ordinance and shall cause the same, or the summary thereof, to be published and posted pursuant to the provisions of law and this Ordinance shall take effect thirty (30) days after passage. PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED BY THE PALM SPRINGS CITY COUNCIL THIS 18TH DAY OF SEPTEMBE ROBERT MOON, MAYOR ATTEST ANTHONY J. MFJ CITY CLERK Ordinance No. 2000 Page 13 CERTIFICATION STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF RIVERSIDE) SS. CITY OF PALM SPRINGS) I, Anthony Mejia, City Clerk of the City of Palm Springs, California, do hereby certify that Ordinance No. 2000 is a full, true, and correct copy, and introduced by the City Council at a regular meeting held on the 24th day of July, 2019, and adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council held on the 18th day of September, 2019 by the following vote: AYES: Councilmembers Holstege, Middleton, Roberts, Mayor Pro Tern Kors, and Mayor Moon NOES: None ABSENT: None ABSTAIN: None IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the official seal of the City of Palm Springs, California, this 14.(c , day of 20 NTHONY J. MEJ, MMC ITY CLERK